Skip to content
39: National Pain Audit episode artwork

Mar 14, 2013 29 min

39: National Pain Audit

from Airing Pain Hosted by Airing Pain

t the launch of the National Pain Audit at the Science Museum in London, Paul Evans talks to people who took a leading role in its development about the need for an audit and what their findings suggest needs to be done in the future. For the first time, the Audit will make available to patients and healthcare professionals detailed information on local pain management services. Richard Langford and Cathy Price of the British Pain Society discuss the reports findings, including the need for more pain clinics to adopt the minimum international standard for interdisciplinary services. This would enable them to take a biopsychosocial approach to pain management, which, as Richard Langford explains, can make a crucial difference to patients. Cathy Price also discusses how pain clinics could do more to help patients remain in or get back into employment. We also hear from Christine Hughes and Jean Gaffin, who have both been involved in the campaign for better pain services, about the problem of inconsistent service provision and the need to work towards a national standard. For more information on the National Pain Audit and to find out about your local pain services visit: www.nationalpainaudit.org In this programme: Prof Richard Langford Cathy Price Christine Hughes, Secretary of Pain UK Jean Gaffin, Honorary Member of the British Pain Society Charles Dobson.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

The state of pain services in England and Wales: the National Pain Audit’s findings revealed.

Ready to play

39: National Pain Audit

0:00 29:19
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to Airing Pain, a programme brought to you by Pain Concern, the UK charity providing information and support for those of us living with pain. This edition has been funded with an educational grant from Pfizer Ltd. Each year over 5 million people in the United Kingdom develop chronic pain, but only two-thirds will recover. Much more needs to be done to improve outcomes for patients. That was the stark announcement by the Chief Medical Officer for England in 2009. In response, the British Pain Society, in partnership with Dr Foster Intelligence Limited and funding by the Healthcare Quality Improvement Partnership, undertook a national audit of pain services. And their final report was published in December 2012. I went along to the launch of that report at the Science Museum in London.

For those of you that might not have met me yet, my name's Richard Langford, I'm President of the British Pain Society, and it's my pleasure to welcome you to this event this evening. On behalf of, really, the three organisations that have been involved in delivering the National Pain Audit, so welcome and thank you so much for coming this evening. It's the final report which encompasses the work which took place in two phases, the first phase being an evaluation of, an audit of, the disposition of pain services around the countries, England and Wales, and the second phase was to recruit patients. who were attending pain clinics for the first time, inquiring about their history and comorbidities and their incoming pain scores, quality of life, etc. And then following them up six months later to find out what treatments, broadly speaking, what treatments they had and broadly some of the outcomes. Why did we need a national pain audit? There was a reasonable amount of pain epidemiology in the press suggesting the sort of range of percentages of the general population that...

suffer with daily pain or chronic pain but we didn't have a great deal of information on where pain services were placed and their composition in terms of staffing in order to deal with the pain problem which we recognized was quite significant with an estimated seven to eight million people living with pain in the united kingdom so we wanted to inquire about where the pain services were what they looked like And also there was very little information on how patients fared once they were referred to a pain clinic. So it was felt that all of that would be useful and very particularly what triggered this national pain audit and indeed was the impetus to the approval for the funding was the fact that it was suggested in the CMO's annual report in 2008. Chief Medical Officer? Chief Medical Officer, yes.

I would like personally, and on behalf of the community of patients in pain, with people living with pain, some of whom are present with us today representing patient organisations and people with pain, on behalf of them, on behalf of the British Pain Society and others, to thank those that were on the Scientific Advisory Committee, the Project Board and the Governance Committee. But I'd particularly like to draw attention to Dr Cathy Price, who was both a leading author of the final report. and also chair the Scientific Advisory Committee, and Dr Stephen Ward, who chaired the project board itself, both of whom are here with me now. So with that, I'll hand over to Cathy. Thanks, Richard. I haven't got quite such a loud voice as Richard, or maybe I have, but maybe my kids will tell me otherwise. I just wanted to run through some quick highlights of the pain audit to represent what's happening in pain management in England and Wales as best we can.

Successive reports from government suggested that we didn't know how well pain services were doing. When people tried to find out a bit about them, it wasn't clear who they were seeing, how many of them there were, and the outcomes from them. Patients didn't know how to find them, GPs didn't know how to find them, and so at the very least, some sort of geography to the pain services was needed. The reports recommended that we also found out a lot more about them. What have you found out about them? Quite a lot of them, actually. The main things are that they seem to be seeing people who have a very poor quality of life, much worse than if they had one single condition, so it suggests that people...

multiple health conditions. We found overall 161 different providers in England and Wales of those 214 different clinics. So some people are really scattered about. We also found that 28 primary care trusts in England didn't appear to have any pain services at all and perhaps they were borrowing from other areas. So it's a great big variation in actual services. There was an even bigger variation in the type of services. For pain services the standard is multidisciplinary.

clinics. And we found that in England, only 40% of clinics could truly call themselves multidisciplinary, a bit higher in Wales, about 60%. But that means that they're not really able to offer the full range of treatments nor get the most effective outcomes of care. So is your aim to name and shame or to kick people into action? From my perspective, it's to highlight where there's variation, to highlight where there is less than a good practice. It's then up to the people in those areas to decide what they want to do. But unless you name people, then probably nothing ever happens. We found that clinicians have been trying to get multidisciplinary services, and yet their voice has not been heard. We hope that the National Pain Audit will give that voice to them. Right, OK, we're not going to name in shame. Where's the best place to have chronic pain in the world?

It looks like somewhere around Gloucestershire and Ipswich are around some of the best services. So particularly the south-west and Suffolk areas seem to be doing well with pain services, as does the far north-east of England. So are those the places to go if you could? Well, I suppose they could be, but we'd hope that the other services can get to their level. If patients and their GPs don't know about the services, where they are...

who to refer to, what's on offer, and occasionally if they don't recognise the benefits that can be accrued from referral, then there is a significant issue for patients. And I think we recognise both us as professionals and patients and the patient organisations recognise that there can be serious delays in the time to referral, in the patient's journey from the first development of a serious pain problem through what... was on one occasion in a separate survey found to be a seven-year period during which the patient suffered their pain before they were referred to specialist pain services. And it's not unusual for these patients, this group of patients, to be sent from pillar to post. First of all, maybe with what ultimately turned out to be, but very well-intentioned, but turned out to be investigations, but necessary investigations, but they don't actually lead to anything that helps, a treatment that helps the pain. And also because...

Patients in this group often have complex problems. We talk about pain being a biopsychosocial phenomenon, so it has the biological aspect, so the actual mechanisms of it, the anatomical damage, the pathology that may be responsible for it. But there's also the psychological impact on the pain and of pain on the person's psychological profile. In other words, they may well become... depressed and anxious. They will potentially have sleep problems. All sorts of things affect their mental health and similarly mental health can indeed lead to chronic pain. So the two are inextricably linked. So there's the bio, psycho and social. The terrible impact that this can have on relationships, on family, on carers and indeed of course the societal impact, the costs.

but also, of course, for the individual, the impact on their ability to work or get back to work. So it's a very wide-ranging problem that our pain patients have. People reported that pain had the highest impact on work out of all areas, so we absolutely need to take notice of that. Part of the problem is that by the time people come to pain services, they come too late, and they've lost everything. We've started locally working with vocational rehabilitation specialists. They are going into local employers, trying to prevent people from losing their jobs and finding new jobs for people. This has been a new approach of high need in Southampton, mirroring some work done in Cardiff in mental health.

health services there. It's been very successful to date, and I'd encourage others to adopt that model. Other services have worked collaboratively with other vocational rehabilitation specialists, and they do see a difference. So one of our recommendations is that services need to do this. It would appear to me that if pain is a biopsychosocial disease, then if you don't address all three issues in your pain service, then it falls short.

Absolutely. And for many people, I think this is the confusion for many people in primary care population, people manage pain, they learn to manage it relatively well, and it's not troubling them too much. But when it starts cutting into their life significantly, it starts taking over and impacts what we found highest on work, then on activity, then on social life and friendships, overall mental well-being. Then when it's got to that level, then you can't just try and treat pain itself, you've got to look at the pain and its effects. And a biopsychosocial approach is really the gold standard for doing that. So unless you try and do that with this population, what we've shown is that indeed the population is.

that which has got multiple needs, and yet services haven't got everything they need to be able to deliver fully effective care. It feels to me like many are struggling. Many people know what they should be doing, but it seems very hard to ask or to develop the need for that. We hope that the National Pain Audit will have at least highlighted that there is a need for a biopsychosocial approach within a multidisciplinary model. The fact that patients are being pushed from pillar to post, does that mean that pain isn't viewed as the problem itself, just as a by-product of something else? Well, I'd hate to generalise on that, but I think certainly on occasion we...

might interpret the patient's history and experience as one in which practitioners again with all good intention focus on the disease or what they think might be the cause with obviously good intention with a desire to treat the root cause but of course if that isn't found to be genuinely the cause of the pain or actually there isn't an abnormality there because pain can occur either long after the original condition has healed up such as shingles or a surgery or trauma or other conditions like a stroke or whatever, spinal cord damage, that can lead to long-standing pain problems. And the focus may be on the original disease or the ongoing disease, for example, diabetes, without enough focus on the pain. So some people are very keen to see that pain is regarded as a condition in its own right. I think it is sometimes a condition in its own right. There is no obvious remaining or maybe no cause ever that can be identified for it. That doesn't mean the pain isn't real. It's very real. Equally, there can be a condition that is ongoing where the pain is indeed a symptom, if you like, of...

I'm a pain doctor, but it can be a symptom, if you like, of somebody else's disease, like a diabetologist, a diabetes doctor's disease. Absolutely, the diabetes has to be addressed. But the message I would like to get out is that whether we regard pain as a condition in its own right or not, pain should always be addressed in its own right. That regardless of the patient's other conditions, pain needs to be addressed. And while trying to improve the patient's physical or mental health, the pain itself needs to be treated. In fact, it's the most common reason for a patient to go and see a doctor. But mystifyingly, it's also pretty common that patients come away with everything being managed except the pain.

I'm Christine Hughes. I'm the Secretary and a Trustee of Pain UK, an umbrella organisation that represents those charities for which pain is a significant part of the condition that they represent. Now you're here at the launch of the National Pain Audit Report tonight. Were you surprised at the paucity of pain management services throughout the UK? I wouldn't say I was surprised, Paul, because having worked in this field now for seven or eight years, I realised how poor they are. But yes, when I started I was shocked and I haven't seen a vast improvement over those six years. I think there's more awareness and I think there's people working extraordinarily hard like the BPS and the CPPC to improve services and raise awareness. But it's not happening fast enough for the number of people who do suffer appalling pain and who often aren't asked about it.

What do you think the next step should be for the report writers or the report publishers? The thing that is important is to be able to go nationwide, if you like, and the only way we're going to do that is if NICE do take up the quality standard and provide guidance. And then we will have a national standard that people could then hold up to commissioning bodies and ask them, you know, basic question, why aren't you providing this? And so I think that is probably where this has to go. Now, you're a volunteer for Paine UK.

Which is an umbrella organisation, if you like, covering people like Pain Concerned. Yes, we've got 23 full-member charities, which range from quite big charities like Arthritis Care, right through to very small ones like Volful Pain or Pelvic Pain, who are really almost one-man charities. Our average charity has, I must get this right, but I think it's 5.6 full-time members of staff. But I think the majority of them actually have less than one full-time member of staff. So these are charities where people are working extremely hard, mainly using volunteers, and they can't...

hit all the buttons, which is why it's very important that we hit pain for them. I'm talking about things like the Polio Federation, I'm talking about the Limnless Association, I'm talking about the Spinal Injury Association, as well as lupus and fibromyalgia and rheumatoid arthritis. And these are all people who should be affected by the National Pain Audit Report? Yes, they should. It will help all of them, even though most of these charities are fighting very hard for services for their particular condition. If you've got endometriosis, you want somebody to be fighting for a better understanding of that. But at the same time...

There will be pain that will not be resolved just by treating endometriosis, and for those people, these services that the pain auditor has highlighted are really, really important, and that goes for every condition I've mentioned. If you lose a limb through diabetes or an accident or whatever, you have phantom pain, or you may have appalling post-operative pain, and you need good pain services to deal with that, and that is not directly linked to not having a leg, which might be much more about having a good prosthesis than anything else. So, yes, it's something that overrides nearly every long-term condition, and we need both things running alongside, good services for rare long-term conditions, as well as good pain services. The thing that stuck out for us was really people reported their quality of life with pain. The Europol score of 0.4 is very low indeed. What that's telling us is that people have got many health problems and that it's on a par with those sorts of conditions, long-term severe neurological conditions and forms of dementia.

In terms of people's general experience of life, people come to specialist services. One of the things that came out from the audit is the high health care use that patients have before they come to a clinic. We found 16% of patients have been to A&Es, which was much higher than we were expecting. After they've been to a service, it dropped down to 9%. Hospital visits are very costly, especially on schedule care visits. And so to me, that really could potentially pay for a service in itself if we were able to address those emergency visits. It's very hard to create a case of need when the majority of care force is social care, and we shouldn't really have the divide that we do. However, pain services exist within health services, and we have to create the...

case of need from within the health needs. If people are frequently attending hospital that suggests that their needs are not well met and it's expensive because poor quality care costs more and I think we can have sufficient there to demonstrate we can cover costs. And the other thing is that when I go to my GP he gets paid for my diabetes but he doesn't get paid for my pain. Absolutely right. It's been a source of quite great frustration, really, that we've not been able to get some sort of quality and outcomes framework registered for pain. I think that's because it's been very hard to define and set some reasonable quality standards. I'm hoping that the quality standards that we've developed with the National Pain Audit can be highlighted to NICE, and indeed that's what we've recommended to NICE, and that those over time can be incorporated into QAF or whatever succeeds QAF in the future.

My name's Jean Gaffin, and I've been hanging around the pain world for quite some time. I first got interested about 25 years ago, 24 years ago, when I became Chief Executive of Arthritis Care, where I was constantly, constantly, constantly meeting people living with the pain of rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis. Nobody bothered very much. Then I went to work in the hospice movement, where dealing with pain was a priority. When I finished that job, I started an advert for the chair of a patient liaison committee of the Pain Society, and I've been hanging around pain ever since, trying to increase understanding of it, increase the management of it.

through the Chronic Pain Policy Coalition, get parliamentarians involved, so now we've got an all-party group on pain. So a very sort of mishmash, really, of concern and interest. Now, we're at the National Pain Audit launch this evening. What were your reactions to it? I think it is an incredibly important piece of work, not just because it's examination of how many pain clinics there are, how few there are, really, relative to the need of the population, because they've done this very important research. Nothing new, but just reinforcing much more scientifically, perhaps, than we've done it before, just what the burden of pain is to people living with chronic pain in terms of work, in terms of quality of life and so on. And I gather that there can be more statistics coming out from...

another national survey, and I hope in the end we'll build up a real head of steam, not easy in this world of cuts, to try and meet the needs of people living in chronic pain, which has been under-managed for so long. What surprised me was that the people who wrote this report, the British Pain Society, they had trouble in finding out all these statistics. Where do we patients stand on this? Absolutely. You know, the signposting of services is minimal. I happen to be a trustee of my local hospice, and we had a clinical governance meeting.

in which two cases were brought to our attention, where there was an inappropriate referral to the hospice. These were two patients, not talking about the last weeks or months of life, two patients who were in such pain the GP couldn't know how to cope and there was no pain service that the GP knew about in the area. And so they ended up at an outpatient's appointment with a hospice doctor rather than in a proper pain service. I'm sure our doctor dealt with it very well, by the way, extremely well, I'm sure. But that isn't quite the point, because that's not what specialist palliative care should be about, just pain relief. As you've heard, this is just a step on the way now.

This is the dissemination of the report, but the next step will be to make sure that it lands on the doormats of those who will hopefully engineer the changes that we need to see. You're really speaking to the converted now, to me, to other members of the British Pain Society, to other people listening to this programme who have persistent pain. What about the people who can really affect our lives, the politicians? What are they going to do about it? Well, I think they need to answer that. We are leaving no stone unturned in terms of trying to access the politicians. We have sent the press release to a number of politicians who sit on the Chronic Pain all-party parliamentary group for Chronic Pain. We may have the launch this evening and the publication of the report with release by the Department of Health and HQIP this evening and tomorrow. We won't let it rest there.

And we will be asking questions. We hope there will be some parliamentary questions in the follow-up to the publication of this report. We have indeed sent copies to the Chief Medical Officer and the Medical Director of the NHS in England and the Under Secretary of State for Health. So we hope in that way to continue our lobbying of politicians and policy makers, our contacts in the Department of Health responsible for drafting policy and advising ministers. We hope that through this continuous drip feed of data, information and canvassing, lobbying, that we will...

make our mark and we will improve the experience for future pain patients. I'm Charles Dobson, I work in the Department of Health and among other topics I have currently responsibility for policy on pain. What does that mean? It means advising ministers, it means helping to facilitate those things which will improve pain services for patients. So for instance I help to secure funding both for the National Pain Audit we've heard about today and also for the question in the Health Survey for England 2011 on chronic pain.

What did you make of the National Pain Audit Review today? I think it's very impressive. It's a wonderful piece of work, obviously involved a tremendous amount of effort from everyone involved, and it's told us some things we thought we knew already, and it's told us some things which perhaps we didn't know before. Like? The very low quality of life, on average, of patients who responded to the questionnaire and who attend specialist pain services. You're a civil servant, your masters are the ministers. What would they do about it? They have set out a new...

vision, if you like, of the relation to two ministers and the NHS at the coalface through the NHS commissioning board as an intermediary. So in the new landscape, ministers will set very broad priorities and the commissioning board will then decide where they need in particular to take national action. Now, one of the five outcomes in the NHS outcomes framework is improving the quality of life of people with long-term conditions. And all the evidence we have shows that you couldn't possibly do that without in particular helping people with pain and people suffering from musculoskeletal disease. It seems to be a no-brainer that the NHS Commissioning Board will want to take action on pain and on musculoskeletal disease. And it's very encouraging that they have, within the last few days, advertised that they want to lead within the Commissioning Board with particular responsibility for musculoskeletal disease. So that will address one key component of the pain agenda. That was Charles Dobson of the Department of Health.

Now, before we end this edition of Airing Pain, I just need to remind you of our usual words of caution that whilst we believe the information and opinions on Airing Pain are accurate and sound based on the best judgements available, you should always consult your health professional on any matter relating to your health and wellbeing. He or she is the only person who knows you and your circumstances and therefore the appropriate action to take on your behalf. Don't forget that you can still download all previous editions of Airing Pain from painconcern.org.uk and you can obtain CD copies from Pain Concern. If you'd like to put a question to our panel of experts or just make a comment about these programmes, then please do so via our blog, message board, email, Facebook, Twitter or pen and paper. All the addresses are at our website, which, once again, is painconcern.org.uk.

Final words from this launch of the National Pain Audit final report go to Professor Richard Langford, President of the British Pain Society, Christine Hughes and Jean Gaffin, who represent patient organisations. What surprises me is how little we actually know about what is available for pain patients out in the big wide world of the British NHS. And I think this is the biggest problem for patients. Information, I think, is king and people go to their GP and very often the GP... Well, one doesn't ask them about their pain, and if they do find out about the pain, probably has not got the kind of knowledge, because it is a very specialised area, to help them with their pain or know where to refer them.

Because there's so little knowledge out there of the services that you could actually have a very specialised pain unit fairly close to that GP and there's a good possibility he won't even know about it. So it is about spreading the information of what is available as well as what is good practice in the hope that we can then, in this new world of the NHS commission, new and better pain services across the country so that there is access for everybody. And I think also quick access because undiagnosed pain will become chronic and become a disease in its own right. Pain is now listed as a long-term condition in the long-term conditions agenda and so we hope. that with all of our efforts at raising the awareness of pain and indeed lobbying policy makers and politicians and now very much commissioners, that we will see that pain rises more in the priority list. I'm encouraged and have been for the last, I suppose, 15, 16 years by the accumulation of data, which hopefully eventually will be powerful enough to influence commissioners. Not quite yet, but I hope we will eventually be able to do that.

The Injury Prevention Academy Podcast DORN Companies Welcome to The Injury Prevention Academy Podcast with DORN!Tune in for your ultimate source of cutting-edge insights on workplace injury prevention, safety, ergonomics and wellness. Hosted by DORN and Cheryl Roy, this podcast is your go-to destination for staying informed about the latest news, trends, and data in the realm of employee well-being and workplace safety.Join us as we bring you expert interviews and thought-provoking discussions with leading voices in the field. Our goal? Empowering you to create safer, healthier work environments for your valued employees.🌟 Key Highlights 🌟🔍 Stay Updated: Get the freshest news and data surrounding workplace injury prevention, ergonomics and safety.🧠 Expert Insights: Discover valuable insights from experts covering pain management, injury prevention, safety programs and technology.🤝 Supportive Strategies: Gain actionable strategies to prioritize the safety and well-being of your employees.Whether you're a business owner, HR prof Pulsating Health: The PEMF Therapy Shift The Advisor W/ Stacey Chillemi Embark on a transformative journey with PEMF expert and author, Gary Woolums, as he uncovers the groundbreaking potential of PEMF therapy for enhancing overall well-being. Hosted by Stacey Chillemi, this enlightening podcast series delves into the ways PEMF therapy can effectively heal chronic illnesses, alleviate stress, combat body pains, and manage anxiety. Gary shares his personal success story of using PEMF therapy to conquer his chronic back pain, offering insights and inspiration for embracing a healthier lifestyle. For a deep dive into PEMF therapy and its benefits, check out the official website at http://www.pemfinc.com/ To enlighten and empower yourself with the transformative principles of PEMF therapy, order Gary Woolums' book "Recharging Your Life with PEMF Therapy" here: <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Recharging-Your-Life-PEMF-Therapy/dp/1925370887" target="_b The Lift for Longevity Podcast-Alleviate chronic pain, fix muscle imbalances, exercises for dental hygienists, injury prevention, strength training for dental hygienists Brianne Novaes| Strength Coach for Dental Professionals | Corrective Exercise Specialist Do you feel like you’ve tried everything to get rid of your pain, but nothing has worked?Do you workout regularly but still have annoying aches and pains that just won’t seem to go away?Are you afraid of getting injured, needing surgery, or being forced to find a new career even though you love what you do?Do you wish there was a long-term solution to get rid of your pain so you can enjoy both your practice and your life outside of work?Hey, I’m Brianne Novaes and I’m here to tell you that you CAN have a life without constant pain and having to rely on temporary fixes, but instead you can live a life that you love, have energy, and longevity in your career! I’m a fit pro turned business owner (and also a girl mom) here to help you get to the root of you pain by fixing your muscle imbalances and building the right muscles for your career through specialized strength training.My mission is to educate dental pros on how to take control of their physical health so they can build a st The ZoneCoach® Show Jim Fannin Bringing you extreme positivity on a daily basis, The ZoneCoach® Show gives YOU the opportunity to learn from the very best in the world. Join America’s ZoneCoach®, Jim Fannin, who has been coaching the best in life, business, and sports for over 50 years. This groundbreaking production offers viewers the rare opportunity to learn about the secrets of peak performance. Airing daily, Monday through Friday, around 12:30pm CST, the majority of our shows are LIVE on social media platforms with video. This gives the chance for viewers to interact directly with our host and guests. Become a better parent, sibling, athlete, employee/employer, & overall best version of yourself by tuning into The ZoneCoach® Show!

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Airing Pain?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this Airing Pain episode published?

This episode was published on March 14, 2013.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Airing Pain episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.