Skip to content
561 // Holly Piirainen episode artwork

Aug 7, 2025 38 min

561 // Holly Piirainen

from Missing Hosted by Crawlspace Media

In this new episode, Crawlspace Media's Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna discuss the mysterious disappearance and tragic murder of Holly Piirainen from Sturbridge, Massachusetts on August 5th, 1993. Holly went missing while visiting a group of puppies at a nearby residence. Her sneaker was found on a road and the search for 10 year old Holly was on. But in October of 1993, Holly's remains were found in Brimfield and the case has been unsolved ever since. If you have any information in the abduction and murder of Holly Piirainen, you can submit a tip anonymously at 413-426-3507. This episode was researched by Bill Huffman. Sources: https://www.ibtimes.com/holly-piirainen-case-david-pouliot-linked-death-missing-girl-1993-390282. https://youtu.be/67wf8hvLPyw?si=UMqZFNHZ285hKICO. https://youtu.be/RU3S0coGffc?si=j7xpajn2HQq9acdc. https://youtu.be/UvSc1HMGd38?si=-jaWRGdO4ogN5tVt. https://youtu.be/kZfmw0a9_yU?si=3ydh9U9O9wkg6E2J. https://youtu.be/RJlkuouLLrY?si=DXUulL7RB3YZZGwT. https://thisweekinworcester.com/holly-piiaranens-family-still-looks-for-clues-26-years-after-her-disappearance-death/. https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2018/10/21/family-holly-piirainen-hosts-tip-campaign-anniversary-her-disappearance/DnhH2V8bunjWOd9basLxlI/story.html. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-republican-more-sex-offenders/177432284/ https://www.sturbridge.gov/about. https://www.westernmassnews.com/2024/10/23/31-years-since-discovery-10-year-old-holly-piirainens-body/. https://hampdenda.com/hampden-district-attorney-releases-evidence-in-holly-piirainen-homicide-investigation-calls-on-the-public-for-help/. https://www.newspapers.com/article/hartford-courant/ 177433323/. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-republican/177436128/. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-republican/177436412/. Main podcast theme by Kevin Macleod. Check out his work at ⁠⁠https://incompetech.com/⁠⁠. Additional music by David Williams. See his work at ⁠⁠http://williamsflutes.com⁠⁠. Follow Missing: IG: https://www.instagram.com/MissingCSM/. TT: https://www.tiktok.com/@missingcsm. FB: https://www.facebook.com/MissingCSM. X: https://twitter.com/MissingCSM. Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0yRXkJrZC85otfT7oXMcri. Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/missingcsm. Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/missing/id1006974447. Follow Crawlspace: IG: https://www.instagram.com/Crawlspacepodcast. TT: https://www.tiktok.com/@crawlspacepodcast. FB: https://www.facebook.com/Crawlspacepodcast. X: https://twitter.com/crawlspacepod. Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7iSnqnCf27NODdz0pJ1GvJ. Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/crawlspace. Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/crawlspace-true-crime-mysteries/id1187326340. Check out our entire network at http://crawlspace-media.com/.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

561 // Holly Piirainen

0:00 38:01
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

She was last seen by her father heading toward a residence around Allen and South Shore roads in Sturbridge to play with puppies. She knew her at a home. About one hour later, Holly was reported missing by her father after she did not return. Welcome back to Missing. I am Tim here today with Lance. Lance, how's it going today?

It's going fantastic today. Thanks so much for asking. I do hope that everybody who's listening, I hope they're doing fantastic as well. This is one of the stories that has been around, unfortunately, for decades, and we're covering it today. It's a tragic story, but it's very important, and we really wouldn't be doing our jobs if we continue to not cover this story. So let's bring this one back into the public conversation. It definitely needs to be talked about as much as possible. But Tim, before we get to that, how are you? Doing great over here. Thanks a lot. Yeah, today we are speaking about the disappearance of Holly Perinan, and she was 10 years old, and she went missing on August 5th, 1993.

from Sturbridge, Massachusetts. And Lance, many of our listeners may know we're both recording this from Massachusetts. I'm actually pretty close to Sturbridge now. And Holly's disappearance definitely still has vibrations in this area. That's true. How often do you hear about...

Holly's story in that area. Well, stories about her disappearance, and we'll get into it, but her murder, do come up on local news occasionally. And Holly Perinian's story is sort of forever tied to Molly Bishes. And she went missing from Warren, Massachusetts, which is basically the next town over from Sturbridge around the same time period. So these cases were connected. A lot of people thought they were connected as far as who abducted these young girls. But as we'll get into, that may not be the case. And big thanks to Bill Huffman for the research for this episode.

And we might see Bill Huffman in person at CrimeCon, Tim, because you and I are going, and we're pretty sure Bill Huffman's going as well. But listeners, you can go too, and you can save yourself some cash. You can get 10% off your standard badge by going to CrimeCon.com and putting in the code word... What's the code word, Tim? Crawlspace. Promo code Crawlspace. All one word for 10% off your standard badge. And we're not going to be alone. We're going to have a session with a very distinguished individual. Yeah, that's going to be a lot of fun. We're going to speak with Joseph Scott Morgan, who is a death investigator. And we're going to be speaking about the New England serial killer story that has really gripped social media in 2025. And we will dissect everything that's been going on with that story. Very good. So you can see all three of us there in person.

CrimeCon.com, 10% off your standard badge by using promo code Crawl Space. All right, we will see you there. And folks, you can see us on Spotify because we are a video show on Spotify. If you're listening on Apple, you can switch right over and watch this podcast as well as listen to it. We are also on YouTube with that same video element, so you can check us out there. All right, everyone, we're going to take a quick break for commercial and we'll be right back to speak about the disappearance of Holly Barine.

All right, Lance, Holly Paranin was 10 years old, and she was born and raised in Grafton, Massachusetts, which is another small town in central Massachusetts, pretty close to Sturbridge, actually, about 25 miles or so. So this was a family vacation that Holly was on, but it was not a very far destination to travel to. And Holly was in the fifth grade at the time. She was a student at the Grafton Elementary School in Grafton, Massachusetts. This was in 1993. Her teachers and her classmates described her as a typical 10-year-old. She was sweet, friendly, well-liked.

Apparently, she loved animals, she enjoyed school, and she was a lover of the water as well. She wanted to be a marine biologist. So the Pranans were on vacation in Sturbridge, Massachusetts, and Sturbridge is located sort of at the crossroads of New England land, some people would call it, because the Mass Pike, which is a Highway 90, Interstate 90, and Interstate 84, they basically cross right there at Sturbridge. Also, Route 20 goes right through Sturbridge, Massachusetts, and that's actually the longest road in all of America, going from Boston all the way to Oregon. So there's some truth to Sturbridge being a bit of a crossroads.

Certainly a lot of travelers will come there, a lot of sort of motor lodges, partially, I think, because of the highways, but also because of Sturbridge Village, which is there, which is a little bit of a tourist attraction. Kids in this area will go on field trips to Sturbridge Village, which gives you a peek into what life was like back in the 17 and 1800s. And Sturbridge had a population of 9,867 at the 2020 census. So for this sort of bustling travel area, not a ton of people actually live there. Right. And Grafton, where Holly was born, has a population of 19,664. That's also according to the 2020 census. So much bigger. Grafton, much bigger than Sturbridge. Yeah. Population-wise. And Holly was born in Grafton on January 19th, 1983. And that is where Holly lived with her parents and siblings before the Paranians' vacation to Sturbridge. So we'll take you to August 5th, 1993. This is the day that Holly disappeared. At 11.45 a.m., Holly went for a walk, and she went for a walk with her five-year-old brother. And they were going to visit...

some neighbor's puppies at her grandmother's summer cottage on South Pond in Sturbridge. However, her brother returned home alone. So when he comes back and he doesn't have Holly with him, their father instructs another brother to accompany the younger boy back to the neighbor's house to get Holly. Okay, so I guess they just figured she was sticking around with the puppies. And when the boys went to her grandmother's house, they could not find her. So it does seem like the grandmother is among the first people to understand that there's something wrong here. The boys didn't find Holly. They did, however, find one of her sneakers.

on the side of the road. Of course, Holly's father, he goes out and he's searching for her. But again, they only find this one sneaker. And so Holly was reported missing at about 1250 p.m. And about 40 to 50 people searched through the night for Holly. So a search crew organized very quickly and searched the area. It sounds like pretty thoroughly, even though it was at night for a good portion of that. So according to the Hartford Courant, police had a hard time searching. There's thick woods there.

Lots of swamplands. There was hundreds of volunteers over the course of the next few days who were searching. And police chief Kevin Fitzgibbons is quoted as saying, obviously, we're concerned as the hours dragged by. Goes on to say, but we haven't ruled out any possibility. And dozens of police and firefighters on the second day, they joined the search as well.

and officials said that they were unsure if Holly might be injured, abducted, or lost. And Connecticut State Police sent two canine teams to Sturbridge to help with the search, a bloodhound and a German shepherd who helped. And the dog teams tried to pick up Holly's scent, and divers probed the waters of South Pond, and helicopters circled over a 3-5 mile area of Sturbridge. But the search was concentrated in the wooded area where the sneaker was found, and apparently it did not extend into Connecticut. And also, according to The Republican, after hundreds of volunteers searched the woods in the rural area where Holly disappeared, police announced that they believed the child was the victim of foul play. And while the volunteer search had been called off, police continued their search using horses and motorcycles. And authorities admitted they were interviewing known sex offenders for clues about what could have happened to her. And Holly's father, Rick Paranin, said that ordeal has left him kind of numb.

And quote here, I've experienced the panic, the crying, and the helplessness, and I'm not sure what to do next. We're following every lead we can find, even if it's just a feeling, end quote. And he's also quoted as saying, I fear it's abduction. That's what I thought from the beginning, end quote. Which is interesting that he was leaning towards abduction right in the beginning, especially when you just find one shoe on the side of the road. I mean, that's...

no other place that your mind can go. Absolutely, yeah. And police questioned a middle-aged man from Sturbridge and searched his brown pickup truck, but they stated he was not a suspect in Holly's disappearance. And the police also interviewed an individual who had some pertinent information on the case. So during the investigation, law enforcement combed through a long list of individuals. They apparently interviewed a man who drove a brown pickup truck and they searched the vehicle. They said he was not considered a suspect. They also interviewed someone with information.

And protective parents may be alarmed by the list of suspects in the case. And apparently there were about 168 individuals identified in the investigation, and about 50 of those suspects were from Sturbridge and the surrounding communities. So they're casting a very wide net. They definitely are. And there were many people on the list that were there for simple reasons, for benign reasons. And a quick example of this is one woman who was interviewed simply because an informant had claimed that she had children over her home. So you can see where this is turning into, like you said, casting a wide net. Somebody informs law enforcement that this woman, I guess, has children over from time to time or had children over her home around that time. So she's questioned in Holly's disappearance. But a lot of these were for these sort of simple reasons. And I guess kind of weeding out the people who are not involved.

And the list also included a guy named Richard Therrien, who was a former inmate of the Treatment Center for the Sexually Dangerous. And he has family ties to Sturbridge. And in 1975, he raped a woman near Worcester, Massachusetts, while on furlough from prison. And Worcester, pretty close to Sturbridge. He wasn't the only questionable person that was involved in the investigation. There were also people like former auxiliary police officers, a condominium superintendent from Sturbridge, a businessman from Wales. And in 1993, a bus driver, Daniel G. Burnett, was convicted of raping and molesting four boys.

highlighting the potential danger in the region. So yeah, with that wide net, Lance, they were definitely looking at all kinds of crimes against children. And there's a town called Florida, Massachusetts, that's out in the western part of the state. And Florida police actually arrested Randall Reese and Virginia Goddard for child rape and child sexual abuse material as well. pretty wild. But it's just it's hard to say if these people could be connected to Holly's case. I mean, in this scenario, Florida, Massachusetts is like literally over 100 miles from Sturbridge. So I doubt that they're on the radar in any real way. Yeah. And there were plenty of names that were on the list that were crossed off because they were likely clean or, you know, they didn't have any criminal record. But it does make you wonder.

what type of concentration of sex offenders exist in that area? Do they have a higher rate of sex offenses in that area that have gone undocumented or have been documented? So like you said, this is a net that they're casting and they're bringing in everybody who might have some sort of background that could be relatable to Holly's disappearance. Yeah, I don't think this is an area that has additional sex offenders more than any other area. I just think they're digging into it. I think if you dig into this kind of thing in any area, you're going to find people who have these charges and offenses. There's no question about it. And one story that...

kind of overlaps here a little bit with Holly's disappearance is serial killer Louis Lent. So Louis Lent is currently in prison, and he was convicted for Jimmy Bernardo's murder. And Jimmy Bernardo went missing on October 22nd, 1990, and his body was discovered about a month later. And that was in New York, though. And again, this is like still over about 100 miles from Sturbridge. But Louis Lent did not stop at Jimmy Bernardo. He also abducted Sarah Ann Wood in August of 1993, August 18th. So that is literally like two weeks or something right after Holly went missing.

Yeah, and Sarah went missing from New York as well, but again, right on that Massachusetts line. And eventually it was discovered that Louis Lent was behind these abductions and murders, and so naturally he kind of came up again in the disappearance of Holly, and could he have been a suspect in her case as well? Has he ever publicly said anything about Holly's abduction and murder? Not that I know of. Yeah, I don't believe so. You'd think that somebody like him would indicate something in order to maybe get some time taken off or some sort of arrangement or something like that, or maybe he's just so far gone in prison that it doesn't matter.

you know, if he gives up information about Holly, if he had anything to do with it. Yeah, I mean, I think his hunting area was not where Holly went missing, you know? So, and I know that's kind of disturbing to think about that, you know, there's this guy, this child killer, abductor, serial killer in the western part of the state. And then there's, you know, Holly who goes missing from like the middle part of the state and really probably not a victim of Louis Lent. Again, he seemed like he had a very close circle as far as his hunting ground went. This would be an outlier for him to have gone all the way to Sturbridge. Yeah, and really opportunistic.

He's not stalking Holly and waiting for her to go check out some puppies at a neighbor's place. And we'll be right back after a quick word from our sponsors. Thanks to our sponsors. And now we're back to the program. But the investigation continued. There were a list of over 100 suspects. Most of those were past sex offenders living within, I believe, a 50 mile radius of the crime scene. But apparently after about a month, nearly all of the individuals who were on this list were actually cleared. So they cleared them through a process of elimination. And during the time that Lent confessed to those two murders, Sarah Ann Wood and Jimmy Bernardo, there were still only a handful of remaining potential suspects in Holly's case. And at times the investigation into Holly's disappearance centered around individuals with no...

criminal background at all. And one notable example is Robert Armies, who was a former resident of Brookfield, which is another town very close to Sturbridge. And he garnered attention due to his enthusiastic desire to help Holly's family. And this actually led investigators to question him multiple times. Interesting. Yeah, yeah. So his enthusiastic desire to help them put him on the radar. I wonder what type of personality he had outside of that. I wonder if he was, you know, an extremely helpful person just in general. That's interesting.

Yeah, you got to kind of wonder about how enthusiastic he was about, you know, offering help or something. Whatever it was, something in there, you know, because there were several people. There was 50 to 100 people who helped search. But I guess this guy, Armies, was kind of looking to get involved a little deeper. Or perhaps the investigators thought he was trying to learn what they knew or something like that, you know? How many times did they see him around the site where the shoe was found or something like that? Is he actually visiting the police station? Is he visiting the family? But yeah, you're right. Something he did put his name on their radar.

And there's also the late Richard Allen, who was included in the investigation because of allegations that he had committed several child rapes, including one actually on August 1st, 1993, which was just four days before Holly's abduction. I did say the late Richard Allen. Allen took his own life at his home in Holland in December, and that was before authorities could do anything to further an investigation into him. And authorities did state that Allen was actually posthumously absolved of any connection in Holly's disappearance. So, not him. Not him, okay. And it's, I guess, respectful enough to have a posthumous absolution.

I guess that's responsible on the part of the authorities. And then on October 25th, 1993, some hunters in the area of Brimfield, Massachusetts, found Holly's remains. And unfortunately, due to the advanced state of decomposition, the cause of death and whether Holly was sexually assaulted or not could not be determined. And items that were discovered at or near the location of Holly's remains were documented, seized, and have been maintained by the Massachusetts State Police since that time. So they still have all of these pieces of evidence that were located around the area of her remains. And Lance, interesting to note that...

where Holly's body was found off Five Bridge Road in Brimfield, Massachusetts. It's about 10 miles, as the crow flies, from South Pond in Sturbridge to this area in Brimfield, which is southwest of the pond. So they were hunters that discovered the body. Three hunters, they had dogs with them. They were pheasant hunters. And they discovered the body at approximately 8.45 in the morning on Saturday. And they said that they found a skull and sneakers or a sneaker. They were pretty rattled.

And so the sneaker did actually match the other sneaker that was found where Holly went missing. So that was one way they were able to help identify these remains as Holly's. And her pants and shirt were also located in that area where the shoe was found. And this area that we're speaking about where the body was found is probably not where she was killed. And this is, according to a lot of experts who are part of the investigation, you did mention that her body was badly decomposed. And just a terrible moment for the father, for Richard. He visited the scene shortly after the hunters discovered the remains, and he had very little hope that...

the remains would not be identified as his daughter. And he was quoted as saying, they found items belonging to Holly at the site, end quote. And he gives a quote about the shoe being the matching shoe. And her pants and her shirt were also there. So that's coming from her father. And just again, another really heart-wrenching moment where the father is coming to terms, coming to grips with the fact that his daughter's 10-year-old daughter is likely the victim of a murder. And Lance, on November 13th of 1993, they held a funeral for Holly Preenin at St. Philip's Church. And there were more than 500 grieving friends and family.

Who attended. And thousands of people all over the country paid their respects to Holly and to the family as well. And Holly's family hired a private lab to do final testing on the skeletal remains. And Holly's dad, Richard, said we had a DNA test done. The state felt there was no need. He says, as far as I know, the cause of death has been left blank. Yeah, that is interesting because, you know, they were looking for Holly as an abduction victim. Yeah.

And then when they found her remains, that seems likely that she was abducted. But yet they can't tell for sure what the cause of death is. So I wonder if that kind of stalled the investigation at all, or if just common sense kind of, you know, carried everyone forth. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's a good point. There's also Trooper John Murphy, who's assigned to the Crime Prevention and Control Unit of the Hampton County District Attorney's Office. And he stated days after the body was found that there were no new developments in the case.

following weeks of examinations by the state forensic experts. So that's interesting as well, that the state forensic experts did not discover anything that would be considered a new development over the course of the following weeks. And so there is a bit of a connection in this area to the disappearance of Molly Bish, who was 16 years old, and she was a lifeguard at Commons Pond in nearby Warren, Massachusetts. And she went missing in 2000, and her remains were found years later in a wooded area in Palmer, Massachusetts. So again, just southwest of where she went missing.

And although there are similarities here, there have been no concrete links that have ever been found, no connection between the two. They are young girls. They were in rural areas, wooded recovery sites. But we are talking about 1993 and seven years later, the year 2000. This is an area that is not immune to crime. So while it does seem like these two could be connected, I'd be very surprised if they are connected. Yeah, there is a really weird coincidence here. Molly Bish actually wrote a sympathetic letter to Holly's family after Holly went missing.

She wrote, Interesting. Yeah. So Molly Bish writes a letter to Holly's family. Right. But when we're speaking about Molly Bish's case, Lance, actually in 2021, the Worcester County DA's office identified Francis P. Sumner Sr. as a person of interest in Molly Bish's murder. And that's pretty much where the case stands today. I don't think it's been confirmed or denied, I suppose, about this Sumner guy. But he did pass away in 2016. He's also a convicted rapist and looks a lot like the composite sketches of the man who very likely abducted Molly Bish as given by Molly's mom.

based on her description of the person who she believed abducted Molly. So yeah, it's kind of a dead ringer. Unclear about Sumner's possible connection to Holly's disappearance and murder though. And we'll be right back after a quick word from our sponsors. Thanks to our sponsors, and now we're back to the program.

stopped by police later on that day. He was released and has never been charged for anything. So not sure where that conversation went, but he was released. And again, he has never been charged. And that brings us to January of 2012, when police revealed a new suspect in Holly's disappearance and murder. A Springfield man, David Pouliot, who is deceased, was named a person of interest in the case after investigators linked his DNA to evidence discovered near where Holly was found. And they claim that a forensic link emerged connecting a Vietnam veteran named David Pouliot to evidence found near Holly's remains.

And he worked at a juvenile detention center, and he apparently frequented Brimfield, the same area where Holly's body was found, and he apparently went hunting and fishing in that area. And Holly's grandmother told the Worcester Telegram and Gazette that the family never knew him, never knew Pouliot, and had never heard of him until prosecutors brought his name to them before they brought his name forward. And she's quoted as saying the family is cautiously optimistic in this development. And David Pouliot died in 2003 at the age of 49. He was at his mother's home in Springfield.

You mentioned that he was a Vietnam War veteran. He was also a member of the Coast Guard, worked for the Massachusetts Department of Youth Services, like you said, in Westfield. And he does have a criminal record, but no indications that he would be capable of abducting and killing a 10-year-old girl. And then in October of 2020, authorities exhumed a body in search of a conclusive suspect. Her family can't comment on any specifics, but Sources Tell Five investigates a tip led investigators to this grave in Hamden County where the body of a young man was exhumed. He died of an overdose in March of 1997. He was 22 years old.

That body that they exhumed was apparently not David Pouliot. So I'm not sure who that was. I don't believe that person's name has been given, but pretty interesting. And, you know, we're recording this in 2025. So about five years after they exhumed that body, I'm going to guess that they did not find that conclusive link. And in 2023, Hamden District Attorney Anthony Galuni revealed a piece of evidence that was recovered from the vicinity where Holly's remains were found. Happening right now in Springfield, the Hamden District Attorney is set to release evidence in the Holly Paranian murder case from decade to go. Let's listen in. And members of Holly Paranian's family to my right.

I thank you all for being here. We need the public's assistance. We need someone who knows something to stand up with us and do what is right. Accordingly, we are here this morning to ask members of the media and the public at large for assistance in the homicide investigation of Holly Paranian regarding one item, a white tank top with a blue, purple, and pink colored Boston motif on the exterior front. The shirt has no tags or size information. We are seeking the public's assistance for any information about this shirt. We are interested in determining who owned the shirt, its origin, or places where it was known to be sold, anything about its manufacture, or any information regarding its association with the area where Holly was found in the 5 Ridge Road area of Brimfield. There are no identifying tags on the shirt, but investigators are hoping to drum up a memory and learn the manufacturing information or other details about it. This is a white tank top with the word Boston on the front in blue, pink, and purple colors.

So the case as it stands today, like you said, Tim, you hear about it around town. It still reverberates around the state. It captured the attention of the entire country during 1993. And Hamden District Attorney Anthony Galluni is quoted as saying, Holly's murder is an incredible tragedy that I know her family continues to grapple with every single day. It never goes away. And Lance, just earlier this year, in March of 2025, Christina Harrington, the mother of Holly Perrinen, passed away at the age of 63. And Harrington was a longtime resident of Grafton, but had actually moved to Utah in the years before her death.

Well, it's always super tragic to hear that when family members, especially parents, start dying. They get older, they start dying without having any answers for these tragedies. And if anybody has any information about Holly's abduction and her murder, they are instructed to contact the Massachusetts State Police at 413-505-5993. Thanks a lot for listening. Don't forget to like and subscribe. And please follow us on social media at MissingCSM. We'll be back next week with another new episode.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Missing?

This episode is 38 minutes long.

When was this Missing episode published?

This episode was published on August 7, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Missing episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.