62 | Christine Paolilla | The Clear Lake Murders

The three mustaches tackle a case from their home state of Texas, and believe me, this one will raise your eyebrows. When Rachael Koloroutis, Tiffany Rowell, Marcus Precella, and Adelbert Sanchez were found shot to death in Tiffany's home in Clear Water City police were baffled. The attack resembled a gang hit, but the four teenagers were all good students with clean criminal records. The ensuing investigation eventually revealed that you should always be cautious about the company you keep. Try Our New 8% Seltzer at HardAFseltzer.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices