Skip to content
563 // Jodi Huisentruit - Part 1 episode artwork

Aug 10, 2025 51 min

563 // Jodi Huisentruit - Part 1

from Missing Hosted by Crawlspace Media

In this new episode Crawlspace Media's Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna speak with Professor David D. Perlmutter of Texas Tech University about the mysterious disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit from Mason City, Iowa on June 27th, 1995. This is part one of two. Main podcast theme by Kevin Macleod. Check out his work at ⁠⁠https://incompetech.com/⁠⁠. Additional music by David Williams. See his work at ⁠⁠http://williamsflutes.com⁠⁠. Follow Missing: IG: https://www.instagram.com/MissingCSM/. TT: https://www.tiktok.com/@missingcsm. FB: https://www.facebook.com/MissingCSM. X: https://twitter.com/MissingCSM. Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0yRXkJrZC85otfT7oXMcri. Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/missingcsm. Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/missing/id1006974447. Follow Crawlspace: IG: https://www.instagram.com/Crawlspacepodcast. TT: https://www.tiktok.com/@crawlspacepodcast. FB: https://www.facebook.com/Crawlspacepodcast. X: https://twitter.com/crawlspacepod. Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7iSnqnCf27NODdz0pJ1GvJ. Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/crawlspace. Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/crawlspace-true-crime-mysteries/id1187326340. Check out our entire network at http://crawlspace-media.com/.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

563 // Jodi Huisentruit - Part 1

0:00 51:18
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome back to Missing. I am Tim here today with Lance. Lance, how are you today? I'm doing fantastic today. Thank you so much for asking. I hope all the listeners are doing fantastic as well. We have a return guest, a gentleman who is welcome to come on the show whenever he has something that is relevant to say in his true crime space. We really love him because he brings us this unique perspective that we didn't realize we would have until we start talking with him and we walk away from the conversation feeling just a little bit smarter.

But Tim, do you feel smarter? How are you today? I'm doing good over here. I'm not so sure if I feel smarter today, but definitely after speaking with David Perlmutter, I did. And Dr. David D. Perlmutter is an author as well as the former dean of the College of Media and Communication at Texas Tech University. But now he is a full-time professor there. So we've got him all to ourselves in this conversation, and we speak about the very mysterious disappearance of Jody Husentrout from Mason City, Iowa on June 27, 1995. And it's a really mysterious disappearance, Lance. You could definitely call it an abduction. Certainly a...

crime scene there in the parking lot of her apartment complex where it sure looks like she was abducted from. So we kind of start there with David and we go over some of the facts. But as we mentioned, David is big into media and communication. And so what he really aims to do is sort of go back to the early days of this disappearance and analyze the media and how it helps or hurts a case. And in this scenario, it's a little extra interesting because Jody Hoosentru was a member of the media. Right, because we've covered...

the media coverage of other stories with david but we haven't covered the media coverage of somebody who's part of the media and then you see what's been discussed or you hear what's been discussed by her co-workers on how to cover her disappearance and the responsibilities that they have and it's really interesting because they're like actually applying that wisdom or those practices they're applying those practices that david has been telling us about for years and What is so interesting about the inner workings of, for example, the news broadcast studio that she worked for is the conversations that happen behind the scenes. Like, are we covering it too much, not enough? And what is the benefits and the pros and cons to, you know, never stop covering it? And then they have to take her out of the picture as a friend because I'm sure they're all friendly colleagues there too. So it just adds like a couple of layers that we can finally start applying some of the things that David has been telling us directly to because she's a part of the media.

But anyway, we'll get into a lot of that in our final thoughts too. Yes, we will. So this interview is going to be broken up into two different episodes. And at the end of part two, Lance, is where we will share our final thoughts on the case. So make sure to stay tuned for that. And hey, if you're listening on Apple, you may want to listen and watch on Spotify. You can do that now. Just switch over to Spotify. You can watch this video show as well as audio show. We'll pop up pictures and you can see the conversation as it unfolds. Right. You can watch our expressions in real time, our looks of shock, of amusement. Anytime we have an emotion, you can actually see what our faces do at that point.

which I'm sure a lot of people have been dying to see. All right, everyone, so please follow us on social media at MissingCSM, and we're going to break quick for commercial here, and we'll be right back with Dr. David D. Perlmutter to speak about the disappearance of Jodi Hoosentry. In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game. Ryan's style is really gunning and gold. And in less than a minute, it slipped away. But he continued to chase the high. Ryan James Wedding. He controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepard, and from CBC Podcasts and the Toronto Star, The Most Wanted Olympian. The Most Wanted Olympian, available now on Spotify.

Welcome back to the podcast, Professor David Perlmutter. How are you today? Thank you so much. I'm very glad to be back among you guys. You're doing just such a terrific job. So you've done like a thousand shows, and it seems like only a month or two ago I was on one. You're really productive and covering so many interesting cases. Congratulations. Oh, thanks. It's always a pleasure to have you on. I always enjoy the messaging that goes back and forth as we prepare for a conversation with you on this show when we record with you, because everything is very...

As we know, in the true crime space, everything's very nuanced, and there are a lot of layers to it, and you bring a really unique perspective to the conversation. But, I mean, it's really redundant at this point, but would you mind introducing yourself to the audience? I'm sure they already know who you are, but there might be one or two who don't. Sure. My name is David Perlmutter, and I'm a professor of communications and media at Texas Tech University. And for about 30 years, I've been studying how the media portray war, crime, violence, and politics. I think that about covers it. I did write a book about 25 years ago now. Yeah, I'll go, okay, that's right.

Still has not hit the New York Times or the Somerset, Maine bestseller list. But I did a study because I was very interested in the wild overrepresentation of police, detectives, law enforcement mystery. Of course, now it's greater. We recently were looking at some channels that were Britbox and others. They're like 99 percent mystery. The mystery genre, the detective genre has just become dominant in the new streaming media space. So I was interested in how people understood.

crime and law enforcement and the legal process through television, news and fiction. I went to my local police department, wrote along for a year and a half, wrote a book about their interactions with us, the public and media stereotypes. And I also was a reserve officer in the police force. And so I've always just been interested in true crime before there was true crime, I guess. as space and media. Well, your book has hit the crawlspace bestseller list. It's gone, it's gone triple platinum. Thank you. I know Oprah is weeping now because she feels eclipsed by your endorsements. So yeah, we make Oprah weep a lot, to be honest. Okay. All right, David. So today you are joining us to speak about the media coverage in the disappearance of Jody Husentrout. So before we get into that, let's just go through the timeline, the brief timeline here of how Jody Husentrout went missing.

And so this is all the way back in 1995 in Mason City, Iowa. And June 27th, 1995, Jodi did not report to her work, which she was supposed to report at 3.30 a.m. because she was an anchor at KIMT TV in Mason City, Iowa. So she was actually on TV and supposed to be on TV that day. But around 4 a.m., her producer Amy called her and actually spoke with her. And Jodi apparently said she'll be at work in a few minutes. And Amy thinks that it sounded like Jodi overslept.

But she never arrived. And around 7.13 a.m., another co-worker calls back in to check with Jodi, see if she's okay and everything, and did not get an answer. And police arrived at her apartment complex around 7.16 a.m. that morning. And it was pretty quickly believed to have been an abduction, some kind of foul play here involved. But no answers all these years later.

Yeah. And you've really introduced us to the basic facts. And what's interesting is now more than 30 years later, because we just passed the 30th anniversary of Ms. Susan Truth's disappearance. We don't know that much more.

This case is odd and anomalous for a lot of different reasons. Let's go to something really basic, which is Jody was an on-air anchor. As you know, as technicians within media space yourself, there's what used to be called, I don't know if you still call them that, the talent, the talent who were on air. And then there's the production staff, the technicians, the people who typically were not visible either or heard in the case of radio. So Jody was an on-air. She'd gone to journalism school.

a wonder person in a lot of ways. She was very successful as a student. She was a very, very successful athlete. Like every sport she played, she was a champion golfer. She was very well-liked and very involved in the community. Back then, we're going to almost another world.

It's still the case in local news that you're expected as a local anchor, as a local celebrity, well-known. You're in somebody's living room or today, their phone, every single day sometimes. And she was on that morning show. So people would wake up and check the weather and see what's going on in town and what's going on the weekend. And so she was a very familiar figure. And this is a relatively small town in a small state. I think the population of Iowa itself is only about 4 million. And so pretty much it would be hard not to know her.

at least by, oh, she's a woman on television. Maybe not everybody knew her name exactly. They were watching some other channels. And then from all the events that occurred where she'd go to a golf tournament or something like that. So that setting is really important because you've covered cases, whether it's Maura Murray or Brandon Maitland, where somebody who's an ordinary person who only in their own family and friend group would really know about, even the cases that become huge, like Gabby Petito, who was a sort of influencer before what happened, the terrible tragedy happened to her. Still, there's a sort of narrowness. But in Mason City, everybody knew of.

And they have even a third of the population might have met at some point physically who's in truth. So that's a really important setting. Not to give an academic speech here, but we have a lot of research from the last 50 years where people do feel what's called a parasocial interaction with people on television. I'm old enough to remember soap opera stars who would be a villainess in a soap opera. And they would do evil in the soap opera. They were an actress who was just doing a really good job portraying an evil villainess in a soap opera. But if they go to the supermarket, somebody would walk you up and say, I can't believe you broke up that marriage. You're such a horrible person. So we've always had this.

attraction. That's why we go to a movie. Some people are big fans of Tom Cruise or Sidney Sweeney. We've always had stars that we felt some kinship to, even though they don't know us or we know it personally. That's true of politicians. It's also true of people in the news. And obviously, people in the media use that to the advantage. It's like, well, just like you guys. You guys are popular, and people want to hear you, and they tune in to hear you. They pull you up in their podcast software to hear you. They want to hear you. It's not just the content. It's the messenger, right? The dark side of that is what we're going to look at because...

There's a lot of speculation about to what extent Jodi's job had an influence on what happened to her or not. And I think it's coming down pretty heavily that there probably is some connection to what she did for a living, which is very different than most of us, and what happened to her. Like how so? Like a direct connection to what she did? Like someone out there was influenced or someone she worked with? Well, okay. So this case is not just an onion with many layers. It's like an onion buried 300 feet in the ground with like...

a million years of strata on top of it. Because if you go to the reputable sources, and I want to shout out to findjodi.com. Findjodi.com was founded by people who knew Jodi in the news industry and others who were concerned that her case was not being solved years ago. And they wanted to do everything possible to get the facts out there, to help the police investigation, to help people not to forget about this young woman who... We don't know what happened, but tragically, her career and her life probably was cut short. And so if you want the absolute 100% established facts and then the maybe facts they're being speculated on and the outright just not trues, go to findjody.com. They also have a podcast. They don't put up new episodes very often because I think that they've said their ethos is to only go on air when they've got something really new to talk about.

That said, I want to take a moment and take a look at the initial news coverage, because another different thing than some of the cases you've covered is that there was almost no delay between something is wrong. And what actually happened? As you said, Jody was scheduled to go on air just a normal morning for her shift. Her producer, this Amy Coons, K-U-N-S, called her. Although it's interesting, even there we get a little bit of question marks. I've seen people say, no, it was somebody else called her or somebody else called her later. But anyway, we know somebody, Amy Coons, talked to her and testifies that she thought that.

Jodi had fallen asleep and had not woken up yet for when she usually came into the studio. And that had happened a couple of times before. I mean, just imagine a job you have to get up every day for five days a week, six days a week at 3.30, you know, and be ready to go on air and talk to everybody in town. That's tough. It's tough. It's a very tough lifestyle to be able to do that. And then she didn't show up. They did not call the police right away because they were preparing for a show. They made the assumption that she went, Jodi Hoosindert went back to sleep. Then when she didn't show up at all, they called the police. The police were there early that morning and they found a scene.

And Tim, I'd like you or Lance to describe a little bit what you described last time in your show about what the police found. And I'm not going to pick it apart, but I'm just going to say this is the kind of oddity about this case in interpreting something and it being established as fact when it's still a question mark. But what do you have down as what the police found on the scene? Yeah. So Jody's red Mazda Miata was found in the parking lot of her apartment complex, which was in downtown Mason City.

A pair of red women's dress shoes, a blow dryer, bottle of hairspray, car keys, and earrings are scattered beside the car along with a bent car key. And there are signs of a struggle. And police pretty much immediately began a missing person's investigation. And those facts were right from that Find Jody site. And wasn't there, in addition to that, wasn't there a palm print that was found on a telephone pole or some pole? I believe on her car. Yeah, let me take a couple of those. So I looked at the initial news coverage. Again, something anomalous about this case was that the news coverage came so quickly. I mean, for most people, when they go missing, for it to become a story that you're missing, unless you're a celebrity, it takes a couple of days for the news to report it. First of all, the police wants to say right away, like, I'll call the media and let them know 20 minutes ago somebody was missing, right? That doesn't usually work that way. In fact, if you can think of a case where...

Somebody who wasn't a celebrity was reported missing in the media within a couple of hours. That's pretty rare, right? Can you think of one? Yeah, I think that's very rare. I can't think of one off the top of my head. Right. So there were, according to the memory of the reporters involved, there were some initial radio reports on some other stations. Then Jody's station reported, I think by noon of that day, that we believe our colleague, you know, Jody's intrude, is missing. So the public was aware there was something wrong with this extremely recognizable person.

So as fast as I mean, we often are sad sometimes about how we think, gosh, this case could have been solved if there had been more attention earlier. Right. You guys have said this in a lot of your broadcasts for different cases is that if people had just been notified that somebody was missing or had been kidnapped or something earlier, we might have gotten more information. Well, you can't get any earlier than a couple of hours. Right. And the implication that there was foul play because.

You can imagine a TV show where there wasn't a better indication that something was wrong than somebody is going to their car and then their stuff is a purse, shoes are strewn around, a bent car key, what the police describe as signs of a struggle. Then within a couple of days, people in the apartment building are interviewed. And I have four to five people saying around. 4.30 a.m. I think is one of the times that's given, although you know how often people were looking at their clock, they heard screaming, a woman's screaming from the parking lot. And we'll be right back after a quick word from our sponsors.

Thanks to our sponsors. And now we're back to the program. Around 4.30am, they heard screaming. This is where if you read the transcripts, there's different reports about whether anybody could hear anything intelligibly. Some person claimed they heard a name. Some person said that it sounded more surprised than afraid. One person, I thought this was very interesting. You guys are technicians of television and video production and so on. One person said it went on for a minute.

Now, you imagine it's police officers. This is a problem, right? Somebody says, I heard screaming for a minute. Now, you know from video and audio production, 60 seconds is forever. If we just went dark here for 60 seconds, we'd lose half the audience. And people would go, is something wrong? Are you guys OK if there's a live streaming, right? So somebody's screaming for 60 seconds. And by the way, nobody apparently did anything. Certainly nobody went to the parking lot. Nobody called the police. We'll talk about that in a minute. But I actually asked one of the people who just recently on Reddit, Scott Fuller, who was one of the founders of.

find Jody had a Q&A on Reddit. And I asked him about that. And he said that he wasn't 100% sure about whether, you know, people say a minute as a unit of a short time. And they may not mean like, I timed it, you know, and it was 60 seconds, right? So right there, there's stuff going on. And the initial news reporting followed the rules, which was, if you look at the initial stories, they say local anchor woman missing. They do use the word missing.

They don't jump right to abducted because there are different scenarios here. I think the weight of evidence after 30 years is that she was abducted in the parking lot and that there was a struggle. But, you know, there are other explanations. If somebody wants to make something look like a struggle, well, that's, you know, you throw stuff on the ground and you bend a car key. So the point is, right from the very beginning.

This is a different case than most cases. And whatever happened had to have happened very quickly. And then whatever happened to Jody after we've talked before, in my experience in the police department, police, when they give anti-crime prevention, how to not be a victim of crime. They always talk about never go to the second crime scene. If somebody attacks you in the Walmart parking lot, then you make your last stand in the Walmart parking lot. You don't believe the guy who says, get in the car. I just want your money. I won't hurt you. Fight it out. That's what police say. I'm not advising that myself. I don't know. I'm not a police officer, but I've heard that very often, right? So whatever happened at the second crime scene has been secreted for 30 years, which is pretty amazing, considering the publicity. I have several connections to Iowa personally, but also I was at the journalism school at the University of Iowa later for about five years.

It is definitely one of the most, there's a couple other famous Iowa missing people cases, but certainly because of the nature of Jody's job, it's hard to not be in journalism in capacity or even be a journalism student, even a young student, like 18. And she was a journalism major and not hear about this case. It's strange to a lot of people that we know so little because you've just described pretty much the fact that there's a lot of, there is other stuff. There's a whole range of suspects. There's been a detective who's been involved in this for years. They've been, different police chiefs have come and gone. The police department have done different things. There was recently a Hulu documentary.

But the case is unsolved after all this time. And I personally think that's pretty amazing that it isn't solved in any way, including recovery of some kind. Not even asking, like, who did it? Yeah. I mean, the scene itself suggests that this was sort of an ambush and it was a struggle. So I'm wondering just how planned out the second location that you spoke of was. So if the abduction site calls for a struggle, like, at what point is she subdued enough to...

put her into a more controlled environment that would cause no answers to be had for 30 years. You know what I'm saying? I hope that made some sense. Like, the ambush itself doesn't feel like it was very well executed because of all of the items everywhere. So I'm wondering what that second crime scene looks like. How prepared was that? But I gotta say, whoever abducted Jodi must have known her work schedule or something to that effect. I mean, unless we're to believe it was random, which I don't really believe. Right, but they would have to, sorry to jump in here, but they would have to know that she was running late. Well, they could have just been waiting outside. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah, so there are these reports, and you guys have talked about this a lot. When you're a police officer or a detective or investigative journalist or somebody in the true crime space and you're looking into a case, it's always good not to get tunnel vision and fixated that there's only one possible solution and to jam all the evidence into supporting that one possible solution. We do not know what happened to Joey, period. That's it. We're done. That's the truth.

There are reports. I have to say that every missing person case, there's a report of a white van seen in the premises. It seems like whenever anybody goes missing, somebody remembers every white van that they saw near there. So there is a report of a white van that was seen continually, not in the parking lot, but near the parking lot. There's a report of like beer cans being seen near where the white van was. So there is some indirect soft evidence that maybe somebody was stalking her. Her schedule.

In terms of when she appeared on the air would be general knowledge. I don't think it wasn't a military secret how early people had to leave. She was in an apartment building. So anybody looking out their window day after day, week after week at a certain time would notice her rushing out to the parking lot, you know, with her shoes and her purse and getting ready and going. So it wouldn't be hard for anyone to know her schedule with just a little bit of observation. Now, there's a lot of wild cards here. She was late, so she wasn't on schedule. Right. So you're thinking somebody who's a total stranger stalking her.

She didn't emerge at her normal time. And if you're a total stranger and you're in a white van in the parking lot, you're always worried somebody's going to drive by and see you. Police are going to drive by, right? Early morning, you never know, right? Why is that van parked and exhaust coming out or something like that? Your level of risk rises there.

So, yeah, there's there's some thought that like it would be somebody who knew her schedule, but a lot of people knew her schedule. And then, as you guys know, sometimes there's just bad luck. Right. So the crime of opportunity, as far as I know, has not been ruled out of just somebody was there. And some of the suspects that have risen and fallen or risen are still suspects are people who've been convicted of similar crimes. And again, fine, Jody has done a very good job of looking at some of them and eliminating some of them.

But you look at some of these people who are serial rapists or serial murderers, sometimes they have no planning at all. It's just opportunistic. You know, you did the case of the Native American women on a highway that were disappearing at a very high rate. I'm blanking now where that highway was. Amber Tucaro. Yeah. Yeah, the Highway of Tears. Yep. And I don't think the culprits in that case, I'm honestly forgetting the circumstances, I don't think that they did some elaborate planning. They just drove along and waited for somebody who they looked at was alone and vulnerable and did their horrible thing, right? Yeah, that's correct. That was, I think, pretty random, maybe a hitchhiker, you know, trucker.

stop kind of scenario. Yeah. So that's interesting. And again, the media at first did their job correctly, which is to say she's missing. Now I've noticed because I listened to a couple dozen other podcasts and I read a lot of newspaper, magazine, TV coverage, the word abduction is always used. And I guess, again, it's one of those things where like, I don't see the scenario where this is Jody deciding to disappear, you know, which we talked about in some of the other cases you've covered that there's a non, I would like to say non-zero chance of anomalous phenomenon of somebody just deciding to disappear.

I think it's so close to zero as to be effectively zero, but we don't actually, I don't think anybody can prove 100% that she was abducted. But whoever did it is either extremely lucky or this was a master crime. You know, because of course, we don't know whether this person is still alive. We don't know whether they're in jail for another crime, right? Whether this was the only crime they ever committed, but this one has not been solved. And we'll be right back after a quick word from our sponsors.

In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game. Ryan's style is really gunning and gold. And in less than a minute, it slipped away. But he continued to chase the high. Ryan James Wedding. He controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepard and from CBC Podcasts and the Toronto Star, The Most Wanted Olympian. The Most Wanted Olympian, available now on Spotify. Thanks to our sponsors. And now we're back to the program. Can we talk about what she was doing in the days prior to this? She had the golf tournament. She visited a friend's house, watched a birthday party video. Is any of this relevant to...

the scene of the alleged abduction or theorized abduction? Yeah, that's really interesting. And you guys know from covering a thousand cases, everything is relevant until it isn't, right? You just don't know. We've given the example of like, if any one of us went missing tomorrow, there's probably something odd we did that day or something happened, which in retrospect, wow, is that connected to the disappearance or something like that? And you as well know that the cases have been solved and longtime theories that actually had some evidence have ended up being completely irrelevant. June 27th was when she disappeared, Tuesday.

June 27th, 1995. I have a timeline here for her for just the last couple of days where over the weekend, she went actually not near from, not very far from where I lived in Iowa. She went war skiing on a boat. There's a gentleman named John Van Seis, who's just passed away recently, who has always been, and I'm using the exact term that police use, person of interest. He was a personal friend of Jody. I think it's worth saying everything is an allegation at this point, but he did appear before a grand jury. There is a grand jury, I forgot, warrant.

for him that's resealed every year because the police say there's something in there that even after his passing away, they want to keep out of the public eye that the attorney for the county has reapplied every year. John Van Zyce was a friend of hers. Some people say that he wanted to be more than that. He was a gentleman who was, I think, 20 years older. He had a vote that he named after Joey, which is something that you don't think about happening too often. Not too many friends I know will name a vote after me or something like that. But again, it's not indicting him.

on a murder charge. Jodi anchored the news on June 26th, the morning before. Her slot was 6 to 7 a.m. So she was the wake-up anchorwoman there. 9 a.m. Now remember, these poor people have to wake up at 3 o'clock. 9 a.m. attended a golf tournament. There was a rain delay, but she socialized at the local country club. 3.15, she went home, changed. 3.30 to 8, she had dinner. And back at the country club, where she mentioned to somebody that she had received harassing calls.

I don't think the police have ever released that. I know in 1995, it was it was possible to trace calls. So I don't I don't think anything's ever been released like and we trace the calls to this person or something like that. Or for some reason, maybe the calls went from a phone book or work. But but that's there. It's a fact that she told somebody she'd received harassment calls the day before.

She disappears. Right. And let me just note, it seems like she's talking about a house phone, not a cell phone at that point. Yeah, we're assuming that that was not a cell phone at that point. In fact, one of the things I've never seen 100% confirmed, I don't think she had a cell phone. Because first of all, when they called her, they would call her at home. And nowadays, of course, everybody would just call their cell. Even at that time, for a professional, you'd call the cell. So I don't think that there was a cell phone. And 1995 was kind of early for cell phones to be so commonplace that everyone had them. I think that's interesting in that.

It wasn't like she was sitting at dinner at the clubhouse after the golf tournament and she was getting phone calls right then. And that sparked her, you know, to mention that to those folks. She actually brought it up outside of it happening presently. You know what I mean? Yeah. Yeah. And there was also one of the facts is that she had discussed taking self-defense classes.

Eight o'clock, she left the awards dinner. 824, I mean, just think about how good a timeline we have versus some people who it's, you know, some of the famous cases you've done, Maura Murray, Brianna Madeleine, where the timeline is pretty vague on, like, not to the minute, certainly, right? And so 824, called a friend in Mississippi and sounded cheerful. Then we have 830 to 10. The night before she disappears, she visits this John Van Syce's duplex. He does not live in the same apartment building. But again, Mason City is very small. We're talking five to 10 minutes to go across town to watch a video of her birthday party. Van Syce said she left about 10 p.m.

And neighbors in her apartment complex say that they saw her return. I haven't seen any narratives of that. That's just something like appears. But again, somebody heard her answer the phone. And this was not a cell phone. So in 1995, somebody called your home unless they had some elaborate Mission Impossible equipment. It was probably ringing at your house.

So then all the events that we've talked about happen the next day. So we do have people in her life. She apparently found a new boyfriend or a partner recently and they'd seen a lot of each other. His name has not come out that much. In fact, the story came out very late in the investigation. John Van Syce has come up again. If you go through Find Jodi, you're going to see there's probably about a dozen people who are associated because, again, they've committed similar crimes and they lived in town, the same town as her.

We also have just a lot of, I can go into some of the other oddities, but to answer your original question. There's not a smoking gun that's real obvious from the days before her disappearance that you can just point to and say, oh, my gosh, this betrayal starts hot there. Can we chat real quick about the item that is continually being resealed by law enforcement concerning John Van Zyce? That doesn't necessarily have to do with Jody. That could be something that is in relation to another crime or something, right? Like this doesn't necessarily have to be related to Jody. Yeah, that's a good question. I believe that in the filing by the attorney's office, they say.

Their specific reason for resealing this indictment every year, even after now he's passed away, is related to this case. And, you know, again, anybody who's listened to your show knows police will often withhold from the public, from journalism, from anyone covering a case, certain details that they want to make sure only they and the perpetrator and the victim know, because that's one way to narrow down. false confessions, false trails, that somebody, false convictions, false accusations, right? One thing I want to flip to, and we'll cover whatever you want. One thing I want to flip to is that typically, again, since 99% of cases are ignored, right? Like 99% of cases of the 250,000 murder and missing that you've listed in your show, 99% of them, there's a news report, somebody's missing, and that's it.

You never hear about it again. You've covered some pretty famous cases that keep being brought up again and again. Jody is brought up again and again. They're billboards in Mason City saying, let us know, tell us, right? So a lot of clues have come up over the years, a lot of accusations, a lot of alleged evidence. The police have been given a lot of information, but nothing has happened in terms of a conviction. And now 30 years passing. You almost wonder in these cases whether there is such a thing as too much publicity, too many people feeling they want to get involved in this.

and reporting something that either may be false or may be completely unrelated to the actual crime. That's definitely an interesting idea, is like if a case does get too much publicity, is there a point where it starts to go the other way and be unhelpful as opposed to helpful? Yeah, I don't know about this case. I would say that's probably not the story here, but I don't really know it enough to know. But I do know that this Van Syce guy seems pretty suspect to me.

Can you repeat again, Jody went to his house to view a videotape of her birthday? Yes, he had thrown a surprise birthday party for her a little while before, and he'd made a video. This is 1995, so imagine, you know, you guys probably, well, I don't know whether, you know, in your cradles you held video cameras, but they were big deals, you know, to have a video camera with a videotape and record it, and then to edit it. to make a combined story, especially pretty quickly, that was a big deal. So she went over there, she saw it. That's his testimony is that that's the last time that he saw her there. You could do it. You could do several podcasts just on his case. And again, we're not making, he's passed away. He developed apparently Alzheimer's and then died recently. I forgot the exact date of his death. It was very recently. He showed up.

when the police were there in the morning, the morning of the disappearance. And allegedly he said, I'm the last person to see her or some variation of that. Now that's a very good example going back to the one minute where somebody says something and in a TV fiction drama, or when you're playing sleuth, you go like, boy, that's a suspicious thing to say. I'm the last person who saw her. Did he say I last person who saw her alive? I see some different reports, but let's just say, even if he just said, I'm the last person who saw her, that's suspicious.

Right. I mean, I would sit up and take notice if somebody phrased it that way. He couldn't know that was true unless he killed her. Yeah. But then, you know, people just say stuff right that they don't necessarily mean in the literal sense. I mean, there's no question he's the last person to have seen her for any extended period of time. And then he shows up at the scene. There's no way he was on Mason City Police's radar.

as a person of interest for his entire life after that. In fact, people have talked about, you know, I mean, he may have been completely innocent. And if so, he said that his life was ruined by association with this. And, you know, you think he really did care about Joey. It's like a double whammy if he was completely innocent. So, you know, we'll know, right? Because the case hasn't been solved. What do you make of the 2017 development when law enforcement filed to have a GPS device placed in two of his vehicles?

Yeah. And those were two vehicles that he did not have, that did not exist at the time of the crime. Right. Right. So they were trying, he, as I recall, and again, findod.com has this sequentially, but like he moved to Arizona. He had to come back to Iowa for a different reason, including being called to testify. Right. And being a person of interest. And so they, they put GPS on his vehicles. And I, I think, you know, again, I'm on the mind of the police, but it seems an inference that we can make that they thought there was a possibility he might go somewhere.

You know, I don't want to speculate on where, but, you know, you just have to jump to, like, he would go to where the second crime occurred. Again, we use these terms of, like, the first crime, if it's correct, the first crime was abduction, may have been murder, but the second crime was covering up a murder or a murder and then a cover-up of murder. And so that's a pretty strong feeling, you know, like for police to do that. They have to really, really be committed to him as a suspect to do something like that. Because you just don't, as a police officer, you just don't get the GPS device, put it on the vehicle and say it's part of your investigation, right? You need to like file for the approval, for the search warrant, like there's a whole process. And you're not going to do that if you don't, like you said, have a really strong feeling. Thanks a lot for listening. Don't forget to like and subscribe. We'll be back tomorrow with part two.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Missing?

This episode is 51 minutes long.

When was this Missing episode published?

This episode was published on August 10, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Missing episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.