Skip to content
3rd Degree Byrne Presents Our First Thoughts on First Steps episode artwork

Aug 4, 2025

3rd Degree Byrne Presents Our First Thoughts on First Steps

from 3rd Degree Byrne – Two True Freaks Hosted by Tim Elliott

Join Brian and Tim, two life long comic freaks, as they take a look at one of the quintessential comic book writer/artists of the last 40 years, John Bryne. Each episode your hosts will pick an issue or issues from the best, the worst, the sometimes-co

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

3rd Degree Byrne Presents Our First Thoughts on First Steps

of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Starring Reed Richards, Sue Richards, Johnny Storm, Ben Grimm, The Thousand Men, Fantastic Four, united in their fight against interplanetary evil. Fantastic! We must prepare for Galactus. Do you prepare it? There are billions of living beings on this Earth. Their fate can be no concern of Galactus. We'll make it your concern. Ben! My Herald the Silver Surfer is always at my point of landing. This is strange.

Hello, and welcome to a special edition of Third Degree Burn. I'm your host this evening, Kirk Greenfield, and I'm joined with the usual cast of characters. We're going to introduce them before we talk about what our topic is. First, we have from Texas, Brian Hughes. Hey! And Tim Elliott is out in L.A., I believe. Sorry, Las Vegas. Las Vegas. Hello. And joining us from Japan, I believe we have Nigel Spink. Hello, Ben. So we have four panelists today, and we have a simple... Oh, who else is here?

Chris Hughes. Okay, thank you. I didn't see you. I hadn't heard you. So Chris is joining in also from Texas. Great. Five panelists then. And the topic for tonight, well, I can't make my four panelists Fantastic Four joke now, but that's okay. We have four fantastic panelists joining me. And we're talking about the Fantastic Four movie and also some of the latest thoughts as far as John Byrne news from the web, the interwebs and what have you. What's your pleasure, gentlemen? What do you want to discuss first?

Let's let Brian, because Brian kind of spearheaded this, I guess the big news about Elswin. You want to let us know what's going on with that, Brian? Yeah, at San Diego Comic-Con, the Abrams panel, when they came up, they announced that X-Men Elswin is going to be published by them for Marvel. starting in April of 2026. And they're going to put all 32 issues in combined three volumes, each one being about 250 pages, written, of course, in pencil by John Byrne. Some of it inked by John Byrne. The rest of it inked by Paul Wills. Now, Paul was...

regular on Byrne's website, ByrneRobotics.com. And so when Byrne was putting the stories out there, he would go in and ink specific pages. There was an actual form out there for inking of else one. And somehow in all that, he's the one that got picked to do the rest of the inking. So there's going to be three books come out, hardback books with dust covers, you know, and all this was put together by Chris Royale, who's like editor-in-chief, I guess, there at Abrams.

And so he just got everything together. He worked a deal with C.B. Cebulski at Marvel so that they could use the characters. And bam, we've got it coming. Now, there's going to be, you know, that he's not really completing the stories at the end of issue 32. He's just going to have a wrap up that he's written, you know, text kind of like what he did for the last Galactus story. So, but what this means is we're getting Elswen put out the way it should look, you know, the way it should be.

And it starts coming in April. And I think it's going to be $39.99 regular retail for each one of the books as they come out. I'm excited. Speaking of continuity, however you approach this. If you listen to the episodes that we did way back when Alistair came out, it picks up from Phoenix, the untold story, which was the original way that they were going to end the Phoenix saga, where Jean Grey wasn't killed, or Phoenix wasn't killed there on the Blu-ray of the moon. It's kind of basically, isn't it, his idea of if he hadn't left the book, kind of how he would have carried on.

Kind of, but, you know, it's been updated and peppered by, you know, 30, 50 years of, you know, thinking about it and everything. So, yeah, he's added a bunch of, you know, a lot of different storylines in there. He's pulled from Hidden Years. He's pulled from Hidden Years. Yep, from Hidden Years and other places. And, of course, a lot of Sentinel stuff and Avengers, Fantastic Four guest starring. This is going to be, it's going to look great. I'm excited. Paul Wills is an excellent anchor for it, along with Byrne doing whatever he's going to do with it.

So, yeah, that's what's coming. Is it going to be oversized like on the bus? No, actually, it's going to be smaller. It's going to be like 11 by 7.5. So, you know that DC Universe by John Byrne book that came out that was about 400 pages of hardback? We actually found it at Ollie's for like $10 at one point. It's about that size. Okay, that's a nice size, though. Yeah. About the size of a typewriter sheet of paper, or now they're calling it printer paper.

Right. I suppose. Roughly. I think it's A1. Anyway, it's something to be excited for. And I mean, you can actually pre-order it if it hasn't sold out from all the sites that had pre-orders set up. Abrams had their own and that sold out. I know that Amazon had it available. Mile High Comics. I'm sure that whatever Lone Star. Is that what Lone Star is now? No, no. Wild West. Mile High is separate, but Lone Star is my comic shop or something like that.

Yeah, oh, that's right, mycomicshop.com. And, I mean, we should be able to order it from our local comic book shop, Collected. It's next year, right? It's not coming out until 2026? April. Yeah, April's the first volume. It'll get reprinted. If it's sold out that fast, it'll get reprinted. Oh, yeah. I pre-ordered it yesterday on the Japanese Amazon. And if you pre-order it, you get it for like $3 cheaper, it seems, like $36.99. Well, I was looking. It was on for about 6,500 yen, which, well, when I converted it.

based on the rate of the dollar against the yen at the moment, it's a little higher than it should be. But I can't do anything about that. Those darn paper tariffs? I expected it to be dearer somehow. It's about a thousand more than it ought to be for the price. But things could change before it actually comes out. I'm sure there'll be a digital option if you want to get the Kindle or the... Oh, there was, yeah. But no, I want the book. I want both.

I'm wondering if if perhaps I should talk to David before saying anything here, but to see if he's going to be stocking it or if he's going to be able to make a group purchase for us, because I'd like he's been very generous to us and I kind of like to give him some business. Well, and he's opening up his brick and mortar shop here real soon. The comic ferret is going to be an actual physical store. All right. Not just online, but I guess we'll be doing that as well. So if I want to retire and move back up to Minnesota, I could work in a store. There you go. There you go. We wish him all the luck in the world. I know it's rough trying to open up in this day and age to open up a brick and mortar store. You guys saw when you came here to Texas, there's comic book shops everywhere. There's got to be a market for it somehow. There must be in certain areas. There's not a lot here, here in Vegas. We've got one or two.

Yeah, that just doesn't make any sense to me. I have no idea why there's such a massive market here in Texas. Because I've tried to talk with people my age about comics, and half of them, and not even half, very little, know anything about any comics at all. And if you remember, as we went to each store, they diversified in so many areas. Games of so many different types, card games and such. They have to. They have to. They have to diversify because you can't... Well, that's not true. There is one shop we went to that was straight up just...

Comics. Which one was that? I can't remember the name. Remember the guy who had long hair? We bought absolute Batman number one there and we bought one of the variant covers. Was that 181 or 150? I forget. No, but we went there and it was just straight up comics only. Nothing else. I didn't even see a Funko Pop. Or statues. That's the other thing that keeps those spices afloat. Funko Pop. I'd heard that you have to be diversified in today's marketplace to have more than one product.

So that you can have crossbreeding, cross-pollinization between different audiences and that otherwise you'll see a quick rise and fall in terms of business. But I can't describe the model for you, except in my experience, all the comic shops and we used to have a whole lot of them in the Detroit suburbs back in the 80s. They've all changed hands and or changed names. None of them, I think, still exist. So, you know, that's 30 years ago and things change, come and go. But I think it's an interesting marketplace and I'd love to see somebody do an analysis at some point of how that works or how.

how retailers survive and what they have to choose. Well, it depends on what, I mean, look at the kind of stuff you see at Barnes and Noble. They have games, they've got Funko, they've got Legos, they've got... And they've got all the graphic novels, you know, all the trade paperbacks. They even at times carry Omnibus. Yeah, but even for them, that area is shrinking because manga has taken up so much of it now. Manga has exploded. Yeah. Graphic novels are maybe two bookcases. Yeah. I mean, I buy a lot of manga in particular. And I mean, some of the manga they've got there is amazing in its storytelling. I mean, they even have DC manga now.

they have like a Superman manga or a Batman manga or a Joker manga right now. They had a Deadpool manga, which was really fun. It even had All Might in it from My Hero, which was funny. And it was cross-polonization. That's, you know, that's kind of cool. Yeah. But I mean, but our kids, I mean, and again, you're 18, but our kids your age are younger. Are they, where, where is their eye going? Is it going to manga? Is it going to that? Or is it just going away from it altogether? Because it's, they don't like to read. Yeah. That's what, that's my point. TikTok. No, because like I even read comics on TikTok.

Like, people will post comic books on TikTok, and I will spend my time going and reading through them. I honestly think manga is, it's the storytelling. I think at this point it's just better storytelling than what's in current, the big two, DC and Marvel. I would agree. I would agree if Absolute didn't exist, or the black labels didn't exist for DC, or the Ultimates didn't exist for Marvel.

Because what we've gotten in the new Ultimate storyline is so much better than what you're going to get. And with Wolverine and with Spider-Man, with the Ultimates, so much better than what we're getting in mainline 616 with Spider-Man and with Wolverine right now. Because they need to do a reset. And they're taking their sweet time doing it. Because the current Spider-Man run that's been going on for the past five years sucks. It's a booty. I hate it. And with DC, they had their Dark Crisis, which was actually pretty good. They've done the Godzilla Kong...

Justice League crossover, which was also really good. Surprisingly good. Yeah, I agree with that. I read the first issue, and I actually can't wait to read the rest of it. Yeah, and then the new DC Absolutes are phenomenal. Those of you that came to Texas, you guys got a copy of each of those, didn't you?

Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman number one. Yeah, and they also have Martian Manhunter Flash and Green Lantern now. And they're coming out with even more that I'm unaware of because I haven't gone to the comic shop lately. But I've been keeping up with reading them. And, I mean, like Absolute Batman, it's surprising me more and more, but in a good way. It's showing a side of Batman I haven't seen quite often. But, I mean, comics storytelling is still, in my opinion, a lot better. Because you're never going to be able to get anything like you do with the compact editions.

I mean, Kingdom Come, Superman, Birthright. Then there's also, you know, All-Star Superman. I mean, those are some of the most premier stories in comics than what you get with Batman Hush, Court of the Owls, and the compact editions just sell. They're $10, which is just as much as a manga. Arkham Asylum is going to compact edition. But you get the full story instead of having to buy multiple volumes of whatever manga you get. And I mean, well, I like My Hero to a degree. I liked Solo Leveling, which is another manga that was really popular. Their storytelling is a lot more linear and not as...

Deep as most comics, I'd say. You'll never get anything in manga like The Watchmen. You'll never get anything in manga like The Watchmen. I'm going to derail you right now and change subjects back to something else that is important. DC's putting out an Absolute edition of The Man of Steel. John Burns, The Man of Steel. And so that really should be quite nice. Actually, I've got The Absolute Watchmen and Absolute Kingdom Come that my family just bought me not till I'm gone. Those are really awesome. So I'm looking forward to Absolute Man of Steel. And that should be, I think, early next year.

This summer, we're blessed with having not only the Man of Steel on the big silver screen, but there's also, not quite a response, but a competing movie that Marvel has put out. And that's one of the reasons why we're gathered here tonight to discuss, since all of us that have attended, I'm sorry, all of us that are here on the call have seen the Fantastic Four. And so we're going to warn folks, from here on out, there are going to be spoilers. There's no way to avoid them. So if you have not already seen the Fantastic Four movie, you may want to pause this and come back after you've watched it because we're going to spoil it for you. Anybody want to tell us your general reaction to the movie? Well, Kirk, let's do a roundtable like we did. Since you started, Kirk, give us your impressions. Let's go roundtable. Okay.

Well, very briefly, I liked it. I thought that it was a very stylish 1950s, 1960s look at the public embracing superheroes. The emphasis was on family. And I think that was a different approach. I think it worked. I love Galactus's images. I wasn't sure if I was going to like a female silver surfer, but I believe they pulled it off. It made sense. The story beats were there. I was a little surprised to see that they went with the big storyline right out of the gate. I was very nervous about that, but I think they pulled it off.

I don't understand how this movie ties in with the preview that we got at the end of the Thunderbolts movie, but that's okay. That may be answered down the road someplace else. In general, I like this picture. I thought it worked. I think most of the responses I'm seeing online are people cheering for it. Those that are saying nay wanted something else and they will never be satisfied unless they get their version of the FF on the silver screen. And there have been a lot of versions over the years, folks. Brian, what did you think?

I really, really enjoyed it. I thought that the aesthetic of it was really, really cool. Very Tomorrowland, you know, 60s futuristic. Just the whole look of it was really, really cool. I, too, did not have any trouble with Shalabal being the Silver Surfer because it worked well with the plot. Just like I didn't have any trouble with, you know, the way that they kind of changed the background on Johnny and Susan. So they weren't just, you know, tagalongs on the ride on the ship, that they actually had a reason to be there.

Beyond that, I mean, there was so much Kirby feel and even Burn feel, especially where the Invisible Woman was concerned. I just really enjoyed it. I mean, I enjoyed it as much as I enjoyed Superman. So, you know, both of them just really made this a good summer movie-wise for me. Oh, and I was glad they brought back Kirby the way that they used him. Who'd like to go next, Chris or Tim? Okay. Well, I enjoyed it. I liked it. I'll say I liked it better than Superman.

Most of my problems with it are nitpicks. Overall, I don't have any big problems with it other than the female Silver Surfer in that if they were going to use a female Herald, why not use Frankie Ray and make her Nova? So you still have the connection with Johnny. You can still have the same kind of backstory. But now if for some reason, whatever happens to her at the end of this film, if in the future, if Galactus comes back, we could get Norn Rad. Maybe he's, you know, you're not going to get two Silver, you know, he doesn't.

When Galactus creates a hero, he doesn't ever give them the same power twice. It's always some different power. So that way it would open the door for, oh, well now Nova has died or whatever. Now we've got Norn Rad. So that would satisfy, I think, everybody. I agree with you, Brian. I think making it in the 60s was smart, and I like the look of it, the kind of retro, analog, futuristic 60s feel. It could have been a little more Kirby, especially with Galactus. I thought his home, his ship, or his home world, whatever we're calling it.

Tattoo. Tattoo was, look, I've heard it described as being Geiger-like, and I agree with that. I think that should have been just slatted with Kirby Tech. It shouldn't have looked like a big kind of dark, some kind of industrial complex. It should just have been Kirby Tech wall-to-wall. But that might interfere with him making Galactus a little darker. You know, he wasn't very bright-colored. The colors were right, but he looked very kind of mechanical, and his face had a weird, almost crosshatch kind of a texture to it. Like, I don't know what was going on there. But overall, I liked it. Like I said, I liked it better than Superman. I do like the...

The theme of family, I wish Reed would be a little more assertive. He seemed a little timid. And the other thing is, again, it's nitpick. I wish they had done something to the thing's voice. Lower it, make it a little gravelly, something like that. He seemed a little too mild. I did a little bit of background on that just because I was like, what was the idea initially? Now, the cartoon is the first one to sit there and make Ben have that gravelly kind of voice.

Stan had said that it was just, you know, Jack's voice. It wasn't modified or anything. So, I mean, it's just, you know, that's just something that kind of happened over the years. But what we got was what was originally intended. Yeah, again, that's, you know, I got a lot of nitpicks with the film. I don't have any big problems. That's just one of them that, it's fine the way it is. I just wish they had done this other thing. Yeah. Well, for me, it was Galactus that, oh, well, Chris gets it. Chris needs to talk. Nigel. Nigel, you go ahead. Okay, well, I think.

Tim's basically just said everything that I would probably be about to say. It's a case of like, as he said, yeah. Yeah, I enjoyed watching the film. I like the sort of the retro 60s look of Manhattan and everything. That was good.

Yeah, again, as we've said, the emphasis was on families and it worked. Yeah, it definitely had me. It brought back the nostalgia of reading the Kirby Lee Fantastic Four stories, you know, the early stories, the way they interacted with one another. Yeah. So that was good. That was like FF. Galactus looked very good. Yeah, we got the look of Galactus rather than a cloud.

Like Tim said, I'm the same about, I mean, I got used to the female silver surfer during the film. I thought, well, yeah, they're playing their part, you know, and it fitted in with the storyline. It was a bit of a surprise. I didn't take, well, I'm going to say I didn't expect the silver surfer to come to the rescue at the end there until it was actually happening. Because like Johnny was more or less getting ready to, spoilers here, getting ready to commit suicide to try and save the day. And then all of a sudden, of course, the surfer dives in.

and stops him from doing that. And I thought, oh yeah, I'd almost forgotten that she was still there because she'd not been seen for a while on the film. So that was a good little bit at the end because, as I said, that was a surprise when they supposedly got rid of Galactus and then all of a sudden he started to kind of try and crawl his way back out of that warp hole. And I thought, oh, didn't expect this. What's going to happen next? Is he coming back? Yeah, so that was a good finish.

Franklin was great. That baby was ace. I've never seen a baby act so well, as it were. So, yeah, I enjoyed it. As Tim says, though, yeah, there's plenty of nitpicks that I've got. And, yeah, Tim, you mentioned one I was going to mention about Reed Richards. As I said before we saw the film in that, I was a bit wary about whether I was going to like Pedro Pascal as Reed Richards. But from what I'd seen in the clips, I thought, well, you know, it seems OK. It just depends how he's going to act throughout the whole film.

And yeah, sometimes he was, he said the kind of things you'd expect Reed to say, and he did the kind of things you'd expect Reed to say. But it sort of fell short somehow. He wasn't Reed Richards-y enough for me. He seemed to not be confident enough as Reed Richards about his ideas. You know, we're all, well, we'll try this, but I don't know. Well, Reed wouldn't be like that. He'd be like, you know, we've got to do this. This is what we're going to do because this is going to work. And, you know, like just before I went to see it, I'd listened to that story time.

with the Fantastic Four story we did from 250. And just listening to how Reid talks and comes to his conclusions in that, I thought, no, it should be more like that Reid Richards than this one who seemed to doubt that things were going to work. And he needed Sue all the time to say, yeah, we're going to be okay. And that's not what I'm used to. Reid is the guy. He's the leader.

I think that the reason why we got that was because of Pedro Pascal and his own personal social anxiety issues. And so he was using that within the character. Because usually when you see people that have that level of intelligence, whether it's Asperger's or something else, they do suffer from other things that make them awkward. So I let that happen in my mind as I was watching the movie. He seemed to be very underpowered too. He kind of just stretched. He didn't form himself into shapes or even when Galactus was stretching him.

It wasn't being stretched that far, but it seemed to be very painful to him. Yeah. They nerfed his power so much. Yeah. He didn't have as much stretching, but yeah. I mean, they really nerfed. Oh, we got to let Christophe. But Nigel, do you have anything else you wanted to add? Well, yeah, we're just going to say, but yeah, overall I enjoyed it and it must have had some effect on me now because when I go into the kitchen to make meals now, I start by saying, okay, what's it going to be today? And start talking to Herbie.

The thing was good. Yeah, I liked his dialogue. But yeah, as Tim says, yeah, I was just thinking we could have done with the visuals being the same, but have Michael Chiklis doing the voice, you know, like James Earl Jones used to be Darth Vader. Or just ask the actor to kind of lower his voice a bit. We should have had Chiklis as the voice of the thing. Yeah, because although he said a lot of things that the thing would probably say.

sometimes he still wasn't thingy enough for me. It was too friendly with Johnny all the time. I mean, those two tend to fight in the comics. Yeah, or at least just have playful banter and fight decision. There was another play of that. Why was the love interest, and I know the actress, I can't think of her name. Why was that not Alicia? Yeah, make it Alicia. And for what we saw, I don't see why they needed to bother going there, other than apparently that character was sort of a tribute to Jack Kirby's wife, apparently. Oh, yeah.

And that's it, really. That was the only connection. Oh, and I didn't like the beard. Yeah, I thought the beard was silly. I loved the beard. That was stupid. I agree with that. Well, I don't know if they've ever done it in the comic because I've not read an up-to-date FF for years and years and years, but I thought, no, whose stupid idea was that? There was a comic where I did see that it showed where a thing would only age every year. He'd get to be...

Ben Grimm for like a week just a normal human self so over the course of thousands and thousands of years he finally aged up to where he was old enough to actually pass away and in that comic he had a beard oh okay well they also they also missed out on Pedro should have shaved so he was clean shaving then we could have got the I've worked all night in my lab read five o'clock shadow and Kirby always you know but that was yeah wasn't that so that was something to do with Pedro Pascal saying when he saw himself in the wonder woman film when he was clean shaven and he hated it so he said he'd never he'd never be clean shaven again well the only time that i recall we saw reed develop five o'clock shadow was in this the original galactus trilogy you know ff 48 49 50 and that that appearing well it may have happened later on but i don't recall it happening before that um until much much you know decades later when they he went away he lived in a cave he came back with a full beard you know that sort of thing but uh it was

I want to say shocking as this story was coming out to see Reed with five o'clock shadow because it emphasized how hard he was working and how he wasn't taking any time. And it led directly into a family bathroom scene where Ben is bathing, Reed is shaving, and Johnny's getting irritated that they're taking a break instead of attacking the problem. So in the comic I'm talking about here. And so it kind of worked, as I recall. But the appearance of the five o'clock shadow was something that Kirby drew and that the subsequent inker kept. That would have been set on.

And he kept it and he emphasized it and he made it look even more natural and real. It looked very much real to me. Sorry, Chris, I didn't mean to step on your toes. That's cool. That's cool. Okay. I think I'm going to be a bit controversial here. I liked the movie. I didn't think it was, it felt a little underwhelming in a lot of parts to me. I liked Ralph Innocent as Galactus. I thought Galactus was super two-dimensional. I had nothing to care for in his character.

I did not want to see him released from his hunger. I had no reason to want to see him end his suffering. I just wanted him to kind of keep going as Galaxx. I didn't want to see anything happen to Franklin Richards. I thought seeing the people get that way with the Fantastic Four being like, sacrifice your child and save us. I thought that was mildly unrealistic because why weren't there more people going against it? Why wouldn't anybody come into Franklin's defense? And no one put themselves in the position of the parents.

or you know susan storm or or reed i mean it that just fell off i didn't like that i couldn't sit there and watch that and actually keep a smile on my face because it shows humanity at a level of depravity that we really aren't at i don't think we're that often no no we're still like the guys in spider-man you know if yeah if i mean these guys are saying to people so many times you have to give them the benefit of the doubt you got to give them an opportunity a chance but they didn't they just straight up said freak you and your child well they they're saying that that's less realistic than everybody turning on Superman within eight seconds of that broadcast in a Superman film? They turned much quicker than that. Right, and Spider-Man did it as well. Some people did, some people did, but they had people like the falafel guy who did it. But we didn't see any of that within Fantastic Four. We didn't see that. We didn't see... We just heard the people saying that they should sacrifice their kid. Yeah, which, that didn't happen in this movie. But Reed should have just kept his mouth shut and just said, we went up there, we tried to negotiate, it didn't work. Don't tell him that he asked for your kid and he'd leave everybody alone.

But then that would come out later, and then that would really turn a lot of people against them. You'd have the same results. I think the conclusion of Franklin was a mistake. I think there's just a bigger problem there, and that is, what is Galactus' motive even more so? I mean, I'm not a prominent Fantastic Four reader, so there's probably things that you guys know that I don't know that might be coming in the future. But even so, the fact that I don't know any motive makes it less intriguing to me, and I don't care for Galactus, which just makes me sad, because I like the idea of what Galactus should be. Yeah, I agree. His motivation to quit, I thought, was silly, that he wanted to do it, so they could eliminate that.

really bothered me into the sense of the plot. I didn't care for it as much because of that. And I was particularly underwhelmed, and I told my father about this as soon as we exited the theater, by the clobbering time when he said the line. I was like, that was underwhelming. And it didn't sound right. And I can agree with y'all, and it doesn't sound right. But then again, I've been spoiled as of lately because I play Marvel Rivals, and I play the thing in that game, and the way he says it in that game is perfect. It sounds awesome. Every time he says it, I feel that nice little shake in my bones and that scratch on my brain that I like.

It scratches an itch that I can't reach. But this movie particularly failed on that. One thing it did do that I really liked, though, was its re-characterization of Johnny. His love for space was really deep. And I just like Joseph Quinn anyways. So adding his performance and his characterization of him.

onto that already kind of new idea was really nice. I enjoyed that. I enjoyed that a lot. And Reed did exactly like I said he would right before when we did the Before Thoughts podcast. He did the same thing that every man who is the smartest man in the world does and that he puts the world on his shoulders. And, you know, that's something that I called was going to happen. And even so, he did deliver a performance that surprised me in a lot of ways, especially with how he kept, his brain kept going to the worst possible scenario. I like that.

We don't get to see that a lot more with the smartest man stereotypes or the smartest man in the room stereotypes. It doesn't happen a lot, which I thought was fun. And it added a layer that I was excited to see. So, Dad, can I just say, before we went and watched the movie, did I not almost call out the entire plot of the movie? Well, I mean, it's hard not to because it's in book form. I haven't read any of the comic books. But it's kind of in public consciousness. We all knew what it was. I thought it was going to have more to tie in with Doomsday or Secret Wars. And this is another problem. That's coming. The other problem I had was I felt more threatened by Doom in that little snippet we got of him than when I saw Galactus. That really bothered me. Let's talk about that closed scene just for a moment.

So let me set the stage. We see Sue reading The Hungry Caterpillar, which is sort of a metaphor for Galactus, to her child. He wants another book. She leaves the room to find it. She comes back into the room and he's not where she left him. But instead, as she comes around the corner, so to speak, you see him being, and this is open to interpretation, he's somewhat enthralled or he's paying attention to a figure that is kneeling, a figure in a green cloak that is turned away from Sue. The question I have is, did he have his mask in his left hand? What was he doing?

He did have his mask removed. Is that correct? So we never get a straight on shot of the character. Was it Franklin holding the mask? I don't know. I remember seeing the mask. Franklin was touching his face. Yeah, like he was healing it or something. So we don't know where it goes from there. There's another thing I really loved about the movie is Franklin. I loved Franklin. I loved Herbie. I thought Herbie was cool. I love how they used Franklin to...

essentially be a conduit to say, hey, he's bringing Sue back to life. Or is he? We don't know. We're not going to say anything. But I also thought that the ending of what Sue did with Galactus, if they made Galactus as strong as he should have been, it would have made that moment that much more impactful. But they did it. Yeah, that wouldn't have been possible. That moment would not have been possible if it was Galactus as powerful as Galactus should be. That was the one thing that I felt about it was that they really nerfed Galactus on his cosmic powers.

And that right there was a physical being being affected by the physical world. Whereas he's not a conceptual being only affected by conceptual things. you could say yeah i have a question about what the ultimate fate of galactus was in this movie this is my my one concern my one large concern with the movie we we get the fight we get the fantastic four they're on the ropes the surfer comes in and helps to shove galactus into whatever that is a black hole a conduit whatever oh good he's gone he's transported somewhere else where they just sent the most deadly being in the universe somewhere else i don't think So my point is, they said that he got somewhere else. Yeah, he was transported to the edge of the universe. That's exactly what they said in the movie. And so now the thing is, is that, you know, not Doomsday, but Secret Wars will probably bring him back into the fold. I don't know, what version of Secret Wars do you think they're going to bring? I don't know, I'm sure. I think they're going to adapt the 2015 one. Yeah, they're not adapting the 80s one at all. I like the 80s one. Oh yeah, it's great.

Didn't Reed say... I think they would do God in person. Probably. Didn't he say that when... Well, they're certainly doing the 2015 one because they want to merge all these worlds so that they can bring in Miles Morales and new versions of people they want to recast and all that kind of... Doom, you know, the FF and all that stuff. Didn't Reed say when they were originally going to transport the Earth.

that they were going to go to someplace where collectors couldn't find them for a thousand years like they're so if he went to the same place is that supposed to mean that it would take him a thousand years to get back if you know obviously when to come back and take the earth so so they have a thousand years to prepare i guess but you know the concept of transporting the earth in its entirety through a black hole i mean it's a comic book plot and i accept that it's very silver age but but it really took me out of the picture like you're kidding the entire planet what sun is he going to place it around What solar system? You know, there were so many questions that my rational mind started to bring up. I was not particularly pleased with that. But for the sake of the movie, you know, OK, let's go forward. And obviously it wasn't going to work or it was going to get thwarted. And it was it was thwarted. But well, that's the problem with writing characters like Reed Richards. Do you explain what he's thinking? And if so.

Why? And you don't need to. You just kind of got to accept, oh, he's the smartest man on the planet. Oh, he's the smartest man on the planet? Oh, he's saying this and we can do this? All right, he's enacting this plan. Somehow we're on this train. We're going. And you just got to roll with it. You can't argue with it at that point because what are you going to be able to say against a fictional character who's the smartest man alive? Robert Downey Jr. is coming and he thinks he's the smartest man in the room. So we'll see how Doom plays this.

Okay, folks, we're coming to the last couple minutes of this show. Any final thoughts? I don't want us to get cut off, but we've got about five minutes of final thoughts. Why don't we go ahead and give it a rating like we did before? One to ten. Ten being the best, one being the worst. Tim, you want to start? Yeah, I'll give it a solid seven and a half out of ten. Better than you gave Superman. Yeah, so I enjoyed it more. If I had to watch one of these again, I'd watch this over Superman. All right.

I'll give it an 8 for its entertainment value as well. I enjoyed it. I'd watch it again. I too would give it an 8. I'm going to be pretty close to the same there. I'm going to go for an eight. I enjoyed it. I think rather than put it on a point scale, I think it's going to be a popular movie. I think it's going to be very well received. I think the naysayers are never going to be satisfied. And so it was a good summertime picture, a good romp. I felt good about it. I had a good spirited discussion with my wife as we came home from the theater. You know, even with the problems that we can nitpick, you know, I still enjoyed it for what it was. So a high eight for me. Chris? I'm on like six and a half, seven.

I did not. I felt a lot less... Excited about it than the rest of us. Well, I had less expectations than I did for Superman. And I walked in with a lot less expectations for this movie, which ultimately usually leads to you enjoying the movie better. But it did exactly the opposite of what I wanted to see from not just the Fantastic Four. Well, I did what I want with the Fantastic Four, in a sense. I didn't want to do what I wanted to see with Galactus, and I did the exact opposite of what I wanted to see with how they portray people, the people. And I thought that really took me out of the movie. It made me disappointed, and I didn't care for it as much.

It's coming from my son who really wants to change the world to a hopeful place. So I can understand that. So I just like when you write superhero movies with this kind of level of stakes, you need to show that when we're put in the face of danger, we won't alter. Not in our morals, not in our beliefs. And that's exactly what happened. And I think that's something that we need to change because a lot of us aren't like that. I don't think there's as many people like that as we want to admit.

I think what they're trying to portray is that the FF didn't falter in their beliefs, at least certainly not Susan, because she's the one who came out. And also, they kind of gave her most of the good big speeches. But I think for Joe Public, all they know is, hey, some guy's going to come destroy the earth and they're scared. So people do irrational things when they're terrified and scared. That could explain a little bit why they kind of turned on it in that, again, reach in his mouth. I understand exactly the reason. I just think that we need to see one day, one time, a story in which humanity doesn't do that. Well, I think that the other thing that kind of hit, you know, prevented them from going further on that was the runtime. The runtime, this is one of the shortest Marvel movies made, just like Superman was one of the shortest Superman movies made. And, you know, is it a trend that's going to continue? Because I'm like, I think they need to spend more time.

Time to find out. There's over a half an hour worth of footage that wasn't put in the movie. A lot of it was, you know, the opening montage of them, you know, Mole Man and all that stuff. They added a lot. They had a lot more stuff done there. John Malkovich's role as the Red Ghost was completely removed from the movie. You only saw one of the super apes. You get the same cartoon form at the very end.

Yeah. And that's it. But, you know, there's a lot of footage that was left on the floor. Hopefully we'll get to see it, you know, when it goes, you know, digital or, you know, in a, what do you call those steelbooks? You'll see it. You'll see it probably in the 4k or on the show up on YouTube. I will be watching this movie a lot because I still enjoyed it for what it was worth. Hey, Chris, have you seen the movie Contact?

Jodie Foster? Yes. Yes, I have. Have you seen Signs? Yes, I have. Okay. I just wondered if you had seen that considering your point of view there. Well, I think one thing this has up on Superman is the opening, and to do it in the talk show format I thought was pretty brilliant, is showing those little clips of them being the Fantastic Four. Like, okay, so we get an intro, we get an origin story in five minutes. I thought that was much better than the, you know, 30 years ago this happened in Superman. Right. You know, three hours ago this happened, three minutes ago this happened. I do have one question though.

Who was the cameraman that was in the middle of the fight between Reed and a super ape? Because that had to have been Spider-Man being the cameraman. That would have been a nice little addition. Maybe it's one of those floating cameras. Yeah. Yeah. Well, there's always that possibility now. So, yeah. Well, I mean, so have we covered everything here? I think so. About as well as we can. Yeah. And I think we're going to run out of time. So we better wrap this up. Okay. I'll go ahead and give them the other things. If you want to talk to us about this, write us at the Third Degree Burn Facebook group, or you can write us at our email address, which has got to get burned at gmail.com. Burn spelled B-Y-R-N-E-D. Or you can give us a review.

on Apple Podcasts, formerly iTunes. We'd really, really love to hear you. Just let us know what you think. Is there anything anybody else wants to bring up before we go? Well, I'm going to ask Nigel real quick. Did you get a Thunderbird's vibe from the Excelsior, that rocket ship? Yeah, yeah. Kind of, yeah. That sort of style. Yeah, yeah. That was kind of cool. Thunderbird 3-ish. Thunderbird 3. Thunderbird 3. Oh, Thunderbird, yeah. It was a bit more sort of sleek and streamlined, but yeah, the basic shape.

All right. Well, with all that being said, I think that we're good to go on now. So for third degree burn, let's say goodbye to Tim. Say goodbye, Tim. Goodbye. Nigel Spank. Goodbye. Kurt Greenfield. Good night. Christopher Hughes. Goodbye, everybody. And I'll say adios. Good night and have a pleasant tomorrow. God, that was like weekend update. It's clobbering time. It's clobbering time.

Thanks for listening. You can find us and many other great shows at tutufreaks.com. That's T-W-O-T-R-U-E-F-R-E-A-K-S dot com. Third Degree Burn is spelled with the number 3, R-D-D-E-G-R-E-E-B-Y-R-N-E and is part of the Tutu Freaks network of shows. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter. Just look for Third Degree Burn, spelled with the number 3, and burn spelled B-Y-R-N-E. Compliments, complaints, and recipes can be sent to gottagetburned at gmail.com. That's G-O-T-T-A-G-E-T-B-Y-R-N-E-D at gmail.com.

Drop us a line and tell us how we're doing. Until next time, this has been Third Degree Burn.

Frequently asked questions

When was this 3rd Degree Byrne – Two True Freaks episode published?

This episode was published on August 4, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this 3rd Degree Byrne – Two True Freaks episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.