Good morning, afternoon, or evening. Please delete as appropriate. Hello there and welcome to this episode number. Don't you love it when it's like a multiple of 25? Episode 575 of the material podcast. I'm Andy Notco. With us is Florence Ion as every week. Hey, Flo, how you doing? You know, I love multiples of 25. It reminds me of counting money. Kind of, yeah. It's not worthy of a cake, but had I planned ahead, I could have thought, you know what? The bakery also makes these nice little cupcakes. And so I could have bought like one of those individual cupcakes. It is cupcake season. Yeah. It is. I would also say though, it's ice cream season, like heavily ice cream season. Yeah. I just want to say ice cream cake also counts.
Yeah, actually, that's a problem because I don't know how my market gets such incredible discounts on Haagen-Dazs and Ben & Jerry's. But every now and then, each of these $6 a pint premium ice creams is like 50% off. And it doesn't happen frequently enough that I need to institute a rule about like, oh, let's make sure we, hey, we had ice cream a couple weeks ago, so let's not. It happens rarely enough that I should take advantage of it, but I'm still like, but you're going to eat an entire pint of ice cream as a treat because it was like three weeks since the last one. But the thing is, it's like, again, it's Ben and Jerry's, which I don't normally buy. And I've already sort of stopped going to the nice ice cream store that's kind of in the neighborhood because it's like I mentioned a couple of times where when prices go up, not an enormous amount, but just like that $1.50 or $2, that's enough to say, you know what? Again, I've got a fridge full of food and snacks like five minutes away from this ice cream store. I really shouldn't be spending $7.50 on an ice cream cone. But it means that, oh, it means that when I have an opportunity to have a little bit more than that of ice cream for $3, and it is.
It is the Jerry Garcia. It's not like the, it's not like those like big, huge, like half gallon tubs. That's mostly air. It is like, it's like, not only is it like crumbled up bits of cookie, but it's like name brand cookie. Like you would eat this cookie if it were separated from the ice cream. So yeah. So that is the temptation. Every time I go in saying, you know what? Today, I think I'm just going to get like maybe a little tub of hummus and some pita crackers. And I'll just like, I had kind of a large-ish one. And then I see this big, big, big, big, big, big, big case full of Haagen-Dazs for $2.99. And I'm like, or we get the caramel, salted caramel cone ice cream and have that for dinner. Only like 2,812 calories. But hey, it's summer.
It is summer. Exactly. They don't count the calories you eat at night. Don't count there. Just treat calories. I have to say, I really do agree with you that if the cookie in the ice cream sandwich is bad, it ruins the entire experience, which unfortunately there are some franchise opportunities available that.
do not have good cookies as part of their operations. It's quite sad because if the cookie's not good, what's the point? Exactly. There's no point. Just give me the ice cream. And you love the sense of pride that says that I know that the cookie is not the highlight. It's not the star of this show. Nonetheless, we are going to spend on decent cookies as opposed to like, you know, the veterinarian grade cookies that like they make for prisons and other places like that. And for like, I was going to say, you know, even a Costco cookie would be great in there because they, you know, Costco uses those big, beautiful chunks. So.
You know, I love desserts, by the way. I love desserts and I love to pick out on desserts in the summertime. And I don't care who knows it. And I have to be quite honest with you that I've also been saving money on ice cream by getting my daughter two scoops that she's not going to finish and finishing the rest of it off. So I'm being economical. Yeah. See, that's too bad because I know that it costs a lot of money to run any brick and mortar business. Okay. But wouldn't it be great if that ice cream store sold taste?
for like three or four dollars you could get just like a tasting flight like not full scoops but like i just want to taste these four flavors so like a little like golf ball sized like scoop of ice cream but the thing is like no they can only they can only profit if they sell you like a more than reasonable quantity at one shot when actually well and now it's it's seven dollars a scoop that's like that there's a report this week in the bay area and local news that was like it's seven dollars for a scoop of ice cream like what's happened yeah um so it's a it's it's a bit of a bummer but i i do but i do have like my my one guilt-free summer treat is uh So the neighborhood like Dollar General has bagged ice for only $2 in a market where it's normally like three and a half, $4. And that means that like I've basically told myself that anytime you want to buy a huge bag of party ice, you're completely allowed to do so. You don't even have to think about it. Go and get that bag of ice and then bring it home and then get the like one liter insulated cup, the tumbler that you got at the Amazon Prime Day, pack it full of ice and then pour whatever it is you're drinking into that and just enjoy mind.
bangingly cold beverage on a moderately hot, but not punitively hot day. Oh my gosh. Coca-Cola over that kind of ice. Oh yeah, absolutely. Well, I know what I'm going to do this weekend to satiate the summer vibes. Thank you. I'm going to get a giant Coca-Cola with, uh,
Anyway, what do we got going on this week? I feel like there's been a lot of, there's been things going on this week, but because we had the holiday, it's also been really quiet. Even out here, the freeways have been quiet. Yeah, it honestly is. Like I said, I actually deliberately put just some minor stuff on the show, Doc, because there isn't anything to get really, really worked up about or anything that seems incredibly important. So there's just some stuff that might be fun to talk about, including the fact that Google has announced the Made by Google event for August. Surprisingly. Yeah, for a week early, earlier than normal, August 12th in New York City. We'll talk about that.
250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. A fun video promoting Google's services that is themed to Independence Day that did not go down great with a lot of people. We'll talk about that as well. And let's see what else here. Also, if we get to it.
Well, it turns out that Google might be liable for the lies that its AI tells people. Oops. I mean, who knew? Apparently that's a thing, holding people accountable for telling lies to people who come to an important international digital resource looking for the reassurance of well-founded facts. But we'll figure all of that out. But before we figure that all out, let's give a thanks and a shout out to all of our members out there who helped to support our show by giving us a little bit every month and maybe a little bit every year. Really, really wonderful. We are so thankful for you guys. Somewhat thankful that, of course, we do a special bonus episode each and every week. And if you are a member of, you're not just a member of our show, you're a member of all of Relay. So you get access to all of the special content that all the Relay podcasters and producers produce just for Relay supporters. We also do a special, annual special special, which we haven't figured out what we're going to do yet, but it's going to be special. Not just special, but special special. Because as special...
be special, special, special, because we try to make every episode special. Every bonus episode has to be special, special, because it has to be different from the ordinary special. If we're doing something once a year, there is some pressure to add that third layer of specialness. So again, much like a premium ice cream, we get a really good French vanilla, then you add salted caramel, then you add peanut butter cups. That's a special, special, special ice cream. So that's what we're going to figure out.
We'll come up with something. But to get in on all that fun, if that sounds like fun, go to relay.fm slash material, and that's where you'll be able to sign up for that kind of fun. You'll also get access to our show notes, links to the stories we're talking about today, and stuff like that. Okay, we're going to take a break. I actually do have the big insulated tumbler packed full of ice with some lemonade in it. I will be drinking lustily and heavily from that during our break, and then when we come back, let's talk about the launch event for the Pixel 11.
Well, Google did send out invites for their annual Made by Google event, which is where they're going to be launching the Pixel 11 series and probably a new version of the Pixel Watch. Maybe Pixel Buds. We don't know. But lots of stuff that they built. It's actually tangible as opposed to ethereal, which is the AI stuff. Although it's probably going to be AI heavy. It's happening in New York City just like last year. Unlike last year, it is happening at 6 p.m. Eastern time as opposed to late morning. I don't know what that means. I'm trying to figure it out. That's dinner time. That's dinner time, right?
For most people. And New York is a very sweet city. In America. Yeah. Unless you're in Spain. I know dinner time's at like 8.30 there, but yeah. Ooh, that's right. So we could have like a New York dinner and then two and a half hours later, like Iberian ham. Correct, correct, correct. With some Prosecco or something. Oh, yummy. Oh, kava. Oh, God. What are we doing on the podcast? We could be having... I know, I know, I know. But yeah, now first of all, I did take the time to do a little bit of investigation.
I don't know. I could not find out, however, whether or not the Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon is dark that week or whether they're airing new episodes. If they're airing new episodes, the fact that this show happens at 6 p.m. would make it unlikely that Jimmy Fallon will be back to host this event as he did last year. So we're still on watch. However, I believe that in a few weeks' time, we'll keep our thumb on this because in a few weeks' time, they'll probably start publishing the show rundowns for August. We should know whether it's going to be safe to tune in without exposure to Jimmy Fallon if you have a Jimmy Fallon allergy. I'm not saying that you shouldn't. That he's a deal breaker.
But he did make it weird last year. Yes, he did. And he continues to make it weird. I don't think he's coming back. So this week I was on Android Faithful and Jason Howell did say, he's like, what if it's Colbert?
because it's like a night show. And I was like, you know what? I love that. Let's just, let's just think about that because of Colbert though. That's because we like Colbert, you know, as a person more than just a lay down entity, which he no longer is. Anyway, that's, I don't think there is a, we did look, there is no poly market for who is going to be hosting this made by Google event. I will tell you that I am not going. So it's a very interesting, yes. The people that were invited.
We're very top of the list, just to say. I'm just going to say that. Maybe in terms of visibility, I should say. Okay. Yeah, I'm in a... And I'm saying that because I notice it being a strategy. That's all I want to say by saying it that way. Yeah. I mean, I've been at this for like several decades. So I have to remind myself that even... You have God bless you. Thank you very much. I feel blessed sometimes. Not if I spent Amtrak money to go attend a Google event and I had to go be confronted by Jimmy Fallon. I would not feel blessed. But nonetheless, the...
I have to remind myself that even in the olden days where... The people who got invited to these events were exclusively members of the press and, like, members of, like, the ink-stained wretches, mostly, press, where if it was someone with a blog who was not associated with, like, a TV show or a newspaper or a magazine, that would have been unusual, okay? And even if I were inclined, which I am not, to say that, oh, their standards are, no, they don't care about getting the information out through the press. It's about, you know, attracting social media influencers. The thing is, like, it is the same thing, okay? Their point is to, it is a PR thing, where the thing is, like, we were, as the technology columnist for the Chicago Sun-Times, I was the point.
of access between Google and a quarter million people in the Chicagoland area. They weren't inviting me because I was committed to truth and justice and perfection of clarity of thought. It was because, again, they could get the message out to this specific targeted 300,000 people. And it's the exact same thing right now. Now they need to get out to a targeted of people who watch creator videos about Ibiza looks. Excuse me, Andy. It's pronounced Ibiza. Thank you.
I always have to correct myself because even growing up, I would keep hearing people say Barthelona. And I'm like, oh, that's just offensive. You're making fun of the Spanish accent. Like, no, that is actually how it's supposed to be pronounced. I actually am. I just want everybody to know that when I say it, I am making fun of a British person trying to say it, which probably isn't better. And I just want to apologize because I know there's a lot of international folks here on the network. I'm talking about The Only Way is Essex. That's the show I'm talking about. All right, continue. We can also be making fun of...
People who like make a show of over, like white people who make a show of overpronouncing. Overpronouncing, correct. Ah, yes, I had a time in Barcelona last weekend. Like, okay. It's the only word you know in that accent. Iberia ham, or as they call it, erbeta ham. Again, I think that you're just trying to show off. It's like politicians who have a battle for how big of a flag pin can I have on my lapel. It's like you're just trying to – that's fine. I'm actually in kind of an odd position because I had already booked some travel that week that was going to have me in New York City starting Thursday, not Wednesday. And so now I don't know what I want to do. Not that if I made – I did not receive an invitation. I'm wondering what would happen if I –
If I pitch and say, oh, by the way, I'm going to be in New York City and, you know, for God's sakes, how great am I and how well would it reflect upon you if I chose to attend your event? It's just like if I could turn this, what was going to be mostly, actually almost entirely, a social visit to some friends of mine in New York City to, oh, wait a minute, I can write off this. Write some of it off. I can write off this trip to the Samtrak ticket. Also, it would be a little bit galling because normally these events start at 10 a.m., which means that I can either take like the 5-something a.m. train and be absolutely dead for lack of sleep.
arriving on time, or I can book a hotel room and spend like $230 just so I can like be there that early in the morning. And here's the one where, no, no, no, you could just, you know, you could just like, you know, slide in, have a good night's sleep and then come in, like arrive at like four o'clock. Get yourself one of those really super, super wonderful donuts that they get in almost everywhere in New York city. Go to that Japanese pen store. That's a, that's near the Republic library. And then stretch your legs a little bit, yawn, check your watch and decide that perhaps you will drop in on the made by Google thing. Anyway, it would, it would bum me out though if I got there and it really was like, like last year's event, which was just like really, really not.
information heavy at all um also uh of course and you're surrounded by the way people by people you don't know i'm noticing more and more that uh like my listen a little inside baseball my briefings definitely know the folks that i'm there with because usually they they kind of like separate folks out based on the kind of content they're taking. But when you go to the event is when you really see the full pool of who was contacted for this event. And yes, I am also getting older, but also it's been interesting seeing the changing tide. It is. It always is. Yeah, definitely. Or at least I'm glad that they've adapted more than they used to because there was a transitional period in which it was like...
Honestly, I need to file something in 90 minutes. Really, I just need 10 minutes holding this device so I can check out a few things and get a few original photos. But I can't because there's like 80, hey guys, this is Jeff, the tech guy with an exclusive review of the hands-on. No, you're not. You're one of like 100 people in the scrum in this demo room and you're trying desperately to blur out the background so people don't know exactly how many people are around you at this moment. But now they realize that, okay, we're going to have studio space for all these hands-on things. So we'll find things out. Also, we're close enough to the launch that a lot of the rumors that have been floating around about what the...
2026 hardware is going to look like is Solid enough that you might want to believe it. It doesn't look like there's going to be anything revolutionary about the Pixel 11 Pro or the Pixel 11, for that matter. There's some pricing rumors from the European markets. Of course, they get the ads and that stuff early. That imply that we're going to see $100 price hikes across the board. So entry-level Pixel 11 Pro XL, which is the one that I would normally be targeting, would be $1,299, $1,099 for a Pixel Pro, and $899 for a Pixel 11. And for that price, they're jacking up the minimum storage from 128 gigs to 256 gigs.
If they only managed to raise the price by a hundred bucks, I think that would be a relief to a lot of people who are very, very, very, very much aware of the rampocalypse. Um, it would still be punishing to spend $12.99 for a pixel for a phone though, or at least for me, it would. You're telling me, I don't know if I'm going to upgrade this year, especially out, you know, I've already talked a lot about how disappointed I am with the camera. I haven't made my scientific reasoning for why I'm so sorry. I haven't exactly had time, but, uh, but you know, I've been thinking a lot about it and this I'm exhausted too. I'm just exhausted by paying for all this stuff. I mean, sincerely. Yeah, it really is. And because like, uh,
I just spent, again, $2,200 on a new MacBook. By the way, this is our first episode recording with the MacBook Pro M5. Muzzle. So I've got not only twice as much system memory, but also four more M's to play with. So I don't know if you're noticing an increase in quality, but that's, I'm already- I do know an increase in M's. Again, that's like five times as many M's, okay? I mean, I don't know why this is not like the top story in the development of the episode. Exactly, it's wonderful. So, yeah, so I'm in that boat where it's like, I mean, I-
The thing is, I'm so surprised at how well I'm getting away with not just having the Pixel 7 Pro, which was my backup phone, but because it was my backup phone, it only has 128 gigs of storage. And I'm getting away with it just fine. I'm just like, it's like, I know that at some point, and the thing is, I know that this is going to get, of course, this gets Android 17. It's already got Android 17. It'll probably also get Android 18. And at this point, I'm like, I'm going to start.
budgeting for like a new flagship phone sometime in the next 12 months. But I really think that the trigger for it is not going to be, Hey, wow, I've got a five-year-old phone and now the new ones are out. The trigger is going to be what AI feature has Google rolled out for the pixels that I really, really don't think I can live without that I can't use on my pixel seven. Yeah. I mean, listen, once they gave me the pixel snap, that's it. I don't really need anything else. Like my life is perfect. Not really. I will say, I will say.
that the summer heat, just like as a total side note, the summer heat, and especially because I was just in the East Coast a couple days ago, and it's been moderately temperate here in lovely Northern California for now. And, you know, this heat comes on, it reminds you, these things are so powerful. They're so great, these devices. They really should not be out in the sun. Yeah. They really shouldn't. Oh, yeah. On the 4th of July, I went to the beach on the 4th of July. As it happened, I wound up not going into the water because everybody was at the beach, even at the town beach, which is, you need a parking permit proving that you actually,
are a resident of the town to use this beach. So it's usually, even when it's busy, it's not really that busy. Of course, this is the, of course, July 4th, so a lot of people are there. And they're also hanging out there, like they're almost like pitching a camp because it was like a civil war encampment because of course the fireworks are going to be launching from a barge, like just off, just off the beach. So a lot of people were like, even at noon, they were setting up these big, big, complicated compounds sort of things. So they could like sit there for like nine hours. So I didn't go into the water. That's one of the nice things about living within walking distance. It's like, you know what? There are people here who absolutely desperately need to like have the full beach experience because they have kids. They don't, they don't, they're not self-employed. This is going to be like, they're big. They might not be able to get back
another month. So they got to do this. I'm like, you know what? I can go back. I can go back to the beach in two or three days when it's not quite so busy. So I was sitting on, I was sitting on a bench. I've had my book to read and my phone was inside my bag. It wasn't like exposed to the light. It was inside my bag. And when I took it out like half hour later, just to take a couple of snapshots of the, of the fireworks barge, it was already saying, yeah, there's some features are not gonna be working because this, the system is way, way too hot. I'm like, Oh dear. So yeah, that's, I would, I suppose that one of the benefits of when I do finally upgrade is that it will have a modern, modern like vapor cooling system or something like that. Um, but let's, uh, let's keep talking about, uh,
What we have to look forward to. Yeah, so the rumors are that we're going to see basically not even physically it's going to change that much. There's the usual like teaser sort of image on the invite that makes it look like essentially it's a gold shape of the edge of a phone, but it doesn't look like it's materially different. Premium. It's supposedly premium. Exactly. Sorry, it's just the gold. You know what I mean? Yeah. One thing that is kind of nice is that.
The rumor about those pixel glow lights, a ring of LEDs maybe around the camera bump that can tell you that can A, either just be fun or B, give you notifications or tell you something about the state of the thing. I'm not saying that that would make me spend $12.99 on a new phone next month, but oddly enough, it would get my interest. I'm a big fan of those things. I think it's a bit of flash and a bit of actual... I don't know, simple analog user interface that communicates things to you even when you're not actually using the phone that, I don't know, I dig that kind of thing. Also, maybe looking for a Pixel Watch 5 probably, which is also rumored to have some kind of price increase. Don't know if they're going to be new Pixel Buds, but okay, this will also be a good place to introduce new Pixel Buds. I finally gave up on the Pixel Buds A that I got for free with my Pixel 6 Pro.
They're still working fine. The first gen? The very first gen? It was a free promo if you pre-ordered the phone. At that point, I already knew that, okay, I don't care. I've got a four or five-year-old phone. I'm going to pre-order it. It was working fine. I don't know what happened either to the earbuds or maybe the shape of my ear canal or something. In the left earbud...
there is some sort of a port, like some sort of opening, like in the shape of the thing that goes into your ear that when it gets blocked, it sounds really, really muffled. So I think it's something, I don't know what's going on there. So I have, so I would have to sort of balance it carefully in my ear so I could actually hear anything out of it. And if I, cause if I put it in there like deep and secure, so I replaced it with a $40 pair of like really, really cheap, like their name brand something, but they are like just cheap earbuds. I want to see like how good in 2026, like a cheap $40 pair of earbuds would be. And they're actually really, really good. I don't miss them.
I think the best feature of them, I think their Beats earbuds, I think their best feature is that if I were to lose them, which I... It's amazing I still have both of my Pixel Buds A because every single other pair of Bluetooth earbuds I've had, I've lost. But basically, if something were to happen to these $40 earbuds, I would say, oh, and A, and A. But then I'd get over it and maybe buy a new pair. As opposed to if I spent $200 or $300 on AirPods Pro, I'd be like, ah, damn it, damn it. You'd be so solemn. You'd be walking the subway at night just trying to find meaning in your life after everything that happened. I get it. I get it. It would be one of these things where I'd have to be a good pair to myself.
And I'd say, oh, no, no, I know it sucks to not have wireless earbuds, but son, you can't just simply buy, I can't just buy you new earbuds every time you lose the old pair. I'm afraid that at least until Black Friday sales, hopefully there'll be a discount. You're just going to have to use the wired earbuds instead. Sometimes you've got to pair it yourself. Exactly. Otherwise, I will never learn.
Let's see. Lastly, there's also in lesser not buying expensive phones news, there's a Samsung event, Samsung Unpacked event. There's several of these, of course, through the course of the year on July 22nd. Announced after, by the way, the Pixel event, which was surprising for us. I wonder if they coordinate those things. I don't think they did, Andy. I don't think they did. I'm just going to say that. Okay. That's all. All we're going to see there is the Z Fold 8. That's a $2,000 phone that I'm not going to be buying. And the Samsung Watch 9, which I also probably am not going to be buying. But again, if that interests you.
It's going to be fun. Actually, one of the interesting things is that they might be showing off. Now, because Samsung is manufacturing the folding screens for the upcoming folding iPhone that's coming out in September, so now they are actually using... I don't know if those exact same screens or maybe just the engineering that they paid for to engineer those screens for Apple. So they're apparently coming out with a new edition of the Z Fold that is, instead of being the big, like tall and narrow unfolded one, it's going to be like a passport style book fold, like the upcoming iPhone, which is kind of interesting. I like that form factor. I just don't know if it's different enough from an existing phone to make me want to buy it. I was just going to say, I think it's supposed to have stylus support. I don't know. Supposedly it's going to be amazing for productivity. I'm sure. Because that's what everybody's thinking about right now is how to get work done the fastest. Exactly.
How to get worked on the fastest and avoid being recorded by someone's hidden Ray-Ban glasses. Okay. We're going to be talking about some more stuff. We're going to talk about our founding fathers after this break. So stick around.
Well, we already talked about how we spent our July 4s. Google spent, well, they released a video that, like I said in the intro, has gone over not well with some people. People had feelings about this. So they did, of course, because it is the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence, Google decided that they should give it a sense of occasion. So they created a video about what would this all be like if...
The founding fathers had access to Google tools, Google Workspace, Google Chat, of course, Gemini, Nano Banana, that sort of stuff. So they reimagined the drafting and the signing of the Declaration of Independence that way. And I mean, have you seen it? I actually have not. I successfully stayed off the internet over, I know you did link it. I'm just going to hop over to it now. That's okay. While you're checking it out. It's cute, more or less, where it starts off with Thomas Jefferson has just finished writing the Declaration of Independence, the first draft at longhand. And then Ben Franklin messages him saying, how's it coming along? And he takes a picture of it with his phone and it automatically gets translated into a Google Doc as plain text. And then now we're in Google Workspace where John Adams and Ben Franklin have been shared with the document and now they're adding their own edit points, their own comments.
John Adams changes inalienable to unalienable, which is a good inside joke for Declaration of Independence fans. That's an actual thing that happened. He decided that they'd actually mean the same thing, but he decided that, no, no, no, that's not inalienable. It's unalienable. Then, of course, Gemini helps the committee schedule a meeting with the rest of the Continental Congress to debate about it. There's a Google Meet group chat to talk about it. John Adams, embarrassingly enough, is on mute, which, from what we know about John Adams, seems unlikely. There's an entire song in the musical 1776 about...
oh my God, will this guy just shut up already? Just shut up, sit down, be quiet, be quiet, be quiet. Oh my God. So I don't know, maybe that was an in-joke. I don't know. Another piece of little bit humor there where King George requests access to the group Google Doc. Somebody asks Gemini about how they should proceed and Gemini advises that they decline to allow King George to see the group Doc as they're developing this. Ben Franklin, who famously was advocating not the eagle, but the turkey as the national bird, uses a nano banana to create a great seal of the United States featuring the turkey as the national bird. It looks like it was AI generated.
I mean, all in all, it's cute. It could have been worse. They could have done a lot more with AI. Yeah, I was going to say. Yeah, exactly. The thing is, I first heard about it, not because I'm subscribed to the Google YouTube channel, but because so many commentators were up in arms about it. Like, I think The Verge had, I'm sorry they didn't cut and paste it into the doc, but like, oh God, it's horrible. It's terrible. Oh God, it's such garbage. And I'm like, oh my God, they did like, were they stupid? Was Google stupid enough to have like Gemini, the founding Thomas Jefferson, just like.
prompt Gemini to create, to hear all of our objections to the rule under Parliament and King George, please write us a declaration. And of course, the joke that I came up with is that the problem with AI, famously, of course, is that because it's been trained mostly with content that's available on the internet, it shows a bias of... white males who are from a position of economic privilege, which when you think about it, would have been spot on for the authors of the actual Declaration of Independence. So absolutely accurate there. But no, it was very, very, again, very, very light touch. It was more about Google Workspace and collaborative tools than artificial intelligence. But I think it just comes to show you exactly how people... I think that Google...
thinks that people love Gemini and AI a lot more than they actually do. That as soon as, it's like MSG. Do they think that or are they trying to really push it? Because the thing about MSG is, I feel like you're about to go into a metaphor about MSG. I like MSG. It's what makes Romanian food taste good. Right.
Gemini is a little different. But what I meant was that as soon as people hear that, oh, there's MSG in this, a lot of people will reject it. Oh, I don't want MSG in it. But you didn't taste it. You don't know what role MSG. It actually is a really good flavor enhancement. It's actually completely safe. And the public...
The urban legends against MSG are largely racist from the 50s and 60s. They're trying to make people not be interested in Asian cuisine. You raise a good question. I think they realize that they have to sell AI to people. At the same time, I really do think that they are so in love with their own creation that they underestimate people's public reaction to the use of AI. I feel like they're really just trying to...
paint it that color and then just say, like, hey, it's always been this way. This is just the way things are done. That's what I feel through a lot of this. I also feel like it's tough, you know, seeing that they're putting together, like, are we talking about a phone or are we talking about AI? You know what I mean? Yeah. We're supposed to be talking about hardware and that sort of thing. And instead, we're talking about what the blowback is going to be post the event. And maybe that's something that Google should take into consideration.
Yeah, I think it feels like the off switches for AI should be a lot more prominent everywhere. As long as people feel as though they have enough control over it, they might distrust it less. I see what you're saying. Right, right, right. Because I feel that way through my own experiences. The more that I have learned to use AI and what it does and what it's capable of and where it falters and where it really helps, I'm not afraid of it. I'm just like, okay, yeah, this is what you use it for. This and this and that. Yeah, it's like...
As a matter of fact, another story this week was that Google announced that they are putting in flags so that people can see when an ad was created with the use of AI. So to give people that sort of knowledge that, okay, this was, oddly enough, this terrible, terrible, terrible promotional ad for something that is just nothing but psychedelic colors in 3D with every single piece of text leaping out at you with all kinds of filigree filling every single, oddly enough, this was not created by hand. They did not pay somebody $8,000 and give them three weeks to design this. It was actually just a prompt. So as long as people get informed about it, it gives them at least the illusion of more control, even though obviously the dangerous stuff is so deeply buried, they'll never be able to figure it out. I've been reading about – I'm getting ready to write my review of the Fitbit Air and the new Google Health app. And the good – people who don't like the health coach, the AI-powered – like Gemini AI-powered health coach.
They have to be told like on Reddit, oh, well, actually you can turn it off. And that's, of course, that's always like the good answer is saying, well, if you don't like it, it's just a feature you can turn it off. But the thing is, there's not like a big, there's not like a big master switch. You really have to dig down into the settings to find out where you can actually disable this thing. And that's probably, that's why I think that.
I do think that Google has more faith that people – all we got to do is we got to just get people to keep trying it and make it difficult for them not to try it because as soon as they try it, they're going to love it. So we're going to keep them from making a mistake that they're going to regret. We're going to make sure that they have access to all this wonderful stuff because if we just give them a big switch in Chrome or their Google account that simply says never expose me to any AI tools whatsoever, my gosh, they're going to be sorry about that years later when actually – yeah, that's actually what I want to do. I don't want my Google search results to have AI inflections about it because sometimes AI lies to me about it. Which is a good transition to our last story. So wacky stuff happening in the German course. Wacky. Spirit fingers. It's a little bit nutty over there. Again, they're holding Google responsible for lies told and malicious information spread by Google's AI overviews in search. So this happened a few weeks ago. So Google lost a very, very big anti-defamation suit in Germany. They were sued by two different German publishers because AI overviews, when people did a Google search about these two publishers asking, hey, what's the reputation of these two publishers?
AI overviews was screwing up and confusing them with other publishers who were very, very well known for kind of scamming subscribers and having really, really sketchy sales techniques. And not only that, but the AI overview was making up out of whole cloth, like, you know, facts that weren't found in any of the actual search results that were below the overview. And so, of course, these two publishers said, we're upset about this. We kind of like them to knock that off and seek redress, so to speak. Google defended themselves. They said, hey, it's perfectly okay that our AI overviews are spreading hallucinated malicious.
lies about honest organizations. First of all, they cited the usual reflex, which as well, Google search is usually safe from lawsuits that are related to the accuracy of contents of search results because, hey, all we're doing is we're just surfacing content that's already been published elsewhere. And that's, of course, true when it comes to actually- We're just surfacing it. We can actually produce it. We're taking the crap from the bottom of the seabed, like in the muck and the mire. We're just exposing it to air where people can now see it. Yeah, we're just sifting it.
Yeah, but that's not actually it. The judge wasn't having it. The judge ruled that, look, the so-called facts that were inside the AR overview, they're not things that were being surfaced from other published sources. They were 100% the creation of Google software. They were written by software that Google is responsible for, and therefore Google is responsible for the fallout. The judge actually even went a little bit further, saying that free speech protections don't apply to AI-generated content because the author is not a person, and only a person can be protected by free speech protections. Ooh, is that going to be upheld? Maybe. Is that going to be upheld through time?
Well, obviously Google is going to be challenging this, but that's actually consistent with what most courts worldwide had found. For instance, you can't copyright or trade – you can't copyright something that's been generated by AI. This is something that the U.S. Copyright Office settled on years ago because copyrights can only be held by people. So it only applies to things that are created by people. People. Things with flesh. Yeah. Well, I should be careful about that because the movie AI, they put the AI in flesh. Anyway.
And a side note, the judge also dismissed Google's defense that, hey, well, we covered ourselves here because we AI overviews. We put in a whole disclaimer that urges the user to double check all facts. That was like. Yeah, like the user has time to be urged. Leave me alone. I need an answer to a question. I don't have time to be urged about something.
I uploaded a photo of the pants and my butt and I asked the AI, are these pants going to look good on my butt? And the AI said, no, it's going to make your butt look great. And I put them on, I bought them and everybody told me, wow, what happened to your butt? It's like huge or something. So I want the money back on the pants and also I want money for new pants and also $30 because I need to have a pizza and I didn't do any shopping this week. Yeah. It's like they're limited to basically putting a disclaimer saying, oh, by the way, check out the disclaimers on a package of fireworks and see if it, you still see how difficult it is to like.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I think that's going to do it for us this week. Hope you all had a wonderful 4th of July. Once again, if you want to help support our show and everything on the Relay Network, become a member by going to relay.fm slash material. We're going to start recording our bonus episode shortly after we conclude this episode and get ourselves another refreshing beverage. But that's going to be it for us this week. Thank you so much for listening to us this time. We hope you're going to be with us again next week. And until then, we hope you have a happy, safe, and healthy seven days. Bye-bye. Bye, everybody.