Hey folks, it's Quinn. Since we recorded this conversation, we've renamed the podcast. It used to be called important non-important, which is what you'll hear in the episode, and it's still the name of the company. But now the podcast is called the most important question.
That is, what can I do? It's the question we get the most from all of you, and it turns out it's the question I've really been asking guests for almost 200 episodes now. So here we are, the most important question. Please enjoy this old conversation.
Thanks for listening, and thanks for giving us shit. Welcome to important non-important, my name is Quinn Emmett. And my name is Brian Colbergennady. And this is the podcast where we dive into a specific topic or question affecting everyone, like you, on the planet, right now, or in the next 10 years or so.
If it can kill us, Brian, or turn us into super human crisper robots, we are in. Our guests are scientists, doctors, engineers, politicians, astronauts, professors, even the reverend. And we work together. Every conversation towards action steps our listeners can take with their voice, their vote, and their dollar.
And this is your friendly reminder that you can send questions, thoughts, and feedback to us on Twitter at important.imp or email us at funtalkandimportant.com. This week's episode, we talk about, Brian, it turns out more food does not necessarily mean more nutritious food. And guess what? That's bad news.
Our guests are professors, Kristi Ibi and Irakli Lolante. Nicely done. Dr. Ibi is the Roman Haas Endowed Professorship in Public Health Sciences at the University of Washington.
And she's been conducting research and practice on health risks of climate variability and change for over 20 years. And boy, do we dig into that. Her research focuses on the impacts of adaptation to climate variability and change, including on extreme events, thermal stress, foodborne safety and security, and vector-borne diseases, all of which sound lovely. She's got like 12 letters after her name.
She's got MS in toxicology and a PhD and a Master's of Public Health in epidemiology. In two years of postgraduate research at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, she has edited four books on aspects of climate change and has more than 180 publications. And Dr. Lolante is a professor of health sciences at the Bryan Medical Center at Bryan College in Nebraska, where he applies mathematical computational and statistical methods to life sciences.
He's taught all over, including Princeton, is an open science advocate. And his research into the quality of human nutrition has been published basically everywhere and cited almost a thousand times. Yeah, one of yours, do you feel like, has been cited a thousand times? Probably something I might say on Facebook one time.
Right, but that's the future, isn't it? Now it's like, you could have said those words when we were in college. Right. And it wouldn't make sense, but now, I mean, someone in college, this is a different conversation, this might be fun talk, but like, someone now can take Instagram live video of anything you're doing, and the whole world can see it live.
Yeah, yeah, things have changed. Just a little bit. Yeah, and turns out our food has changed too. Turns out, it's not great.
No, but people are working on it. At least two, and for no one. At least two. Anyways, all right, let's go talk about food.
Our guest today are professors, Christy Ebai and Erakli Loladza. And together, we're gonna talk about, Brian, it turns out more food doesn't necessarily equal nutritious food. That might not be great. Christy and Erakli, welcome.
Thank you for having me on. We are. We're very excited to have you, and thank you for all that you had to get through this morning to be here. So real quick, if we can go just one by one, maybe we can start with Christy, and just tell us who you are and what you do.
I am the director of the Center for Health and the Global Environment at the University of Washington. I've been working on various aspects of climate change and health for more than 20 years. Wow, so you were one of those first people who were like, hey, listen, this is not great. We might need to start.
Talk 20 years. That's great. Yeah, that's a fairly accurate representation. Although there were definitely people along the way who picked it up, but it's been pretty slow in.
I'm sure that hasn't been frustrating at all. There's been lots of very energizing moments as particularly ministries of health realize the challenges they're facing, and it's been a real privilege working with ministries of health around the world to help them better prepare for a change in climate. Sure, and you said you were actually testifying to Congress yesterday, is that correct? That's correct.
So you were able to get the car out of the driveway yesterday. I live in Seattle. The testifying was in Washington, DC. So good, you didn't drive there.
No. Good, good. And what was yesterday all about? Yesterday was the House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology.
And it's the first of a series of hearings about climate science and why it matters. There were five experts who testified on various aspects about climate change. I spoke specifically about health issues. Fascinating.
Yeah. I imagine that's the first time we've had one of those committee meetings in quite a while. That's true. There's also a House Committee on Environment and Energy.
And I believe they just also held a hearing, and they're also scheduling more hearings. So you'll be hearing more from, certainly from the House of Representatives about climate science over the coming months. Thank God. We'll take it.
It's nice to know that it's going down. Well, thank you for making your way all the way there and doing that. That's pretty exciting stuff. I'm sure I was meant to be invited.
I'll make the next one. No, it's fine. It's fine. Things get lost in there all the time.
Excellent, Christy. And, you're right. So I'm an associate professor of biomedical sciences at Brown College of Health Sciences and Brown Medical Center in Lincoln, Nebraska. And I'm formally trained as a mathematician and applying mathematics to biology.
And I've been working on this issue of impact arising to you on the quality of crops and wild plants and human nutrition since 2000. Wow. So a while as well. Same thing.
Fire and flare-ish. Yeah, people are just happy to not pay attention. Oh, God, thank you. Thank you so much.
Actually, where are you from originally? I'm from Georgia, but not Atlanta. I don't have a Southern accent, so. Sure.
A wonderful place. There's different reasons. Thank you for clarifying. How did you find your way to Nebraska?
I came to grad school to Arizona State University 1994 and then I had a post-doc position on the East Coast. And then ended up in Nebraska for my faculty positions. That's cool. We're on the East Coast, where are you?
Princeton, New Jersey. OK, nice. Wouldn't it be great if you ended up in Georgia? From Georgia to Georgia?
I mean, I visited it. Yeah, Atlanta. Yeah, dynamic seating. Yeah.
I'm easily entertained. And I suggest you ask Arakali how he first got interested in this topic. Hey, Arakali, can I ask you a question? I said you just first get interested in this topic.
Well, it's nuclear weapons in cows. I'm sorry. What was that? Involves nuclear weapons in cows.
I was there was mandatory service to military service back in the former US-Assar. And I was sent to Lithuania. And we were supposed to guard this nuclear warheads underground and part of the Air Force. And so I didn't really like the job.
But there were cows, 53 cows grazing above. And I don't know what the purpose was of cows, but somebody had to take care of them. And so I got the job of a cow taker. And the irony of the Soviet Union is that we had the sophisticated military technology, but they didn't have a single milking machine.
So I had to milk them twice a day with my hands. And that allowed me to really closely literally see what type of milk and how much milk I get. And I noticed that as cows graze different places, that they would eat different grass and the quality of grass affected the amount of milk. So that registered in my mind that there was this connection between quality of plants, and the output of animals give.
And so that then developed into my PhD thesis, where it was a mathematical model that tracked how that food quality affects the consumers. Holy shit. That's super cool. Christy, I have to say thank you for suggesting that we get there.
Usually we don't do too much back story, but now I feel like, because we want to move into forward-looking and action, but it does feel like occasionally, boy, there's some gems out there. Wow. That is amazing. Well, listen, we have to say thank you to those cows.
Because without those cows, we wouldn't be here today. I love them. And I'm the wonderful creatures indeed. That's wild.
That is fantastic. Groovy, so we're going to go on here, as a reminder to everyone, our goal always on the podcast is to get to provide some context for the topic we're going to talk about, and then dig into action oriented questions so that we can come away from this thing with some steps to take to help you and support you and save the world. If that sounds OK. Sounds great.
Great. Awesome. And don't worry, we're going to keep feeding Brian coffee, because clearly it hasn't kicked in on that side. I have to.
Yeah, he does have two in his hands. He has two. OK, so listen, Christy, Erakli, we usually start with one important question, something to sort of set the tone here. I encourage you to be bold, to be honest.
So instead of actually saying, tell us your entire life story, I don't know how we beat nuclear cows. We like to ask our guest, why are you vital to the survival of the species? And Christy, I'd say let's start with you. That's a very interesting question.
I'm not sure I'm vital to the survival of the species. I can help facilitate the science to policy interface. I spend a lot of time on that. And so I can help bring science to policymakers, help them understand challenges, opportunities, options for action.
And I've also done quite a bit of work on helping design and implement research agendas. I've had opportunities to work in many countries around the world. And I can synthesize that information and bring forward to funding agencies, for example, what kind of research needs to be done. I, of course, have led some of that research, but also have helped facilitate research led by many others.
So more facilitator than vital to survival. Well, that sounds pretty important. Sounds important. Yeah, absolutely.
I love it. Inter-racally? I think Chris is really more distant. She's a pioneer in the field of global and planetary health.
And I do think that she's vital for our survival. Well, as a scientist, what we do is we generate knowledge. I'm not an activist or policy maker. And I think it's a very noble profession where we essentially, what we do is kind of expand that circle that represents the knowledge of humanity.
Maybe it's a little progress, but it's never the less there's addition to that expansion of that circle. And in that sense, as part of being a scientist, I think we are definitely a vital for the survival of our species. And I would add to that, roughly, we always say we stand on the shoulders of others, which is absolutely true. And you'll never know if someone was missing from that.
Right. How things would look differently? Yes, good point. Sure, absolutely.
And I'm sure there is a multitude of young scientists and activists who look at you folks the same way. If you hadn't been fighting for this past 20 years, if those cows hadn't been milk, then we might not be here. And things might be a lot worse. So awesome.
I love it. All right. So listen, we are going to just set up a quick little context here for the question in hand, just so everybody's kind on the page. So we've talked about agriculture and food and water and climate and things like that, sometimes in different silos, sometimes mixed together here.
Obviously, there has been interaction among all those things. But we are barreling towards 10 billion, tightly packed humans, on this little pale blue dot of ours. And somehow we're going to have to feed each one of them. As a reminder to our listeners, we already actually make more than enough food for everyone on the planet.
The problem is, of course, the problems are many of the calories are empty. We waste an immeasurable amount of food, and it's nowhere near evenly distributed. There's actually a new diet that came out the past couple of weeks by a bunch of different scientists prescribed that could theoretically drastically reduce agricultural emissions, which would be great, and also help our nutritional health as well. But that's all just to set the table, which is just an awful pond.
Here's the thing. Plants eat sunlight and carbon dioxide. And as everyone knows, our atmosphere is just now brimming with carbon dioxide, thanks to 200 years of industry and agriculture and things like that. But we know what happens to temperatures and things of that nature, if the atmosphere gets too much carbon dioxide.
But the question that we're going to talk about today, and that these two have been working on, so diligently, for 20 years is what happens if plants get too much carbon dioxide? So that is our focus today, which turns out we've been making more and more food, but it's not necessarily becoming more nutritious. In fact, it might be going the other way, and that is not great. So, Christy, and your partner in crime here, Rocky, what is this big revelation that we have come to about the food that everyone's eating today?
Oh, briefly summarize it. And then I'd really appreciate, Rocky, to come in, because he's worked much more on the plant physiology side and why this is a concern. But the bottom line is that there are essentially two main mechanisms by which plants take the carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere and turn it into the carbon that forms the plant. And one group includes rice, wheat, potatoes, major staple crops around the world.
And the insight from experiments that Rocky and others have been involved in is that as the concentrations of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere increase, then for rice, wheat, and these other staple crops, there's less protein, there's less iron, there's less zinc, there's less of the other major micronutrients. And we were part of a study that showed specifically for rice, there's fewer of the essential B vitamins. And so, as you mentioned, overall the nutritional quality of the food is quite a bit less, as CO2 concentrations continue to increase. How much less are we talking?
Rocky, do you want to explain a little bit more and then go into the details of the experiment? Right, so imagine that if you're stuck in one place, and then you can't move, and then you have all this weather that unpredictable in many ways, anything like drought and freezing and heat. And also, you don't have any food, you have to make your own food, and all you can use is sunlight, water, and dirt. And most of us would die, right?
But plants are able to flourish in these conditions. And because they make their own food, right? And because they make their own food, and if we think logically, right, is any factory that produces anything, you need to have something where you store your product, right? As you cannot immediately use it.
And indeed, if you look at plant cells, they have these two distinct features that animal cells lack. And that is one is the central vacuole, and it's huge. It would take the most of the cell volume, and the plastics, and plastics are like most well-known, it's chloroplasts, but there are also other plastics that are specifically for storing nutrients, and one of those is amyloplast, that are for storing starch. And so because of the storage components in plants, essentially what we eat when you eat fruit or vegetable, you actually eat the content of those central vacuoles in the plastics to a large degree.
And they allow plants to have very flexible chemical composition, and which animal sense, they already don't have such a chemical variability in their content, and the plants do. And the second thing is, if you live in such a predictable world, you become opportunists. So plants, if they see excess of any nutrient, they're gonna take it, they're gonna store it. It's like in a good homemaker, if it produced too much of cake or cookies, it's gonna store it for future use.
And that is important to understand why plants should change their quality, and that's what kind of original thinking about me going back in the early 2000s. So because we increase your two globally, plants then start to synthesize more storchers and sugars, and they start to store more of those storchers in their tissues. And that doesn't really hurt them. I mean, they like it, just in case they wanna have it.
The problem is that the plants really don't care about her nutrition, right? We eat plants, we're kind of their enemies. So there is this global shift where all plants, almost all plants around the world, start to pack more storchers and sugars and because their chemical composition allows that, the central back goes and plastics allow them to do that. We end up eating more of that and less of other nutrients.
So it's a finite amount of space within the plant. And again, I couldn't be further from a botanist of any sort here. I mean, I have a garden and it grows okay. But so I'm imagining a finite amount of space in this plant, this storage facility of sorts.
And right now, because of the increased carbon dioxide, it's storing more starches and sugars in less of zinc and the B vitamins and things like that. Is that way off base? Exactly, per unit of biomass, right? So the density of starches and sugars are all increases and the density of protein and minerals decreases.
Now there are other physiological mechanisms that also contribute to different quality. So the change in quality is not uniform. Some minerals like, for example, manganese, I found doesn't really change much, but say magnesium or iron or zinc or nitrogen and those drop considerably. That's so wild, the things we need.
And if I could, can I add something to the moment? A question that we get a lot is people will come back and say, doesn't it have to do with the soils? But the experiments that Rockley was referring to are done where you have several plots. So the soil's the same, the air temperature is the same, the precipitation's the same, but on some of the plots, you blow carbon dioxide across them.
So they're growing under high or CO2. So this is not just the soil. This is a change in the plant physiology. Which is a different, and we've talked to another podcast and something I keep wanting to dig into because America's soil, however, I understand it, isn't a very pet place.
So that is a different discussion, but you're saying with all of that controlled and we've waft some more CO2 over it, that is having a specific effect. Correct. Right, yeah, and Chris makes this point delineates that thing because when you start to talk about declining food quality, people bring out of valid issues such as depletion of soils and degradation of soils on really a massive scale. And we have no one about that.
And other issues that change for higher yields where we deliberately breed for higher and higher yields. And that's the single-minded kind of focus. And so there is a fundamental trade-off between quality and quantity. And if you only focus on quantity, then quality gets lost in the process.
And this has been known for decades, but the issue of rising CO2, making global, causing global declines in food quality and contributing to them is relatively unknown. Which is not great. Not great. Yeah, I'm sorry I'll interrupt again.
No, no, you should always interrupt, please. Slightly more complicated. Which from back to Erockley, we're not the only one that eats plants. Right, right.
It's easy to stay human focused. But in fact, humans don't need enough plants. Correct. We prefer burgers, but everybody else eats plants.
And the birds talk from cows. Cow to eat plants. Right. Right.
They all start from plants. It's always back to the cows. Hey, so you guys, when did this like, you know, revelation come to me? When was this all, did somebody go, oh, hey, I think something's going on here?
Did we, you know, was it something that we stumbled upon or did somebody think, well, we should start looking into this? Well, you know, because of CO2, we knew this CO2 is increasing the biologists and agronomists started to run these experiments where that is prescribed. The only difference was CO2 concentrations. And they would look at many aspects of plant physiology, such as plant growth and amount of nitrogen they use.
And they noticed that plants use less nitrogen. They actually need less nitrogen. And the reason why is because when CO2 concentrations go up, plants have easier time capturing CO2 molecules. And they capture them with this rubisco enzyme, which is very rich nitrogen, essentially it's a protein.
Some say it's one of the most abundant proteins on earth. And so the plants say, hey, we can be more efficient. And so this was considered like a good thing, higher nitrogen use efficiency for plants. They started to look at minerals.
And there was this disarray, really. Some cases they declined, in some cases they increased. It's like, you're trying to measure weather temperature in certain city. If you do it five, 10 times, you're not going to notice global warming, right?
You need massive amount of data. So when I started to look at it, I saw that there was a consistency with respect to nitrogen, but the large inconsistency with respect to minerals. But the minerals are the ones that humans are most deficient in their diet, specifically iron and zinc, and calcium and magnesium as well. And so that's where my concern was that if minerals decline, then that would affect human nutrition.
And then I started to make a logical argument why minerals should decline. In other words, there should be some signal, I mean, all that noise. And that is one of those problems that you stumble upon in the lab, I imagine, and go like, oh shit, this is something I should probably pursue. Not like, oh, this is a little interesting thing.
Is the rate of our food, is the nutritional rate declining precipistically. So, so Christy, how did you find your way into this? I was asked to. Erockly and I work with a just a fantastic scientist at USDA that I've known for a long time, Dr.
Lewis Siska. And Lou and I have collaborated on a number of projects and lose collaborated extensively with Erockly and others. And as this work was ongoing, the question, of course, was the human health piece. And to put the numbers that Erockly just mentioned into perspective, right now around the world, there's about 815 million people who are food insecure that is they don't get enough to eat.
There is more than two billion people who have micronutrient deficiencies. So the micronut deficiencies are a much larger problem overall than just food insecurity. And so Lou brought me into the project to say, so what does this mean for our health? Sure.
And this is the thing, and we really try not to be fear mongers here, but we do try to be objective about everything that's going on and expose what is really going on because people aren't getting all of the most important news. And that's as much as, you know, writers like Stephen Pinker and guys like that talk about how much, statistically how much better, so many different parts of the world and ways of the world and people in the world and things like that have gotten better over the past century, which are absolutely true. We are not measuring these things in a vacuum, which is to say that the numbers you just talked about, 800 million and two billion, those are now. That's before immigration gets out of control due to climate.
That's what people still think for a variety of reasons. It's very controversial, whether GMOs are good or not, all of these things before we've figured out a perennial wheat, et cetera, et cetera. So you look at that and go, those numbers would be the tip of the iceberg. Again, try not to be a reminder but going, yes, a lot of things have gotten better.
However, we have some enormous things that we have to look at. Does this increase in carbon dioxide affect all plants the same or are there any plants that are not affected? Like Chris mentioned, our wonderful colleague, Luis Ziska, and he worked on this CO2 effects on plants for a long time. And not just quality, he looked at, for example, that some weeds that might benefit from CO2 concentrations.
The majority of plants are on earth that's called C3 plants. And that means that when they synthesize this CO2 into starches, that one of the products contains three carbons. And unlike C4 plants that would have four carbons. So C4 plants like maize and many grasses, they are able to concentrate CO2 concentrations internally.
And so they really don't benefit as much from higher CO2 concentrations in the sense of increasing photosynthesis. And so we have this dichotomy between C3 and C4 and there'll be different responses. Both plants, however, start to lose less water. Because again, the way the plants get CO2 is that they get it from little openings called stomatics, like their mouths.
And when CO2 goes higher, they say, hey, we don't have to keep our mouths so wide open. They partially close those stomatas. And as a result, they lose less water. So there's less transpiration that brings all these water from roots to what shoots.
And as a water flow decreases, it also decreases the flow of minerals, some minerals towards roots. It's another effect that results in lower crop quality in both C3 and C4 plants. Wow. Are there parts of the world in general that are more affected than others?
That's a good question. So thanks to all these researchers that were generating the data on four continents. And when I encountered a lot of doubt that this is happening, including from plant experts, and this has been going on for many years, I said, okay, let me collect everything that have ever been published, right? As I couldn't get grants to actually generate the data.
So the data collected is from four continents, Australia, Europe, Asia, and North America. There are no data from South America or Africa, unfortunately. But the effect is very pervasive geographically. It's on all latitudes that we have data for the temperate forests or subtropical regions or tropical regions and it affects both edible tissues and foliar tissues.
So it's pretty systemic effect throughout plant tissues. And the second part- No good answer, Christy, please. So the second part of that question was, what does it mean for those of us who are human centric? And it really depends on our diet.
And so the regions that are most vulnerable are places where people rely heavily on cereal crops. So today in Bangladesh, even as its economy grows, three or four calories comes from rice. Sure, sure. And those of course are the areas of the world that are growing the quickest.
Well, there's also the poor in our own country who rely heavily on starches. Right. So it's the poor everywhere that are the most affected because they typically have diets that are high in starch. Right.
Sure. It's interesting though. And we've tried to really delve a lot into climate justice and environmental justice here because, like you said, they surprised they poor are being affected the worst. And sometimes in America, that's by design because that's the system we've built, which is terrible.
And sometimes that's just the nature of how a country or region has developed no matter how it's going. But I am curious with if you guys have thoughts on this, this new diet. And I am 99% vegan and eat plants all day long and whole foods. And that's what I feed my children and things like that.
And that's a lot of what this new diet that's been proposed by all these doctors and nutritionists have said is, we have to, especially in North America, cut our red meat down drastically and increase legumes and things like that and increase grains. I'm curious how those two things intersect, that proposal, which could theoretically, the math adds up reduce agricultural emissions greatly and make people healthier. But at the same time, like you said, those foods that are being proposed are inherently, turns out, a lot less nutritious than either we thought or people know of. I think, Christy, I remember seeing a quote with you that you had that said something along the lines of like, why the hell would I know that my bread is less nutritious than I thought it was?
Why would that occur to us person? So I'm curious on your guys' thoughts on how we make this transition to a new diet that can benefit the world. But at the same time, it's not as fantastic as we thought, nutrition wise. That is a good and complicated question.
Of course, a good diet is not just the cereal crops. It's also fruits, vegetables. There's a range of sources of food from which we get the nutrients that we need. And as Rockley very clearly pointed out, the plants aren't producing those needs because we need them.
It's just the way the plants work. And they're doing the best they can with what they've got. And so number one, as you've pointed out repeatedly, this is a new area. And so it sounds always awkward for a scientist to say this.
We need a lot more research because there is this fundamental understanding of the mechanism. And Rockley was key to laying that out and other people that we work with. But there's also what does it mean in the context of a diverse diet? And are there ways to understand how we can get the kind of nutrition we need from other sources, understanding that those other sources also may be affected by rising CO2, by changing temperature, changing precipitation.
And if the overall quality of our food is declining, then what are our options? You mentioned GMOs. And I will point out that essentially all of our, everything we eat is already genetically modified. Yeah, it's an argument I have more or less every day with people.
But we choose certain things because we like them. They're more robust to the weather patterns. People find them more attractive. They're easier to ship to market.
So we're already selecting for all kinds of characteristics. And can we select for some characteristics that would be beneficial for our health and support the health of the plants? Sure. And that's, I'm curious, and you've talked about how we need a whole lot more research.
And we just mentioned GMOs. And I'm excited because we are working our way towards action here in the ways we can dig ourselves out of this hole. So talking about needing a lot more research, do you feel like there are enough people working on this across the related disciplines? And do you feel like the folks that are working on this are asking the right questions?
Do we know the right questions to ask yet? This is what I love about science. Like you said, it's awkward as a scientist to say we need more research, but that's what's beautiful about science is we're constantly finding out things that we don't know and trying to prove ourselves wrong and things like that. So I'm curious if you feel like we're starting to head down the right path or paths with this.
Well, I'll provide my perspective. I'd really like to hear Iraqis as well. Are we asking the right questions? Yes, we have enough understanding of these basic mechanisms to start asking the right questions.
There is a deep understanding within certainly the climate community that we need to have multiple disciplines at the table. We need to work together and collaborate in ways that historically were relatively rare. The major challenge at the moment is there's pretty much no funding. So this issue's gotten enormous media attention.
I've given a number of interviews. I know, I know, quite a few interviews, no funders contacted me to say, gee, this is really important. So where are you guys getting your funding for the research currently? I volunteered all my time on the paper.
Yeah, I worked on it without funding since, I mean, since originally since 2001. Oh, my grants got rejected. So I actually found that grant writing is so kind of waste on it when I said, okay, what can I do with my just laptop and internet connection that actually made a faster progress. So in regard to these good questions that we ask, as Chris pointed out, we ask the right questions.
And one interesting question in particular is that, we have two problems with nutrition. Is that on one hand, we have obesity and too much calories for some people. And then we have not enough nutrients for others. So under nutrition, mineral under nutrition or micronutrient malnutrition, and obesity are two largest problems in nutrition today.
And what the rising CO2 does, it exacerbates both. So on one hand, it adds these carbs that many people already get in excess. So I believe it contributes to obesity and we don't have a proof of that yet. And on other hand, it decreases all these nutrients globally, essentially almost in all plants.
So it intensifies micronutrient deficiencies. And the question is, and we want to know is, what would be effects on a precise obesity when you end up with empty calories? And I think you refer to Eat Lands at Commission in a recent report where they wanted, they want to shift human diets toward more plants and less meat consumption. And what the recommendation I like is that they say, reduce the consumption of refined sugars and starches.
So this is kind of empty calories. And if you shift toward more nutrient dense foods, then everybody would benefit. But they recommend eating less meat. And recommendations, I have doubts that people will actually switch toward less meats.
And let me explain why. I think subconsciously consciously, people notice that plants become crappier for whatever reason, soil depletion, rising CO2, chase for higher yields. And their bodies just say, hey, you know what, I don't want to eat lettuce, I want to some meat. And we see that as soon as people have access to higher income, they actually, the meat consumption increases.
So while the commissioner recommends doing one thing, I think people will be doing, as a majority of people will be doing another thing. And to combat that really, if we really want to reduce the consumption of meat, then, which will be really beneficial for the environment, we really need to make the plants more nutrient dense. And right now, no farmers paid by the amount of zinc or potassium in grains. They're all paid by the amount of yield.
So they absolutely have no incentive adding any zinc to soil, unless it boosts yields. And what boosts yields is adding nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium, that's it. And that's why all the fields in the world are sprayed by these nutrients, only those three nutrients essentially. And there is an enormous imbalance in the soil that is further exacerbated by increases in CO2.
Hey guys, it's Quinn. If you're listening to this, you obviously like podcasts, and you probably like music too. On Spotify, you can listen to all of that in one place for free. You don't even need a premium account.
On Spotify, you can follow your favorite podcasts. So you never miss an episode. You can download episodes to listen to offline, wherever you might be. And you can easily share what you're listening to with your friends via Spotify's integrations with social platforms like Instagram.
Spotify has a huge catalog of podcasts on every topic, including the one you're listening to right now. You can just search for important, not important, on the Spotify app or browse podcasts, and then you're a library tab, very convenient. And of course, you can follow us, so you never miss an episode of important, not important. Spotify is the world's leading music streaming service.
And now it can be your go to for podcasts too. Yes, and there was news this week about all the small farmers in America who effectively cannot make money anymore. I believe they said the average revenue among, I'm gonna mangle this and we'll put it in the show notes somewhere and I'll correct it at some point. But average revenue among small farmers in America this year was something like negative $1,000.
I think just we were just like, oh, this doesn't work anymore. So inherently it's these huge industrial crops. And of course, in America, we really only grow all these monocrops, which only a small percentage are used for food anyways. But like you said, it's yield, yield, yield.
And again, we do have to grow more food for all of these people. But the incentives seem to be all wrong in light of what we know and what you have so diligently both worked on for free for 20 years. So we're gonna work towards what our listeners can do here, but I guess more. I mean, I would have to get Chris response on this as she's an expert on global health.
I only see like, from my perspective, incentives, you gotta change the incentives. Unless you change those incentives, farmers will keep chasing yields and you can't really blame them. As you said, their profits decline, but the profits of a big ag and the big food industry are increasing and farmers just become little widgets. And they know that essentially forced to dump those chemicals and pesticides and pesticides and synthetic fertilizers.
And if we have, I don't mean its regulations, where you start actually pay farmers for higher quality crops, maybe then things will change, but I would love to hear Chris and answer this. Oh, I have a slightly different perspective I'd like to add. I fully agree with everything that Rockley said. We were part of a paper published last year that looked specifically at Rice.
And concentrations of CO2 you'd expect later in the century if we don't keep emissions under control. And it looked at 18 of the most popular rice lines in Japan and in China. And essentially there were declines for all of the nutrients we're talking about across all the rice lines. Some declined less, some declined a lot more, some of the declines were quite large, as I recall in one of the rice lines, for example, folate, which is associated, a lack of folate is associated with burst effects of up to 30%.
But when you're thinking about whether it's possible to genetically modify if they all decline, that's not gonna be an option. So this is one of the research questions of are there other rice lines, or you don't see such a large decline? Are there other ways that you can try and take what you've got with that genetic code and find ways that you can increase or even just maintain the concentrations of these critical nutrients for our health, even as CO2 rises. So the challenge is difficult.
And Rockley's right, there has to be incentives, there has to be ways to think about how to ensure that what is brought to our grocery store is as nutritious as possible. And you don't wanna do that at the expense of yield. Right, because it's not just take the foot off the pedal with yield, that is imperative. However, we're just producing more and more of less nutritious food.
And again, like you said, the least we can do is try to maintain the nutrition we've got because the air is only gonna get worse for a little while, as far as we can tell. So, all right, as we said at the beginning, what we always try to do is to point our listeners towards actions they can take with their voice, their vote and their dollars, so they can get out there and help kick some ass because it sounds like you guys are not getting really any support despite all the publicity, which is great. So- That's great, we're not getting support. No, I think- Please sense the sarcasm.
Heavy sarcasm. Heavy sarcasm. Usually by this point in this kind of conversation, that's where I try to- It's either that or we're just gonna start yelling in frustration. Or I just start crying on the microphone.
Or crying. I chose sarcasm. So, all right, their voice. One of the overarching goals is really to shine on where we need to go as a people.
So, what are the big actionable questions, specific questions our listeners should be asking of our current representatives? So, basic question is what do we know about the nutritional quality of our food in the United States? And how that could be affected, both by rising carbon dioxide concentrations and also by climate change itself. Because climate change is going to affect where you can grow certain crops.
There's been a lot of publicity around chocolate being affected. I live in the state of Washington and there's lots of discussion here on how hops are gonna be affected. We grow 75% of all the hops that are used in beer in the United States. And so, understand- Okay, if the chocolate and the beer are getting fucked with them.
You heard- And coffee too. And coffee- Half the coffee crops in the world. You don't eat anything else. You forgot to add the pasta.
Oh, God, it's getting worse. And you wonder why I'm sarcastic. Sorry to interrupt, I just- Yeah. Right.
By semi-dear. That's why I mentioned it. It's important for people to realize this is a rough-based issue. And we don't have the fundamental answers to that question.
So, I'm curious, because again, I really want to get specific. So, in areas like Washington, where you're growing 75% of the hops, or in the Central Valley in California, where we're growing most of the nation's fruits and vegetables, where we're currently also out of water, different discussion. So, those are places where listeners can get really specific with their representatives and say, you know, take different texts. It seems like, hey, we're growing 75% of hops and craft beers exploding, and all these things, is it less nutritious?
Is the crop as fortified as it once was? How's that going to affect our economy? How's that going to affect our revenues? Is it going to have to be grown somewhere else?
Does that make sense? I'm trying to point people- Yeah, definitely. And in fact, you know, what we're talking about, it's not in the future. It's already happening.
There are two studies, one by Davis, that showed that the vegetables and fruits in the United States declined, the quality declined in the last several decades. The similar study was done in Britain by Annamari Mayer. And then we have a very recent study by Crane that analyzed data from, again, it's cows. It's a cow poop.
They had this data about the quality of fecal samples going back to 1994. And because their sample size was huge, it was 36,000, these fecal samples data, they detected decline in forage quality to the point that cows are protein stressed. So just over the last 22 years, in CO2 concentrations, you know, increased over the time from 360 parts per million to 410. It's like increased, I don't know, like 14%.
So this is something ongoing. And definitely, you know, we need to ask our representatives what is going on with our food? And what's essential is a large sample size because there is a lot of noise in the system. And if you use a typical sample size of three, you are not going to see that signal.
But it's signaling is there. It's pervasive and it's global. And we need, of course, finding for that. And it's large sample sizes over time.
Right. This is not a one-off. We do it this year, and then we're done. We've got to see how changes happen as our weather changes, as our CO2 changes.
Exactly. It's longitudinal, right trends. And there's a continuous positive data that really out of many, many studies, just few produced data on the quality of nutrient content. So there's tremendous gaps in our knowledge that can be addressed with existing tools.
It just requires a little bit of funding. All right. So I guess that moves into the next two pieces of the question. Right.
So also, you know, their vote, right? What can our listeners do with their vote? Who are your most reliable allies, elected allies out there today, if there are any at all? Well, as we mentioned at the beginning, I did testify yesterday to the House Committee on Science, Space and Technology.
Voting matters. As you noted, it's one of the first hearings on climate science in quite a while. And there's real enthusiasm for talking about climate change and thinking about what needs to be done. So reinforcing that getting out and making sure you vote, if this is important to you, really helps.
One of the things that you'll see in the various media write-ups that are coming across my desk is that in the hearing, essentially every single member, Republican member, started out his statements with something about how he agreed with the climate on the science on climate change. Which is good. Surprising. Yeah.
There's more enthusiasm from the Democrats, as you would expect. But, you know, basically the entire Committee is to Committee on Science, and we're going to talk about the science of climate change and what needs to be done, taking into account. There's going to be winners and losers, and that's going to be a difficult issue to manage and how to do that efficiently and effectively. We're parts of the questions that arose.
And we've got a group of people in the House of Representatives now that want to have those discussions. Well, yeah. I mean, that is a perfectly tangible result of voting folks, is that we get people who've been working somewhat in a vacuum frustratingly for decades on this to actually be able to come and, like you said, be a facilitator to hopefully pass some of that knowledge and hopefully spur some action into people who actually have the power to do something about it. And now we're actually seeing that.
I think I did see somewhere, it literally was a first Committee meeting in like eight years, which is insane. Now we're just going to get people to vote. So what about with their dollar? We talked about incentives.
Hopefully that's something again that we can start to work with on things like the Farm Bill, but what about literally on a day-to-day basis? A certain way is to spend their money, I guess, in two ways. One is commercially. Are there any opportunities to spend their money in the right way?
And two, and again, I would love to get specific on that. And two, similarly, with regard to research or foundation supporting work like yours, because it sounds like grants are more or less nonexistent. Where can we point people? I honestly don't know.
Rockley, Juneau? Where people can be pointed to? In terms of funding, I don't really know because scientists usually go to the government like NSF and NIH for the grants. With respect to how they can spend their dollars, I have this loan, right?
And I see my neighbors using synthetic fertilizers and putting all these herbicides and pesticides. And they take proud if their loan looks like a goldfield. So there is no this little awareness that kills the diversity, that there are no flowers there, it's just a grass. And that reduces the source of food for pollinators.
And we know that bees are declining. So on this local level, I mean, why not to have more natural loans, right? And stop supporting this big chemical industry that essentially promotes using these synthetic fertilizers and chemicals. Supporting organic foods would help as well.
And there is already movement where people start to grow more local foods and some restaurants start to gather towards that. To work more sustainably raised products. So these day to day decisions, I think they do have an effect. I read yesterday that there is more acreage in the United States devoted to lawns than to any single crop.
I read that same thing. It's like an insane amount of acreage. More than any crop in the world. Yeah, that was a wild stat.
And the amount of chemicals that dump into it and then these lawn machines and they take proud in that, somehow they identify it. And some way, at least in my neighborhood, the goodness with how good your lawn looks. And really, I mean, nobody plays soccer on that or golf. So, you know, this is some decision that everybody can make.
So yeah, that's a good point, Chris. And stepping back a bit, the fundamental issue that we're talking about is rising CO2 in the atmosphere. And if we can stop that rise, keep that rise from going much too quickly, we will see a benefit for our nutrition in the long run. Because we won't have such severe changes in the nutritional quality of our food like we've been talking about.
So a fundamental issue is thinking about how to reduce your own greenhouse gas emissions. Everything from being more efficient when you do errands, go out and do them all at once, instead of going out and back, you know, planning how you're using those greenhouse gases you're going to burn. Right. And I want to point one thing as, you know, Chris mentioned this rising CO2 levels and what we can do about them.
Very often critics of this view of declining crop quality say, look, we increase CO2 in greenhouses deliberately. And we get this, you know, last time I ate greenhouse food from the greenhouse, nothing happened to me. So, you know, stop this, all of them is crap and, you know, a little drop of nutrient doesn't make big difference. And what they're really missing.
And I'm frustrated that even the experts in these areas in terms of plants, they're missing is the scale. So yes, you can't raise plants in high CO2 in controlled environments such as greenhouses, where you also in the rich soil. There's no problem with that. I love food from greenhouses.
But the problem is that all around the world, we're increasing CO2 only. We don't add zinc, potassium, magnesium to our soils. And the issue is the scale. It's not something that eight time drop one time in my bowl of cereal.
I wouldn't give a, you know, a dime about it. It's a thing is that it's every day with every plant that you eat for the rest of your life. Doesn't matter what plant you eat, you switch from a salad to something else to different crops. It's everywhere.
Almost all minerals are declining. And what is cumulative effect that is scaring me? And it's a really the issue of scale, just like with weather, right? If the temperature today is three degrees higher, I don't care.
But if the temperature is three degrees higher all around the globe, we have a problem. Sure. Sure. There's a wonderful writer from the New York Times who wrote when everyone was getting angry about the polar vortex and things like this and are just incredible.
President was tweeting about how if the weather is so cold, how could there be climate change and she made wonderful analogy to, again, weather is not climate, you know, effectively saying, I'm not going to mangle it, but we'll put in the show notes, you know, weather is what you wear every day and climate is what you keep in your closet. Right. And saying, you know, there aren't a lot of Floridians, they might have to wear coats today, but they don't have a closet full of coats. Right.
Because that's how climate works. So let me ask one last question before we get to the end here and I can't thank you guys enough for your time. So like you said, you're in a hard time coming up with places where they can really focus their money because most of the grants come from national science and things like that. What does a typical, let's say you were to go out for a grant for this research, how much are we talking about?
What is not, what are you guys looking for? What would enable this research? Not obviously the biggest number in the world or the smallest, but what would get this going? Just so people have an idea.
A Rockley and I worked on a proposal that was unsuccessful. All of our proposals have been unsuccessful. And we were asking over several years for several million dollars, a Rockley. I don't recall the total at the moment.
Right. Yeah. Right. The welcome trust proposal was running.
Yes. Somewhere like a million or two, but you know, I did some work without money at all. So in this case, even a little bit money just going to conferences would have helped and spread the word. But for example, we specifically, one of the proposals we applied was to generate new data in a very efficient way, high throughput way.
And that was costing renting greenhouses and so on. It was only costing several hundred thousand dollars for like two years. Right. But let me step back.
There was more than a decade ago. There was concern when the first nanoparticles emerged and there was concern about their health issues. And the National Academy of Sciences put together some expert panel to take a look at what kind of investment should we make? And I don't recall the exact number, but it was somewhere around the range of at the level of the federal government for extramural research of 150 to 200 million dollars per year.
And those are the kinds of numbers that are typical when you see an issue that's important in which you need to make investment. And yes, it is a big number, but it's a really big problem as well. Yeah. When researchers on four continents are saying, Hey, all of the food in the whole fucking world is not as hell.
It's like not as good for you as it should be anymore. How does nobody give you any money? Because that's the way it is right now. I mean, I don't know how it is.
Yeah, I just my mind is blown. Yeah, it's the reality. But when you think of the level of ambition in the National Institutes of Health, when we had the outbreak of Zika, they came forward and said we're going to invest a couple hundred million dollars into developing a vaccine. Right.
Which is necessary. However, you know, again, what do the two things we can do with that food and water? Yeah. Pretty huge deal.
Okay. Well, that. Okay. All right.
We're going to continue to work and talk to you guys about that on our end. Not saying anyone can move mountains, but there's got to be, there's got to be fixes to this. Okay. We're getting close to time here.
Brian is just seething on the couch over here. I just don't cannot thank you both enough for your time today and everything else you have done in the past 20 years, 20 years, 20 years. Is there anyone else you can think of that we should talk to on this subject or other subjects that are, again, pertinent to the survival of everybody? Anybody you recommend?
We can mention them now or we can talk about it offline, but we always love recommendations from our guests. Like I think as Chris mentioned, Louis, this got did amazing work. And I mean, as a government employee, I'm not sure if he would be allowed, but if he is, that would be really great to talk to him. And then also Max Tao did some work in Texas.
He did the work of showing that the protein declines in edible parts of crops. And Rockley, who's doing the work with a cows? Right. So, a crane, Joseph, does it and it's an interesting guy.
I think he made money on some genetic kind of, something related to genetics. He has his own company. And so I think he plants his own research, which is really admirable. So, right, Joseph Crane.
And I think his adventure is called Jonah Ventures. And it's in Kansas, one heaven Kansas. And when you do talk to Louis, Luke, and talk to you as a federal employee, he's also done really interesting work on issues like ragweed and how that's getting worse with climate change. Poison Ivy, which is also getting worse with climate change.
And the climate inequality also, Luke showed that the protein and pollen declines by 30% because of rising CO2 specifically. And so that would affect the bees. So Dr. Ziska says this can comprehensive you what CO2 does to plants.
That's a good one. I would love to dig into bees. Yeah. Yeah.
All right. Well, those are helpful. And again, if you have anybody else, please send them all our way. Brian, you want to bring it home here?
Yeah, Kristi and Rachley, it's time for the lightning round, which is not a lightning round. But Quinn's going to ask you some questions and the answers are going to be wonderful. And then we'll let you guys get out of here. When was the first time in your life when you realized you had the power of change or the power to do something meaningful?
I've had the privilege of being involved in national and international assessments for 20 years. And of as a participant in those of assessing the body of literature to come up with policy relevant recommendations. And then certainly in the international sphere of seeing governments actually take some of those recommendations up seriously discussing them, talking about what they could do. It's a lot of work.
It's all volunteer work. And it's really rewarding to see that governments then consider that in their policies and their programs. Yeah. I mean, for me, when I was writing this paper on the linking CO2 to human nutrition, I was concerned about that.
That might potentially affect everybody. So I was really hoping to publish that paper and thought that that way could affect that. That was one of the most meaningful things back in 2002. Sounds pretty good to me.
You guys are making change. For each of you, who is someone in your life that has positively impacted your work in the past six months? Well, I would mention both Chris and Dr. Ziska really because my grants were rejected.
And I really got depressed about the whole situation that it wasn't really getting traction. Some ecologists were publishing papers saying that there's actually qualities not dropping, which later were withdrawn those papers. So yeah, and then you know, Lou reached me and asked me to help with this governmental report. And then it took from there.