Skip to content
558: A Brown Trouser Moment episode artwork

Mar 12, 2026 1 hr 7 min

558: A Brown Trouser Moment

from Material Hosted by Andy Ihnatko and Florence Ion

Andy and Flo explore the competitive threat posed by Apple's new MacBook Neo. They're both unsurprised that YouTube has officially surpassed the Mouse in revenue. The hosts also examine the very difficult week for Waymo's self-driving fleet.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

558: A Brown Trouser Moment

0:00 1:07:27
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Good morning, good afternoon, good evening. This is the Material Podcast, episode number 558. God, we've been going for such a long time. I'm Florence Ion, and I'm joined here, as always, by my co-host, Andy Anaco. Hello, Andy. And as long as truth is being shrouded and put underneath baskets, blankets, tarps, and hampers by the tech elite, we will be there every Wednesday, sometimes every Thursday, sometimes very late on a Thursday, to record our podcast. Sometimes very, yes, correct. And then you'll hear us sometimes very early on a Friday.

Thanks to everybody for just kind of sticking with us. I know sometimes following the news leads to a slightly, I don't want to call it erratic, but it's definitely. Anyway, we love you all so very much. Andy, I got to ask you something. I've been dying to ask you this, actually. Did you hear what Timothée Chalamet?

I'm sorry, complete your question, yes. Listen, we don't have to get into what a fool he is, all right? Or the fact that he's Kardashian-pilled or anything like that, okay? Because it's not... That's not the intention of my bringing this up. Actually, what my intention is, is, so I realize, okay, so for those who have no idea what I'm talking about, because this is very pop culture, it's very much in the middle of pop culture here, Timothee Chalamet, who is an actor, you may know him from Dune, okay? He's the boy. He's the boy, Zendaya's the girl. There you go. He is dating a Kardashian, and I'm not saying that Causation...

Or whatever equals causation. Correlation equals causation, yes. Thank you. Because you all know that I have always tried to keep kind of like a mid-mind about the Kardashians because they are a very unfortunately powerful family. And so I do still have to kind of like watch them. Or what? Your restaurant will lose its liquor license or something? What? I don't know. But I mean, for instance, Kim Kardashian made headlines because she brought her... Anyway, this is not important. What's important?

is that timothy and the reason we pronounce his name that way is because his name is spelled uh the french way okay he comes from a family of performance artists his mother his sister i think he has a cousin who also like does ballet and opera whatever this is a guy who comes from a really talented stock he went to the same performing arts school as Oh God, it just fell off my mind. But a bunch of kids went to this very famous performing arts school in New York. And so a lot of them you see in indie films and in big Oscar winning films these days because they got their start in one of those schools. God, I know so much about this person.

No, but okay. So he basically made a mean comment saying something along the lines of, and this is just my paraphrasing, something about how the opera and the ballet maybe aren't as relevant of art forms as the theater and the movie theater. Something along those lines. And of course, it created backlash. And this actually happened last week. So over the weekend, I was fielding a lot of responses from all the opera houses in the United States, right? With social media channels. God bless you all.

It was like the libraries, when all the libraries logged on to social media, like social media got better because of that. And I actually really do love, for instance, the San Francisco Opera, the SF Opera account. And I wanted to send it to you, but I always want to send it to you and I have to stop myself. So I hope you find your way there someday. But they recently got a Gen Z social media.

editor, whatever you want to call it, manager. And it's been really cute the way that they've been, and I don't mean cute in a derogatory way. I mean, sincerely, that's awesome the way that they've been kind of trying to reach out to the social media crowd. And so this is all to say, I have decided that I need to go to the opera. So I decided that I need to support it in contrast to Timothee and the Kardashians, but also because I haven't gone to a pro, I mean, I went to the Nutcracker Ballet about two winters ago, but you know.

And these art forms are very, very underfunded, unfortunately. But they are such a beautiful part of being in a metropolitan area, having access to that kind of experience. The fact that I get to go on part. I get to get a train and go down to downtown San Francisco. And I get to walk through the gritty city to get to my historical theater to go watch an opera. And so all of this is to say, as I guess, thank you, Timothy, because you being a scornful little boy, which I can call you because I'm an elder.

compared to you, has led me to just want to go and give money to all the beautiful performing arts that we have in the Bay Area. And I actually posted about it this morning on Instagram. My story is just because I was musing out loud. And a couple of my friends were like, I want to go to the opera with you. So, bye.

So I said to my friend, I said, I need to ask Andy before I decide what I'm going to. And the SF Opera has got its calendar for the next two years. So there is a lot to do. We don't have to decide it right now on the episode. That's not what I meant. I just wanted to let you know that in the coming days, perhaps weeks, knowing me and my procrastination, I will be reaching out to you, trying to ask you, do you think I should go see The Barber of Seville? Or do you think I should wait to go see Elektra?

Ooh, those are two tonally very different operas. I know, I kind of figured. That's like, I mean, you've got like something that for an opera, it's very, very lightened up the thing and fun versus you run the risk of, one of the reasons why I love opera is that no other art form, whether it's live performance, recorded performance, whatever novels, moves me immediately and emotionally like opera. So if it's a really, really heavy story, I need to like sort of like figure out, okay, Andy. You'll probably be back out on the streets at, I'd say, 10.48 p.m.? Where are you going to hang out for an hour to compose yourself before you go on the subway and go back?

I don't know. And the other question is that, because I sometimes get this kind of question of like, hey, what would be a good first opera? And we're like, hey, I think I'm going to be in New York. I want to go see something that I'm at. Here's what's being presented during the four days I'm in town. And you kind of want to be hip and cool and say, oh, well, gosh, there's a producer. There's a production of a Philip Glass opera, Iconotin, that the staging, I can't even contemplate it, but it debuted. And that's absolutely true. It's beautiful. It's lovely.

But if you see, if you recommend La Boheme, which is, and particularly at the Met, which is, it is one of like the two or three operas where, oh, I recognize this music. Like, oh, wow, this music, I recognize that theme from, it was in Rent and it was in Moulin Rouge and it was like, and it was in that cheese commercial from like, from 2003. And the staging at the Met is like, this is like the most over the top in such a beautiful way, staging that only a company like the Met Opera, which is, I think is like one of the best funded like arts organizations in the world. They have like. They don't hire like, oh, well, there's sort of like a village crowd scene. Okay, so we'll hire like 10 to 13. No, we can't afford 13. We'll hire 10 people and put them in pets and costumes. At the Met, it's like, let's see, we've got several dozen people that are full-time chorus members and several dozen people who are full-time artists. We can pack that freaking stage with people and activity. So that's why I tend for people who've only seen, maybe seen a couple and haven't really, who haven't really gotten into it yet. I will always say the one that you're kind of familiar with, I think will be more fun. So I would say if it were between those two,

I would definitely say Barbara Seville. You can compare it to all of the Warner Brothers cartoons that you've seen that involve like the conductor messing with the tenor as they're singing the big Figaro song. Oh, I love, I love, I love that Bugs Bunny. Vignette, whatever you want to call it. I have some friends in the Met Opera Chorus and the number of, the number of them that have like in their little dressing cubicles like Bugs Bunny figurines like from What's Opera Doc or from like the, the Barbara Seville one. Like, yeah, they're, they know what they're about.

Well, see, so if there's one good thing that could come out of this, right? It's like negative press. All press is good press, right? Negative press. Yeah. I mean, you know what? I didn't even consider posting on social media about it. Basically, the headline of the story is kind of dumb actor, movie actor says something dumb and ignorant that it's not like, oh, how dare he? It's like, you know what? That's kind of like when someone says something that is like wrong on its face.

It's like, yeah, you know what? Like every city pretty much has an opera company, whether it's a permanent opera company or visiting opera company. This medium has been around for hundreds of years now with no signs that there will ever not be new productions like happening. I appreciate that. I appreciate that. Like I have never been riding the commuter rail and overheard someone talking about how, oh my God, I just saw this new Philip Glass opera at the Met and it's wonderful. And me, oh my God, Iconotin, did you see Iconotin? Yes. Like, oh my God.

That's more likely to happen with a Marvel movie, say. I will allow that. But we don't have to defend ballet and opera. If anything, I'm glad that it gives these institutions a chance to basically a free, like the door is open for a walk into this room where people are now talking about these comments and now put it into people's heads and say, hey, you know what? There is actually like an opera company in your city. And maybe they'll even find out. One of the most basic things that I tell people like recommending like the Metropolitan Opera is that if you come in and you want to see some live theater, you can choose between.

Someone who was on RuPaul's Drag Race did not win, but made it through to the final five or six, who can kind of carry a tune, but not really. No acting experience, no dancing experience, but they've been put into one of the lead roles of this musical on the fact that, hey, social media, it'll be a draw. That ticket will cost you $180. Okay. Whereas that fully staged version of La Boheme, which might also feature an international superstar of opera, will cost you at minimum $40 with prices all the way up. The SF Opera starts at $28 the ticket, by the way.

And those aren't great seats, but the music goes everywhere. Yeah, it's not about the seats, guys. It's about the experience and being with your friend. And then after you go out with your friend, you get some tea. And then you guys talk about what you think the meeting was. And then you go and you Google the meeting. And you realize that both of you had no idea what the heck happened on stage, actually. And then you spend the next week reading every think piece you possibly can on this opera and what you probably should have gotten out of it. And so that's what happens to me. That's why I always tell people, this is something that I learned on my own. And this is the advice I give myself that, you know what?

read the libretto, like read a good synopsis of the story and go in knowing what happens because you know what? Like scaffolding. Yeah. You probably know what happens to Tosk at the end, but maybe you will not know exactly what the relationships are like and what they're really singing about down there. There are super captions projected above the stage usually, but even there it's like, you know what, I would like to go on at least being able to recite in one paragraph format what the story is. I don't know what this guy is singing, but I know why he's there and what he's there to do to this poor woman. I know he's supposed to be killing her because for some reason that's opera for you. Oh, that's the other thing about opera. It's very metal.

That's a lot of... It is very, very metal. It is very metal. My favorite opera is Lucia de Lamamore. And again, this is like the starter pack of explanations where people are genuinely interested and they don't mind if I will speak for five minutes explaining what's so cool about opera. I always say, okay.

There's a scene in Lucia de Lamamore where Lucia, the lead, she has been sort of emotionally manipulated into marrying someone she doesn't love. She basically went along with it because her heart has just been broken because of part of machination behind the scenes. But she had sort of like a break with reality and she murdered, murdered her new husband on their wedding bed while the wedding reception was still going on downstairs. And so she emerges in her bridal gown, covered from head to toe with blood and holding a knife. And then sings a 10-minute super metal aria about her mental state while all of the partygoers are looking on horrified. There is an opera that I did not get to see, but it's also legendary. I can't remember what the one was. But the director who was staging it decided that, you know what would be awesome right here?

What if we turned the entire Met Opera stage into sort of like a shallow pool and we filled it with fake blood so that when all the chorus members and everyone's walking through, they're basically splashing up blood and their legs and the bones of their costumes are being coated with fake blood. And someone said, well, of course, that'll be a difficult thing to pull off. I'm not saying no. I love this idea. Let's just figure out how to do that safely because, of course, there's no way we're not doing this. And you spent $30 to get in to watch this, not $180 to hear, again, American Idol season 12 rejected in round three.

try to be Sally Bowles in Cabaret. That's my pitch for opera. Oh, I love it. Thank you so much for indulging me in that for a second. Thank you for indulging me, you and listeners, for listening to me enthused about opera. Because I haven't been back to the Met for a couple of years for reasons I have nothing to do with opera. And it's like, oh man, I really got to go back soon. It's a trip for you. You have to plan it. The thing is, what I keep telling myself is that normally, it's not that bad. But the thing is, it's like, and also I have a dear, dear friend that I enjoy visiting in New York and I can stay at his place.

And so it's like Amtrak ticket plus staying at his place and then probably getting a good cheap ticket to something. But even so, I try to be a little bit more careful. I try not to say I'm going to spend $200 or $300 just because I kind of want to have a fun weekend in New York City. I try to say, oh, wow, the Apple event where they're introducing that new super cheap notebook is happening. Great. I'm definitely going to that. While I'm there, I'll extend my trip by two or three days. I'll go to the Met. And unfortunately, Apple didn't invite me to that this year. But that's the sort of thing I'm talking about. Yeah.

Well, hopefully we will have a chance to see each other in New York. Hopefully. See the opera once again. Indeed. That is what I manifest. All right. Speaking of manifestations, let me tell you what is not manifesting so well for Google. That MacBook Neo that Apple announced last week, it is the hottest thing right now on social media, which is partially why I'm kind of not like...

I'm just kind of sitting back because every time I open my phone, it's about the MacBook Neo. We're going to actually talk a little bit about it because it's pretty much coming after the Chromebook game. And although we don't cover Windows on this podcast, I can also say it seems the Windows industry is also looking the other way, covering your ears, going la la la, hoping that it just goes away. We'll talk about it. And then we'll get back to Google and we'll talk about some good news for Google. So a financial research firm has told us what we all were feeling anyway. YouTube is officially bigger than Disney. Yep, we'll talk about that. And they've done less damage to characters from the Marvel Creative Universe and Star Wars. Let's put that out there. That's also true. In fact, you could probably still find the original cuts of those movies and what have you on YouTube than you could on Disney's streaming service. So maybe this will become why Disney has faltered. And then we're going to talk about Waymo because Waymo has...

been making the news a lot. And although we're going to talk about some instances that happen outside of California, I can also say anecdotally, I've also been fielding a lot of posts on Reddit about Waymo. Like now that Waymo is this big thing, there's a lot more to say about it. So we're going to talk about that. I also want to let you know that we are going to have an extra little bit of Andy and Flo time for our members. So we want to thank our members for being here and being a sustaining member of the Relay Network. This week, Andy and I are going to be talking about, well, Andy is purporting that he's fixed Google search, but he's also worried about it. For myself, not for everybody. I'm sorry. I've been really busy for the past couple of weeks. If I get around to it, I'll fix it for everybody right now. I'm just fixing it for myself. I want to set expectations correctly there. Well, at least if you ruin it for yourself, it's not for all of us, right? So this is good. Andy's the guinea pig.

That's how I was here. We're the guinea pigs. You are way more adorable than a guinea pig. Sorry, all the guinea pigs out there. Yeah, if you want to find out about becoming a member so you can get access to that reel of speaking, you can go to relay.fm slash membership to find out more. Become a sustaining member of material today. You help us. You help us so much. You have no idea. Especially me over here, Miss Freelance Life. I wanted the freedom. I wanted the time. Let me tell you guys, freedom doesn't pay the bills.

But you get to experience the growing upness of your doable daughter. Who can put a price tag on that? I definitely have been taking her to school a lot more often than I ever did before. Awesome. Anyway, it's all because of you guys out there helping sustain us. We're going to take a quick little break. And then when we get back, we're going to just roll into it. And sorry, we're going to talk about Apple. Well, I don't know if you've seen, but everybody has caught on that Apple is now making colorful laptops at a very affordable price. Now, these are...

You are going to say $5.99 laptops. I'm going to rant off and say these are $600 laptops. I know. Listen, I like the zero zero of it a little more than the nine nine. Now, what's interesting is they they have they were able to offer the laptop at this price point because they put in a two year old iPhone processor. Is that right, Andy? Not only that, but it's the rejects like it's their binned processor. So, yeah. So, I mean, it's not just that it's not just they built. They took an iPhone and added a bigger screen and keyboard to it. But it's like the key.

One of the keys to all this was that, yeah, they were using not the M class, like Apple Silicon, like the desktop class, Mac class processes, but they said, hey, what the iPhone CPU is good enough that maybe it can handle a lot of basic like Mac functions. The other part of it, and I know this is, we're not going to turn this into like a segment on the Neo because I have said and written so much about the Neo. I've read it. I've been every, I've been checking. I know about the Neo because I get your, because I'm on a special friends newsletter list. And I was like, oh, oh yeah. I have one more piece left to go. And even then I'm like, I hope I'm not.

I hope I'm not testing people's tolerance of content. I think it's one of the biggest things Apple has done in a long time. It really is. There are a handful of fence post hardware releases. Again, the first Macintosh, the first iPod, the first iPhone. There are a handful of these things that are like, wow, this is actually kind of a moment in the history of Apple. And a truly affordable MacBook.

beyond much cheaper than this is at the bottom price is what i what i would have found thought even remotely okay to consider like as a prediction okay uh that's a pretty like fence post item and it wasn't just because they use like this old phone process it's also because like apple knows how to manufacture aluminum body things really inexpensively or relatively inexpensively. Yeah, they've been doing it for so long. Yeah, they know all the tricks at this point. They don't have to say, okay, enjoy your 64 gigabytes of storage and two megabytes, two gigabytes of system memory. No, this is all very, very credible stuff. Early consensus, I think the review embargo lifted yesterday, I think. And the early consensus is that we were kind of expecting the performance would be good enough, but it's much better than good enough. It's not great, but it's not like...

second-class citizen status. So if anybody who is competing with Apple, including Google, was following these rumors for the past couple of years and thought, okay, but it's going to be made out of plastic, so it won't seem like a premium thing. Or maybe it'll be limited to just apps from the App Store, so it won't have the full power of a Macintosh. Or maybe it won't have upper and lowercase keys. I'm sure we don't have to worry. If not, no, you really do have to worry because this is kind of... If this were like a Windows laptop with all of these specs and the spill quality, it would pretty...

I don't know. I don't want to say it would run the table of that marketplace, but it would be like, how the hell did you build that for that price? They figured it out. Should I get the government on your back? Because clearly you're trying to sell $1,000. If you're losing $300 in each one of these laptops just to put us out of business, we'd be very hurt by that.

Well, as you can expect, of course, Chromebooks. What is going to happen to Chromebooks? There's been a lot of discourse around this. First of all, the number one thing that I see on social media are people retweeting, whatever you want to say, reblogging, whatever it's called this day and age on whatever platform you're on. Essentially...

normies who are really excited about the idea of being able to afford a MacBook. And not just like any normies, we're talking mostly like students and people who just need a laptop to check email and maybe buy tickets on a bigger screen kind of thing. This is the thing that they've been waiting for because I know, again, anecdotally, for my own lifetime in this industry and just watching people use devices, I know that people aren't very, they were not very happy with Windows being the cheap alternative back in the day, especially because of the legacy of bloatware. That's followed it everywhere. And then with the Chromebook, it's so limited in scope compared to what the MacBook can do.

in the sense of running applications. Because the MacBook Neo is running full-scale applications. Am I right? It's running the exact same operating system. The only limitation is its CPU. And that's the same as... And it's no different than the case between a Mac Mini can't do the same thing that... A $500, $600 Mac Mini can't do the same thing as a $6,000 Mac Studio. But once again, I think we'll get more clarity on this as they get in the hands of consumers. Because right now, it's being reviewed by reviewers who... Even the ones that are more credible than others are...

when I was reading the reviews, they were a little bit starry-eyed by this. Like, it's amazing that a $600 notebook can do, the MacBook can do this much. And so it's not, it will take a couple months to really see what that line is between, you know, you can't squeak by, the users who can't squeak by on a Neo know you really are going to want to have like the new M5 MacBook Air or even like a refurbished M4, like a refurbished one that's a year or two old might be a better choice for you than the Neo. But yeah, it's... It's interesting. I've been trying to... I think there have been a lot of commentary that's had the suffix hyphen killer. Like, okay, this is not a Chromebook killer for a couple of reasons. Number one, a $600 notebook is not a $350 notebook. To a school district, yes. Exactly. To an individual, to a family who says, I've got three children, I want each of them to have a laptop of their very own. Do you want...

all of them to have their own laptop or do you want one them to share one of them? Or is it reasonable for even, you know, their kids, this kid is like nine, 10 years old. They're going to screw this up. They're going to drop it. They're going to break it. I don't want them to break even a $600 laptop. I want them to break a $300 one. But you, but you made the even better point that like the thing that's laughable is the idea that school systems that are buying Chromebooks are going to be swayed by the MacBook Neo because again, there's a reason why there's a reason why the cars that are used as taxi cabs are not like general.

They are specifically made to be taxi cabs because kids with their laptops, they are going to just beat the holy crap out of it. Yes, they are. And they're going to see a video on TikTok saying, well, look, you can make sparks come out of a paper clip if you jam it into the USB port of the notebook. Well, I want to do that. Well, it really does happen. I've mentioned in Song and Story over the past few weeks, updating this old, old, old Chromebook. Actually, it was not a Chromebook. It was a Lenovo ThinkPad that...

is sold and designed for deployment in school systems. You can buy it as a Chromebook. You can buy it as a Windows 10 notebook. And looking at this thing, the thing is, you can take the entire damn thing apart with a basic screwdriver. The battery is not glued in. You can just swap that out. The display, you can just simply rip it out and replace it. You don't need special tools. You simply pop out the bezel and you've got access to everything. The keyboard can be pulled out, washed, hosed down, and put back in or replaced.

damn it, this thing could be used as a murder weapon. Like, you know those old episodes of Columbo where like the 1970s where like a phone is used as a murder weapon. That's been like back in the days when like you couldn't own a phone, you can only lease one. And that's what they're made to basically be leased and like swapped out and repaired. That's the sort of thing we're talking about. So that's not, so Chrome, Google does not have to worry about what the Neo is going to do to Chromebooks. But I don't, I'm worried about aluminium now.

Do tell. What's your worry about it? Well, OK, so we've been following this thing ever since at the Qualcomm Developer Conference, I think it was last year, was the first time that Google was super, super public about the idea of, oh, we're now getting very, very serious about putting Android on notebooks. And they're working together with Qualcomm to build a class of CPUs that will work well for that. And they've been developing this new operating system called Aluminium. The clever bit is, oh, it's not Chrome, it's Aluminium. It's a different thing. It's similar to, but not the same thing as. Okay, that's great. And they've also, of course, for several years, been working on turning Android into a desktop-style multi-windowing operating system for now so that it will work with tablets and folding phones, but also in the near future so that we can have low-powered laptops that can run this mobile operating system that will perform and be as productive as a desktop operating system.

Now, however, I don't know how that changes the math of that. I was looking forward to this because it seems like a really interesting idea. But in a world in which they're competing with a $600 really beautifully designed MacBook class in terms of physical design MacBook with like a retina, what Apple calls a retina quality screen for $599, I'm wondering what. what Asus or Acer or Samsung or anybody could build that would be in Best Buy in America and sway people to buy an Android aluminum-based notebook instead of this MacBook with the Apple logo and these fun fruity colors. I don't know. I mean, the world is bigger than the United States, I know, but it's like, yeah, the same problem is going to play out in China and in India and in the UK and in Europe. I bet there's a lot of people drinking that we're not planning on drinking so much last week.

Yeah, I don't know. Let's talk about another big megacorp, shall we? Okay. I'm talking about Disney. We're not actually talking about Disney. I'm laughing at Disney. All right. Listen, I love this so much for YouTube. There is a beautiful, beautiful report that is telling us YouTube has surpassed Disney as the world's number one media company. Now, mind you, this doesn't include Disney's theme parks and, you know, every other tiny little facets of their business. But let's just think about it. Disney, the broadcaster. OK, Disney, the content maker. Think about it in that perspective. Even the movie studio. Yes, in the movie studio. YouTube has surpassed the mouse. Now.

Alphabet, as you can imagine, has been very proud to let investors know about this during every single quarterly results call. And it is a really big deal because not only is YouTube topping Disney, but it's topping Disney's competition as well. So we're talking Warner Brothers. We're talking NBCUniversal. Everybody else is a small player compared to YouTube, the platform. Now, this influential financial analyst firm called Moffitt Nathanson, they ran the numbers and they declared that in 2025, YouTube, its revenue had actually surpassed that.

Disney. So they estimated 2025's revenues would be at $62 billion, while Disney's settle in at just under that at $60.9 billion. It's still a lot of money between the two of them. Disney should be very, very happy. It's not that $60.9 billion is not still a lot of money, comparatively speaking.

Many people would be happy to make half of that in a year. I know I wouldn't. Oh, my God. I'd be happy to make a tiny little speck of that, actually. That would be great. I didn't make $60.9 today. This is not about us, listeners. This is not about us. Yeah. If we did include Disney theme park money and their licensing money, it probably would tell a slightly different story. But we're talking about movies, TV, Disney+, the streaming channel. We're talking about the revenue from all the channels that Disney owns, including ESPN, which is a big sports network. And so...

The fact that YouTube's 2025 ad revenue surpassed Disney, NBC, Paramount, Warner Brothers combined, this is a really big deal. The actual estimate of YouTube's ad revenue is, by the way, $40.4 billion. Whereas if you combine the totals of the other companies that we just mentioned, it's about $37.8 billion. So these are all hard numbers. What does this tell us about YouTube? This tells us a couple of things. A, the fact that YouTube is an app that is on every single Android device that comes bundled in on every single Android device, right there, that's the easy barrier to entry. Anybody could just slot right in and do YouTube. And so because they've had that legacy for so long, I am not surprised by this. Why would you pay the paywall for Disney Plus or for Peacock or for HBO or whatever they want to call it now?

when you could go to YouTube and find exactly the kind of content that you want to watch. Do you know what I've been watching lately for comfort on YouTube? I've been watching, you already know, everyone knows I like train videos. I like the videos where they, I like the videos where they put the video, the camera at the very front of the train and then it's just like the train tracks and it's scenery. Like that's obviously the best. But then I also like the ones where the travel influencers go on the trains and like show you all the amenities you get and show you like how all the trees pop out on Amtrak and stuff because I've never done that before. But the other thing I like, and I've noticed this.

I've noticed this is really coming under the radar. It's old MTV. So, you know, people are restoring hard drives full of DVR content. They're restoring VHS that they have in the basement. Like the people are coming out of the woodworks with this very localized content that they recorded way back when and putting it into these like three, four hour blocks of content. And so if I'm like getting ready to go out with my family, what am I watching? I put on a two hour MTV, you know, it feels like it's 2005 again. I'm watching the commercials from back then. I'm watching the shows from back then. The music rights are all there because it's scraped off the TV.

And there's nowhere else that I can get that kind of content, but I get it through YouTube because it's user-generated. All a person has to do is rip it off of whatever source they have and put it on the internet. And I'm just a small niche of this, of course. We're also talking about the fact that YouTube Premium is doing so freaking well for YouTube, as well as YouTube TV. And YouTube TV, the thing about it is it offers access to all the sports. So you have people paying for the sports packages, and now they're allowing you, I think, to pay a little more a la carte. So if you just want to pay for Major League Soccer...

I think you do that through YouTube. Then you would go to YouTube TV and pay for that or NFL or what have you. So between that, YouTube music and YouTube, what a giant empire Google has, excuse me, Alphabet has. Yeah. That's absolutely true. It's kind of shocking. It seems like for the past year or so, maybe even longer, every single one of their quarterly earnings calls, their CFO mentions that, oh, and YouTube is the number one streaming service in the world. And that's not even counting phones and people watching videos on the subway. It's like, no, people on the sofa watching TV on the big good TV with the remote in their hand. YouTube is far and away ahead of Netflix and everybody else. And that surprised me the first time I heard it.

Maybe because it worries me that like, oh, I thought it was kind of a rebel here. I'm actually kind of mainstream getting most of my like screen time video entertainment through YouTube. But yeah, it's good stuff. And it's just weird to think about how our viewing habits have changed. For some reason today, I got a terrible earworm like today where there used to be a jingle for the TV guide. I was like, lean back, watch TV, open up that magic box and look at what's inside.

Nothing gets you into it like TV. And now it's yours. And it's within my lifetime. There used to be the most popular weekly magazine in the world used to be simply a digest-sized magazine that simply told you what's on TV. It was just TV listings. And now broadcast TV is so irrelevant right now to me. I'm looking forward to watching the Oscars. I'm not as big into it as I was back in maybe the 90s or the early 2000s, but I'm still kind of interested in it. And right now I'm like, what will I have to do? Especially since Conan O'Brien is hosting again. But right now I'm thinking...

how much trouble am I going to have to go through to actually get live broadcast television on the TV in my living room? And or would I not prefer to simply wait a day and watch all the clips that are going to be posted legally and illegally onto YouTube? It's like, you know what? Maybe I can just wait. And boy, you can't. I'm sorry. I just did one of those things where I corrected myself before I said something that was not quite right.

They're like, Google has been blessed with a, they're not like Apple where by and with very, very rare exceptions, they have built everything that made them a huge success. Everything that was like the iPhone, they built that pretty much from scratch. They bought like the operating system that was, it's based on, okay. But in terms of like, they didn't say, oh, here's a nice phone maker. We want to be in the phone business. Let's buy this phone business. By and large, everything that's revolutionized the company and basically turned them into a successful company into a multi-trillion dollar company has been something they built themselves. Whereas Google by and large, and this is not an insult against Google, they have just been very, very shrewd and saying,

Ooh, this video platform looks like it would be very relevant to our future interests. It would be a very good thing for our portfolio and basically wrote a check for $18 and 30 cents. And now it is as big as it is right now. They've done that several times, which basically means their leadership has been consistently very, very wise in figuring out this. Not only is this going to be big, but it's going to, it has a potential to be huge because of what we can add to it. So even though you could fault Google for, well, the Apple built the iPhone, they designed the iPhone, the Macintosh, they invented the Macintosh. Like, yeah, you know what? But there's also something about saying that.

I'm going to buy seeds from somewhere, but I'm going to cultivate them really, really well. And I think that YouTube is case in point. Well, I have to say, again, anecdotally, because that's my favorite thing to say. You know, I've got a story about that saying. Sorry. I'm sorry. I'm ashamed of that. That was actually, that was a really good one, actually. You should not be ashamed of that one. But I was going to say that I realized lately that most of my content now, it does come from YouTube. The only reason that I am still paying for Disney is because the kiddo, that's what the kiddo watches the most. But in terms of content I watch, like.

I think Peacock is the app that I watch the most. Really? Because I watch Housewives and I watch a lot of like, and I watch the Olympics. And so, you know, and NBC had the rights to that and everything. I'm still stuck on the idea that I'm actually about to cancel Netflix for a few months and cancel Hulu for a few months because I've kind of run out of things to watch on it. And that's like a more dramatic version of the same problem that I've been having with Paramount Plus and Disney and Peacock. It's like...

it's like, I will find a couple of things that I want and then there'll be a huge dry spell in which I'm spending 10 bucks a month for something, a membership I don't actually use. So like YouTube is, YouTube Premium is always safe because I don't want to see those commercials. I really, really don't. Oh my gosh, YouTube Premium is amazing. HBO for me is safe because they are constantly rotating in new stuff and I'm not nearly finished watching the old stuff that's already there. They've been, as a cable channel, it's been around for decades. They've created original programming that they'd never lose rights to. That is still kind of superb.

But it's like, I can't keep pending. It wasn't wise when it was seven or eight bucks a month, but now there's 10 or 12 or 13 or $14 a month. It's like, you know what? I'll set a reminder to like renew, reactivate Hulu when the remaining episodes of this season of Bob's Burgers have all been aired. I will reactivate Hulu for at least a month so I can finish out the season of Bob's Burgers. I will watch stuff. Yeah, that's what I'm talking about. It's a weird thing. Only YouTube, because of the fact that it's millions of new videos a day, plus a really good recommendation engine, only that one is always giving me new reasons to keep tuning in. It really is my pick up the remote and see what's on TV reflex that used to be true for broadcast television. Mm-hmm. Oh, my gosh. Well, we still have a little bit to talk about Waymo, so let's take a quick break. Okay.

Well, Waymo isn't the shining beacon of self-driving transportation. I don't know where I was going with that. We're just going to leave it on the podcast. We're not editing out. I don't know how to start this because Waymo is very polarizing. It used to not be as polarizing as it is now, but lately with all of the report infractions, I think it's become a little harder for people to ignore it. If you've had Waymo as a Google alert in Google News, your phone has been very, very noisy this week. Let's put it that way. Yes. And not for reasons that Waymo's marketing department is going to be pleased by it. Let's put it that way.

Well, oh my God. Okay. Okay. How am I going to lay this out? So we've got a astonishing number of embarrassing incidents that have been happening to Waymo. All this just from the last week, by the way. So we're going to discuss the ones that have kind of been the most viral recently. And so the first one is in Austin, a Waymo stopped too late at a railroad crossing. I did see this. And the flashing bar came down behind it.

But fortunately, it stopped itself short of the actual railroad track, but just like the person being inside and seeing that it was driving onto the train tracks. That was a term that I learned in the 80s known as a brown trouser moment. Oh, yes. That's for darn sure. And to be fair, it's not as though like, oh, by the grace of God, it happened to stop just before. No, it's like it seemed as though the logic it was facing where it could not stop. It did not see the flashing light on the bar when it was raised and did not stop in time to stop before. It slowed down, but did not stop in time. So rather than crash into the bar, it decided. I'm sorry.

Basically, it made an intelligent decision that, okay, I can't stop in time, but I can stop well short of the track, so that's what I will do. Apparently, and I didn't put this in the notes, but there was some discussion about this that I saw that claimed that Waymo software actually understands the severity of the problem of being on the tracks when there's an oncoming train. That if it were that kind of a problem where Waymo is aware that I am on train tracks and I'm between two flashing bars that say that there's barriers that say that there's an oncoming train. the program says, go ahead, destroy that freaking barrier, get off those tracks. But nonetheless, again, when you're in the backseat of a car- It didn't hit the barrier. Excuse me? Sorry, I was going to say, it didn't actually hit the barrier, so that didn't come in. Right, so basically what I'm saying is that it's not as though, like, if it had been stuck on the tracks with an oncoming train, the program said, well, I'm certainly not good. There's an obstruction in front of me, but I don't want to scratch the grill work of this vehicle or damage that piece of county property. Like, no, it's told that, yeah, floor the hell out of it, because even if you did not have a passenger behind you-

Preserve yourself. And that would be an inconvenience to the oncoming train if it's smashed into a car, okay? A lot of people are not going to get to work on time if that happens. And that's also bad. We can agree that a fatality would be the worst case scenario, but delaying a commuter train would also not be good, not help promote Waymo's interests. The other thing that also wouldn't help promote Waymo is when a Waymo drives left across eight lanes of traffic, which is what happened in Phoenix. And this is another video that went super viral. There were human...

There were human people in the car. And this particular turn in Phoenix, Arizona, it gets a lot of it's. it's really hard even for human drivers to really like get through. Just to be clear, it's not like it was making an illegal turn like across like this is an intersection where at some point it's a tricky intersection. Exactly. And it's, and it's definitely, I mean, all of us, almost all of us drive and you realize that this is a bad intersection and this is, I can make this turn safely with the implicit agreement of all the other cars that they're going to let me through and not T-bone me. Okay. And that nobody wants a multi-vehicle accident to inconvenience them when they're just trying to go get their takeout sandwich on the way home.

But yeah, again, hard to be like inside a car with a ghost driver and a steering wheel that goes by itself and trust that, oh, is this piece of software that I don't understand trying to kill all of us? I guess we'll find out. Yeah. You understand why the video went viral and why this is not a problem. I mean, it goes viral because right now talking about robot cars and what's happening to the robots you put on the streets, that is just good social media fodder. It's the same way that people in LA are constantly following around those little food delivery robots. But in this case, those food delivery robots, they're very small. Whereas when a Waymo stops and blocks something, they can sometimes block an ambulance that's trying to answer to a mass shooting where people need help. People need immediate help. Thank God that never happened to Waymo. That didn't happen last week too, did it?

Yeah, no, it did happen last week. And so city authorities in both Austin and Phoenix, they have restricted Waymo while they're getting answers. You know, they're investigating in this. And then, of course, Fast Company published a report recently on Waymo's operations in San Francisco. And they based the report on data that they got from the city's agencies. And the article basically, which we're going to point to in the show notes, it outlines all the problems that Waymo's have created for San Francisco's public services. And I have seen these on social media, right, because I live here, so I get them served to me. I have seen these happen between TikTok and threads. It's wild.

Waymos, again, they tend to create conflicts with public transportation. There's a light rail train that goes through San Francisco and it does not come off the tracks. There's also a bus system that is very well integrated into the system. But because, as you can imagine, all those hills and narrow roads that there are to navigate, that if there's a Waymo blocking the way, it can be very hard for a bus to get around it. So the other thing is all this stuff happens and it becomes a pain in the butt because there's no driver to flag. You have to basically go through an online connection situation and try to get somebody on the other line. It takes a lot of effort to try and get help when a Waymo is in a situation it's not supposed to be in. And the other thing that sucks is when there's a Waymo blocking, you know, let's say a public safety situation, there's no way to move it. Like you can't just push it out of the way. It's a car. It's a Jaguar with very nice brakes, very nice disc brakes. So very hard to... To be fair, Jaguar drivers can be jerks.

So it's not like a Ford Fiesta where you'd have, you know what, this is a good salesperson. I trust it. Because I'm just saying this is a nice luxury car, so it's not going to let you move it. Now, according, so this is all like really interesting. This is all happening, right? Because as we learned this week, part of Sundar Pichai's new payment package is actually tied to Waymo's success. Now, they usually do this with executives to keep, you know, the fire underneath their butts.

keep them from slacking off, keep them from really looking at those revenue numbers. And so according to an SEC filing this week, Sundar's new deal is worth as much as $692 million. But he could lose as much as $260 million of that if Waymo doesn't meet certain financial targets over the next three years. It can be very hard to make those targets when you have constant bad news. And Waymo's already left a really bad taste in the mouths of San Franciscans because of what happened to the beloved bodega cat. And not just the beloved bodega cat, by the way. There have been subsequent reports of other animals that have been hurt. I'm on Reddit, as you can imagine, and I'm in the Bay Area subreddits. And I've been unfortunately reading some really awful things about how men can do whatever they want to women in Waymo's. Because again, there is no person in the car and there's no immediate...

help to really call for when you're in the situation. You kind of have to just sit and wait and deal with it in the moment. And so all of this is just creating a really, how should we call this? I wonder if Sundar Pichai wondered to himself that someday I'm going to be leading robot cars and how well they do in the public will reflect upon my salary. I feel like the guy was just hoping he would stick with Chrome and Android. Yeah, it's a weird...

Like we've been all along, I won't speak for you, but I've been impressed with Waymo because Waymo seems to be taking a very sane approach to self-driving. They seem to appreciate the remarkable danger presented by even an edge case failure in the software. And that this is not, given the unprecedented nature of this technology and the damage it can do by basically letting software pilot a... ton and a half missile on the highway with passengers inside and other people on the streets, they have a responsibility to not cut corners, to not look for ways to simplify, not look for ways to like work around whatever regulations there are. Okay. Compare and contrast with, of course, Tesla, which is like, oh, come on. A camera is fine. It costs less money. It's fine. We want our business plans to make sure we do self-driving as a service you subscribe to no matter what car you buy. So we're going to figure out how to get by as few sensors as possible. And whatever happens, happens. Waymo seems to have been, you know what?

We are going to basically we're going to have these cars like the tires run like the rims down to the ground because of all the weight of all the sensors we're loading onto this thing to make sure that no matter what the conditions, they can get a good idea of what's going on. OK, we're going to roll out these services really conservatively. We're going to start off in a very, very small patch of a city where every single street is at right angles to every other street. And then we're going to go into San Francisco where we're absolutely nearby. And we think that we have hands on knowledge of the thing.

But now they're in a position where we are rolling out to as many cities as we think we can. We're still being a little bit conservative, but we are now being bold about expanding the services and we are promoting how many paid rides we are offering. We are completing every single day and every single week. And that means that something that was once. super super rare is now routine like the social media is going to be flooded with every single time the car did something that the passenger was horrified by okay even if it is something that a human driver would have been doing the absolute best and right thing would have done the exact same thing but the fact that there is again ghost driver the steering wheel is just moving on its own responding to software that the passenger does not understand one tiny bit that there will be a certain amount of shrieking there will be a certain amount of again, need for fresh trousers. And Waymo is going to have to try to figure out how do we manage all of this? There's going to be a point, like even when things are perfect and they're by no means perfect right now, there's going to come a time where they have to have that discussion saying that, look, this will never be 100% safe, okay? There are times when it's going to actually screw up. And the two saving graces here are going to be that it will almost certainly be screwing up less frequently than a human driver would in that same situation. And secondly,

At least people who don't have cars because they can't afford it. It's not convenient all the way to know they have certain physical attributes that preclude them being able to operate a motor vehicle and get a license. Those people still have access to like road transportation without having to wait 45 minutes for a bus. And I don't know how the marketing department is going to handle that to say, yep, two people died. But we figured that if it helps, we have all this data that says that 98% of situations where human drivers in that position, the passengers would have died anyway. That's not going to be good enough, especially when it's a $4 trillion umbrella company is trying to assuage people that, yeah, this is still perfectly safe. I hope the good thing is that.

We're still in early days. Waymo is still, I think, in a position where they are, as far as I know, working with communities to make sure that we have permission to operate in your constituency and that we are obeying all local laws. And things are moving slowly enough that these communities have the ability to pass laws based on what they're seeing in the trials that are happening for Waymo inside their cities and in other cities. I still think I'm still hanging on to the idea that self-driving technology is important, particularly when it allows an expansion of public transportation in unexpected ways that would not be possible to complete by adding new bus lines and laying new train track. I still think it's a positive thing, but I don't want a situation where an Elon Musk gets to basically decide the minimum acceptable requirements for regulation and safety. I hope that Waymo does not lose.

I'm not sure what public perception is, but at least does not do anything to lose my faith that, OK, they're still feeling their way along this, but their heart is in the right place. This is not 10 years from now. I'm not going to feel like a stupid idiot, like a dupe and like a thoughtless person for thinking at this time that Waymo is probably an OK thing to add to the infrastructure of the city. Well, I was going to add a little bit to that, but I think I think it's time we wind it down. There's so much to say about Waymo, but like this thing is going to be continuing. It is it is a continually growing beast. And I'm I'm kind of hoping that whatever is slowing it down.

is good for it because I was starting to get really worried when they were talking about New York City already. I don't know why there's a difference for me between San Francisco and New York City, but there's just something about when Waymo gets to New York City and it's there, like that's it. I feel like that's there. I feel like that's their flex goal. That's what they're going for right now. Yeah. So we'll see. But again, hopefully like this pay package deal for Sundari is going to ruin things. You know what? If he's in a position where, damn it, you know what? I really, really, really wanted one of those big like inflatable like snow globe type Santas on my lawn for Christmas this year. But if I don't get that $200 million bonus, I don't know if I can afford it. I don't know if I can swing it. Let's cut corners to make sure that I get that bonus because the kids were so looking forward to the Christmas card photo in front of that big giant inflatable snow globe thing. I'm successful with a temptation like anybody else, okay? I'm the head of the most viable important companies in the entire world. But you know what? I'm just a man. I'm just a man.

Well, me and the man are going to log off now. We want to thank everybody for sticking with us this long. We love and appreciate that you are here every single week to listen to us. As always, you can help support our show and everything that we do here on the Relay Network by becoming a member. Head over to relay.fm slash material to sign up and also gain access to the special members only episode, which is coming up next. That's coming up next. So that's it for this week. Andy, is there anything you'd like to leave folks with before we sign off?

Gee, I wish I had something pithy to say right now. I've just been so freaking busy for the past week that I don't have time for contemplation. I will only say that tortillas, like flour tortillas, they last a surprisingly long time in the pantry. Oh, they do. I used to buy tortillas when I had a project, and I would try to use them up as if they were bread, because I know that, okay, well, bread, A, it'll start becoming nasty by X date, and then they will actually grow mold by Y date.

And like I used a tortilla, I used like my last two tortillas that were well by the best, the best by date. And I barely noticed any sort of a difference. And so now I've kind of added that to like my list of like staple items because there are, I will, I will not, I don't use tortillas as often as perhaps I would like, I would love to be making burritos twice a week. But the thing is a pack of burritos is going to last. certainly as long as it takes me to use all those tortillas. So I share this knowledge with you because it has improved my life in certain ways that I would like other people to experience. Yeah. And they stay great in the bread box too, by the way. Amazing. I won't continue. I did throw out one package that I had sort of misplaced inside the kitchen. And even then I was like, best by October, but they're still flexible and they don't have any mold on them. And then I had to basically advise myself, Andy, this is like a $3 or $4 pack of tortillas. Why don't we give ourselves permission to buy another pack of tortillas sometime this week? And throw this out because October was such a very long time ago, was it not?

Yeah, that's for darn sure. I might kind of have to fry them though to see if I can make like chips. Anyway, go ahead. Yeah, you should. You should. Very delicious. I love a homemade chip. Okay, well, that's it from us this week. Thank you so much for listening to us this time. We hope you will be with us again next week. As for me, I'm going to leave you by saying that Andy and I hope you have a happy, safe, and healthy seven days. See you guys next week. Bye. Bye-bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Material?

This episode is 1 hour and 7 minutes long.

When was this Material episode published?

This episode was published on March 12, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Material episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.