Skip to content
#5: Nathan Barnard (again!) on why general intelligence is basically fake episode artwork

Jul 28, 2023 1 hr 9 min

#5: Nathan Barnard (again!) on why general intelligence is basically fake

from Pigeon Hour Hosted by Aaron Bergman

Very imperfect transcript: bit.ly/3QhFgEJ Summary from Clong: The discussion centers around the concept of a unitary general intelligence or cognitive ability. Whether this exists as a real and distinct thing. Nathan argues against it, citing evidence from cognitive science about highly specialized and localized brain functions that can be damaged independently. Losing linguistic ability does not harm spatial reasoning ability. He also cites evidence from AI, like systems excelling at specific tasks without general competency, and tasks easy for AI but hard for humans. This suggests human cognition isn’t defined by some unitary general ability. Aaron is more open to the idea, appealing to an intuitive sense of a qualitative difference between human and animal cognition - using symbolic reasoning in new domains. But he acknowledges the concept is fuzzy. They discuss whether language necessitates this general ability in humans, or is just associated. Nathan leans toward specialized language modules in the brain. They debate whether strong future AI systems could learn complex motor skills just from textual descriptions, without analogous motor control data. Nathan is highly skeptical. Aaron makes an analogy to the universe arising from simple physical laws. Nathan finds this irrelevant to the debate. Overall, Nathan seems to push Aaron towards a more skeptical view of a unitary general cognitive ability as a scientifically coherent concept. But Aaron retains some sympathy for related intuitions about human vs animal cognition. Get full access to Aaron's Blog at www.aaronbergman.net/subscribe

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

#5: Nathan Barnard (again!) on why general intelligence is basically fake

0:00 1:09:34

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Unhappy Hour with Matt Bellassai Pineapple Street Studios From professional whiner and award-winning drunk Matt Bellassai comes Unhappy Hour, the podcast about everything we love to hate. Join Matt, his co-host Bari, and their special guests as they vent about all things political, personal and cultural. Because nothing brings people together like good complaining. Leave us a voicemail on our rant hotline at: (601) 600-RANT (7268). Support this pod and wear your unhappiness LOUD and PROUD by buying our merch at unhappyhourshop.com. Explicit The Vin Armani Show: Exploring Ideas of Liberty Vin Armani Weekly 2-hour podcast with host Vin Armani covering current events with a strong bias for a free and voluntary society. Interviews with remarkable humans. Solutions to empower individuals. Vin Armani is also the TV star of Gigolos on Showtime, an author, DJ, and agorist entrepreneur. Watch this as a live broadcast on Mondays at 1pm EST on https://www.youtube.com/user/VinArmani.FREE REPORT: How to Get Started with Bitcoin: https://www.activistpost.com/bitcoin Explicit Truth Be Told with Tony Sweet: Paranormal Tony Sweet | Club Paranormal Network Truth Be Told Paranormal takes you beyond the headlines and into the mysteries that challenge what we think we know. Hosted by veteran broadcaster and truth-seeker Tony Sweet, each episode features compelling conversations with leading researchers, authors, experiencers, and experts exploring UFOs and UAPs, alien encounters, ghosts, ancient civilizations, secret societies, unexplained phenomena, and the hidden side of history. Whether you’re a lifelong believer, a curious skeptic, or simply fascinated by the unknown, Truth Be Told Paranormal invites you to question the familiar, consider new possibilities, and decide what the truth means to you. Follow the show and join us each week as we uncover the stories, evidence, and mysteries waiting just beyond the ordinary. Become a supporter of this podcast: <a href="https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-be-told-with-tony-sweet-paranormal--3589860/support?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign= Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Pigeon Hour?

This episode is 1 hour and 9 minutes long.

When was this Pigeon Hour episode published?

This episode was published on July 28, 2023.

Can I download this Pigeon Hour episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.