424: Is American Gigolo Doing It For Us?

Forty-two years after Paul Schrader's American Gigolo pioneered the sex-worker neo-noir micro-genre, Showtime's limited series of the same name is trying it again -- and returning guest Sarah Baker joins us to talk about tone problems; weird directing choices; pervasive misogyny that's even more tiresome than usual; MVP Rosie O'Donnell; and whether Jon Bernthal should have gotten better writing to work with. We went Around The Dial with Monarch, The Dick Van Dyke Show, The Mary Tyler Moore Show, Animal Kingdom, Cobra Kai, Severance, Big Brother, and Rings Of Power before Baker screwed up her courage and asked the Canon to PEN15's first-season episode, "Dance." Lee Jung-jae won, Dick Wolf lost (while John Oliver won), and a non-regulation Game Time about TV sex work was NOT considered especially heinous. Slow that disco standard way down for extra poignancy; it's an all-new Extra Hot Great.GUESTS👤 Sarah BakerTOPICSLead Topic: 🕺 American Gigolo Around The Dial: 👑 Monarch Around The Dial: 💼 The Dick Van Dyke Show Around The Dial: 👒 The Mary Tyler Moore Show Around The Dial: 🐷 Animal Kingdom Around The Dial: 🐍 Cobra Kai I Am Not A Crackpot: 🍕 Cobra Kai LocationsAround The Dial: 💍 The Rings Of Power The Canon: 🍆 PEN15 S01.E10: DanceWinner & Loser: 👍 Lee Jung-jaeWinner & Loser: 👎 Dick WolfGame Time: ☎️ Call ThemNOTES🗒 Full episode notes can be found on the episode 424 page on ExtraHotGreat.com🎙 Tara's Rosie O'Donnell interview at Vanity Fair👀 Watch Sarah Baker in The Kominsky Method on Netflix🎞 Kominsky's third-season trailer🧭 The Great North on Hulu🌳 Central Park on AppleTV+🪫 Tara's Mark Proksch interview at VF❌ Tara's Decider piece about current primetime soaps, ALL of which ended up getting cancelled🤰 Tara's The Handmaid's Tale S05 review at VF🎶 The #LilithFair40 season finale on MASTAS💄 Listen To Sassy📷 Photo: Warrick Page / Showtime