40. Membership Q&A: Keeping Members Active, Getting Member Feedback, Members Who Only Consume Content, Starting a Membership From Scratch and More!

Register for the 3-Day Fill Your Membership Challenge happening March 23rd, 24th, 25th here: https://paigevandy.com/fill-your-membership-challenge   🏴 NEW LIVE MASTERCLASS DATE: Feb 5th, 2026 Build a Sticky AF Membership Community, REGISTER FOR FREE BELOW: https://paigevandy.com/live-masterclass-sticky-community#/ In this episode, Paige answers some of the most common questions membership founders ask about engagement, retention, feedback, and starting a membership from scratch. If you’ve ever worried that your membership isn’t working because members aren’t posting or engaging publicly, this episode will completely reframe how you measure success inside your community.   FREE On-Demand 35-Minute Training: 🏴 The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in Join Million Dollar Memberships Club: 🏴 https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club    You’ll learn: • Whether it’s actually a problem if members are only consuming content • What “normal” engagement looks like inside healthy memberships (10–20% active is standard) • Why most members are quiet consumers — and why that’s not a red flag • How engagement shifts as members gain confidence and start executing • What matters more for retention than comments and postsPaige also covers: How to keep members active in your community • Encouraging member-to-member conversations • Bringing members together through shared experiences • Modeling the behavior you want to see • Using leaders and ambassadors to set the tone The best way to get feedback from members • Why quarterly feedback surveys work best • Why anonymous polls get more honest responses • How to encourage participation without pressure Can you start a membership with no previous clients? • Why specificity matters even more when starting from zero • How to define a clear before → after transition • Why showing how results happen matters more than social proof early on   More From The Million Dollar Memberships Podcast:   Free Training: 🏴 The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in   Ready to start or grow your membership? 🏴 Join Million Dollar Memberships Club https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club   Want higher-touch support growing your membership this year?? 🏴 Work with Paige 1:1 to scale to 7 or multi-7 figures https://paigevandy.mykajabi.com/expand-community-business-consulting-2024?preview_theme_id=2159387564   Connect With Paige: Instagram: @themembershipmuse YouTube: @themembershipmuse TikTok: @membershipmuseofficial   This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build highly successful online membership communities and scale to multiple 6 and 7 figures on autopilot.