Welcome to the Sif Pop Sif Spoil. We're going to go over all the hanging threads, romances, jokes, easter eggs, cameos, death, resurrections, and post-credits sequences. They all die. From vengeance. Andrew, you said you had a lot to talk about in Spoilers for Vengeance. So why don't you kick us off with where you want to take this conversation now that everything's on the table? Well, I kind of touched on how the ending of this didn't work for me because I don't feel like B.J. Novak's character, from what we'd seen throughout the entire movie, his timidity, for him to go from that to murder, it's a big leap.
It is. I do think it's the point of the movie. Now, that doesn't mean it has to work for you, but I do think that is specifically the point the movie is making, is that he would go from one to the other. But it doesn't mean it has to work. Yeah, no, I didn't either. I didn't necessarily either. I'm kind of with you on this. You know, that's, again, not the specific reason that the ending brings the movie down for me as much. But I do see what you're saying there. I also think that the movie is trying to do a fine balance, too, here, which is if the transition is clear and obvious, the ending is less shocking.
Right. I think part of the reason the ending is so shocking is because that transition is less clear. And so I do think that's specifically done on purpose. It just means character wise it may not work. Yeah. And you kind of have to you have to suspend a little bit of disbelief and just relegate it to being internal. You just have to go to the place where you're like, oh, all this happened off screen and internally. I just didn't get to see it. Yeah. So I think that's what the movie wants us to do. Yeah. I feel the same way. Again, I totally understand and can see why you feel that way. And you're not wrong necessarily. But yeah, I think that was the point of it. And especially just like.
Cause I didn't see what Ashton Kutcher said in those final moments like coming. And like, it was so true. Like one, two punch, right? Like it was, it was, it was just like the minute he started going, it was like, go ahead. But you know, I'll be the bad guy for like a week. And then I'm going to be, people are going to go online and they're going to say, well, wasn't she just another like drugged out girl and all this stuff. And it's like, I'm going to be Scott free. And I was like,
Yeah, that's exactly where we're at these days where everybody has an opinion on something, whether it be a trial between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard or politics, whatever it is. It's like there's enough like out there in the world for like a murderer to get off scot-free. Well, because everybody has a take and then there's always backlash and there's always backlash to the backlash. And it's just because everybody has to have an opinion about everything. Every opinion about everything exists. And it's, you know, I've said this before, but we no longer in our culture need to have straw man fallacies, right? Like the straw man fallacy is where you like invent.
an opinion to argue against. And it's like, well, nobody has that opinion. It's like, guess what? We now have proof that everybody has every, every opinion exists out there. There are no straw men. Now the straw man fallacy, I think is kind of morphed into something else, which is that we take something that one person believes or one person has said, or a very, very small minority of people have said, and we make it into this big thing so that we have something to argue against. I think that is part of the problem of social media is that every voice seems equal and it's not. I don't mean that in a human value way. I mean that in a majority minority way of what, you know, most.
humans would feel or believe or think or, you know, value. And so it equalizes things that aren't equal and that becomes very difficult. But that's what that whole final thing is about is just like, you know, polarization just allows everything to be my team versus your team. And I'm going to have a team and I probably won't suffer as much consequences as you like. So, yeah. Yeah. So it worked for me, though, essentially, just because like in that moment after he said that, I was seriously like, oh, kill him. I was like, I was like, I literally like gasp. And then I turned to my husband. I was like, good.
Yeah. I was like, this guy's going to do it again. Like, I don't know. I mean, I'm not saying I agree with that. Well, the movie is making it seem like he just did do it again. The movie literally has him dragging out another girl that we saw earlier. And I think there's something in those final few minutes about the police saying there's another body out by the, you know, whatever. I thought they were talking about Kutcher's body too. I thought they were. I thought they were talking about Kutcher's body. Yeah.
I think that's probably right. I mean, you're right. They are showing that, like, he doesn't care about these girls and, like, if they pass out for these drugs. He's a serial abuser, if nothing else. Yeah, he'll do it again. Even if he's not a serial murderer, he's a serial abuser. Yeah, he'll do it again. It's not, and that's, I don't know, now we're going back to, like, Dexter theory, right? Like, if he's actually going to keep doing it, is it really bad? Well, this is, I think, the heart of why I have difficulty with the ending of this movie, which is I am a pacifist. It's something that I've talked about before on the show. It's something I've grown into.
You know, I've always hated violence. I've always hated the idea of hurting other people in almost any situation. And now that has morphed into hating the idea of hurting anyone in any situation. And so that's where my pacifism comes from. And this movie is in many ways indicating that there is a time and place for vengeance. There is a time and place for violence. I know there are lots of people that believe that. Listen, I understand that people believe differently than me. I just don't believe that way. That's not part of my ethic. It's not part of my worldview.
For me, that last scene rings really difficult because it speaks to that part of us that wants judgment and vengeance and the idea of, you know, that we are the ones to – sometimes it has to be us. Nobody else is going to do it. It has to be us. We're the ones that have to rule. And that type of vigilantism – and honestly, I don't know that it's – again, you know, my pacifism extends to governments as well. I don't think governments should be being violent to people or killing people either. So, like, that goes for war. That goes for the death penalty. It's – I just – I think it's always a bad idea.
Um, and again, I know there are other beliefs and I'm not trying to have that debate right now. I'm just telling you my own personal worldview. So, so when a movie is like, you know, let's think about this. I'm like, I've kind of already thought about this. I know how I, how I feel in there. There's never a time I would feel like it was okay for me, not only to take another human being's life, but to be violent to another human being because I, you know, disagreed with them or whatever. Now where that, you know, line falls as far as like self-defense and those kinds of things. Um, you know, uh, like I would wrestle with somebody, I would pin them down. I would do everything I could to stop them. Um, but I would.
if I accidentally used lethal force on someone, it would destroy me. It would just, it's just like, I just, you know, it's, it's, so it's hard for me to come away from this movie going, I feel great about it because it is saying something about that, you know, and I don't know that I fully agree. So, yeah, I totally actually agree with you, Aaron on like in real life. That is how I feel. I almost, you set it to a T how I feel when it comes to movies and television. I feel like that's my outlet to when it's, when it's not, not, and obviously this is not based on a true story, right? So when it's not based on a true story, because I do feel like when it's a true story, it gets different, but this is fictional. So I do feel like that's my outlet.
to like be like when things like this happen I'm like it's the same with the show like I mean I watch TV shows and I'll be like oh my god I hope they kill that one off like kill them kill them but it's because it's fake I always say it's fake like you know where so that's where I take this is just like no, in real life, if this happened, I would not think it's okay. Like if it, if that was the case, but I just appreciated it in the film one, because I feel like most of the time they would take the route of like the moral correct way to go about it, which would be like, you're going to jail. We're going to let the justice system decide, whatever. Like, and I'd be like, okay. So, but for.
theatrics and you know for more of a dramatic effect i appreciated it because i was like oh you actually did it and and what what it makes for a great movie yeah but also what action kutcher said was another one of those things that like stays with you and it makes i would hope people would think twice because it's another thing i can't stand is the fact that and i when i got to i actually got to speak to bj novak about this movie and he said how like how terrible that everybody has to have an opinion on something with social media. It's just like really bad for the world. And I agree because I just think it's causing more of a divide and people are feeling they have to say an opinion on something they truly probably don't even care that much about because they feel like they're unseen if they don't, like they don't matter. It's like, if you don't have an opinion, you're not, you don't exist in this world. And it's like, that's something I personally- Or if you don't have a public opinion, you don't exist in this world. There are so many conversations I'm more than willing to have with the people who I'm close to, with my family, with my closest friends, or even with a stranger when we're in the same room and we just find ourselves on a topic. That's fine.
There are many things that I don't make public about, you know, because I don't I don't have to. I don't need that to validate my existence as some sort of public commentator on, you know, things. So, yeah, I think it's it is it is definitely an era where that seems to be the norm where you have to have an easy to hide behind social media and do it because you'll say whatever you want versus like what you just said, in which I think the movie does a good job of trying to say, like, it's about having conversations in the same room with somebody because then you're going to understand each other. And that's, I don't know. So, and I, we're at least going to be forced to see someone as a fellow human being, which we lose a lot of time online, you know? So, you know, yeah. So I do want to, I do want to make it clear. I did. I did like this movie. Almost loved it. Like this is, you know, I really, really enjoyed this movie. And when I'm talking about how a movie differs from my own, like personal moral convictions, I generally, it takes a lot for me to really hold that against the movie. And it's generally when I feel like the movie is making a specific moral point.
That I feel is unhealthy if it were to be expanded to, you know, because when a movie is doing that, it's specifically doing something that I think is unhealthy or, you know, negative for culture. And that, you know, I do have those opinions, but in general, it's so nuanced. Like you can't, you know. there's an argument to be made that even when a movie is saying something you don't like or you don't agree with, that there's value because it creates that conversation and it gives us all the ability to talk about it. And I do, I think that's valuable. So I get that it's nuanced and that it's, you know, so I'm just, I'm explaining my own kind of feelings and how those impact my overall view of these. It's actually kind of interesting because I was with a bunch of my old friends. We were all coworkers. We used to work in a hospital and we saw just some, we saw a lot of stuff while we worked there. And one of our duties was in the morgue, you know, we were, and the other day when we were talking, we were talking about,
this separation we all have like whenever we see a death in a movie or on a tv show is and how different it is from something like that in real life so i can definitely appreciate the the pacifism conundrum of like you know what does this mean for me to watch this and you know so i can totally respect that aaron yeah no for sure uh for the movie itself i have one other thing and by the way please don't forget that i like this movie but the other thing that was that was a big negative for me uh that now i can talk about spoilers was the fact that he's having bj novak's been he's having this you know learning experience throughout the entire movie because of what's happened to uh I'm trying to remember her name now. Abilene? Abilene, yeah, thank you. For what has happened to Abilene, you know, and he's, like, learning, you know, about her way of life, you know, and, like, we see it slowly turning him into what we would consider a better person. And then we have the revelation that she's just not a good person at all, and that she's kind of, yes, she is a victim of this tragedy, but, like, she was like, oh, I have you in my phone as this douchebag that I was, you know, seeing in New York. I don't think that she's not a good person.
No, I think the movie has a lot of empathy. Yeah, she did that thing. She read Harry Potter books to that guy who wasn't even allowed to read Harry Potter books. And she was like, good with her family. I mean, I don't know. But don't get me wrong. Like, I agree with you. But I think for me, in the moment, that movie moment made me feel like the movie was saying like, oh, so she wasn't that great of a person. So maybe all the stuff that Ben was learning, you know, can kind of go out the window. That's what the movie felt like it was saying for me in that moment.
I think we're supposed to believe – if I'm interpreting the movie in the way it wants to be interpreted, I think what it's trying to do is to plant that on the Kutcher character as well. I think what it's trying to say is this man is such a gaslighter, has such a way with words, has – like we see him do it with the other girl when he talks about her voice or whatever. And I think what we're supposed to believe about Abilene is that she got caught up in that and that that was – she thought she was in love. She thought that she had found her thing. And what she did was wrong, yes, but I don't feel like the movie ever – ever seemed to be indicating that we were supposed to hold that against her in any way. I think we were supposed to hold that against the Kutcher character. Agreed. Yeah. And I think that if anything, it also revealed that she was a little smarter than the family let on because we think for so long that she was supposedly like, she thought that her and BJ Novak had this like amazing relationship. And in reality, she wasn't like that dense. She knew that she was like, yeah, I'm using that. So no, I definitely didn't think that. Yeah. She was using him as, as a cover, you know, that's all it was. She was. And I also, you know, that I'm not trying to, you know, I also have empathy for her as she was an addict, you know, that's just, that's the terrible disease.
But yeah, I don't know why. Again, I like this movie. It's just if it wasn't for the ending, I think could have done better. I would easily say I love this movie because everything leading up to that is brilliant. So just out of curiosity, what do you think should have happened in that ending then that would have kept you to love it? If he had been recording, like he said, he'd been recording the whole thing, you know? Yeah. Which he had been. Yeah. And then he deleted everything. That's the only other thing I wanted to talk about was how you felt about that part of the ending. But just real quick, I think if he would have called his bluff.
you know, if he would have called his bluff and uploaded everything and the movie would have shown, yeah, the world's not as sick as you think it is. Like if there is some justice that sticks, you know, but yeah, going back, I like that ending, but you know, but it is a more typical ending and then you don't get the, the shocking moment, which for me is okay. I, you know, I think that's the, you know, I think I would have enjoyed, I think I would have come away liking the movie more. I think that would have been, I think your ending is, it's good, but it's extremely predictable. Yeah. I also see how the other way could be shock for shock's sake, you know? Right.
So what about erasing everything? My wife and I were trying to work this out. Did he erase everything? That's what I got from it. Yeah, that's what I thought too. My thought was he was like, no, what I'm doing is shallow and unimportant. This isn't something that I need to have a public entertainment on. It is something that I experienced and I'm going to leave it in the real world of experience. And it wasn't just about protecting himself from that last moment. It was literally about a lifestyle change. That's what I understood. I felt like he felt almost hypocritical to post it. If he did it, it was not with...
I'm just using this family, using this girl's death. It would just all be an icky use of that podcast. Right. So Aaron, with your interpretation, are you asking, did he delete everything from the moment he landed? Yes. That's how I feel. I thought you did that. I don't think that's right. That's what my wife said. My wife said she didn't think that was correct either. You think he kept some of it? This is why I think that doesn't make sense. It's because he's been emailing.
those clips. It's a shared cloud. It's a race character. Eloise, is that what it is? So him deleting everything doesn't, you know, do anything because it's already up there in the cloud. And she said that they've been editing it, you know, so it's already existing. So I think the only thing he's deleting is that last audio clip of him talking to Ashton Kutcher's character, Quentin.
But there's so many clips that we see getting deleted. Yeah, I thought we see like a straight shot of him looking like... The entire folder and it all goes away. You're right. And you're absolutely correct. And this is what we talked about. You're absolutely correct that Issa Rae has had access to this already, has already been editing some episodes together. They've already had drafts that have been sent and previewed, like all that kind of stuff. But I think what it's trying to indicate, and I could be wrong, is that he is making it impossible for them to continue that project. He has permanently deleted their ability to... So all they have is whatever working stuff they happen to move off the main cloud.
So like a lot of that stuff, even that they've been working on, could still be in those folders if nobody has moved it to a separate cloud or a separate hard drive. So if all they have is just the stuff they happen to move to an email or a hard drive or whatever, then they're working from a place where they just don't have anything. But it's a little bit, not confusing, but a little bit unclear to me. I want to rewatch it. Maybe I'll pay more attention. I just took it as everything got deleted, but maybe I'm wrong. This is a very rewatchable movie because that family is so lovable. Like I said, Boyd Holbrook, what he gets up to is so funny. You just smile whenever he's on screen. Yeah, he's good.
uh well there you go um unless you guys have anything else that you want to talk about otherwise from vengeance i don't think so i love that little boy yeah i love that sleeping on the floor yeah see that's another thing that was great about abilene she let that little brother sleep in that room well and again the entirety of that mystery of how to get into her phone is solved from their relationship and you know i i just i thought that was really sweet i thought that was really beautiful um Also, I hate gun culture. Okay. We'll move on. Thank you so much for tuning into the Sip Spoil. We will be back to spoil things when we want to ruin them for you. Bye.