Skip to content
*5.2-Makkos Daf 04 A (10 lines Up)* episode artwork

Jan 6, 2020 15 hr 11 min

*5.2-Makkos Daf 04 A (10 lines Up)*

from BNEI AVIGDOR. Learn with us. Hosted by Ed Levy

*5.2-Makkos Daf 04 A (10 lines Up)**Summary**Mishna: Rabbi Meir:* Witnesses testified that A *owes* B two hundred _sus_ and they are found to be _zoimemim,_ they *get malkos* for giving false testimony ( _Lo sa’aneh_ ), and they *also have to pay* because of _ka’asher zamam_ . They receive two punishments because each is based on a *different “name"* .°*Chachomim:* If they have to pay, they cannot receive malkos. (The gemara asks that in general, the opposite is true - one who receives malkos doesn’t pay, see 5.?).(There is a general rule that we cannot give two punishments for one sin, this is the reasoning of the Chachomim. However Rabbi Meir holds that _hazamah_ is _knas_ and thus not limited by the laws of regular punishments; 3.1, 5.3).Mishna continues: *Rabbi Meir:* Witnesses testified that A ate _neveilah_ and *deserves _malkos_* and they are found to be _zoimemim,_ they *get _malkos_ twice* for _Lo sa’aneh,_ and for _ka’asher zamam._*Chachomim:* They only receive _malkos_ once.° *Rashi;* Ordinarily we say that they only receive the more severe punishment, however since here there are two different _pesukim_ and thus two separate sins, they receive both punishments.*Tosafos:* _Lo sa’aneh_ is not connected with _hazamah,_ as such it remains an independent _lav_ and requires punishment. This podcast has been graciously sponsored by JewishPodcasts.fm. There is much overhead to maintain this service so please help us continue our goal of helping Jewish lecturers become podcasters and support us with a donation: https://thechesedfund.com/jewishpodcasts/donate

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

*5.2-Makkos Daf 04 A (10 lines Up)*

0:00 15:11:12

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of BNEI AVIGDOR. Learn with us.?

This episode is 15 hours and 11 minutes long.

When was this BNEI AVIGDOR. Learn with us. episode published?

This episode was published on January 6, 2020.

Can I download this BNEI AVIGDOR. Learn with us. episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.