Skip to content
418: 2023 Sifties (Part 1) episode artwork

Jan 23, 2024 2 hr 4 min

418: 2023 Sifties (Part 1)

from SiftPop Hosted by SiftPop | Aaron Dicer, Andrew Ormsby

Welcome back, Robert and Aaron! - Favorite NON-MOVIE Pop Culture Moment or Thing of 2023 (8:35) - Movies that Let You Down (15:46) - Movies that Surprised You In a Good Way (33:29) - Movies that Just Weren't For You (48:50) - Movies that Just Weren't For Them (1:18:38) - Top 5 TV shows of 2023 (1:31:42)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

418: 2023 Sifties (Part 1)

0:00 2:04:07
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Live from a bunker in the heart of the Ozarks, a podcast that's hoping to find a few more people so they could call this episode 8 is Knuff. It's Sif Pop. Welcome to Sif Pop Weekly, streaming live most Fridays are available to download later in your podcast feed, unless of course you're a patron. I'm your host, Aaron Dicer, and he's a Ken. It's Andrew Ormsby, ladies and gentlemen. I am Kenneth. Ahoy. Each week we'll chat about movies, TV, and whatever else from the pop culture universe is on our minds. And please welcome our guests this week. He is also a Ken. It's Aaron Schweitzer, ladies and gentlemen. I'm just Ken. Yes.

And finally, please welcome our other guest this week. He, yeah, he's a kid as well. It's Robert. I was wondering if I was going to be an Allen. I couldn't do that to anybody. I just couldn't do that to anybody. That was the original idea. And I was like, nah, nah, everybody's kid. We're just kidding. Michael Cera is a compliment to me, though, I will say. You know, I was just watching last night, Paws of Fury, The Legend of Hank, and just thinking, Michael Cera, what a guy. What a guy. He's certainly canuff as well. By the way, one of the big surprises to CCAs, which I'm fresh back from.

I'm just can one best song at the CCA. I was so happy. I was like, that's the right call, right? Like that's, that's, it's a good song. Um, I know it's not like quite as like tear jerking as what I was made for. And I love that song, but I think like when you're looking at like amazing songs, I just, I was, I was really thankful that, uh, that the critics decided that that was the one from Barbie, uh, that was going to go to the top. Do you think it has a chance at the Oscar? Yeah.

Probably the What Was I Made For song. Yeah. It feels more like prestige or Oscar or something, but sure, why not? Why not? I don't think Ryan Gosling even expected the CCA Awards. No, based on that reaction, I think he was a little bit shocked to be sitting at a table with Billie Eilish and be the winner. Oh, hey, Billie. Guess I beat you. He's like, guys, this is La La Land for Best Picture again. I'm not going up there. That's right. Yeah, somebody's pulling my leg. Did any of you guys check out the CCAs? Any of you guys watch along with the awards or kind of see what happened? Highlights because I was at work. What were your surprises, those of you that watched?

Oh, I'd have to remember. Or anything that stood out. Anything that stood out. Chelsea Handler's great. What's that? Chelsea Handler was super good. Isn't she great? I just think she's such a great host and just kind of understands her role and does it so well. I was looking at the teleprompter for a lot of the evening because I had a straight shot at it.

I was kind of sitting sideways because I was like at the back of the table. And so I turned my chair and so I could see the teleprompter and the people speaking in the moment where she got a laugh and then said, thank you for laughing at that. My writers wrote it like to diss the comedian from the host of the Golden Globes or whatever, who I guess she's dated before. Like he's like a friend of hers or whatever. So and that got a huge reaction in the room. I don't know what, you know, how it felt on TV, but that was all impromptu. None of that was on the prompter. So I was I was really impressed with with her ability that day. So, yeah, I didn't watch the Golden Globes because.

reasons and well at least they're supposedly not a shifty cabal of unknown people anymore at least they're you know trying to figure out what it means to be legitimate but so i didn't know that that was necessarily a dig but i just thought it was like hey like our writers did this this is why we should pay them like yeah if you didn't see it the guy was basically throw through his writers under the bus during the opening monologue like there would be dead silence and he'd be like you know look i didn't like it either my writers wrote that one or something like that like it was afterwards and it was not yeah yeah yeah ricky gervais he was not But it kind of felt like he thought he was, right? Like that was kind of the idea. Yeah, I thought Chelsea did a great job. From inside the room, that's why I'm always interested in the perspective outside the room because it's a totally different experience. From inside the room, it felt like it went really well. It felt like it was a great celebration of the movies that came out that year. You know, it was produced well. It hit its mark on time. Like it's just, you know, I just think it's a really great show. I wish, I wish, I wish, the main thing I wish is that it could get on like a main network and not be stuck on the CW where nobody knows how to find it. CW is a main network. It is not. It is not. And it doesn't stream anywhere.

It could. I mean, I streamed it on Hulu, but I think it just picked up like a local antenna somehow. I don't know. I wish the CW used to be when people still put a cable in the back of their TV. Right. But now that people don't do that anymore, it's kind of fell off. Right. Yeah. Well, like even like in this area, even if you do like Hulu live TV or YouTube TV or one of those things that's supposed to be like cable. CW is just a conglomeration of VOD. It's not an actual streaming channel. Like you can't even go to the CW channel. So it's just it's one of those weird things. And I don't think that's true everywhere, but it might just be because there's not a CW.

Here locally, I don't know what it is, but it's weird. So anyhow, I wish more people would see it because I really do think it's a good show and a good celebration. So I had a good time. But that's not what we're here for. We're not here for the CCAs. We're here for the Sifties. The real awards. The real awards of the year. That's right. We are going to do the Sifties in two parts, as we have done the last few years. I was actually doing a little bit of research on the Sifties, which officially started, I think, in 2017. So before that, there were like end of the year awards that we did. 2013, when it was The Critic, The Geek, and The Girl, when I was on with Danae and Captain Logan, we did an end of year. In 2014, we did an end of year. And then 2015 was the first like Sift Pop kind of end of the year, but there were no official categories.

And then from 2016 on, it looks like we have all the official categories, most of them, although TV, we only started doing like three years ago in conjunction with this. So, yeah, it's kind of been an interesting look through the different years and what the official Sif Pop movie of the year was. And so as we go through each category, since I've done this research, I may give you a couple of the highlights from the past six years, you know, of like some of the other winners of these categories. Just kind of walked down memory lane since I kind of went through the library and did that. So we're going to go through this first episode. We're going to do the what are called superlatives. So these are the awards that are around the big performances, around the big movies. And then we're also going to do television, which for a couple of our guests, and I won't mention who, is going to be difficult because they don't watch.

TV, I just found out. I just found out just today they've decided that television is not for them. So they're going to try to come up with their top five TV shows. So those superlatives are movies that let you down, movies that surprised you in a good way, movies that just weren't for you slash overrated, movies that just weren't for them slash underrated. Those are the superlative categories. And then, of course, we will do the top TV shows. And then we'll do next week, just so you know what's coming next week, we'll do the top 10 performances of the year. We'll do best movie moments. And then we will do top 10 movies of the year.

as well the one thing i really like about this first episode and we like to kick it off with this uh is a different category called best non-movie pop culture moment of the year this can be anything in pop culture outside of movies um that you had a good time with uh this year so let's kick it off with that and aaron why don't you kick us off what is your best non-movie pop culture moment of the year um sports count right yes absolutely cool i was like i'm i'm pretty sure but uh yeah i'm pretty sure robert did a celtic something last year because Probably got one this year. But I'm a Chicago boy, which means I'm a Chicago sports fan. And there's no highlights to the White Sox season this year. But the Blackhawks winning the draft lottery for Conor Bedard, which is a generational talent, maybe the best player in the last 20 years, the best prospect in the last 20 years, is kind of incredible to me. And just one tendon tear away from never playing again. I mean, you know, this kid, this kid two weeks ago.

uh, got hit and fractured his jaw, which is a six to eight week injury. And he was on the ice seven days late after surgery. That's a hockey player. That's a hockey player right there. Uh, that'll count. Andrew, what's yours? What's your favorite non movie pop culture moment of the year? I'm going to go with episode three of the last of us. I like it. I like it.

it emotionally wrecked me uh as somebody who played the video game uh the story of bill and frank was always one of uh like talking like they talked about the history of bill and frank you never actually saw it so actually seeing this episode and just how beautiful the relationship was between these two people who found each other and it's i found it incredibly beautiful because if it hadn't been for the apocalypse this beautiful love story would never have started or have come to fruition you know it's Yeah, it's just utterly beautiful. And I wish I would be so lucky to find somebody like a Frank Robill. Yeah, that's a great choice. That is if we were doing best episodes, which some of us would have a hard time doing. If we were doing best episodes, that would, I think, be a pretty easy front runner. There's not one I'm thinking of that would even compete with it. That's just an incredible episode of television. I can think of two episodes from the bear, but yes. Yeah, but I'm telling you as good as those episodes from the bear are, I still think that episode of last of it. I didn't even like last of us as much as most people did. Like, I like it. It's fine. I enjoyed it for what it was.

but I don't vibe with it, if that makes sense. The Last of Us is not my vibe. Not like The Bear is much my vibe either, although those episodes of The Bear do have a lot of my vibe. Like, there is a really interesting thing that's happening, especially with, is it Forks where he, where Evan goes? Yeah, yeah. Oh, Forks was such a good episode. Yeah, Forks is so good. But I think that episode of Last of Us would probably be the one. Sure, I would say those would be the three of the year, but I don't know, I didn't see Succession. Yeah, there's also a couple from Succession.

uh all right uh i'll go next um i think for my uh movie or for my non-movie pop culture moment uh i'm actually going sports as well um but i i have a clarification to make see here's here's the thing i was thinking anything from sifties to sifties but we don't usually do that we do calendar year don't we it's like calendar year so michigan winning the national championship is not that was right calendar year that's 2024 so now i kind of have to rethink this and then i just came I just came from LA where I saw an incredible performance of MJ, the musical, the Michael Jackson musical. It's been on Broadway and it just came to LA for a little bit. That was phenomenal. Also saw that technically in 2024. So like I've got, I'm trying to remember like what shows I saw in 2024.

I can't remember when I saw Jeff Daniels in To Kill a Mockingbird. Was that in 2023? It was. I think I saw that in 2023. So that would probably be it. Seeing that, I was in the third row, so basically Jeff Daniels was sweating on me when he was coming forward. Not only Jeff Daniels, but written by Aaron Sorkin. That was the other thing, too. It's like a Sorkin-written kind of thing.

to kill a mockingbird and live theater has like i've fallen in love with it uh all over again the past couple years having been to a few shows in new york my wife and i are planning a europe trip or a london trip technically uh and we're gonna go see steve coogan do uh armando annucci's version of dr strange love uh which opens uh which opens there this fall uh so that's gonna be a blast like that kind of stuff like i'm just like oh to be in the room where it happened so to speak uh so yeah it's it's been a lot of fun and i really enjoyed jeff daniels i see what you did there thank you yeah i only saw what i did there as i was doing it there uh robert your best non-movie pop culture moment this year mine is movie adjacent so tell me if it doesn't count uh but it's also uh like a being in the room while it happens type of thing i got to see an imac screening in new york of uh beau is afraid but that's not the moment i'm talking about because afterwards martin scorsese did a q a with ari aster at the theater oh nice so just being in person and seeing that q a with the two of them up there was just awesome like i i don't get starstruck very often well i don't see stars very often but i can't see many people who i would like be starstruck of

But Martin Scorsese is definitely one of them. And there was a clip that was going around online from that Q&A where Scorsese compared Bo was afraid, like, you know, an initial mixed reaction to a big epic like this to Barry Lyndon. And it was just cool being in the room, hearing him say that to Ari Aster's face and just feeling the energy of that room. So, yeah, that was an awesome moment. That's really cool. That absolutely counts. Definitely counts. That's a fun one.

All right. Well, there you go. Our best non movie pop culture moments of 2023. Let's move on to the next category. Your biggest letdown the movie that lets you down the most. Now, here's how the superlatives work on the 50s. We do nominations. So we will go around and each of us will nominate. So the let's see. So we will each pick between three nominees and then vote on a winner. There will be three rounds of nomination.

that we will do. So each of us will nominate three things and then we will pick a winner. These are not necessarily in order. Your nominations are not necessarily in order. They are just the three things you want thrown in the nomination pool. So we should have 12 to choose from by the time we're done. Biggest letdown. We're going to start with you, Robert. What is the biggest letdown of 2023? I have to start with Leave the World Behind. I, you know, who doesn't like Ethan Hawke, Julia Roberts, and Mahershala Ali and that sort of premise? But I actually kind of hated the movie. I went into it on Zip Pop Writer's Room. There are a lot of things I really didn't like about. I thought it was too in your face. Holier than thou, the worst tendencies of...

uh shamalan and adam mckay uh mushed into one movie and i just had a bad had a bad time the entire time uh what you meant to say was the best qualities of shamalan in mckay uh but we just see the world differently uh in that we're actually in his own movie this year so uh yeah i i understand that pick you are not alone with that pick i actually really like that movie um But yeah, Leave the World Behind is the first nominee. I'll go next and nominate Next Goal Wins. This is a Taika Waititi movie. And I love sports movies. Like, I was so ready. And again, the biggest letdown category is sometimes about expectations. These first two categories are about expectations, right? My expectations for this movie were super high. And this movie is okay. Maybe, you know, low side of okay. So, in my opinion. So, Next Goal Wins is my first nomination. So, there you go. Andrew, you're next.

How can you mess up a movie about a bear doing cocaine? That's what I want to know. How do you mess up a movie about a bear doing cocaine? No, yeah, cocaine bear. That's my that's my first nomination. I mean, the movie had everything going for it. It really did. And the fact that you can't pull it off is kind of impressive, but also incredibly disappointing. All right. So Andrew nominates cocaine bear for biggest letdown. Good choice. Good choice. Aaron, what is your first nomination for biggest letdown? I'll say The Flash. And here's the reason why. After being completely out of the MCU, the initial reactions and first trailer for The Flash.

Sorry, not MCU, DCU. I was going to say DCE. Kind of got me excited for the movie. I was like, oh, that looks like a good bit of fun. And Michael Keaton returning as Batman and the potential for other things. And, you know, two flashes. This looks like a fun movie. And instead it's...

disappointing on every level, including Michael Keaton. Instead, it's terrible. All right, Flash, good nomination. Robert, what's your second nomination in this category? This is a movie that just didn't end up being very well seen because, you know, I think it was terrible and the studios realized it, and that's Faux starring Saoirse Ronan, Paul Meskel, and directed by Garth Davis, I think his name is, the director of Lion. I love Lion. I love both of those performers. The movie isn't even two hours, but it feels to be about two hours and 45 minutes, and it just...

Has a bunch of endings. It just doesn't work on about any level. Kind of like leave the world behind it. Had me wondering if some performers that I love are actually bad performers. Right. I hate it when that happens. You start to realize how much is in the director's hands. You know, like how much like choosing takes and that kind of stuff is in going for the tone you're going for. Robert, that's a great pick. I had it in my list of possible nominations. Foe is a terrible film. Like, how do you mess this up? How do you have Saoirse Ronan and Paul Mescal in a sci-fi concept that should be right up my alley and just completely.

punt it like it's just it's it's wild how bad uh how much that movie missed so um yeah foe is a great choice for sure uh let's see my next nomination i think we're to me is going to be wish Disney's Wish. I had decent expectations for this. It sounded really interesting, really fun. Disney Animation has been on quite a role, in my opinion, for quite a while now, providing, if not excellent movies, great movies. So Wish is not, though. Wish is muddled. It's messy. The music doesn't work for me, which is strange. You basically just have to write a song that has notes in it to work for me. I love music and movies, and I just didn't like the music in Wish. It does this weird world-building thing with the Disney universe that should be an interesting idea.

but completely makes no sense and kind of almost destroys the foundation of the entire library of their classics. It's a really weird choice the way they went about it, and Wish was a huge letdown for me. So that's my second nomination. Andrew, what is your second nomination? A movie starring Adam Driver that I didn't really have high, high expectations for. But man, this movie is so bad that it just ruined everything. And that movie is 65. I mean, in contention for worst movie of the year. This is just a garbage fire of pointless. I don't even know what kind of commentary the movie is trying to make. Like what it's trying to say about maybe a father figure trying to.

uh, connect with a young girl, but there's a language barrier there that doesn't add anything to the movie. It's just a really weird, uh, and it's got back the guy who gave us a quiet place. So I, I kind of did have a little bit of expectations for this movie and I was let down tremendously. All right. 65, another good choice in this very depressing category. Uh, Aaron, what is your second nomination for biggest letdown? Um, I'll mention Luther, the fallen son, because I'm a huge fan of the TV show and.

I really wanted this movie to be great so that people that haven't seen the show would be like, oh, cool, I'll check this out. Just, you know, experience some of the best TV that BBC has to offer. And instead, the movie's fine. And that's a big letdown. Yeah.

I haven't seen this movie, but I also didn't watch the TV show, so that makes sense. There's no need to watch the show to watch the movie. In fact, it may even be a worse experience because it's such a dip in quality. First three seasons are excellent. Four is fine. Five is fine. Movie's fine. All right. Final nominations for this category. Robert, kick us off. I'm pulling an audible here. I didn't write this down, but I'm going to go with Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny. I almost didn't like it at all except for the very end, and I guess I'll keep it unspoiled, but the last big.

set piece and place that they go. I did find entertaining and engaging and interesting. But everything up before that, I thought the direction was kind of bad. I didn't think any of the characters were very interesting besides Indiana Jones himself. And even that, it's just another grumpy old Harrison Ford performance. I'm like everyone else. I really like the first three. The fourth one is fine. The fifth one I just thought was kind of terrible and easily the worst out of all the Indiana Jones movies.

Oh, easily the worst. Wow, that's a bar. Fighting the urge to argue. I actually enjoyed that with Destiny, alright. It's not going to be in my top ten movies that I would mention, but I had a good time with it. Definitely let down, though. I agree with that. I agree that it can be a good time. Especially with James Mangold.

Yeah. Yeah. It made me super excited. Yeah. The main goal thing is, is a part that can, yeah, really, really turn things into a letdown because he does such good stuff.

Let's see. I'm having to pull an audible as well because foe was going to be one of my nominees for show So I'm instead going to go with what was the movie? Let me see if I can I'm trying to remember the name of this movie pain hustlers pain hustlers was a huge letdown and I think for some people they maybe weren't expecting a lot out of this movie, but But for me, I liked the what it was exploring and the the fact that has Emily Blunt Chris Evans and Catherine O'Hara in it. I was like, oh, this is going to be a really fun, interesting movie, if nothing else. And it just fumbles everything about what it's trying to do. It centers the movie on the wrong people and learns the wrong lessons. It's a really strange, in my opinion, way to go about telling the story, and it kind of messes up the whole movie. So Pain Hustlers will be my third nomination. Andrew, what about you? Well, I'm going to ruffle some feathers with this one, so get ready. The killer. Oh, the killer? Yeah.

I know that you absolutely love this movie now, Aaron, but there was a time when you didn't. There was a time when you didn't. I think if you listen to that episode, you will hear me struggling with realizing some things about that movie. I think if you listen to that episode, you'll hear me discovering that movie. I found it to be pedantic and overall lacking in any kind of.

thorough or like through line of a plot like I couldn't follow Fassbender I get what the movie's trying to do with like him not being as good as he thinks he is you know I'm pretty sure that's what the movie's trying to say like he's not as good as he thinks he is I think that's the point yes If that's the point, then I think that the movie is a huge letdown. There's also not much more beyond that. That's kind of the thing. Yeah. Yeah. For me, at least. Yeah. Yeah. As Andrew mentioned, I have the movie has grown in my estimation over time. I would like to revisit it at some point, but I have no problem with it in this category. Let's see. Aaron, what is your final nomination? Oh, boy.

You guys pull in your audibles. You really like, I feel like there's two movies on my list that like should have been mentioned by now. And I don't know how to pick which one we officially need. Well, that's, that's the game. You can mention them both. You have to pick one. Only one gets to be nominated. So I think I've, I think I've kind of got worried. Like my first thought was a man of the lost quantomania. Okay. Um, but like, I know Robert like didn't expect much for that movie because he hasn't, but, but I mean, your top five anticipated dicer, but I'm going to officially pick chicken run. Dawn of the nugget. Hmm.

What a terrible choice. No, I'm just kidding. I'm just kidding. Quality comparison to the first movie, which admittedly, I think I'm a little bit lower on than most people, but like I found nothing to like in Dawn of the Nugget. Like it was totally fine and it's got its ardent charm sometimes. And like I would say, especially for big fans of the original, like skip this one because Zachary Levi is a completely different character. Like obviously a different voice, but nothing resembling Rocky from the first one. And I just, yeah, I don't have anything really good to say about Chicken Nugget.

I actually don't mind it in this category because I am one of those who have chicken run in my top 100 movies of all time. It's such a phenomenal movie. It's going to be a letdown. I would even say Dawn of the Nugget was a letdown for me as well. I was expecting more out of it, but I still really liked it. I think it does a good job, in my opinion, of disposing of a lot of the...

The initial things that a lot of movies feel like they have to do, like the movie basically goes, you know what you're getting. Let's go ahead and get into it. And then once you're into it, I have a lot of fun with it. But yeah, I think it's a letdown. I can go with that. All right. So here are the 12 nominees for biggest letdown. The four of us will now have to agree on the winner. And before we get into the nominees, previous winners of this category include Thor Love and Thunder last year as the biggest letdown. The Card Counter the year before that was the biggest letdown.

uh bright burn in 2019 uh won this category is the biggest letdown and the other one i wanted to mention was downsizing uh won this category in 2017 uh so there you go uh and let's see here are the nominees leave the world behind cocaine bear next goal wins the flash foe wish 65 luther the fallen son indiana jones in the dial of destiny pain hustlers the killer and chicken run dawn of the nuggets The goal here is for us to agree on something. Now, I know there were a couple of these that we both had as possible nominees. Robert, you and I both had Faux as a possible nominee. What was the other crossover you had with somebody, Robert? Cocaine Bear. Cocaine Bear. I also had Indiana Jones on my list. Indiana Jones was a crossover. So we can start thinking about those. If there are others you want to put into the mix as the official choice, feel free to shout them out. And we'll just we'll figure this out.

I will say that I have not seen Leave the World Behind. I didn't write it down because I knew Robert would mention it, but I agree with Leave the World Behind. I think I like that movie too much to agree on that one. Andrew, you haven't seen it, right? If all three of you were like, that movie was terrible and I expected a lot out of it, then I might relent. As soon as Andrew said Cocaine Bear, I was like, oh yeah, that's obvious. I, again, didn't have it written down.

I had other choices, but I would agree with Cocaine Bear. I think I like the movie less than even like Robert. Because I remember you being like, it's fine. It is what it is. I'm like, I had an okay time with it, but I wanted it to be a lot more. The problem kind of is, it isn't what it is. The problem with this movie is it isn't what it could have been. Like, you know, that it doesn't go there like once. And like, and you know, the rest of it is like chopped to bits. Like there's stuff in this movie that doesn't make sense because, you know, they cut it up so weirdly. I think it's Cocaine Bear. And I think we all can be in agreement on that. Yeah.

All right. The 2023 official biggest letdown of the year is Cocaine Bear. All right, let's move on to biggest surprise of the year. What is that movie that you went in with low expectations but had a pretty good time with? We'll start the nominations with you, Andrew. What is your first nomination for biggest surprise of the year?

Just because the first movie and this isn't a sequel, but the first movie was so atrociously bad. I had very low expectations, but Dungeons and Dragons Honor Among Thieves quickly rose to my top 10 movies of the year. And I was utterly surprised by how funny it was. The character development in this movie is spectacular. I mean, Michelle Rodriguez. It is not Michelle Rodriguez. Is it? Yeah. Okay.

shockingly good in this movie. Like she may be my favorite character in the movie. It's great. Very charismatic film. Good choice. Good choice. Did love me the D&D movie. I will go next. I'm going to say Godzilla minus one. Absolutely came out of nowhere and blew me away. It's the difference between, I guess, having low expectations and no expectations. I didn't even know this movie existed and all of a sudden it was being amazing in front of my eyes. And I'm like, hey, Aaron, can we review the new Godzilla movie? And you're like, the what? Yes, exactly. Exactly. Robert, what is your first nomination for biggest surprise?

Alright, so this has been Memes to Death, including on the Sif Pop Writers Room podcast, but this is genuinely a huge surprise for me, and it's Gran Turismo. Like, the trailers, I saw it a thousand and one times, and they looked just fine. I saw all the memes online, you know, for months before the movie even came out, and then, like, something happened in my life that I couldn't see it right when I wanted to, so I saw it a couple weeks late, and I went in. I had one of the best times at the movies I had all year. I think it's super fun. The racing scenes are awesome. The characters are okay, but, like, I think everything else has done so well that I just had such a great time, and I would almost say that I loved the movie.

Good pick. Yeah, I think it's a good pick too. I think Gran Turismo is a surprisingly competent and enjoyable film. So, you know, somehow better than the Michael Mann racing film that came out this year. So, yeah, Gran Turismo is a decent pick. Aaron, what's your first nomination? Well, given that three of my nominations were already knocked off the board here. You're going to have to dig for nominees. I'll kick things off. No, I wrote down like 20 for this category because I know that that was going to happen.

So there's a movie that came out that you're going to be like, Aaron, what are you thinking? And I didn't see it for the longest time because I had no interest. And then Robert was like, Hey, it's kind of enjoyable. So you know what? Movie that surprised me in a good way. I had a good time with 80 for Brady. Like, Oh, I didn't get around to seeing this. It's kind of, it's kind of really fun. It's a brisk, like 90 minute kind of golden girls esque. Yeah. Sure. Good for you, Aaron. Yeah. Yeah. I love that choice. I just haven't seen, I haven't seen the movie. So I, you know, I have no comment, but I believe it. I believe it could be fun. My mom totally agrees with you by the way. She loves it. Like it's worth watching for free.

Yeah, yeah. Yeah, it is. I should get that on my list. Make sure I check that out. Andrew, what is your second nominee? This is a movie that surprised me just because I didn't know anything about it. And that is Bottoms. Bottoms blew me away with how good it is. Besides D&D, it may be the funniest movie of the year.

Did it win anything at the Critics' Choice Award? No, it was nominated for Best Comedy, but I can't convince enough of my fellow critics to actually award a genre comedy of the award. I'm working on it. Instead of a dramatic movie that has funny stuff in it? Yes, yes. My personal opinion is if it could win Best Picture, then let's go ahead and give something else in the genre that can elevate the genre of the award. It's the one award I don't just vote for Best Movie. I actually do vote for Best Comedy, in my opinion. Anyhow.

Bottoms is my pick. Good choice. Good choice. My second nominee is Wonka. I thought this movie was going to be terrible. I really did. And it is not terrible. In fact, I really enjoyed it. I had a good time with it. And I thought Chalamet was surprisingly adept at playing a song in Dance Man. And I was not expecting that. So I had a really good time with Wonka. It is my second nominee. Robert, what about you?

I'm going to go talk to me here. I put off seeing this for a long time because people said it was going to be really scary. Aaron S. told me that it wasn't going to be that scary, and I normally trust his horror opinions, and I went in and I was terrified, and that never happens in movies. So I still hold that against him. But it's really good thematically. It has really good characters. Obviously, like I said, it has great scares. Yeah, it just kind of came out of nowhere for me, and it's stuck around with the top movies of the year.

Yeah, yeah. Talk To Me really stuck with me as well. And I think a lot of that has to do with the metaphor and the thematic stuff in it. Yeah, there's some really interesting ways they play with that metaphor in that movie that I really like. Sure, sure. That final scene is like one of the most horrifying things I've ever seen in my life. Yeah. It's the movie I've seen the most from last year. Oh, interesting. Oh, I don't want to watch it again. Me either, technically. I think I've seen it seven times. Wow. I don't think I've seen any movie from this year more than twice.

Yeah, I don't usually year of release see them too much unless it's La La Land and I just like watch it on repeat. But yeah. So Aaron, I think we're ready for your second nominee. Yeah. I'll throw out a movie that came out on, came to be because it was written, the article was written on the website and then Robert Watson is like, hey, backing up this four and a half star review because To Catch a Killer is really good. And it's on Hulu now, but it's like just under the radar, never, like kind of never heard of it, expected nothing because it's a Shailene Woodley, Ben Mendelsohn. I was like, oh yeah, I'll know what I'm in for. And like, kind of know what you're in for. Like it's not really gonna throw you a curveball anywhere, but like it's just really well done and really well like shot and performed, especially by.

Ben Mendelsohn and the killer but there's a like just the scenes of terror depicted in this movie are actually just really really horrifying like some of the scariest stuff scarier than talk to me in my opinion I praise I haven't seen this one so another one to put on my list to catch a killer nominated for a surprise Andrew your final nomination final nomination let's go with a movie I expected to be terrible and was surprisingly good Quiz Lady I think that the chemistry between Awkwafina and, please forgive me, Sandra Oh is perfection. It really is perfection. I mean, I totally 100% would believe that these two are siblings just by the dynamic between them and the dichotomy between them, how so different they are from each other. Yeah, the movie is absolutely hilarious, and it features a Will Ferrell performance that may be his best performance. I mean, he's not in the movie that much, but he has such an Alex Trebek slash Mr. Rogers-ness about him.

that is just so wholesome. I think he's great in this movie. I'm typically not a huge Will Ferrell fan. um although he was the only person at the awards i actually got a selfie with because my wife loves elf so much uh but uh but i do love him in elf uh but i think he's great in quiz lady and i think that's the kind of role i want to see him in i think he's terrible in barbie i think he's the worst part of that movie um i love him in barbie do you really yeah i really do uh i think he breaks the movie um but uh but yeah it is uh it is it is definitely good to see him in this you know kind of role so yeah i think he's a good choice he does remind me of matrix resurrections in barbie so maybe that's why i love you guys fair that's fair uh all right my final nominee for biggest surprise is are you there it's me margaret um was not expecting a ton out of this uh rachel mcadams is incredible in it and uh everybody is actually everybody in this movie is so good the movie is so heartfelt so beautiful um i really really love this movie was not expecting a judy bloom adaptation to be this amazing but it really is um so that is my final nominee

Robert, your final nominee? My final nominee is somewhat of a softer endorsement, but that's Hunger Games' Ballad of Songbird and Snakes. Sure. Went in with no expectations. I've seen the third and fourth Hunger Games movies one time each, just never really super got into it. But I was really, really loving this one up until they leave the games. And after that, I really soured on it. But I think everything before they leave is just really excellent, really great. It's interesting to see the behind-the-scenes workings of the Hunger Games themselves and why they're done and the rationale behind the people doing them.

That's all really interesting and isn't really done in the original four movies. So for that alone, I thought it exceeded my expectations. I agree. I really like Songbirds and Snakes. I was worried and therefore had some low expectations that it was going to be Fear the Walking Dead, where it's like the promise of what the thing is doesn't live up to what you were expecting. I expected that show to be like Origins of...

The Walking Dead and basically just turned into The Walking Dead within three episodes. And this is like, no, it's legit the origins of The Hunger Games. And it feels like you're really getting a sense for the world building here and the society and why it is the way it is. Yeah, I really enjoyed it and I'm excited to see kind of where they go from there. So, yeah, that's a good choice. Aaron, what's your final nominee? Is it possible to nominate a movie I haven't seen?

Listen, you can make whatever noises come out of your mouth that you want to make come out of your mouth. Like you can say whatever words you want to say. It's your choice. I would expect some ridicule possibly. Here's my thought. You can ridicule me. You can veto me. You guys can do what you want. But the biggest surprise of the year is Sound of Freedom and its box office run, right? Like, when are we going to get the documentary about that?

I want the dumb money of Sound of Freedom, you know? Yeah, yeah. I have seen Sound of Freedom. I know Andrew has seen Sound of Freedom. I think Andrew would probably qualify it for Biggest Surprise. It didn't really live up to it for me. I have no interest in the movie, but it's a surprise, right? Nobody mentioned it in the Summer Sums game, and it made, what, how many? Like 490 or so? I don't know that it fits like the...

The heart of the category, really. The heart of the category is, like, movie you had low expectations for, but that was great. That's kind of the heart of the category. I understand what you're saying. Well, we'll let that slide. Then I'll mention No Hard Feelings. Yeah, that's a good choice. Because I had no expectations for it, and the first, like, two-thirds of that movie is really funny and really good, and it just loses its legs when it wants to stop being a comedy. As does want to happen sometimes.

All right, there you go. Those are the nominees for Biggest Surprise. I will list them off for you. Before we do that, some previous winners. Last year, you remember last year's winner was Top Gun Maverick. It was the biggest surprise of the year. Barb and Star has won this. Palm Springs. Ready or Not was one that was chosen for this category. And then back in 2017, Get Out won this category for Biggest Surprise of the Year, which seems funny now because it's so widely considered to be one of the greatest movies ever made. But that year, I don't think anybody was expecting Jordan Peele to make one of the greatest movies ever made. So yeah, there are some of the previous winners.

of that category. Here are the nominees this year. Dungeons and Dragons Honor Among Thieves, Godzilla Minus One, Gran Turismo, 80 for Brady, Bottoms, Wonka, Talk to Me, To Catch a Killer, Quiz Lady, Are You There, God? It's Me, Margaret, Hunger Games, Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, and No Hard Feelings. Where's our crossover here? I think it's between two. I think so as well. I think it's between Godzilla Minus One and Talk to Me. I was going to say Godzilla Minus One and Dungeons and Dragons. I think that's where...

It sounded like that's where everybody's headspace was. When those got mentioned, everybody was like, oh, yeah, that's what I would easily go Godzilla. I don't want to spoil it, but we'll be talking about that for me again later towards the end of the episode. So, hey, that's a sweep then. I think it's Godzilla minus one. I think that fits this category really, really well. So the official SIF pop biggest surprise of the year. Godzilla minus one. All right. The only reason I didn't have it on mine is because, you know, I'm a giant Godzilla fanboy and I just expected to love the movie. Right.

right uh okay let's move into the two most difficult categories to come to a consensus on because they are defined by their non-consensus so we are picking the things that we believe everybody else loved but we didn't or everybody else hated but we loved and because of that it probably means the other three people love the thing we're gonna pick or hate the thing we're gonna pick uh so let's start with overrated or the thing that uh i just didn't get the thing that we just didn't get um let's see who hasn't started i don't think i've started yet uh so i will kick us off And I will say, I'm just going to throw this one out there because I'm ready for the hate. I think Sisu is completely overrated. I do not understand this movie, why everybody loves it so much. Well, I should restate, I do understand why everybody loves it that much, but the reasons they love it don't make it a great movie. It's just not fun for me to watch. Aaron, I 100% agree with you. Really? I thought you loved Sisu. No, I think it's pretty overrated. Go ahead.

I would say there's narratively nothing to the film at all. Yeah. So the other part of this is also how much everybody else loves something can factor into it well. And Sisu is definitely one I just heard people chirping about a lot. And so, yeah, that is my first nominee. I was just thinking like...

I don't think it was very highly rated. I mean, sitting at like a 3.3 on Letterboxd, I guess that's like pretty good. And sure, I guess overrated. It's fine. I'm with Dicer on this one because whenever I mention this movie or I hear somebody else mention it, somebody will always go, oh, Sisu is great, man. And I didn't mean to do a bro voice there that just came out. That's not saying that only bros can appreciate Sisu. It is a bro-ish movie, though, that machismo, tougher than I'll get, over-the-top violent kind of movie. Yeah. Robert, what's your first nomination for a movie that you just didn't get? All right.

Mine is just all very hot takes. I'm going to start with Blackberry, and I don't know if I've seen anyone else say they didn't like it. I love Blackberry. Exactly, because I think this one and another one I'll mention later are just the bones without the meat of a type of successful movie that we've seen in the past. So this is the bones of the social network, and I don't get any of the meat of it. I will admit it's very entertaining to watch, but by the end, it just left me very emotionally and intellectually slash thematically cold.

interesting i agree with your reasoning but not i can see your reasoning i guess i took more from it i guess i really i really liked what i felt it had to say about the idea of um uh what's the word i'm looking for uh pride and um you know avarice and those kind of things and the the comeuppance in the movie i thought was was really good and had something to say about you know what happens when you let that stuff you know blind you but i just didn't get any of the foundations of uh what's his name the main character uh I'm blanking on his name, but I didn't get any of the foundations of his characters or reasoning for being prideful or anything like that. It's just like all of a sudden he is. I don't know why. No, I can understand that. Blackberry is Robert's first nomination. Aaron, what is your first nominee? I'm going to lose all my reputation in this category. We all are. That's what this category is. I know what you're about to say.

I think. You'll know what I'll say second, but I'll say talk to me. It's just not for me. It was a movie not for me. Maybe it was like my context. I had a friend that was hyping this movie up for months and telling me like, it's supposed to be the scariest movie. Okay. And I saw it with a movie and I'm like, it's okay. It's fine. I don't know that I want to see it again. It's not hereditary, you know? No, because it's good. Yeah, it's better. Shots fired. Oh boy. Aaron on Aaron violence over here. Sorry, I had to. Yeah. Okay. No, it's...

I think I understand what you're saying. In fact, I've heard that from other friends about talk to me is and I think I think my perspective is that it boils down to going into it with an expectation of a scary movie. And I don't, I don't think this is meant to be a horror. Like, I think there's, this is meant to be more than that. It's meant to be different than that. It's meant to be Get Out than Hereditary. I think this really falls into the movies I wish I could see, I saw again before the 50s. It's maybe like the best way to define this category for me. Like, maybe I just didn't get it the first time. Like, I'm certainly interested in giving Talk To Me Another Shot. And probably will do, especially since Best Buy is, Best Buy is just trying to get rid of their Blu-rays at this point. Yes, they are.

All right, Mr. Armsby, what is your first nominee for a movie that you didn't get that everybody else seemed to? Everybody else, you can calm down. You don't have to worry about everybody going, oh, what were you thinking? Because I have the ultimate just wasn't for you movie that's going to make everybody else mad.

That's Guardians of the Galaxy. Yeah. See, see, the bar has been set. You guys don't have to worry about saying anything else. Taking the bullet. Yep. No, it just, I couldn't vibe with it, man. I couldn't vibe with it. The, um, I thought it was a visually a grosser movie than I was wanting it to be. Um, uh, not, that's not only for the, uh,

uh, the animal cruelty thing that was going on, like to make rocket and everything like that. I'm talking about like, there was a planet that they went to or a facility they went to that was a living organism that they had to, yeah, no, I knew exactly what you were talking about when you said gross. Yeah. Like it, it just didn't work for me. Now there are parts of the movie that are extraordinary. I think that the rocket story arc is great. I think that that whole thing that they did with his backstory and his origin and the, um, I forget what his name is. I think he's the architect or something like that. But, uh,

I think that that villain is very well thought out. But just overall, the movie just from the level everybody else loved it, I couldn't get to that level. I understand. Makes sense. These are the categories where we all get to be wrong every time. Set the parameter, everyone. You're safe. Aaron, I think Aaron has a bigger one coming by the looks on his face. So we'll see. I don't think mine are going to be... I'm not going to drop any bombs with my other nominations simply because they're artsy films that probably not a lot of people have seen that people love and I just go, I don't understand. And I'm going to start with Passages. This is a very artful movie that does some interesting things. I just found it inert and just...

difficult to maintain interest in. I think much of that has to do with how much I disliked the characters. And that's okay. It's okay for a movie to contain a lot of characters that have those human qualities. But the movie didn't seem to give me a way in to understand what I'm learning from their personality types and their...

They're conundrums. So Passages is my next movie that I just didn't get. The main character is kind of just like, this guy sucks, and look how he's a jerk to everyone, and then it's done. Yeah. Thank you, Robert, for summing it up. I like it a little bit more than you, but I definitely see where you're coming from. All right, Robert, what's your next movie you didn't get? All right, and the same thing as Blackberry being a social network light. Air is Moneyball Light. Oof, I really like air. Okay.

Pun intended, it's airy to me. It's very entertaining. It's very funny. But again, it doesn't have that weight. It just has the bones. Whereas Moneyball, you're more invested in the father-daughter relationship and this guy keeping his job. This feels like Nike propaganda a lot of times. And I understand wanting to give credit to the grunt laborers who do the work. But at the end of the day, it's still Nike, the multi-billion dollar company. That's so interesting. The last thing I just want to say real quick is that I'm never invested in Matt Damon as a character. They're all just like vehicles to get the Nike shoe made. He says like,

he hasn't been home or whatever he needs to get the money for this and that but i don't it doesn't show anyone else in his life it's just him saying that bug me yeah i think i think what i'm i'm willing to give you uh because i'm just so gracious is that uh that making the sunny character feel like the main protagonist is kind of confusing in this movie because i think this movie is about dolores jordan i think this is a movie about the jordan family and about her strength and the speech that she gives towards the end of that movie gives that movie all the weight it needs for me like there's there's this this thing the movie is doing about um how people uh take a stand against big companies, or at least in cooperation, but, you know, getting theirs or whatever, that is really interesting to me. And, I mean, Viola Davis can do no wrong. She's so incredible in that scene. So that's where the movie finds its way for me. But what you're saying is correct. The Sonny Vaquero character is just a weird piece to build the movie around, I think. Yeah. I get what you're saying, but then when it's literally Michael Jordan, it kind of loses it also. Like it was just some guy taking a stand, but then it's Michael Jordan. Yes, yeah. But it's not, it's Dolores Jordan. And there is a slight difference, you know? Yeah, yeah, I see it.

All right. Let's see. So I think we're Aaron. Are we to your second? I think so. Yeah. I think that Oppenheimer's and I'm kidding. But does it soften the blow when I say that my real pick is killers of the flower moon? Oh, I knew it. Yeah. I don't think it justifies its runtime. And while I think that the last scene of what Scorsese is trying to say in that scene, my rebuttal is that don't make the movie. Like if your whole point is you shouldn't be making the movie, then don't make the movie. And I think the movie ultimately is better served if it's from the perspective of the indigenous people as opposed to the white people trying to kill them.

which I guess is a step better from when it was initially proposed as supposed to be about the Jesse Plemons character. I think the movie is good. It's going to get a Best Picture nominee, and that's fine with me, but I get that the craft's there, and the messaging is good. This to me is overrated. Not for me, but overrated. Okay. I would agree that it doesn't deserve a front time. What did you say, Andrew?

I was saying that I agree with Schweitzer that it does not deserve its run time. I actually think the movie could have been shorter, too. I do think Scorsese, this late stage, Scorsese is really taking advantage of his ability to really live in his movies. I do not blame him for that, nor do I think it's necessarily a bad thing overall, because there is something to be said for really finding that breathing room. I mean, his last three movies are all over three and a half hours, right? I mean, Silence was, I think, over three and a half, and The Irishman, I know, was over three and a half. I don't know that Silence was three and a half, but I feel like it was 240-ish.

Wall Street and Silence are like high two, low threes. Andrew will let us know how long Silence was. I was almost sure. Was it at least three? What was it? 245. Okay. So he's finding this space to make the movies he wants to make, and that's fine. The difficulty is you lose some of the power of tightening those things up. And I do think Killers of the Flower Moon could have been a tighter film. As far as who gets to tell what story, I think it's a valid conversation to have.

I am glad Steven Spielberg made his version of The Color Purple. I think that's a valuable movie for the time. I am glad now that we have a version of The Color Purple that is made by a person of color. And that is important. But it's one of those things where I think at the end of the day, you can only do your best at what you want to do. And Scorsese wanted to tell this story. And I think he did it about the best way he could figure out how to do it. And I found the end to be pretty powerful. And there's value in auto-critique too, like critiquing what you're doing.

especially the systems in place that only allow people like him to make movies like that for such a long time. Well, a great example of this is Watchmen, the TV show, right? Like Damon Lindelof headed that up, but he did so in a very purposeful way to tell a black story. Well, you know, Corey Jefferson, who wrote and directed his first movie, American fiction this year, phenomenal movie, basically did the Watchmen. Like he was one of the go-to writers and directors in that show. And like, so you like, I think there is a way for places of, of privilege.

to elevate, right? And hopefully that's what Scorsese is doing here. But yeah, I think it's a valid conversation to have and to continue having as we grow as a culture. So yeah, Killers of the Flower Moon, most overrated. Andrew, what is your second nominee?

Killers of the flower. It is the killer indication. The killer killer. You have the reason why I'm having this on. I just wasn't for me is because I think that this movie, not just for you, Dicer, but I think this movie for a lot of people has grown. If it wasn't already, you know, in their liked or loved category that this movie is growing on a lot of people, but it's just not for me. All right. The killer is the second nomination for Andrew. Okay. Final nominations for movie. I just didn't get it. I'm going with the taste of things. I.

I think I talked in my ballot episode a little bit about this movie. Um, this is, you know, the official selection for, uh, you know, best independent film, uh, from France. Uh, it is boring as all get out. I do not like, look, if you like to watch people cook food, fine. That's fine. If you feel like you haven't seen enough movies that use food as a metaphor for sensuality, fine. Okay, fine. Uh, but like, it's just, it's very, very boring to me and I don't see why everybody loves it. So that is the taste of things. Has anybody else here seen the taste of things? All right.

Well, I would recommend. You don't bother, but that's just me. Robert, what do you have? I'm between three last ones, and we're all going to hurt someone's feelings. Well, mention as many as you're brave enough to mention. I'm just going to say the one, my nominee, and I think I'm going to go with Maestro. Maestro, speak to it. That's the one I think is most overrated out of the ones left. I get what people see in the filmmaking, but I don't get what people see in the emotion of it. Because I...

Because Bradley Cooper knows how... Look at Andrew's face right now. Bradley Cooper knows how to make a movie. That Mahler scene broke me. I'll say that's the one movie, the one scene that I felt it, you know. I'm Team Robert on this one. My wife was in the room and she's been in orchestras and choirs her entire life. And she was like, how can anyone even follow what he's conducting right now? She had no idea how that was going. And that really colored my impression of that scene. I imagine that would. I imagine that would, yeah. That's not what I've heard, by the way. That's fair, yeah. But yeah, no. As a whole, the filmmaking...

Bradley Cooper knows how to make a movie, but it seems like a lot of the shots feel unmotivated, except for a couple here and there. Specifically, there's one with people in the line as Felicia walks away, and it stays focused on her. That's really cool. But it kind of just throws in the Felicia stuff at the end of her getting sick, to me at least. And then after the whole movie of just showing him being just a jerk to her, basically, and not respecting their relationship, it felt unfocused, and I couldn't get on its wavelength.

Interesting. I think the movie is talking about her taking ownership of their relationship and the idea that because the movie is very clear, she knew what she was getting into. There is a way to say he was not respecting their relationship. Let me be very clear. I do believe that his cavalier-ness, if nothing else, was a disrespect to their relationship. However, the movie lays out a foundation of she says things like, I know what I'm getting into. I'm an adult. We're adults here. I understand this. So I think that the...

the tug and pull of that which by the way is the quote that the movie you know sets us up with is that tuck and pull of where meaning is where you know truth is um that that's where art is uh is it's kind of the heart of the movie so i didn't see it as him just being a jerk i saw it as them figuring out what this partnership meant to them It's also, he has that quote at the beginning, the one that stood out to me, where he talks about the difference between a composer and a conductor and how you need a different type of person to be each one. When he said that, I was like, oh, that's really interesting. I'm going to keep an eye out for that. And then kind of like Aaron Blackberry, I just saw a lot of that and not a lot of why for that thematic through line. All right. All right. Well, this is what the category is for. Both Andrew and Aaron thought they had the biggest bomb to drop, and I think Robert just dropped it. So Aaron, what is your next nominee for a movie you just didn't get?

It's hard to call this movie overrated, right? Here's the thing, though. I think that the Super Mario Brothers movie is a genuinely bad and unfunny movie. Okay. And so the fact that people came away going, yeah, it's fine, or I liked it, or it's good for kids. I think it's a genuinely bad and unfunny movie, and so I didn't even want to finish it. So, boom. There you go. The Super Mario Brothers movie is Aaron's final nominee. Andrew, what is your final nominee? Soft pitch here. Easy enough. Punching down on somebody. Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny.

That's an interesting one to pick because I didn't see a lot of love for this movie. Yeah. It got bombed out of whatever festival it premiered at. Yeah. Oh, well, maybe I just am talking to the wrong people then. I think it's because you hang out with me and I liked it. But yeah. Fair enough. All right. There are the nominees for most quote unquote overrated or the movie that we didn't get. Previous winners in this category are Fall. That was last year's winner. Come on, come on.

one uh one year robert shaking his head uh as are many other people that is the point of this uh but you had to agree to it you weren't you on that episode maybe i was on that episode yes yes that was the situation that was a tough one uh by the way also on this list uh aaron will be glad to know going back to 2018 hereditary was uh voted the most overrated uh movie that year so uh There's a theme for a couple years there. It goes The Killing of a Sacred Deer, Hereditary, and The Lighthouse. So it's like those weird, gross movies. Our house horror films. Horror films that people love that we just didn't get. All right. So let's talk about the nominees this year. Sisu, Blackberry, Talk to Me, Guardians of the Galaxy, Volume 3, Passages, Air, Killers of the Flower Moon, The Killer, The Taste of Things, Maestro, Super Mario Brothers movie, Indiana Jones, and The Dial of Destiny. At least two locks for Best Picture nominations in our most overrated category. Where do we want to land here, guys? Where's some crossover? What are you guys thinking? Sisu?

I didn't see Sisu because Sally saw Sisu by the seashore. I didn't see it because I think I heard basically you guys talking about that you didn't like it and I just took it off my ever-growing watch list at the end of the year. So maybe that's worth something. Have you seen it? Yeah, it's fine. But I just don't know.

Again, it sits at like a 3.3 on letterbox. So you don't think it's well-loved enough to really fit the heart of this category? It's got a 6.99 IMDb. Like, I guess it's got a 94 Rotten Tomatoes. Like, that's obnoxiously high for this. But like, yes, I disagree with overrated. I get like, or even like not for you. That's fine. Like, I understand and even get that. But I don't know if it's something like, I'm kind of team Robert on air. Like, where I'm like, it's kind of missing that oomph for me. And so it's a three-star movie. Or again, like for me, Mario Brothers, like the fact that that movie made a billion dollars at the box office is just dumb.

to me like um i the killer is another movie not for me um and i even watched it after i think listening to this podcast episode so like kind of knowing what the movie was intending for i'm like oh i just don't think it landed um okay to me so to me i struggle with with sisu because i don't i think it's kind of properly rated except for rotten tomatoes i think that's a valid perspective to bring to the table uh robert that's the choice i'm also like fine with that um I'm trying to calibrate my own thoughts on the killer because I think I'm kind of like you, Dicer, where it's gone up since I saw it, but I haven't gotten the chance to revisit it. And I don't know how much more I'll get out of it because looking back, I do like that he's bad at his job, but I don't know how much more there is than that. And I still had other problems with it. So that might be worth it. I know my other picks aren't really going to be in the conversation. So I don't know. Yeah, I'm persuaded by the Super Mario Brothers argument. I don't know if we want to consider that. It really feels like it fits the category in a strong way in that.

It depends on what you mean by movies that everybody got but me, because you could talk about Rotten Tomatoes scores, you could talk about critical acclaim, but you could also talk about just the general populace, which I think is probably a more valid thing to think of when we think of this category. Like you said, it made a billion dollars, and people loved that movie, and it's just not that good. I like that pick. I'm kind of persuaded by the Super Mario Bros. choice. What do you think, Robert? My one small pushback against it, I'm not going to argue for the movie, but for the overrated part.

I don't know. I didn't see much discussion of it too late into the year. And Super Mario is Super Mario. Like, every kid in the entire world loves Super Mario, so that kind of gets you to the box office. So I don't know if the box office is necessarily an accurate argument for the overratedness of it, or its high rating. Yeah, and it has a 59% on Rotten Tomatoes, so it's not like the critics loved it either. What's the audience score? The audience score is 95%. And it's got a 7 on IMDb. About 46 Metacritic score, you know?

It's clearly a drawn line between the critics and audience on this one. If we can't agree on anything else, it would probably be the best. I like Robert's argument of like, with kids' films, kind of asterisk the box office. Especially the amount of spin-offs that they've announced about this movie. I'm like, I don't even want a sequel. I'll go ahead and say it. Peaches, not the best.

I don't get the love for that song. And also not the best Peaches reference in a pop culture property this year. That would go to Blue-Eyed Samurai. Which we were going to be talking about later. It sounds like we've kind of tossed up Sisu, The Killer, and Mario Brothers. Those have gotten some strong consideration, yes. I don't know if there's anything else to consider, but any of those three could be fine with me. Maestro? It's just really what we want to... It's definitely not going to be that one. What's the factor that you want to most consider? Right, right.

I'm leaning Super Mario, and one of the main reasons is we've all seen it, which I think helps that out. Although we've all seen The Killer too, right? All four of us have seen The Killer. I think I like it the most, so it would probably be up to me to relent on that one. That's also one of those where I think critics and audience are divided on that one as well, right? Yeah, that's true. I don't remember what the audience score on The Killer was. Significantly lower than critics' score, I'm pretty sure. Yeah, it's an 86-61 audience score, so yeah, it doesn't necessarily check both boxes either.

These are always the toughest ones. You can choose each one of those for a different criteria. I'm going to throw Super Mario Brothers movie out there for this category. And just like you're sitting in an exit row on an airplane, I'll need a verbal yes from everybody that you understand. Robert? Aaron? Yes. Andrew?

Yeah. All right. Super Mario Brothers movie is the official overrated movie of the year. Let's move on to an equally difficult category. The most underrated, the movie that you got that nobody else seemed to get. We will start the nominations with Aaron. What is your first nomination for a movie that you got that nobody else did? I think I only have like one legitimate pick for this category because I think most things were properly rated this year. Even my underrateds, I wasn't super strong on. And I'll pick Extraction 2.

I think it's way leaps and bounds better than the first one, which was just a forgettable, cool-looking action movie with only memorable thing about it being a seven-minute one-er. I think Extraction 2 is the best shot action movie in a long time. Sure, the characters are as shallow as a kiddie pool, but I don't know what you were expecting. I watched it for the cool action. I think Sam Hargrave just really directs this movie well. All right. Extraction 2, the first nomination. Andrew, what about you? Bo is afraid.

This movie was made for me. I mean, if you want to know what it's like to have bipolar disorder, watch this movie, because what he goes through is like scarily close to what it was like internally for me whenever I had my manic episode a couple of years back and where I had to quit the show for a while. So. Yeah, what he's going through visually is different, but you can see tonally. I didn't see a giant penis monster attacking me whenever I was going through my manicness. But close. No, I'm joking. But no, this movie feels like it was made for me. All right. Bo is afraid in a movie that I got that others didn't. My first nominee in this is going to be theater camp. I think this movie is very underrated. I love this movie a lot, a lot, a lot. And it just kind of came and went and didn't hear a lot of love for theater camp. So that is my first nominee.

uh robert um this is one that has fairly low scores and that and not many people have seen it i've talked on a few different podcasts now and that's called she came to me um which is a ridiculous rom-com starring peter dinklage and hathaway and marissa tome um it's wild but i kind of love it because uh I don't want to spoil it because so many people haven't seen it, but it goes into so many different avenues that in any other movie, you would take it very seriously. But it doesn't really take it as seriously because it is more interested in being a little bit of a heightened rom-com that just says, hey, true love is a thing and we should all love each other and explore what makes us happy. Yeah, I just need to harp on this movie, how great it is every time I get a chance because not many people have seen it and it's ridiculous and fun.

I like this choice. I didn't love Love This Movie, but I really like this movie. I like more where it ended than where it began. I think it takes a while to kind of get going. But once you kind of know the characters, I think the journey is really interesting. So yeah, I like that pick. That's a good pick. She Came to Me as Robert's pick. Aaron, what is your second nominee? I think this movie is generally well-liked, but I just think I love it more than everybody else. I'll go with Creed 3. Again, I think Michael Jordan really directs this movie well.

Probably a step down from the original Creed, but it's leaps about better than Creed 2 and excellent performances by Michael B. Jordan and Jonathan Majors and Tessa Thompson as well. I really dug this movie. It stayed in my top five for most of the year. All right. Creed 3 is the second nominee from Aaron. Andrew, what is your second nominee? I'm going to go with a movie that is under scene, I think, more than anything.

Knock at the Cabin. I think that this is a really good Shyamalan movie. I loved that this movie didn't really have a twist. I know Shyamalan is really known for his twist. This one was just kind of a straight, like you didn't know until the very end whether it was real or not. But at the same time, I don't consider that a twist. I think that's a narrative driving force more than anything. Because it's a twist if it happened or if it didn't happen. Like, it's not really a twist if any outcome is acceptable. The twist would be if, you know, something completely different happened the night before the world was going to end. But no, I think Dave Bautista has given a really good performance in this. I think that it came out at the beginning of the year. So maybe it was just underseen or maybe just people forgot about it. But I think that it's a really good Shyamalan movie.

I like this choice as well. Knock at the Cabin is what, like 2.9 on Letterboxd? And I do think plenty of people saw this movie, and I do think plenty of people didn't like this movie. So it's hard to see through my Shyamalan bias sometimes. I tend to defend most of his stuff. Not all, but most. What about The Last Airbender? Hey, we don't need to bring that up. We will have another one coming to us soon that we can.

either destroy or love. Um, so yeah, not gonna happen. It's a good choice. My second choice for movie. I got that a lot of people didn't is very under scene. And I think that's the primary reason, but I'm going to go with artifice girl here just to give it another shout out. Um, I, I really, really enjoyed this movie and, uh, love everything it had to say, love the way that it said it has some great performances in it. Uh, if you have a chance to check out the artifice girl, please check it out. Uh, Robert, what about you? Uh, I'm going to push back against an earlier pick and say next goal wins. Um, surprisingly, even to myself, because I've not really enjoyed the,

Tycho being the Marvel guy recently and Star Wars guy. But this isn't as great as some of his earlier movies before he officially came over to Hollywood. But I think it's much better than it's gotten credit for. It is very fun. It has a great sense of humor. Even though Michael Fassbender starts off shaky, I think he eventually sides into the overall tone and feel of the movie. It's not particularly deep. It's not innovative at all. It's just a solid three and a half star for me.

People really didn't like it, and I just had a very good time with it. Definitely fits this category. If you enjoyed it, next goal wins. Aaron, what is your third and final nominee? Yeah, going again towards the under-scene side of this, I'll re-mention To Catch a Killer. All right. Catch a Killer. Andrew, what about you? Final nomination, a movie that I thought everybody loved, and then it turned out that apparently I was on an island. That's The Creator.

They did it. Yeah. Great choice for this category, though. I thought that everybody loved this movie, which there are a bunch of people that do. But I guess the vast majority just kind of went by the wayside. And that's shocking because I think Gareth Edwards is such a phenomenal director. He proved you don't have to make a $300 million movie to make a visually impressive film. I mean, the guy is talented. He also proved that nothing has to make sense to make a visually impressive film, too. Wait, no, I'm sorry. I'll take it. I'll take it. Zack Snyder proved that first.

My next pick is Rebel Moon. The creator fits this category very, very well. And glad you threw that out there, Andrew. My final is The Teacher's Lounge, which, again, a lot of people haven't seen. Not near enough conversation on this movie. Maybe the best conundrum movie of the year. If you don't know about The Teacher's Lounge, it's an international feature. I forget which country this is from. Let's see if I can look that up. But it is...

It is one of those movies where you are with your protagonist as they try to make every right choice and every right choice they make makes things worse. And so it leaves you with one of these conundrums of what was the wrong choice, the right choice then? Are the ends the important thing? Are the choices we make along the way the important thing? It is a really, really beautiful, beautiful film. And I think more people need to see it. I absolutely loved it. It's called The Teacher's Lounge.

It's Germany's. Yes. Yes. This is Germany's official entry for the Oscars. OK, Robert, final nominee. Another soft endorsement, but I'm going to go with Napoleon, which was pretty middling to dislike to cross the board. That's another one visually very impressive, which you shouldn't be surprised by with Ridley Scott doing something historical. I think you don't really understand the characters very much. But at the same time, you get the very surface level. You know, this guy, he started the Napoleon complex for a reason. And this is a guy who.

Yeah, he's just a little bit of a loser and he's petty and that's kind of why he ruined Europe for a long time. So it has that surface level idea along with just being the well-made historical war movie that Ridley Scott is an expert at. There you go. All right. We have our nominees for most underrated or movie I got that others didn't. Before we list them off, some previous winners. Last year's winner was, anybody remember? Bullet Train. Bullet Train was last year's winner for most underrated. M. Night has made this category before. Old was a previous winner for most underrated. Tenet was most underrated the year it came out. And then Bad Times at the El Royale was one of my favorites that won this category.

2018, Only the Brave, another good one that a lot of people haven't seen that won this category too. So let's talk about it. Extraction 2, Bo is Afraid, Theater Camp, She Came to Me, Creed 3, Knock at the Cabin, The Artifice Girl, Next Goal Wins, To Catch a Killer, The Creator, The Teacher's Lounge, or Napoleon. Felt like there was a pretty clear winner here, but I want to hear it from you guys as well if you felt the same way. So what are some of your thoughts about where the consensus might lie? If your thought was The Creator, you're wrong. My thought was not The Creator. Okay, I don't hate it, but I didn't love it. Yeah, no?

I would just say that, yeah, if we're going underrated over underseen, I think it's definitely Knock at the Cabin. Yeah. And I like that for this category because we've all seen it. It's a film a lot of people have seen. It's, you know, low rating, lower rating on Letterboxd, you know, lower rating on Rotten Tomatoes. And yet I think at least enough of us would agree it's actually a pretty good movie. Some of us would say it's a great movie that it belongs in this category. So congratulations, M. Night, just owning the underrated category the last few years. Knock at the Cabin is the official Cif Pop underrated movie of the year.

All right. That brings us finally to the best television of the year. We're each going to, uh, we're done with the nominations. We're just listing our top five. We will go around Robin from number five to number one and maybe give a few shout outs at the end, but, uh, let's get to it. Um, Robert, kick us off. What is your number five television show of the year? All right. So this is going to be a very Robert core list because this is, you know, if you know me or you'll know what I like, that's, you can probably predict list. Sorry. Number five. I think you should leave with Tim Robinson. Um, I only got into the show this year. Like I caught up when I just saw all the people, everyone posting stuff.

from the new season i was like all right i gotta watch this um there were like eight all-timer sketches for me the phone sketch the zip line the pig um the the egg game the drive-through the jason sportsman don't talk about your kids one like there were so many sketches that i love and i've already incorporated into my everyday references that again my wife is just more than tired of hearing them so um yeah i love the show and it's obviously it's not much deeper that's why it's only number five but number five out of 13 is still great That is a great choice. That show captures the comedy zeitgeist better than any show that I see. Like SNL, I still watch SNL. It's fun. It has its occasional great moments. The George Washington sketch, maybe one of the greatest sketches of the year. But the neighbor got to one, I should say. But Tim Robinson. You asked me about temperature.

So, so I do watch SNL, but SNL feels like it's not the zeitgeist, but Tim, but Tim Robinson, is that what it is? I think you should leave. That's the zeitgeist stuff. Like every single sketch is just like, it's easily memed. People just remember it. Like it feels like modern comedy. And it's got just enough cringe level to it to, you know, have that factor to it. Like it's, it's really interesting. So that's a great choice. Aaron, what is your number five? Oh, by the way, we are playing Trump roles. So if you do hear something, you have, we will do that. I have the last of us at number five. Very, very nice.

Oh, did somebody say Trump? Sorry. Yeah. Trump! There we go. Okay. Thank you, Andrew. I don't know why you waited so long to say it. Andrew, what is your number five? Demon Slayer. Ooh. Yes. I have animes on my list, ladies and gentlemen. I think Demon Slayer, this is not a hot take, by the way, is the most visually impressive anime ever made. Absolutely loved it. The Sword Village arc was fascinating. I still liked the...

the second season the most. The second season is one of the greatest seasons of any show ever. Yeah, just visually impressive, great characters. If you haven't checked it out, highly, highly recommended. All right.

Demon Slayer. Okay. My number five is Welcome to Wrexham. I love this show. It has not only turned me into a football fan as a fan of Wrexham, but it is the show that I think when it's on, I'm most like, oh, I can't wait to see the next episode. I'm so excited to see how that team is doing. The way they've tied it into the community is just perfect. It's just an understanding that it can't only be about the sports. It has to be about something bigger and the way they consistently make it about something bigger and more interesting.

um is really really cool and the fact that the story it reminds me of uh king of kong if you remember that documentary where as they're following the story it just gets more interesting and more interesting and more interesting they've got i don't want to say lucky necessarily but they've been very fortunate that the story's been really really interesting these first few years on what's happening with the team and how they're doing and now i follow both during the season live and so now my experience is like okay how are they going to show this next season like how you know um so it's it's it's interesting in that way like if you want to be spoiled uh you can be as far as like how the team is doing um literally planning to go see a rexum game when we're in the area uh in the fall So, um, get myself a scarf. You know what I mean? Like, it's like, who would have known, but the show has done that to me. So that's, that's my number five, uh, is welcome to Wrexham. So good stuff. Um, and it helps that, you know, Ryan Reynolds and, uh, Rob McElhinney are really fun to hang out with. Uh, that, that definitely helps a lot. Uh, Robert, you said the King of Kong thing earlier. I was afraid that you're going to say, oh no, is Ryan Reynolds or Rob McElhinney going to turn into a villain halfway through? And we're going to, they're going to put on a big giant wig mullet. Stay tuned. Uh, Robert, what is your number four? My number four is Barry. Okay. Yeah.

All right, Aaron, what is your number four? What We Do in the Shadows. Oh, nice. Speak on it. Cool. It's been two seasons since I believe that the show has been better than the movie. And while the show, I think, is... I think it had its heyday in season two. It's still really good. It's still really consistently funny. It's kind of like you mentioned. The characters are just really fun to hang out with. Obviously, I don't really want to hang out with them because I'll die pretty quickly. One way or another. But I love hanging out with the vampire gang in New York. And I think they...

Um, they managed to do some things, um, like some little things that are always really funny and managed to keep some like long story arcs. And, um, but, but at the same time, like, I'm, I'm happy that like the next season is going to be the last. Like, I think it's like, it's, it feels like that's where we're headed. It's like the show is feeling like it's wrapping up and I like that, but it's, um, it's, it's close to overstaying. It's welcome. Well, there you go. Very good choice. Uh, Andrew, what's your number four? This is where I have the last of us. Ah, speak on it.

Yes. Just as good, if not better than the game. Just because we get so much more character development in the show than it's supposed to in the game. I was like, David Fincher's the game? Why are you comparing? I was so confused there for a second. That's how out of video games I am. It literally took me that long to remember that The Last of Us was a game first. Don't you remember that episode of The Last of Us with Michael Douglas? Yes, yeah, it was really good. No, the show is phenomenal. Pedro Pascal is charismatic as all get. And the episode Long, Long Time is probably the best episode of TV this year.

Aaron, you had it at number five, is that right? Yeah. Talk a little bit. I think the game is super overrated, but that's because most people consider it the best game of all time, and it's fine. I think the show is really good.

Yeah, I think that the Pedro Pascal and Bella Ramsey are kind of really great as these characters and the story. I think the thing about the show that I really love about it is that it takes the story and the world of the game and builds upon them. As mentioned, Bill and Frank are kind of a footnote in the original game and to get their whole episode that is excellent is just really great and inspired. The show does do some like emotional manipulation, but like... you know anything that wants to pull the heartstrings like that's just kind of their go-to at this point consider me manipulated yeah it's good tv it's good tv uh all right my number four uh is another reality show no not all five will be reality shows i promise but a majority of them will be uh my number four is survivor uh which continues to be incredible television um i i'm blown away by how this show continues to just cast such interesting people and put them in interesting situations and just an incredible two seasons of survivor in 2023 uh enjoy both of them very very much um so it is my number four Robert, what is your number three? The Curse. Ooh, talk about it. Nathan Fielder, Emma Stone, Benny Safdie. It's everything that you would expect from a mix between a Safdie brother and Nathan Fielder with, you know, the reality TV, the off-kilter reality TV that kind of makes you uncomfortable with just everything going wrong from a Safdie brothers movie and you probably not liking any of the characters very much at all.

The ending, the season finale, I don't want to spoil it whatsoever because it's something. It's a swing, turns into a Michelle Gondry film somehow. Really don't want to spoil it for anyone if you haven't seen it. I think it works. I've stewed on it for a week now. We're going to talk about another Emma Stone performance later, I'm sure, but I think this is her best performance ever. The way that she was able to be such a garbage person in a naturalistic setting is just beyond anything that I've ever seen. I'm not surprised that she did it, but it's just still amazed that she is able to pull it off.

Not much happens throughout the show, but for some reason, I just couldn't wait every week to watch it. I love Nathan Fielder, and it's just everything that I would have wanted. I'm so glad you had it on your list. It didn't make mine. I am still, still stewing in this show's finale. And this is, you know, the road to hell is paved with good intentions, the TV show. And it is a road to hell. But are they good intentions? That's exactly what the show is making you ask. And it's like, there's a really interesting thing we do as humans where we don't realize how involved our ego is.

in our uh wanting to be a good person right so so being a good person means doing these things or saying this thing or not doing these things and not saying these things and we don't realize it's our ego that's driving that not necessarily the intent to be a a partner or help to somebody else in the world um so yeah this i think this show is kind of brilliant so i'm glad uh glad you brought it up for sure i am stewing on the finale meaning still but i will say that 100 got me emotionally like my anxiety was up and i felt it too yeah yeah it's it's a wild finale it is a wild finale Uh, all right. Uh, Aaron, what is your number three? I have shrinking here. I love this pick. Yeah. Um, shrinking is the first time that Harrison Ford has cared in 20 years. Uh, wow. And it kind of just really works. Uh, like he, cause he kind of gets to play, you know, his like grumpy self, but, um, I think the writing is really clever. It's of course a Bill Lawrence show, uh, and scrubs is my favorite comedy of all time. So like, of course it's going to work. Uh, it packs some emotional moments. I think it's messaging is really solid and it introduces some of my new favorite characters to hang out with. I, uh, um, yeah, I just, I really love shrinking.

Very nice. Good choice. Good choice. Andrew, what is your number three? Attack on Titan. It'll be the last of the animes on my list. I'm going to be one of the people who said, yeah, I was there whenever Attack on Titan was, you know, a thing. I was there when Titan was attacked. Yep. I was there. I was alive when Attack on Titan was streaming, and you had to wait a week in between each episode, and this was the final season. They wrapped everything up.

Japan would have the fecundity to be able to make a show like this. It's totally out of this world. It's otherworldly, even though it takes place on our planet. It's a great show. Definitely check it out. All right. That is Attack on Titan. My number three is Billions. Final season of Billions. I think this is one of the most underrated TV shows to ever exist. I think it's brilliant. I think the writing is incredible. You have to have a certain level of...

pop culture endurance to watch this show because In much the same way, like Sorkin will treat the characters as, you know, like nothing they say a human being would have the wit or cleverness to say, you know, in the moment. Everybody on this show has the exact correct sports or pop culture reference to go with every single situation. And it just slays me every single time. And I love living with these characters. There's an elevated reality to the show that I really, really enjoy. Plus, Paul Giamatti is Paul Giamatti. And I'm glad people are remembering that this year with the holdovers. He's so incredible in this show. And I just these I think six seasons is what it ended up being. I think they're worth a watch if you've never checked.

out billions to to uh go kind of put it on and see if it doesn't suck you in um because i just think it's really great stuff so billions uh is my number three um robert you're number two how to with john wilson is my number two um i have loved every single season of the show and um i just happened to watch the series finale on my birthday um and there's something very touching about the final line of the series i don't i guess i'm not gonna say it but like that really touched me at my core because the show at its core is about humanity and the shared humanness that everyone has no matter how weird or wacky or out there you may seem. John Wilson has this ability to, I don't know, put himself into these situations as such a timid guy.

and platform these people who are just trying to get by in their own way. There are so many different types of people that he shows. And even when he leaves New York, he just finds just like the most interesting types of people. And it really makes you think about what it means to be human, what it means to experience life on earth as we all just try to get through it. And yeah, I love it. And it goes meta in a really interesting way in the final season too, which I appreciated the effort there. So yeah, good choice. I'll see you with John Wilson. You're number two, Aaron. Barry.

Nice. A little bit of a slow start, but I think that just like where it gets to with the finale is it's just incredible. One of my favorite series finales of all time. And in a way that like I watched it with a group of friends and we were like, all right, let's sit down. We got to like talk about how insane that was, especially like when you consider how far the show has come since its first episode of the series, which was a straight up comedy with a slight bit of drama. And now it's a super dark drama with a lot of dark comedy, not a lot of like ha ha moments. And just kind of seeing like where the show has gone from there. And it's just.

I think Bill Hader is giving his absolute best behind it in front of the camera. Henry Winkler has been one of my favorite performances the last couple of years. Everything about the show just works for me. well uh take a take a drink of your mocktail because uh i'm about to drop a name but uh hater was at the table next to me at the awards this year and i i got to have like a five minute conversation with him on barry uh and it was a surreal experience to just talk to him about just like watching season four just like watching season four so uh so yeah it was uh it was really really cool and it was like he was one of those i love it when they do this um i i actually wasn't the one there were two of us talking to him and the other guy was like hey can i take a selfie and he did the thing where it's like look here's here's the thing if we take a selfie the mob comes So like, it's just like, I need to kind of get sitted down and situated. So, you know, he was so gracious about it. And I love that. I love, I love giving people in the limelight the right to be graciously, to turn those things down graciously. And, um, and he, he absolutely did that. So that was really cool. Um, but yeah, Barry is a, is a great choice in at number two. Uh, Andrew, what is your number two? It's going to get Trump. So get ready with the button, Aaron, the bear. All right. Uh, yourself.

He has the bear at number two and number one. What are you going to do? My number two, nobody's going to Trump. Maybe in the universe. I fell in love with a new reality show this year called The Traitors, and it is my number two show of the year. New season just dropping, by the way. Just started on Peacock. This brings together so many things I love about reality television, including many members of reality television casts that I've enjoyed watching in the past. In the first season,

Has the refields on it. I won't tell you how it all ends. I will tell you that she's on it for the entirety of the season. And not only her, but other amazing players from Survivor and Big Brother in different reality shows. The first season also had just people who had never been cast in reality TV before in their life that were on it as well. So it had some famous people in or some famous reality stars and then just the normies. Season two is all reality stars. And I'm not sure how I feel exactly about that. I'm liking the season so far. Just an incredible line of amazing strategic players.

But the basic idea is that game. I don't know how you've played it. Some people play it called Mafia. Some people play it called Murder. Some people call it Werewolf. The idea that every night somebody gets murdered and then the villagers try to figure out who the murderers are during the day. This is that game in reality show format. And it's done really, really well. And it's really cool. So The Traitors is on Peacock. It's my number two show of the year. How is Alan Cumming as the host? The best. He is so good. This takes place, they shoot it in Scotland. And he basically is the lord of the castle. And he just plays the role so perfectly. So yeah, he's a great host as well.

All right. Time for our number ones. No more trumping available. Robert, what is your number one show of the year? No surprise. It's succession, which actually has the best episodes of the entire year. Honor's wedding is one of the best episodes I've seen. The episode is one of the best episodes I've seen. The final episode is I, you know, this is one of those shows that you can have a thousand theories of how it's going to end. And it, the finale somehow lived up to all of those potential theories and potential, you know, ending points.

It's one of my favorite shows ever. I don't really know how to succinctly tell you how much I loved it. All the performances are great. Jeremy Strong, Kieran Culkin, Matthew McFadden, Sarah Snook, so many more. it ends thematically exactly when it needs to, you know, showing that humanity in these people is the reason why our system is broken. And it still always manages to be hilarious and entertaining. Yeah, that's about all I can say without just going down an hour-long rabbit hole. Succession is Robert's number one show of the year. I do not begrudge that pick. It is certainly my honorable mentions. Aaron, what is your number one of the year? I have the bear. As do I. Let's talk about it. You first. Tell us about your love for the bear. I have the first, I watched both seasons this summer.

kind of also in between two different restaurant jobs. And so like the... there's a scene in season one where the ticket is just going and going and going and like it just gives me anxiety um because like we've all like we those that have worked in food service like we've been in that situation um and uh and somehow what i thought was a perfect season one is just amplified to a perfect season two uh as mentioned i think before we started recording i think forks is the best episode of the year for tv um the fact that they took richie and made him such a scumbag from the free season and made me be like i really want this guy to succeed in season two should like be all that they're needs to be said about like the way that they treat their characters here because i thought richie was the biggest scumbag and hated him so much and now he's just like oh what's richie up to now and um yeah it just uh Just really intense, really, really great work all around the board. I agree. I second everything Aaron said. Yeah, it's a phenomenal, phenomenal undertaking that they made me care about fancy food. This is everything the Taste of Things thought it was, but it's so much better because there's so much character work going on here with each of the individual parts of what's going on. So many different moments where it just feels so human. Actually.

what's the is it spoons is that the one before forks uh no fishes which is the best episode yes you guys are wrong is that the christmas one yeah yeah no i stick with forks yeah i stick with forks too in fact what i was going to say i think a lot of people would say fishes fishes may be the weakest episode for me like it's it's it's a great episode of tv but like but but fishes does some things where it's like um It feels it's work a little harder than the other episodes because there are so many new characters that we're having to understand so quickly that I don't think it succeeds as well as the overall picture of all these characters. I mean, it's quite an impressive group of people they brought in. Yeah, its greatest strength is also its greatest weakness, right? Because I'm distracted that it's Jamie Lee Curtis and John Mulaney and Sarah Paulson, you know?

It's cool they got all those people. Burnfall works because we've gotten a lot with Burnfall before. But the rest of them, it's a little more difficult. But even in that it succeeds, but I think it succeeds better even in the other stuff. The Bear is an incredible show and is my number one as well. Andrew, I guess that just leaves you at number one then. Yep. You're all wrong. You're all fools because the correct answer is Blue-Eyed Samurai. I don't begrudge that pick. Yeah. With all of these other shows that I've mentioned, Demon Slayer, Attack on Titan, The Bear, even The Last of Us.

I've seen shows kind of like them before, or I've seen movies kind of like them. I've never seen anything like blue eye Samurai. That's fair. This, this show, I almost called it a movie. This show is vibrant. It's beautiful. It's horrifying.

The main character, Misu, is one of my all-time favorite protagonists for a show. She does female empowerment and strong female character right because she's motivated, she's dedicated, she's smart, she's strong, but she's flawed. She is so hell-bent on revenge that it blinds her to everything else around her. This show is easily my top five of the year, and it was going to be before even the episode with the Onryo, which was the... Have you all seen Blue-Eyed Samurai, by the way? No. No? Okay. You're missing out. I'll just say episode five. Yeah, you're welcome. As if I had anything to do with it.

I will tell you, and I don't think we're going to change anything. I don't think we're going to have a spoiler warning or anything because I think for the most part we're far enough away from the show that most people know the protagonist is female. But I was glad I didn't know because it's kind of a reveal at the end of the first episode. Is it though? It is. It's definitely written that way. Whether it works or not. It was written that way, yeah. Yeah, yeah. So like, I mean, I had my suspicions the entire time. So that's another reason I'm not too, you know.

uh scared of that being like a big spoiler or whatever but the way it's written that first episode the the gender reveal at the end is really really powerful and i was glad to experience uh not knowing yes again the peaches reference um but it's uh beyond even that the show does such a great job at understanding um narrative momentum uh understanding uh how action should be worked into uh the emotional beats of a show um yes it's really well done uh i totally understand why it would be your number one uh show of the year So there you go. Those are our shows. Before we pick our official Sif Pop TV show of the year, I will throw out a few more nominees and you guys are not nominees, but a few other honorable mentions. You guys are free to mention other shows you like as well. The most recent season of Fargo is phenomenal and has some things to say about abuse that I don't think I've ever seen portrayed so clearly and powerfully. For All Mankind continues to be just absolutely crazy fun about the space race. Highly recommend that. Just caught up on Slow Horses.

That's a pretty amazing show. New season of Futurama was really good. Futurama is just still amazing Futurama. That's really cool. Still don't think enough people saw Mrs. Davis. I thought that was really amazing. Poker Face, not enough people talking about Poker Face. I think that's an amazing show as well. And then the only other one I wanted to mention was Jury Duty, which I think we've mentioned before. But yeah, just an absolute fun show that is now on Prime. That's a fun experience. Did you guys have any other shows you wanted to give a shout out to? Yeah, Beef. Yeah, Beef is really good as well.

So good. I just want to say that the biggest travesty of the year was winning time being canceled so unceremoniously. And the biggest, like to me, like the most underappreciated show on TV right now is Righteous Gemstones. Yeah, that's a good shout out for sure. Elementary also finished its season at the beginning of the year. And that one I also really love. Yes. Good choice. Good choice. All good shows. Previous winners of this category last year, Barry won Sif Pop TV show of the year. The year before that, Ted Lasso won TV show of the year. And the year before that, The Watchmen won TV show of the year. I think there's a pretty clear one that was on at least three of the lists.

No, no, it wasn't succession. The bear would be my number six. I'll say that. Okay. All right. Well, there we go then. Barring any arguments, I think we can call it the official Sif Pop TV show of 2023 is the bear. And there you go. That will wrap up part one of the Sifties.

Thank you so much for joining us today for Sif Pop. It is part of the Studio DNA Podcast Network. You can find out more about other shows on the network at Studio DNA Media or by searching Studio DNA in your podcast player. Huge thanks to Andrew for hanging out today. Thank you, buddy. Big thanks to Aaron Schweitzer for being with us today and Robert. Aaron, you go first. Where are some places you want to point people to what's going on in the Sif Pop world or in your own world? Just the Sif Pop Writers Room Podcast. We get to hear from all the writers for the website. Come talk about lots of different things. Robert, what about you? Thanks for coming on. What are some places you want people to find you? Well, of course, Sif Pop.com, which is...

as you know as lively as ever with all of our writers going and publishing reviews in the sifties for the site um also one twice a month actually on the sift pop writers room feed um and my own podcast i started with a fellow pop writer foster called also see uh we talk about lesser-known movies from well-known directors and actors which is just a way to fill in the gaps of filmographies that i do anyway so i figured why not you know change that into a podcast Very, very cool. I highly recommend also see and the Sif Pop Writers Room podcast. Add that to your feed. Lots of fun conversation going on in those places. Also, big thanks to producer Phil for producing the audio and video show. Thanks, Phil. And much love to our Sif Pop members for supporting. You can go to patreon.com slash Sif Pop to check all of that out. We really, really do appreciate you guys. Support starts at three bucks a month and you get access to lots of fun stuff there at the Patreon. Again, that's patreon.com slash Sif Pop.

Lots of ways to connect with us. Feel free to leave a comment or rating or review at Apple Podcasts or Spotify or wherever you listen. There's an email, feedback at siftpop.com if you want to use that. And finally, if you're having a good time, your movie-loving friends will probably like it too, so let them know about the show and that listening is much easier than keeping up with one billion hours of television. We'll be back next week with part two of The Sifties, where we get more into the performances and the best movies of the year, and we will see you then.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of SiftPop?

This episode is 2 hours and 4 minutes long.

When was this SiftPop episode published?

This episode was published on January 23, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this SiftPop episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.