Hi and welcome to classical stuff. You should know a podcast about the classical stuff You should know from classical educators who work at a classical. So why are we so good at these intro things listen? We need somewhat we need to hire out someone to do our interest.
I'm worried with I'm like the one you did AJ If we hired it out. That's right over the top. Whatever you want to talk crazy. Let me go back to that I wouldn't pay something for what I did My name is Graham Donaldson, and I am here with my good friends AJ Hanenburg That's me and Thomas Megby and that's me and we all work at a classical Christian school in Austin, Texas called Veritas Academy We don't really have like I guess go defenders.
Go defenders. Is that like, you know, you got go big blue and you've got like Training hearts and minds for the glory of God. I don't know how to sporty. Wait, you don't just mean every time we yell defense That's like our call because we're on offense.
We can call defense, and it's still careful If you have a great classically themed thing that we can yell at at sporting events, please email us at classical stuff at Veritas Classic will cheer. Could you imagine so what would it be? I don't know if we we could have a song that's like half and Latin The fight song for the University of Toronto go blues where I went to school is part in Latin I don't know what it means has to trees. I'm just imagining people hollering classical things at the refs like vine eyes are clouded That's been Latin.
So your judgment is this merge if you have been listening with any degree of faithfulness or at least last week Was your first week you will know that we started talking about the Odyssey and AJ is here to Bring all those pieces back together He's here to kick out all of the suitors that that have been nesting in our podcast room for weeks eating our food drinking our coffee Those aren't suitors those are ants We actually do have a problem. It's okay. We're moving campuses in a while And also AJ this explains why all of those axes are lined up against the wall and while you're holding a bone arrow Oh, is that an Odyssey thing? I don't have any axes.
I do have a giant hammer. You do have a giant hammer. It's threatening. Where do they go?
It's over there. All right, AJ. Obviously us classic kazas. Okay, we'll do first.
I I thought that we've never really talked about like we talked about classicism a lot But we've never really talked about how we're Christian like that wasn't really a warning that we gave when we started this podcast So I wanted to take a second and say yes, we all have a worldview. We're all coming from a specific place We all go to church we you know I would say that we probably land pretty much near Orthodoxy on a lot of things not even near we are nestled deep inside Orthodoxy, right? Yeah, I like Chesterton's book So it but but we don't do that assuming you know We're not trying to exclude people who don't believe the same thing if you are not a Christian if you don't believe the same things We do that's fine. You're still welcome to listen to the podcast.
We'll try to make it friendly to folks who don't have the same world view We would love to hear your take on things I just I don't know I thought I'd say something about it Sort of come out and sort of out us as Christians because we all are and so we'll be speaking from that perspective And if you like that, that's fine Well, we love to have you continue to listen and hear your view on things whenever you feel like writing in I was just listening and I realized that we just sort of have it as an assumption and never make it overt So I thought we just make put it out there Yeah, okay We are talking about the Odyssey for the second time which means a quick review might be in order if you listened last time This this will be review if you didn't then this might be a little bit new The Odyssey is the story of Odysseus a champion from the Trojan War who is returning home after the completion of the war He's the guy that invented the Trojan horse. He is a commander He's a king in his own right in his little island called Ithaca He did not want to go to war because he had a young son that had just been born he was usually well Why they're young because they're they were just you can have a young son who was not just born I could have an eight-year-old that's still pretty young. Okay, so he had a newborn child And he'd tried to get out of it by acting crazy and they caught him and made him go to war anyway And this is a story where he dressed up like a dress up like a lady That's a killing. Oh, I love that story Odysseus pretended to be an insane person and started sewing salt on his own fields He tried to pretend that he was insane and then they took his new baby boy Telemachus set it in front of the plow so either he could continue the ruse of insanity and kill his kid or go to war Yeah, so they caught him really I feel like crazy to see is probably could have even figured out a way to save telemachus and continue to be crazy like look at this strange Carrot and then pick up the baby Well, he didn't So he goes to war and the Odyssey is the story of his return from war It takes him 10 years on the return trip most everyone on the return trip either dies quickly or returns home in short order safely so he's been gone there are a number of suitors vying for his wife's hand at home and they are eating all of his wealth and Drinking all of his wealth and treating his kid staff and wife without respect just being general hoodlums It's like having a bunch of frat boys living in your house for the entirety stop by so much They don't go home.
Yeah, that's exactly what it's like. It's a frat party in your house every day eating all your stuff The suitors not actually there for Penelope like were they there there were 114 of them a lot There is no way that all of them thought they had a chance with Penny Yeah, and not only that but at the council where telemachus tells them to go home They say we're gonna continue to eat all of your goods until penny makes a decision So they know what they're doing they know and they are actually called to the carpet by some other people in town who say yes It's shameful you are breaking the gods laws. You shouldn't do this and they pretty much say who's gonna stop us Well, there's a bunch out. We're all powerful.
You're an old man You're a young kid no one's gonna challenge us until your mom makes a decision because it's also like a penalty Had to keep them there because that's a part of the hospitality law, right? But they were abusing it is that they were they were abusing her hospitality And she actually kind of said you know you guys have to figure things out until I make it said told him to get out of his house They just say no Homer makes it very clear that they are in the wrong So this is we find out that it's kind of implied that he's reluctant to go home because he doesn't know the situation He doesn't know if his kid is still there or is willing to accept him his father He doesn't know if Penelope has remarried he actually told her to remarry when there was a beard on his face He doesn't know if that's happened yet. He's not sure if he has a place He could be facing all kinds of crazy things at home So he kind of dilly dally's and looks for adventure and looks for glory he ends up visiting the underworld Talks to some of his heroes that say glory's not worth it What matters is the home your son your wife being alive and so his attitude changes and he starts heading home eventually comes home Kills the suitors retakes his home And it's the sort of the the story of coming of age of two men at once We have the coming of age of telemicus and the coming of age of Odysseus at the same time And the imagery given is a union of his two sides his wild side and his domestic side So that's kind of the story of the Odyssey in review that the olive bush that we talked about Yeah, that's the olive bush image that we we encountered in book five of the Odyssey And then it kind of returns later in the form of his big olive bush bed, which is kind of a cool bed Yeah, right. Okay.
Did you ever reconcile your two sides growing up my wild side and your demand your domestic inside? You I guess my question is that like a thing that all men must do I think it's a refined balance when I was a kid and everyone else was jumping off clips I would be the cliffs. I was the one that said I don't think the ratio here is a good one I'm not willing to risk my bodily well-being for a moment to find I was a stick in the mud Yeah, and so I think I think there's a balance to be had between risk and glory and yeah I'm kind of a stick in the mud too, but I Think this is a what's that you all also read our mainlyness something all of come across before It's okay. I know I know the website and they've done some writing on how like the idea that we tend to point you for masculinity is like the gentlemen But like that's only a certain Society that likes the gentleman.
There is a there's a society that prefers the roughing on so like even today You could say what is the model of masculinity is it someone who's really good at fighting people or is it someone who is in public life? So I don't know you know It's not like the cowboy and the samurai and that kind of like person who is the law in a lawless place Anyway, right here if you're Nietzsche you like the outlaw He said the model of the true free man was the criminal Yeah, that makes his own law and that has the power to actually like act out that law. Yeah, and for clarification We think that I don't think that's very that's kind of bad. Oh, yeah He's a do I do not agree with Nietzsche very often That's the nice part about this olive tree that it has both that there is a wild side But then there's a refinement to it also Nietzsche's mustache is like his one redeeming.
Yeah, one Oh, yeah, that thing's for sweet I feel like it makes him kind of like one of those brain whales or where he has you know the teeth That's a broom I feel like if he just sort of shoves food through his mustache and then like and suck the food off of it later Yeah, I just imagine him only eating soup where he pours it through his stash and then saves a little room in facial hair for me So that's great. Yeah, and I probably discussed that I Alright, so today what I wanted to talk about was a couple of things relating to the Odyssey sort of vaguely one is the heroes journey And this is it was a theory put forward in Joseph Campbell's book the hero with a thousand faces And he talks about something called the monomyth or the heroes journey and he's a mythologist He has all these different stories and he started to recognize different elements that popped up again and again and again and again in stories And then kind of put them all together and describe them in an incredibly dry and boring book. Oh, man It is I read it's so painful. It is just the worst It does so this is another thing But I really want to do a podcast on writing well because there's a lot of ways I was never taught to write well in high school or even college and like the actual pure craft of writing I don't I mean I can't it's one of those things where maybe I was and I didn't receive it like when I was in 10th grade Maybe I had this brilliant teacher that tried to do it and I was like Derpy derpy derpy derpy and he's just never what happened.
No, I was never taught it I never even buttered up against the teaching of true style and my question is I'm not even sure if it's classical the writing manual So I'm coming from one is really fairly recent and one is from the 60s, but I feel like that'd be beneficial for everybody right? Can we can we nudge it? Yeah, man yeah? We probably could although that writing manual like definitely telegraphs that is from the 60s from strong and white no strong and white I think that's like pre World War one.
Okay. Yeah, but the one from the 60s is it's clearly written to kids who are like sticking it to the man And ride motorcycles and say things like far out. Yeah Yeah, it's written to, if I understand correctly, I think it's a Stanford professor writing to 1960s. He's realizing that all his students in the 60s are these counter-cultural, like, protests in the war.
And he's like, so I hear you guys want to protest the war, but have you protested the war with proper writing? I can't. So, yeah. So it's not strictly classical, but I could probably find some classical resources.
I don't know, it's really interesting. Anyway, we're talking about rhetoric for the trivia and stuff before, so that makes sense. My main beef with Joseph Campbell is that he's really bad at writing concretely and putting people in his senses. There are no people in his book, it's all these ethereal ideas and it's just painful to read.
But like, should it work of philosophy? I mean, his is like literary criticism, but like, should that have characters in it? No, I don't mean characters. I mean, making people do stuff, talking about people.
So I could, a great example of this, and we are a little off track here, but don't worry, let's not get this back soon. One of the podcasts is to be off track, right? But one of our students was trying to write in her thesis about the concept that doctors evaluating each other would be better because they're not always the ones being evaluated. So she put it ethereal, right?
She said, the doctor will spend more time evaluating his compatriots than being evaluated himself. It was this big, long thing. When she could have put it in concrete terms, she could have said he's gonna spend more time on the judges bench than in the context doc, right? Which is an easier way to understand it.
It's shorter. It doesn't deal only with ethereal ideas. And we get the point, right? And the point is that there's a person in there.
I'm talking about a doctor, right? As opposed to someone in the medical profession, or I don't know, I'm just putting people in my sentences. It's a better way to identify with that more readily. The human mind works with concreteness and specifics and people rather than these big ethereal ideas.
And if I do this podcast on writing, I'll give you far more examples from Strunk and White and from some other writing manuals. Anyway, back to it. So he writes this really painful book called The Hero with a Thousand Faces. And he puts forward his theory of the monomyth.
And so I'm gonna walk through a little bit of it because it's often related to the Odyssey. And in fact, it's more closely related to Star Wars, which I know you guys know. And so I'll have you guys try to identify some of the spots where Star Wars and the Matrix come in because he actually built Star Wars on the hero's journey in monomyth. So it's not just a coincidence.
He crafted his tale based on the monomyth. All right, so before we talk about this, this was just a thing that he saw in works of literature. Common features in myth. All right, so there's kind of three primary divisions of the hero's journey, right?
It's kind of this big cycle. The first part is departure, second part initiation, third part return. And each one of those is divided into small phases. So at the very beginning of the hero's journey, there's the call to adventure.
And the call to adventure is when something outside of his world kind of breaks into his world and asks him to go out and do something, right? It's an in-breaking into normal life. What would this be for Luke? Help me Obi-Wan.
You're my only hope. He gets a message from R2D2. So yeah, it's where I'm pretty sure it was Lee. Or to bring the message.
Out of R2. Yeah, yeah, yeah. The message is from Leo. Yeah, from Leo.
That was really good. Thanks, please. Yeah, that was really good. So the call comes.
And then the hero will typically refuse the call. That's the next phase. So call to adventure, refusal of the call. So what is this for Luke?
I can't do this. We got the harvest coming. My cows, my moisteries. That's exactly right.
He says we have the harvest coming. I can't. There's another. Uncle Obi needs my health in harvesting the moisture.
He sure does. What about in the Matrix? What's the call to adventure in the Matrix? I have a job.
No, the call to his father. He's followed by rabbit. All over the white rabbit, right? And it's an in-breaking into his normal world.
It's not something that happens normally. He has to go follow. Yeah, exactly. What's the refusal of the call?
He won't climb out the window. He doesn't call it. The pills come later? The pills come later.
The pills come later. The pills come later. We're not even quite there yet. And then the next part is supernatural aid.
So some sort of magical helper. Campbell says this is often an old man or a crone or somebody that is experienced that can give a token that will help him in his journey. Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan.
Who gives him the lightsaber? Wow. Who gives him the lightsaber? Wow.
What about in the Matrix? It's got to be Morpheus. Not there yet. Old man.
Oh, is it the lady with the spoon? There's no spoon. That's later. I'm watching.
When Trinity extracts the bug. Oh, my gosh. They're tracking me. Yeah, they're tracking me.
So they pull out this little creature and there's your supernatural aid. From the belly button. From the belly button. He clearly remembers Matrix much better.
Okay. So he's had the call. He refuses the call. He meets someone that gives him aid.
Right. And then he crosses the threshold into the actual adventure. The real story. Yeah.
He moves from home from regular life into actual crazy life. So what is this? He literally gets killed. Right.
He has to go. He enters into the cantina. He enters into the cantina. The cantina is the move from everything.
He knows. He goes down the rabbit hole and he gets the pills. Right. He goes into the matrix or out of the matrix for the very first time and realizes that everything is illusion and oh my gosh.
I have to eat gruel for the rest of you. You might have like a burlap sack. And your head is shaved and you're actually, you are actually emaciated. And your battery.
And your battery. It's like a USB. USB 3. It's a larger jack.
USB C is smaller. Eventually they realize that the large reports are way to go. Much more information. What's that?
Good. Yeah. I don't understand why it's not wireless. It's a future future.
Why can't we jack in with just like Wi-Fi. The connection's not good. Oh, it's probably because the robots can hack it. You're really thinking through this.
Like muddle your connection with memes. So you show up and you're listening to Yodeling Kid instead of someone who knows Karate. How many times did you see the Matrix when it was in theaters? Like were you super excited when it was in theaters?
I think once in theaters and then many times after that. It is a great film. And I've never watched the third one. Never watched the last one.
I think I've watched half the second one I've ever watched the same thing. The point at which they lost me in the Matrix series is when they were doing, remember that maybe this was in the third one so you might not have seen it, but they're on the roadway and they're all fighting and cars are exploding. The second one. And they're fighting the white dreaded twins?
Yeah, the white dreaded twins. So at one point you see a car flip over and slide past the camera. And I don't know what happened, but the visual effects people are just lazy because you can see the dude in the car is clearly wearing a helmet and braces all over. And as far as I know people on their commute don't typically wear motorcycles inside their car.
It's not like guys at least try it. Like at least give it a little effort. Okay, so I crossed the first threshold and then they move into the belly of the whale. And this is the final separation of the hero's known world and self.
And so the hero shows a willingness to undergo metamorphosis, willing to kind of undergo change. And it's kind of like being fully in and ready to go. Okay. And it's actually the trash compactor.
Right, right in the middle of the desk door. But the trash compactor doesn't seem to have a big transformation for Luke. Like specifically the trash compactor for Luke. Yeah, it doesn't.
And I don't know. I'm thinking that if we're looking at Luke's story on a longer timeline that the belly of the whale would actually be when he is dealing with Yoda and he goes into three movies and he confronts himself because this is actually what it's described as. The hero confronting himself, he may appear to have died. It's like there's actual real danger here.
There's real risk. He's going to change that sort of thing. Luke's journey is all three of those movies. The initial movie I think has its own small hero's journey arc, but all three movies have the same kind of thing.
It's rings within rings within rings. So, okay, another crazy Star Wars idea is that it's the ring theory. It's a chiasm. Have you ever heard of a chiasm?
I've heard of the optic chiasm, but I feel like we're talking about something else. So a chiasm is a method of writing what Hebrews used to do. And it's essentially if you can imagine kind of a big X or the beginning. It's what chiasm means.
Yeah, yeah. The beginning chapter and the final chapter will be mirrors of each other, right, an introduction and a conclusion. Right. And then they will sort of ramp up in importance also with mirroring.
So it'll be like a greeting to people. So, introduction, greeting, and then at the very end you'll have sort of a farewell and then a conclusion, right? So, every part sort of parallels each other in this X with a center ramping up to a final center core and then everything out. And everything flows out of that.
And the notion is that I think it's the- So, there's a crazy person on the internet who has written a long blog treatise. It's not me saying that the prequels and then so movie one through six is this like big elaborate chiasm where the first movie, the Phantom Menace mirrors return of the Jedi. Almost like frame. He's convinced it's like frame for frame.
And you know what? It's really convincing. If you can look at it and almost shot for shot, things are arranged the same way, things are like staged the same way. And then a new hope mirrors revenge of the Sith or the last one was called and then Empire mirrors Clone Wars or whatever the movie was.
Yeah. I'm not necessarily saying it's good. Okay, good. But, yes.
But anyway, so go read it. I can't remember what's called. If you just Google Star Wars ring theory, you'll find it. I still can't get over the fact that when I was like 18 or whenever Phantom Menace came out, I was so excited and I sat there and I was like, I'm watching a movie about a trade dispute and I was kind of fascinating.
But then the double stated like double bladed lights that were made me happy as a kid. So, or I guess the team flips around and it's kind of great. Okay. Yeah, so we need to move on.
We got a lot of stuff to cover here. So we are past the departure. He's finally into the adventure and then we have part two initiation and so the first part is the road of trials, right? It's a series of tests that they have to undergo.
For Neo, this is sparring with Morpheus and learning karate kung fu. Isn't that a form of karate? No. I know kung fu.
That's the line. Well, this is for a loop. If it's learning kung fu for Neo. It's got to be flying around the X-Wing and blowing up the star.
Learning. We're talking about new hope. We're talking about all three of them. I was thinking just new hope.
Then it's when he's practicing with the blaster shield. Yeah. With my blast shield down, how am I supposed to fight? It's a winding thing.
It's like pewing. It's like this is absolutely shoulder. Ow. Yeah.
All right. So the road of trials gives my favorite line to all the favorite Star Wars movies about hokey religions and laser swords don't beat a blaster on your head or whatever it is. Man, I haven't seen it for so long. I gotta go watch it.
All right. So there's the road of trials. There's the meeting with the goddess. This is where the hero gains items that will help him in the future or talks to some powerful goddess that maybe gives him some sort of moon that will help him for the matrix.
This is the oracle, right? He meets with the goddess, gets some information that's going to be really useful. For Luke, it's probably meeting with Princess Leia, which is a little bit weird. Yeah.
Here's why he doesn't look confident, I guess. Which is so weird. But you're not going to go through classical literature too long until you come across like Eppice. Yeah.
So it's just pretty bad. Yep. Okay. And then we have the temptation away from the true path or woman as temptress.
For Luke, this will probably be temptation by the dark side. For the matrix, this is probably temptation to remain in the matrix, right? You can stay. You can refuse the knowledge that you have.
We will give you time to. And isn't there like a character? You remember him? He's eaten that steak.
Can you talk about half of it? Yeah, yeah, yeah. The biggest delicious and it's better just in the world. And then we move to Atonement with the Father.
I bet you can guess what this is with Luke. Literally finding out that Vader is his father. Yeah. I'm also talking about that.
Well, if we're talking about the long story arc, there really isn't Atonement with the Father. He stands and they actually have an Atonement. And then we move to Apotheosis, which is the point of realization in which a greater understanding is achieved. He learns something big.
Armed with this new knowledge, he is ready for the more difficult part of the adventure or the final push. For Luke, this is probably just Atonement with his dad, defeating everybody else, taking control as like the new poster child for the rebellion. For Neo, this is probably understanding everything. He's become the one.
He knows he's the one. He knows that he can beat the Smith brothers, the many Smiths. Don't they have the many Smiths at the end of the first movie where they're all flooding him? No, I think that's later when Mr.
Smith starts taking over everybody. All right, so that's the initiation. And then we have the return. Sorry, next is the ultimate boon.
And this is like the big moment, the big push. He has come to the full understanding. He knows he's the one. He knows that it's his responsibility.
He's got the thing from the goddess. He's got everything. He finally does the big thing or destroys the Death Star or destroys the Empire, right? Is it Matrix?
Is it when he like figures out that he can like stop time or whatever it is? Yeah, and then he flies. That's the worst part of the first movie when he like flies off like Superman and then I mean the original machine starts playing, which is a nice way to go up for it. Yeah, wake up.
It's really good. The flying is lame. But humanity's salvation is within reach, right? He knows he can defeat them easily and reorder the Matrix as well.
And then we have the return. Right? This is the movement back to normal life. So we've moved away from normal life.
We've spent time in the crazy. We're heading back from the crazy. So sometimes there's a refusal of the return. They don't want to come back.
Right? They have a new life. Returning to normal life seems drab or lame. They don't necessarily want to do it.
But they kind of have to. So, so that's one possibility. These don't necessarily come all in order. There's also the magic flight for Luke to speak to him, like Falcon swooping in.
If I'm thinking Lord of the Rings, can you imagine what's the magic flight? It's wrong. The Eagles? The Eagles.
Right? They help him return from Mordor where he is. And we actually have Frodo saying he doesn't want to come back, right? He'd rather say he's been in this new world.
He's experienced the ring. He's no longer a normal Hobbit that doesn't like adventure. He's just not. He's changed.
Yeah, he's changed. They don't necessarily have a flight, place to fit. Sometimes this means rescue from without someone else helping them, which is another. Han Solo.
Han Solo, I mean Falcon. Let's blow this thing and go home. Then they become master of the two worlds, which is like the victory ceremony. They are now in possession of their two halves, right?
Their heroness, their homeness, they are, they have everything within themselves. They are a master. And that gives them freedom to live. They no longer for your death.
They no longer for your returning home. They are. They have grown, I guess, into what they will eventually be. And that's it.
The freedom to live is the final bit of the return. So, you know, leaving initiation and return, these are the three parts of the hero's journey. The trouble is that they don't necessarily correspond with one of the greatestness of all time. The Odyssey.
What would be the call to adventure for Odysseus? It would be off-screen, right? Or off-script. It would be way at the beginning of his tale.
Calling being called to go to Troy. We have the refusal of the call, which is setting his son in front of the plow. Supernatural aid? The gods are always there.
Athena? Right, helps him out quite a bit. Crossing the first threshold, this would be when they were going to go to war. The belly of the whale.
He's probably on the beach at Troy, and he actually, in fact, goes inside the treasure horse. The road of trials? On my home. On my home, probably meeting with the goddess?
There's lots of them. And he meets with lots of them. Temptation away from the true path. Oh, yeah.
Cersei, Calypso. Cersei especially. Calypso was less of a temptation. Oh, but she's so tragic.
I feel for Calypso. So sweet. I told him that with the father? His dad is lying in like a flea blanket.
Apotheosis. Becoming the god-liker, mastering everything, realizing that he has come together. He's got a couple. He's got the one under all the bush and he comes out glistening and everyone's like, dang.
And he also has the big reveal when he takes off his robe, and he's like, I'm not an old crazy person, I'm here to kill you. I think meeting with the goddess would actually also be when he talks to his mom in the underworld or when he talks to Tiresias in the underworld. Right? He gets that thing that will help him return, which is knowledge about what's going on at home.
The ultimate boon is when he kills all the dudes, takes control of his house, refuses all of the return. Nope. I mean, maybe it's ubiquitous. It's everywhere.
He kind of refuses all along the way. Is there like an old legend that Odysseus does do another journey? Yes, later. He has one more journey after him.
I don't know exactly what the journey is. I'd have to study it. So maybe that is what you're saying. That's kind of the weird thing.
Like, you have to read things outside of the alien in the Odyssey to get the whole story. Yeah. Right. So I guess that makes sense.
Rescue from without. Maybe when Athena comes and helps him. I mean, maybe his son in the final battle. It's kind of weird.
He has a son. Save him in the battle. Not really. Helps him.
Yeah. Crossing the return threshold where this is when he finally comes home and he, she actually, you know, disguises him. Master of the two worlds. It's where he's, you know, he's to have to become one.
Freedom to live is afterwards. So I guess, I guess there's little pieces, but they don't necessarily line up completely. And it doesn't all happen in the Odyssey. And here's my problem with the hero's journey.
Right? Does it appear often in Miss? Absolutely. Mm-hmm.
Especially when the thing is designed to be like Star Wars, right? And in fact, they teach in a lot of writing classes as an easy way to do it. It's just an easy archetype. But really, I don't think that it's, there's some deep monometh in humanity.
I think it's honestly just recognizing elements of good storytelling. There cannot be a story unless the guy gets a call to adventure. There's no story if it's just talking about him going to the store at home. That's not something people want to hear or read, right?
The refusal of the call. Well, what normal person wants to go and face Mortal Peril? Nobody. That's what, I'm just wondering if this is all really similar to the, it's like the five stages and your exposition, your writing actions.
Oh, you're saying like, angered? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
And I mean, crossing the first threshold. Well, at some point you have to actually get into the adventure. Supernatural aid. Well, if you don't have someone helping you, you don't really know where to go.
You're just going to wander around in the forest for a while. Yeah. For Frodo, this is the wizard. What's in Gandalf?
Right? If he didn't have Gandalf, what's he going to do? Just go north? He doesn't know where anything is.
He's a hobbit, right? So you need someone to tell you where to go. Then the road of trials. Well, it's not an interesting story unless there's something to do.
Meeting with the goddess, that's just cool. And Joseph Campbell actually points out that they're not in every story, right? They don't always appear. And I think what he's doing is just recognizing cool stories and like going to the, he talks about the belly of the world, right?
Going to the world navel or the most, the place where all the knowledge is kept in meeting with the great God. And I think this is really just authors going like, what's the coolest place you can go? Hell or to talk to God or the gods? And when you're writing an epic about an epic king, you're going to send him to the coolest place you can.
You're not going to be like, he went to Canada. So, but I mean, as human beings, we like to categorize things and categorizing things is helpful. Like being able to put things into categories carries a lot of mental freight for us. It really helps us understand something.
Sure. You make it a complete, like when you make it the thing itself and you eliminate the possibility for understanding everything outside of a category, you can be compound by your category. And then you can kind of, you know, the world is not in categories. We've put, we've invented categories to help us understand the world.
And then as soon as we say the category is the only thing and then we have something that falls outside of it, we don't, you know, it's just we don't really know what to do with it. Yeah. No, this is sort of, we haven't done a good podcast on Aristotle, but Aristotle is interesting in this because he categorizes everything and he was sort of a very systematic person. But it doesn't explain everything.
It's the central tension of systematic theology in you want to create a theology that explains everything, but you can't explain God with a systematic theology, but you can do what you can get really close to it. But if you think that your system can contain everything, it's hubris. I don't know. I find it a fascinating thought because we are in a world where we say we can gather data, data, data, data.
If we can get all the data we can get with all of the computing power we can get, we can predict or understand things better and create these models that can explain everything and this rush to explaining everything. And yes, we can explain a lot of things or predict a lot of things, but you can't, but not everything. So that's what the hero's story archetypes are. My point is you can do this with almost anything, right?
If I was recognizing elements of a class, I would say there's the crossing of the first threshold, they're walking through my door. There's the meeting with the mentor, the teacher, there's the road of trials and the meeting with the unknown. Well, they're going to meet stuff they don't know yet. Then comes persistence and mastery, and then the freedom and the new knowledge and eventually the exit.
Where's the navel of the classroom? Good question. The Beowulf test? Yeah, maybe it's probably the Odyssey test.
That's the toughest one. I think Joseph Campbell, I don't think he's doing anything revolutionary and I don't think you as a listener have to read his book to understand myth. I think he's just putting together all of these elements of storytelling that are there. Can you use it to be a model for good storytelling?
Yes, sure. Absolutely. And we have Star Wars. Yeah, we've seen it work, but do you need this to understand myth?
I don't think so. Do you need this to be a good storyteller? I think it's more important to have a good understanding of humanity than it is to understand the monomyth, right? I mean, this is taught in college classes, it's taught in writing classes, but from what I can tell, all it is is a recognition of what good storytelling is.
Can I do a dream with him then? Oh, we have, I think we've got a plane flying over here. You can hear that as an audience. It's not like a missile.
Does it make it a bad thing? Like to say this is how good stories have been told in the past. Like, no. Is it fine just to say that?
No, I think that's totally fine. But I think it would be wrong to tie more meaning to this than it deserves, right? To say that this is the only way to tell a good story. Yeah.
Or that this is saying something completely revolutionary about how our myths are made and how they talk to the human person. Right? It's just storytelling. Right?
People telling good and non-boring stories. Yeah. So what part of the hero's journey is where in the next movie you bring everybody back to the same place they were before and all the character progression that happened doesn't happen in Han Solo's Smuggler again, not married. Yeah, people movies.
But the hero's journey is a circle, isn't it? Yeah. Or a pet of nature to it too. Oh, nice.
We could be called to adventure again. A new adventure. I know. Just the newest movie starts when we bump me out.
Okay. Sorry. Moving on from the hero's journey. We got one more thing to talk about today.
Bowls. That's okay. Golden bowls. And I know that's weird.
For only $9.99. You two can have a classical stuff you should know. Golden bowls. We're expanding our sales.
Are you serial in the morning? Really? Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.
Oh man. It was a speech. So it's a memory. And the whole analogy stretched way too long.
The professors filled that golden bowl. We are brains. Are the golden bowl. And we have a choice to drink or not to drink.
Wow, from the golden goblet. It was real painful. Sorry if you're listening. I was not a fan.
Our commencement address. So if you've ever seen the movie Good Will Hunting, filmed at the University of Toronto. Oh. And there's the one guy who is, so Will Hunting comes in and he's all like swagger math.
And he comes in and he takes over sort of the attention of this older professor who's played by that Danish guy. And the professor has had this other kid who's like his TA or whatever who hates Matt Damon and because he works really hard and he's not a genius. Anyway, that actor actually is a real mathematician who's brilliant. And he spoke at my commitment.
The kid? The other kid? The other kid who played the guy who was upset that Will Hunting came in and took his professor. He is actually a really successful mathematician and he spoke at the commencement address and I didn't understand anything.
Let me relate our journey through college to an equation. Yeah. He may have talked about the Matrix but not the movie. We are X and our hearts are when X is placed over negative one.
And I was just like, what is he talking about? Okay. So the Golden Bull theory as it relates to the Odyssey is that Odysseus goes all over the place. Right?
He is at the island of Cersei. He's at the island of Calypso. And if you look at a map of where he traveled in Greece, it's totally insanity. At one point he's almost home.
Then he goes back to the island of the God of the Wind, Aolus. And then he's in the underworld. He's all over the place. And it's really hard to sort of put together a mental picture of what his journey was or looked like.
And he's nearby in Egypt. It was a common trope to have a bowl or a plate with engravings around the edge. Right? And this isn't only in Egypt.
Right? We see kind of the same thing happen with the Hebrews and the same thing happen with the Gilgamesh folk. What are they called? The Sumerians.
Yeah. So the Sumerian culture, same kind of thing. And it's a pretty common depiction of what we would call a cosmic journey where a hero leaves the center of the bowl, travels around a series of trials depicted in small carvings around the edge of the bowl, and then sort of reenters normal life after having completed the circuit. And the circuit follows the path of the sun.
So the way they understood the sun to work in ancient cosmology is that in the mornings it would sort of like jump out of the ocean and then kind of make its circuit across the sky in its sphere and then go back into the ocean at the end of the night and then travel under the earth as it was kind of a big flat disk or through Tartarus or whatever. And then, you know, just to jump out of the ocean again at a later time. And in Egypt, this is often depicted as relating to goddesses, the goddess of the sky or the goddess of the sky and the goddess of night. And so the sun would sort of follow these two things and be in their realms and they were sort of a rebirth imagery happening when the sun is rebirth in the morning.
And then, so there's two kind of cosmic junctures, one in the east and one in the west, where sky and underworld meet, right? They are so close at these cosmic junctures where the sun comes out of the ocean and goes back into the ocean. So if we think of Odysseus' journey less as a random journey all over Greece and more like following the path of the sun, it might make a little more sense, right? Because if I'm going to remind you of a little bit of Greek cosmology here, but they understood all of the disk of the earth, a big flat disk, to be surrounded by something called the Ocean River, right?
It was just this big river that went around the whole thing and past that became the kind of the area of night or twilight, because you were actually outside where the sun reached, right? The sun made this big circuit and if you went past where the sun came out of the water, well, you were in twilight. And that's actually what happens to Odysseus when he visits the land of the dead. It's easy to miss when you're reading the Odyssey because it just says we sail past the Ocean River and then we got to the land of the people of the night.
It's a huge deal, right? It's enormous. He just passed out of the known universe, into the unknown universe, to talk to the folks of the dead, past where the sun rises and then eventually he comes back in. And the island he meets prior to that episode is the island of Cersei, who is the daughter of the sun.
And it says that her house is where the sun rises in the east. And so if we think of her kind of like a goddess at the cosmic juncture, like the, there's Isis and Nefthis that are the two sisters who protect the dead in, I think, Egyptian mythology. Yeah. So if we think of Calypso on one side, the west, because she's the daughter of Atlas who stood in the west according to Hesiod, I think.
And then Cersei, who lives in the east, we can think of Odysseus as a journey like following the path of the sun. The first half is, we find him often in caves, often threatened with oblivion. We have the lotus ears, right? We have the cyclops happens in the cave and so he's following the path of night.
And then he hits the cosmic juncture, the east at Cersei's house, where the sun rises. He goes, bloop out of the world, talks to some folks of the dead, goes bloop back into the world, and then continues on the path of the sun, past the sirens, Skila and Cribdus, and then he actually hits the island of the sun, the right, and eats the cattle of the sun, continues on to Calypso's island, which is the last juncture before he can re-enter normal everyday life, right? And as he re-enters normal everyday life, he actually loses everything. So he cannot, he cannot return to this cosmic journey.
So an easy way to understand Odysse's journey is to think of it less like, like I said, like a random traveling around everywhere, but more like a circuit of the known cosmos. He hits, he follows the path of the sun, traveling around the known universe, even visiting the realm of the gods, exiting where the sun shines. He sort of goes on this big cosmic tour, right? It's an easy way to think of this, right?
It's kind of like what Dante did, right? Dante went through the known universe as the medieval's understood it. Well, Odysseus may have done the same thing, so I present this idea to my freshman, and they usually reject it, right? Because.
Because it's feeling a stretch. The journey of the sun is a very small portion of the order. Freshman hate order. No.
So any other reject that here was journey too. Yeah, probably. Well, it's the last half of the journey's really short, and that he hangs out with the cyclops, but it's not like he's dark all the time, right? He goes into a cave.
It doesn't, it doesn't, it's not really. It's not really. It's not really overt that Cersei is where the sun rises. It's especially not overt that Calypso is in the west.
I mean, it seems like we're trying to pull together some pretty sketchy pieces here. And the Ocean River, usually for the Egyptians, it was Ouroboros, the snake that eats its tail representing eternity that goes around the edge of the bowl. So I don't know, it seems it feels like a stretch, right? And it feels kind of to me like a stretch, but it would have been a common trope for the Greeks.
Like this, that depicted these heroes' journeys, or at least they would have seen them with the nearby Egyptians because they're kind of all over the place. I just think that maybe it's an easier way for you as a reader to think of the Odyssey, right? He visits gods, he visits goddesses, he goes out of the realm of the sun. That much is true.
That actually does happen. So it's an easy way to sort of think of him making a circuit of the cosmos and getting into tours of those places that the Greeks would not have been able to tour. But would you say that Golden Bowl would explain the Odyssey well, but maybe wouldn't explain other epic myths as well, but the heroes' journey applies to more stories than the Golden Bowl theory would? I just, I wanted, there's no sense to putting them both together other than they both relate to the Odyssey.
I'm asking if you think Golden Bowl is better for the Odyssey than the heroes' journey. Because what you said is that there are parts of the heroes' journey that are missing in the myth. Or at least that they don't, it doesn't feel like they are orderly. I think that they both are aides to understanding what is happening in the Odyssey, but I think perhaps the best way to approach it is just to read it like a story, right?
Think of him as a person going through a trial and try to take lessons from it if you can. Maybe they're just, yeah, aides to understanding. And it actually does, we see the same heroes' journey or the cosmic bold journey happen with Gilgamesh a little bit too. Remember he goes through one of the cosmic jumps he travels under the mountains through the darkness and then ends sort of in the realm of light and the gods.
And I think the mountain he traveled through was legended to have its roots like in the bottom of the earth and its roof in the sky. So he kind of does this same kind of bold journey and then returns. I bet you've seen more of that since you teach ancient literature, right? Because by sophomore year, I don't know, the Golden Bowl, something like that.
Frankenstein isn't really hitting all the cosmic spots. I mean, it's just, we just do less epics in 10th grade and we're in novels or, I mean, we do, we do Paradise Lost. But I've never sat down and sort of thought, because we don't read all of Paradise Lost in 10th grade, we just read books one through four and then nine through 12. So I've never really gone through and thought about like the structure of Paradise Lost as a whole.
But I'm sure, I mean, Milton was brilliant. So I'm sure there's something, I'm sure like, you don't write an epic without being completely like drenched in the structure of old epics, right? Yeah. Anyway, I hope this will help you to understand the Odyssey and kind of approach it with a new with a little bit more knowledge.
We have a last sort of final question. If you were going to write a story or if you were going to write something like a hero story, AJ, would you personally say, I'm going to have the hero's journey in the Golden Bowl, just the rough outlines. I'm going to have them on a piece of paper beside me as I think about my plot, or are you just going to, or do you think that's kind of hokey, or do you just sort of do quote, do cool stuff like what you said earlier? I think, I mean, it's hard to avoid having elements of the hero's journey in there and it does provide a good structure.
I would think a lot more about the kind of character that I wanted to build and style perhaps. I don't think it'd be a bad way to go about things. The cosmic journey, maybe not so much. Yeah.
We're a little less tied to that these days. But thinking about, okay, he needs some sort of call to adventure. He needs to want to stay home because all of us do, then he needs someone to tell him where to go. That's a really good writing style, right?
That happens in a lot of things. Cool. Anybody have a commonplace book offering? Negative.
Hburg? I had one, but I left it in the car. I also do not have any because that's the way I do things. Okay.
We would like to hear from you about the writing episode. If you'd like to learn some basic style things on how to write well, I would like to know if that would be something that you would benefit from. Yeah. Maybe a little bit more of a technical podcast.
Yeah. A little bit. I could make it entertaining. I promise you.
I'm not sure you could. Yeah. I believe. We'll be back to the beginning of this podcast.
Please tell us if we in this podcast have been inadvertently followed the hero's journey or the Golden Bowl theory. I would love to hear. I would love to hear. I'm refusing to know.
I would love to see that. I would love to see that mapped out for us. Thank you. And you can send that to us at classicalstuff at veritasacademy.net.