Skip to content
45. Beckerman's Search For Meaning episode artwork

Nov 21, 2018 34 min

45. Beckerman's Search For Meaning

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

This week, Uri and Rivky compare their travel woes from last week's storm, and then Uri gives several more disclaimers about how he isn't a supporter of Jews for Jesus. (The lady doth protest too much?) They then dive into this week's topic - an article written by writer and editor, Gal Beckerman, entitled American Jews Face A Choice: Create Meaning or Fade Away, which reviewed five new books touching on American Jewish identity, and what will sustain it in the future. Beckerman argues that what defines the experience of non-Orthodox Jews in America today is not antisemitism, it’s assimilation. So, how will American Jews continue to affiliate as Jews? What will continue to bind them to any sort of Jewish identity? Uri and Rivky ask, is non-Orthodox Judaism really doomed to be killed by assimilation? How does Israel, and Zionism, relate to this? And how does Orthodoxy fit into this? Relevant articles: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/12/books/review/steven-weisman-chosen-wars.html?module=inline https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/17/style/ivanka-trump-jared-kushner.html

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

This week, Uri and Rivky compare their travel woes from last week's storm, and then Uri gives several more disclaimers about how he isn't a supporter of Jews for Jesus. (The lady doth protest too much?) They then dive into this week's topic - an article written by writer and editor, Gal Beckerman, entitled American Jews Face A Choice: Create Meaning or Fade Away, which reviewed five new books touching on American Jewish identity, and what will sustain it in the future. Beckerman argues that w...

Ready to play

45. Beckerman's Search For Meaning

0:00 34:03
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Bree. And I'm Rivki. And you're listening to Talking Topless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So Rivki, I think you had an eventful night this past Thursday. You want to tell us about it? Yeah, I mean, I think a lot of us did. It was definitely the night from hell. So I work out on Long Island and I leave in Washington Heights, which means that usually the drive back is actually kind of annoying because we get stuck in like the George Washington Bridge traffic. So it ends up taking the way there is only 40, 45 minutes. The way back can be more than an hour. It could be like an hour, 15 minutes. And Thursday was the first snow of the year for New York. And we were a little bit nervous. We decided to leave early. We left at 3.30.

And we ended up getting home. Do you know when we got home? Well, I was following on Facebook, so I got an idea. We got home at 2.30 a.m. Insane. It was an 11-hour drive. It ended up being ridiculous because even though we did stop for gas before we left because we were like, oh, gas is a little bit low. Let's just be careful about it. We went down to half a tank. We made three stops for snacks.

three stops for a bathroom. It was just, it was, where were you stopping for gas stations? So not gas stations. Basically we were driving, the highway was closed at a bunch of points. We couldn't even get onto the highway. We were driving through the Bronx. So, and we were, it was stands though. When I say driving, that's a loose term. We were sitting in our cars going through the Bronx very slowly. And basically what would happen is I would say, you know what? I'm hungry and I need to stretch my legs. Goodbye. I'd get out of the car.

Walk two blocks, find a deli, get some snacks and come back and we would be in the exact same spot. I was driving with a coworker. We just kept taking breaks, you know, taking turns, getting out and just trying to do something. But it was quite something. I heard a lot of horror stories. I saw a lot of things on Facebook. But 11 hours seems to be on the more horrific end of things. And you also on Facebook Live, your experience, right? I am a minor internet celebrity. By minor, I mean with literally just my Facebook friends. So pretty minor. Aliza Abrams, who is a friend of ours and I think sometimes listener, she did a Facebook Live video. And then a couple of friends reached out to me and were like, you're just sitting in the car. You're like texting anyway. You're watching a movie. Like do a Facebook Live. It'll be funny.

So yeah, my coworker was like, no way, I'm not being in that. So I just was like, okay, how do I do this? And I did this like, I think it was like five minutes video where I just kind of answered questions and sort of like, where are you? What are you doing for bathroom? I thought it was really great and inspiring almost that you were able to put a positive spin on it and have some fun with it. And I was also impressed with your ability to simultaneously talk to the camera and read questions. That was very hard. And address the questions. People were writing in questions, sort of looking for updates. And it was smart questions that I should have thought to answer in the first place. But it was very hard to do that as I was also talking. And I'm not a camera. I'm very much a behind the camera kind of person.

face for radio you know that's why we have a podcast um so being on screen was very stressful for me i was sweating a lot uh but it was it was Quite a night. It was quite an adventure. Were you driving anywhere that night? No, I actually almost felt guilty that I didn't have anywhere to drive. No, we didn't need more cars on the road. In my apartment, I just heard honking all night. Yeah, that was one of the things. Generally, people were pretty good. No one really got in any fights or anything like that. But randomly, I think people were just getting so frustrated. They would just hold down the horn. And then other people would join in. I think in my video, I called it a symphony. But it was like a cacophony. It was crazy. They needed to let out their frustration in some way. I think everyone was just deadened by the whole experience. So it was quite a night. Hopefully the last one.

Yes, I'm gonna be a star. Maybe you can drive my car. And maybe I love you. So before we dive into our main topic, we wanted to address a little bit of listener feedback that we got, especially from one listener named Adi, who is a big friend of the podcast. And she had a lot of pretty strong reactions to share, especially about the Squirrel Hill episode, the Pittsburgh massacre, but particularly about the whole Jews for Jesus thing. And I think she was pretty upset with you, Ori. She was upset with me, but I found it interesting. And I'm not criticizing you, Rivki, but I think you and we could have done a better job of explaining what actually happened because Adi herself acknowledged after I responded to her that she had misunderstood what actually happened. She was under the impression, and somebody over the weekend actually told me the same thing.

the impression from listening to the podcast that this event was like some kind of special memorial ceremony for Pittsburgh. That Mike Pence had gone to Pittsburgh to speak. For that purpose specifically. And that this person was invited as almost like a keynote person representing the Jewish people at that event. And so it was just, in reality, it was a regular campaign rally that was pre-scheduled that happened to be, you know, the day after the massacre. And this guy wasn't even specially invited. He was some sort of Republican activist who was there. Well, he was invited, but not by the Pence campaign. They didn't know who he was. It was by the person running for, he was invited by, exactly, the woman who was running for Michigan's 11th. And at the event, Pence met the guy and said, oh, wow.

you come up and say something. Right. So that being said, Adi was still pretty upset at me for, I guess what, condoning that rabbi getting a platform to speak. What exactly would you say was her anger? I'm going to read out loud just a specific piece of Adi's email.

She wrote, Yeah, I understand her critique. I just don't think it's fair or accurate. To some extent, I'm playing devil's advocate by defending this guy because, as I said very explicitly, I have a big problem with Jews for Jesus. But at the same time, obviously you're going to say it's different, and I agree it's different. But what if someone came out and said, reform rabbis are bozos. If a woman reform rabbi got up and spoke out of service and an ultra-Orthodox guy was like, oh, she's a bozo and she doesn't represent our religion or our people, people would be up in arms and horrified by that. I can tell you exactly the difference between those two. Jews for Jesus is a group that was created by Christians who are meant to proselytize to Jews. Reform Jews were created by Jews. You're saying who created it. I'm not saying that's a critical distinction. But what about that guy himself?

assuming he was born to two Jewish parents, he's Jewish by Jewish standards. It doesn't matter. He's representing a Christian movement. It's a Christian movement meant to prostitutes as Jews and I think that's a distinction. And Ori, I do want to ask you, I think you kind of said, A, you don't think this is a super big deal. No, you don't like Jews or Jews. You don't think it's a super big deal. And B, you think people had sort of like political motivations and you think it was blown away out of proportion. So do you think if Obama had done something like this, or I mean, I know Pence didn't do this, but if there had been a speaker like this, exactly, yes, with Biden, do you think you would have said like, oh, people are making such a political movement out of this. This isn't such a big deal.

It's a hard hypothetical to answer. I think I probably would have criticized it in the same way that I don't think this was a good thing. I criticize it like it shouldn't have happened. I just don't think it was a catastrophe. And specifically tying it, what I think what I was really disagreeing with you on was specifically tying it to the Pittsburgh thing and saying, this is like jabbing a knife into the Jewish people who just experienced this trauma. Now you're traumatizing them again by having this Jews for Jesus guy speak. I think that was very unfair. And that connection is like a dangerous connection to make to imply that this kind of trauma is anywhere comparable to the massacre of Jews praying in the synagogue.

Like, I think that's what I was objecting to and what I thought was like a grossly unfair comparison to make. Right. To me, it feels like the connection that I was kept thinking about was there was that big protest because Mormons had been retroactively converting to Holocaust victims. Exactly. And saving them, quote unquote. And these were people who lived as Jews and died in the Holocaust as Jews, obviously. And there was a big pushback and a big sort of like fight against that, which also...

You can't equate the Holocaust and a pseudo-false conversion after someone has been killed, but do you think that's a... Ricky, if this guy had been up there and said, by the way, I think the solution for the Jewish people is to believe in Jesus, if he would have said that, I would be at the front of the picket lines with you, okay? But he didn't say anything like that, and his belief in Jesus, while sounding very weird and also being offensive to me, was very much not the point of his remarks and what he said, and so it's not the same as the Mormon thing, where what was protested was their active, like, you know, you're saying Jesus tries to convert Jews. I think that's true, because I've experienced it myself, and it was very disturbing, but that's not what that talk was. He didn't do that, so...

Again, I don't think it was as traumatic and disgraceful an event as you say. Okay, well, we discussed this last week, we discussed this this week, we can continue to talk about it, but now I think it's, what do you say, should we move on to the main topic? Let's move on to the main topic. Okay, so last week, the New York Times book review section published a pretty interesting article written by Gal Beckerman called American Jews Face a Choice, Create Meaning or Fade Away. This article actually reviewed five new books touching on American Jewish identity and trying to sort of figure out what's going to sustain that identity in the future.

The review and all five books touch on a lot of different ideas. But the main question is a pretty provocative one. Yes, they acknowledge antisemitism exists. And yes, they acknowledge antisemitism is on the rise. And yes, there was a big antisemitic attack in Pittsburgh recently. But realistically, well, of course, the books don't talk about that. They were written before. But Gal Beckerman writes about that. But realistically, what defines the experience of Jews in America today, and when Beckerman talks about Jews, he really means non-Orthodox Jews, is not antisemitism. It's assimilation. The vast majority of Jews marry outside the tribe. Many millennial Jews don't even affiliate as Jews at all. And American Jews, especially younger ones, increasingly feel alienated from Israel. And Israel in the past had really been a...

a connecting point between secular Jews and Jewish identity. So, these authors ask, how will American Jews continue to affiliate as Jews? What will continue to bind them to any sort of Jewish identity? The authors all have different approaches, but the reviewer cleverly combined them with a line from one of the books, create meaning in Judaism or accept extinction. What that means, at least to my mind, is that Jews will only continue to be Jews if the meaning they find is not related to Judaism, it must be Judaism itself. Much of the identity of American Judaism, Beckerman argues, has been defined in the negative, like reaction to the Holocaust or defensiveness of Israel or reaction to anti-Semitism. But what about a Judaism with a positive source of meaning?

I fear, he says, without this added value, to be crass about it, my two young daughters won't have anything to hold on to. So Uri, what do you think? Is non-Orthodox Judaism doomed to be killed by assimilation? How does Israel and Zionism relate to this? And if you accept his premise, what do you think the solution is? Do you think that Orthodox Judaism is immune? And if so, what's the secret? I thought it was...

a somewhat interesting article, but overall I found it very silly and empty. This was the front page of the book review on Saturday, and it was clearly put there because of the Pittsburgh thing, I think. Well, he references Pittsburgh, unless he was already writing it. Yeah, he was already writing it, and I think he was almost done with it. He talks about it in one of the New York Times podcast. Oh, interesting. Okay, that is pretty interesting. Meaning he talked about how does this anti-Semitic attack affect the way that I think about this, which was a pretty interesting conversation. Yeah, I think what was so weird to me about the article was that he kind of like...

very honestly acknowledges the challenges and really failures of the American Jewish establishment, mainly the reform movement, as not really working in the way that it was supposed to. You know, he goes into the history of the reform movement, but now he talks about the current reform movement and his experiences, let's say, going to high holiday services that felt completely empty and pointless and boring, mainly. But then the solution that he kind of gives at the end is basically the reform movement. We just have to make different reforms and we have to make different changes because he says, like, you know, they did weird stuff in the 1880s. It was weird when they brought an organ into the temple and when they mixed the genders in the seating.

But then it became normal. So we have to do weird things now. Like he talks about like the neo-Hasidic... service that he went to or other kinds of like new agey kind of things. Like maybe we have to try other weird things now and then that'll solve it. Like I thought it was very bizarre that he says we need to focus on the religion itself and the essence of Judaism, but he doesn't talk about Orthodox Judaism at all. He actually references Orthodoxy three times in the article and in all three times he references it. It is as an exception to the point that he's making. So first he says that a vast majority of Jews are intermarrying and then in parentheses except for the Orthodox. Then later on he says 90% of American Jews practice what he calls a cafeteria religion where they just pick and choose the things that...

are easy for them or convenient and put some weird combination together. He says, you know, except for the Orthodox. They don't do that. But that's like, you know, in parentheses. And then the third time, a few paragraphs later, again, he says how the birth rate among Jews in America is extremely low. And in parentheses, except for the Orthodox. So meaning, I think people are free to practice however they want, as I was saying before with the Jews for Jesus thing. But it's bizarre to me that he is so close-minded that in trying to have an open conversation and discussion about like how to make the religion more meaningful and feel more connected to it, he doesn't even entertain the thought of, well, maybe we can look to the Orthodox and see what they're doing and see why they don't, why all of the problems that I'm describing for the Jews in America.

America don't apply to the Orthodox. They're not having any of these problems, at least not in the same way. Maybe we could look at them, but he doesn't go there at all. I thought that was weird. And the other thing that bothered me, being who I am, was the Israel stuff. He talks a lot about how more recently American Jews, secular Jews especially, feel much less connected to Israel.

And he specifically says, you know, after 1967, let me actually read the quote. What about Israel? Is it really no longer capable of exerting a magnetic pull on the whole Jewish people? Not really. For hundreds of years of diaspora, Jews scattered everywhere had to negotiate between two impulses, universalism and particularism. They did so on a case-by-case, community-by-community basis, balancing their tribal needs with their desire to engage with the world at large. This dynamic has been replaced by a bipolar Jewish world with two centers of Jewish life, each basically representing opposed values.

Israel's primary mission is the security of the Jewish people, and its government is beholden to an orthodox establishment that narrowly defines Judaism. Its leaders regularly denigrate Reform Jews, with one recently calling them, quote, a group of clowns who stab the Holy Torah. For their part, American Jews care primarily about the health and well-being of American society. Issues like immigration or human rights or reproductive health, Israel's actions, meanwhile, especially when it comes to the conflict with the Palestinians, are difficult to understand and often perceived as deeply immoral. End quote. Okay, so there's the American community, Jewish community, and the Israeli Jewish community. The Americans care about America, they care about social justice and reproductive rights, and the Israelis care about security and they're immoral.

Am I misreading it or is that basically what he said? I'm sorry. He said they have opposing values, the two communities. And the examples are Israel's values are security and immorality. No, he doesn't say security and immorality. He says security and his government is beholden to an orthodox establishment. And American Jews. So what other examples of, he says there's conflicting, they have conflicting values, right? So what Israeli values did he mention other than security and then later on that they're immoral? Did he say any other? What do you mean they're immoral? He said difficult to understand and often perceived as deeply immoral. Okay, they're perceived as immoral? Yeah. Perceived by him, I'm assuming. What's your complaint?

I'm just saying the implication from what he's saying is that they have opposing values because American Jews are good, they have good values, and Israeli Jews are bad. Why are you saying that he's saying they're good? This whole article is about how it's not good and it's losing any sense of a center. He doesn't say their values aren't good. I mean, in this paragraph, he says their values are great. They care about the health and well-being of American society. He didn't say Israelis care about the health and well-being of Israeli society. It might be implied, but he doesn't say that.

Okay, I hear what you're saying. I'm not reading it the same way, but I also don't really understand why this is a problem. Like, I hear what he's saying. There are different values, right? He's claiming the central values of Israel are its own security. And I kind of think that's true. I think that's very offensive. Security is not a value. It's a necessity. I mean, I think they've done a ton of polling. It's because they're under attack from all sides, obviously. You can make a claim about why, but he's saying this is what it is. And they don't have other values. They've done polling after polling when it comes to Israel, when it comes to voting, when it comes to elections, all these things. And the number one thing that everyone votes about is security. And it's like economy, 2%. I don't think that's fair to say that that's their predominant value. Because it's the most important thing that they vote based on.

Israel doesn't have these type of social issues about gun control and abortion. Like, most of those are on the liberal end and across all parties in Israel. And the things that they disagree on are security. That doesn't mean that that's their predominant value. Wait, you're saying they don't disagree about other things? Of course they disagree about other things. It's a socialist country that's now completely capitalist. These things all matter. And the argument he's making, but I also, okay, I feel like we're quibbling about the small pieces, but I want to understand sort of the larger thing that you're bothered by.

Well, I mean, I just think it's, first of all, he says how American Jews have grown very uncomfortable with Israel. But one thing that I thought was very interesting was that even though in that paragraph, and the other one that I referenced where he says post-1967, you know, morally speaking, American Jews have a moral problem with Israel, he actually goes into detail. about the reform movement and how in the establishment of the reform movement, the conference actually happened to have been in Pittsburgh. And he says how one of their basic reforms and values was how he writes, the key was to let go of 1800 years of yearning and praying for a return to Zion and instead root themselves more firmly where they lived. And then he gives an example of a reformed rabbi in 1841 who said, this synagogue is our temple, this city is our Jerusalem, this happy land, our Palestine. And as our fathers defended with their lives, that temple, that city and that land, so will their sons defend this temple, this city and this land. So I just think it's interesting how he's almost giving like historical support for non-

Orthodox Jews in America to distance themselves from Israel. The implication to me was that we're being true to our history of the Reform Movement by not caring about Israel. Now, what he leaves out is that the Reform Movement was anti-Zionist, basically, before the Holocaust, but then after the Holocaust and the founding of the State of Israel, they were very pro-Zionist. And then that has, though, gradually eroded over the years. But, you know, he leaves that part out and just goes straight to the original thing about the anti as part of the Jewish religion. So I just think that's interesting that that seems to be a big part of it for him. It's like Israel's out the window. And he's basically admitting that it's not about the occupation. It's not about 1967 because he gives an example from 100 years before the occupation saying why reformed Jews in America distanced themselves from the idea of Israel. So I'm just saying I think that's telling and interesting. Wait, I feel like you said a bunch of things there. And some of them I want to come back to. And some of them I want to challenge you on, but I feel like a little bit lost. Okay, I guess my main thing at the end.

that I'm just pointing out as interesting. I'm putting some pieces together and tell me if you think I'm mistaken. He says that the reason why American Jews are disillusioned with Israel is because of the occupation and the immorality of what's going on in that country. implying that if Israel wasn't immoral and they did the right thing, quote unquote, then those Jews would support Israel and be in favor of Israel. Oh, I see what you're saying. I didn't read that into what he was saying at all. Okay, so they don't care about Israel and they also happen to be anti-Israel or have a problem with Israel because of the immorality, but even without that, they still wouldn't care very much about Israel. So the way that I was reading it, and you can disagree, and of course listeners will of course post the article so you can read it as well and tell us how wrong we both are, but I think the way that I was reading it was that American Jews are feeling disconnected from Israel for a whole host of reasons, not necessarily because of Israel and the Palestinians and things like that, but more because American Jews feel much more closely aligned with their liberal values than with the Jewishness part of it.

And if in the past, the reason that American Jews felt so strongly connected to Israel was because the Jewish ties were sort of binding them together, that no longer is true because they're much more connected to the sort of liberal values. That's what I read the author is saying. And the author adding that that's not going to be enough. Because soon, if the way they're talking about social justice is, social justice comes from my Jewish values, what's going to stop it from happening that within a few years or one or two generations, it's just going to be social justice for the sake of social justice and the Jewish thing is totally unrelated and it's going to be dropped. That's how I was reading what they were saying. Okay, what you just said, I don't think that contradicts what I said. I guess I'm reacting or commenting on what I hear a lot from liberal Jews, which is that...

I want to be connected to Israel. I love Israel, but they're making it impossible for me to do that or to act on it because of their policies. Right, because American Jews are focusing much more on their liberalness than on their Jewishness. They don't feel comfortable connecting to Israel just because, oh, I'm a Jew, they're a Jew. They feel much more liberal, more so than anything else. He had this statistic in the Q study that something like a third of millennial Jews don't call themselves Jews. So I think it makes complete sense. It's not because of Israel, but what used to be that because of this Jewish connection would mean they would be more connected to Israel than they would be normally, that no longer is the case, and that has been dropped. My point is that not everybody admits that, or many people don't admit that, or don't say it in that way, or maybe don't feel that way. But you know what I mean? They say, I do care about Israel.

value of mine, but because they're so immoral, I can't support it. And he's saying they are immoral and I can't support because of that. But also, I don't believe that Israel should be a part of my Jewish identity for more fundamental historical reasons. Which, by the way, is something that I hear a lot more. I understand the emotional connection to Israel. I feel very connected to Israel. I have a lot of family there. I love going there. But I also think that...

People to say to me, like, you should feel connected to Israel because you're Jewish, like, I'm immediately defensive and a little squeamish about it, right? The same way I feel defensive or squeamish about someone like, oh, you shove a lot of kids because they killed so many people in the Holocaust. That is not a reason to have a lot of kids, right? Like, there is the individual person and there's, like, a sense of community to say, like, oh, you representing as a Jew. have to feel connected to Israel because you're part of the larger Jewish people. Like there is something that I think that I, and I think a lot of young Jews feel like, no, I don't feel comfortable doing that. I'm my own person. I want to make choices based on my larger values and not just because like it's like nation, nation. You know what I'm saying? I think I know what you're saying. I don't agree with it, but I do think that more and more people feel that way. Okay. I understand what you're saying. I also just think it's funny the way he ended his article, which I also thought undermined a lot of his.

what he said, or if he had a point to undermine it, where he quotes from Lamentations. The title of the piece is called Lamentations. And then he quotes from Lamentations, Eicha, at the end. And he says, he's talking about Amos Oz, the Israeli author. And then he says, the Jewish imperative to remain fresh and relevant is summed up in a line from the book of Lamentations. Renew our days as of old, to which I'd only add, or else. End quote. And that's the last line of the piece. So renew our days as of old.

That sounds to me like, you know, make America great again, make Judaism great again, which is like a funny association. I'm not like saying that's just funny to me, but also like what old, which old Judaism, like Orthodox Judaism, Judaism that values Israel, like which old Judaism is he thinking of that he wants it to be more like that? If his whole point is we have to change it and make it different. So I don't think that's what he was referring to. I think he was referring to.

a vibrant secular Jewish culture or vibrant secular, maybe the word culture is too much, but the idea that there is a secular Judaism that is real and that is meaningful. And I think he sort of is sounding the alarm. And the truth is that I really agree with you. I don't think he has many great answers. I don't even know if these books have great answers. The way he was reviewing them, I didn't love their answers either. I made a lot of notes in these margins, but...

I agree with him where he adds, to which I'd only add, or else. Because if there isn't something positive, if there isn't a meaningful, positive experience that people have with Judaism, then people are going to drop their Judaism. Because there's no point to it. And I think it's interesting that you're right. He doesn't really grapple with it. And to a certain extent, maybe that's because none of these five books grapple with it. But there's no discussion necessarily about what are the values we can learn from orthodoxy. Maybe we don't want to become observant in their way, but what are the values of orthodoxy that we can sort of learn? I did think that was a little bit telling. But I also think it's a little bit interesting that he doesn't even talk about, forget about talk about ritual or forget about talk about practice. He doesn't even talk about...

why a connection to Judaism is so important. And we talked about this a little bit with a Michael Chabon talk where he was giving the graduation speech at the Reformer biblical school. But this idea that he's saying that it's so scary because there seems to be sort of like a missing solid ground for the future of American Jewish identity and we have to figure out where to find it. But I feel like I want him and I want all of these people to grapple with why do we want to find it? Why is it a bad thing? If Judaism dies out, is that a loss for the world? And why? I feel like I have an answer, right? I feel like maybe mainstream quote unquote orthodoxy has their answer. Maybe mine is the same, maybe mine is different. I feel like it's probably a little bit different. But if there's no good answer for why Judaism matters, why does he care if his kids don't feel connected to Judaism?

Why does he care that American Jews are marrying non-Jews? What does Judaism mean that we should be so worried about losing it? Yeah, we had this discussion with the Michael J. Bond thing, but I definitely hear what you're saying. Maybe I'm reading something that isn't really there, but let me just read out loud the piece that I think is so critical here. What he writes is,

enhance and elevate my day-to-day existence in the modern world, and not just mine. I fear without this added value, to be crass about it, my two young daughters won't have anything to hold on to. I think what he's looking for from Judaism is a meaning that he's never, again, that he's never really felt. He calls himself unaffiliated. My reaction to that line, the very powerful line, is like, who's stopping you? You know, that is there, very much so, and not just Orthodox Judaism, but for sure in Orthodox Judaism. I don't think it's there in Orthodox Judaism. Okay, well, it's there somewhere. We'll do that next week. Yeah, it's definitely there. He just hasn't ever seeked it out, and now he's saying, oh, if only I had that identity. Like, okay, go get it. Like, it's very easy. No, seriously, where?

You think if he walked into an Orthodox shul, he would feel like there was an elevation? I'm genuinely asking, right? I go to an Orthodox shul. You think if he walked in, he would walk out and be like, finally, it's what I was searching for? No way! I think if he spoke to the right people, you know what? I think if he goes to Israel, which clearly he's probably not going to do or feel good about, but I think there's a lot of Jewish and religious inspiration in Israel. That's, I mean, traditionally where people often find it. But it doesn't have to be Israel. I think there's a lot of ways it doesn't have to be Orthodox. I think there's a lot out there and I think it's offensive and very reductionist to just make that blanket sweeping statement as an unaffiliated Jew and say, if only Judaism had something to offer me.

I just think it's weird for him to say that. I think you're making his statements much stronger than they actually are. I think he's searching for something, and I think it's not to say he's saying, and that thing doesn't exist, Judaism is crap. Why is it such crap? I think he's genuinely saying, I'm searching for something, I don't know where to find it, and I actually think he's right. I don't know where to find it either. Maybe he and I will get together. You seem perfectly content in your American Jewish experience, and that's great, Uri, and I'm really happy for you. Well, I'm just not blaming other people for, if I have a spiritual need, I would want to figure it out and find it, not just say, oh, it's not there, so I'm not going to look. Where do you get that he's saying, oh, it's not there, so I'm not going to look? I've been around American Jewish and Orthodox and spiritual and hypothetically meaningful establish

So like to say that this guy is doing it wrong feels like a strong statement. It is really difficult to find incredibly meaningful Judaism in America. I didn't say he's doing anything wrong. He just doesn't say that he's doing much of anything. He doesn't know what to do. I don't know what to do either. If he reached out to me and said like, how do I find a meaningful Judaism? I'd be like, oh my God, you and me both.

I agree. I actually think it's a lifelong endeavor and challenge for any thoughtful person who wants to find a spiritual connection. There's no easy answers. The nice thing I think that orthodoxy does offer is you have a lot of people who are really grappling with that question and I think trying to think really intelligently about it. Do they come up with better answers? I don't know. Sometimes yes, sometimes no. Maybe often no. But at least I think within orthodoxy, at least I found for myself, a lot of people who are really struggling with that conversation. Of course, there are also a lot of people who not only aren't struggling with that conversation, think it's sort of heretical or disgusting to even try to approach that conversation and definitely find that also. But one of the things that I think is so beautiful about orthodoxy is I often find people who really want to engage in that and really do try to figure it out.

So it's not all bad. Well, this was a really interesting discussion. There's a different article in the New York Times from Sunday's paper that we're thinking about talking about. Maybe we'll talk about in the future, but we'll include it in the. description and people could read it and see what they think. The title of that article was, but are they good for the Jews? It was about Jared Kushner and Ivanka Trump. It's funny how the New York Times, I mean, I think all newspapers do this, but you have the print edition of the paper, right? And I have the online version and they always change the title slightly. Yeah, mine is, are Jared and Ivanka good for the Jews? So I think it's a little interesting. Yeah, well, the article had a lot of pushback. I think both articles were actually just examples of like Jewish navel gazing. You know, they're both on the front page of a section and it's just kind of like secular Jews talking to other secular Jews about like just like their Judaism and their feelings and like not actually saying anything substantive and whatever. But anyway, people can see what they think. And I also just want to say one more time, the Pence thing, it's not.

Not the hill I want to die on, or whatever the phrase is. I'm not tying myself to that argument. Uri is Jews for Jesus. The guy was disturbing, Pence made a mistake by having him speak there. I was playing devil's advocate.

I just don't think it was the worst thing of all time, but it's like not my thing to defend that. Okay, I just want to clarify that. I'm sorry to keep backing you into corner and you feel like that's your thing. All right. Well, thank you everyone so much for listening. As always, we love to hear your thoughts. Please be in touch with us. Let us know how many hours you were in traffic for. We always want to know. Send us an email at TalkinTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. And of course, join our conversation on our Facebook page, TalkinTalklessPodcast. Thanks as always to Drive-In Productions. You know, Rifki, my commute to the Drive-In Productions studio was pretty short on Thursday, and thankfully that's why I didn't have to drive for 11 hours. It's like they're everywhere we need to be. They really are. And thanks as always to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of TalkinTalkless

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 34 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on November 21, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.