51. Justice Misguided: The Unlawful Detainment of Keith Gilmore

In this episode of The Lethal Library, Dani and Stephanie head back to North Idaho for a bizarre 1984 case that has everything: a stranger on a roadside walk, a weird note left near a bridge, bar chatter that turns into a bad idea, and a “citizen’s arrest” that escalates into something far darker in the woods. The situation quickly snowballs into a messy courtroom saga filled with refiled charges, heated arguments over what the law actually allows, questions about mental illness and credibility, and a community split on whether this was public safety or straight-up vigilante behavior. Plus, they share a few podcast updates (old episodes are back!) before diving into a story that will have you asking: how did this ever get this far?Contact The Lethal Library at [email protected]. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!