Skip to content
6.  Happy Holidays! episode artwork

Dec 12, 2017 29 min

6. Happy Holidays!

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

This week, Uri and Rivky talk about Birthright - is it a good thing for the Jews? For Israel? What is the value of Birthright? In their second topic, they pick up where Howard Dean, Melissa Harris-Perry, David Brooks, and Robert George leave off, and ask - do liberals hold the moral high ground? Catch up on everything below: 1. The Nation, Romance on Birthright Israel: https://www.thenation.com/article/romance-birthright-israel/ 2. Debate: https://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/liberals-hold-moral-high-ground 3. The G.O.P. Is Rotting: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/07/opinion/the-gop-is-rotting.html Video/song links https://www.hulu.com/watch/217024 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qR3rK0kZFkg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6i-gYRAwM0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfLHAJrNnsM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YCnt-drXsiU

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

This week, Uri and Rivky talk about Birthright - is it a good thing for the Jews? For Israel? What is the value of Birthright? In their second topic, they pick up where Howard Dean, Melissa Harris-Perry, David Brooks, and Robert George leave off, and ask - do liberals hold the moral high ground? Catch up on everything below: 1. The Nation, Romance on Birthright Israel: https://www.thenation.com/article/romance-birthright-israel/ 2. Debate: https://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/liberal...

Ready to play

6. Happy Holidays!

0:00 29:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Shalom and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rivki. And you're listening to Talking Tachless, the show where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. How's it going, Uri? Pretty good. I'm really excited. We're in the holiday season. Finally. And we're brought to you again by Drive-In Productions for all your holiday video needs. And I'm also glad to say that the war on Christmas is over. Finally. Yeah, we're officially allowed to say Merry Christmas as much as we want. Oh, it feels so good. Merry Christmas, Rivki. Merry Christmas, Uri. And there's also another holiday coming up, and that is Hanukkah. Heard of it. And we want to give the gift of Tachless to all of you. Oh, boy. All right, let's get started.

Well, now that we're in the Israel spirit after that beautiful Havana Shalom in the beginning, Rifki, why don't you tell us about the big news coming out of Birthright? Yeah, absolutely. Recently, Tugli, Birthright Israel, which we normally just call Birthright, has announced that they are extending the age of Birthright participants. It had been for a long time that from the ages of 18 to 26, you're eligible to go on this free 10-day trip to Israel. And now, instead of limiting to those under 26, Birthright will take participants up to 32 years old. So this is pretty big news in a very specific cohort of people, right? Like a bunch of my Facebook friends have posted about it, mostly tagging their friends who didn't get to go when they were younger. But it's pretty exciting. So Uri and I have both been much clean, kind of like camp counselors on these Birthright trips.

And I sort of want to take a step back and ask, forget about what birthright donors say. Uri, what do you think is the goal of birthright? I think it's complicated. On a birthright trip, the participants are introduced to a lot of different ways of... interacting with and understanding their Judaism. So obviously Israel is central to the trip because it's in Israel and it's about Israel, but it's also about Jewish history. It's also about Jewish peoplehood. And while it's not a religious trip, you can't be in Israel and on a Jewish trip and not talk about religion. So I really think it's a lot of different things. And what I think is so nice about Birthright, one of the things that's nice about it is that you have 40 participants on a trip and you have 40 different experiences on that trip, on that bus, because everybody really takes different things from it. And no one, to me, no one ideology or way of thinking is forced on anybody. And you're kind of given this massive...

platter of Jewishness, and you can pick and choose from it, whatever you want. I don't know, because that's sort of a, it is a really beautiful answer, but it's also a little bit vague, right? So if we're saying, what are the funders, or what are we trying to have people get out of a birthright experience, then what's the answer? Just sort of like some sort of vague, amorphous connection to however they think of Judaism? Like, what is that? To just push a little bit, tachlis, what do we want people to walk away with? You took the words right out of my mouth. I was about to say tachlis. Like, let's get into it. I know that people have issues with birthright, and...

my understanding of the main problem that people have with it is that they see it as this right-wing propaganda machine. And I find that to be just simplistic and insulting because I don't think that a Jewish person feeling connected to Israel is a political statement. And I think that the fact that it's come to be seen as political somehow is really, really sad to me and I think dangerous to Judaism, to be frank. To say that it's not political at all, I think is a hard thing to say. Well, first of all, what I meant was...

being pro-Israel or feeling connected and supportive of Israel should not be political. Do they have an agenda? Yeah, of course they have an agenda. Their agenda is to get people to like Israel and to, I guess, also want to marry Jews, which is also part of their mission. And to call it political, you can call it political if you want, but anything could be political. That doesn't mean it's bad. Sometimes people equate political with bad, and in this case, I don't really see that.

Sure, if you agree with politics. Why don't you tell me what would make it less political or what would make it more, quote-unquote, even-handed? Birthright can be a lot more strict in sort of setting the agenda and making sure that they're getting a more even experience, that they're meeting with all these different people and seeing all these different types, right? When I was on Birthright, you didn't go into any Arab towns. in Israel, right? I'm not even talking about beyond the green line. I'm talking about Arab towns in Israel. Because birthright's saying, that's not really what we're about. We're trying to create sort of this Jewish identity. We're trying to help people. But they're also kind of political. Kind of. I'm not saying it's bad. But they're also kind of political about Israel. And they're giving them sort of... I don't think it's political to only meet Jews. That's not political. That's just Jewish. It's making a choice about what you're presenting about Israel. I'll happen to add that on my most recent trip, we actually went to an Arab property over the green line. We heard from a Palestinian. The argument is not about whether birthright does or doesn't. The argument is that birthright... Should they be required? Yeah. The argument is that birthright gives a lot of freedom to the tour providers to choose these things. There are a number of mandatory...

visits. The hotel. The Dead Sea. Independence Hall in Tel Aviv. There's a whole number of things. I think it comes out to more than 50% of the...

The trip are these mandatory things that every single trip has to do. I mean, this also brings up the article that both of us read and discussed this week, which was an article written for The Nation in 2011 by Kira Feldman. Did you read The Portland Weekly? Yeah! Did you read The Willamette Week? Yeah! Did you read The Seattle Stranger? Beginning to end. Did you read The SF Weekly? I loved it. The Harvard Lampoon? Well written. Did you read Mad Magazine? I did not like the end of it. And Feldman talks about her birthright experience. She is extremely critical in a very nasty way about birthright. I didn't think it was nasty, but you can read the article. We have the link in the description. One of the things that was really hilarious to me was she mentions that they actually did hear from an Arab-Israeli.

But that Arab Israeli was sort of like saying nice things about Israel, which obviously was impossible to Kira. And so like, you know, there's something wrong there. And it's just so funny to me when you have these ultra liberals who are fighting for a cause and these oppressed people. But when somebody from the actual oppressed group doesn't agree with that fight, their mind explodes and they don't know what to do with it. So it's got to be some sort of a conspiracy or I don't know what. But I thought that was funny.

On my most recent birthright trip, we actually went to an Arab property over the Green Line where there's an organization called Ohel HaShalom. And it's an organization where Palestinians and religious settlers get together and meet and talk and eat together and find common ground, even though obviously there's a lot of not common ground. And we heard from a Palestinian who I'm now friends with on Facebook. He's a really nice guy and I hope to see him next time I go to Israel. He was not Zionistic by any stretch. He was not one of these, you know, plants, ringers that they find out who apparently, you know, was on one of Kira Feldman's trip. He was giving the Palestinian narrative and he was talking about the right of return. The Palestinians all want to go back into Israel proper and whatever.

We had a discussion, and that was on Birthright. Birthright didn't have to bring us to that. Birthright does... There are a lot of providers that make choices, and they're... providers that make other choices. The idea is that birthright in and of itself gives a lot of freedom there. You have people giving hundreds of millions of dollars, and then those people are dictating the certain basic things. I mean, Michael Steinhardt, who is not a religious person, he said something really interesting. It's quoted in this article in The Nation. To him, Israel is a, quote, substitute for theology. So, I mean, Michael Steinhardt is not a religious person, but this is still something that's very important to him. I just think that it's also interesting in The Nation article. Do you agree with that? I don't know. I hear that quote, and I think that that in and of itself, I mean, what I was doing before was hypothetical, but now I'm just thinking, you know, from the perspective of me, Ricky, the idea of Israel as a substitute for theology feels...

so challenging to me. Like, is that what we want either? Is that what we want as birthright? That's not your Israel or that's not your Judaism, but why can't that be somebody else's? What's the value of a Judaism that has a nationality as its core? Let me ask you, Uri, what is the value of that Judaism? Well, I mean, I think Judaism has always had a nationality. Do you mean a land or a nationality? A substitute for theology. Faith in Israel is a substitute for theology. Yeah, I mean, I think a lot of the founders of Zionism and the founders of Israel. Okay, so you, Uri, do you think that that is valuable?

Do you think a birthright that creates that institution is valuable? To me, that's better than nothing. If a Jew is going to either be unaffiliated and have no connection to Judaism or Israel, or they're only going to be affiliated through Israel and the land, but not through the religion, I think that's very nice. So if what they're trying to do, let's say they're trying to do two things. They're trying to make Jews connect to Judaism enough to marry other Jews, and they're trying to have Jews who are connected to Israel.

if they choose to marry other Jews because they're like, hey, I feel really connected to the land of Israel. You feel really connected to the land of Israel. Let's have Jewish children. Is that a value? What's wrong with that? Is that a value? I think it's a nice thing. I don't see anything. Why is that a nice thing? That's like saying, I love Teaneck. Hey, someone else grew up in Teaneck. We both love Teaneck. What's the value there? Who cares? As much as I love Teaneck, I don't think it says...

important as Israel. Why is it not as important as Israel? I'm trying to get to a very specific question. Let's say they're like, I love Israel. I had an amazing time slathering mud on myself at the Dead Sea. What's the value of that? When you talk about what it means to be a Jew, that could be a topic for another day because as we said, it's very complicated. But part of it is Israel. I think just like the Torah and the land and the people, these are all integral elements of what Judaism is and what it means to be a Jewish person. So this is one part of it. There are some people for whom this is the only part. I don't see that as a bad thing. It might not be the full picture, but why would that be negative? It feels to me like such a neutral thing. Like being connected to the land of Israel without being connected to the...

Jewish community in a deeper sense, or without being connection to religion in a deeper sense, without those things, to me, that feels very superficial. It's like saying, I love my town. I love my house. Like, what's the meaning there? What's the deeper meaning between under the land? I guess to me it goes without saying, but I guess if I had to articulate it, the land encapsulates a lot of the history, and...

So much of what Judaism is, is its history and its story. And that story is completely tied to the land. I agree with you, but I think of the history and I think of the story and I think of the background of Judaism and of Israel as tools to create something deeper. Another thing that's criticized in the Nation article is that she tries to expose the fact that all the funders, all the big funders for Birthright are like these right wing. people. And I mean, I'm sure that Birthright would be happy to take $100 million from George Soros. Nobody's stopping him from giving that money. And I think it's very telling that he hasn't given money to Birthright and that other left-wing quote-unquote, you know, philanthropists or millionaires or whatever haven't given money. I don't think that's a coincidence. And so like, it's almost like chicken and egg. What are you criticizing? You know, are you just upset that there isn't more of a left-wing agenda in Birthright? Or are you really saying why aren't more left-wing people supportive of things like Birthright? I think they might be because they're uncomfortable with it. I mean, I think my argument is not exactly that. It's more that they are...

to ideological in certain ways, and then they leave a lot of flexibility when it comes to what I think is the core issue, which is the way that they try to get people to feel connected to Judaism is through, I think, really superficial things. It's through trying to get people to have crushes on each other and trying to make them see, like, look, isn't this fun? And also, not just fun, the Holocaust, right? It's so sad. But also, look at all this history because we have a coattail, right? But not actually trying to give people really authentic, meaningful experiences. And it's hard. Why are those things not real? Why is Yad Vashem and the coattail not real?

Of course it's real. Of course Yad Vashem is real. But it's also something about it rubs me the wrong way when it's in the service of and therefore have Jewish children, which is the very, very explicit goal. I don't think that's the therefore. That's a goal. That's not the goal. That's a goal. A big goal.

So what do you think the goals are? I really would say the two goals are... To connect to Judaism. And connecting to Judaism involves marrying Jewish. That's part of it. Because if you don't marry Jewish, then your kids aren't going to be Jewish and you won't be connected anymore. So one of the things that's... I mean, birthright's in a tough position, right? Because a lot of the kids who go on birthright trips are the product of intermarriage, right? They have the same rules for birthright as the right of return, right? Or as the Nazis had, right? It's one Jewish grandparent. So at least on my... I don't know about your birthright trips, but on my birthright trips, about half of the kids... Yeah, we had a lot also. ...were the product of intermarriage. And it's interesting because the Israeli soldiers who joined our trip and the guides on our trips were...

pretty anti-intermarriage, pretty explicitly, which I totally understand because that's a goal of birthright to be anti-intermarriage. It was pretty hard for these kids. So I actually didn't have that experience. We were kind of warned ahead of time, but we had a really amazing tour guide, especially on my first trip. Shout out to Joe. Joe, really? Yeah, he's on our sweatshirt and everything.

And it's funny because also in the article, she makes fun of how the group wanted to put the tour guide on the sweatshirt. So he warned us ahead of time. He said, just basing on the essays that the kids wrote ahead of time, that a lot of them are the products of intermarriage. And I think we actually tried very hard to make sure that nobody would feel uncomfortable or out of place. It's another example of the tour guide and every trip is different. I mean, the approach on my trips was kind of like, let the participants.

talk it out amongst themselves. And the staff kind of took a step back. And for a lot of them, this is the first time that they're really encountering a lot of these issues and thinking about them in a very real way. It's very heavy. It's hard. But at the same time, going back to your earlier critique of it being somewhat superficial, yeah, it's a 10-day trip. It's going to be superficial no matter what. This is sort of just like a table of contents to Israel and to what it means to be Jewish, maybe. So I think that's actually part, and we have to end this segment, but I think that's part of my, when I think practically about what can be done to change birthright, the first thing I would say is mandatory follow-up and follow-through. A lot of the birthright buses, they're all coming from the same city, but at least...

for my provider, nothing's mandatory. It's more like, oh, if you decide to host a Shabbat dinner, we'll give you a lot of money to subsidize the cost. But it's not, you know, any sort of... Again, making things mandatory, then you get criticized for other reasons. I mean, you're giving people a free 10-day trip to the Middle East. You're allowed to throw in some caveats there. I think we should leave the segment at that. But there's definitely, of course, a lot more to talk about. We want to hear all your thoughts. Please email us, talkingtachaspodcasts at gmail.com.

For our next segment, we want to talk about yet another panel discussion that took place this past week that, again, only I attended and Rifki sadly was not able to make it, but she did watch it online. This one was actually a real debate and not just a discussion where everybody was saying the same thing and patting each other on the back. And the motion was, quote, liberals hold the moral high ground. And then one side defended that motion and the other side tried to disprove it. The debate was run by a really cool organization called Intelligence Square Debates. So the people on this debate were pretty impressive. On the liberal side was Howard Dean, former DNC chairman and governor of Vermont, most well known for his primal scream in the 2004 Democratic primary after he won New Hampshire. Not only are we going to New Hampshire, Tom Harkin, we're going to South Carolina and Oklahoma and Arizona and North Dakota and New Mexico. We're going to California and Texas and New York. We're going to South Dakota and Oregon and Washington and Michigan.

And then we're going to Washington DC to take back the White House! But he's looking good now. He's looking great, considering that was 13 years ago. The other person on the liberal side was Melissa Harris-Perry, who's a professor at Wake Forest University and also used to have a talk show on MSNBC. And then on the conservative side was Robert George, who's a political philosopher and professor at Princeton University, and David Brooks, who I'm a big fan of, op-ed columnist for The New York Times. The main issue at hand, which I find pretty interesting, was about the moral high ground. But I also thought it was very interesting the way they worded the motion itself. The way they phrased it was, liberals hold the moral high ground, which made it a lot harder, actually, for the liberal side to prove their point. Because for them to win, they have to prove that...

that liberals hold the moral high ground. But for the conservatives to win, all they have to prove is that liberals don't hold the moral high ground. They don't have to prove that they have it. To explain the way that debate was set up was all the audience members voted in advance, sort of agree, neutral, or disagree. And then they voted again afterwards, agree, neutral, or disagree. And the liberal side won if more people moved to the agree side. And the conservative side won if more people moved to the disagree side. I mean, because what do you think, Rifki? Do you think liberals, or do you think you have the moral high ground?

I don't know why you're putting me in this liberal camp. I mean, I would like to think that in my political and social and personal convictions that I hold the moral high ground. Sure, who wouldn't want to think that? Who wouldn't want to think that in any situation they're doing what's good and what's right? And when they're looking at the economy, they're looking at what's good and what's right. I think everyone wants to think that. Well, I think there's a difference. This might get into semantics.

thinking that you're doing the right thing is not, to me, it doesn't sound the same as the moral high ground. Because when you say you have the moral high ground, that is in contrast to the other person on the other side of the debate, who I guess has the moral low ground or whatever the opposite of the high ground is. And as they got into the debate, you know, David Brooks, in his opening remarks, said that that's why Donald Trump won the presidency. Because you have a whole, you know, demographic of people, mostly on the coast in America, who look down on middle America and see them as inferior and morally inferior. And that caused this backlash of people supporting somebody who they otherwise would not support. He even mentioned, you know, a whole bunch of areas of the country that voted for Obama in 2008, now voted for...

for Trump, seemingly not necessarily for idealistic reasons, but more for anger reasons. So do you think that liberals have that notion of themselves as the moral high ground just as often as conservatives have it for themselves? Yeah, I definitely do. I definitely think, you know, I, so the three possibilities were liberals hold the moral high ground, liberals... don't hold the moral high ground and undecided. And I would definitely put myself into that sort of undecided if it were pre-debate and I think post-debate. I would like to think that I have the moral high ground, but I also recognize that these things are complicated. First of all, I would not call myself a very strict liberal. I think that the world is more complicated than I would like to think that I am more complicated than that. Well, that's why I said I don't like the binary as if you're either liberal or you're conservative. There's obviously so many different things. I wouldn't even say in between because it's not just a straight spectrum. And so that actually came up. So first of all, both conservative quote unquote debaters readily acknowledged right off the bat that they did not and do not support Donald Trump.

Something that David Brooks spoke about in his opening remarks, he said something that resonated with me, which is that Donald Trump is not a conservative, first of all. But second of all, the real fight right now, the ideological political fight happening, not just in America, but in Europe also and other places in the world, is not between liberal and conservative. To him, both of those sides, as we think of them, are really on the same side. And what's on the other side is populism. And there's populism coming from the right and there's populism coming from the left. And he sees that as dangerous in both cases. And I agree with that, actually. And so that's why people connect. I don't think either of the individuals would appreciate this connection. But you have Jeremy Corbyn.

leading the Labour Party in England, and you have Donald Trump, President of the United States, as a Republican in America, those are both intensely populist leaders who have a populist following who someone like David Brooks sees both as dangerous in different but similar ways. Yeah, David Brooks actually last week, around the same time as this debate, he wrote an opinion piece in the New York Times where he's a columnist, The GOP is Rotting. And in it, he really writes about the demise of the conservative movement in America as it is tied to the Republican Party and sort of talks about, you know, the GOP is rotting. He talks about the rise of populism. If I, you know, part of the reason that...

Trump won this election. That's a bigger conversation. There's a lot of facets to it. But part of the reason is the huge swaths of uneducated white people who voted for Trump, right? That's just what the statistics show us. It's way more likely these people who didn't go to college to vote for Trump. But if uneducated white people voted for Obama, that would be fine? I mean, it's fine. I'm not saying good or bad. No, I'm saying this is what populism is. Populism is this.

angry group of people who say that none of these people represent us. I'm not saying you're necessarily wrong, but I think you're already veering into dangerous territory, which gets into what David Brooks was saying of this is why Trump won, because you're speaking about this huge swath of people as if they're unintelligent and don't know any better, and they're just getting swept up in this populist movement. I'm saying that they're making a conscious choice. When you say don't know any better, obviously I think they're wrong, but I'm not saying that they're just like morons who took two shots of bourbon and then picked up something arbitrarily. I think they're making a very conscious choice against the status quo. I'm playing devil's advocate to some extent. It's rubbing me the wrong way. I think that's been a criticism of democracy. I totally understand why it rubbed you the wrong way.

say the elites have always said the masses are the asses. That's not what I'm saying. It sounds like it. Okay, sorry to hear that. You can say that maybe I should deliver my message, whatever the message was, in a different way. But to say that it's not important, I think is ridiculous. I think there's always been uneducated, poor people, white people, whatever you want to say, black people in America. But there have been other leaders who have had a lot more integrity who have garnered those people's votes, whether it was Obama recently or going back to FDR, Lincoln, whatever. Just because they're uneducated doesn't mean they're going to be voting for somebody evil or who is perceived as evil. So I don't think that's the issue at hand. No, it's about the fact that they're not educated and the fact that their jobs are all gone and the fact that they're angry, right? There are a lot of things that are combining. It's not blaming them.

It's not saying they're absolute morons because they're uneducated. But I do think that that's part of being uneducated is the rejection of people that they look at as the elite. Right. Well, getting back to the moral high ground issue and kind of what I see as the danger of that mentality. I was actually on a date. This was during the 2016 primaries. And so I think it was before Trump was officially the nominee. But politics came up and my date was kind of espousing her liberal ideology, which is OK, that's fine. It's a free cunch. And so I was kind of playing devil's advocate on some of these issues just for fun, for the sake of argument. And at one point she kind of said.

how is it possible for somebody to call themselves a Republican and also be a good person? And I just found that really funny. Like that's the kind of thing that you think people say and you accuse like liberals of thinking, but they would deny it if you accuse them of it. But here's somebody who actually said it. And I didn't really feel like answering the question because I took it as a rhetorical question. But I just thought it was funny. And I think that when you...

when one side of a debate has that mentality, there is no debate and there is no respect for the other side. And something that was like very cute and almost like overdone a little bit on this panel, although I did appreciate it, was all four of the participants in the debate were constantly saying how much they respect the other side and the people as individuals. Some of them taught at the same universities or they know each other from different spheres, but they kept talking about how much they respect the other one. And I guess, you know, that was appreciated by me and other members. This is a side note, but wouldn't it be beautiful to have a debate like that with different leaders of different Jewish denominations where people actually were able to have conversations like that? I think that happens. You don't think that ever happens?

when they're explicitly talking about debating points of sort of Jewish thought and practice? I don't think so. Name me the last time you heard about that. Well, I need to start going to more panels. I'm in like a panel mood. I do think there could always be more of that. I would think that it exists, but I can't think of anything specific. There's an interesting question, actually, that came from the audience that I just want to play quickly. My name is Uri. Something that hasn't come up tonight at all is foreign policy or America's role towards the rest of the world. I was wondering on each side, what's something that defines your side's approach to this issue and why that's superior to the other side?

Thank you. That's a great question. I'm glad you brought it into the conversation. Let me take it first to the side arguing against the moderator. I agree with the moderator. That was a great question. That guy's a voice for radio. I think they didn't really get into foreign policy too much. But one thing that they spoke about was that each party has had their moments of glory. So Howard Dean said that the Vietnam War was started by Democrats. But then the second Iraq War was started by Republicans. And supported by Democrats.

Right. Robert George talked about, I guess he must have seen my kippah on my head. So he said the push... You're trying to get publicity at these debates. I know why you go. Well, I did plug the podcast. I should have. I wish. So Robert George said that the movement to support Soviet Jewry was largely a Republican endeavor, not a Democratic one. But then he said the civil rights movement was largely Democratic. And he's embarrassed that the Republicans weren't more on board with that. So if we talk, talk, listen, let's wrap up here. The poll that they asked the audience at the beginning of the end was, do liberals have the moral high ground? Is it yes, no, or undecided? Or where do you stand there? Well, as I said in the beginning, ironically, even though we were in New York and...

in the moment that we are in, the conservative side won the debate by a large margin. So what do you think? What would you vote for if we had these three things sitting in front of us right now? Or what did you vote for? Well, I agreed with David Brooks that liberals do not have the moral high ground. You said against the motion. Yeah, but that doesn't mean that I think I have the moral high ground. I think there are good arguments to be made on all kinds of sides. And if we could have those conversations respectfully, I think it can only lead to good things. Yeah, I think I'm agreed. You know, I very much generally would affiliate as a liberal and I would also say against the motion. I don't think that I, I wish I did. I wish I could say that I didn't. I wish I could say my movement did. But overall, I don't think we can make that claim.

All right. And that was our show. Thank you all so much for listening. And as always, please send feedback to TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. We love hearing your thoughts. We want to wish everybody a happy Hanukkah, happy holidays, and Merry Christmas. Bye. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on December 12, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.