Welcome back to Missing. I am Tim here today with Lance. Lance, how are you today? I'm doing fantastic today, Tim. We've got such a really disturbing story that we're telling in this particular episode. We have a guest on who did a great job bringing a story to the public light in a documentary that he made with such care and detail and compassion. I can't wait for people to be introduced to this multi-part documentary. Super talented filmmaker. But Tim, before we get into all of that, how are you today?
Doing great over here. Thanks a lot for asking. And yeah, in this conversation, we have an interview with filmmaker Michael Bayer. Not Michael Bay from Armageddon, but Michael Bayer, who directed this three-part documentary called Vanished, the Heather Elvis case. And Heather Elvis went missing in 2013 from Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. And this three-part documentary is all about this case. It is a fascinating story and it is a well-made documentary. Some of our friends like John Lorden are involved in the story a little bit because I believe he covered the case. And there are some really interesting...
online elements that develop in the aftermath of Heather's disappearance that I think a lot of our listeners would be interested in. So yeah, this conversation is with filmmaker, the director, Michael Bayer, and we get into the story and really don't hold back too much. But this is now, this documentary is now publicly available for free for the first time. And it is available on Tubi. So you go to Tubi and you can find Vanished, the Heather Elvis case. And there is a link in the show notes as well. And you can learn more about the filmmaker, Michael Bayer, who personally speaking, I would take him over Michael Bay because you just know what you get with Michael Bay, with Michael Bayer.
There's a little bit of mystery there, so I like that. He's a little bit more nuanced than Michael Bay. But you can go to the website, vanishedfilm.com, and that'll give you more information on Heather Elvis and the film and all of the circumstances that went into this completely tragic and unnecessary event that happened in her life. It's been filling me with these really unfortunate emotions about the people who perpetrated this. Absolutely horrific, disgusting people.
And I'm going to talk more about that in our final thoughts. Yes, and we will be back for final thoughts after the interview. So this is actually going to be broken up into two parts. So most of the interview will take place in this episode, and the last third or fourth of the interview will be included in part two. And then after that will be our final thoughts to speak about our feelings on this documentary and the interview with Michael Bayer. I'm going to say real quick before we get into this.
Everybody, we're going to CrimeCon. CrimeCon is in Denver this year, September 5th, 6th and 7th. It's in Denver, Colorado. We will be there. We will have a session with the great Joseph Scott Morgan. He's got a great show called Body Bags. He is a scholar of applied forensics at Jacksonville State University and might say a distinguished one at that. So we are going to be speaking with him about this phenomenon. That's the New England serial killer. These rumors that I've been swirling about. So it's gonna be a great session and you could get 10% off, Tim. You, you could. If you weren't going already as a member of this session, you could get 10% off as well, but everyone else can too. Go to CrimeCon.com for your standard badge, 10% off. Use code CRALLSPACE.
All one word. Yes, and Joseph Scott Morgan, a very relevant person to speak with when we're talking about this New England serial killer case because there are a lot of undetermined deaths. And Joseph Scott Morgan is a death investigator, Lance. And I listened to his episode of Body Bags yesterday that spoke about Jeffrey Epstein's death. Oh, yes. Yeah, I highly recommend checking that out because I don't think Joseph Scott Morgan thinks that his death was very clear. Check out the episode. Very interesting stuff. I really want to talk to Mr. Morgan about that. Let's get him on.
Obviously, it's a very relevant story these days. All right, Lance. Also, last announcement here. I just want to mention that we've got a premium service now. You can subscribe to Missing Premium on Apple Podcasts. You can become a member on YouTube, and you can click right through to either Patreon or Supercast right through our Spotify link there on the Missing Show page, and you can show your support. You will get bonus episodes. You may get some early releases if you subscribe on YouTube or Apple Podcasts, and you will get everything ad-free. So definitely check out Missing Premium. It's very reasonably priced, and I think...
I love it. Yeah, we're going to put together some other material that you can get there, especially part of being a subscriber. You mentioned the bonus show. The bonus show is great. We peel back the onion. We peel back the layers a little bit on our personal lives as well as talk about some of the episodes that stood out to us over the past week or so. So really a little less like super heavy true crime and a little bit more of a...
conversation. And sometimes we do them live too. So fantastic. And no matter where you listen, no matter what platform you want to get subscription service, it's out there. YouTube, Patreon, Supercast, Apple, any one of them. All right, everyone, we are going to break quick for commercial here and we'll be right back with filmmaker Michael Bayer to speak about the disappearance of Heather Elvis. This has probably been one of the most unique missing persons cases I've ever had to deal with.
An officer came to the door and asked me, did we have a car that was missing? I said, my daughter drives that car. It's been 69 days since Heather Elvis went missing. Heather Elvis, a cosmetology student, mysteriously vanished after arriving home from a date. This car was found in a peach tree boat landing. Now we knew something's wrong. Heather and Sidney Moorer met at Heather Elvis' job. Sidney Moorer was an older married man, older than Heather. A husband and wife are facing charges in connection with this case as authorities intensify their hunt.
The disappearance of Heather Elvis has probably changed the face of missing persons investigations forever, thanks in large part to social media. There was a huge conspiracy theory that was spread all over social media that Heather's father and her own sister had had something to do with this crime. Most of the social media was torture to the victim's family. What they were doing to us, it was tantamount to going into a crowded theater and yelling, gun or fire. Sidney, I think, was fearful of her. I don't see a lot of suspects in cases act like Tammy. The trust issue is big. I can imagine. I'm handcuffed to the bed. She didn't hear the second voice anymore. They don't have a case. People lie, Nancy. I still think today, I know I'm innocent. This was not a one-person job. She might actually be out there somewhere.
I need to find her who she is. Welcome to the podcast, Michael Bayer. Michael, how are you today? Good, good. Thanks a lot for having me, Tim and Lance. Yeah, absolutely. We're so thrilled to have you on. The documentary docuseries that you shared with us is fascinating. The case itself, the story is tragic and really all-consuming. Once you start watching this docuseries, it's really tough to put it in another spot so you can go do something else. I was trying to do some work and have it on in the background, and that's not a thing with this docuseries. You don't just have it on in the background and kind of half pay attention to it. It grabs you. So well done on that. But there are some people that don't know who you are.
Could you fill in the listeners as to a little bit about yourself and your background? Yeah, my name is Michael Baer. I just started a new production company called True Case Films, and we're actually going to specialize in making these investigative documentaries. We have another one actually that we're in post-production on now right now that we finished all the interviews with. And also we're going to start doing this raw interviews on our YouTube channel as well with different crime stories from police and victims and stuff like that. I personally worked in production for six, seven, seven years doing commercials and explainer videos. So that's kind of how I got my background in storytelling. And then my brother is a criminal defense attorney, and I started out.
just kind of always helping with his marketing and doing this and doing that. Then I got further and further into it. And I kind of also started a marketing consulting company for lawyers and a lot of them are criminal defense. So that's kind of how I got into law. And then I said, why don't I combine these two together and start doing investigative documentaries? And I reached out to an investigative journalist, Summer Dash, for this one to do the first one. And it just kind of went from there. That's an incredible background. The work that you did for lawyers was a marketing position or? Started as marketing and just.
I had to learn law. So I had to learn, I mean, I did, I got interested in it. You know, my brother's a criminal defense lawyer. So we go over his trials and this and that. And that's how I kind of really got into, into the law part of it. And it's very important. You have to kind of, you have to have that background if you're going to make this type of content, because otherwise you just don't know what to look out for. Yeah. And you don't know what to say and what to not say. If it's right or wrong, it doesn't matter really, because you could say something that could be detrimental in an investigation.
Right, or just understanding a case in law and how that works. As you can see, it vanished up. A big part of it was the court proceedings, you know, the trials. And, you know, I had to watch all those trials and know what to look out for. So that background helped. Right. And how long did it take you to make the docuseries? It was, you know, I spent a lot of time editing this one. There was just so much information. There's so many records to go through, so many news clips, so many, the court, I'm sorry, the trials. There was three trials. So Sidney Moore actually had.
the first trial was a mistrial. So he had a retrial and then you kind of had to compare the two. So it was, it was, it was a very in-depth case and I wanted to really dig deeper into it. And then also setting up the interviews. I mean, it's not something just call someone up and say, you know, I'm in town. Let's, let's talk about a very, very sensitive topic. You have to gain their trust. You have to, you know.
It takes some time to eventually say, hey, look, I want to do this. So that took time as well. How did it come together where you had such great access, where you spoke with Heather's family, law enforcement, lawyers, Heather's friends? So I started out, I reached out to Summer Dash, who was a reporter for a local station, a local news station in Myrtle Beach. And I asked her, I said, hey, do you want to co-produce this with me?
She said, yeah, you know, and I mean, she thought about it. Obviously, she looked and say, what is your objective here? What kind of angle are you trying to take? I know the family is very sensitive about this topic. And she was she was close to him because she interviewed him a lot. And then she said, sure, let's do it. And also she had a very good relationship with Jimmy Richardson, who was the solicitor, an amazing guy. I mean, just amazing, amazing man. I really he did an excellent job in this case, but he does an excellent job for Horry County as well. But so she knew him and he he opened the door. He was the one who really, really opened the door because without his.
wanting to be part of this. I don't think the police would want to be part of it. The other prosecutors wouldn't have been part of it. I don't think even the family probably wouldn't have been part of it. So he was kind of the one that really, really was like, okay, let's do this. That's really cool. It is always an amazing thing when that one chip falls into place, that one person agrees, and then the dominoes kind of fall subsequently after that and everything comes together because after tinkering around with certain parts, you found that one thing that fell into place, causing everything to come together. Did you realize that when it happened or was that something that you realized after the fact and you're trying to imagine the scenario if it didn't happen?
Yeah. I mean, I think once Jimmy Richardson's like, yeah, let's, let's do this. And then he also had Nancy Livesay and Chris Helms, the two prosecutors on the case. I said, okay, this is a big part of it. And then also Peter Sestir, who was one of the lead investigators on it, or, you know, he was the lieutenant higher up on the case. Once he was like, yeah, Jimmy Richardson, I talked to him, you know, so then, you know, and obviously Summer had a good relationship with the family. And I think, you know, that, that really helped as well. So it was, it was, this was, you know, that's another thing about documentary filmmaking.
I've spoken to other documentary filmmakers. That is one of the biggest challenges in making these things. You have to have access to certain people, otherwise it doesn't work. One person doesn't want to do it. It's not going to be as good. You can still do it with a few main people, but when you have everyone together telling the story, it makes it that much better. Tell us about how you're releasing this docuseries. We started out by releasing it on Amazon, Apple, and YouTube. It's foreign to a lot of people now in the streaming world, but it's something that someone has to purchase in order to watch.
It was bigger, I think, 10 years ago. A lot more people purchased content, but now with Netflix and, you know, all these other streaming services, people are used to watching it for free, which is fine. We, you know, we had a window for people who, you know, wanted to purchase it early, you know, support us as filmmakers, independent filmmakers. And a lot of people did, which I'm very, very appreciative of for everyone who did go and watch it and buy it. But it will be on Tubi, July 18th. And, you know, a lot of people, I don't know if you see what's kind of going on in the world of streaming, but Tubi is a free service and it's ad supported. So we do get paid per.
you know, stream and stuff like that, but our audience is able to watch it for free as long as they would like to sit through, you know, advertisements, commercials, like the old school TV way of doing things. I was just going to say, what? I don't know. Go right back. We're going right back. Hey, if the content's good enough, I will sit through all 100 prescription drug advertisements that seem to take over the streaming services. I will, I'll get myself some, I don't know. What's the, it's a big one. Trimphaya. Open up your phone. Right, right. And we'll be right back after a quick word from our sponsors.
Thanks to our sponsors, and now we're back to the program. All right, so let's talk a little bit about the case. Yeah, tell us who was Heather Elvis. So she was a 20-year-old who went missing from Myrtle Beach, and she was involved in a love triangle. You could say it was with a married man who was older. His name was Sidney Moore, and his wife was Tammy Moore. And once she disappeared, they became the prime suspects in the case.
This story has been covered before it was on Investigation Discovery. I think Dateline did two episodes on it. So that the actual story itself, I think, you know, the love triangle and everything, you know, it's been covered many times. One thing that we wanted to dig deeper in with this documentary is how social media played a role in the investigation, in how the public perceived the case. And I think it was very important because this case happened around 2013, 2014. This is right when Facebook was kind of, you know, when iPhones were combining together and more and more people were starting to chat about cases. I think this phenomenon, as we've seen with the...
Karen Reed case, as we've seen with, I think I just saw one about Bam Mangiora, the guy from Jackass, and how this social media played into his conservatorship and all these conspiracy theories. So it's starting, you know, people are starting to become more aware of how social media influences cases now. And it's a huge part of it. I mean, I think I was listening to this one lawyer during the Karen Reed case just happened. He's just like, maybe people, you know, people who are involved in any case are going to have a PR team or really worry about what's going on online. So this case was one of the, I think one of the first ones where social media really, really took investigators by surprise and just harassment and conspiracy theories and how it was used.
As we've seen play out years after, it's just become a theme. But that was one of the main things that we investigated. And it's an amazing story. I think that we still don't know where Heather is. So bringing awareness to that story is very important. The family would like to know, would like to have answers. So there's multiple things going on here. Can we just get into a little bit more of Heather's circumstances and her family life and how she met Sydney?
Yeah. She worked at this, this restaurant called the tilted kilt. It's, it's, I don't know if it's still around. I don't know if that location is still around, but it's one of these restaurants where it's kind of like Hooters. And he was, he was a maintenance guy there and they met at work. And one.
thing when when a big part of the story i think that people you know they always argue about online was you know she shouldn't mess with a married man or you know she shouldn't have gotten involved like that but there was a huge age gap in that relationship i think he was close to 40 and she was like you know 19 20 years old at the time so i don't i mean you know say what you want but she was very young i think she did not really understand kind of the dynamics of of Sidney Moore and his relationship and everything else. And he also said, you know, Hey, look, my wife is okay with this. You know, it was an open marriage. This isn't a big deal. You know, I'm going to leave my wife at some time. And this is according to her roommate who we interviewed in the documentary. And she talks about that part of it, but that's how that relationship came to be. You have some really good reenactments in your doctor series and you have very good performances from your actors who are portraying these characters. If I were enlisted to play Sidney, I'd want to take a shower every single day. Like that is a disgusting person. I'm just giving you my, my initial.
feelings on this individual and his wife of course we'll get to but was there ever a time when you and the actors would get together and talk to each other and say I can't believe that they were blaming her in some way as a 19 year old and not looking at this like horrible 40 year old who knows what they're doing understands you're he's working at the tilted kilt like he's surrounded by all of these young women with the uniform like you said it's like a hooters only they're wearing kilts I mean he's just preying on them just and just she happened to be the one that that he reeled in. Like, sorry, I'm going on a rant, but did that affect the actors at all? Did you guys talk about that? You know, it's interesting. The guy who played City Moore, even I was talking to other people that were following the case and they kept pointing out how much he looked like him, you know? And it was like, yeah, you know, nicest guy he'll ever meet. I mean, he lives, actually, I see him all the time running on the beach. So I bump into him all the time. He's like, how are things going? You know, and he looks just like City Moore. It's crazy, you know? So yeah, I mean, he's a sweetheart. He's the nicest guy ever made. He completely looks like him, but does not act like him. I mean, everyone, especially the girl who played Heather Elvis said the same thing. I mean, she's young herself, you know? And I think.
Everyone thought that, you know, disgusting people, you know, just anybody who preys on a young girl like that knows what risk he's putting her at because he knows who his wife is. That's another part of it. And I don't know his background, if this is something that he did in the past. I've heard things. I mean, I don't want to say I didn't investigate that myself. I mean, obviously, when I'm in Myrtle Beach recording this, people are telling me a lot of things about him. I don't know what's true. You know, these are rumors and hearsay, but who knows if this is the first time he did this or he did this in the past. You know, this is this thing. But I mean, he does know his wife's temperament and what type of risk he's putting these people at.
And like you said, I mean, she's 19. She's not 30 years old. I mean, she's too young to even understand, even get an inkling of understanding the situation. I'm sorry, 20. I think she was 20 at the time she went missing. But still, that's almost a teenager. I mean, in my books, you know, way too young. Yeah, absolutely. Now, her car was left behind. Can you tell us about the circumstances in which her car was found and then the investigation really began? Yeah, they found her car at this place called the Peachtree Boat Landing. It's kind of a remote area.
I went out there multiple times while I was filming. You see people kind of going there to be out of the eye of the public. I don't know what they're doing, but even when we're sitting there, just random people come in there and they see we're there and then they turn right around. So, I mean, it's one of those places that's just out of sight, you know, and it is a remote area. So it's, you know, Myrtle Beach is a tourist area. You have a lot of people, especially in the summer. So when you go back up to Sacaste where this happened, it's a lot more remote. It wasn't Myrtle Beach. So it was one of those places where it's a little eerie when you're over there, especially at night when we were doing some B-roll footage, filming some B-roll footage. That's where they found a car.
And then after that, the whole story unfolded. And they found out through her roommate and phone records and stuff like that, that these were the phone calls that were last made. And then they started putting the pieces together for the investigation. Can you tell us a little bit more about what you consider to be the inciting incident here with Heather and the relationship between her and Sydney as far as when it escalated and the decision was made to do something about it? There's speculation that she might have been pregnant. And that's something that came up around that time. There was also a thing when he was on the night she went missing, he was buying a pregnancy test. So we don't know what that was used for. I mean, he never.
He never, he never testified in court, but there was that speculation and a big part of the motive in the case. So that, that was it. And then also his wife, when she found out there was a little bit of a back and forth between her and Heather, then, you know, kind of ended. So it kind of makes you wonder, you know, why did they re-engage or what was going on there? It makes you wonder. Yeah. And can we talk a little bit about Tammy, Sydney's wife? So what was she like? And then what was, what happened when she found out about Heather and Sydney?
I never spoke to her. We did not have a chance to interview her because this is interesting. South Carolina does not allow prisoners to be interviewed. So we reached out and we tried and we weren't able to. We wrote letters and stuff like that. So but she did testify, which I think was was interesting. So you did get to hear her side of the story, which we put a big part of that in the documentary, you know, in episode three. So I think I think it was important to get her side in there. It seemed like, you know, she was the dominant one in that relationship. You know, there is there is some, you know, where we show kind of where he gets a tattoo of her name.
on his, on his, on his abdomen. And also that she was handcuffing him or supposedly was handcuffing him to the bed and kind of as a punishment, which he admitted to police. She said it wasn't true in her testimony. Also, I mean, I don't want to give away too much here in the movie, but you know, so there's, you know, speculation on what really was going on there, but she seemed very much like the dominant one there. And in a big part of the movie and a big part of the debate is, you know, was this an open relationship? Was she upset? Was there an element of jealousy here, which, you know, she, she was denying. But when you look at the circumstances and the evidence, you know, maybe someone could come to a different conclusion. And we showed, we showed that in the film, those aspects of it.
Yeah, her behavior when she was testifying at the trial was so arrogant and condescending towards the prosecution. And I really am curious if there was anything that was said to you off camera about how she came across when she was being questioned on the stand, because it seemed like she just sunk herself. I think a big mistake was testifying, but... You know, one of the jurors expressed that, you know, she kind of couldn't, you know, didn't seem remorseful. But at the same time, I think she had that character where, you know, she was going to explain to everybody her side of the story, what happened here. She was upset at Sidney for not testifying in his trial. He didn't take the stand.
Off camera. Um, I don't want to say who or what or when, but yeah, I mean, a lot of people didn't, weren't really, didn't say too many things about her being friendly. Let's put it that way. Um, so, you know, and not only that, just how she acted throughout the whole investigation. I mean, was she being cooperative? I mean, if she really, if she really was concerned, like you said later that, you know, she wants to find Heather and this and that and the other thing, you know, why wasn't she more cooperative and being nicer to people, you know, online and stuff like that. So. Yeah. And you're bringing up the online and being nicer to people online. Tim and I are very familiar with that whole.
twisted environment. It's a gross swamp that a lot of people exist in. And that term troll, you know, we learned about that many, many years ago. And it's so hard to wrap your head around why somebody does this, a psychological thing that they do. And a lot of our listeners know what it is. But can you explain some of that that happened in Heather's story?
Yeah. I mean, I think in this situation, it's, it's, and that's another thing when I was talking to the family and talking to people involved in the case, I really didn't understand it. It's like, who are these people? How did they kind of group together? How do they work as a group? Like who's leading the group and what's their motives and stuff like that. I think it's multifaceted. I mean, you have Tammy Moore, who's obviously very invested in, invested in the people to think that she's innocent and that someone else did it because maybe, you know, she doesn't want to be, you know, she's the one being investigated and prosecuted for the crime. And she's trying to show that she's innocent. And then you also, who are these out of state trolls and people who just want to get attention or pushing her theories and kind of riling everything up. And.
I mean, every, everyone jumps on now. I will say this, I've noticed this, this whole ecosystem explode since then in the last 10 years of just how many more people are in line, how many more, you know, this is 10, 12 years ago, how much more of a infrastructure there is and just in true crime and law and whatever, whatever not. And just sometimes a lot of it, it turns into entertainment, you know? I don't, I don't want to keep up bringing, I don't want to keep bringing up Karen Reed, but if you see kind of how that social media played a role in that case, I mean, it's, it's like the Heather Elvis case on steroids, if you really think about it. And we'll be right back after a quick word from our sponsors.
In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game. And in less than a minute, it slipped away. But he continued to chase the high. He controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepard, and from CBC Podcasts and the Toronto Star, The Most Wanted Olympian. The Most Wanted Olympian, available now on Spotify.
Thanks to our sponsors, and now we're back to the program. Yeah, me and Lance were talking before we started recording, too, about how there really probably isn't an appropriate amount of research done on this phenomenon yet. And this sort of topic gets political, too, when we talk about the last three presidential elections. I think before that time period, you wouldn't have believed that the internet could have that kind of hold over people. But now I think it's more common. But again, there really isn't that academic research that's been done to say how truly effective this is. And certainly it's a tactic that...
you know, people who know what happened in these cases will do. And it's, it's quite amazing, quite shocking. Yeah. I mean, if you, I mean, just look at it from this, this point of view too. So let's say you have a, even a YouTube channel and you're a criminal defense lawyer. Cause I, that's why I work with him. You're not going to take the prosecution side because that's going to be, that's your kind of your audience there. But in a lot of times good criminal defense lawyers create conspiracies, you know, that's how they get, that's how they bring up reasonable doubt, you know, so that's how these things go. And then people start to hear these and you know, the public here, you know, they start to believe in whatnot. And you know, that person did it. And it's just like, well, you really piece together the evidence. You look at their motive. Like, why would that person?
do it. I mean, there's just no evidence for it, but yet when you look at the conspiracy and whatnot, where that's just how, that's how these, these trial, if you look at the OJ case, right? I mean, um, it's just a big conspiracy, you know, the LAPD framed OJ, you know, but what motive did they have for that? You know, but by bringing up that conspiracy, bring reasonable doubt into it. So I get that. And, um, there's authors, there's people write books about this stuff, you know, and conspiracies, you know, they're always, you know, people, that's a whole genre in itself, you know, that sells. Um, so yeah, I mean, it's, it's, the internet only amplifies it, you know, and it's part of it. I don't know how you stop it because freedom of speech is, is a huge cornerstone of our democracy. I mean, there's no way we can go without it. And
kick off the internet and who you allow on. And, you know, like you talked about politics and where do you draw that line? We don't want one side to get, you know, to get, to go one way or the other. So it's here to stay, you know, and I don't know how, I really don't know how you, how you change. I mean, with trolls, I think identity is a huge thing. I think social media is starting to realize that the companies, people having to, I think, show who they are or things like that. I think that can, that can help. There's, there's ways to do it, but I mean, they're always going to be, I mean, the way the media is structured, I mean, you're always going to have that in politics and law and everything. So I think it's here to stay. Yeah, I agree. I think it's here to stay, but there's going to be some parameters that are put up. Like you said, you need to verify. Yeah
identities and I think that will help quite a bit and I also think that law enforcement is starting to come around on a little bit more of a serious you know mindset towards it or approach towards it by saying and we'll use Karen Reed again by saying you are actually impeding an investigation you are you are conflicting this investigation that happened with the person in Worcester that I'm not going to give any credence to by saying right you know what that person put online that that that is now going to be deemed as illegal like you can get arrested for right for that's defamation right exactly exactly so as long as the checks and balances are all put in place I think that there can be some control and regulation over it but on the same side I hate the fact that people like Tammy or whomever in Heather's story will comment and put out there a statement about Heather's family, about the father. Like he's involved. You got to look at them first. I hate that the person who does that thinks they're so smart. Like they've uncovered some grand psychological revelation that I can just say the family did it.
And know, like, that's brilliant. Like, that's not brilliant. It's just basic to feed off of someone's desire to want there to be a sensational story. We saw it with JonBenet Ramsey. People are so passionate about JonBenet Ramsey. And Tim's going to roll his eyes because I've said this so many times. One of the investigators has said, and I love this, has said, like, all of these rumors are just hurting the investigation because all the investigators are doing now is trying to prove a negative.
That's all they're doing. And that's wasting so much time. You could say anything. I could say, I could say you're really Michael Bay and you just wanted to make a documentary and put an ER at the end of your name and you wanted to fly under the radar with this one. So you just said you're Michael Bayer. I can put that out there. And for the next, like, however many years, you just be trying to prove that negative and be like, I'm really not. Although maybe, maybe you don't try to prove the negative in that particular. Right. No, in that situation, like, yeah, that name helps. Yeah. But you know what I mean? Like, did, did, did, do you think that Tammy thought she was just so smart by doing these things?
you know, I really, I can't, people DM'd me on Facebook saying, Hey, I think, I think Terry did it or, and this is way after everything that unfolded. Are you making a documentary about this? I want to tell you my theories and stuff. I'm like, yeah, sure. Let me hear. And I'm like all these like just wild and bizarre theories. And I was just like, that's kind of when I got a grasp of like, wow, how to control this thing get. And then I started to look deeper into it. It's just like, it just, it just feeds on itself. It's just, it's, it's.
bizarre i mean because like there is zero evidence that his father had anything to do with her sister or any family member at all and if you look at how strong the evidence is towards the moors i mean the truck um the motive uh you know the text messaging everything else I mean, it's just like now you're saying it's their father. I mean, it just doesn't make any sense. And how it got to that point and how people believe it. I think Tammy is smart. I mean, I will say one thing. I mean, the way she used sock puppet accounts, and that's something that John Lorden was talking about, how it looked like other people were liking and commenting. And also, I think that played a huge part because that's social proof. And, you know, now I think people are a little more wise to that. But I think at the time, when you start hearing it over and over again and people saying this, maybe that was. And people want to dig in and then they want to investigate themselves. Maybe there's something in here. There's some kind of cover up. And I mean, just like, I mean, you guys are from Massachusetts. You just hear it. I mean, just the Karen Reed case and just how people got deeper and deeper. It's like, guys.
You think the cops killed a friend? Think about it. Where's the motive? And they got away with it. With all this media attention, think about it. And they just nail out to one little thing that was the search or something. And the same with this case here. I mean, here's a big part of how the rumor mill started. And Tammy was very smart. She went and got all the police records with the public in half. So they had an investigation by the roommate. I'm sorry, they had a video. What's it called?
where they were interviewing her roommate, Bree. And she was saying that she was kicked out of the house. And she thought she had a bad relation with her dad. And so she just took that and put it online. And there you go. I mean, that's saying it from the roommate. So wait, what's going on here? And then the comments start. And so she was smart in picking apart the evidence and the discovery and putting out things only she wanted the public to know, not the things, not the other side of the story. So yeah, that was smart. Absolutely. It's definitely an effective strategy. And as you noted, probably more effective a few years ago, like when she was doing that, than it would be now. People are a little more wise, yep.
Yeah, and it was nice to see John Lorden on there help us sort of get a feel for all that. Yep. I don't see a lot of suspects in cases act like Tammy acted in this case. I think there's a component to her personality where she believes that she's the smartest person in the room and she had to control the conversation. Actually, it's been pretty rare. I really haven't seen anyone swing as hard or kind of be as loud as she was. Now, was there one site, one social media site that people gravitated towards for these rumors more than others? I think at the time Twitter and Facebook were the big ones.
You didn't have Instagram, YouTube, probably. But I think Facebook and Twitter were probably your two biggest at that time. Now Facebook is, you know, not what it used to be. You know, you have all the TikTok and everything else. So now tell us about the stalking of Heather, because it seemed like Sydney and Tammy, too. They were both stalking Heather before she went missing. Can you tell us about that?
Yeah, I mean, think about it. You're a 40-year-old and you're sitting here stalking a teenager almost. It's sick. I think they would hide out by her work. There was a point where she came into work with a black eye. That's from her roommate who worked over with her at the Tilted Kilt. I don't think she ever admitted to what happened there, but if that had something to do with the stalking or what they were going to eventually do. So yeah, it went on for a little bit before she disappeared. The police were able to use cell phone data, the pinging.
uh the cell phone and that's uh in the um i was a guy out in idaho that they just they just got um co-worker yeah they were able to use the cell phone pinging and i think that was that's a huge huge way where police can really piece things together because they know that they look why is heather here and you're here if you look at the two cell phone datas you know why are you they can trace kind of the movements and everything like that so that's another big you know, piece of evidence that, hey, these people probably had something to do with it. Why were their phones following her around? For sure. Yeah, I think that's quite a big clue, in my opinion. Huge. And if you look at the Kohlberger situation, I don't know if they've been able to get him if it wasn't for the cell phone, or at least, you know, obviously he had one other person in there. But I mean, if you look back at Ted Bundy, and I think that's who Kohlberger reminds me of, he probably would have kept doing this as a serial killer. And how do you imagine if you had Ted Bundy's cell phone? You know, you would have gotten him a lot quicker. That's an interesting thought experiment.
I never thought about that. Like, what if what if Ted Bundy had a cell phone? What if the Zodiac had a cell phone? That's an interesting experiment. Right. Or their cars had GPS. I'm telling you, Kohlberger would have been a cell. Look, I'm just saying what I what I don't know, maybe. But just kind of just seeing how he had no motive to do this was kind of like a thrill to him. Why wouldn't he just do this over and over again? You know, this is his first was his first killing, you know. So. All right. That's part one. We will be back tomorrow with part two of the interview with Michael Bayer and Lance and I's final thoughts. Thanks a lot for listening. This episode is brought to you by TELUS.
Scammers. They're about as annoying as this. Tell them to buzz off with TELUS. Get built-in scam protection included on new mobility plans and help protect yourself from pesky scam texts, calls, and emails at no additional charge. Visit telus.com slash scam protection to learn more. Conditions and exclusions apply.