Skip to content
44. Reflections on Pittsburgh episode artwork

Nov 15, 2018 37 min

44. Reflections on Pittsburgh

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

On Saturday morning, October 27, a gunman entered the Tree of Life Synagogue in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh, killing 11 people and injuring 6 more. The shooting is being called the deadliest antisemitic attack in US history. What lessons can we learn from this horrible tragedy? Does this represent a resurgence of antisemitism? Is that resurgence connected to the rise of Donald Trump? Is it fair to tie the threat of antisemitism to the Republican party? Relevant links: FBI Hate Crimes Statistics: https://ucr.fbi.gov/hate-crime/2017/topic-pages/tables/table-1.xls https://www.commentarymagazine.com/politics-ideas/the-slaughter-in-pittsburgh/ https://twitter.com/simonerzim/status/1056504354444902400 https://www.cnn.com/2018/11/03/us/new-york-temple-antisemitic-messages/index.html https://www.haaretz.com/us-news/.premium-farrakhan-s-hate-speech-leads-to-actual-abuse-of-jews-i-experienced-it-1.6634780

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

On Saturday morning, October 27, a gunman entered the Tree of Life Synagogue in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh, killing 11 people and injuring 6 more. The shooting is being called the deadliest antisemitic attack in US history. What lessons can we learn from this horrible tragedy? Does this represent a resurgence of antisemitism? Is that resurgence connected to the rise of Donald Trump? Is it fair to tie the threat of antisemitism to the Republican party? Relevant links: FBI Hat...

Ready to play

44. Reflections on Pittsburgh

0:00 37:05
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Marie. And I'm Ricky. And you're listening to Talkin' Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So we actually got an interesting email this week from...

a listener, Mikey Piesem. And he actually shared with us, it's pretty cool. There's going to be a new publication, academic journal, called the Journal of Controversial Ideas, which of course relates to those scholars that we talked about a few weeks ago who had published all of these false articles showing that academia in a lot of ways is publishing false research and it's kind of a joke and you can't really trust it. And part of the problem that we had talked about there is that a lot of academics feel like they can't really explore different or nuanced ideas because they can get in so much trouble. So Peter Singer, who's one of the, do you know who Peter Singer is? Yeah. So he's one of the proposed journals editors and he actually has some really interesting ideas. I think he's a bioethicist. And he's written a lot about it.

and abortion, definitely things that are controversial ideas. And so it makes sense that he'd be one of the editors here, creating this peer-reviewed, serious publication that will print what they call worthy papers from any discipline and stand behind them regardless of the backlash. So it's a pretty interesting idea. I'm kind of excited. I think maybe they got the idea from us. Yeah, well, I definitely called for something like that on the podcast, so maybe they were listening. It's where they didn't reach out. Right. Well, indirectly, they seem to have. Yeah, I saw that article. It was interesting. I'm curious to see what kind of articles they published. The examples that they gave in that article had to do with mostly abortion, like it was the Peter Singer thing, but then there's also this other person who talked about

post-birth abortion. It's interesting to use the word abortion when you're talking about after birth. Right, which definitely can be very, sounds to be somewhat disturbing for me at least. But I guess if I'm calling for controversial articles, I can't say only one type, that's the whole point of it. So I'd be very curious to see what kind of articles are published and what the response to them is. Yeah, it's pretty exciting. They mentioned a few ideas like a defense of colonialism, which definitely in the 21st century is not a popular opinion. Also a paper on so-called transracialism. Do you remember the Rachel Dolezal thing? She had been the head of a chapter. Right, NAACP. Exactly, NAACP. She wasn't actually black. Exactly, but she thought of herself as black. And that was obviously, it got a lot.

of ridicule online, but they're saying, you know, let at least talk about these things. And I think it's kind of cool. It's brave. What's interesting about it also is that academics who publish in this journal are going to be able to publish anonymously, which is pretty rare in academia, but I think it's the only way that these people can really protect their... They said like untenured professors might want to publish anonymously. So we'll see what happens. Pretty excited about it. Maybe if Talking Talkless listeners want to come together, we can all chip in for a membership. These things are so ridiculously expensive. You think this one's going to be expensive also? Yeah, it's like, unless you're part of an academic institution where you can... Well, we can probably just go to the library and read it there. Perfect. Talking Talkless field trip to the library. I love it.

Well, getting to our main topic for today on a much sadder note, on Saturday morning, October 27th, a gunman entered the Tree of Life Synagogue in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh with a rifle and three handguns and opened fire on the congregants inside. Eleven people were murdered and six were wounded. The shooting devastated the American Jewish community, as well as the country in general, and it is being called the deadliest anti-Semitic attack in U.S. history. Aside from mourning the tragedy and getting a sobering reminder that anti-Semitism is still very much present in this country, a lot of people quickly turned to politicizing this event.

President Trump visited Pittsburgh the day after the massacre, but he was met by hundreds of protesters, many of whom were from the squirrel-held Jewish community. These protesters and many others believe that it is at least partially President Trump's rhetoric and seeming inability to condemn white nationalism that led to this attack in the first place. The attack also occurred a week before the midterm elections, and many people argued that voting Democratic in the midterms was the best way to prevent similar attacks from happening in the future. So Rivki, what do you think? What lessons can we learn from this horrible tragedy? Does this represent a resurgence of anti-Semitism? Is that resurgence connected to the rise of Donald Trump? And is it fair to tie the threat of anti-Semitism to the Republican Party?

So you and I discussed as soon as the attack happened that we wanted to talk about it, but we also wanted to give it a little bit of time because it was so emotional and so raw and so difficult to even try to have a conversation about it. And it's interesting. It's been a few weeks. And I think to a certain extent, I still do kind of feel that way. Like we are having this conversation, but it's hard to feel like I'm being completely rational when this still feels like it was a really emotionally difficult thing. I remember it feels so small, but I remember exactly where I was. I think I'm going to remember that for the rest of my life. We could say it's only 11 people who were murdered and six wounded, but this feels huge. I think every one of these victims is someone who...

I feel like I either have a friend in common with or a relative in common with. These are people who are really part of us. Right. I felt like I don't know them, but I could know them. Right. I know people who could be that person. Right. Also, Riffy, when you say you're coming from an emotional place and you're not sure if you can speak about it rationally, what do you mean by that? What is that emotion that is coming out? So it's interesting. I mean, my first instinct is definitely feeling like.

This is exactly what we would expect, right? There's this, you know, rise of anti-Semitism. We could talk about anti-Semitism coming from the left, right? Obviously with Louis Farrakhan and, you know, things like that with anti-Israel stuff. We can also talk about anti-Semitism coming from the right. We can talk about Charlottesville, right? Jews will not replace us. White nationalism really becoming more and more prominent. I don't know if they're, maybe the numbers are going up slightly, but really it's just become much more prominent in America and in the world at large. My first sort of emotional instinct is feeling like, wow, this is exactly what I always would fear. But then my other emotional instinct says, oh my God, we need more security in shuls. My other emotional instinct is, that's not the world I want to live in. It's all of these sort of competing emotions and I can't even get out of my own.

head to say like, okay, let's think about what this really is. And I don't even know if I'll ever be able to do that. You know, it's hard to, again, when we talk about family, it's hard to take emotion out of it. For sure. But you just brought up two major things that I want, I definitely want us to address. So the first you brought up about antisemitism from the left and antisemitism from the right. So what I was kind of alluding to in that intro, which I wanted to talk about was some of the statements that are coming out specifically tying not just this act of antisemitism, but the threat of antisemitism in general from coming from only one of those two sides. There were a lot of...

statements and Facebook posts and Twitter in the immediate aftermath of the Pittsburgh attack that I found very disturbing. And I want to read a couple of them. So one of them is from Simone Zimmerman, who we've discussed before. She was briefly Bernie Sanders' liaison to the Jewish community until after strong protests, after a couple of days, removed her from that position because of her really, really strong anti-Israel and anti-Netanyahu statements. So after the attack, Shmuley Boteach, who we've also discussed, posted something about we have to condemn anti-Semitism in all of its forms, including Islamic anti-Semitism, et cetera, and terrorism. And he called on President Trump to condemn all these forms of anti-Semitism. And so in response to that,

Simone Zimmerman posted on Sunday, the day after the Pittsburgh attack, quote, no words, Jewish fascists abusing white supremacist terrorism to stoke Islamophobia and anti-Palestinian hate. Your collaboration with our Nazi-friendly administration is part of what allowed this to happen, and you are a disgrace to our people. End quote. Okay, so very, very strong words. She's literally victim blaming. She's blaming Shmueli Boteach, and I guess by extension, other Jews who support Trump. She's blaming them, at least partially, for this attack. I think that's absolutely disgusting. I think what's difficult and sometimes sad about all of these things is what events like this do is cause us to more and more get entrenched in our own earlier previous assumptions. So someone like Simone Zimmerman looks at this and says, I already know exactly why this happened. It happened because Trump loves Nazis. It happened because Shmueli Boteach loves Trump. It happens because we American Jews pretend like Trump is pro-Israel, but really he's a deep-down anti-separate. All of these things. And I think that instinct is something that, I mean, to be honest.

I share too, right? And I kind of imagine you share too, and I imagine all of us share too. No one changes their mind. No one sees something like this and says, let me think how the world might be a little bit more complex than I already think. Let me read another one. I don't want to say his name, but this is from somebody that both of us know personally. He's a very active poster on Facebook, and this particular post, as the last time I checked, had 181 likes and many comments, so it was very much viewed and discussed. He wrote, if you are a Jewish Trump supporter, you voted for a guy that cornered the neo-Nazi, quote, Jews will not replace us, vote. He riled this group up.

What did you think was going to happen? Did you think they were going to go away after he won? How many more glaring red flags are you willing to ignore? Trump's rhetoric led to this. That's it. There is no other answer. If you support Trump, then you support an environment that leads to synagogue shootings. Yes, anti-Semitism has been around for years. Nobody is saying Trump invented it. But those who tend to act on things, they read on Breitbart.

slash Reddit slash Fox News slash Daily Wire have spent the past few years getting juiced out by a culture fostered by Trump. It's empowered them and led to blood-stained walls at that Pittsburgh shul. Right-wing Jews, you have made it very clear. Islamophobia, hatred towards the LGBT community, and gun rights are more important than the safety of Jewish Americans. If you are a Jewish Trump supporter, before you thoughts and prayers this event to justify your continued support of this White House, ask yourself what actually matters to you. It's not the betterment of the Jewish community, that's for sure. That was made crystal clear today. So he posted that the very night of the attack.

He's literally blaming Jews for these murders. And this was not an isolated opinion. I saw many people saying things like this. He's saying that Jews who support Trump, who think that Trump is pro-Jewish or pro-Israel, are actually somehow self-hating Jews, I guess, and want other Jews to be killed or don't care about the safety of other Jews. And I will say, by the way, that I think something like 80% of Orthodox Jews are pro-Trump. So he's basically saying 80% of Orthodox Jews are either knowingly or unknowingly accessories to these murders. To me, when I read something like that, I think, okay, it's strong rhetoric and I maybe wouldn't go this far. But what I hear is just his anger. And I understand why he's so angry. Like, he feels like there's a part of...

his internal community, our internal community, that have allowed something evil to flourish, right? And not to say, like, you, John Smith, you voted for Trump. You are a neo-Nazi. You are the reason this tree of life didn't happen, right? That's not actually true. But, like, this particular guy, right, there are a bunch of circumstances, obviously, that combine to lead this person to do what he did. But, Uri, do you think that this guy would have done what he did if not for Trump being in office and if not for white nationalism controlling a lot of this conversation, right? He was in touch with a lot of white nationalists. I obviously have no idea what was in this guy's head. It happens to be that...

The guy himself was very critical of Trump, mainly because Trump wasn't anti-immigrant enough. You know, I was reading an article in Commentary by John Podhortz, and he said, based on the early evidence, the shooter was not only consumed with the hatred of Jews, but possessed a kind of sneering contempt for Trump on the grounds that Trump was basically a Jewish agent or a Jew lover himself. Okay, so this guy was no Trump lover. But it doesn't even matter. Even if the guy was a diehard Trump fan, which he wasn't...

I still don't think that means Trump is to blame. If you want to criticize Trump for his inability to properly and fully condemn white nationalism, then I agree, and I'm on board with that. But the implication here in that post and many other posts is that if Trump wasn't in power, then we wouldn't have a problem of white nationalism. We wouldn't have a problem of these type of anti-Semitic attacks. And I think that's, first of all, just so wrong and also so dangerous to have that attitude that this is all Trump's fault and how Trump invented this. This is only around because of Trump. And if we had other people in power, we wouldn't have to worry about anti-Semitism. We wouldn't have to worry about these kind of threats. I think Trump is to blame for not condemning white nationalism. And I don't know any Jews who defend that.

or who say, oh, neo-Nazis, they're not so bad. You know, like, Republican Jews don't say things like that. I think it's only Jews on the other side, liberal Jews, who overlook and ignore antisemitism from the other side. And that gets to my main point, which is just that let's condemn this guy, let's condemn what he represents, the communities that he comes from, the white nationalism and those ideas, in the fullest terms. I'm not defending or rationalizing any of that. But let's not pretend that that is the only source of antisemitism, because not only is that... Who made the claim that that's the only source of antisemitism? Who made that claim?

To say that this happened because of Trump and now in the midterm elections, which were, you know, taking place a week later, tons and tons of people were posting about we have to vote. That's the best way that we can combat this attack and make sure it doesn't happen again. Let's vote Democratic next week in the midterms. As if to say that if we vote Democratic, anti-Semitism will disappear and we won't have to worry about it anymore because it's exclusively a right-wing problem. I don't think they're saying anti-Semitism is going to disappear. I don't think they're saying that anti-Semitism is a right-wing problem, right? What he wrote in this Facebook post is, yes, anti-Semitism has been around for years. Nobody's saying Trump invented it, but those who tend to act on things they read on Breitbart, slash Reddit, slash Fox News, slash Daily Wires for the past few years getting juiced up by a culture fostered by Trump. It's empowered them and led to

stained walls at that Pittsburgh Shule. That is not... to exclude that there's also anti-Semitism on the left or maybe even rising anti-Semitism on the left. But that paragraph, would you disagree with what he just said? Well, because I think it's missing the point. I think we have to condemn anti-Semitism for its own sake and for what it is and not condemn it as a tool for our political agenda, which is to get Trump out of power, which you could be all for. And I'm very much not a fan of Donald Trump. But to tie this event directly to him and to say that's how we have to combat the event, by getting him out of power, I think it's just really disgusting. I hear you, but I don't know why it has to be one and not the other. It's not one side or the other, but my point is that it's very dangerous to politicize anti-Semitism and to tie it so...

to one side of the political spectrum because anti-Semitism can come from anywhere and we have to condemn it for its own sake. I mean, we've spoken, okay, the biggest example in this country of like a left-wing anti-Semite is obviously Louis Farrakhan, who we've talked about a bunch of times on the podcast. And so do you know Avram Milotek? Yeah, I read the Facebook post. Yeah, so he's a rabbi, does a lot of really great stuff. He's actually very politically active. Sometimes I'm a little bit turned off by his...

that he posts on Facebook because it's very left-wing. But overall, I know him personally. I think he's an amazing person. He does really, really amazing work. So he posted a few days after this Pittsburgh attack happened, he posted a story that happened to him on the subway where basically he was accosted by an African-American man who called him a fake Jew. He said, you have no right to Israel. Which is Louis Farrakhan's language about Jews. He shoved a picture of Louis Farrakhan in Avram's face and said, you know who this is? This is a real Jew. You're a faker. You're a phony. And he said there was one other person on the train who even responded or reacted and kind of took that guy's side. Nobody else said anything. It was just a very scary, terrible incident that happened in the immediate after.

of the Pittsburgh thing. And clearly the person who did this is not a white nationalist and did not, I'm assuming, did not vote for Donald Trump. But when we talked about Louis Farrakhan in the past, you know, on this podcast, we talked about how a lot of people just want to minimize the threat that he poses. Like, oh, he's not actually a politician. Yeah, a lot of people in Congress and very prominent people, including Obama himself, have close relationships with him. There was that picture with Obama around, with his arm around Farrakhan that the photographer chose not to publicize out of concern of hurting Obama's reputation a bunch of years ago, you know. And they minimize the threat. Are they just waiting for one of Farrakhan's supporters to do something horrible like this and then it'll be a real threat? What's so difficult about something like this is that

I think because it happens to be that the person who did this Tree of Life awful terrorizing act was a right-wing nationalist who was also an anti-Semite, the vision we have is right now focusing on that type of anti-Semitism as the forefront of anti-Semitism. But if this exact act had happened, and instead of the guy who did it being this insane person, this white nationalist, it was instead this man who attacked Abraham Lotech on the subway, if that guy shot up a shul and killed 11 people, would we only be talking about anti-Semitism from the left and not from the right? Both of them seem to me a little bit of dangerous ways of framing that conversation. I don't think, I don't want to hypothesize what would happen in that situation. I certainly wouldn't focus only on the left because like I said, I'm not minimizing.

a threat from the right at all. I think it's very dangerous and needs to be addressed. Actually, one thing, and it's a little bit off topic, I just think it's something that I want to just like honor Avram a little bit because this is obviously a scary situation that he went through and I think it's pretty insane. I got chills reading it, but he said basically how the man repeatedly was telling him Israel wasn't his, he was a fraud, Jews are responsible for the entire mess in the city of New York and all over the world. He lifted up a picture of Louis Farrakhan and asked, do you know who this is? I didn't answer. He kept asking and asked louder. Yes, I said, that's an anti-Semite.

I actually thought that was incredibly brave. That's a really, really intense experience to go through. And I'm imagining myself on the subway and I think I would be too scared and I would just walk away from the entire situation. But for Avram to turn to him and to turn to everyone on that subway car who isn't saying anything and stand up for himself and stand up for the Jewish people and stand up for values there, I thought was a really, really beautiful thing. For sure. No, I was very impressed by the way he handled it and the way he wrote about it and everything like that. But I mean, I don't want to obsess over the Farrakhan thing, but we spoke about how the organizers of the Women's March have very close ties to Farrakhan. There are prominent politicians who have close ties to him. And actually, I don't know if you saw this, at Aretha Franklin's funeral a few weeks ago, Farrakhan was...

seated right in front next to President Bill Clinton, former President Bill Clinton. Really? I didn't see that. He sat right next to him. And he was basically fully embraced by that very liberal, democratic world and not seen as the raging anti-Semite that he is. The other big thing that he's in this world was... Did you see what happened with Chelsea Clinton? So Chelsea Clinton called out with Farrakhan a few weeks ago. I'm not saying everybody has fallen into the trap, but many have. His most recent thing was he said, did you see this line where he said Farrakhan was giving some speech and he's like, hey...

People call me an anti-Semite. I'm not an anti-Semite. I'm anti-termite. And everyone went crazy. No, not everyone went crazy. No, no, I mean like cheering. No, no, I mean people were excited. Right, right, right. My point is not to prove that anti-Semitism is a problem of the left and not of the right. Okay, my point is that let's not politicize anti-Semitism. So did you see this case in Brooklyn? Also in the days following the Pittsburgh attack. So it's logical to imply that there was some sort of connection or copycat kind of thing where somebody vandalized and wrote like anti-Semitic, you know, Nazi death kind of anti-Jew graffiti and arson set fire to a bunch of different like yeshivas and shuls. I don't think any major damage was done, but he attempted.

It turned out that this person had actually been profiled in the New York Times a year ago. We can include a link to that article. But basically, he was an activist for Obama. And he had an LGBT rally for Obama. He met New York City Councilwoman Christine Quinn, who took a liking to him and then brought him under her wing. And then he ended up kind of working for her on her re-election campaign. And combating hate crimes. Yes, combating hate crimes, prejudice. And it's a very sad story. And this guy has mental health issues. And again, I'm not saying that proves a conspiracy. My point is that anti-Semitism can come from anywhere and come from any side. And so something that was particularly ironic and disturbing to me was...

Somebody else that I'm friends with on Facebook posted an article about that incident in Brooklyn, about this guy, about the arson and the graffiti. And she wrote, we must condemn and resist hatred, racism, anti-immigrant sentiment, transphobia, and all injustice. In addition to voting next week, how are you taking action, friends? So first of all, she didn't mention anti-Semitism in that list, which is a little bizarre. And she's basically saying, tell me if I'm wrong, but...

The clear implication to me is this terrible thing happened. We can solve it, at least partially, by voting Democratic next week. I mean, I happen to know this person is a very big Democratic activist. Voting Democratic next week. But this guy himself was a Democratic activist. So why are you pretending a simplistic narrative? I'm going to say that the reason that she said that, and I don't know where I'm going to say, the reason she said that is because Democrats notoriously give much more funding to public health and public mental health education. And therefore, we can get him the help that he clearly needed. I hope he does get the help and other people get the help they need. But I just think it's really offensive and demeaning and cheapens the whole conversation to tie this so directly to politics. And because it also applies that if somebody who doesn't...

vote Democratic, if somebody votes Republican, a Jew who votes Republican is basically a self-hating Jew who encourages neo-Nazis and anti-Semitism. Okay, so remember the Parkland shooting at Stoneman Douglas High School in Florida a few months back, where 17 students were killed and a bunch of others were injured, right? Immediately, what came out of that was students at this school and students at other schools coming forward, going to Washington, creating rallies, right, talking about gun violence and how it specifically affects children, and trying to make this both a political issue and a social issue and trying to really impact America, impact policy, impact the world. Do you think that also is incredibly problematic? So it's interesting. I made that kind of connection. I was thinking like, you know, every time there's an attack, a mass shooting. So it's always done basically with a gun or multiple guns. So there's the gun element. But then there's who was killed. So there was the gay nightclub a couple years ago. There was a black church a couple years ago. So each time it's like, yes, this was an attack on that, on those people, which can't be ignored. This was an anti-Semitic attack on Jews and a shul. That can't be ignored. There's also a gun thing. So when people connect it to guns, like I personally have mixed feelings about guns. I'm not sure exactly where I stand on that issue. But it makes a lot more sense to me that when somebody murders a large number of people with a gun.

It is fair, even if I don't agree with their conclusions and what they're saying, it is fair and legitimate to say, let's work on gun control and taking guns out of the hands of dangerous people to try and prevent these type of attacks in the future. I think that's legitimate and fair. And even if I don't agree with the specifics of what they're calling for, I don't think that's inappropriate as a response. But the response from so many people in this situation is not, let's combat anti-Semitism and let's find it in all of its forms and try to... get rid of it, they're making it political, they're tying it to Trump, and they're completely missing the point about the nature of anti-Semitism and how that threat is not tied to one political party. It's very clear that people were killed by a gun. It's not very clear that they were killed by Trump. Right, so you're saying the connection between guns and policy about gun control...

And a shooting is much more intimate at the time. Yes, exactly. You can't avoid it. It's obvious. This is not obvious. And this is a much bigger leap. And I think it's a very offensive and inappropriate leap. Right. It's actually interesting. I was thinking today the FBI released its annual report about hate crimes. Did you see this? No. We'll put a link to this, obviously, in the description. But basically, as we can imagine, Jews topped the list of hate crimes for the previous year. And it actually wasn't even close. I think it was over 50% of anti-religious hate crimes, even though...

Jews constitute something like 2% of the American population. I actually don't think it's as you would imagine. I mean, I knew that statistic being that way. It's been that way for a while, but people haven't been talking about anti-Semitism as if it's the number one problem in America. But anyway, sorry, continue. No, no, that's a good point. It's probably not the right... Until the last few weeks, I don't think anti-Semitism has really been on the minds of people as hate crime against religious groups. I think people think of hate crimes against Muslims, definitely hate crimes against black people or other racial minorities and much less about hate crimes towards Jews. But there's a lot of pretty scary information. That having been said, one of the things people are trying to figure out is how much of it is a difference in reporting, how much of it is actually happening, how much of it is actually violence versus...

You know, someone like often like I'll be with my husband. Not often, but I'll sometimes be with my husband and someone will scream at him from across the subway like, oh, stupid Jew. I've heard that. And it's very scary, but it's obviously very different than a fire bomb through a window or something like that. Right. So I think there's a difference between the violence. The sentiment, I think, is definitely the same and is definitely really critical. That anti-Jewish sentiment being so high is something I think we often forget when we think about the incidents and the hate crime. Yeah. I mean, I think anti-Semitism has always been here and it's always been a problem and it always needs to be addressed. You know, not to get too into the Trump connection, but I did notice and I think we spoke about it at least partially in previous episodes.

You know, in the lead up and the aftermath of the 2016 presidential campaign, there was a lot more discussion about anti-Semitism in an attempt to tie it to the rise of Trump as if it hadn't been a problem before. And now it's a problem where the statistics clearly do not support that. It was a problem before and it was a problem after. And there is no, you could say individual elements of it are tied to. elements of the support of Trump, which is for sure true, but it's not exclusive to that in any way. Isn't it the same way that we're talking about anti-Semitism a lot more after the Tree of Life shooting? We're talking about it more because it's more tied to things that are probably happening. No, because let's say Israel supporters and American Zionists, especially on campus, have been talking very loudly about the fears that they have on campus from pro-Palestinians or anti-Jewish or whatever groups for years and years. It just hasn't really been in the mainstream media. Of course, but if there were a shooting, God forbid, in a Hillel where 11 people were killed, I think it would be a lot more mainstream. But I was bringing up before the shooting, I'm talking about the rise of Trump. But I'm saying when white nationalists walk around in Charlottesville talking about Jews will not reflect.

us, or when Louis Farrakhan, which has been more and more in the past few months, it's not just in the past few weeks, the Women's March, even in the past few weeks, Alyssa Milano, did you see this? She's been one of the big celebrities who have been involved in the Women's March. Alyssa Milano actually popularized this Me Too hashtag. It was created a bunch of years ago by a black woman, but Alyssa Milano has really popularized it, and she said that she will not take part in the Women's March if Louis Farrakhan is at all involved, even if I think the... I think Linda Sarsour and Tameka Mallory are still involved and refuse to condemn it. That's amazing. I didn't see that. I'm very happy to hear that. So there's a lot happening, and I think it's kind of interesting to sort of figure out what's going on and if the right-wing anti-Semitism is actually provoking more people to speak out about left-wing anti-Semitism. I hope so. Because that's what I've seen. I'm not sure, but I hope so. I want to switch gears a little bit in what happened in the wake of the shooting at Tree of Life Synagogue. Did you follow the whole Mike Pence messianic rabbi story? Yes, I did see that. So for our listeners who didn't follow the story, basically there was a real outrage when there was a rally outside Detroit after the Tree of Life Synagogue shooting where Mike Pence appeared with a rabbi, but that rabbi actually happened to be a messianic rabbi who was part of the Jews.

for Jesus movement. This provoked a huge, huge backlash with every Jewish denomination basically incredibly angry, slamming the appearance, talking about how insensitive and tone deaf it was in the wake of the shooting. The rabbi, Lauren Jacobs, he actually, I think his smitha, quote unquote, was revoked, like about 15 years ago for other reasons. But basically he opened his prayer by talking about God of Abraham, God of Isaac, God of Jacob, God and father of my Lord and Savior, Yeshua, Jesus the Messiah, and my God and father too, which is pretty intense if you're calling yourself a rabbi. And then in the end, he also talked more about Jesus. And I think it was interesting, a lot of people who were in such an emotional and painful state after the Tree of Life shooting to then turn around and see this, it felt like,

We've got anti-Semitism from people who are literally trying to shoot us. And then we have anti-Semitism from, you know, and this is obviously an extreme reaction, but the vice president of the United States calling up. someone who is explicitly trying to convert us and not allowing any room for Judaism to be as we actually think it is, right? There's like a lot of emotion and pain that went into the sort of outrage after the anti-Semitic massacre. And then this group whose main purpose is to proselytize the Jews, you know, appearing with the vice president. So there's a lot of pain there also. Yeah, I agree that that's a little bit weird. I think this story is really overblown and unfair. And I think it's just, it's very similar to the Trump thing where people despise Mike Pence on many levels and he can do no right. And it's not exclusive, meaning like you think he didn't have or witness or...

support legitimate Jews who were condemning this attack. This is one guy at one rally who happened to be a Jews for Jesus guy who said a thing. And somehow this, I mean, what is the claim exactly? This is Mike Pence saying Jews should convert to Christianity. Like I don't even understand what the criticism is. It happens to be, like I said, this was a little weird. I happen to be a big critic of Jews for Jesus. I find them to be a very disturbing group. I've actually seen them. I bumped into a group of them once near NYU and they were sort of like proselytizing in a way. It was like weird because at first there was like a Jewish thing and then they dropped the Jesus.

thing on me and i was like taken aback but at the same time like i don't understand like what exactly is the problem here so i think the problem again i'm just talking about from emotional perspective i think the problem that a lot of people who i spoke with and i read you know sort of their their thoughts and reactions i think the the the emotion behind it was that at a time where it felt like we were actually under attack and we're under attack from a lot of right-wing nationalists and we're under attack from a lot of left-wing anti-semites we're just it feels very painful and it was right after the attack for mike Pence, who is an evangelical Christian who takes his faith incredibly seriously, to appear at this event. And I read a lot about it, and it actually does seem like my Pence didn't even know he was there. Didn't even know the guy, didn't know what he was going to say, didn't realize he was a messianic rabbi. Totally. But also, he didn't come out afterwards and say... And then you'd be criticized for anti-free speech or anti-religious rights. Why anti-free speech? He's not saying he's not allowed to say that. He's just saying, like, I called up a rabbi, and especially there was something insensitive about that, and that was disrespectful. No, he would get criticized if he criticized that guy. Criticized by whom?

Why does that guy not have a right to believe in Jesus? Of course he has a right to believe in Jesus. But if you're calling up someone and representing them as a rabbi, as a leader of the Jewish faith, and what they're professing is something, it's a movement started by Christians to proselytize to Jews. I don't know the history of the group, if you say that's what it is. So yeah, I didn't understand that either. And then I was actually having conversations with friends about it. Like, why are people so emotional about this? Okay, so I disagree with them. But you know, I disagree with a lot of people and they're still called up. But I think what makes Messianic different for a lot of people is especially because he was appearing as a leader of the Jewish people. I don't think that's true. And he comes from a group of people who are not Jewish and proselytized to Jews to convert them out of Judaism. I don't know what that means he's representing the Jewish people.

He was a guy at a rally, and he blessed the Republican candidates. He's like a Republican activist, whatever. Like, I don't understand what he did wrong. And I think this criticism is coming from people who generally are, like, supposed to be the liberal, like, open people to, like, do your thing, be you. Right, but what I'm trying to explain is that these people are speaking from a very emotional place. Their emotions are raw. They're in a very vulnerable and intense place after the shooting, after this massacre. I understand that. And then two days later when this happens, I totally understand. It feels like you have a blow from this side, then you turn away, and you get a blow from the other side, and this really feels like a blow. So if you're saying, look, this doesn't affect you emotionally, maybe it doesn't affect me emotionally too, but I understand why people are so affected by this, which I think I didn't understand at first.

The reason why I'm cynical towards it is because I think it's just political. They have an emotional response to Mike Pence himself. And that's why they're interpreting this in that way. And if Obama had been president, I know like one of the Hanukkah parties that Obama hosted, he had a woman rabbi who made the bracha on the candles and then said some sort of political message. I don't know if it was about immigrants or I don't remember exactly what it was. And there were a lot of religious Jews who were upset about that. But it's the same kind of thing where it's like a religious sensitivity and a different sect of Judaism. I think there's something fundamentally different about Messianic Judaism in that it was founded by Christians as a way to proselytize the Jews. Okay, I understand that. And like I said before, I hate Jews for Jesus, to be honest. My point is just I don't.

I think this criticism is coming from a political place, which is why it bothers me. I think that's definitely true, but I think it's a combination of, again, when these things happen, people sort of revert to their own sort of natural inclinations, and they also speak from a place of raw emotion. And I think that's fair. I think that's what we all do, and I think it's understandable. And I do think that it's incredibly immature and ridiculous that Mike Pence, and this really kind of maybe goes back to something that I think is a constant sort of trope with me, but I think that often people just don't apologize. They do things wrong. They understand why people are upset, and they say, well, if I apologize, then I'll get criticized from this group, or then I'll look weak, or I'll look like I didn't know what I was doing. And it's like, be an adult. Be human. These people are in pain. You hurt them more. Just apologize. Yeah, I'm not sure exactly

sound, but I understand what you're saying. Anyway, Uri, even though this was, I think, a hard conversation, I'm glad we had it. Do you have any last thoughts specifically about the shooting and about everything that came from it? Well, like you said, this was a difficult conversation. I think I may have gotten a little bit heated. You know, I do understand the emotions and the way that's channeled into political ways and criticisms of this administration that I think many of which are very legitimate. And so I understand that. But at the same time, obviously, I hope that nothing like this ever happens again. But I think the only way to properly...

address and combat anti-Semitism is to fully acknowledge anti-Semitism in all of its forms and from all of its sources, no matter how uncomfortable it may be to address. And, you know, separate conversation about the anti-Israel connection to anti-Semitism. But just broadly speaking, I think it's just important to just be honest, no matter where that leads and no matter who it leads to, to address this really dangerous type of hatred. country and in our world. Definitely agree. And I actually think it's interesting. I was listening to Commentary Magazine, their podcast, in the days after the shooting, and thought it was particularly interesting that, I mean, I think a lot of the people at Commentary Magazine were never Trump or Republicans, but they very, very plainly stated that they thought that the rhetoric that Trump had attributed to definitely was a part of it, and they were further left than I kind of thought they would be on this. But they also very clearly, not everyone on the podcast, not everyone in Commentary, obviously, is Jewish, but the people who were Jewish were very clear that they thought that this was part of a much larger chain of anti-Semitism. They were not at all surprised by it, be it from the left or the right. They talked a lot about a Malik. It was like a pretty firm podcast. Interesting to listen to it. Yeah, I thought it was pretty interesting.

Well, anyway, of course, we'd love to hear your thoughts. I know this is a pretty emotional topic, a pretty raw topic, but I think that can actually be a really good thing. And, you know, we always want to hear from you. So please email us at TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. And, of course, please join our conversation on the Facebook page, Talking Talkless Podcast. Thanks, as always, to Drive-In Productions for sponsoring this week's episode. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Talkless. All right. Bye, everyone. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 37 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on November 15, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.