Skip to content
337: Sonic 2, Fantastic Beasts 3 episode artwork

Apr 18, 2022 1 hr 32 min

337: Sonic 2, Fantastic Beasts 3

from SiftPop Hosted by SiftPop | Aaron Dicer, Andrew Ormsby

Aaron and Andrew welcome Alice back to the show this week! They review "Sonic the Hedgehog 2" (2:49) and "Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore" (20:40), rank Best Ever strange animal movies (51:48), then finish up with Buried Treasure (1:21:15).

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

337: Sonic 2, Fantastic Beasts 3

0:00 1:32:56
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

What else with Corey Mann on the Studio DNA Podcast Network? One-on-one conversations with some of your favorite artists. Find this podcast on iTunes, Spotify, and Spreaker.com. What else with Corey Mann on the Studio DNA Podcast Network? Live from a bunker in the heart of the Ozarks. A podcast that's about as useful as a backstage pass to Limp Bizkit. It's Sif Pop. Welcome to Sif Pop Weekly Streaming Live most Saturday mornings. We're available to download later in your podcast feed. And let's go as your patron. Patrons get perks. Patrons get those perks. Woo! I'm your host, Aaron Dicer, and he's just the kind of average Joe the world needs. It's Andrew Ormsby, ladies and gentlemen. Ahoy.

Each week we'll chat about movies, TV, and whatever else from the pop culture universe is on our minds. And please welcome our guest this week. She's our new BPFFAE. It's Alice. G'day, g'day. I am so honest. Best friend forever and ever. Best podcast friend forever and ever. Oh, I didn't even hear the P. That's right. Well, you know what? You might exclude Alice to simply a podcast best friend. I consider her the coutrement.

best friends. Nice. I like it. I like it. Stop it, guys. You're going to give me a big head. Stop it. We're excited to come to you and talk about a couple movies. One that came out last week that we didn't get a chance to mention, but apparently everybody watched because we made like 80 million last weekend, which is Sonic the Hedgehog 2. So we are going to review that. And then we're going to talk about Fantastic Beasts, new movie, the third in the series, I believe, The Secrets of Dumbledore. I'm excited to hear about this new Dumbledore character and what's going on in their life. Our best ever challenge this week is going to be best ever strange animal movies, movies that have strange animals in them. This is a pretty broad category.

Oh my God. I had to stop myself from having 50 like honorable mentions. Yeah. So we'll talk about it more when we get there. I kind of gave myself a little more handcuffs on this one to kind of keep it to a general idea for me. But obviously there's so many movies you could do. And I will not be vetoing anybody's choices. Feel free to put whatever you want on this list. I will say this though. I did put limits on myself because there are a couple of franchises that I tend to mention every single week. And I'm like, you know what?

Just imagine those are my number twos and my number one and everything else. But I just want to give shout outs to these other movies because I feel they deserve the light. Yeah. Yep. For once. Yep. So we will definitely talk about that. Of course, we'll do some buried treasure as well. If you guys are ready, we'll go ahead and get into it. Let's go ahead and kick it off by talking about Sonic the Hedgehog 2.

I discovered the source of ultimate power. We need to get it back before the world is doomed. You rock some kind of space porcupine. I am an echidna warrior. After settling in Green Hills, Sonic is eager to prove he has what it takes to be a true hero. His test comes when Dr. Robotnik returns, this time with a new partner, Knuckles, in search for an emerald that has the power to destroy civilizations. Sonic teams up with his own sidekick, Tails, and together they embark on a globetrotting journey to find the emerald before it falls into the wrong hands. Globetrotting. Yeah, globetrotting. I will say, after reading that, it does bring to mind one of the things I want to say, and we'll start here and then get kind of your initial rating.

It amazes me how much these movies are the video games. How much they are really making the video games into a plot. You read that plot and you're like, that's a plot for the video game. It's pretty amazing. What do you guys think? Did you like it, love it, dislike it, hate it, or it was just okay? Alice, go first.

I really, really, really liked it. I don't want to say love just because I, like full bias, I went with the perfect group of people. Oh, that's fine. So I had the best time. We laughed our asses off the entire time. So I'll wait till I watch it at home. And now I really liked it. Very nice. Andrew, what about you? I'm very close to saying I really liked it. I could be convinced to pull the trigger on that, but I'll just go with liked it for now.

We're in simpatico, guys. I really liked this movie. High side of liked it. High high side of liked it. I don't want to throw it into loved it. And I think the reason for that is primarily just because it's it's just there's nothing spectacular about like it's not something I walk away from going, oh, I have been moved, you know, or I walk away from going, oh, that was so cool. Like there are moments of kind of both of those things in smaller degrees, but it's just a movie that knows what it is, sets out to do what it's going to do and does it really well. And sometimes that's all you need to have a really great experience. So.

It's more than most video game movies can say. Yes, yes. Alice, continue. Pour some love on Sonic the Hedgehog 2. Oh, yeah, so...

I went with my old share house group because we went to see the first one all together because they all grew up playing Sonic as kids. And so when this one was coming out, we were like, well, we all have to go. And we all actually happened to have matching like jumpers or sweaters, I should say. Nice. So we went to the movies wearing our matching sweaters and we sat and it was, like I said, we laughed the entire time. It was the most enjoyable movie experience I've had yet this year. And it was just, it was just so much fun. Like it was, everything was just so much fun. I finished the movie. I'd had a great time. Speaking of moments where you go, oh, that's so cool.

I know that, yeah, it definitely wasn't. And that's why I'm reticent to say I loved it too. But that post-credit scene had my partner, Toby, literally jumping out of his seat. I will just say that. If you're a fan of the Sonic games, he was so excited by that. So it pretty much almost hit there. But the rest of it, I basically, the best way I can summarize it is that this movie is just a huge meme. And if you're in the right mood and if you're willing to just let it take you, you will have a great time. Yeah, I agree. Andrew, thoughts?

Ben Schwartz was just born to play, I guess, Sonic. I really like, I like everybody in this movie. Jim Carrey is always, like, he was amazing last time, but I think he's really just given himself to this character even more in this one. And I just think Carrey's the best, and I wish he hadn't retired after this. It broke my heart when I read that.

I love this interpretation of Knuckles, you know, the Idris Elba, the mighty warrior. Everything is very serious, you know, and like I will vanquish my foes during a baseball game, stuff like that. You know, it's like, yeah, I'll eat that kind of, you know, over traumatic, you know, stuff all the time. And if it's Idris Elba's voice, then yeah, just sign me up. And I like Tails too. Tails is adorable. Yeah. Yeah. And Tails is voiced by somebody I hadn't really heard.

A lot of Colleen O'Shaughnessy. Yeah. She's the only of the original cast from the video games to be ported over into the movies. I guess they were just like, I mean, Idris Elba makes sense as Knuckles, you know, obviously Jim Carrey's Robotnik. And then, you know, having Jean-Ralphio as Sonic, like you wouldn't think that makes sense, but it does. Oh, Ben Schwartz is so good. He's one of my favorite people right now, yeah.

Yeah, he's fantastic. But I guess with Tails, they were just like, let's just get the original one. I don't see anyone else doing better. Well, I mention it because I love that. I love that when in voice work, you don't necessarily have to celebrity cast. And really, Ben Schwartz isn't really a celebrity casting. He's character casting. He's cast really well as Sonic. And I'm not saying Ben Schwartz doesn't have a level of celebrity. I'm just saying it's not like you're putting Tom Holland as Sonic. Or Chris Pratt as Mario. Thank you. Thank you for the right answer example of what I'm talking about. So yeah, I really love the voice casting in this.

watch jim carrey make one of these movies every year i i am just i'm so thankful that he's working in this kind of area again where he's just going all out he's i just watch him do this stuff and i'm like you know there have been many imitators over the year of his energy his pliability kind of what he does i don't think anybody has nailed it the way he does it feels so perfect when he's in that mode yeah it's just there's something beautiful upset like well i actually don't retire jim well yeah so i actually because i was looking up on the third movie afterwards because again that post-credit scene i was like oh what's happening and um the filmmakers have been asked a lot like are you going to recast Robotnik now that Jim Carrey is really strongly considering retirement, blah, blah, blah. And they were basically like, absolutely not. We will not recast Robotnik. But they said they have a very strong feeling that he will return for a third one. Like he won't do anything else, but he will come back for the next one because he just has so much fun doing the character. And I would love that because he honestly, the movie's great, but he just makes it that extra little bit special. Like literally the goat, every time he's on screen, I'm having the best time. There's a bit in the movie where he does his like Grinch laugh and I, my heart exploded from happiness. I just, I love him so much. And so if you want to retire, man, I'm like,

I'll be really sad. Totally get it. I'll be really sad. But please just come back for the third one. Just finish it off. Let me have my happy little trilogy and then go and live your best life painting. Yeah. Yeah. What an interesting guy, you know, to follow his career and to watch him pursue like the awards and dramatic acceptance and love from his peers and to be so denied by that and how it impacted him. And, you know, he's talked a little bit about it, but it's just one of those things where I have so much respect for somebody who can rocket to stardom like that.

And just, you know, become the like the face of, you know, 20 million dollar actors. Right. Like that was the whole thing when he had that big one, two, three year. And then all of a sudden was getting 20 million dollars to go do movies or whatever. And and somebody who can handle that and come out the other side, even somewhat coherent, insane. And he has he's he's really his career is really interesting to me. And, you know, I'm really glad to see him finding some some contentment, some peace, some joy in the stuff. So.

Yeah, that's really fun. I actually think James Marsden is really great in this role too. He's just kind of that perfect, you know, just kind of dad character. He's found his niche. Yeah. Yeah, he's a, I say my problem is just, if I do have one complaint about this movie, it's, I think that the Marsden, you know, future brother, not brother-in-law, but you know, the sister-in-law and that whole Hawaii thing didn't go anywhere really. Right. It was just comic relief. Yeah. Yeah. But I enjoyed it. It's just so you have a break every now and then from, you know. Yeah. I agree, by the way. It was the one part that didn't work for me either. I think Natasha Rothwell is funny. I think she's great. I think that character,

feels a little forced into the story to me. I think it feels like one of those things like, oh, people loved this character from the first one and some of the things that happened with that. So let's design something in the script for this character in this one. And Shemar Moore, I just, I wasn't buying it. I don't know what it was. I just, I wasn't really connected to what he was doing. But yeah, that was really kind of the only thing in this movie that just kind of lost me a little bit. So yeah, yeah. But everybody else I like. Yeah, I mean, I thought it was a weird.

weird tangent but i still had fun with like all the random bits like the really tiny you know weapons and um you know the way they have to kind of do their own sort of side mission and kind of be like oh yeah these characters exist let's let them do something um like i mean yeah it was it just kind of i feel like when that whole um sequence ended it was a part of us where we were all like oh yeah Why were we there so long? Let's get back to the real story. But, you know, it was just a bit of fun. And to be honest, that's kind of the movie. It's like, it's just fun. I already said this, but, you know, this isn't a movie that's trying to go down. Like you said, it's not meant to be something that really moves you or go down as one of the greatest movies of all time. You know, it's not trying to be that. It's just kind of, it's Sonic, the movie. It's one of the games.

well ported over into a coherent movie that actually one thing I will say in terms of positives as well is that it seems to have nailed its Easter eggs because every few minutes my like Toby was just like oh like he just kept gasping next to me and I was like oh is this a thing from the games because I didn't play I didn't play it so I'm just having a good time but he was like oh yeah for example the um I will say the design there's an Eggman robot and the design of that is something that was apparently extremely accurate and it was like perfect representation um including yeah so that was just something that got everyone very excited especially because it's such a big part of the games apparently too Yeah, I've heard often about this movie and I think it sums up a lot of things really well that Jeff Fowler, the director, understood the assignment. You know, like he understood what to do. You know, there was the poster for the movie looks just like the cover for Sonic the Hedgehog 2, the video game. You know, like just these little things that you don't have to get.

You know, like, it's not like the World of Warcraft thing that I've talked about where, like, I go and see that movie. It's like, OK, that was a reference, but I don't get it. Like, they're not so in your face that, like, if you don't get them, you're going to be confused. But they're there and they're easy to pick up on. And I didn't play a lot of Sonic. I was a Nintendo kid. And but, you know, the ones I catch are fine. And the ones I miss, I don't even know that I'm missing them, really. So, yeah, like the egg. And you get enough. You're like, oh, that's probably a reference. So then I would say, was that a reference? And then he'd be like, yeah, that was a reference. And I'd be like, cool. Anyway, back to the movie. A literal robotic Easter egg in this one, apparently. Other thoughts? Andrew, we haven't heard from you

say? Well, as it was mentioned, there was a post-credit scene. Yes, yes, there is a post-credit scene. Or mid-credit scene, I guess. How dare you steal that, Alice? That is the one thing Andrew looks forward to. I got one job. One job he has to do. You take it from him. Well, we have another movie. We have another movie. Well, I actually, there's one character that I really wish got more screen time, and that was Dr. Stone.

Yeah. Because I wanted Robotnik to have a Wilson in this movie. You know, he'd been stuck in Mushroom Planet for so long that I just wanted him to have a little Wilson that he carried around with him and, you know, talked to. Yeah. Yeah. But he has the real, oh my gosh, that whole bit in the barista scene. Oh, the barista? Yeah. That was gold. Like when he's, you know, there's a bit where he's making it and he gets emotional. Oh my goodness. I could not stop laughing, honestly. But in terms of like.

You know, I'm obviously saying how high I am on this movie. One thing that I was a bit like, there were a lot, I feel like almost more pop culture references than in the last one. And they were dated in this, like watching it now, which I don't know if that was intentional in that, oh, they're dated now, so they won't date later. But there was just so many. And I noticed it at some point. I'm just like, oh, you don't need to do that. It's OK. Yeah. Yeah, totally. I totally get that. Yeah, I think my only other thing I would want to say is this is one of those movies that.

really walks that nice little balance between, yeah, being a movie that kids will enjoy and kind of a family movie, but anybody can go to and have a good time. Like there's, you know, there's enough going on. And it doesn't, it doesn't feel like that thing where they're doing a bunch of jokes that, you know, are purposely supposed to go over the kids' heads or whatever. There are a couple of those, you know, word plays. But for the most part, yeah, I just think it's kind of one of those movies that everybody's just going to enjoy. If you can find your way into that space. And if not, that's fine too. If it's not something you like, then, you know, don't spend your time with it. But man, I had, I had a really good time with Sonic. If you'd have told me the Sonic the Hedgehog movies were going to be some of my favorite movies.

uh over the last few years that would have that would have really surprised me but uh yeah especially after that first trailer not that you would have seen it well i was certainly aware of the public discourse that sonic looks terrible or something or had teeth maybe you had to have gone online and seen the original design by now i'm not sure i maybe You would remember. You would remember if you did. It would be haunting my nightmares. The teeth. The teeth. Okay. All right. Well, then maybe I haven't seen it. He had like weird human teeth. And again, you know what? That for me, perfect representation of this movie. They were like, okay, our bad. We'll go back and we'll fix it. And they did. And now the design of him and Tails and Knuckles, it's so much better. And that's another thing. I also really liked Knuckles. I thought he was like kind of cute in his anger. He really reminded me of my puppy. And I was like, oh, you're a little cutie that could kill me if he wanted to do. And that was like a perfect representation of him.

But yeah, no, I just think you're right. It is just fun. And like, yeah, you could comment on like small little tidbits here and there, but I actually think as well, it's a great sequel to the first one too. So I feel like if you want to know if you're going to enjoy this movie, if you enjoyed the first one and you want more of that, that is very much what the sequel is. It doesn't have sequel-itis. I think I almost enjoyed it more. So there you go. Yeah, yeah. Andrew has been kind enough to link me in our chat to the original Sonic. And wow, that's a different look. That is a monster.

yep it's even more terrifying in motion as opposed to just even a single picture like if you go back and you watch the original trailer like him walking and moving around and talking yeah it's way too human it's just way too human is what it is it feels like the teeth yeah it feels like some it feels like a human child wearing a really intense sonic suit um yeah that's that's wild well thank you for sharing that uh Thank you for the nightmares I will have for the next few weeks. I was going to say, enjoy the nightmares. Appreciate that. Let's try to wrap that grotesque creature out of our mind by talking about other grotesque creatures and beautiful ones. Fantastic Beasts, The Secrets of Dumbledore. I'm sorry to disturb you, Thomas, but I've just received troubling news. Tell me, what is it? It's Grindelwald. The time is closed, my brothers and sisters. Our war with the Muggles begins today. The world as we know it is coming unknown. If we're to defeat him, we'll have to trust him. Mr. Kowalski, we need you. I said I won an out and I won out.

You do know I'm a witch, right? Dumbledore asked if I give you something. Take it. In an effort to thwart Grindelwald's plans of raising pureblood wizards to rule over all non-magical beings, Albus Dumbledore enlists his former student Newt Scamander, who agrees to help, though he's unaware of the dangers that lie ahead. Lines are drawn as love and loyalty are tested even among the truest friends and family in an increasingly divided wizarding world. This is Wizarding World of Harry Potter, and still going. Movie number three in the Fantastic Beasts series. What did you guys think? Did you like it, love it, dislike it, hate it, or it was just okay? Andrew kicks off.

It's known by now that I'm not really a Wizarding World fan and I haven't, especially for this Fantastic Beasts. So I didn't like this one. Alice, what about you? I cannot describe how much I hated this movie. Oh, I'm so excited. But you're going to try, right? You're going to try. I'm going to try. You're going to try to describe how much you hated this movie. I was angry leaving this movie. Wow. And I was angry leaving the last one. Wow. Well, it pains me to say then I think this is okay. I think it's maybe even high side of okay. It's certainly the best one for me of the three. I feel like it's more cohesive than the other two. I feel like the plot makes more sense than the other two. And I feel like I'm connected to the characters in a more interesting way than the other one.

Shocker. Now is the fun part where my, hey, this movie was kind of okay, turns into Aaron loved the movie. I did not. I did not love the movie. We will talk about all the flaws. I'm sure Alice will list them one by one, and I will agree with them. But since I did apparently like it more than everybody else. Yeah, what's so good about this movie, Aaron? What makes this movie amazing, man? What makes this movie the best movie ever, dude? Why is it your favorite movie of the year, man? Why is this the best movie of all time? Why going on the record with that? I don't know. I think for me, these movies have to do one thing really well, and I'm going to be okay with them.

And that is the magic stuff has to be really cool. And there are just so few. I was watching Sorcerer's Apprentice recently. The Disney one with Nicolas Cage and Jay Baruchel. And it's a really fun movie, but I find it really fun mainly because it has a lot of fun with the spells. It has a lot of interesting little different things that happen. And for me, Harry Potter has never connected to me deeply on a like, you know, a level of growing up or coming of age or that kind of stuff. It's really more connected to me on. Oh, man, I love the idea of.

casting spells and magic and what that would look like in the real world and when you really start thinking about any of that stuff none of it makes sense but you kind of have this like uh suspension of disbelief that you can go into these movies and just be like well you know if if there are ultra powerful spells that these people have why aren't they doing them all the time well you just kind of suspend your disbelief and just go no because it's more fun right here if there's you know a creature whose neck turns into a hot air balloon. That's more fun right here than a different spell that might do the same thing. And so I watched this movie and there was moment after moment, for me, of fun like that, where it's like, oh, I've never seen anything like that before. That's really creative. I love what that spell does, what that creature does. I love the creature at the center of the plot in this one. I think it's a really interesting idea and kind of how that navigates what's going on here. So for me, when I watch a movie like this, if it's doing those things well, and I think this movie does those things well,

I'm going to be able to suspend my disbelief and have a good time. I think Jude Law as Dumbledore is really good. I really enjoy his presence. The Newt Scamander character is one I like for a specific reason. There are very few protagonists like him. And I love that. It is actually a little bit of that Jay Baruchel energy from Sorcerer's Apprentice, where it's a little bumbling, but not really. There's a competence there underneath the perceived nerdiness that is kind of interesting to me. So I like that Newt Scamander character. So yeah, I mean, if I like Newt and I like Aldous, like...

You know, the rest of it is going to be fine. I certainly have negatives. I'll let you guys get into that. But that kind of maybe explains why I was OK watching this and had a decent enough time. It would even say high side of OK, but not like it. I didn't like this movie, guys. I didn't like this movie. It was OK. All right. There we go. Do you guys have anything positive to say about it? Andrew, you liked it a little more than Alice.

Actually, the main thing that I was going to say is that, yeah, I agree with you. I do like Jude Law. Just he has a presence about him that I think, you know, he carries himself away in these movies where, you know, whenever he talks, everybody listens. And he just really has that. And also kind of like the Dan Fogler character. I liked him more the very first movie that I saw. Because he was kind of like our in to this world. You know, he was the, is it Muggle or Muggle? Muggle. Muggle. Yeah, he is the Muggle of the bunch. And just like us. So we get to see all this fantastical.

through his eyes. So, yeah. Other than that, not... I laughed. I definitely laughed in this movie. Swivel? Yeah, there's a swivel, you know, bit that was just so ridiculous. I didn't know if I was supposed to cringe laugh or just laugh laugh. That was funny. I thought that was really funny. No, but at the end of the day, I realized, you know what, there's really not a difference between a cringe laugh and laugh laugh. I mean, yes, it's incredibly stupid, but I'm still smiling.

So, and that's really what's important. It's like, yeah, I'm smiling. This movie made me smile. Well, it's exactly the kind of, that scene to me is the promise of this property. The idea is that this character understands these crazy creatures so well that, you know, he has a different type of relationship to the animals of this universe. He, you know, he studied them. And so, and he's also, you know, willing to drop any pride to, you know, interact with them in the proper way. So, yeah. Yeah. I liked it. Allison? Yeah, Alice.

Oh, I said Alison, sorry. That's okay. That's all good. It's so early. I will say, it's late for me. I totally feel it. Same, same, but different. No, so for me, I agree. I like Jude Law. I think the chemistry between Jude Law and Mads Mikkelsen is better than the chemistry between Jude Law and Johnny Depp. And having said that, I actually think, I do like Mads Mikkelsen more as a Grindelwald, but that's, I think, because I really like Mads Mikkelsen as an actor, period. So I'm more willing to kind of be on board with him. I think he's fantastic. I really like Jude Law, seeing them against each other. I was kind of like, yeah, I mean, I buy that more.

And that is where it is. Okay, getting into it. So as we know. We are transitioning to the hate, ladies and gentlemen. Get your hate umbrellas ready.

Technically, Andrew Jacob is a nomad, not a muggle because he's American. So that's just a little thing. And that right there can tell you that I am a huge Harry Potter fan. I am the target audience here. So we are about to get into some high, high level toxic fandom right now. This is this is about toxic. The reason I hated this movie and I will admit, I think that this movie is better than the last one, but by like five percent, you know, like three percent. And the reason I'm so angry at it is because of the emotional manipulation it used to try and win and buy its fans love to try and be like.

Look, we know we made a bad one the last time around. We're trying to fix it this time around. Please just like us. Please just like us. And it didn't work because there is a reuse. And you might not know this, Andrew, not being a fan. And I don't know about you, Aaron, obviously, maybe not having seen it. I've read all the books, but I'm not a huge fan. So there's uses of quotes that are directly from the movies and the books that were angering. Very important quotes said by characters later on in very important scenes that they took to just try and stab us in the heart. Then there's use of music during when you see Hogwarts and when you have different... It's fan service.

The Hogwarts one I got, but there's one when, say, suitcases explode. Suitcases are exploding when there's literally using scenes from the Harry Potter movies and the music from the Harry Potter music. movies I should say and it was just I could tell it was them trying to be like look it's whimsical and fun like in this movie and then there's the fact that McGonagall is in this movie when she's meant to be like four years old and it's spitting in the face of anyone who's actually a fan of the Harry Potter and Wizarding World because we know that we know that she's meant to be like four years old at this time because otherwise that means that during the Harry Potter movie she's meant to be like 95 during the Sorcerer's Stone of Philosopher's Stone it doesn't make any sense but what they're doing is they're taking it and they're shoving it down our throats to try and be like please please please like us please like this horrible horrible thing we've done and it's not working because they did that all throughout the marketing as well I don't know if you guys I know you haven't seen it, Aaron, but Andrew, the trailers, all the trailers were literally like, hey, remember how much you love The Wizarding World? Remember how much you love Harry Potter? Most of the trailer is just clips from the Harry Potter movies and then footage from The Wizarding World theme park and then there's like 30 seconds at the end for the actual movie because they knew what they've done and what they're trying to fix and it didn't work because this stupid movie is so convoluted and just let it die. I don't want it anymore. Okay, okay, Alice, Alice. We'll talk you down here with Alice. Okay.

I can be more. I just need to get that out. No, no, no. That's fine. I imagine there's more to come. So far, though, this feels, forgive me if I'm wrong, but this feels very personal. This feels like this is one of those things where there's a lot of projection going on. You are assuming motives for a lot of what you're saying, and those motives are crucial to why you hate it.

Like, you know, there's not a lot of talking about why the movie doesn't work for you. There's a lot of, so far, and I totally get it. I'm a fan of things too. I know how it can be. But so far it's like, I see you trying to make me like this and I'm not going to fall for it. And it's like, well. But it's so blatant. But it's not blatant enough that I picked up on it. No, but everyone I know who's a deep, deep core Harry Potter fan like me feels exactly the same way as me because it didn't work. But I will be more measured. Okay. I just had to get that out. Oh no, you don't have to be more measured. You can say whatever you want to say, Alex. This is great podcasting. I'm loving this. Okay, good. Good. Because.

The reason I say let it die is because I think the main issue with this trilogy so far and what is meant to be five movies, but we'll see if that happens, is I think that this would have worked if it had been a Fantastic Beasts movie or... or if it had been a series about the whole Dumbledore-Grindelwald struggle. Mashing them together gives it this weird, unbalanced tone that ultimately comes out in this insanely convoluted story that they try to sweep under the rug by literally having a plot point be about, oh, it's confusing on purpose, because then they can make it confusing. But that's not to say they didn't do it properly. There's such lazy writing in this movie. For example, huge character set up in the last movie, Nagini, just not.

Not present. They set up this character who we've known in the Harry Potter movies as literally being the personification of evil. And all of a sudden she's a person that got a horrible fate upon her, turned into a snake. And we later know beheaded by Neville. But we're like, oh goodness, how did she go from being a good person? Because at the end of Crimes of Grindelwald, she's a good person to literally being the snake upon whose teat Voldemort sucks. You know, like that. And then they just, obviously they couldn't figure it out either. So she's just not in this or mentioned or anywhere. And that's to say with her, as well as I'll say, there's also a character turn at the end, which is a very obvious retcon for an intense character motivation flip in the last movie.

that doesn't make any sense and it just that those sort of things are present throughout the entire thing where it's just like you could you couldn't figure out a way to fix it so you just did it and hoped that we wouldn't notice well we noticed i'll let you guys speak a little bit no no it's great it's great i just i don't i don't know how to respond because i don't see all those things right like you know it's not something that's necessarily stands out to me i go to a movie i go okay movie tell me what you want to tell me i don't i don't you know for the most part especially when i'm not tied to a fandom uh for the most part i try to let each movie exist kind of on their own to tell me the story they want to tell me if they don't want to bring nagini into this movie why do they have to like you know it's not like they're you know but you're seeing it from a bigger picture, right? Like you're seeing it as a fan of the whole universe and you want to know how this, why Nagini was this way and then ended up being this way, but that's not the story they wanted to tell you in this movie. So like, you know, like that's their prerogative, right? But they brought her in and they just, she was set up to be a major character. Okay, but it's a sequel, Aaron. You can't just set up a character in the movie before it who's a major character who's meant to be like the best friend of Credence pretty much. And she's just gone.

like not even mentioned. She's not even mentioned, like not even a lazy line of like, oh, Nagini's turned into a snake now or whatever. You know, there's just, she's just not present. And they do the lazy line, you know, with other characters, or I'll see a lazy presence with other characters. And that was...

confusing, if anything else. The whole thing's just confusing. It's just, I get that they're working off a confused base because I think that J.K. Rowling wrote the original screenplay and then, for obvious reasons, she didn't continue it and they had to use it. I don't know why. And they also are working off a confused base because the last movie was so cacophonous that they just had to kind of piece it together. It feels very reminiscent to me of Rise of Skywalker, where it feels like the filmmaker's trying to undo a bunch of stuff that people didn't like in the last one, and instead it just created this weird, imbalanced story that ultimately just left me wanting. And so that's really my main issue, is that the plot is so convoluted.

doesn't make sense the characters I feel like you know you say obviously Newt's the protagonist but I honestly feel that's a very strong word because he's not really he's not doing very much for a protagonist you know and so and also it's also very predictable as a story I knew what was going to happen in the first five minutes and that's not because I'm a Harry Potter fan it was so obvious the way they presented everything and it just wasn't magical Well, there you go. I'm not happy. Just let it die. Start again. Andrew, they have destroyed something that Alice loved and she is in pain. Can you help? What did you see in this movie? Well, nothing good. So I'm probably just going to pile on to everything that she just said. Actually, I'm going to disagree with Alice on one front. She bought into the romance between Jude Law and Mads Mikkelsen. I didn't. I didn't buy into that at all. I like Jude Law and I like Mads Mikkelsen.

Specifically, I like Mad Mikkelsen in this role. Will they please stop recasting Grindelwald? Because, you know, first it was Colin Farrell, then it was Johnny Depp, and now it's Mads Mikkelsen. It's going to be Jim Carrey next role, I know. Wow. Maybe then I'd be okay. Yeah, but honestly, I did not buy into any relationship between these two at all. I felt that it was very forced and that I just wasn't buying it. Now, having said that, my biggest issue with this movie is, is this the last one of the fantasy movies? No, it's meant to be three of five. So the next one is going to be all about Nagini.

Because they're going to listen to this podcast and they're going to be like, Alice needs some resolution with the genie. I don't even care. Let's go. I don't care about the character. It's just weird that they would bring her up at all. Yeah. Anyway. So then that kind of makes sense for going forward because I thought this was the last one. And I felt like it was lacking a lot of resolutions, which now makes sense that they're not resolving a whole bunch of stuff like with Ezra Miller character or with, is it Goldstein? Tina Goldstein? Tina Goldstein. Yeah. Like this, will they, won't they?

they probably won't because they're never on screen together anymore sort of thing. What is holding this romance together if they're never together? The fact that J.K. Rowling said that they're married in the Wizarding World histories. So that's what's holding them together. Jessica Williams, who plays Lolly, has one of the worst British accents I've ever heard somebody try and pull off. Was that British? I thought she was doing transatlantic American. It felt like she was trying to do a proper British accent whenever I was watching. I'm like, this is not good.

Aaron, what did you hear her say? I didn't notice any problem with her accent. I thought she was American, I will tell you that, but I didn't notice any kind of issue with it. It sounded like, yeah, it sounded, I have to listen again, but- Maybe it's more like Catherine Hepburn, you know that? Yes, yes, transit later. Like, hey, what do you think about that, see? Like, that sort of, which was, it is kind of weird because she's the only one doing it, but I think she was doing it, yeah.

Yeah, just a lot of this stuff. Maybe it's my unfamiliarity with this grand, I don't even know how you would describe the vastness of this Wizarding World universe. What would you even call it? The Wizard Universe? The Wizardverse? They call it the Wizarding World. The Wizarding World? Okay. So the vastness of this Wizarding World, there is so much information to consume that I think if you're somebody like me who doesn't consume that information, these movies, all three of these Fantastic Beasts movies, have been incredibly confusing.

They've been very, very confusing because I think that they, and I don't see anything wrong with this. You know, I think Aaron, you talked about this whenever we were talking about, uh, Sonic, uh, whenever you referenced the, uh, the world of Warcraft movie, you know how it's a movie made for fans or you may have said it about this franchise. I can't remember, but it's a movie made for fans and they don't bother, uh, you know, handholding anybody through it. Like characters are introduced. We're supposed to know who they are already through previous knowledge. We're supposed to have a general understanding of spell crafting, spell casting. And, uh, I don't.

I'll say this, and this is kind of tangential. I think that this franchise would be better served if there was a more set in stone, possibly more well-delivered rule set for how magic works. Because whenever I'm watching this movie and this franchise, it just seems like if they can think of it, then they can do it. It's kind of what I like. That's kind of what I was talking about how I like. I just give myself to that. I'm like, show me the next cool thing you want to show me.

It can be cool, but at the same time, it can feel like, you know, just a get out of jail free. Oh, sure. Of course. Oh, yes, absolutely. And that's my main issue with it, because I'm never, you know, I don't know what the stakes are because I don't know what everybody can do. So like my level of like fear or, you know, fear or dread that Grindelwald's going to get away with this, which I know, you know, tangentially with the style of story, you know, bad guy can't win in this world, you know, sort of a thing. But at the same time, it's like, yeah, well.

For all I know, these people are gods, and if they want to do something, then they can do it, you know? And I have no understanding of people's limits. Like, I hate making this comparison, but if you look at the MCU, you look at Iron Man versus Thanos during that big fight. I'm worried because... Yes, Tony Stark is incredibly smart and he has amazing technology, but he's a human. I know his limits. Whereas Thanos, I know, is a titan. He has, and I'm not even using, you know, previous knowledge that I have of reading comic books or anything. I think that the movies themselves did a good job of letting us, the audience, know this is what this person can do. This is what this person can do. So whenever I have that knowledge, I can set myself in either one's position and understand the stakes and the dangers that each person is in. And that's been my major issue with Wizarding World as a whole for a very long time. I never knew how powerful.

Who's the main, main bad guy in the original Harry Potter? Voldemort? Voldemort, yeah. That lets you know how much I don't know about this franchise. I never knew how powerful Voldemort was. Andrew needs to do a rewatch. No, please. But I never knew how powerful Voldemort was. I never knew how powerful Harry Potter was. I got the sense that Dumbledore was possibly one of the most powerful just because he was really old and he was the head of the school. So his title gave me an idea of his abilities, you know? But other than that, you know, I was fairly lost. That's my tangent.

I think that Alice's tangent was more personal, whereas mine is a whole lot more general. My overall issues with the wizarding world as a whole. I don't disagree with a lot of what you guys are saying. The only thing I would push back maybe a little bit is the idea that this plot is convoluted. It feels very simple to me. Maybe you're talking about branches of the plot that are also being... The steps taken to get to the... Yeah, I think that's where... Because the main plot is fairly simple and I actually really like it. Stop it, man. Well...

No, I'm talking about the antagonist plot. I'm talking about Grindelwald's motives and plot in what he is doing. I think it's fairly well laid out. I think it's, you know, communicated to us well. I never felt confused. I never, I always knew where we were. I knew what everybody was trying to do. I just, you know, so that part of it doesn't ring quite true to me. That wasn't my experience. My experience, I never felt confused during this movie. I always felt like I understood what the goals were and what needed to happen. It must be nice. Maybe just click for some reason, but I don't know. Yeah.

Yeah, don't get me wrong. It wasn't that I wasn't confused personally. It wasn't me going like, what? It was more me going like, why? Why is all this happening? This is stupid. And I agree. I think the actual plot at its center was super simple, which is why I knew exactly what was going to happen at every point. But the way of doing it...

I feel like they were, they did it in a way that they tried to make it more adventurous and fun and whimsical. And instead it just made me not want to be in the movie theater. Like it just was just kind of like, okay, now this is happening. Okay. I had a moment of levity during the swivel moment. And you know, yes, I enjoy seeing magic happen too, because I love Harry Potter and magic is cool. And I wish I was a witch, you know, but even the way the magic happens. And again, yes, I completely understand. I'm coming from a huge fan perspective. So my opinion is my lived experience will be if you were a Harry Potter fan, this is probably what you're going to feel. And I'm so sorry for you. This is Alice's Dark Tower moment.

My Dark Tower. Actually, it's funny because the last movie was My Dark Tower moment. And this is like they made a sequel just to hurt me. No, no, no. One of the many reasons we love having you on the show, Alice, is your fandom. You are one of my favorite fandom people. You really invest yourself in the things that you love. That's a lot of fun. I love it when people love things deeply. I love that passion. So, yeah, there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. Anything else you guys want to say before we move on?

No post-credits soon. No post-credits soon. If I was the person in charge, which I should be, but that's another story. This is what I would do. I would just pretend this never happened. They wrapped it up. Going back to your earlier point, Andrew, I think what they did is they wrapped it up in a way where it's like, in case they don't get greenlit for the fourth one, it kind of wrapped up. But in case they do, they can obviously still continue the story. I think just leave it. And then if they really want to do a prequel, they should do the prequel that everyone has been asking for since the third movie came out, which is, and this is really, again,

It's a fandom thing, but there's the Marauders. So the story of Harry Potter's parents when they were at school. So that includes James Lily, Sirius Black, Remus Lupin, and then also Snape. That is a whole history that was mostly cut out from the movies just because of time and, you know, obviously because there was a different story we had to focus on. But it is a story with a lot of depth, a lot of potential. And it would also, I think, solve your issue, Andrew, of it would help kind of re-explain the steps because they ultimately were at school. And so there's that kind of setting again. And so I think if you really want to do something, do that.

Honestly, as a TV show, I think this would be great as a series. And then just wait like 20 years and then redo Harry Potter as a TV show. So you can include all the stuff that got cut out. That to me is the way it makes sense to continue the Wizarding World and bring all the fans back. There you go. Hire Alice. That's all I have to say. Hire Alice as your chief creative. Let Alice be the Kevin Feige of the Harry Potter world and just move on. Now, I knew that Fantastic Beasts obviously was, you know, a prequel to the Harry Potter with Dumbledore being as young as he is. Does the Harry Potter's parents take place during these events here?

No, no. This was the 20s. They're not that old. I don't know. I don't know how long Wizards live. I don't know how time works. I mean, they're just like normal people. You say that like I'm an idiot, but Jude Law is in his 50s in this movie. How old is he going to be? Dumbledore's the exception because he had a little bit of elixir of life from Nicholas Flamel, but normally wizards and witches age at the same rate as humans. Come on, come on. You knew all about the... It would have been like the 80s-ish. You freaking moron. All right, let's...

Before we head on to the Best Ever Challenge, a reminder that you can become a Sif Pop member and hear more of this amazing passion on your own bonus podcast in your own podcast feed. This week, Andrew caught us up on his opinions on the two movies we talked about last week, Ambulance and Everything Everywhere All at Once. I really wish we got to spend some time talking about Ambulance. Yeah, we talk most of the time about Ambulance, obviously. No, some really great additional Everything Everywhere All at Once conversation in the members-only pre-show. If you're interested in checking that out, and even more than that, just kind of supporting what goes on here and at the website, you can do that at patreon.com slash Sif Pop. And a huge thank you ahead of time for doing that for us. All right, let's move on.

to the best ever challenge. Best ever strange animal movies. We already talked about how this is a really broad category. We will go from number five to number one. I will kick us off and I will just say...

I kind of tried to limit myself to actual like fantastical creatures. Like, you know, not just the fact that, you know, this is a different kind of horse, you know, or, or whatever, you know, it's just like, it's, it's, you know, actual weird, fantastical creatures. Um, and so in at number five, um, like you don't have, you don't have Clint Eastwood with an orangutan in a, in a semi truck. Correct. Correct. But I wouldn't veto that. I get it. Like, you know, make the category work for you. Totally understand it. Um, but I went, uh, with avatar at number five, I'm getting so super excited.

Super, super, super pumped for the Avatar movies. I really hope James Cameron is going to do some really incredible visual world building. I'm really excited to see what he has for us. Aaron, definitely try and skip the trailers for Multiverse of Madness because they've confirmed they're going to show the Avatar 2 trailer in front of that movie. Oh, okay. Wow, that's interesting. So yeah, so I was thinking about Avatar and a lot of the creatures from the other world. I think of the weird floaty umbrella creature. Jellyfish? Yeah, like the jellyfish that I saw. I really, really loved.

um so yeah there's there's a lot of cool stuff there and i really do like avatar so yeah that was my number five uh alice what about you yeah i tried to limit myself as well because to be honest, every Disney or Pixar movie could be in this category. So I allowed myself one Disney slash Pixar movie and I allowed myself one other major franchise, but I also, the rest I just went on instinct because if I thought about it too much, like I said, my list would have been here for a very long time. So I went instinct for the top five and then I just wrote down a bunch I could think of and then I just was like, that's enough, walk away. And so that's what I did. So number five, I've got, and this might get trumped, or it might not actually, The Princess Bride. Nope.

No, I didn't consider the, like, I thought about the big rats. Yeah, it's just that they're big rats. And so, yeah, I didn't quite see it. Again, will not veto it. Yeah. Or the Wally Sean. Wally Sean is a weird animal. True. Or Billy Crystal. Yeah. And his wife. Have a storm in the castle.

But yeah, I think that, like, it's, you know, you don't really have rats that could kill you. Like, oh, I don't think there are. I could be wrong. And I live in Australia, where we do have other things that can kill you. Yeah, you need to go to New York. Yeah, that's true. Oh my gosh, actually, though. Yeah, my friends always tell me about that when they've been to New York, and I'm like, that sounds horrific. But back to Princess Bride. I love this movie. I think most people love this movie. It's...

whimsical. It stands up really well. Gosh, what is it, like 40, almost 50, is it 50 years later? I don't know, it was the 80s, so 40 years later. It's so exciting and just a great watch. It's wholesome. It's told as a full whole. The performances are great. The story's great. I'm not going to say anything that people haven't said before, but- Princess Bride's late 80s. Late 80s, there you go. So yeah, I think if you're maybe in a younger generation and you haven't gotten around to it yet, I would definitely recommend checking it out. And maybe sometimes, especially if you're like, oh, it's old, I don't want to watch it. Just ignore that. Just watch it anyway. It's really, really good. And yeah.

it's just a really nice fantasy story and there aren't enough of those. So that's my number five. Absolutely. Uh, I did put a, I did put a picture, I did put a picture in our, uh, in our comments. Yeah, but they're so chill. They wouldn't kill you. They just kind of look at you and then keep walking by. Yeah. Yes. They are rodents of unusual size. However, they will not, uh, they will not kill you. Uh, that's true. All right. Uh, we will go to Andrew. Uh, what is your number five?

by number five well let's go with big fish oh it's trumped it's trumped it's trumped i'm glad it's trumped all right we'll go on to our number fours uh in at number four for me is the fifth element um some interesting creatures in that one specifically i'm thinking about that that creature that has like a trunk and is like multi-colored and i forget what the creature's name is but this is one of my favorite movies um it's just it is one of those fantastical sci-fi movies that it just it tweaks something i mean i hadn't seen elsewhere you know there just seemed to be an imagination there uh and i really enjoy it so yeah fifth element is um One of my favorites. That's my number four. Gary Oldman is definitely a strange creature. He is absolutely a strange creature. Alice, what do you got at number four?

This is where I have big fish. Talk about it. Yeah, I adore this movie. I watched it as a kid when it first came out. I honestly kind of think it's almost Tim Burton at his best, you know, doing his whimsical, crazy thing, but in a way that is really wholesome. I also love Ewan McGregor. He's one of my favorite actors. So I'll watch anything and everything he's in. And again, similar to Princess Bride, it's very wholesome. I love the metaphorical nature, the familial metaphor behind it. And it's just such a nice story of...

beautiful vignettes and what it means to just be a person who lives with a vivid imagination. And as a person who also is like that, not to the point that the main character is, although, you know, talk to me when I'm about to die, but we'll see what my mind does then. But it's just, it always makes me smile, this movie. And the big fish at its centre. Yeah, it makes me smile. It makes me cry. It makes me be like, oh, that was nice. That's one of these movies. And I think it's a cult favourite. But again, if it's been missed, like it's just such a lovely movie and I really do recommend it. And everyone in it is fantastic and the story is fantastic.

Andrew, you had it at number five. Anything to add? Yeah, it's interesting. Whenever we do these best ever challenges, I always find myself as I'm making the list, I like pick one movie. It doesn't even have to be the number one movie. I'll go back and I'll rewatch it. And Big Fish was the one that I went back and rewatched yesterday. And gosh, Albert Finney, man, he's just the best. And yeah, I'll compare this movie to the Harry Potter franchise. You might be confused a little bit, but give me some rope here. I think that this movie does a better job of con, you know, what's the word here? Conveying, you know, magic.

to people, you know? I know it tries to put it in a more real-world sense that, you know, the imagination and, like, a wandering mind itself is magic, you know? But at the same time, like, I would walk away from this movie believing in magic more than I would, like, a Harry Potter movie, just because I think that there's more heart behind this than, like, a Fantastic Beasts movie, you know? But I also almost feel that this movie's about, you know, the magic of... of the real, you know, the magic that you can find in your real life. Like you can't cast a spell in your real life, but you can experience something like this. Yeah. Yeah. Maybe you can't cast a spell in your real life. You don't know about it. I got a remote. Yeah. But actually a hundred percent else, you know, it's like you see somebody tall and you know, you did with the magic of your imagination. They're now a giant or you see somebody, you see a very hairy Danny DeVito and you're like, Oh, that's a werewolf. You know, you know, just the power of the magic in imagination is incredible. And how that is, you know, conveyed from father to son.

You know, like one being a very literal person. And, you know, he's like, I just really want you to experience the magic that I've felt my whole life. And gosh, that ending gets me every single time. Yeah, so good. So good. What's your number four, Andrew?

My number four, let's go all the way back to 1954, was Godzilla. Oh, yes. Yeah, that'll work. This is a horror movie. Yes. In case you guys don't know this, I always found this to be a fascinating fact I like to share with people. After World War II, whenever Japan was under American control, you know, specifically when it came to film entertainment, it was strictly forbidden to do any films that had any propaganda that was anti-nuclear war.

you weren't allowed to do any nuclear war propaganda. So the way that they made, you know, they went around it is they made Godzilla who is supposed to be an analogy for, you know, atomic destruction. He is an, you know, and it would take a great sacrifice to stop, stop this uncontrollable power. Now going all the way from 1954 to how Godzilla has. evolved i guess you could say over and i'm not using that as a pun of him actually evolving but you know the story arc of him just being a giant kaiju who you know fights other giant kaiju and stuff like that and just an awesome monster movie but that first movie was trying to say something the first god the first godzilla back in 1954 is a horror film it is a horror film that is done unlike any other horror film since i think yeah it's one of my favorite movies i should say this yeah all my top five are in my top 100 movies all time oh nice nice i think mine are too um nicely done all right let's move on to our number threes I have Galaxy Quest at number three. That was my number six. Yeah, I just see Tim Allen fighting that lizard pig or whatever that thing is. Yeah, the pig lizard. The pig lizard. I'm doing all right with the pig lizard. This movie is so funny. This is one of those movies that I never hesitate to recommend to people. It almost doesn't matter who it is. I'm just like, just watch Galaxy Quest. You're going to have so much fun. So yeah, Galaxy Quest is a ton of fun. Really kind of the birth of Buzz Lightyear in some ways is in that movie. Did Galaxy Quest come out before the first Toy Story? I don't think it did.

Toy Story came out in 95. Great question. Great question. No, you're right. Galaxy Quest was 99. So, yeah. The birth of Buzz Lightyear was actually in 1995 with Toy Story. And then Galaxy Quest was a further exploration of that. Well, you know, Buzz Lightyear in and of himself is, you know, an amalgamation of so many different space around characters throughout cinema. Totally. Anyways, love Galaxy Quest. Check it out if you haven't seen it. Switch to number three, Alice.

My number three is, speaking of Harry Potter, let's go to a good one. Again, could save the entire franchise, but I'm going to focus in on what many people consider to be the best, which is Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. Pick your poison with your strange creatures. You've got werewolves, you've got rats that are magic, you've got dementors, you've got hippogriffs. But the movie is excellent. It is fantastic, and it is a great interpretation of the third book with the beginning, unlike the first two that were pretty much...

carbon copies of the books. This one took the third book and kind of made it its own thing. Alfonso Cuaron really decided to kind of put in his own style and it helped evolve the franchise. And I honestly think it kind of helped create the franchise into what it ended up being and allowing it to become as memorable as it was because they weren't feeling as stuck within the pages of the books anymore. Because with any adaptation, it is about taking what is there and then doing it in a way that is honorable and honoring that text, but doing it in a way that translates well on screen. And I think it's that perfect middle. And I think Alfonso Cuaron, we all know now what a fantastic director he is.

And so he took that and really made it his own. And the color palette, you know, the way the characters start to even wear clothes. And I will say the werewolf transformation scene is one of the greatest ones. It looks so painful to watch. And I've never seen a werewolf transformation scene and gone, oh, that sounds horrible. I don't want to be a werewolf. You need to see American Werewolf in London.

I own it. I haven't seen it yet. But that one, as a kid, my Achilles heel still feels it because there's the bit where it focuses on his feet and I'm like, oh, yeah, it's just so fantastic. It's Harry Potter. If you've seen it, you've seen it. But it's a really good one. I didn't realize you were a Harry Potter fan. You should have said something earlier when we were talking about Fantastic Beasts. I had to mention one. Why did you hold on to that? Andrew, what is your number three? I guess we haven't technically. We've used aliens, you know, like space-faring creatures in other ones. So, yeah, let's go with aliens. Sure.

Yeah. The queen xenomorph is still one of the most horrifying yet incredibly well-crafted creatures in the history of cinema. Xenomorphs themselves, just the creature design on them, right up there with the predator, you know, it's just one of the most unique and recognizable, you know, alien species. So, yeah, xenomorphs are like the bane of nightmares for so many people. Aaron and I have said this before, we actually like aliens more than alien. Both are amazing in their own right. I'm the same. I'm the same.

Yeah. Again, I love Alien. It took off unlike anything else. But I think Aliens, you know, is where you really get to see Ripley come into her own as the queen of BAs, you know. yeah I love aliens so much it's great I will also say I didn't mention this I eliminated from my selections horror movies I just there's so many strange creatures in horror movies and so like limits on yourself I really did I for whatever reason again it's just such a broad category but yeah aliens is an incredible movie and certainly would have been at least in my honorable mentions all right let's go to our number twos I put up here and I up is it's really that bird that just really Kevin writes and Doug i mean doug is a dog yeah i mean i know he talks but that's a that's a dog but but kevin is the machine that makes him talk yeah right yes exactly that's a strange machine not a strange animal uh but uh i talked about up plenty everybody knows i'm a pixar fan um but man best first 10 minutes of movie history um and yes uh and then it just it continues on from there uh this movie arrivals you at the beginning yeah i turned it on its head everybody you can say that yeah yeah yeah i was gonna say yep

Alice, what is your number two? I see your Pixar and I raise you Ratatouille. Because rats don't cook. So he's a very strange creature. I won't veto it. I won't veto it. I would love it. But Ratatouille, I don't know why. I never say it's my favorite Pixar movie, but I feel like it's the one that lives most in my heart. And I don't know if it's its portrayal of food and cooking or the story at its center or the music. I think it's honestly probably got my favorite music in all of Pixar. But it is something that it's just so...

Like the music's so melodic and beautiful and I just find myself humming it all the time. And the story at its center is something that I always enjoy watching it every single time. I literally watched it a few months ago and I was seriously considering watching it again last night. And then I forced myself to, I mean, forced myself is a strong word, but I forced myself to watch Inside Out because I felt like watching a Pixar movie. But I just needed to watch something different. And I don't know, I just, there's something about it. It just hits me right in my center. And I feel like I'm saying that a lot with these movies, but I guess Strange Creatures, maybe that's my niche, who would have known? But yeah, Ratatouille is great and I love food and I love Pixar, so.

Well, Alice, I will say no more than this. Ratatouille is in a cultural consciousness right now, and you may know why soon. But that's all I'm going to say. So we are on to that look. I love it. That look means I didn't give anything away, and that's great. That's beautiful. All right. We're on to Andrew's number two. Yeah. How about a foreign language film, guys? Okay. How about it? There are strange creatures in those. Pan's Labyrinth. Yeah. My favorite foreign language film of all time. Gosh, I love Guillermo del Toro. Yeah.

I know this is going to sound like a weird comparison, but if I'm comparing this to the Wizarding World of Harry Potter, I think that this movie does so much better job of conveying the wonder and the mysteriousness of magic and stuff. No, I think that as far as like a, you know, a fantastical movie, I think that Guillermo del Toro has really carved out a little spot for himself that is solely and uniquely his. Like you look at Pan's Labyrinth, you look at, or I almost said Lady in the Water, but no, that's the wrong one. You look at Hellboy, you look at just, it was a Crimson Peak even. You know, he has a way of creature design and maybe it's his, his adamance for using practical effects that is kind of like a foregone thing that you don't really see in a cinema anymore. Creatures in this movie can be beautiful. They can be mysterious. They can be terrifying. The skin man who has the eyes on his hands. Oh my God, don't speak to me about him. One of the most horrifying creature designs ever in cinema. I had nightmares after I saw that movie the first time. Oh yeah. Oh yeah. Ophelia, yeah, I think that she's an amazing character and I have to look up his name. It's Sergei Lopez who plays Victor. He's kind of like the...

the captain, you know, of this, uh, it's in Italy, so it's not, uh, it's not German, but a Nazi-esque, you know, very dictatorial, you know. you know, Mussolini, yeah, Mussolini-esque, yeah, type character. And he is an amazing, an amazing villain. And, you know, you have this side story with the rebels and stuff, which can, you know, in any other movie would feel like, you know, it's just a, you know, a chance to bring you back to reality from all this fantasticalness, but it's actually just as captivating. It can be just as captivating as the fantastic world that Ophelia finds herself in. So all around, it is a incredibly well-written, well-directed, well-acted movie. I love it.

I'm not here to yuck anyone's yum, so we will move on to our number ones. Aaron's allowed to be wrong. Don't forget, he thinks that Secrets of Dumbledore is the greatest movie ever made. How could you ever trust any of my opinions? All right, let's talk about our number ones. I'm going with Empire Strikes Back at number one.

Tauntauns. And man, Empire is one of those movies that I don't know how to separate it from my childhood. Like I don't like I don't understand like Star Wars. I think it was almost early enough. Like Star Wars came out when I was like one. So, you know, like I can separate Star Wars out a little bit as something I didn't really experience. But when Empire Empire came out, man, I was just that we recorded off of television and I wore the snot out of that VHS. And it was just, you know, embedded in me, that opening Hoth planet scene. And I just everything about it is in my brain space. It was your Harry Potter.

Yes, and Star Wars absolutely was my Harry Potter. So did the first Harry Potter come out when you were one? No, but I just mean how it defined my childhood. Oh, the book came out when I was two. Well, there you go. There you go. Absolutely. So anyways, many people have talked about Empire Strikes Back enough, so we can continue on. Alice, what is your number one?

I started in the 80s. I'm ending in the 80s. I'm going with Labyrinth because that is another film that defined my childhood that is not a franchise. So much so that my partner is called Toby and he was named after the character in Labyrinth. I think I mentioned that on a podcast. But yeah, the little boy in Labyrinth. You got to name your partner? That's amazing. I know, would you believe? His name's Bill, but I was just like, nope, you're Toby.

You say that, but do you remember Jareth, who we've had on the show a couple times? He was named after David Bowie's character in Labyrinth. And I find it so interesting that his mum was like, no, Jareth is weird, but Toby is a reference that I will know. And so, yeah, so his name is Toby because of the little brother, Toby, in the movie. And so I didn't even, like, when I found that out, I was like, oh my gosh, that's so exciting because I watch Labyrinth so much because my mum is a huge David Bowie fan, as am I, grew up on him. And so Labyrinth was a mainstead in our house. And I've had nightmares of the opening scene where all the goblins are all in one arm.

that as a five-year-old will change you that's just it'll it'll change your brain and then you'll never be the same and you'll end up like me so but it is just such a great This crazy portrayal of Jim Henson's brain, and I love it so, so much. And I'm so glad it's become such a cult success again. Obviously, it wasn't successful when it first came out, and it now has this fandom and this love behind it. And yeah, it's just, again, a great showing of how practical is always better, if you can do it, because it holds up so much more. And David Bowie's such a great Jareth. And so much so, you don't really question that a 37-year-old man is trying to hook up with a 15-year-old Jennifer Connelly. You just let yourself go with it. And then you become an adult, and you're like, that's kind of weird. When you're an adult, you're like, that's kind of weird. But I love the music, and that's the movie.

magical creatures along the way. Nice. Andrew, what is your number one? Well, you guys had your animated movies earlier on. It's time for mine. You chose to go with Pixar. I'm going with Miyazaki. Let's go with Howl's Moving Castle. Nice. Great. Now, people are wondering, like, why didn't you have Star Wars or why didn't you have Lord of the Rings? Those are the limits I put on myself. I'm like, I'm sure that people know my love, you know, Legion for those movies by now. Yeah, those would have been my number one and my number two, so just move everything out. But I felt like I really wanted to give these movies a shout out. I'm breaking the rules of Sith Pop here. Howl's Moving Castle is my favorite Miyazaki film. I think it's the one where, actually, I think that if you were to go and find the actual...

english dubbed one it's a whole new experience because the cast for the english dub is crazy christian bale billy crystal i'm not gonna list everybody but uh it's it's like so well done and i think that it adds you know a level of calmness really it's a weird word to use but i think that christian bale's you know his you know interpretation of how um in the way he's just very calm you know and he's yes mysterious but there's also just a a safeness to him that uh that that a voice can convey over the actions that have already been, you know, established. You know, that's the power of voice acting. You have to be able to convey an emotion you feel over, you know, something that somebody else has already animated. The visuals to this day stand up. It's a Miyazaki movie, so if you're unfamiliar, you're in for a wild, weird ride. You might not understand the first time. But if I'm going to compare this to Fantastic Beasts, you know, I think that this movie does a so much better job of conveying...

You need to stop ripping on the greatest movie of this year. I really do. I really do. I'm not giving it as just a sort of photo. No, I love it. There's our top five. Honorable mentions. I'll throw to you first, Alice. Do you have any? Yes, I do. I know there's so many. There's so many.

500 or so. Like I said, I was just writing them and I was like, oh, I remember I got told off for having 11. So I'll stop here. Just list them. Let's go. Let's go. Eight. I've only got eight. I stopped myself. All right. Never ending story because when I wrote Labyrinth, the never ending story came to mind. Incredibles 2 for the Raccoon. That was also because I was like, I don't know if that quite counts. Along those same lines, I've got Mary Poppins for the Penguins, Paddington 1 and 2, Spider-Man No Way Home. Now, and again, similar, I feel like I've talked about MCU again, but Lizard, I don't know if that's a spoiler or not, but there's a Lizard that is different. Okay, fair enough. Listen, you do you.

I'm not saying Spider-Man's the strange creature. A radioactive spider is a very unique creature. Yeah, that's true, but he's not in this one. Mitchell's versus the machines for the pug, because that is not a normal pug. I don't know. I've known many a pug who are just like that. Okay, well, still strange. And then similar to Big Fish, I've got Bridge to Terabithia, because I feel very similarly to that movie with this movie, and it breaks my heart, and I cry and cry and cry. This is the movie that makes me sob.

Big Fish is to make you be hopeful with wonder. Bridget Herbithia is to make you sob with grief. And then finally- I've never seen this. Free the pee. Free the pee. Free the pee. Not that bit. Oh, okay. And then finally, along the same lines as Godzilla, I've got Colossal. So it's such a great movie. I remember when I saw that. Yeah, it hit me. It really hit me. And I loved it so much. And so if you haven't seen it, Jason Sudeikis and Anne Hathaway are amazing. You need to watch it.

The thing with Colossal is it's so hard to explain to somebody without giving away what it's really about. So people go in with one mindset and then they're not expecting it. So it can be kind of jarring. But at the same time, you don't want to spoil it for somebody because it is such an amazing... It's really one of those, would you just watch this movie kind of movies? Don't make me explain it, just watch it. Just trust me. Andrew, what's your honorable mentions? Well, you guys mentioned all of them except for one and I know that it's a movie that everybody besides me in the world hates and that's Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou.

Nice. I would throw in Men in Black, Shang-Chi and Okja. I knew somebody was going to say Okja. Yeah. That's the first one that came to my head when I read the email. There you go. There you go. All right. Let's move into the buried treasure. What's that one thing in any area of pop culture you want to make sure people know about? Andrew, why don't you kick us off?

If you don't mind, before I get into my buried treasure, I want to do an update to a previous buried treasure. Okay. Yeah, so a couple of weeks ago, or actually it was a little bit ago, I was saying that I was really intrigued by the show Severance. Yes. And they just finished the first season. And oh my goodness, this show is amazing. Yeah, it's a home run. It's a home run. It is so good. Well, this might be my favorite Apple show. I think it might be my favorite Apple show. I would put Ted Lasso in the conversation, but... Oh, never mind. Ted Lasso is my favorite. I also really like Mythic Quest, but... Mythic Quest is a lot of fun. Yeah. Yeah.

But this is such a unique and intriguing show. Good job, Ben Stiller, on coming up with this amazing idea. To Adam Scott and to everybody who's in this, Christopher Walken, John Turturro. I'm so depressed I have to wait a year and a half for season two. I know, I know. But that's actually a really great segue into my actual buried treasure. My actual buried treasure is the final season of Attack on Titan. Everybody thought that this was going to be, like, because they just wrapped up.

just recently. And I was like, wait, that's, you didn't wrap anything up. And then like, yeah, we did a part one of season four. We did a part two season four, you know, like how sometimes they break up a season twice, you know, there's a part three of season four coming out now. And I'm like, at that point, just do another season, you know, because you're going to have to wait a year and a half for the final part three to come out. And.

It sounds like I'm ragging on my buried treasure because of the way that they did it. But honestly, this is going to go down as one of the best shows of all time, not just one of the best animated shows of all time. It will be one of the best shows ever made. It's one of the most unique. The art style is unlike anything ever. The way that they portray eyes in the show is so uniquely its own. The Titans themselves are...

We were talking earlier about, you know, like, the skin man from Pan's Labyrinth being just a horrific design. I never thought I could see that type of fear and, like, uneasiness conveyed in an animated sense. But that's what the Titans are. The Titans are just the skin man. They're so close. It's an uncanny valley-esque bit of, like, they're supposed to look human, but there's something off about them.

And it's just so well done. The story is so well done. There's season in season two. I won't give away the actual episode, but there's an episode in season two that I think is one of the greatest episodes of any show ever made, like top three episodes of any show ever. Nice. And yeah, for those of you out there who are listening, you know how good Attack on Titan is. And for those of you out there who have not seen it, I say watch it, but go in knowing that it's you're not going to binge it because it's a show that makes you uneasy and you don't want to like.

You want to watch the next episode, but you're also like, I need to take a breather. That was heavy. It's a very heavy show. A lot of a lot of animes have like, you know, an episode every now and then. Oh, that was just a funny one. No, not. Yeah, it's an incredibly depressing, but beautifully told story. Looks like Four Seasons on Hulu. If you want to check out Attack on Titan. Alice, what is your buried treasure? Yeah, so I flip flopped a lot on this buried treasure. And then I ultimately. Yeah, you didn't, which is why I was like, oh, please go. No, no, no, Alice, you go last.

I'm glad that I decided to preface it then. Continue. The reason I forgot to do mine is because it feels very basic. But I've been watching Moon Knight and I wanted to let people know that I'm really enjoying it. I didn't know if we were going to do an actual review of the show. That's amazing. I went to you first and then I was like, no, me first. I'm going to talk about Moon Knight. Alice, you're the guest. I watched the third episode. Yeah, I did too. Like an hour before we recorded. Yeah, I watched it yesterday. So Alice, I will let you talk about it. No, no, it's okay. I've got something else I can talk about. You know what? I'll just jump on yours. I have something else I can recommend.

Okay, I really don't have a ton to say other than I'm really enjoying it. It blows my mind that Oscar Isaac and Ethan Hawke are in a Marvel TV show of all things. It's wild to me. They're both great. They're both great in it. You know they're neighbors in real life? That's how Ethan Hawke ended up as the character is because Oscar Isaac was like, I want you to play this character because they're neighbors in real life. Oh, that's fun. That's fun. So yeah, I'm enjoying it. I'm enjoying that so far it seems...

pretty disconnected from, you know, like having to Easter egg all the Marvel stuff. Um, you know, nobody's mentioned the blip yet. Um, so like it, like I like that. I like that. It's just kind of its own thing. I imagine it will play into kind of the, whatever universe that blade is going to be in that they're kind of developing, like the more spiritual kind of, you know, uh, ghosts and, you know, spirits and that kind of thing. Um, supernatural. Yeah. We'll see. It makes sense. Yeah. Well, you know, there's, there's a, there's a God element to moonlight and stuff or moonlight, moon night, you know? So anyways, I'm enjoying it. So, yeah.

I love it. And as a mythology nerd, so I'm a huge, huge, huge mythology nerd. So I know all about ancient Egypt and it is giving me giddy, giddy, nerdy, like happiness watching this. And in the most recent episode, especially I was like, look at all the things. So yeah, no, I'm also really loving it. I think it's so fantastic. It's so different. I wanted to just bring it up as a berry treasure because I feel like if people have Marvel fatigue, they might skip this one because it doesn't feel as important in the grand scheme of things. And I think you shouldn't because it's honestly probably very quickly becoming my favorite of the Marvel TV shows.

Sure. Yeah, it's so good. But we'll see where it goes. All right, Alice. I do have something else. What is your actual lyric treasure? I'm going to recommend a book. And I already vaguely mentioned it to you, Aaron, earlier, but it is Creativity Inc., which is the story written... Oh, it's not the story. It's the book written by... Would you believe I'm reading it? I can't remember his name. I think it's Ed Catmull. He is the founder of Pixar. And it's kind of like part...

memoir, part history, part... Ed Catmull, yeah, I was right. Yeah, it's part history of Pixar, part memoir, and also kind of like part management book, which I did not expect because I have less than no interest in those kind of books. But we're actually reading it for my works book club. And so I was like, yeah, I like Pixar. I'll read it. And it's so insightful to me because he peppers in his theories of business in and around the actual stories of the making of and the creation of Pixar from the very beginning to when Steve Jobs owned it to when they created Toy Story 2. And now they're speaking about the idea of the brain trust and creativity and inside out and that sort of thing. And it is just a really... First of all, it's a really easy read. So if you're not...

of a reader, you can flick through it pretty quickly. But it's also, I haven't read something like this before, and I'm really enjoying it. If you really like Pixar, you're going to like it. If you really like memoirs, you're going to like it. If you really want to learn more about how to be a good manager or a good person who runs an office or a culture of any kind, you would like this book. I really do recommend it. And it was written in 2014, so anything after that is not included in this book. It sounds like the Pixar Moneyball. Yeah, it kind of is. It definitely kind of is. And I actually would love making a Pixar movie. I think that'd be so cool.

There's a documentary called The Pixar Story that you can check out that's pretty good. Is it on Disney Plus? Yeah, I think it's on Disney Plus. But yeah, as far as like a narrative, you know, kind of cast people as the characters, that would be really, really interesting to me. I never watch documentaries made by the people at the documentaries. Yeah, no, that makes sense. I get it. Creativity Inc. is a book. I've heard of those. Moon Knight is on Disney Plus and Attack on Titan is on Hulu. Well, congratulations, guys. We managed to do a podcast. Well done.

Thank you so much for joining us today for Sif Pop. It is part of the Studio DNA Podcast Network. You can find more about other shows on the network at studiodna.media or by searching Studio DNA in your podcast player. You should say, Xander, for coming and hanging out again today. You know that I think the magic of this podcast, if I'm going to make this comparison, you know, to the Fantastic Beasts movie, I think that we really capture what real magic actually is. I agree. I agree. Big thanks to producer Phil for producing the audio and video show. Thanks, Phil. Thank you, Alice, for coming by again to talk movies with us. I almost said real witch, but that just sounds derogatory. It is the correct term.

If only you would care a little bit more about the movies we're reviewing, that would be helpful. Sorry for my complacency. I just couldn't muster the energy today. Feel free to let people know where they can find you. Yeah, so Ali G Mick, A-L-I-G-M-I-C-H on Letterboxd and Instagram. Find me there. Message me why I'm completely right about Secrets of Dumbledore. I don't want to hear how I'm wrong because I'm not. No, I'm joking. Otherwise, I'm also a writer for Siftpop.com and my most recent was the one-stop pop for March, which was the Batman, would you believe? Biggest movie of March. I also wrote the review on Secrets of Dumbledore. So if you want to read what I said today in hopefully a more coherent way, you can find that there too. Nice. Well, we appreciate you being here. It's always fun when you're around. Also really appreciate...

We will be back next week with a couple, I think they're biographies of Andrew. The Northman. And unbearable weight of massive talent. Both sound right there. They're about me. So there you go. Hopefully that's what we'll have next week. And we will see you then. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of SiftPop?

This episode is 1 hour and 32 minutes long.

When was this SiftPop episode published?

This episode was published on April 18, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this SiftPop episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.