Welcome back to Missing. I am Tim here today with Lance. Lance, how are you today? I'm doing fantastic today. Thanks so much for asking. I hope all the listeners are doing fantastic as well. I hope people are going to be doing fantastic after hearing the story that we're going to present to them today. Our show is called Missing. We deal with missing persons all the time. This one is a really sad one, really mysterious, but also kind of infuriating too, and we'll get into it during the episode itself. But Tim, let's get into your mood. How are you? Doing good over here. Thanks a lot for asking. Yeah, today we're going to get into the mysterious disappearance of Teresa Lynn Butler from Risco, Missouri on January 25th, 2006.
And Teresa is 5'7", 110 pounds with black hair, brown eyes, and her right ear is pierced twice and her left ear three times. And she has a C-section scar on her abdomen and has noticeable dimples. And this episode was researched for us by Kathleen Studer. Big shout out to Kathleen. And right off the top, if anyone has information about her disappearance, you're instructed to contact the New Madrid County Sheriff's Department at 1-573-748-2516 or the Missouri State Highway Patrol Missing Persons Clearinghouse at 1-573-526-6178.
All right, Lance, and before we get into the story of Teresa's disappearance, we have a few announcements. One is that we are going to CrimeCon in September in Denver, Colorado, and we're doing a session with famed death investigator and distinguished silver fox, Joseph Scott Morgan. Wasn't expecting you to bring out the hard truth like that, but you did, so well done, yes. He is a silver fox, and he is great when he's analyzing any case that needs some... concrete answers, and we're going to be talking about this whole New England serial killer phenomenon that's happened over the course of the last few months here, and he's going to go through the bodies and the victims, and we'll talk about the manner of death, and we'll talk about whether they should be connected or not. We'll probably get into a little of the media coverage and how that's been responsible or irresponsible, but either way, I think it's going to be irresponsible for people to not get 10% off their standard badge by going to CrimeCon.com and using promo code CRALLSPACE. Alright, we'll see you there in Denver. It's going to be a fun session. Really interesting stuff. Okay, and Lance also wanted to let our listeners know, specifically our listeners on Apple, that we are a video show on Spotify, and you can...
Check us out right there. Watch us discuss these cases. We'll put pictures or any relevant video that is included. That's usually all there in the video element, so you can check us out on Spotify. And hey, whatever podcast app you're using to listen to us, make sure to give us a five-star review. Yeah. We'd really appreciate it. If they offer six stars, go ahead. Give us six stars as well. But also, Tim, let's talk about the triumphant return of the bonus show.
Yes. Yeah, we just recorded our first private bonus show that is for subscribers only. And yeah, it's going to be fun. We're going to do several of these. I know we kind of promised two a month. I feel like we're probably going to end up doing closer to three or four a month because it's just so fun to do. So check us out. It's $4.99 a month. You can subscribe on Apple Podcasts, on Patreon. You can become a member on YouTube. But really, just click through on whatever listening device you're using. Apple, you can just click through, or Spotify, just click through there and subscribe. You get ad-free episodes and our bonus show.
All right, so we're going to break real quick for commercial, and we will return with the story of Teresa Lynn Butler. On the morning of Wednesday, January 25th, 2006, Gary Dale Butler came home from his overnight shift at Maverick Tube, a steel mill in Blytheville, Arkansas, to his home about 60 miles away in Risco, Missouri. And he was a little late getting home as he had stopped to have breakfast with his mom on the way home. And here's where the story gets a little bit mysterious right from the jump. He arrives at his house. It's about 9.30 in the morning, and there is a puzzling situation. Teresa's Jeep, his wife Teresa, her Jeep was parked out front as it usually is. The doors were locked, and their two sons...
their ages were two and four, were not in their bedrooms. The porch light was unscrewed, so it wasn't working. But even more mysterious there is that it was unscrewed. Yeah, yeah. So was it like kind of jostled loose over the course of time, or did somebody just unscrew it enough so it wouldn't be able to turn on? Yeah, interesting. I mean...
Not many reasons why you'd want to do that with a light bulb. And keep in mind, like, he must have worked the overnight shift, right? He's coming back at 930 in the morning. So this is something to make sure that nothing's illuminated overnight. So unscrew the light bulb, you know, and you're not breaking it either. Right. So yeah, but he did locate the boys in the bedroom, his bedroom, him and Teresa's bedroom. The oldest was curled up in a blanket on the bed and the younger one was lying on a love seat at the end of the bed. Really sad, really sad scenario to picture. Yeah, and the younger son's diapers were soiled and he was sucking on an empty bottle and Teresa was nowhere to be found.
And Gary, who went by Dale, started calling around to friends and family to see if anyone had heard from or seen Teresa, because this was unusual. And when that turned up no further information, he called Risco's lone police officer. Risco's lone police officer, the single police officer in town. Risco, Missouri is a one-night town in Missouri's Boot Heel. This is an area defined by the St. Francis River to the west and the Mississippi River to the east. The river also defined the state lines between Arkansas, Missouri, and Tennessee.
And since it lies in the floodplain of the Mississippi, most of the land is taken up by agricultural fields with small towns here and there throughout. So don't you just picture that in your head as you're flying, ever flown over these areas? Sure. Yeah, this is like such an accurate depiction of that. The population of Risko had steadily declined from a height of 502 in 1960 to a low of 296 people in 2020.
Big thanks to Kathleen Studer for putting this research document together because it's those details that really add the texture to these stories. And that's why we love working with her. Absolutely. Yeah, we need to know a little bit about the area, of course, the terrain, how many people, all that is very relevant to the story of a disappearance. So big shout out to Kathleen. So Dale and Teresa lived just outside the city limits of Risco near the intersection of US Highway 62 and Farm Road 241. And they met while working together at a factory. And Dale had been previously married with one son from that relationship. And Teresa's parents live just up the road.
just about a mile or so away. And her brother and sister-in-law lived around the corner in the downtown area of Risko with a high school and ball field between their houses. So it sounds like they were all kind of closely connected there in a small town. Yeah. And Teresa had lived her entire life in this area and was one of five children that her parents, Donald and Linda Buchanan, raised in Risko.
And Teresa is described as a wonderful and reliable person devoted to her family who loved photography and attended church regularly at the Risko First Baptist Church. Really painting a good picture here of the community and of Teresa and sort of the routines that people go through in these small towns. You got the church, the regular attendance at church. And I don't think anyone's ever described me as being reliable. I don't think in my town, you know, like there's so much going on just in like a town that's slightly bigger where no one would look at.
me and be like, that's a reliable guy. So the fact that she stood out like that is pretty impressive to me. Yeah. And relevant to the story about how her two kids were left alone in the house. That is very uncharacteristic of Teresa. That is the opposite of reliable. Exactly. So the day before Teresa went missing, it seemed to go like an average weekday at the Butler house. And she went to work at her job at the photo department at the Walmart in Dexter, Missouri, which is a town about 36 miles away from Risco.
And she did arrive home in time to fix dinner for Dale before he left for his job at around 5 p.m. And after he left, she went over to spend some time with her sister-in-law, Sarah Buchanan, who then followed Teresa back to her house to use her scanner to copy some things for work. And Donald Buchanan, Teresa's brother, said Sarah was back home a little after 9 p.m. And Teresa told Sarah that after she left, she had planned to give the boys a bath and get them ready for bed. And notably, Sarah remembered that when she left, the porch light was on. Well, that's important because she would know if it's off, right? You're leaving in the dark, you'd be like, hey.
Your lights, you know, the porch light needs to be turned on. So very interesting. So that's a little after nine, like right around nine. Yeah, she she ride back home at 9pm. So this would probably be like 850 or so. Yep. And Dale was on break from his work at around 11 and called Teresa but got no answer.
So now a window of time is sort of developing here. But it was late enough, so he wasn't too concerned because he just figured that she was probably sleeping. And once police arrived on the 25th, they were given information about the previous day's timeline as they searched the house, and Dale checked if any items were missing and actually noticed that Teresa's purse and cell phone weren't there. Interesting. He did also report that a PlayStation and a GameCube were missing along with games, a Maglite flashlight, and the CD player in Teresa's Jeep was gone.
But there were no signs of a struggle. Right, so doesn't that strike you as somebody who comes in and kind of quietly robs a place and then on the way out takes the opportunity to take the stereo, the CD player, out of the Jeep? But the Jeep was locked, so they would have to break in or unlock it with keys and then shut the door and lock it again after they've taken the CD player out of it. Yeah, I mean, and why not just take the car? Too hot? You're not that type of thief? I guess, yeah.
So friends and family just couldn't believe that Teresa could walk away from her family like that. It's a pretty typical story that we hear. Yeah, such a strange and, again, uncharacteristic scene at the house, sort of, you know, when police were called, yeah. And police did find that a key had been broken off in one of the locks of the house, so they took the lock as evidence. Very weird. Yeah, I read that a couple of times when, you know, reviewing this and trying to figure out, like, is this an accident? Is there, like, maybe someone's moving around too fast and the key snaps off, or is this a way to make sure that the lock is never opened? I don't know, but apparently it was like...
You could still retrieve the key, which is good that the police did that. And strangely enough, Teresa's wedding rings were located under the couch in the living room. Very interesting part of this. Definitely have some opinions on this that I want to share after we go through the story on that detail. And Dale explained that Teresa would take her rings off at bedtime, but where they were found was not a normal place that she would set them. Because at first you think that this is like a struggle or something, or somebody is pulling the rings off because they're robbing her, and somehow they end up underneath the couch. But with Dale saying that she would take her rings off at bedtime, I was thinking maybe...
Maybe she set them on the table and they fell off. Anyway, yes, we will go over this. This is an interesting part. We will go over it later. Yeah. So speaking of Dale, at first, in most cases like this, Dale is obviously the primary suspect. Police did check into his work and confirmed he was there. So there's a check for him. And he also passed a polygraph. So he was at work. There's his alibi. He passes a polygraph and he's taken off of the suspect list. Good. And a search of the area started immediately as a team from local county and state law enforcement investigated the case. Searches were done on foot, by air and on horseback in a 10 mile radius from the house.
Horseback. I don't remember doing a missing person story and hearing horseback. Yeah, not many, that's for sure. And since the area is an agricultural floodplain, it has many canals, ditches, and levees to include a canal that is right across the street from Teresa's house. And Kathleen included a picture here of the canal. I don't know if this is at like a low water level season that this picture was taken, but it doesn't look like much more than a few inches of water there, maybe a couple, maybe a foot or so. Like you could definitely walk through this and not...
be anywhere like close maybe up to your ankles yeah that looks that looks accurate to me yeah it does look like a good rise i mean it comes right up to you can kind of see like where the water level is um comes right up to the to the flat roads there so yeah right right across the street from our house yeah and obviously it doesn't take a lot of water for someone to drown um if that's what we're talking about but you know in in a low amount of water you probably would have noticed so they contact a non-profit group called the outlaw riders search and rescue team to assist in the searching and This is a really cool rescue team. The team is made up of firefighters and EMTs in the area. So love the fact that they're called Outlaw Riders Search and Rescue Team. And they searched from February to May of 2006 using people on foot, the aforementioned horseback, ATVs. But just like with law enforcement, same results here. The searches didn't come up with any new clues about what happened to Teresa. So now we have law enforcement and a nonprofit independent search party pretty much doing the same thing, searching the same grounds and beyond. Right.
And investigators discovered that two phone calls were placed from Teresa's cell phone in the early morning hours of January 25th. So this would be just after she went missing. So one was at 316 AM to a number in Gideon, Missouri. And police contacted the owner of that number who stated he did not answer the phone and did not know anyone in the Butler family. And the second phone call was to elderly sisters in Clarkton, Missouri. And they stated that they received the call but heard nothing on the line. And they also did not know Teresa or anyone in her family.
Interesting. Yeah, really interesting. Yeah, and I looked up these towns, Gideon and Clepton, and they're all like the next town over from Risko. So they're like, you know, a series of like 10 miles or something like that. Interesting. Yeah, and they're all small towns as well. So very mysterious phone calls there being made from Teresa's cell phone, you know, a few hours after she went missing.
To seemingly like random numbers. Yeah. Yeah. Very confusing. Well, the local paper, the Daily American Republic, had numerous front page stories about Teresa's disappearance during the time. And in June of 2006, Risco's 100th anniversary was celebrated and the city was throwing itself a party. But much of the story covered talked about Teresa. Right. Interesting. This huge story in town was happening, but all anyone wanted to talk about and could talk about was Teresa's disappearance. Yeah.
And 60 Hope for Teresa Butler t-shirts had been sold to help fundraise for the outlaw riders, and they wore those shirts to the event. But small-town gossip was running wild, as it does in these cases, and law enforcement said that they were getting several tips every week that they were following up on, which is good. So this wasn't a cold case at this point. And we'll be right back after a quick word from our sponsors. Thanks to our sponsors, and now we're back to the program. I just want to revisit the size of the town. We're talking, like, around 400 at this time, right? Because it said it was steadily declining, and I think 2020 was under 300, so this is 2006. So it's somewhere between, like...
I don't know, 350 and 450 or something. So these leads, these tips have to be almost connected directly to people that everyone knows. I would imagine. Yeah, it's a very, very small town. Yeah, I would think most people know of each other in this area. Yeah, but months went on and the leads didn't go anywhere. There were no new leads. And on November 26, 50 of her friends and family held a vigil on what would have been Teresa's 36th birthday, releasing 36 pink balloons in her memory. So 50 of her friends. And if the town is like 450, I mean, that's a big chunk of the town. True, true. Yeah. And it's noted here that pink was one of Teresa's favorite colors. That's why the balloons were pink.
And life was really hard for Dale trying to raise his two sons on his own. He had friends come stay with him for a little while, which the rural gossip turned into him having a girlfriend so soon after Teresa went missing. And I'm sure there was talk of suspicion and things like that. But this was not true. And this part just kills me. He's in a horrible car accident and he finds himself on disability. So he's immobile for the most part. He's not able to fix things up around the house. This water leak happens in the house and mold starts to build up. So he's got a mold issue. And so Dale.
covers the boys' beds to try to keep them as dry as possible because no one wanted to leave the house in case their mom came home. So they're staying there despite the mold. Dale can barely move. He covers the bed so that they can stay dry because they want to still be there if Teresa comes home. So tragic and sad. But the community stepped up and they raised money.
for Dale and his boys. So that's nice. Life a little bit easier for them. Yeah. And finally, in March of 2007, a tip came in and a woman was interviewed about the night of January 25th, 2006, when she says a local man stopped by her and her husband's house. And this man claimed that he had robbed a guy up north of Risco and beat him up because of a drug debt. This kind of takes an interesting turn here.
really had to go through and process this because we have Teresa who's a mom of two, Dale in the accident. We're setting up a story to go in a certain direction and now we have this come in. So March of 2007, there's a woman interviewed claiming a local man stops by her house, her husband's house, and claims that he robbed a guy up north and beat him up because of a drug debt. He had a camera and a camcorder that he traded her husband for a gram of meth. So this guy comes to, am I reading this right or am I interpreting this right? He comes to the house, says that he beat up a guy in Risco because of a drug debt.
Now he wants to barter with this technology, a camcorder and a camera for a gram of meth from this woman's husband. Yeah, so this is about 14 months after Teresa went missing. This woman comes forward, and obviously you can probably see why she didn't come forward right away, because maybe her husband could potentially be implicated as a drug dealer in town, which it seems like he was. So this mysterious man had a camera and a camcorder that he bartered and ended up trading. with her husband for this gram of meth. And the wife, though, right away, she wondered if this had something to do with Teresa's disappearance. So she actually looked at the camera and video's contents and saw a woman and two boys in the video that she believed to be Teresa and her kids. So her husband does the super responsible thing and tells her to throw the camcorder and camera in a ditch while he burns the videotape that was in it that apparently has this footage. He burns that in a barrel. Yeah. And the husband apparently confronted the random man who bought drugs, but that man denied any involvement in Teresa's disappearance.
Yeah, just not sure why you'd be burning that. That seems like that would be good evidence. And police searched the ditch where the woman said she disposed of the camcorder, and they were able to locate it. And it was the same brand and style as the one that was missing from the butler house. But since there was no video inside, nor was there a serial number known, police said that they could not for sure connect it as evidence in Teresa's case, even though it sure seems like it was. Yeah, shady, shady stuff. The husband is like, no, it's better for you to burn that evidence. And I'll just independently tackle the investigation with this with this man who showed up at the house. I'll go I'll go get the info from him. Let's not send it anonymously to the police and try to help the investigation. You burn it and I'll just go, you know, roughhouse him until he gives me the truth. Yeah, super, super suspect. Yeah.
Even kind of more sus here is in 2008, police again interviewed the woman. And at that time, she divulged that they still also had the Nintendo GameCube as well as the games that were also apparently, you know, they were stolen from Teresa's house and then traded to this woman and her drug dealing husband. So those items were taken into evidence, but it's unknown if anything was done as far as contacting the person that brought those items to be traded for meth. Investigators also followed up on leads from some of the rumors, digging in some areas where Teresa was rumored to be buried, but could not find her. So apparently in the meantime, they were fielding tips that her body was buried in various places. But to no avail, I just want to back up a little bit.
You think that they're, are they playing these games? Are they, is the Nintendo and GameCube like set up and they're playing them? Oh yeah, probably. I would think. Yeah. So twisted to me. That's probably why they didn't say that earlier. Like they didn't want to lose the game system. Jesus. But at least they did come forward. Yeah. So we can, we can appreciate them for that. But on the 12th anniversary of the day Teresa went missing, Dale died at home at the age of 43. So young. I know. So young. And now their boys were without their mother and father. Very tragic. Well, I hope they're doing well now. Yeah, seriously.
There's a picture here of the boys with their grandparents, with Teresa's parents, and hopefully that relationship has maintained some stability for them. Let's talk about Melvin Ray Hufford Jr. This guy's got the three names plus a junior tacked on the end, so that obviously immediately raises a red flag for when we're talking about suspects and things like this. It wasn't until April 8th of 2019, when a detective was again interviewing career criminal Melvin Ray Hufford Jr., he decided to confess to what had happened to Teresa Butler. Investigators now say that he had been a suspect from early on in the investigation, but it's not known why it took him so long to confess. Very interesting. Yeah, that's 13 years. So that's wild. And Hufford's story was that on the night of January 24th, 2006, he and another person were over at Teresa's house getting high on meth. Not only getting high on it, injecting it intravenously. Yeah.
And Melvin claims he himself then injected Teresa with it. So where in the story did you expect Teresa was so addicted to meth that she would be injecting it or letting someone inject it into her veins? I don't think that is true. I don't think that's true either. No, she didn't have him over to do meth and to inject meth in front of her sons and then do it herself. I just cannot believe that that's what happened here. No. So Melvin's story is that Teresa, after having been injected with meth, which, you know, by the way, I did have to look this up, but...
Getting an injection from meth is supposed to hit you harder than smoking it. Harder and faster as far as the effects of the drug. So I guess that's why people inject rather than smoke it. Yeah. So apparently after this guy injected Teresa with meth, she was complaining that her chest was hurting. And Melvin went into the kitchen to fix himself a drink. And he came back and he says that Teresa was passed out. We got a picture here of Melvin Ray Hufford Jr. And we also have pictures of Teresa. And if I were to guess the meth addict, it would be Melvin Ray Hufford. I don't want to generalize, but when I look at this man and you were to tell me.
This guy is addicted to meth and injects it. I believe you. I wouldn't say the same thing about pictures that we've seen of Teresa. So they find her passed out and Melvin Ray Hufford and the person that he's with, they check her for a pulse and they couldn't find one and they both start freaking out. Yeah, we talk about stories like this, how this, you know, because in a lot of missing persons cases, this ends up being the local rumor that, you know, there was an accidental drug overdose and then everyone freaks out and decides to dispose of the body or something like that. But I think what we've found in our 10 years of doing the show, Lance, is that this thing is not as common as the local rumors in towns of missing people would have you believe. Yeah. Also, I always fall back on these are people who.
are often described as being irresponsible and addicted to drugs. They don't hold down jobs. I'm not, again, I'm not trying to, you know, cast a blanket over these people, but the fact that people who are known to inject themselves with meth and are in the presence of somebody who accidentally overdoses, suddenly they become so good at hiding bodies. They're never found again. Yeah. That's a part of it. That's weird to me too, because at that point they're suddenly very competent in getting rid of evidence and things like that. Yeah. So that, yeah, a lot of times I don't believe it. They suddenly found their calling. Right. Yeah. And we'll be right back after a quick word from our sponsors.
Thanks to our sponsors, and now we're back to the program. So apparently they wrapped Teresa in a tarp and took some items from the house to make it look like it was a burglary. Okay. And they eventually took Teresa's body to Melvin's dad's abandoned house and put her underneath the kitchen sink cabinet. I mean, that sounds like what...
someone like him would do, but where is she? Well, Melvin ended up going to prison again for a few years after that. And it was for a different crime, probably a drug-related or a theft crime, I'm guessing. And when he got out, he claims he retrieved Teresa's body from this abandoned house, and specifically underneath the kitchen sink cabinet. He says that he retrieved her body and burnt it, and then crushed all of her bones. That was such garbage. And he says he put those remains in a bucket and then dumped them in a ditch south of his house in Tallapoosa.
That is such a garbage. Like, even if she's in there and she's decomposed after a few years, I'm sure some animals might have gotten in there. All he has to do is take the body and just bring her out to a desolate part of the wilderness. He doesn't have to go through the process of crushing bones, burning, and then dumping them in a ditch that apparently is, like, close to his house. It's south of his house in Telapusa. But, I mean, you don't even have to move the body if it's been there for so long. Yeah, it seems like this house had been abandoned for years because he goes to prison after he puts her there. And then...
I'm guessing once he got out, he realized, oh, I got to get rid of her body because that's evidence that could put me back in the place that I don't want to be in. So maybe that was his motivation for, I guess, destroying the evidence that is her body. But in November of 2019, Melvin was charged with first degree involuntary manslaughter and evidence tampering related to the death of Teresa Butler. Jeez. And he was sentenced to a total of 10 years for those charges. That's it. And still no physical part of Teresa has ever been found. Right.
I can kind of believe that part of his story, to be honest. I definitely don't believe the part of how Teresa went missing. But I can believe the part where he claims to have disposed of her body. Yeah, I can believe that. I can see that. Because that is a direct connection to him. He's probably been thinking about it for the years that he was in prison. Right. But definitely he's not shooting up meth with her. No, not with her. Absolutely not. And my take on her wedding rings being found underneath the couch is perhaps when this guy apparently showed himself at the...
the butler residence that she figured he was there to steal some stuff and she hid them. Yeah, exactly. Either that, or she had been hit or something and was on the ground and then put them under the couch. But I'm kind of thinking that it happened pretty soon after he made himself known to her and she slipped it off and stuck it under where she was sitting, you know, so they didn't get stolen as well. Yep. Or, or maybe just so it would be like.
a calling card from her a message to her husband investigators exactly yeah i mean probably she probably didn't think she was about to go missing at that point but you know who knows i don't know if she knew this guy uh she's probably trying to protect her kids too yeah absolutely and i definitely don't believe melvin that he was with someone else there seemed like he went there to rob the place for uh drugs essentially to barter for meth and ended up taking her too i'm not quite sure why um but that was his story and apparently confirmed by a in a court of law yeah Yeah. And this whole like other person, this other person I'm pretty sure doesn't exist or else he would have thrown that other person under the bus pretty quick. Yeah.
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, there's no way that there was another person there. I don't know why he he, you know, mixes what seems to be truth with likely fiction, in my opinion. But I think that's just kind of how how these people are, you know? Yeah. But there's a big problem speaking of meth and how these people are big problem. Meth in Missouri in the mid 2000s. There were a lot of meth labs that were prevalent in Missouri, so much so that it was called the meth capital of America because it was number one in the nation for meth lab seizures. Melvin Hufford had a long criminal history that included drug charges as well.
And in all of the accounts found for this story, there was no mention of Teresa using meth other than Melvin's account. So, you know, our instincts, I think, about his story were right in that scenario. Could you imagine? They found no paraphernalia at the house. There's no mention of that. There's no mention of anyone else, including her sister-in-law, saying that she was with her that night. I mean, you would know someone who's like experimenting with meth. That would be part of your account. I think so. Yeah. So it is not known for sure if the second man at the butler house was ever charged in this case, nor do we know his account or if there really was a man.
I'm inclined to believe there wasn't, but I don't know. It's possible, I guess. Headline stories in the Daily American Republic were only of her disappearance. Once Melvin's story that included meth came out, it was only reported on local TV news stations, which is responsible. Is that good? I think the point of this is that meth gets dirty and people don't want to hear about this. And the story of a mysterious disappearance is something that people want to hear about. But then once something as dirty as a drug like meth is introduced, people tend to look away. And, you know, we've definitely experienced that with some of the cases we cover. I would say notably the just in comparing.
Maura Murray's disappearance to Brianna Maitland's disappearance, Brianna's friends and family will say that mentioning that drugs might have been involved in her disappearance. And by the way, there's no evidence that there was, in fact, likely was not. But the fact that that will come up in some of the local rumors and things like that make Brianna's case inherently less more searchable than Maura Murray's case, which does not have any element of that, even when it's forced. Yeah, good point. So shout out to the Daily American Republic for not falling down that rabbit hole by including all this meth talk. Right. And to further drive that point home, Kathleen here notes that if you search the name Teresa Butler in 2019 through 2025 in Missouri on newspapers.com, not a single story comes up. Yikes. Yeah. And that is the time period that Melvin confessed and was sentenced for causing her death and hiding her body. That's interesting. Yeah. So it's just a point about the media, really. And how, you know, I mean, they don't want to cover stories like that. Wow.
Well, there was a prosecutor on the case who said, quote, although I do not believe that Teresa Butler died as a result of a drug overdose, we have no physical evidence to prove or disprove the defendant's version of what happened, end quote. That chuckle there was my sarcastic chuckle. That wasn't a quoted chuckle from the prosecutor. But just so, so frustrating. There's not a shred of evidence that she was doing meth. Right. No, she wasn't. I mean, I feel pretty confident saying that.
Yeah, she had two young sons around. I mean, I know people are addicts, and certainly some children in some situations are introduced to that, and that's very sad, but that does not seem like the situation here. Both Teresa and Dale had full-time jobs that they seemed to have kind of bent over backwards to go to, seeing that both of them were many dozens of miles away. Yeah, and Dale's was overnight. Right. So I don't think a family like that who's working so hard to raise their sons and to put food on the table would also be spending money on meth and doing it right in front of them. Yeah, inviting friends over like Melvin. Right.
What we do know, though, is that Teresa was a wife, a daughter, a sister, and a mom. She is still missing, and her family is still missing her. And regardless of what actually happened that night, she and her family deserved better than this. Definitely. And it does make me sad to think about those boys. I really do hope they have gotten themselves into a good place. But man, that's so tough after losing both your parents at such a young age.
Yeah. And I'm sure their grandparents, you know, may not have survived too much longer either because even in the picture shared, you know, they're certainly not like super young. Yeah. So that is it. That is the story of Teresa Lynn Butler, Lance, a mysterious and tragic one. No doubt about it. Like pretty much every case we speak about here.
So we're going to wrap it up by saying again, if you have information on the disappearance of Teresa Butler, you are instructed to call the new Madrid County Sheriff's Department. That's at 1-573-748-2516. You can also contact the Missouri State Highway Patrol Missing Persons Clearinghouse, 1-573-526-6178. Thanks a lot for listening. Don't forget to like and subscribe. And please follow us on social media at MissingCSM. We'll be back next week with another new episode.