6 – Wisdom vs Power: Modern Paradigm Part 1
from Wisdom, Leadership & Success
Welcome back to our ongoing series about the history of the ongoing conflict in America—and how we fix it. In our last three blogs, we discussed the basics of the Wisdom Paradigm—the dominant way of understanding life for thousands of years—for almost all cultures, religions and philosophies. The Wisdom Paradigm teaches us that human nature has been the same through history, and that we all have the same destination in life, the same purpose, which is Happiness, fulfillment. Happiness comes from having good relationships—with ourselves and with others. If Happiness is our destination and purpose, then we use our reason to figure out how to get there. Reason tells us that it’s a fact that if we practice virtues like honesty, justice, wisdom and love, we will become good people prepared for good relationships and Happiness. Finally, the Wisdom Paradigm sees human relationships as fundamentally covenant relationships where the good of the team and the good of the individual are the same. The more you put into the team, the better you get. The more the team invests in you, the better the team gets. Covenant relationships are the highest-trust, highest-performance and most stable relationships possible. In the deepest covenant relationships, people are willing to die for each other out of love. The Wisdom Paradigm was the right track for the ongoing development of humanity—until we took a wrong turn and got off track several hundred years ago. What happened? What got us off-track? Religious Wars in Europe In the 16th and 17th centuries, Europe was overcome by a series of religious wars that raged for hundreds of years. These religious wars devastated large parts of France and Germany, and led to the deaths of millions of people. The wars took a terrible toll on Europe, impoverishing millions more and driving governments to bankruptcy. In many areas, there was anarchy as rival armies marched back and forth, plundering everything. Civil wars broke out as people took advantage of religious differences and bankrupt rulers to take power themselves. The suffering throughout Europe was enormous and long-lasting in a way that is hard for us to understand today. Think of the devastation of the civil war in Syria, but across Europe and for a hundred years. People and nations became exhausted and impatient by the suffering that seemed to be unending and systemic. Thinkers began to search for a new way to understand life—a new paradigm—that could get them out of the terrible religious and political conflicts. They needed to find a way for people of different religions to live together without killing each other. This led to the is the rise of political philosophers like Hobbes and Locke and Rousseau that you may remember from your political sci class in college. The Modern Paradigm--Reason Alone The Wisdom Paradigm is based on a foundation of purpose and reason. As we said in earlier blogs, our purpose, Happiness, is our destination in life and reason tells us how to get there. Ever since Europe had become Christian, faith had taken the role of purpose. So, for European Christian civilizations, the equation was essentially faith/purpose and reason. Faith provided the purpose, the destination (salvation), and reason helped people understand what was needed to achieve salvation. The horrific wars in Europe were over religion, over faith, over what people understood to be their purpose or destination in life. So, for many European philosophers, the answer to ending the vast suffering was obvious. Let’s drop that thing, faith, over which we’re killing each other, and reconstruct our entire understanding of life in terms of reason by itself. They do that by splitting life into public and private. Instead of the Wisdom Paradigm’s understanding of life as a unified whole focused on Happiness, the Modern Paradigm splits life into your public life and your private, or personal life. Public life is what reason can more easily discuss. Public life is the quantifiable side of life. Private life contains the things that reason has difficulty discussing, like faith, love, purpose and meaning, because they are either hard to quantify or they are personal. The modern philosophers believed that to get to objective Truth, it was very important to eliminate the superstitious influence of faith and religion. So, modern thinkers put faith, religion, purpose and feelings all into the private side of life. These subjects are not matters of reason. They are subjective. Matters of personal opinion. The public side of life is where reason can be applied to pursue the Truth. Objective Truth. The public side of life includes business, politics, science and other subjects that can be analyzed using reason. At first, morality was on the public side of life. But over time, as morality became more difficult to justify with reason alone, it appeared to become more subjective. Morality became more a matter of opinion than fact and moved from the public side of life to the private side. Today, most young people consider morality to be a subjective, personal issue. When this division of life into public and private happened in Europe, pretty much everyone at the time in Europe was Christian. So, while faith and purpose are put in our personal-private side of life, everyone pretty much shared a common understanding of our purpose in life—Happiness and salvation. We just don’t talk about it publicly as a community. Keep that in mind—that we stopped talking publicly about purpose, Happiness and salvation in life—because that will come back to haunt us after a few hundred years. So, for public life, no more purpose plus knowledge. The Modern Paradigm bases everything on reason alone. Basing this new, Modern Paradigm, on reason alone seemed to make sense. Reason is a powerful tool that seems to point us reliably at the Truth. Reason is something all rational people share, that we can use together outside of religion to get to the Truth. In other words, we’ll stop basing our understanding of life on something about which we violently disagree (religion) and base it on something on which we all agree (reason). And so many of the philosophers of the 16th, 17th and 18th centuries introduced us to the Age of Reason and the Age of the Enlightenment. Collectively, they helped reconstruct our understanding of life, moving us from a Wisdom Paradigm based on faith/purpose and reason to a Modern Paradigm largely focused on reason. What’s really important to remember here is that purpose—becoming good and achieving Happiness—no longer serves as the central, unifying element that ties our understanding of life together. The Modern Paradigm has switched it to r Human Nature In the Wisdom Paradigm, we have to understand human nature to understand life, our purpose in life and fulfillment. Human nature is the starting point for everything that follows including morality, relationships, Happiness, work and the meaning of life. In the Modern Paradigm, with purpose and Happiness moved from public life to private life, understanding human nature is not as important. Imagine a person suffering deeply from a question about the meaning of life. In the Wisdom Paradigm, when you ask, “What is the meaning of life?” the answer is obvious: to achieve Happiness. The Modern Paradigm has a problem here. On the public side of life, the Modern Paradigm can study human nature from a scientific perspective. We call that psychology and psychiatry. A scientific understanding of how the mind works in individuals and how minds work in groups is valuable in a wide variety of areas including educational, industrial and social psychologies. But when it comes to purpose or meaning, the Modern Paradigm hits a roadblock. Remember that science, on the public side of life, can tell us the how and the what about things, but—because the Modern Paradigm rejects purpose—science cannot tell us about the why of things. So, science cannot tell us about our purpose or meaning in life. In the Modern Paradigm, questions about purpose or meaning or why are relegated to the private side of life. When a person who is really suffering from a question about the meaning of life, modern psychology is going to be unable to answer that question. With the modern separation of life into public and private, questions about human nature and purpose are usually tackled in terms of one’s religion or spirituality. And so, with the Modern Paradigm’s separation of life into the public and private, deep questions about the meaning of life get two hard-to-reconcile answers. You get one answer from the Modern psychologist in public life and—almost inevitably—a very different answer from a minister in your private life who is coming from the Wisdom Paradigm. Over time, this inability for the Modern Paradigm to talk about the deep, most important questions about life is going to cause huge problems for our society. When people think that there’s no meaning or purpose in life, bad things happen. From Wisdom Covenant to Modern Contract Relationships The breakdown of society in the religious wars of the 16th and 17th centuries made Modern philosophers take a new look at human relationships. Modern thinkers started with the idea that humans are radically free individuals in a state of nature without basic, pre-existing relationships with others. These individuals have lots of freedom to do whatever they want, but don’t have much security, because other people are free to do bad things to them. So, the Modern Paradigm says that people come together in a social contract where they give up some of their freedom to the community and get more security in return. The Modern Paradigm tends to treat all relationships—from family to business—as essentially contract relationships. ...
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.