Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rifki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So Uri, you had a fun activity last night. Yeah, I actually didn't know you were going to be there until I saw you there. But we both went to the New York premiere of our friend Yadidic Gorsetman's new movie entitled Empathy, Inc.
Yeah, it was premiering in New York at the Brooklyn Horror Film Festival, I think. And I didn't go to any other movies in the festival. I just wanted to see this film. But yeah, it was a really, really cool experience. It was really cool being in a room with all the actors, the producers. Obviously, our friend Yuditi was the director, hearing the Q&A after and just, you know, seeing the film on the big screen. It was pretty exciting. Yeah, it was very interesting. I thought the movie was pretty good and obviously just very cool that our friend put that all together.
It's obviously a very huge endeavor. It's actually going to be in the Austin Film Festival in two weeks. That's pretty cool. Yeah, I heard about that. And another festival also in Philadelphia, I think, the weekend after. There's a bunch of reviews like an AV Club and other sort of like film or culture websites. So congratulations, Didya. And people who are looking for a new film to check out, see how you can make your way to see Empathy, Inc. Well, I don't know if it's available yet. They can buy tickets to the festivals. They can go to the festivals. Or they could also... That's what we did. Right. They could also, I think, like the Facebook page and stuff like that to build the community, I guess, of people who are interested in the project. Actually, can I tell you a funny story? One of the characters is the mother-in-law, the main character. I was talking to the actor who played the mother-in-law afterwards.
And she was so funny. She was like, I don't know. I couldn't really follow it. It was a little confusing. It was amazing because it's sort of a, you know what?
sci-fi, interesting sort of concept. And she's not in those scenes. She's in the family scene. We got some of the behind the scenes, which I've had involvement with, but not everybody realizes how these things work. So one of the actors was saying that he had never even met the main actor in the film until the film was actually screened many months later. And so, yeah, there's different scenes and different people that don't necessarily even know each other, don't even know what the movie is about fully. And obviously other ones, probably the more main actors have to know and are very involved in the philosophical side of the story and what it means and everything like that. But it was cool to hear them all talk afterwards and to see that whole process.
Also, to just briefly reference our episode from last week when we talked about the controversy surrounding Judge Kavanaugh, who is now on the Supreme Court, we had an interesting discussion on our Facebook page that was started by a friend of the show, Sasha Zakarin, where he kind of challenged a statement slash assumption that I made at the end of the episode. And we had a little bit of a back and forth on Facebook. So if you want to check that out, look at our Facebook page and feel free to jump into the conversation. It's an ongoing conversation. Now we've heard from the alleged victim, but now it's time to hear from the hero, Judge Brett Kavanaugh.
who I'm told has been shadowboxing in the men's room for the last 45 minutes. Judge Kavanaugh. What? Judge Kavanaugh, are you ready to begin? Oh, hell yeah. Now, I am usually an optimist. I'm a keg-as-half-bull kind of guy.
But what I've seen from the monsters on this committee makes me want to puke and not from beer. So why don't we jump into this week's topic. A couple of weeks ago, three academics revealed an elaborate hoax that they had been perpetrating over the course of a year. James Lindsay, Helen Pluckrose, and Peter Boghosen wrote 20 fake scholarly papers that they then submitted to various prestigious academic journals. The topics of the papers varied, and they were submitted to journals in the fields of gender and sexuality, feminism, queer studies, and race studies, among others. The authors grouped all their papers into a field that they coined, which is grievance studies.
Each paper used fashionable buzzwords and made up data to support purposely absurd and ridiculous conclusions. Of the 20 papers, seven were accepted for publication, and at the time the hoax was revealed, four were actually published. Seven more were going through various stages of the review process, and six were rejected. Here is James Lindsay talking about the project in a video the three released explaining their motivation. Since approximately June of 2017, I, along with two other concerned academics, Peter Boghossian and Helen Pluckrose, have been writing intentionally broken academic papers and submitting them to highly respected journals in fields that study gender, race, sexuality, and similar topics. We did this to expose a political corruption that's taken hold of the university. By this point, several of these papers have been accepted in highly respected journals, and one that claims that dog-humping incidents can be taken as evidence of rape culture has been officially honored as excellent scholarship.
To be clear up front, we think studying topics like gender, race, and sexuality is worthwhile, and getting it right is extremely important. The problem is how these topics are being studied right now. A culture has developed in which only certain conclusions are allowed, like those that make whiteness and masculinity problematic. The fields we're concerned about put social grievances ahead of objective truth. So as a simple summary, we call the problem grievance studies.
To test the depth of this problem, my collaborators and I dedicated ourselves to a one to two year secret project targeting top grievance studies journals with an agreement to publicly release our findings, no matter what the outcome. So the paper about the dogs that James Lindsay was referencing was titled Human Reactions to Rape Culture and Queer Performativity at Urban Dog Parks in Portland, Oregon. And that paper was published in a journal called Gender, Place, and Culture. There was also a paper which dismissed Western astronomy as sexist and imperialist and makes a case for physics departments to replace astronomy with feminist astrology or to practice interpretive dance instead. In a slightly darker tone, a different paper advocating for the atonement of white privilege involved the authors advising college professors to enact, quote, experiential reparations, where they tell privileged students to stay silent and periodically bind them to the floor with chains during class. So, Rifki, what do you think about this elaborate hoax? Do you think it revealed any important truths about the state of academia? Do you think this story is unfair and maybe even a little bit misleading?
Yeah, I mean, let's just start with being a little honest, right? It stings a little bit. They were able to write these papers incredibly quickly and just make up everything, right? They made up studies. They made up field work. They made up all of these things just using all these buzzwords. They made up the names of the people submitting the papers. It's crazy. And the fact remains that so many of these, right, seven of them were published and a couple of them were still being reviewed. That's pretty discouraging to people who really care about academia, care about journals. One of the counter narratives that I was reading online was people saying, yeah, but that's not how people read journals and fields like this. People don't read the whole thing through and assume it to be true. You know, people sort of look for keywords for the thing that they're studying and they only read that article. So it doesn't matter if it's...
You know, it's not as important. It's not like science. It does. It does. At the same time, the criticism that argues that this shows that these fields are full of crap and that these journals can't be trusted seems to speak to something larger, right? Which is, have you been reading about the replication crisis in science and social psychology, right? So there's something interesting that seems to be going on in a bigger way in which a lot of studies that have been published are seeming to have a little bit of trouble staying honest, right? That includes the hard sciences and also the softer sciences. Or even papers that are honest can't.
be replicated afterwards. Exactly. Which is a little bit difficult. And that's not, again, that's not trying to say that that means that these hoaxes don't seem to show anything. I think they actually do show pretty important things. But the fact that statistical analysis begadol, right, in a larger way, is not really showing us truth in the way we want to think of academics as looking for truth. I think there's something missing there in a larger way. Right. Well, one thing I want to say is we actually haven't done this in the last couple of weeks, but it wouldn't really be an episode of Talking Tachlis if we don't qualify ourselves and our identities. So neither of us are academics.
Tell me if you are any different. But I have read academic articles in my life, but it's definitely not a regular part of my routine. And so I don't feel that I have a full or a good grasp and understanding on what these journals are like. what a typical article or essay feels like or sounds like. But I guess that leads us to the question of like, what really was the problem here? I mean, what do you see as the problem? So I agree with you. I think the real issue is not that these subjects should not be explored because you're right, as crazy as some of these ideas might be, there's nothing bad about serious scholarship and serious creativity going into sort of really breaking down and analyzing these subjects. You know, that's what science is for. That's what journals are for. That's what academia is for in a lot of ways. The problems that these studies seem to expose is that a lot of times these aren't done with real scholarship, right? This was crap. This was made up work. This was buzzwords that have no real meaning and they were being published as if they were being able to take seriously.
And I think that's part of what's so disappointing about it. Right. And on top of that, they were all coming from the same political agenda or perspective. Meaning, here's a quote from the authors themselves in a very long article slash explanation where they talk about... what they did and why they did it. We undertook this project to study, understand, and expose the reality of grievance studies, which is corrupting academic research. Because open, good-faith conversation around topics of identity, such as gender, race, and sexuality, and the scholarship that works with them, is nearly impossible. Our aim has been to reboot these conversations. We hope this will give people, especially those who believe in liberalism, progress, modernity, open inquiry, and social justice, a clear reason to look at the identitarian madness coming out of the academic and activist left and say, no, I will not go along with that. You do not speak for me.
I think what they're saying is that outlandish and crazy and out-of-the-box ideas are accepted and even embraced in these journals wholeheartedly, but not the other way around. Anything that questions identity politics or... or those type of ideas is not going to be accepted and is not even going to be discussed. And I think that's really their concern. I totally agree. And I think what's a little bit sad about this is I think a lot of people who are reading about this, what they walk away with is gender studies is a joke, racial studies is a joke, all of these studies are completely ridiculous and they should all be booted off campus because there's no place for considering these things academic at all, which is not what the authors are saying and not, I think, what I think. I think what the fundamental problem is that a lot of these departments are flawed because there seems to be one way in which they're trying to drive the students towards, which I think is the more alarming thing, right? When the goal of the professors and the heads of these departments is to push everyone towards this fundamental...
understanding of race theory that is not a nuanced look at race theory, that's the issue. But unfortunately, I think what comes out of these sort of hoaxes is not that more nuanced way of saying, okay, let's expand, let's think differently about it, let's try to be more inclusive, let's try to allow for more creativity in different directions. It's more like this whole thing is crap. Well, it depends. I think different people have taken this in different ways. And I was trying to find critiques of this hoax and people criticizing these academics as having done something bad. Actually, just yesterday in the New York Times, they published...
letters to the editor in reference to the original article they published about this. And there were three letters. Two were in favor of the hoax and saying it was important and one was against it. The one that was against it was actually written by an editor of one of the journals that published one of the articles. So clearly this person is upset. What did that person say? So basically, from what I've seen, the types of criticisms go along the lines of...
They took advantage of trust. There is a trust in the academic world that when you submit a paper and you give data, we're going to assume that the data is correct unless we have some sort of reason to assume not. It sounds like they're saying they're not going to do the type of investigation or due diligence into every single data point, just maybe because they don't have the resources for that. So they're going to have to assume it's true. To be fair, I think actually a lot of these places do not have any money. That's why one of the, it's funny, it kind of overlaps. One of the other criticisms that people have is that this, not just a replication crisis, but also that...
in, let's say, economics journals, because there is no funding for a lot of these journals and a lot of these departments, a lot of these papers are really paid for by the authors themselves. So that also contributes to us really not being able to trust a lot of the academic departments and their publications. Yeah. I mean, in addition to that, some of the criticism went along the lines of this scandal is now hurting and perhaps permanently damaging the reputations of those particular journals and maybe even journals in general now, which as, and that's sort of like the end justifies the means, meaning like you may have had a point in doing this, but these journals are really important and they're dealing with really important subject matter and now you've hurt their reputation and now you've hurt their ability to enact progress and change in the world. I just think that's such a crappy argument. I don't know, like we live in, as much as you might want to think that I believe differently, I am a capitalist, right? If I go to a restaurant and there's a bug in my soup and I put that out on Facebook and on Yelp and it's like, oh, but you're hurting the restaurant. That's not how it works. They have to not put bugs in people's soups. They can't just publish crap and then say that it's our fault for reporting it. I'm really glad to hear you saying that because along the same lines, the broader criticism is that not that you're hurting the reputation of the journals per se, but more that you're hurting the reputation of these fields of study in general. You're making gender studies and feminist studies and race studies.
studies look less serious. And that can be seen as even more problematic because these are fields that are trying to help people. That's really what their goal is, I think. Right. And I think that is true. But I think that's why the authors, they wrote this whole thing about saying, we believe that these programs are valuable. We believe they hold really good things and there's a lot of promise to them, but they need to be more careful about these things. Unfortunately, that's getting sort of washed away and no one's hearing those voices. Right. So, I mean, like I said, I think different people are going to experience and react to this different ways. I would hope that this has some sort of positive impact on the academic world. Like you were saying, these are like the humanities and the liberal arts that are...
can be seen as problematic. You were saying even the hard sciences, medicine and physics, chemistry, also have problems that are slightly unrelated to this, problems of reproduction and problems of data and whatever. So maybe that's part of a broader trend. I was also thinking about, of all the different articles, there was one written by Ben Shapiro that I found kind of interesting. Our good old friend, Ben Shapiro, who has come up in the past on his podcast, we've talked about him. And while I didn't love the tone that he took in his article, like he calls things idiotic and he uses kind of like extreme and inflammatory language sometimes, he also addressed certain aspects of this story and the issue that...
I thought kind of went on to a deeper level than a lot of the other reportings of the story went. Yeah, I'm going to read from the article the point that I thought was particularly interesting. And, you know, I'm no Ben Shapiro fan, but I want to address this particular argument. What he said was, what was the goal of the hoax? The authors explained that they had amassed evidence that there is, quote, a problem with bias in fields influenced by critical constructivist approaches and assumptions, end quote. That's no shock. Constructivism is perhaps the most idiotic philosophy at work today in education, and it is also one of the most prominent. The authors of the hoax described constructivism thusly.
End quote. Universities are dominated by this philosophy. It is the philosophy that undergirds intersectionality and identity politics. So basically, Uri, everything is socially constructed, right? So we're having an interaction, like you and I are in a fight. The dynamic that's happening from this fight is because you're a man, I'm a woman. No, it's because you live here and I live there. No, it's because you grew up with this kind of class and I grew up with that kind of class. That everything that's happening, it's not about the ideas, right? At its most extreme, it's completely about the social dynamics and structures that we fit into. Well, I think it's also, in addition, I think that's true, but in addition to that, what it's also that philosophy would also say is that any type of gender interaction that we see as like, oh, because that's what the man does and that's what the woman does, this philosophy would...
say, no, that's what society tells us it is. But in reality, there's nothing in our DNA or in our hormones that is actually dictating that. It's social and not biological, right? Nature versus nurture, it's entirely nurture. Right. I mean, do you agree that that's what that philosophy would say? Yeah, I think so. And I think like, obviously, it's classic Ben Shapiro to say it's the, how does he put it? He says it's the most idiotic philosophy at work today in education. Right. And what he says actually in the next sentence after where you finish reading was that it is the philosophy that undergirds postmodernism. And what he means by postmodernism is the idea of subjectivism, that there is no absolute truth.
Truth is subjective. And therefore, according to him, once the academic world has decided that truth is subjective, then they can take their political agenda, which is whatever it is, and then they can push that as their truth. And I think what Ben Shapiro is saying is the danger there is that instead of academia being the pursuit of truth and knowledge, it instead becomes the pursuit of pushing an agenda and disregarding data and reality because there is no real reality. And this is what we think is right. And this is what we're going to put across as truth because it's our truth and not the truth.
So do you think, are you concerned about that? Do you think that's a problem? Yeah, I think it's definitely a problem. I think like anything else, right? It's somewhere in between. I think it's ridiculous for people like Ben Shapiro to say like, there is no merit to this argument whatsoever and all these people are morons. Well, again, he's speaking in extremes, but that doesn't have a point. Obviously, to a certain extent, there are things that are hardwired, right? Why do we do things a certain way? Testosterone matters, right? When we talk about gender or when we talk about sex, we have to be able to talk seriously about how biology is a factor. But that being said, if we don't also talk about social factors, we're also limiting the conversation. I just feel like obviously it's more complex than one extreme or the other. And when Ben Shapiro or when others, when others on either end, right? Like when others like maybe the editors of these journals or when people like Ben Shap
we lose the nuance of the conversation and it makes for a poorer conversation. Right. I mean, this again keeps reminding me of Sacha Baron Cohen. I'm Dr. Naira Kane and Degicello, and I believe that the world's most dangerous chemical weapon is testosterone. His point, though, is that this hoax was directly attacking or critiquing the academic world. So we're talking about them right now. Yes, there's problems with non-academic people also, but we're talking about them. And it seems to be, again, I'm not an academic, I'm not an expert. It seems to be from what Ben is saying and what other people are saying that that is the prevalent...
approach in academia, that everything is a social construct, like when in doubt, assume social construct. And there's this pushing of the agenda of intersectionality and identity politics that seems to be more and more pervasive. And I think what these authors are trying to say is that that is dangerous. Yeah, I wouldn't disagree with that. I think, you know, like anything else, we move in waves, right? There was this...
really long way for a long time. There was an overcorrection in the other direction and we need to find a happy medium, right? Right now there really is this overcorrection where I think we're confused and maybe taking things too far in academia because in a lot of ways it is the most creative and it really is at the forefront of a lot of new ideas and thinking about things in a totally different way than we've grown up thinking them. They're presenting things in a way that is very confusing to us and I think to a certain extent they're confusing to us because they're a little bit ludicrous and going a little bit too far and I think that means it's been an overcorrection and we need to find somewhere in between. I would agree with that. Trying to get...
like into specifics that are more practical. The way I see it, and I'm curious what you think, like in terms of like, okay, what is the real danger? You know, like these areas of study, feminist studies, race studies, like I do believe that they're trying to achieve more equality. They're trying to help traditionally disadvantaged groups gain an upper hand or gain equality, let's say. But at the same time, I think an unintended consequence of a lot of that is actually to increase divisiveness. The trend now is to just talk about, again, within identity politics, to talk about all motivations.
and actions as being a function of a person's gender and ethnic and racial identity is just causing more separation. It's a version of racism in a way. And I think that is just causing animosity. Like, you know, so we were talking last week about in the Kavanaugh discussion. Trump said something along the lines of, wow, it's really a dangerous time to be a man these days. And he was obviously ridiculed for that. And my point then was like, okay, it's not a competition. Yes, if we had to say, is it hard to be a man or a woman? Most people would say woman. And if you say man, you're being dishonest, let's just say. But why does it have to be one or the other? Why are those even the terms that we're using and the way that we're talking about the conversation, splitting people into groups, separating people into their tribes, and then saying, you're good, you're bad, you're disadvantaged, you're privileged. I don't see that as really being the way to achieve.
Yeah, I hear what you're saying. And I think the reason that sometimes people, let's say people on the left, right? Like I know that for myself and for a lot of people, the pushback to Trump's idea was it's both things, right? It's like, A, it doesn't have to be one or the other. You can be discriminated against and so can I. But B,
When it seems like what people are doing are equating like, oh, I could be falsely, not to make it too much capital, I could be falsely accused of sexual assault. Oh, that's nice. I could be sexually assaulted. When it seems like we're equating those two, I think that's where people on the left, you know, got upset. But I think you are right when it comes to things like these departments. I don't think the fundamental split at this point is between people who are black or women or queer or things like that and people who aren't, right, between straight white men and others. I actually think the critical split now between groups and the chasm is growing wider and wider is people who buy this whole idea and people who don't. And I think people who buy this whole idea think, you know, maybe there's a little overlap with what we talked about last week. People who buy this whole idea think that the other side is...
awful, and people who don't buy this whole idea think the other side has gone off the deep end, right? They just think they're crazy. So I think that the difficulty there, and maybe this hoax sort of brought this down in the open, is the people who think this is hilarious, you know, glad they did these hoaxes, what they're really saying is, now we're exposing that you're all full of crap, that this whole thing is a joke, and you guys have been crazy. So stop being so crazy. Close all these things, and just be normal. Right. I mean, I...
agree with that. And I don't know if this is the most productive thing to say or to push, but I do. No, I've said this before on the podcast. I do think that the election of Donald Trump as president was in large part a reaction to this type of intersectional identity politics that a lot of people felt very disenfranchised and they felt demonized just for being who they were, for being white, for being a man. And a lot of people reacted against that by gravitating towards this ridiculous anti-PC character, caricature, really, who they said, like, you know, you guys have pissed me off so much.
Now I'm just going to go with this guy. He's sort of like the id. Is that the right word? Yeah. He's like, you know, saying the things in the deep down that you sort of like think about, but would never say in public, but he says them. And then there's an allure to that. And I think it's very dangerous. And I think that was, again, an unintended consequence of some of these things maybe going too far was now we've come to Donald Trump. And then it just perpetuates because then the chasm, like you said, grows wider. And then people take sides. Because then it becomes like if you voted for Donald Trump, then you're X person. And if you, you know, things like that, it becomes a little bit confusing. I'm not sure that I agree with you, but about the Donald Trump thing. And that's obviously a bigger conversation. The truth is that I don't know. I think it's very confusing. And, you know, I.
I don't think the data, you know, the data seems very confusing to me. But I don't know, Ari, do you have any sort of like last thoughts, last ideas that we should share? Yeah, I mean, I would be very curious now that we're talking about, you know, academic papers and journals. I want to find a journal that advertises itself as being the anti-journal. You know, we're going to publish articles that are rigorous and involve real data and real ideas, thought through ideas, but that are not PC and they're not necessarily going with the agenda. And let's see what they have to say. And maybe I would hope that this hoax that came out and exposed some of the hypocrisy or some of the low standards that these journals have would lead to more, first of all,
oversight and also maybe more openness in these institutions to hearing, quote, the other side or to hearing challenges to the accepted liberal intersectional doctrine that they live by. Yeah, I think it's an interesting idea. I mean, obviously, there's been a lot of sort of soul searching the past few weeks since this whole hoax emerged. I wonder how these journals are going to deal with it. I wonder what they're going to do going forward, because I don't think the solution is to sort of close or to say, let's stop going, let's stop having creative ideas and taking submissions that are sort of wacky sounding. I think it just means more rigorous research and actually looking into all these things and trying to publish things that...
feel more real. And not to say... And what about publishing things that go against the accepted... I mean, I'm always happy to do that. I think in general, there's always room for us to be thinking outside the box, for us to be talking to people who think differently than us, reading things that are different than us. I think it is valuable. I think it's valuable for all of us. And I think that's part of why we started this project, you and I, why we started this podcast. So we could be the model. If these journals need something to look at, they should definitely call us. I heard they have a lot of spare money, so they could even sponsor. Oh, we're always looking for sponsors.
Namaste. I'm Dr. Naira Kane and Degicello, and I'm a cisgender white heterosexual male, for which I apologize. Two weeks after the election was stolen from President Hillary Clinton, I managed to get out of bed. I've been cycling through our fractured nation, listening respectfully without prejudice to Republicans, with the hope of changing their racist and childish views.
to try and heal the divide. And that's our show. Thank you all so, so much for listening. As always, the conversation does not end here. We want to keep talking to you. Please email us at talkingtalklesspodcast.gmail.com and even more so, please interact with us on Facebook. Please join our community, Talking Talkless Podcast on Facebook and let's get into the conversation. Yeah, like we said before, we've had some interesting conversations on the Facebook page in the last couple of weeks and we hope to keep those going. And thanks as always to our sponsor, Drive-In Productions and to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Talkless. All right, bye everyone. Bye.