Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rivki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. Rivki, welcome back. You too. Nice to see you. How were your holidays? They were very nice. How were yours? Mine were good. You were gone for a while, right? You were in Israel. I was in Israel, yeah. It was really great to be in Israel. I was there for Sukkot and a few days after. And it was just like really nice. You were in Teaneck mostly? Yeah, I was in Teaneck for Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur and then traveling a little, seeing friends over Sukkot. I actually saw your sister at a wedding last week and I was so confused. Yeah, she just came back from Israel. I'm like, Uri told me that your family is still there. But yeah, it's good to see her. Yeah. And Uri, I actually had a story that I
with. And she told me that not only is she a Talking Talkless listener and fan, which was, you know, it's always exciting to hear, but even cooler, she's actually a high school teacher in one of the local schools. And her school started a new curriculum on Israel and Zionism. And she's one of the pioneer teachers of this new curriculum and program. And she's actually playing for her students a couple of our episodes. Yeah, the If Not Now episode. And I think there were one or two more, and now I don't remember which ones. But it was, first of all, a really interesting conversation that emerged out of that. But it was also really exciting to feel like our impact is kind of getting bigger than I thought. Yeah, that's pretty cool. Well, it's nice to know we're connecting with the younger generation. What if she's like...
They were very bored. They were not interested. Yeah, well, I guess we'll have to hear back from some of them for their feedback. You mentioned our fans. We spoke last time about what to call our fans. And I kind of said talking heads. Our friend Nisa came up with that. Then my friend Amitai texted me after that episode. And he had another suggestion, which I actually thought was very good, which was Tach listeners. It's cute.
The hard thing about these words is that they just, I don't know if they lend themselves so well, but Amitai, keep them coming. The one thing that bothered me about it was I don't want it to sound like our fans are only listening. I was thinking that also, yeah. And they're passive in their experience. But at the same time, it does kind of flow, like talkless. Listen, yeah. Right. We want to try to build, though, a community of people who are not only listening, but it's reacting. So we'll see. Guys, if you have any thoughts, of course. Other suggestions, yeah. Please, please keep them coming. And I liked, one of the things that was fun while we were away is that we were able to start a little bit of conversation on the Facebook page. Our talk listeners, our talking heads, you know, they got into the conversation a little bit. So that was fun. Yeah, we did have some activity on the Facebook page while we were off the air. And it happens to be
the big topic that we were talking about three weeks ago is still the big topic that everyone is talking about. It's funny because I think at the time we both thought like, too bad we're not going to be recording because it's a big topic, but it turned out to be much bigger and longer than we thought it would be. Exactly. And that gets into our main topic of today. Over the last few weeks, one of the most divisive political climates in recent American history became significantly more heated with the nomination and eventual confirmation of Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh. Now, unless you've been living under a well-insulated rock for the last two months, you're at least somewhat familiar with the controversy surrounding the Kavanaugh nomination.
What started as an intense and strongly partisan debate over Kavanaugh's qualifications and political background suddenly took a drastic turn when allegations of sexual assault against Kavanaugh surfaced in mid-September, just days before an expected confirmation vote in the Senate. On September 27th, Kavanaugh and his main accuser, Dr. Christine Blasey Ford, testified before the Senate in a nationally televised hearing. After the hearing, the nonstop news coverage intensified, along with countless protests and counter-protests, with speculation on all sides as to who and what to believe, ultimately culminating in a limited FBI investigation and the eventual confirmation of Judge Kavanaugh on October 6th by a vote of 50-48. This is not the first Supreme Court nomination that has been controversial and divisive. The trend has been moving in that direction for at least the last 30 years, but things seem to have hit a new low with the shadow of the upcoming midterm elections hanging over this whole thing. So Rivki, what's your take? Which parts of the story do you think are worth thinking about and discussing? And what do you think the story says about where we are right now as a country? Big sigh. I don't even know where to start. This has been a really emotionally intense last few weeks. I mean, you weren't here. I'm sure you were still following incredibly closely, but there was something almost in the streets. I remember a few years ago, the morning after the election of Donald Trump.
I remember taking the train to work, walking through Penn Station, and it was all anyone was talking about. It was like you heard the people in front of you, the people in back of you, the people on the phone as they're rushing by you. All they were talking about was the election. It looked like there were ashen faces everywhere. In New York. Yeah, it's a very specific kind of world. And I really, truly felt that in the last few weeks here. It was one of the few things that I was talking to my friends about. Every Shabbat and holiday meal over a week and a half period, this was the topic of conversation. Wow. Did you have that same environment? It wasn't as much as that. Regular Israelis, some of them were talking about it, some weren't.
It's not nearly as personal to them, I think, as it was to Americans, but there are tons of Americans in Israel, and I was around mostly Americans. So people definitely were talking about it. I don't know about a constant... level of intense conversation, but it was definitely a lot. Yeah. At the day of the hearings, especially, which was, I think it was a Thursday. It was literally, I think it started at 10 a.m. and it went until 4 or 4.30. I knew it was going to be a long day, but I didn't realize how long. I remember I woke up early so I could do a couple hours of work before the hearing started. I basically watched the hearings all day. When there were breaks, I went back to work. And when they actually ended, then I worked for a few more hours to finish the day up. And the whole time, I was talking to a bunch of different people, following Twitter. It was like we were all just glued to this.
incredibly difficult and sad situation. Yeah. Well, so where do you want to begin? What should we start? Right. I guess the question that I keep thinking about that I keep, and again, in some ways, this is obsolete because he was confirmed. And in other ways, it's not at all obsolete because first of all, the Kavanaugh conversation is continuing, but also the larger conversations that have been really pushed to the forefront. The Me Too related conversations. Absolutely. Yeah. These things are absolutely not going well. And I don't think should go away. And also, you know, the whole ideas of innocent and proving guilty, all these things I think are really important to the conversation. So I guess the first question that I keep thinking about, and I'm definitely curious to hear your take, Uri, is this.
We don't know if he did it. Right. And I know you watched a lot of the hearings and I watched the hearings and we've both been reading a ton about it. We don't know for sure whether he did what he's said to have done. We don't know for sure whether he assaulted this woman. And if he did assault this woman, if he remembers doing it, we don't actually know. Let's assume for a second. We probably will never know. Yeah. In certain terms. Yes. Let's assume that he did it. OK. OK. If he did it, is he unfit to be a judge? Right. A Supreme Court judge or any kind of judge. Well, I would say any sort of judge. But meaning, let me explain why I'm asking that question. I sort of assume.
that we would universally answer yes. But I've also been hearing and reading a lot where there's this language, especially coming obviously from, you know, the more right, which I put in quotes, saying, you know, it was a long time ago. Kids who are drunk do very silly things. People grow up, people mature. I was a young, drunk college student. And things like that make me wonder. So I just want to be a little bit more precise. If we knew for sure that he did it, would that be automatically unqualifying?
So you're saying yes. I say yes. I say if he did something like this. Well, let me say it a little bit differently. If he did something like this and then reacted the way he has reacted, he is automatically unqualified. Well, you just added a whole other layer to it. Okay, fine. So you think if he would have admitted to doing it, apologized, and...
handled it in whatever the best way could have been, then you would not necessarily think that he would be unfit to be a judge? Absolutely, yes. I mean, as we've talked about on Talking Pachas many times, I firmly believe in the power of Chuba, the power of growth. I do not believe that who someone is at 17 marks them for the rest of their lives. And I believe that's true across the entire criminal justice system, which is definitely something that we could get into later when we talk about. You're obviously a very forgiving person on a certain level. Thank you. And very idealistic. I don't know if that mentality would be shared by a significant...
percentage of the Senate or American people. Well, that's what I would think. But then there seem to have been so many people who keep saying 17-year-olds, young drunk kids at parties, things like that. So I'm sort of curious to hear your thoughts on that. What I was thinking about a lot is, first of all, I definitely think that it's significant that both of them were in high school when this incident allegedly occurred. I'm not sure exactly what that changes or how that affects things, but it definitely matters and makes a difference as opposed to many of these other cases where the man who did the abuse...
was in some sort of position of authority in the world. You know, Kavanaugh was not a judge. He was not a lawyer. He was just a high school kid, and that doesn't excuse his behavior on any level. But I just don't know exactly what to do with that. So listen, Rifki, to answer your question, if these allegations were true, would that automatically disqualify Kavanaugh as a Supreme Court justice? My inclination is to say yes, but I also am slightly ambivalent because I really just don't feel like I have a good grasp on what is the precedent, what are the legal rules of how to treat things like this.
How do we understand the fact that he was a minor at the time of the alleged incident? Like, I just don't know how all of these things are supposed to play into it. All we have really, for most people, including myself and I think you, is like our intuitions of what feels right and what feels like too far. But I don't know if that's really the most honest or fair way of approaching it. I just don't know. I think that's true. Something that I think we often as a culture lean on is the law. We talk about, oh, this person's a minor and this person isn't. And I think to a certain extent, I understand why that is, right? We shouldn't be talking about an eight-year-old the same way we're talking about a 22-year-old, right? That makes complete sense. But I think it gets fuzzy when we talk about someone who's 17 and a half versus 18, right? Especially with sexual things. Kids are kids, right? But I think also...
more fundamentally, and this is part of the discussion, more fundamentally is what they do with the knowledge beyond that. And if we have someone who committed atrocious acts when they were 17, and when they were 50, or 55-year-old Judge Kavanaugh, then treated the rest of the world the way he is for now, and we actually know that he is guilty, again, this is a complete hypothetical, we will probably never know, then I think it's completely telling, and it doesn't matter how old he was when he did it. Right, I understand that, and I agree, but at the same time, the legal system does have these cutoffs, and this is not a legal matter, he's not on trial. The legal system is so... So far away from the world that we've come to understand about sexual assault, about sexual misconduct, right? There are statute of limitations laws in so many states that do not take into account the recent research. So I think using legal frameworks for this particular issue is, I mean.
In general, I think the law hasn't caught up to a lot of realities. But I think specifically in sexual assault and harassment, all these things, I think that the law can't be the framework that we use. Right. I mean, I get what you're saying. I think if the law is outdated, then it needs to be revised. But to say, let's not even look to the law as a guide in this case, I think is a little bit of a scary thing to say. I mean, taking a step back a little bit, I think I would say, and tell me if you disagree, but I think you agree, that really many people on all sides of this issue have really been disingenuous about the reality of the situation, the source of their opinions.
standpoints on these issues. A lot of people are saying things now like, how could any woman now feel comfortable bringing a case in front of the Supreme Court because Brett Kavanaugh's on the court? But a lot of those people were actually saying the exact same thing before these allegations came out, only because Kavanaugh is a conservative, and so they speculate that he'll be bad for women, bad for women's rights. I think both sides are just not acknowledging how partisan this is and how politics plays into it. It's obviously not a coincidence that the people, for the most part, defending him are Republicans, and the people accusing him are Democrats. That's obviously a huge part of it. Yeah, absolutely true. And so I think the sad part is, you were talking earlier about, and this is something you talk about a lot, which I think is very...
blah blah like people just owning up to their past owning up to what they did making real apologies which we almost never hear from public figures and if they could do that we could talk about it in a different way but at the same time because of the climate that we're in especially around politics and politicians it seems almost impossible for them to do that so like you know the whole discussion about his drinking in in college and maybe high school also it just it's almost laughable and i think a lot of people were laughing about it maybe inappropriately i think it was in the orrin hatch um op-ed where he said people haven't been talking about alcohol consumption this much since prohibition and it's like yeah people are treating his drinking as if it's like they've never heard of college kids drinking alcohol before and someone who drank in college must be some sort of deviant who's clearly capable of sexual assault and it's things like that and the fact that the case only came up at the very last minute when Senator Feinstein knew about it and had it and was sitting on it for weeks. You know, if it had come out earlier, the investigation could have been more thorough. The Republicans may have had time to put somebody else in and still had a vote before the midterms. Obviously, there's tons of really partisan stuff on the other side also. But I think because of that climate, it became almost impossible to have a real discussion and debate.
about the issue without it being about politics. Yeah, I think that's absolutely true. And I think that's one of the saddest things. People like Dr. Ford, I think no matter what you believe, you watch these hearings and they're really heart-wrenching, right? Dr. Ford is someone who clearly is convinced, and I think most of us watching her are convinced as well, that she went through this incredibly, incredibly vivid and traumatic experience. I think the fact that there's so many, the way that Trump made fun of her, right, at his rally this week, the way that there are people who are sort of joking and laughing and talking about this as sort of, you know, at least in the Senate and in the judiciary, they held back on criticizing her directly. I think that was smart of them. You know, maybe they...
grown as human beings since, you know, the Anita Hill debacle. But I think that one of the things that's so disturbing is that we're forgetting to see these people as people like Judge Kavanaugh, who it seems to me really firmly believes that he didn't do this thing. Right. Again, I don't know whether he did it or not, but it seems to me that he's absolutely convinced that he has this unjust thing has been happening to him and it's just completely difficult for him. He has not coped well with it, which I don't know. I can't imagine that people disagree with that. I think he has had no idea how to deal with it and chose very poor tactics. But I think that for people on the left.
It's hard for them right now at this point in the conversation to say, I cannot believe what you've gone through and we need a serious conversation about sexual assault. And it's hard for people on the right. And I'm not equating these two, by the way. I'm not saying these are the same thing. But it's also hard for people on the right to say, I understand why people would be scared about this accusation because it seems like people are immediately rushing to judgment before hearing all the facts. I understand both those sides. Obviously, I think sexual assault is worse and I think...
Equating sexual assault and the accusation of sexual assault are definitely not the same thing. But both are incredibly difficult and traumatic. And I understand both of those fears. Right. There's been a big movement now. Trump started talking about this. I think it was Donald Jr. who also talked about this. But it's just in general sort of one of the talking points over the past week is it's so scary to be a man now. It's terrifying. You never know what's going to happen. And you know what? They're not wrong. Of course, a malicious person could just accuse you of something. Of course, that's true. And in today's sort of climate, people will be suspicious of you. But also, that's OK. Right. Like, that doesn't mean that it's scarier, quote unquote, to be a man than to be a woman. Right.
Being accused of sexual assault is not as scary as actually being sexually assaulted. But again, that's not a competition. I agree completely. But the way it's being set up right now is the left is going around saying you have to believe women because they just keep being assaulted and this is enough is enough and this is insane. You have to believe women. And the right is saying, no, no, no, that's not true. I'm ignoring everything you say. Look how hard it is to be a man. It's crazy. These things can both exist. But instead, everyone is having their own conversation. And then I, and Uri, I don't know how you feel about this, but definitely I as a left-leaning woman.
who absolutely, look, again, not a competition, but I feel my sympathies more aligned toward Dr. Ford than anyone else here, feel almost like a little bit scared, like that people would call me, would say that I'm a traitor, or people were saying that I'm standing with these evil people or things like that, where, I don't know, I just feel like there's a lot of pain to go around, and we can say that everyone is a victim here, right? Judge Kavanaugh, in a lot of ways, is a victim. It is crazy. This child, this 16, 17, 18, 19-year-old, clearly had a drinking problem. It doesn't matter if he's like, I've never blacked out drunk. He was drinking multiple times a week. This is very scary, and none of the adults seem to notice. This is...
crazy. Well, maybe they didn't notice because everybody was doing that. 100%. Oh, this is a larger cultural problem. I'm not saying Judge Kavanaugh had a worse drinking problem than his friends did. Well, that's a big part of it, though. The fact that this is a part of the culture, I think is...
Awful. And we're not even talking about that. The insane drinking culture that's going around with these children, right, that's going around in colleges. I feel like I'm mixing up a bunch of different topics right now, but I feel like part of what's happening is we're keeping topics so separate. We're saying X. No, no, no, not X. I'm throwing that away. Y. No, I'm throwing Y away. Z. And we're not actually having a conversation about the totality of all of these things. Right. Well, that's what I think has made this whole story so part of what's made it so complicated. And it reminds me of what Cory Booker said. You know, Cory Booker, senator from New Jersey, is somebody that I used to have a lot of respect for and I've gradually lost.
Some of that respect for various reasons and various things that he's said over the last few years. You're so Shemily Boteach. I don't know. I don't mean I don't identify as Shemily Boteach either, but it just happens to be that it's sad because I've heard him speak a couple times, Cory Booker at YU and other places. And he's a very, very impressive person. But he's become, I think, more of a political hack than he was in the past. And he said something a few days ago where basically it doesn't matter if Kavanaugh is innocent or guilty at this point because so many questions have been raised. We really just have to.
dump him and get somebody else. And I think that's such a scary and terrible thing to say because it's like, it's complete circular reasoning because you're the one and your people are the ones who brought all these questions, arguably for completely political reasons. And now once the questions are there, then you yourself are saying, well, there's all these questions. How could possibly, you know, we can all agree that there's a lot of questions and therefore he's- Wait, I'm not sure how that's true, right? Dr. Ford is not some like- But Cory Booker is saying even if he's innocent, it doesn't matter. That's what I'm saying. He's saying because enough questions have come up from the next step. I don't think that's a crazy thought, right? But all those questions are based on what he's saying could be a completely false accusation. Okay, let's take a complete extreme example.
to show that I don't think it's crazy. Let's say Judge Kavanaugh was accused of being someone who allegedly raped someone. And then, or attempted rape, I'm sorry. And then, in response, he got so angry and shot someone. Obviously, it's not the same thing. Would you say, okay, but he only shot someone because you upset him so much about the first question? So, like, let's ignore all that and focus on the inconsequential allegations of the first question. No, of course not, because what happens next matters. What Cory Booker was saying, and you can agree with him or disagree with him, but his idea isn't insane. What Cory Booker is saying is that because of the allegations, we then saw another side to Judge Kavanaugh, which we hadn't seen before, and that side was scary, and that side is enough to say he shouldn't be on the Supreme Court. Now, it doesn't matter big adult whether what he's saying is true or not. It doesn't matter.
for the purposes of Supreme Court confirmation because to be a judge on the Supreme Court, you have to have the highest... Actually, Anthony Kennedy was interviewed and it was kind of funny to hear. It was months ago and they asked him sort of what you think the major qualifications for the Supreme Court are and the first thing he said in his sort of list of things was temperament. And I was just listening to this interview and it had nothing to do at all with the Judge Kavanaugh thing. It was actually on a recent episode of This American Life. It was in a...
a story that had nothing to do with Judge Kavanaugh. But it was interesting that temperament was the thing that he focused on. Yeah, that is interesting. And that's the thing that people are now calling into question. That is interesting. I mean, what Orrin Hatch in his op-ed said is like, obviously, if Judge Kavanaugh was faced with a case that he himself was involved with, he would recuse himself like any judge would. And this is a case that's directly involving him. And he's gotten very worked up because basically his reputation, his family's reputation has been permanently damaged no matter what happens with his confirmation or not. And that's a huge deal. It's something that will never be gone from his name and from how people see him.
But he has a record as a judge and as a public figure for many, many years. And, you know, he didn't have any issues with temperament or whatever in those cases. And it's like, maybe this is what you're saying, Cory Booker's saying, whether or not he's guilty, the way he handled it and reacted to it. I don't agree with that, but I understand it, I guess. But I still think what Cory Booker said was very, very dangerous. And it sets a dangerous precedent for the future where it's like, once there are questions and accusations, it doesn't even matter, innocent or guilty, because there are questions. I just think that's just a very dangerous thing to say. He's not saying it doesn't matter. Like, truth doesn't matter. He's saying whether he should be confirmed on the Supreme Court, we don't stop at X once we have Y and Z.
So I want to ask you a question that I've been thinking about a lot that I've really been grappling with, because I think this is a question, if we take it sort of out of the Dr. Ford and Judge Kavanaugh situation, we just talk about sort of the larger question, especially of sexual assault, which is something that I think is often more difficult than other crimes or other situations like this to corroborate. What happens in this sort of he said, she said thing? What should we do? And I think, again, as we talked about before, I don't think the legal system has the right answer. I don't think we should turn to them. I'm more thinking sort of philosophically or hypothetically. If we're in a situation in which a man says, I absolutely did not do 100 percent. I did not do that thing that she accused me of. I did not rape her. I did not attempt to rape her. And this woman says.
A hundred percent, it was him. He did it. And let's say she has, you know, let's say she has a date or, you know, something like that. And he says, nope, absolutely not. Absolutely not. I was in my room. I did not do this thing. Who do we believe? And is it different than other crimes? I think these types of allegations need to be taken very seriously. And if a person comes forward and says that they were the victim of abuse, they have to be listened to and that has to be taken very, very seriously. But at the same time, we have to then take that accusation and we have to investigate it and we have to look into it and see if we can find any evidence or corroborating evidence, circumstantial evidence, something to support that claim. And there's different kinds of evidence, different levels of proof and certainty.
I personally don't think that demonstrating that this person drank in college or had sexual innuendo in his high school yearbook counts as evidence of sexual abuse. But if there's a situation where someone levels an accusation and an FBI investigation takes place and there is zero evidence found to corroborate anything in the story, that doesn't mean we should call the person a liar. But I don't think we can act on that kind of accusation when there's just nothing real backing it up. I just don't think that's how a society of law and order works. I hear what you're saying. I mean, to me, it feels like, and maybe this is my fault for not sort of breaking down the question further, but the question sort of like, who are we inclined to believe, I think has different implications when we're talking about who are we inclined to believe, and if we choose her, he ends up in prison, or who are we inclined to believe, and if we choose her, he doesn't get this job, and his name is publicly smeared. Because first of all, his name is publicly smeared no matter what. I don't know how much this affects it. But also, we do have to say, you're right, that it destroys his life in a lot of ways. This is always going to be associated with him. Our kids are going to know what happened to Judge Kavanaugh. This is obviously a huge part of the story that will follow him forever. And yet...
being a Supreme Court justice is not something that you just deserve because you were nominated. Yeah, that's what people are saying. Cory Booker's like, oh, just because he went to Yale, he's not entitled to it. Nobody's saying he's entitled to be a Supreme Court justice because he's white or because he went to Yale or because he's a smart guy. Okay, no, right. That's not what I said. Nobody's saying he's entitled for any reason other than he was considered to be qualified and he was nominated by the president in the same way every other Supreme Court justice has been nominated. But there have been plenty of justices who were nominated and then rescinded it because it was clear they said it wasn't going to confirm for one reason or another. Right, that's happened. I have no idea. Do you know the percentage of nominees? It's pretty low, but I think I was reading about it recently. I think there was one or two with Reagan.
I think even, I want to say it was Clinton. Clinton's first nominee ended up being rescinded, but I'm not 100% sure. But it happens, right? And it happens for less than attempted rape. Again, we don't know that it happened or that it didn't happen. But if we're not sure, and it's a Supreme Court seat, right? Again, we're not putting him in prison. We're not putting him under house arrest. We're not saying he's not allowed to do, you know, whatever XYZ that he would want to do. I don't know. It doesn't seem so crazy to me that he doesn't just deserve the seat because he was nominated. I think if this would have come out...
a month ago or a month earlier and the Republicans would have had time to dump Kavanaugh because he's too toxic and get somebody else confirmed before the midterms, then it would be a different story. How is that fair to the victim that what's being decided is about the amount of time they get? That's crazy. Because we started this conversation by saying that this whole thing is so political and partisan that it's basically impossible to have a real conversation. among politicians about what happened and what should be done. And I think this is a perfect example of that. Because it was brought and presented in such a political way, it was responded to in a political way, and it was dealt with on both sides in very partisan terms, and people took sides and teams, and that's just how it was treated. It's crazy. It just feels like it's so unfair to Dr. Ford, the entire situation that unfolded around her, which is so, so different than what she wanted. What she wanted was this quiet investigation, and for him to sort of be able to quietly be taken off that list because of these allegations, maybe they would look into it, maybe it would be its own investigation. But what if they wouldn't have found anything in the investigation, which is basically what happened? I don't think she had plans on going public with it. No, okay, but if they wouldn't...
have found anything, then nothing would have happened and he would have been confirmed. Yeah, isn't that crazy? I think that's actually so crazy. You don't think the Democrats had an incentive to want it to go public because then it's a lot more credible? Of course they did. Okay, and that's what happened. If there would have been an investigation, a private investigation that wouldn't have found anything, do you not think the Democrats then would have played their next card, which is bring it public and see how the public reacts and if that can get them the result that they want? It could very well be, but I'm talking about what Dr. Ford wanted. I'm not talking about what the Democrats wanted. Yeah, the Democrats want to win. The Democrats are slimeballs. Politicians are slimeballs. Dr. Ford is definitely not a politician. I'm sure she has political leanings. I'm not going to assume that they played into this even though they very well could have.
Maybe. I mean, that has definitely not been part of the conversation. Because she's an academic from California, I guess I would imagine that she's a Democrat, but I have no idea. And she reiterated over and over that she is not involved in politics and has nothing to do with politics. She would be very happy for them to just have gone to the next person on the Federalist Societies list. What I would conclude with, and kind of building off what you were just saying, is that I'm willing to believe and accept that Dr. Ford, first of all, is very sincere and truthful in her recollection of what happened and is not coming from...
a political motivation. It's just the question of this is somebody who is being nominated for Supreme Court or potentially nominated for Supreme Court, and this is something that has to be brought forward and known. At the same time, a lot of the conversation in this whole debate, and really the conversation that's been happening ever since Trump was elected, it kind of reminds me a little about something that we've discussed in the past after we talked about the panel discussion about where the topic was, do liberals have the moral high ground? And while we keep saying how viciously partisan our culture is right now, I don't think... the way conservatives look at or look down on liberals is the same way that liberals look at or look down on conservatives. I think when conservatives criticize liberals, it's usually that they're naive or stupid or endangering the country even. But when liberals criticize conservatives, it's almost always, especially recently, it's that they're evil.
They're terrible human beings who are dangerous to women and minorities in society. You know, I spoke in the past on the podcast about the time that somebody said to me, how could you actually be a conservative and still be a good person? Like to a lot of liberals, those two are mutually exclusive. And so it's no longer a political debate. This is good versus evil. And when that's the perspective that you have, you're very unlikely to see people on the other side as...
potentially decent human beings who also want what's best for the people and for the country. That's just something that makes me sad. And I wonder if it's like we're moving in a direction where it's just becoming more and more of that, or if there's any way that things could retreat from that in some way. Yeah, it's a scary thought. And I think to a certain extent, I actually really agree with you. I think the way that conservatives and liberals talk about each other is not quite the same. I also think, though, that that became maybe worse since Trump's election, because not only does Trump talk about the other side as evil, right? And not only does he use really, really degrading and awful ways of talking about- Maybe criminal. I don't know about evil.
Whatever, not important. It's terrible. We both agree that it's terrible. But I think also one of the things that's been very demoralizing to people on the left, especially people I know on the left who consider themselves, I guess, moderate left, I think what's been so difficult for us to swallow is that so many people could support someone like him. And it's not about policies. I mean, sometimes it is about policies, but it's also not about policies. And it's also been a very difficult thing to look at this group of people and say, how could you line up behind this person? And I think to a certain extent, that's why I've really been encouraged by the people on the left and on the right. People like Collins and Jeff Flake, people who have really been struggling, Murkowski, over the past few weeks, specifically what to do about this whole Judge Kavanaugh situation.
And it's been very disheartening for me as someone who is left leaning to see how quickly we've dismissed those people when they ended up not voting on our side, quote unquote. When Flake and Collins eventually decided to support Judge Kavanaugh's nomination so quickly, it was like flooding. Like, OK, that's it. Collins is out. Let's throw money at her opponent. Right. All of these things instead of feeling like, OK, this is someone who really did give things a fair shake and came out on the other side. And that's been really difficult to watch. And again, I want to reiterate, honestly, I go back and forth on this, but I do not think it was appropriate for Judge Kavanaugh to have been given a seat on the Supreme Court. But I also.
do not think that the way in which anyone has gone about this has given me any sort of hope for the future. So on that exciting note, it's been really fun to be back in the studio with you. Yeah, I mean, I feel a little bit rusty, but I think we've gotten back into the swing of things and hopefully we'll have some good topics coming up in the coming weeks. Yeah, I'm really excited. Maybe a little bit less depressing. Yeah, I mean, we'll see. Thank you all so much for listening and rejoining us. For new listeners, great to have you. As always, we love, love, love to hear feedback. Please email us at TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com or even better, join the conversation on our Facebook page, Talking Talkless Podcast. Follow us, share with your friends. We love to have you. Thanks as always to our sponsor, Drive-In Productions. We miss this gorgeous...
studio but it's obviously but it's really nice to be back and thanks as always to triple threat trio featuring rage brigade they are the official band of talking talkless bye everyone bye