Skip to content
368: She Said, Disenchanted episode artwork

Nov 21, 2022 1 hr 31 min

368: She Said, Disenchanted

from SiftPop Hosted by SiftPop | Aaron Dicer, Andrew Ormsby

Aaron and Andrew welcome Susan Kamyab Stephens back to the show this week! They review "She Said" (8:18) and "Disenchanted" (34:59), rank Best Ever movies with "she" in the title (54:32), then finish up with Buried Treasure (1:16:17).

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

368: She Said, Disenchanted

0:00 1:31:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Uncle Bob can fix just about anything around the house, at least according to him. But when it comes to natural gas appliances, they should always be inspected by a qualified professional. Learn more at embergegas.com slash safety. Live from a bunker in the heart of the Ozarks, a podcast that never just says stuff. Not if we can help it. It's SIFPA.

Welcome to Sif Pop Weekly. Streaming live most Saturday mornings are available to download later in your podcast feed. Unless, of course, you're a patron. Patrons get perks. Patrons get those perks. You stole my joke. I'm your host, Aaron Ticer. And he looks good even when he's not bathed in the light of a forgiving moon. It's Andrew Ormsby, ladies and gentlemen. Oh, it shines right off my bald head. It does, indeed. Each week we'll chat about movies, TV, and whatever else from the pop culture universe is on our minds. And please welcome our guest this week. She's going to sing the entire show. It's Susan Kamyab-Stevens. Hi. You would not like that. I think you underestimate the joy I would take in that situation.

Hey, guys. Exciting to chat with the both of you. We've got a couple of very different movies this week, which is always interesting when that happens. I don't see it. Yeah, pretty similar. Really, just dealing with the same issues, really. Basically. Well, so necessary.

Yes. Yes, indeed. So, yeah, we're going to talk about She Said, a new movie that's out in theaters in Disenchanted, which is the Enchanted sequel that came out on Disney Plus this weekend. We're also going to do a best ever. What are we doing this week for best ever? Did I not prep best ever? Best ever challenge. She movies. Oh, that's right. Movies with the word she in them. Guys, I'm going to be honest here live on the air. I somehow skipped prepping for the best ever challenge. I'm going to be doing some last second. Wow. There's no graphic for yours. Not yet. You know what I will do is when we do the first movie, Susan, I'll just have you sing for about 20 minutes.

I do that. No, we'll figure all this out. So anyhow, yes, we're going to do best ever she movies, movies with the word she in them. If you send me your like a Patreon speech, I can do that while you're looking up. Thank you. Thank you. I appreciate that. The word she can be hidden in other words as well. So that opens it up a little bit wider. So, yeah. And then, of course, we'll do some buried treasure along the way. Susan, how are you doing? How's life been? It's been a hot second. How's stuff? How's award season? What's going on? Good. Good. Yeah. I feel like it's like in full swing right now. We're finally getting screeners, but I've got to admit, we're getting a lot of.

links and like apps and stuff which honestly is a little um gets me a little more stressed out because i feel like when i got the physical dvd screeners i could organize that out a little bit more and see what i need to watch so now i'm like literally making a list on my phone of all the movies i need to make sure i watch i don't go to the screenings too um so but yeah just working a lot and i know we've got uh well i know you went to you went to the glass onion thing right yeah i went to the glass onion premiere this last week um and enjoyed my time there uh that you know there's it's interesting my experience this year has been that not only aren't we getting physical discs, I think I've got two discs this year for screen. Oh, I know. I know. It's crazy. Yeah. But we're also not getting a lot at all. Like, I'm just going, like, there's a list of 40 movies that I would love to see before we have to vote in three weeks or whatever it is. Two weeks. I know. Three weeks, I think. In December. Yeah, I just, it is, yeah, it's really, really weird. Yeah. I was just thinking how, I wish I could have gone to that. I was invited. I wanted to go to that because I wanted to see Glass Onion really badly, too.

Um, but that's another one that's on my list to, to watch. And I just, yeah, in general, I don't feel like we're getting stuff that we need to watch. Like, and I wish they would do it. Didn't we get used to get those like in October? Like, I don't remember. No, it has never been this late, uh, before. And, and I think there's this growing sense from the studios.

that they want to be the last thing that they put in our brain. And it's like, fine, go ahead and take that risk. But if I get 40 movies with two days left, I'm going to have to figure out a way to prioritize, which isn't fair for anyone. That's not fair for anyone. And especially, and you might say, well, go to the movie theater and see the movies, Aaron. Well, some of these aren't out yet. Some of them, especially where I'm at, aren't playing locally. A lot of the ones that are going to play in New York and LA and maybe some of the major markets aren't here in Springfield, Missouri. So I rely on these screeners to be able to make an educated assessment during awards season.

Uh, this isn't a way I don't get to see movies thing. This is a, I want to do my job right. Like I have a task to do here and I want to do it right. Um, so yeah, it's, it's been a weird one for sure this year. It seems very strange. And there was a lot of that chatter around the event this last weekend. Cause a lot of our, um, contemporaries were, were there at the glass onion premiere. And a lot of us were talking about where are the screeners this year? Like, where are they? It's yeah. And they're not really as accessible about, um, links as much as I'd like to. I mean, some people are, some people, like I said, they were really good about the menu, but I want to see bones and all. And they're not getting a link for that. And I'm like, well, can I get the DVD?

I don't know. It's just, yeah, I'm just worried that exactly that, like I'm feeling a little bit overwhelmed. So I'm trying to get a headstart on whatever I do have so that by the time that they overload us and we have to spend a whole weekend trying to watch everything that I don't have anything that I already have. Like that's my main thing. Yeah. I set up a list every year. I don't know if you're on Letterboxd, but I put the list on Letterboxd of the awards contenders that I want to make sure I see. And it's worked well for me to kind of make sure that I check out everything that might have a little bit of buzz around it. Basically, I take the three main.

sites that do a best picture race ranking. And they usually rank like the top 50 movies that might win best picture. And I average those rankings out and then sort it and make a list of, and the list this year is like 63 movies that have a shot according to that list. And it is on Letterboxd, my Letterboxd, if you want to check that out. Last year, Coda ended up winning best picture. And when I made those rankings, which I usually make around the end of October.

Coda was ranked number 8th as the possible Best Picture winner. That's not so bad. And it ended up winning. So, yeah, it's interesting to see how things change from late October to, you know, Oscar Day. It's an interesting kind of thing. So, like I said, I got 40 more to go. And I have one of them.

I've already seen all the ones that I have access to. So it's, it's why. What do you have left to watch? Oh, you want me to list all 40? All right. Let's, let's go. Oh, you have four. I thought you said you have, what's the, what's the one that you have that's left to watch? Oh, um, I would have to look. Uh, I just, I go to the list and see what I have. Um, but I've knocked off several that I have. I just have one more. Um, yeah. That I can knock off. It's already out there. So, so yeah. Anyhow, critic problems, you know, world's smallest violin. Andrew, how's it going for you? Screener season. How's it, uh, how's it working? I've watched a few. Yeah. I bet you have. Yeah. Yeah. So.

Can't talk about him yet, obviously. We'll talk about him when it's time to talk about him. Exactly. All right. Well, we're going to get into it. Let's start with a review of She Said. Why is sexual harassment so pervasive and so hard to address? Let's interrogate the whole system. Hi, my name is Jody Cantor. I'm an investigative reporter for The New York Times. What have you got? I was told that the wrongdoing in Hollywood is overwhelming. I don't want to be quoted. Period. Understood.

In your previous stories, how did you persuade women to tell you what had happened to them? The case I made was, I can't change what happened to you in the past, but together we may be able to help protect other people. The truth, basically. New York Times reporters Megan Tooley and Jody Cantor break one of the most important stories in a generation, a story that helped launch the Me Too movement and shattered decades of silence around the subject of sexual assault in Hollywood. This is a journalistic process movie, journalistic investigation along the lines of, you know, the Woodward and Bernstein stuff or Spotlight, All the President's Men, yeah, all that stuff. This is all the president's women, or all the producers' women. Yeah, I guess you could call it that for sure. Zoe Kazan as Jody Cantor, Carrie Mulligan stepping in as Megan Tooley.

And some real-life people stepping in with their own part of the story as well, including Ashley Judd, who played a major role in the breaking of the story. What did you guys think? Did you like it, love it, dislike it, hate it, or it was just okay? Andrew, why don't you kick us off on this one? I am really close to loving this one, but I think for now I'm going to go with really liked it. Okay. Susan? Really liked it. Just exactly what Andrew said. Like, almost there to love in it, but really liked it.

Man, there's no almost there about it for me. I loved this movie. My wife and I, after this movie was over, sat in the theater and talked for a bit. And then my bladder made that conversation stop a little bit early. So we continued to talk at home for a while. This is one of those movies you have to sit with and process and go over. And it was such a beautiful conversation to be able to have.

Together after this movie, we were also both in tears at the end. This movie was very emotional for both of us. And, you know, I'm not trying to take ownership of what is very much a female story. But I think it is important for us as men to feel these feelings and these emotions in this movie, even if we don't feel them as deeply and authentically as a woman might after watching this. Also, we can't forget that not only women are victims. Correct. I think that's well worth stating. I think that is well worth stating.

Um, so, so yeah, I, I just, the experience of this movie is the biggest emotional, uh, journalistic investigation experience I've had since spotlight. I think this is the best journalistic investigation movie since spotlight. Um, I think you like it better than spotlight. Yeah. Yeah. Um, can I ask why y'all like it better than spotlight? That's interesting. Well, I don't know. I don't know that I have the ability to process that right now. I think I'm too close to this one right now. Yeah. I just watched it yesterday. So yeah. Yeah. She said, no, no.

No, she said I just watched yesterday, so it's kind of hard for me to say immediately that I liked it more than Spotlight because I like Spotlight a lot. So I don't know if I'm there to say I like she said more than Spotlight. That's a weird thing to try to weigh in my brain right now. I think it needs time. But it feels like that to me. It feels like how I felt after Spotlight where it's just such important information. You come away. There are two things I have a real bias for in movies, and this movie is both of them. It should not be a surprise that I love it because of this. True life stories. I feel the emotion so much deeper when I know it comes from the real world.

And especially in a situation like this where some of the real people are talking about what happened in the real world. Like I'm getting emotional even just thinking about some of this movie. And that brings the emotion home for me in a really real way. And then the other part of this is my bias is competence porn. Any movie that gives me people amazing at their job, doing amazing things with their job is just catnip for me. And to watch these primarily women, these two women at the primary center of this.

absolutely dominate the journalistic process and just completely with integrity and solidity and understanding their responsibility and their rules to get it right. I know there is a shifting perspective of how we trust new sources in media in this country. And I understand that I get that. And a lot of that has to do with polarization. That is not the conversation we're having now. But a lot of the distrust of media comes with the idea that when the media says things that don't agree with your worldview, the media must be corrupt. And that goes all the different ways.

Having said that, to watch something like this, you go, you know what? When you put it out there to do it right and you really make an effort to be above reproach, there's something really powerful about investigative journalism. And this movie shows that in so many different ways and the way the respect with which it handles sources and sourcing and on the record, off the record, all that stuff. Man, I just love that stuff in this movie. And it's a movie that would be – I feel like I'm dominating the conversation. I will let you guys talk, but I just really love this movie. Keep going, brother. Yeah, keep going. I love it. I feel like when you watch this movie.

You're watching a movie where people are just making phone calls. Just talking. There's an entire scene where people are reading an article on a computer. We're just watching them read something off of a computer. And they're taking turns being like, okay. I love how the guy's like, hold on. Wait. It's so perfect. It's so perfect. How am I feeling this emotional and intense about people reading silently on a computer? To me, that is the magic of a movie that does this well, is it takes you into the nitty gritty.

of the process, and you are on pins and needles about a phone call. It's astonishing how well this movie holds your attention for how boring it should be. The process should be boring. Now, granted, there are lots of this process that would be boring, probably, to watch. This movie finds those moments of the boredom that are most important and most meaningful and most emotional and brings those to us. That's the beauty of what a movie can do, the way it can tell a story. But it is intentionally showing you

the nitty gritty grind of this process and it does it in such a really powerful way um so i've said i've said enough what are some of the things you guys liked about this movie because you both really liked it as well so yeah i mean i feel like you you kind of covered a lot no no no it's a good thing because it's making me like it even more maybe i'm there maybe um yeah i think that i think there's something to be said that um because i do feel like people could look at you know i will say i went on a matinee and it was me and one other person it was an older white guy i was already surprised i hate to say this i don't know i will just say that halfway through the film he left and he didn't come back so And I was so curious why, like, I was like, why was this? Did he not, was it political reasons? Was it, but I'm also like, did he get a text that his son had a flat tire? Like you just never know. I just, cause I'm like, I don't know how you would leave. Like it's just getting even better now. So, um, but then I also wondered, are people going to find it boring if it, cause it is, it's, it's a lot of talking. It's a lot of researching. And, um, but this movie does that so well to the point where I'm, it's exciting. It's thrilling. Like every, I love it. I love those shots where you're walking down the hallway in the middle of the newsroom or you're.

When you're intensely researching and you find something, I love that stuff. Exactly like you said, before they hit submit. But also the performances are fantastic. I think Zoe Kazan and Carey Mulligan. We want to talk about acting awards. Here we go. I don't know. Maybe Carey Mulligan has a slight edge here. I'm not sure. I don't know. But they're both fantastic. Well, I think it's worth mentioning that Zoe Kazan, I think, is submitting in lead and Carey Mulligan is submitting in supporting.

What? I think that's worth mentioning for a couple reasons. Number one, it helps to clarify awards chances. Number two, it can bring back that discussion that we have every year about category fraud and the idea of why are we letting actors decide or producers or whoever's making these decisions, what category it goes in? Shouldn't that be the awards body?

that decides what category it goes in. Now, technically it is, by the way, the awards bodies, but what awards body is going to go, nah, I'm going to put you in lead instead. I would. Yeah, I actually would too. I actually have, in fact, done that. Wow. That's interesting. Yeah. I mean, I'm glad they're doing that so they don't, I mean, obviously it's so they don't split votes. Well, that'll help their chances, both of them. Yeah, but Jennifer Ely could have been a perfect supporting suggestion for this movie. Her scene on the Cornwall.

at the beach in Cornwall where she's telling her story. She is so good in that scene. She has a perfect definition of a supporting actor nom, or a supporting actress for the category. But yeah. And you bring up another good thing too, is I think this had a really perfect opening hook. I love the beginning of this movie. I think that was really great in how it comes back too. Yeah, yeah.

You got her some thoughts. What do you like? Well, I think that the best compliment you can give this film is that it would be considered the sequel to All the President's Men, which I think is the best investigative reporting film that I can think of. I've actually never seen that. I thoroughly, thoroughly enjoy it. But I can see how a lot of people would watch this movie and go, okay, it's a copy-paste of that movie because there's the Deep Throat character, you know? There's the...

The final call at the very end where you're waiting for that call to come in. There's a lot of scene for scene comparisons with that. But if you're going to try and base an investigative reporting movie off anything, you could do a lot worse than All the President's Men. Going on to our two leads, I think they are just incredible. I personally would say that Zoe Kazan is the one who steals the movie from me. But they're both so good. Kazan has several scenes where she really pushes her character to an emotional breaking point that I felt not only believable, but genuine.

Again, not to take away from Carey Mulligan or Patricia Clarkson or Andre Brower. That core group of people at the New York Times, I really loved the team aspect that they brought. Everybody had something that they brought to the table. I love how every single time somebody had to talk to Harvey Weinstein, Andre Brower was like, I'll take care of it. And he would just put him in his place. Every single time I was like, yeah, you go. It's so good. Yeah. It's an acting tour de force, which you need in a movie like this, where there is a lot of walkie-talkie going on.

But every single time that there was a victim that had to be interviewed about their experience about working with Harvey Weinstein, it was insane how all the victim's stories entailed horrific aspects that were very similar to one another, but each story being told felt deeply personal and unique for them. And I struggled so many times in this movie to keep from crying, and I failed multiple times in this movie. Here's the trick, Andrew. Here's the trick. Just cry.

Just don't try to stop. Just let it flow. Let the emotion flow through you. I do the lip quiver. It's a beautiful thing. I love it. I love it.

It is a beautiful cry. I would never call that a beautiful cry. Other thoughts that you might have? If we want to go into negatives, we can go in there. Whatever else about this movie that impacted your experience? Susan. You guys have negatives? I don't have negatives. I was curious of y'all's thoughts on Ashley Judd in the film. Yeah. Because I didn't expect her and I also, you know, there were moments for a second. That was probably where it almost took me out just a moment of the movie for a split second. Well, let's talk about the choice this movie makes, right? The choice this movie makes is that if this is a person you're going to recognize,

It's either going to be that person or we're not going to show you their face. Yes. Right. That's down the line. Now, maybe if you like studied this story and you know some of the players, I'm not talking about that. I'm talking the people that the majority, Gwyneth Paltrow, Rose McGowan, Harvey Weinstein, Donald Trump, the people that are in this movie, that the majority of people would know what they look like. The movie makes the choice to, I think Ashley Judd is the only one that is actually the person that we see. Yeah.

Yeah. I could be wrong about that. And please let me know. But if it's somebody else, we see the back of heads. We hear voices. The Gwyneth Paltrow voice was dead on. Like it sounded like Gwyneth Paltrow to me. We heard Gwyneth Paltrow? Yeah. On the phone. The Donald Trump voice was dead on. Yeah, the Trump voice was. I think those are authentic recordings, aren't they? Some of them are, but I don't know. Not Rose McGowan. No, I don't think the Rose McGowan stuff is authentic. Trump one was good. It was either a recording or it was – what I'm bringing up here is the fact that the movie gives you the best chance you have at not being distracted by that stuff. Right. And I think it does it really, really well.

And what you bring up about Ashley Judd is, ironically, that maybe becomes a distraction because you know that actually is the person. And so you are aware that this is a person who is reinserting themselves in the story, who is now older than they were when this was happening, although not a lot. Seven, eight years? Yeah, something like that. So for me, I didn't find it distracting. I found I found myself getting more emotional during those parts. Yeah, it was just the initial because I didn't expect her and I was like, oh. Oh, okay.

You know, just the initial shock. Yeah, that was like the moment where for a second it took me out and it was fine because obviously there's a key moment with her and Zoey because I did cry and I was like, oh my gosh. It's almost like similar to like first, I mean, like you remember like Honey Boy with Shia LaBeouf where it's like when you're recreating, like, you know, it takes your mom like, okay, it's interesting to see them play themselves or I mean, I know he wasn't playing his dad, but still, you know what I mean? Like playing characters they know, it just like takes me a second because that's very rare. It's very rare. We're in a biopic or not in a biopic, you know, like a true story.

the real person comes in and plays themselves. So I just wasn't expecting it. But once I got into it, I mean, I love that she did that. I think that's wonderful. And that's speaks volumes on her too. Like that's, it was, it was, it made it that much more impactful and that much more authentic. I think that's a key thing with this movie is that it feels so authentic and they don't try to be very Hollywood with it. I don't feel, I feel like they don't mind just being like, I don't think simple is the right word, but.

I mean, it's just very authentic. I feel like that's just the main thing. They don't try to go glitzy and bigger or anything like that, and that's what makes it so much more powerful. Well, and also because it's not – I mean, okay, let me state this carefully. It is, of course, about the experiences of all these people, but the movie is so centered on the journalistic process and what that means to the stories of these people that I don't think we have really – the movie doesn't get starstruck. There's nothing about this movie that feels like –

I was I was actually worried at the beginning with the Trump call. I was actually worried at the beginning because the very first thing one of the very first things we hear is this conversation with Donald Trump. And I was like, oh, is that what we're like? We're just going to be like, hey, look at these famous people that were involved. But the movie very quickly finds its its balance in its tone. And that becomes just a part of, you know, the launch pad of what we're talking about. So. So, yeah, I hear what you're saying. Yeah. And I think that was so essential to have that because that that showed that. Well, that was the start of it. But it was interesting because I'm not trying to it's not a political thing. It's just like they showed what that man did with sexual misconduct.

And then he became president. And then, you know, what other people, other people got in trouble for other actions. But this man became president. Like it was just, it was interesting to see that. There's an underlying theme or through line about why does it matter? All this work we put into investigating and being above reproach. Why does it matter in the case of Trump if he's just going to be elected president and nobody cares? And you get a real sense that the feeling even during Weinstein stuff was like, we'll put this out.

Is it really going to make a difference? Like, what makes a difference? And there are several conversations about why you make that choice, even if it doesn't make the difference that you think it might make that I think are really powerful. And we have the benefit of hindsight to go, well, of course it made a difference. Like, it became a huge movement, which, by the way, this movie never references Me Too, the hashtag Me Too. Not once. Not even in the end, correct? Like, not even in the Harvey Weinstein was accused of this, like, you know, the end things that come up in these movies. I never mentioned Me Too.

at the end of the movie where they have it in different languages, she said, and, you know, it's like translated for like the global audience. I was surprised. I thought I was going to see it in there too. I was so surprised that I wondered if it was a legal issue. Like I wondered if somebody owns the rights to like the, what's it called? The trademark on that phrase or something, which would be a shame, honestly. But, you know, I mean, that is how, you know, ownership content culture works, unfortunately. So it did seem strange enough that I wondered, like, maybe there was a reason they couldn't do that. Or maybe they just didn't want that to be part of the distraction. I don't know.

Right. I think that could have been. That could have taken people out. Yeah. All right, well, let's do our one last thing. Any final thing you want to talk about with She Said? Oh, go ahead. No, Andrew, I was going to add something, but you can go ahead. It's okay. I just wanted to mention that She Said earned a Sophie for the Critics' Choice Women's Group, Women's Committee. We announced that this week, so I just thought it was relevant that it was the women's seal. And I think it was, I just watched it, and I think it was very well earned. It was the seal of female empowerment and entertainment. And yeah, I just want to give it that credit. Yeah.

Yep. One last thing, Andrew? Besides no post-credit scene, I would say that this film is directed beautifully by Maria Schrader, who I just found out about because I think she's only done, besides her acting career, she's a German director mostly, so not a lot of English films that I might have heard of. But I found she has the ability to capture specific scenes with this nuanced sense of dread and suspense. What I mean by this is there are scenes where you'll have two individuals who are...

who we're focusing on and they're having a discussion. Yet the camera is shot from either a reflective surface or from outside of a window. And it builds tension because you see, you know, the reflections of people walking down the road or down the hallway. And you don't know if it's just a random pedestrian or if it's somebody following these reporters. So the way this film is shot, I think deserves a lot of praise. I think it was very smart the way they did it. Yeah, it was. I also like that they didn't show, I don't know if that's necessarily a spoiler, but they don't show the actual attacks. Like, yeah, that's true. I like that. And it's funny because the.

The way the women talk about it is so descriptive and visual in your mind that you almost feel like you watched it. You're like, oh, I feel like I did see that. But, you know, you just see images of clothes on the floor or something like that. And I thought that's in some ways that's even more graphic just because it's left to our own imagination. Do we know, do you guys know, because I did not look it up, the recording.

of the, uh, event that happened. Is that the actual recording? Is that a matter of public record? And they were able to use it or. I was wondering that too. It has to be right. Unsettling scene in the entire movie. I was going to say, you know, you bring up the fact that, that, you know, we're not shown anything, but to hear that, um, even if it was a recreation, it's a spectacular recreation. Uh, I don't believe it is a recreation. There are moments where like the, the subtitles say, you know, like, uh, unintelligible or like, you know, where you can't hear exactly what's being said.

Um, so it felt very almost documentary like in, during that moment. And it's just, the visual is just slow pans down hallways, hotel hallways. And it's, it's, it's so effective. It's so effective. Um, it just feels like this movie, every 100 choices this movie made, 99 of them were correct. And the other one was good enough. You know, like none of them were bad. This movie did not make bad choices. It just, it really doesn't feel like it did. Um, so, so yeah. Uh, so yeah, I guess that would be my, my kind of one final thing. So there you go. That she said it's available in theaters. High, high recommend. This is one of those movies where it's just like.

Don't let it just fly under the radar and be like, oh, I don't want to feel things, so I don't want to go see that movie. We need to process this stuff. We need to experience it. We need, as a culture, to wrestle with the demons of what it means to be humans and to be around other humans and the empathy that it takes to live together and hear each other's stories. Also, you've got to be aware that this is a movie that can trigger a lot of emotions. Of course. You need to be aware of the type of movie that you're watching. While it is being important, I never would want to have somebody relive an experience just to see a movie.

But it is a very good movie and it's an important movie too. Yeah. The stat I hear often is that one in five women have been sexually assaulted. And the fact that 20% of the female population has dealt with actual sexual assault, not sexual impropriety, sexual assault is astonishing. And I think you clearly understand the kind of topic that you're going into here. And there's a large portion of women who have already had to process this and deal with this. And you know yourself.

you know, better than anyone else and whether or not a movie like this would be a overall negative experience or an overall positive one for you. Um, but, uh, from my perspective is it is necessary watching for many, many people, um, to understand. So, um, yeah, so there you go. That is, she said, uh, let's move on and talk about disenchantment. Totally different. Yeah. Just a little bit.

This world feels very different. Is it sometimes easier to live in Andalasia? Well, I wouldn't say easier. We have dragons and ogre rebellions. Last year, the entire kingdom was trapped in a giant whale. Oh. This is not a magic land. It is a land far, far away from my friends. I'm so late. I'm a commuter now. You're riding this train over and over and over and over and over and over and over. And then you die.

Disillusioned with life in the city, feeling out of place in suburbia and frustrated that her happily ever after hasn't been so easy to find, Giselle turns to the magic of Vandalasia for help, accidentally transforming the entire town into a real-life fairy tale and placing her family's future happiness in jeopardy. She must race against time to reverse the spell and determine what happily ever after truly means to her and her family. This is available on Disney+. I do not believe it's getting a theatrical release. So this is a sequel, of course, to Enchanted. It brings back most of the...

The cast for another round, Patrick Dempsey, and is coming back with Amy Adams as the central couple. And then, of course, you've got James Marsden and Idina Menzel as the Andalasia king and queen. So, yeah, let's talk a little bit about Disenchanted. What did you think? Did you like it, love it, dislike it, hate it, or it was just okay? Susan, you get to start this time. Like a notch above. I don't want to say hate it. Oh. Like a low dislike?

Maybe I'll give it like it was a low okay. I was going to say, it's definitely a low okay if you're going okay. I can tell by the tone of your voice. Yeah, sure. When you're like, I don't want to say I hated it. We're already well into the low okays at that point. I don't want to say I hated it because I loved it. Andrew, what about you? Well, I had to watch Enchanted first. Oh, okay. How was that experience for you? Yeah, I liked Enchanted. I thought it was a lot of fun. Oh, I love Enchanted. Yeah, Enchanted's good.

This one, I would say that I did not like as much as the first one. I will join Susan in just okay, but I'm not teetering into didn't like or anything like that. Well, we run the various spectrum of the just okay, because I'm on the high side of just okay. We're all in an okay round. We're all just kind of like, meh, but I kind of liked it. Meh, but I didn't like it. And meh, meh. So, yeah. Not that I watched it.

I guess that means I'm the one that loved this movie. I guess that puts me at the highest ranking of all of us. Why is this your movie of the year? This movie is so good. No, I'm just kidding. Oh, my God. Look, here's the thing. This movie is exactly the movie you think it's going to be. This is one of those movies where you're just –

following the next thing you're finding a little spin to put on it but you're trying to recapture the same literally magic and and do you know put a movie out there that can recapture you know the audience of enchanted now that is a good thing and a bad thing it is a good thing meaning if you like enchanted you're gonna find some stuff to like here you're gonna like these characters already you're gonna want to see what the next page of the the story tells i did like that this movie started with the idea of you know happily ever after doesn't that mean ever like ever after like why are we doing a sequel like you know you get married and then you're happy and that's how that's how that's all that works there's no problems after i love that kind of idea at the beginning uh but this movie goes exactly where you think it's going to go so negative of that is there's not really a lot here to keep me interested because I kind of get what's going on here. You know, this movie lives formulaically ever after. It just, it feels like they took the formula of the first and put a little spin on it and yay, happy, skip to my loo, we're having an okay time. But yeah, so that is where I land. I think I put it on the high side of okay because I like Enchanted. I like this universe. I like Amy Adams. I absolutely love the James Marsden character. I think he's almost in a different movie than everybody else and I wish I was watching that movie a little bit more. It almost feels like the,

The Chris Pine performance from Into the Woods where it's just like this really interesting royal character. I like when the movie goes to those places more than when it tries to find its authenticity in the human world. That's actually my biggest con with the movie is James Marston. Oh, interesting. Because he's not in it enough. Oh, yes. I was going to say that. He wasn't in it enough. And that was so great about Enchanted is I felt like I got a good amount of him and we needed so much more in this one. You got all the laughs from me in the first one. Yeah.

Like the Maya Rudolph stuff wasn't working for me. And that kills me to say I love Maya Rudolph. And again, there are a lot of things that go into whether a performance works or not. But it was just like, I think that was supposed to be. comedy but she's normally very funny it's not her fault I think it was the script like I just wasn't I did not laugh at anything with her and I did not like even like the two side minions whatever they were it was just like I'm not feeling this at all it really feels like it might be the writing in this case because Jama Mays is also hilarious I love her and stuff Yvette Nicole Brown is great community come on yeah but it's just like they weren't given the the stuff to work with here oh they're very empty characters yes even the whole like thing when she did the cupcake sale and she's like vote for morgan all that stuff and then she's just like you're not supposed to do this let's take it down i'm just like what what this isn't anything like this i don't feel this i don't feel It just feels cringy. Yeah. Yeah, there is unfortunately a little bit of a cringe element to it. I was trying to think other than James Marsden, who you're right, is not in it enough where the humor points were. And I think some of the songs have some funny things in them. I do. I always I like songs. You know, these aren't like memorable songs by any stretch of the imagination. But it's it's fun to see Amy Adams dancing with a large group of people in a courtyard. Like that's that's fun for me. The fact that she really did like take voice lessons to be able to sing this stuff. Some of the stuff she's singing is like she's really talented. She's, you know, found a.

And of course, she's in a movie with Idina Menzel. How do you stand up to Idina Menzel? Yeah, Idina's song is the best part of the movie. The one with the memories, right? That was my favorite part. You think that's Oscar non-worthy? I think it is. Yes. Because it gave me... That was the one point in the film where I kind of got chills. I will tell you, I was struggling to pay attention in this movie. And more so halfway through. First half, I was in it. And then when they do the...

spell whatever i'm like oh no i hate this and then um adina's song pulled me back like i was on my phone and i was like what's this now and i was getting like like the chills and i was like oh i don't know if it's her i mean she she is phenomenal she could sing the phone book and i would be in trance but that song like was with the memories and everything i love that part that was my favorite part yeah maybe oscar nunez but maybe laugh a couple times you know like he you know he had a couple funny lines i thought um but overall yeah beyond james marsden just nailing that character um there just wasn't a lot to laugh at He wasn't as good as James Marston, but I think that Patrick Dempsey, whenever he was trying that character, it got a few chuckles out of me, but it was either... It's just he's not that good at it. No, I thought that's what made me cringe too, is I could tell he was trying to be like James Marston in the last film, and I was like, oh, this is failing. Yeah, Prince Patrick Dempsey or whatever he was in that world was the cringiest part of the movie for me. I was just like, nope, it's not working. Oh, that was the cringiest part for you? Well, it was up there. I was like, I could see what he was trying to do, and I was like, okay with it, but really it was the three, you know...

evil, I guess they weren't witches, but, you know, close enough. No, you're right, actually, Andrew, I agree with that. My biggest pro for the movie, which you guys did mention, is Amy Adams, and maybe it's the fact that I have watched the first one and this one back-to-back, but I got the sense that she is somehow able to fully embody all of these Disney princess characteristics in a very convincing way. Like, I can't imagine how difficult it must be to fully embody the traits of specific animated characters and then make them believable in a live-action performance. but she did. So kudos to you that that's really, really impressive. And I don't know if it's just because Disney has a patent on fairytale whimsy and wonder, but it felt so real. The magic felt so real and like loving, even like even the darkest magic that's in this reminded me of all those, you know, animated Disney films I watched growing up. I'm like, Oh yeah, this reminds me of a Maleficent or Oh yeah, that reminds me. But it's still, it brought a smile to my face whenever I saw that. So I think that's why I can't say I didn't like this movie because it did make me smile. And I'm not, I'm not upset that I watched it.

What else do we want to talk about with Disenchanted? Aside from how perfect the title is for our response to this movie. Oh, that's savage. Did anyone feel like Patrick Dempsey almost felt like useless in this movie or not as connected? I felt like he was a little bit like they were – I don't know. I just felt like obviously since it was more about her relationship with her stepdaughter that they kind of – they were forcing trying to make Patrick Dempsey's character relevant to the story. And that might be why he was so cringy as trying –

i don't know i just didn't i don't like that they went with the route that to keep him in this his storyline was going to try to be like uh the prince like i was just like why don't you be more involved in this this is your daughter like well i don't i don't know it just felt very i was like this is this is what we're doing with you uh that was like probably one of my biggest problems susan i 100 agree with you yeah you nailed it like they they've they were writing the script and then it's as if they're like oh yeah, he has to do something, doesn't he? And then they were just frantically trying at the very, no, you're 100% right. And I'm sorry, I can't remember if it was Aaron or Susan, but you brought up the stepmother aspect of this. And I think the film focuses, and this is my biggest negative with the movie, by the way, the film focuses on the cliche of the evil stepmother. And I was kind of hoping that this particular story arc would have something to say about how in the real world, a stepparent can be just as real as a birth paternal or maternal figure. But the film doesn't.

want to focus on that which is a shame because I think if they would have done that that could have made this movie just as good as the first one like because otherwise I don't think this movie actually has anything to say right I think they cop out on that I thought that's where they were headed like the in the beginning I was really into it the first half honestly before they did the the switch there I thought we were gonna see like you know her stepdaughter wasn't feeling like the real daughter like you know I thought they were gonna go on their bond like we didn't and then when they switch it turns into oh no I'm turning into an evil stepmother I was like wait now you just lost sight of what you were going for or what I thought you were going for Yeah. I mean, I tried. I really tried to give the movie credit for the evil stepmom stuff because there's something it's trying to say about humanity, about the idea that we all can find ourselves being a villain in someone else's story. Right. The idea that from her daughter's perspective, you know, there is something villainous about a stepmom. Like, you know, there's a reason that's a trope. Right. The evil stepmom. And so the idea that to think about how you.

become less of a villain to the people who you may appear to be a villain to is a really interesting thing to think about. And, you know, who and whose narrative am I a villain? You know, and the case is as a human being, probably someone's probably more than one. Someone's you're the villain in their story. And why is that? And what can I do to, you know, reclaim that narrative? What can I do? You know, we shouldn't all go around.

you know, trying to be the hero in everyone else's story. That's not our job. Our job is to be, in my opinion, find purpose in being the best version of ourself. We can be according to our worldview and how we see the world and what it means to be a good human. And that is an interesting philosophical conversation that this movie doesn't have an ounce of energy to give to. Like, it just lays it right there in the text one or two times without really exploring it. But I think that was the...

I think that was the goal. I think the goal was to find a way through that topic. It's just trying to do too many other things to really spend a lot of time there, in my opinion. So, yeah. But that's there, right? It's there. And it certainly could be could be meaningful to some people. So, yeah, which at the end of the day, you know, that's not bad. That's good. And this is one of those movies where I just go, you know, I'm glad it's there. I'm glad people who like Enchanted have a way to kind of carry on this story. It just sits on Disney Plus. And if you want to check it out, check it out. Like, it's I don't know. It's fun that we live in a world where movies don't have to be award contenders to have a positive place in somebody's life, you know, just to be like, yeah, we'll throw this on and watch it with the kids tonight, you know, kind of thing. I think it helps that it's a streaming film. I don't know if we're trying to tell people to go pay.

to go watch it at the theaters necessarily. Well, I'm not even telling people to go stream it on Disney+. I'm just saying it's nice that it exists as something as a choice, that you and your significant other, you and your family, you and your kids, you and your parents, whatever, have an opportunity to go, hey, let's watch that Disenchanted movie tonight and just have a good time together. It's not one of those movies that I think you'll come away from going, oh, that was terrible. Why did we spend two hours watching that? Which, by the way, it is...

a two-hour movie. It is a two-hour movie. It felt really long. Yeah. So to contradict myself right in the middle of saying, hey, maybe watch it. Yeah, it is two hours long. But yeah, I'm glad these movies exist. I really am. I am for a world where mediocre movies can exist for the joy of some people who are not me. So yeah, that's where I land. Just put it on the DVD case. Put it on the Blu-ray case. Aaron Dicer. Glad this movie exists for people that aren't him. That'll work well for promotion. Any final thoughts? No post-credit scene. If you haven't seen the first one, definitely check it out.

I thought there was a... No, there wasn't, huh? No, you're right. The first one had one, right? I can't remember now. I can't either. But I think the only thing that's going on during the credits is some background effects and stuff like that, but no actual scene. Susan, did you have anything else you wanted to mention? Not really. I mean, like I said, it's okay if you want to keep watching it. I mean, I was just such a fan of the first one, so I think that was why. It didn't have the magic of the first one for me. But I did really enjoy that song, and I do think Amy Adams is incredible and James Marsden. So, yeah, it's fine.

It's okay. Yeah, I agree. That's your DVD box title. It's okay. That's right. It's okay. Yeah. Yeah. I think I don't really have much else to say. There's nothing I feel like really needs to be brought out. I had a time. I had a time. You had a time. I had a time. Well, it didn't help that right after I watched it, I watched Spirited. And I know maybe that's not as much of a kid's movie. Oh, that's the Ryan Reynolds. Ryan Reynolds and Will Ferrell. And I enjoyed that far more. Oh, nice.

Well, there you go. That's my one last thing. I haven't seen Spirited, so I'll watch that. Okay. All right. Before I move on, I just want to let you know we appreciate our Sif Pop members so much. We love doing extra content for you guys, by the way. We had a great conversation about the menu, and I will mention this here because you may be wondering, why aren't you reviewing the menu this week? The menu came out. We reviewed the menu on this podcast several weeks ago because I got a chance to see it at a film festival a while back, and so we did a full review then. However, if you're curious to hear Andrew's thoughts on it or Susan's thoughts on the menu or my extended thoughts on the menu because it is clearly a movie I loved.

We have that in the members-only pre-show for this week. So what happens when you are a SiftPop member at a certain level? You get bonus podcasts most weeks, and those just show up in your own personal podcast feed, including ad-free versions of the main podcast show up in that feed for you as well. So if that's something you're curious about, maybe you've been thinking, oh, I'd love to support them. Maybe that's the thing that puts you over the edge. Whatever the case may be, just know that you're loved and appreciated for even considering it. We do appreciate the support we get from our SiftPop members. So check that out at Patreon. It's patreon.com slash siftpop. That's patreon.com slash siftpop if you're curious in checking any of that out.

All right, let's move on to the best ever challenge. We are going to look at the best ever movies in a particular category. The category of this week is best ever she movies. These are movies with the word she in the title. And be creative. Have fun. Doesn't have to be the actual word she. It can be hidden inside another word. In fact, I don't even have one in my top five that is the actual word she. So all mine are hidden. But yeah, so we'll get into it. We'll go from number five to number one. And of course, if you have one higher.

It will get trumped, and we'll talk about it at the highest part of the ranking. All right. Susan, why don't you kick us off? What's your number five? I'll be surprised if you guys know what this is, but it's called She Gets What She Wants. It was also called Slap Her, She's French, like the original title. It's a weird title. Yeah, and then it changed to She Gets What She Wants.

It's, yeah, it stars Piper Perabo, which, and it had Trent Ford in it. But basically it's kind of like a, this family with this popular girl, they take in a foreign exchange student who essentially ends up wanting to be like a popular girl and like take over her life. You're going to see a lot of rom-coms and comedies on my list. This was a, I think this actually was a TV movie maybe. And then eventually it was a rental for me. I think I like repeated, this is a very easy rewatch for me. It's just fun. I love movies like these.

Nice. I've never heard of this. Yeah, no, I know. I would have been shocked. I would have been shocked. It's amazing.

I will go next with my number five. I think a movie that fits in well with, she said, Bombshell. I think I enjoyed more than most. Kind of deals with very similar topic and has some really incredible performances in it. This movie did not make the choice that she said made where the famous people are not shown. It definitely has people playing famous people. What are you talking about? That was Megyn Kelly. You know what? It really appeared to be. So, yeah, Bombshell is in at my number five. I really like that movie.

Andrew, what do you have at number five? I had Bombshell on my list of movies to watch last night because I was wanting to put it on this list in case it was good enough, and I did not get around to it. Oh, okay. I thought you were going to say, and it was not good enough. No, no, no, no, no. Honestly, though, but every single time I see a screenshot of Charlize Theron, and I'm like, that's Megyn Kelly. It's crazy. She's so incredible, yeah. But my number five is a little old Robert Zemeckis film called Death Becomes Her. This is a split word, she. This is the S from becomes and the H-E from her.

Yes. Kind of like fine. You guys really had the she's. Because I couldn't find any that actually had a she in it that I was able to pick from. But no, this is a fun movie. I mean, it's not anything that you would be like, oh, you haven't seen Death Becomes Her. You've got to see that. But if it's something that's on, it's a fun watch. I love Goldie Hawn and Meryl Streep in a movie I never would have expected to see her in. Actually, really, any of these people like Isabella Rossellini, Goldie Hawn, Bruce Willis. None of these are the types of people I would expect to see in this movie. But it's fun.

It's fun. I think you'll have a lot of enjoyment in this one. It is fun. It's definitely worth being in the honorable mentions for me. You ready to be very jealous, Andrew? You ready to be very jealous? Oh, I'm so ready to be jealous. I spent a few minutes with Goldie Hawn at the Glass Onion premiere because she was there supporting her daughter. Goldie Hawn was there? Goldie Hawn was there hanging out at the after party. I'm jelly. Just an absolute legend.

Was she nice? Yeah. Yeah. She was very nice. You can tell when she's in a crowd that there's a lot of attention on her. And so she wasn't there long. I think it gets very exhausting very fast. But she did want to support Kate. So, yeah, she was hanging out there. And it's easier when there's a lot of people that people want their attention. So, you know, like all the actors were there. And then there were people like Jamie Lee Curtis was there. Like, you know, there were people, you know, associated with the franchise. So, you know, there were a few people too.

you know diminish the throng but when you're somebody like Goldie Hawn like your gravity is just because you're a legend you're just a legend at that point and so the gravity kind of goes up but yeah it was great All right, on to our number fours. Susan, what do you got at number four? I just have to add, actually, Death Becomes Her used to be one of my favorite movies as a kid. Oh, nice. Interesting movie to watch as a kid. It was on USA, like, repeatedly, and I'd be like, yes, loved it. But my number four, honestly, this was one, I mean, it's good. It's good, but I threw that in because it was really hard. I picked Sherlock Holmes in 2009. Aaron hit the button.

Apparently you're getting trumped, Susan. There you go. So does that mean I'm next? You are so next. My number four is a very recent film. I think this is this year, in fact. Marcel the Shell with Shoes On. I love this movie. I cannot wait to watch it again. Just so sweet. It has such a specific tone and point of view.

and really digging Jenny Slate's energy and what she brings to films. So Marcel, the show with shoes on is great, worth your watch, and comes in at number four. Was Jenny Slate the original voice actress for Marcel? Yes. Yeah, it's her creation. All right, you're number four, Andrew. This is where I have the Thomas Jane Punisher movie. It's not a great movie. No, it's not. Kind of like Death Becomes Her, you know? Maybe I could have flipped these two around. Probably should have, in my opinion, but yeah. Yeah, well, I think it's more along the lines of Death Becomes Her.

While it is good, it's not my type of movie, but I can always turn on a cheesy action movie and be semi-entertained. Yeah, Punisher, Jon Bernthal is the only one who ever really got it right, but he's not in a movie. He's not in a movie called The Punisher, so I had to choose the next best thing. There you go. I don't have anything to say about this movie. You, Susan? No. I promise that my top three are really good movies. Good, good. No, it's fine. People like what they like. That's fine. You can put a Punisher movie in there. But I know this isn't a good movie. Susan, what's your number three? Number three is She's Out of My League.

I actually love this movie. I think it's so much fun. It's another one that if it's on TV, I have no problem rewatching it. I think it's, yeah, it's a really cute rom-com and great message in there too. Yeah. Give skinny nerdy guys hope. Sure. That's what the message of this movie is, right? Yeah. Totally. No, this is an adorable movie. I absolutely love it. It's funny. Great cast. Yep. I like it. Good choice. My number three is The Fisher King. I have at number three. Robin Williams. Yeah. This would have been on my honorable mentions.

Yeah, I've gone back and forth on this movie, actually. I didn't like it the first time I saw it. And a friend encouraged me to do a rewatch shortly thereafter, actually. And I found his view on the movie convincing. And watching it kind of through his eyes, I was able to find a really deep respect for this movie. So, yeah, Robin Williams is in it. Jeff Bridges is in it. It's definitely willing to go to some places. And certainly knowing Robin Williams' story, in hindsight, it's kind of a...

a there's a lot of pathos to watching it you know um because of some of the things it deals with so yeah if you haven't checked out the fisher king um it'd be recommended for me that's my number three uh it's kind of hard to put a uh a genre like stamp on terry gilliam because you have movies like this then you have monty python and the holy grail i mean the guy does pretty much everything i i haven't liked a lot of his newer movies but uh no this is a good one this is a very good one and it should have been you know what take out the punisher move becomes her up and then put uh fisher king at the very fair enough fair enough uh andrew what is your number three This is where I have Sherlock, the 2009. Nice. It's a good movie. It's fine. Yeah, it's in my uncle mentions. It's because this was done after, if I'm correct, the Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman show had started. I think this came after that show had begun. Did it? Man, that's not how I remember it, but I can look it up. Go ahead. Keep talking to you. I'll look it up. But I love this portrayal of Sherlock as this spasmatic, almost...

undefinable genius. It's so fun. But I think that what makes this movie absolutely work is the fact that you have to have good chemistry between Sherlock Holmes and Watson. And I think that the going back and forth between Jude Law and Robert Downey Jr. is just perfect. It's so good. I think that they're just kind of reminds me of like something in Lethal Weapon where the chemistry between two completely different people work so well in trying to solve a case. And I think that the actual mystery itself is a lot of fun because I questioned throughout the entire movie if there was a supernatural element to it.

And I should have known, but it was just done so well that even I was, I say even I like I'm some specialist, but even I was like, you know, kind of, you know, questioning what was reality and what wasn't. Yeah. They released very close together. In fact, the movie came out December of Christmas of 2009. The TV show released July of 2010. So like seven months apart. So the movie did come first. Maybe I just haven't seen it. Okay. Yeah. The movie did come first. All right. So on to our number two. Susan, what do you got at number two? What I call a classic. She's all that.

Okay. All right. Yeah. I mean, that's one of the early, like that when there, when there was actually really good rom-coms and they were in the theaters, this was, I don't want to say necessarily like I've rewatched it and there are flaws as if I had to review it today, it would not probably have a good score, but for its time, I mean, I ate it up. I, this was such a repeatable watch. And I mean, what was that? The start of the take a nerdy for the nerdy makeover. Oh wait, no. Can't buy me love was probably the start of that.

No, but this was one of, like, if there's going to be a Mount Rushmore of, like, a nerdy girl to, like, prom queen, I think this is on, it's on the Mount Rushmore version. Right? Yeah. This is definitely, yeah, the female version of that. Well, because, I don't know, like, Can't Find Me Love was, like, the male, I would say. When did A Walk to Remember come out? Because that was kind of in that genre, too. That was definitely around the same time. Yeah. I think it was after, because I remember Rachel Leigh Cook actually dated Shane West, and they were dating, I don't know, but I assume it might have been after. But, yeah, this was just one of my favorites. Yeah. Rachel Leigh Cook.

Famous for being in, you know, rom-coms and stuff like that. This is her bread and butter. This is definitely hers. This is, and if you watch, I will tell you, if you watch the Netflix, he's all that, you will think of this as an Oscar winner. It was so bad. So terrible. And Rachel Leigh Cook plays the mom of the popular girl. And it is just awful. Like, I can't even, it's terrible. Yeah.

All right, my number two is an animated film, Stop Motion, Flushed Away, one of my favorites. Really, really dig this movie. Kind of one of the forgotten arguments, and not a lot of people think of it, but it is a blast. It's a lot of fun. It's beautifully animated, and one I would definitely recommend. So Flushed Away comes in at my number two.

Andrew, what's your number two? Well, it's in my top four movies of this year. In fact, we reviewed it either last week or week four. I knew it. While I was saying it, I was looking at your eyes and you had a little glinter like, I'm going to push the button. I'm going to push the button.

All right. How frustrated I am that we haven't had a screen or a DVD. They sent us a freaking screenplay book. Like I have the screenplay to this movie and I'm like, I don't want to read it. This is another one I saw at fantastic fest. Uh, so yeah, yeah. I would be in the same boat. Yeah. I do not, you know, I could definitely see being a number one. Uh, Susan, what's your number one?

Also in the realm of rom-coms, one of my favorites as well is She's the Man with Amanda Bynes. Oh, yeah. And Channing Tatum, I believe his first movie. That might have been the introduction to Channing Tatum. This was before Step Up? Yep. I never even knew who he was. All I remember was when I watched this, I was like, ooh, he is not a good actor. Oh, no. That was in this. He's gotten so much better. I feel bad. I mean, he's improved. He really has. His original, his first film, there are definite struggles. But still, he does a great, he's still funny in it. And, oh, my God, Amanda Bynes, best role of hers ever. She's hilarious. Nice.

Amanda Bynes was a huge part of my childhood. What was the show All That? Which was the Nickelodeon version of SNL. Yeah, so she's been in a thing or two. Easy Gay is one of my favorite movies. I love Easy Gay. Well, my number one has been mentioned. Banshees of Inishiran is number one, both because I think it's probably the best movie of the ones that I found, but it also has the word she in it twice. So, you know, it double counts.

I'm still resonating with this movie still, you know, months later for me, processing my way through the messages on friendship and what breakups mean and the idea of human nature to make mountains out of molehills, make very violent mountains out of molehills. It is, in fact, into our conversation really kind of helped me clue into even some of that deeper metaphorical stuff. If you listen to our episode of the show, Andrew kind of pointed me to some of the metaphors in here that. I kind of knew were there, but I just hadn't really processed them fully. And so kind of like processing those has even given me a deeper appreciation for this movie. So yeah, I really, really dig Banshees of Ed Sheeran. So I'm sorry, Banshees of Ed Sheeran. Yeah, that's what it is. I really, really like that. Andrew, what is your number one? I can't say enough good things about Banshees of Ed Sheeran, but my number one is a movie that nobody has ever seen, it seems like, because I feel like I'm always the one that's recommending this movie to people. Not only that, it's my number 64 currently on my favorite movies ever. And that would be the 2011 film Take Shelter.

Oh, yes. Starring Michael Shannon, Jessica Chastain, Shea Wiggum. Yeah, this is Jeff Nichols, who Aaron knows is like one of my all time favorites. I love that guy. He just his his movies like speak to me on like such an amazing and profound level. And I think this is the best movie he's ever done. The story of a man. It's very biblical in a sense. I feel like a man like almost the story of Noah. Like he knows like he has dreams that he thinks are possibly visions of this impending storm coming. And.

throughout the movie it's him trying to convince people i i swear i know a storm is coming please believe me you need to take shelter uh you know you need to uh and he's doing all this stuff but at the same time the things he's doing are for the protection of his family but also they're hindering some very important you know like known problems like the daughter needs surgery and stuff and he's like okay yeah we get a shelter but i need to build the storm shelter in our backyard so he's spending all this money on the shelter and you're like oh my god what is this guy doing i you you want him to be right but at the same time If what he's saying is right, you don't want him to be right. Right, yeah. But it's what I consider the best Michael Shannon performance, and that's saying something because I think he's one of the best actors we have. Man, as soon as we're done here, I need to put this on my to-watch list on Letterboxd. I have not seen this, and it sounds like it's right up my alley. So I need to check it out.

I'll just tell you this. I have a higher appreciation for this movie for some reason than a lot of people because I look on Rotten Tomatoes and IMDb and it has a semi-decent appreciation, but nothing to the level that I have it at. What is the Rot-Tom? The Rot-Tom says 92%. That's a good score. Then I did not look up the right movie because the one I saw said 63%. No, it's a 92% and a 7.3 on IMDb. That is not bad.

IMDb is a tougher critic than Rotten Tomatoes. Oh, for sure. The review bombing that happens and that kind of stuff. It's very comical, actually. And again, if you don't understand the Rotten Tomatoes number, it can be deceiving as well because 92% isn't a quality grade. It is a percentage of people that thought the movie was not bad. You know what I mean? Which is a different way to look at it. We only have a choice of saying fresh. Yeah, it's binary. Yeah, it's binary.

Yeah. So it's like, it's not like I wish they'd let you like do the score. They do. They have an adjusted score rating, but nobody really pays attention to it because most of the critics do give their like grade or. I do a grade. Yeah, I do as well. Oh, the actual review as opposed to the actual. Right. Yeah. So they do have a separate rating for that, but it's people don't often go by that one. Nice. Take shelter. Well, let's talk honorable mentions. Were there any.

It would have been Fisher King. I'll throw in Death Becomes Her because I didn't know that was in there. I love that movie. The honorable mentions will just be us mentioning the ones the other people found that we didn't. The only one that I had that hasn't been mentioned that I thought might be worth mentioning is Wedding Crashers. I know a lot of people dig that movie. Oh, yeah. I love that movie. Crashers. Yeah. Sure. I'll take that too. Sold. That's a fun movie. It's a really fun movie. I love that movie. Yeah. It is fun. It is fun. Well, there you go. There's the best ever challenge.

All right, let's finish it up with the buried treasure. What is that one thing in any area of pop culture that you want to make sure people know about? Susan, you're our guest, so you will go last. Andrew, why don't you kick us off? What do you want people to know about? Have you ever had a movie that you know is like remarkable and then you rewatch it and it just reaffirms how remarkable and you may have undersold it all the time? Well, there's a movie that was in my top 100 movies of all time and I was like, I haven't watched that in so long. Is it really just as good as I remember? And it was better. And that movie is A Beautiful Mind with Russell Crowe, Ed Harris, Jennifer Connelly, Christopher Plummer, and Vision.

I'd heard of John Nash whenever I was in school because, you know, all the math teachers have to talk about John Nash at some point. I actually even had a teacher who, whenever this movie came out, which was like 2003 or 2002, somewhere around there, I can't remember. 2001, wow. But every single year they would, even in high school, they just played it over like once a semester. And I'm like, okay, cool. There are two days where we break down A Beautiful Mind and we just talk about it. So I'd heard of John Nash and then I'd seen the movie, which was remarkable.

Russell Crowe is stunning in this one. What a one-two punch. Because the movie he did just before this was Gladiator. And while I think this is the better performance, I might have Gladiator as a better movie. But not to take away from... How do you guys feel about Ron Howard movies? I know Aaron is a fan. Yeah, I like most of his movies, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I like him, yeah. Yeah, I think that his portrayal of a man slowly losing his grip on reality.

It's done just so masterfully. And Akiva Goldsman, who is definitely a hit and miss kind of writer, he hit with this one. Yeah, it's one of my favorite movies of all time. I'm glad I rewatched it. I forgot how tense and like a white knuckling, like anxiety inducing this movie can be in points. But yeah, it's so good. So good. Yeah, I love this movie. I'm due for a rewatch as well. So I might have to pump up the rewatch list after I get through the 40 more movies I need to see in the next three weeks. Well, hey, if they don't send you any screeners, you know, you can always pop it in.

Yeah, no, then I will catch up on the 40,000 TV shows I need to catch up on. Yeah, it's hard to find time to re-watch stuff. We'll never get caught up. Yeah, no, never, never, ever. The last movie I had that experience with was Everything Everywhere All at Once. I did a re-watch on that recently for awards consideration. And that movie is, I thought that movie was astounding the first time I saw it. I am now in awe of that film. It's still my number one of the years. They didn't send a screening. Did they have a screener, did they? No.

The 4k is actually on sale on Best Buy right now. So for a really good price. So really good copy available if you want it, but still number one movie of the year for me. It is definitely closer to that for me now after a rewatch. So, yeah, that's a that's always a good experience to have. What's your buried treasure for my buried treasure? I had a lot to pick from because I'm catching up on so many movies. I decided to go with one that's on prime called Argentina 1985. So Argentina 1985 tells a true story. Imagine that. I enjoyed watching a true story about the trial in the mid 80s in Argentina, which you would guess from the title, where they basically put.

A military coup on trial, like election subversion. Now, Argentina had a past full of dictatorships, full of people taking power, owning the military and just running the country. Yes, a past. In fact, the point of this movie is since 1985, they have not had a dictatorship again. And there is there is this trial that is often seen as the.

The process that led them to this never again movement, which is this idea that we as the people are going to put people on trial who tried to do this. It is really astounding. It's one of those movies where you watch the characters and you just go, how would I hold up under that pressure? How would I hold up under the life or death pressure of knowing that, you know. People wanted to kill you if you were going to put them on trial. How does a system put on trial somebody who has broken the system? And it's really, really interesting. I would highly recommend, as always, watching the subtitled version, not the dubbed version. I always get very distracted during the dubs. The default for Prime apparently is to just do the English dub. I think you miss so much of the emotion in the performances when you do that.

So I would highly recommend the subtitled version. But this is a great courtroom drama, and I love courtroom drama movies. So Argentina 1985 is on Amazon Prime. So, Susan, what do you got in your buried treasure? Well, I have kind of in line with screeners that we had as well. And this is another Sophie recipient. It is Selena Gomez, My Body, Mind, and Me. I think it's that documentary that she came out with. It's on Apple TV+. And I was kind of like when I saw the advertisements for it, I was like, whatever, we'll see. And I watched this late at night, and I'm thinking I'd only watched like 10 minutes of it. And I got pulled in to watch the whole thing. I cried. I was captivated. I just think she is so...

raw and real and i feel like we see a lot of these um celebrity uh documentaries and i i they I don't know. This one felt more authentic than the ones I've seen before. She is okay with making herself look not bad, but like she doesn't mind. She's not trying to create a perfect image of like, oh, here's my struggles and here's my highs or anything. She lets herself look annoyed. There's a scene specifically that really hits for me whenever she's getting interviewed by somebody who's clearly not listening to her and is asking good questions. But like, as she likes, she's like, oh yeah, wow. She gives her an answer that she could easily like, okay, thank you. And she's like, okay, great. And like, she just like kind of cuts her off. Like you can tell. And she's like.

And she goes back to her French like, I hated that. I feel like a prop. And it just makes you in our industry feel like, wow, you know, like really listen to your talent that you're talking to. Like, don't just like move. Like, I mean, she just ended it. So, but it just shows a lot of the struggles with her mental illness and any insecurity she has and her life in general. So I thought it was really eyeopening and I appreciated her sharing that part of her life with us. I think it's so important to find empathy for celebrities because I think there is a real natural tendency to be like, what do you have to complain about? Right. Look at your bank account. Look at your fame. Like, why are, what do you have to?

to, you know, be upset about. And we know that a bank account and fame don't change you as a human. They're humans. They're just like us. It doesn't change human nature. It could change how you interact with the world. It could change, you know, money certainly. I think most people would say money, power, those kind of things really just allow you the opportunity to show who you are, you know, in a grander way. But I think there is real empathy to be found for what fame can do to people and how it can impact people.

Enough of these stories get told and come out. And I think we see the change in the pursuit of fame because enough of these stories get told and more and more people go, oh, maybe I don't want to be famous. Maybe the pursuit of the idea of my opinions and my stuff is important for everybody to see. Maybe that changes a little bit. And, you know, as somebody who puts a lot of content out, I'm glad I'm just like, you know, like the lowest possible.

You know, famous there is like whatever the lowest tier of fame is. I'm glad that I'm just there. I really honestly like sometimes I'll think, would I want 10,000 Twitter followers? I mean, Twitter is a whole different conversation to have right now. But I think, you know what? I don't know that I would. I think the couple thousand people who like to hear what I have to say or whatever is is fine. I don't like, you know, if that were just, you know, like my family and a dozen friends, that's great, too. Like, you know, it's it's just it becomes a lot clearer when you start to tell these stories.

That you get to weigh everything that is involved with what it means to be in the spotlight in a big way. And we all get to judge and react to our own participation in that story. And what that means to us as how we treat celebrity and what it means to celebrities is how they feel. So, yeah, I love this kind of stuff and that more and more of it is coming out. I think it's important. Susan, do you think somebody who only knows Selena Gomez through Only Murders in the Buildings would appreciate watching this? I don't think so. I don't know any of her songs or anything.

I don't think you need to know her songs, but knowing where she's – I mean, she started really young. She's from actually Dallas, Texas. So that's cool. But she started on Barney at a really young age. And I mean, I've always had empathy for child actors because I do think like we get so mad at them. But it's like – because there's a trend. I mean, they always hit a really rough spot and they go to rehab or something. And I'm like, well, imagine being exploited like just at such a young age and maybe being deprived of a normal childhood. There's an interesting argument that performing –

should be illegal in the same way that alcohol or tobacco is illegal under a certain age. There's an argument that fame should be a controlled substance and that minors should be kept out. Now, I think the only way this happens is if technology progresses to where all kid parts are just digital actors, which, sure, why not, right? That's interesting to me, so I don't know how you accomplish it otherwise, but there's an interesting solid argument that fame is a drug and that it should not be allowed to be partaken of by those who are still developing. Um, so, uh, yeah. Can you, can you imagine a world where we made that illegal to have anyone in your movie or TV show that was under the age of 18 or 16 or wherever we put it? Like, like that'd be wild. I mean, we're just so used to kids, but it's literally called a child labor. I think there just needs to be some sort of like boundary to not overwork them. And I think there's something exist. There are definitely child labor laws that impact the movie industry. And that's oftentimes why they use twins under a certain age. Um, so because there are limits on how much they can work, um, those kinds of things, those laws do exist. Um, but just the idea of how you would.

How you would find a way to legislate fame. That would be fascinating to me. I don't know that it's possible, but it's an interesting conversation. Yeah. Well, there you go. That is My Body, My Mind, and Me, the Selena Gomez documentary. That's on Apple TV+. Argentina 1985 is on Amazon Prime. And A Beautiful Mind is available to rent, I think, if you want to find it. But I do not know that it's streaming anywhere for free. So you can check those out. Well, we did it, guys. We did a podcast. Congratulations to everyone involved. Well done.

Thanks for joining us today. Force of Pop. It is part of the Studio DNA Podcast Network. You can find out more about other shows on the network at StudioDNA.media or by searching Studio DNA in your podcast player. Huge thanks to Andrew for hanging out again today. Thank you, buddy. You're welcome. Huge thanks to producer Phil for producing the audio and video show. Thanks, Phil. And thank you to Susan Kamiap-Stevens for hanging out with us again today. Always love it when you're on the show. Yeah, thank you. If people want more Susan in their life, where do they go to make you famous?

Go to thischicksflix.com. You can find me on my YouTube channel. You can also find me on Instagram, Twitter. I always say Google me. So, but that's the safest bet is that website. There you go. Thischicksflix.com. Chicks and Flicks both with X's. This Chicks Flicks.

Also, thank you to our SifPop members. We've already talked a little bit about that, but want to throw a thank you out to you as well. If you want more information on what it means to be a SifPop member, just a reminder, that's at patreon.com slash SifPop. If you would want to connect with us, that helps us out as well. And like the search ratings, those kind of things, you can leave a comment, a rating, or a review wherever you listen, whether that's Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever. And if you have an email you want to send us, feel free to send that to feedback at SifPop.com. And finally, if you're having a good time, your movie-loving friends will probably like it too. So let them know about the show and that listening is much easier than using a sentient blender without feeling like you're torturing it.

we will be back next week probably with Glass Onion I know that's doing a Thanksgiving run so we'll probably talk about Glass Onion next week and Strange World the new Disney movie is coming out next week as well so have a happy Thanksgiving and we'll see you then bye bye

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of SiftPop?

This episode is 1 hour and 31 minutes long.

When was this SiftPop episode published?

This episode was published on November 21, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this SiftPop episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.