Skip to content
62. Snowplow Parents episode artwork

Mar 20, 2019 34 min

62. Snowplow Parents

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

This week, Uri and Rivky dive into discussion about the college cheating admissions scandal. They ask, cheating is bad, but how does it compare to legacy, affirmation action, tutoring, coaching, and a long, long list of ways we boost students? Links: Woman who got football scholarship for a men's team: https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/28/sport/missouri-female-football-player-scholarship-spt-trnd/index.html College Admissions Scandal: https://www.cnn.com/videos/us/2019/03/13/college-cheating-scandal-felicity-huffman-lori-laughlin-kaye-pkg-vpx.cnn NYT Snowplow Parents: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/16/style/snowplow-parenting-scandal.html Music: Talking Heads - Life During Wartime: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLwZvg46jms

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

This week, Uri and Rivky dive into discussion about the college cheating admissions scandal. They ask, cheating is bad, but how does it compare to legacy, affirmation action, tutoring, coaching, and a long, long list of ways we boost students? Links: Woman who got football scholarship for a men's team: https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/28/sport/missouri-female-football-player-scholarship-spt-trnd/index.html College Admissions Scandal: https://www.cnn.com/videos/us/2019/03/13/college-cheating-scanda...

Ready to play

62. Snowplow Parents

0:00 34:05
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rifki. And you're listening to Talking Topless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So Rifki, any follow-up thoughts on last week's topic? Yeah, last week we talked about women in sports. And I think we got some interesting feedback. But Uri, there was actually, you know, follow-up thoughts. There was actually something in particular that as we went home that night, and I think that this always kind of happens after we leave the studio, there's always like those thoughts that you kind of wish you had mentioned. And I kept thinking about this, you know, for the next few days. So I'm glad this podcast is still happening. But I was thinking, the question that we were grappling with is whether there's inherent sexism in not...

portraying women as prominently as men when it comes to sports, when it comes to WNBA versus the NBA, women's soccer, men's soccer, things like that. And the argument that I think I was kind of making is that it's not really about sexism. Not that it's not, but sexism is nowhere near as prominent as other forces like capitalism, like the balance of power between labor and just things like that. Market forces. Yeah, exactly. I was just thinking that term and I'm like, too specific. But the more that I thought about it, the more that I realized that even though I still think that's true, I do think that as much as the reason that these sports and these women are not being portrayed as prominently as men's sports is not because of sexism, that

the fact that it happens definitely contributes and perpetuates more sexism. Because the more we don't see female athletes on TV as much as male athletes, and the more we see them not make as much money and not being given the same endorsements, we don't see them in the same Gatorade commercials and things like that, the more we kind of internalize this message that like, oh, it's because they want the top athletes and women obviously can't be top athletes, so why would they be wearing Nikes? And so why would they be featured on TV during prime time and things like that? So I think even though it might not be because of sexism, it definitely contributes to a more sexist environment and kind of affects our thinking in that way. Right. I think I hear what you're saying. I think that's an interesting point. I would just say that

We're talking about sports here. And it could be, or one could make an argument that sexism in sports is not the same thing as sexism in education or in the corporate world, in the business world. Meaning because of, people talk about differences between men and women, but one type of difference that most people agree exists is the physical difference. And so that doesn't necessarily mean that women's sports are not as interesting or as important or compelling as men's sports. But I do think it's possible one could make the argument that full equality and exposure and opportunity should exist in most other realms. But sports might be different in terms of like, it might just be that people are more interested in watching men's sports than women's sports. And there's nothing inherently wrong with that. Right. Well, I agree with that. I think that what you're saying is sort of let the market choose. The argument that women's soccer is making is that the market isn't getting to choose. But actually, it's interesting what you mentioned. We didn't even talk about this at all last week. One thing you just mentioned is sort of biological differences between men and women. There's this whole genre of discussion right now in sports about how you deal with sort of...

especially like women who have, let's say, higher level, like elevated levels of certain hormones that is more common in men, which makes them faster, makes their muscle stronger, whatever, stuff like that, or specifically trans people, right? Like, you know, what category they're going to fall into in competitive sports and things like that, which is a whole other... Complicated, yeah. Yeah, and it's really tough. And that's another issue. Maybe another day. I know people are clamoring for sports. I'm talking topics. No, it is a very complicated question. And it's another argument to say...

In men's sports, it's called men's, but if a woman was able to make it onto an NHL or an NBA team, they would be allowed on. Most likely it has happened in the NHL and other sports. There have been women in NHL? Yeah, goalies, yeah. Wow, I never heard of that. Not long term, but there have been women who have played a game or two in the NHL. Huh. So in that case, it wouldn't matter if the person was transgender, what kind of hormones they had. It would just be like, it's a person. Right, sports and sports. As opposed to women's leagues where you only have these questions when it comes to women's.

competition is that true in all men's major league i mean maybe you don't know but major league sports like if i want to play college football i think it was and she was the first non-kicker so there have been kickers who have been on men's college football team women and now there's a woman who i forgot her exactly um tight end or wide receiver or something like that. I'm not a huge football person, but she's basically the first time kicker. Wow, look at you teaching me all this about sports. I love this new dynamic. Well, before getting into our main topic for today, we of course have to mention the horrific terrorist attack in New Zealand where 50 worshippers at two different mosques were murdered by a white supremacist. I mean, there isn't really much to say about it aside from just how terrible it is. I've seen a lot of like solidarity type things of Jews and Muslims, which I think is very nice. I think, to be honest, the fact that this

has nothing to do with Israel-Palestine makes it easier to just bypass that whole entire conflict and just like be supportive and embracing one religion to the other, which at the end of the day, in this case, is, I think, a positive reaction to a horrible event. Yeah, I think that the New Zealand thing feels like so much closer to home than even, you know, I was reading, you know, I think it was a church about two days later was attacked and people were gunned down in Kenya. But even to us... That feels a little bit different because we're, I think, kind of like, oh, well, we don't exactly know what happens over there. It's a little more complicated. We think of New Zealand as much more like, oh, it's a Western country like us and there's a religious minority. So the comparison feels more apt. But it's obviously such a tragedy. I don't know. I think it was a tough Shabbos, I think. I remember the last thing I saw before.

Turning off my phone before Shabbat this week was, do you get the New York Times alerts? This was an alert that said, hello, brother, the man at the New Zealand mosque door called out just before the approaching killer opened fire with a semi-automatic rifle. And that term, just hello, brother, like Shalom Aleichem or something like that, it really freaked me out. And during Shabbat, it was really disconcerting. I wonder, the way I think a lot of shuls really clamp down, like they put a lock and a combination code on the shul that I go to in Washington Heights after the shooting in Pittsburgh, I wonder how mosques are going to change.

It's sad to think that now you have to be more suspicious. It's a really sad situation. Yep. Well, changing gears a little bit, the topic that we wanted to talk about this week is something that was very much in the news last week, which was this college admissions scandal. Here's a clip from CNN explaining the story. We're here today to announce charges in the largest college admissions scam ever prosecuted by the Department of Justice.

A jaw-dropping scam dubbed Operation Varsity Blues involving at least 50 people, accusing wealthy parents of allegedly cheating so their children would be admitted into prestigious schools. One of the schemes involved parents allegedly paying millions for fake athletic credentials just so their children could gain entry to college by being accepted to the school's athletic team. To be clear, these were not really student-athletes. Singer helped parents take staged photographs of their children engaged in particular sports. In one example, the head women's soccer coach at Yale in exchange for $400,000.

accepted an applicant as a recruit for the Yale women's team, despite knowing that the applicant did not even play competitive soccer. So this is like a pretty juicy story. I think a lot of people were excited about it because of all the drama. And I guess Schadenfreude. Yeah, that's exactly what I was thinking. It touches on so many elements of wealth and privilege and competition and kids and adults and parenting. So, I mean, there's a lot to talk about, a lot to discuss. What are some of your thoughts or questions about this?

My initial instinct, and, you know, we do a lot of prep for these, and I thought my notes were really bouncing all over the walls here. Like, I had so many different instincts and so many things I was thinking about. But my first thing that I really kept coming back to was I just, I felt really bad for these kids. You know, I think it seems like most of these kids really didn't know about it. They were really completely shocked hearing this. I was a little bit skeptical about that, but in some of the cases, I'm sure it's true. It could be, and I could very well imagine that at least, you know, a minority of the kids knew about it.

or at least were maybe surprised that they had gotten in or didn't think that necessarily they had the grades to do it. But you can imagine, you know, like I didn't think that I would get into some schools also. Like sometimes, I mean, maybe my parents paid. Yeah, but you probably, I'm assuming, filled out your applications yourself and whatever. That's true. That's true. But, you know, I also, you know, I definitely had, first of all, I had college guidance at my school. And I remember, this is really embarrassing, but about six months ago, I was talking to friends of mine who had gone to public school and they mentioned something about guidance. It took me a while to put together, but basically they had a guidance counselor for the four years of their high school, which was just their guidance counselor, which was college guidance. And also like, how was your class?

schedule going all of those things and i didn't realize that not every school had college had all of these things divided up and also that we at my school had at least four college guidance counselors in addition to the regular guidance counselors or all those things well yeah first it's a slightly bigger school but still and in like a friend of mine who i was talking to there were i think you know 1200 1400 kids in her school and she had one counselor for the entire school so even though you know yes it's true that my parents did not send in my application for me i got a lot of help right you know that and that's also again part of the story we might be jumping ahead a little bit here but i did think that overall i felt really bad for these kids you know like to think that you had gotten in on your own merits, even if, you know, you're kind of oblivious and maybe you should have been a little bit more thoughtful here. And then to find out that you not only didn't, but you're now a laughingstock and everyone's making fun of you and making fun of your parents. It just felt really sad. Also, what's so sad about it is that, like, you haven't done things on your own and you're now an adult who hasn't done things on their own. I don't know. What do you think? Yeah, well, so, I mean...

There's a lot to say. I learned a new term today. I first saw it in an article and I kind of skimmed over it because I didn't really know what it meant. And then I saw it somewhere else and then you actually mentioned it before we started recording. That is snowplow parent. I've heard of helicopter parents, but I hadn't heard of snowplow parents. When did you learn that term? Just in reading this article. There's an article in the New York Times called How Parents Are Robbing Their Children of Adulthood. And basically the way to find snowplow parents are parents who kind of...

crush and move every possible obstacle out of the way to keep their children's futures bright and clear and that they can do anything they want to do. And that sometimes these snowplow parents might end up crossing ethical boundaries, legal boundaries or things like that in their effort to save or help their children. Yeah. I mean, to me, the more interesting discussion here revolves around the legal. aspects of this industry meaning obviously when people break the law when people are this was like so over the top which is part of why this story was so sensational and popular because like it involved bribes involved like people taking tests for other people photoshop photoshopping like athletes students out to athletes bodies and pretending that they were on the team like all that stuff is so obviously emails about like these crazy stories right it's it's very salacious it's very and as you said the shadow for it like there's there's also like this really exciting thing of like these elite crazy snobs who thought they were tricking us and getting one over on us but like now they look like it yeah i mean i think That makes me a little bit uncomfortable because I don't like class warfare. I think it's very dangerous. You prefer race warfare. Right. And that's something that has, you know, I think become more prevalent with the rise of Bernie Sanders, especially he's talking obsessively about the 1%, the 1%. He really is othering the richest people in the country as the evil people. And like, you could criticize them, but like, I think it goes way too far and it's dangerous to think of these people as evil people. Obviously here, they're breaking the law. Doesn't necessarily make them an evil person, just makes them a criminal, I guess. But I think it's more interesting to talk about the much more prevalent practice of...

parents paying also large amounts of money for other kinds of things like hundreds of hours of tutoring or these consultants and coaches who... craft like a brand that's something that's spoken on this story but like you know branding the kid of like what the perfect combination of extracurriculars and the clubs and the hobbies I'm sure plenty of these things will write a kid's essay for them and that's not something you can ever really prove was done if not write it for them then just help them a lot with it where it's basically the same thing and then obviously the more extreme thing of like donating a wing or a library to the university which is also not illegal but clearly we'll get in you know we'll get these kids into the school when they otherwise wouldn't and what also becomes muddy I just want to want to add to what you're saying because I totally agree that that is what's more difficult and also interesting is that that's just an extension of what I don't want to say we, is what I already had. I wrote the essay to get me into college, but there was a lot of red marks all over that thing by my parents, by the college guidance counselors, by my English teachers. There were a lot of people who had a voice in that. To say that it wasn't my paper, I think, wouldn't be fair. But to say that I didn't have a lot of help that many other kids don't have, just by virtue of the resources at my disposal, it would be lying if we didn't go into that also. There's clearly a spectrum there. And to also complicate that, one of the notes that I wrote down here is legacy.

Comma, affirmative action, comma, donations, comma, cheating. And obviously all four of those things are different, but those are all ways that students are given a leg up, right? And what else I didn't mention is athletics, right? Which is obviously part of what we talked about last week. But in, you know, in other countries, as I think we even talked about, athletics cannot be determined to help students get into college. So it's also a kind of interesting question of like, what is an appropriate leg up that gives you this advantage? And what is an inappropriate leg up that gives you this advantage? Right. I think...

Going even more broadly, America, the American dream and the American story is all about meritocracy and saying that unlike in classical Europe where there were certain families and hierarchies of who were the people who had privilege and who didn't, in America, the way it's supposed to be is everybody has equal opportunity and the harder you work and I guess the smarter you are, the more successful you will be and what your name is, what your religion is, your race, none of that is supposed to matter. In reality, depending on who you ask, that is either... partially true or not true at all right and this is kind of like maybe for a lot of people as kids their first introduction to the concept of like you thought things were gonna be fair but really life's not fair and then the question is when do we say this is just life's not fair and work with it, deal with it? Or do we say, let's try to level the playing field? Right. So, you know, when it comes to affirmative action, I saw a lot of people talking about that in this case where it's like, see, all these rich people breaking the law, doing all these crazy things, even when they're not breaking the law, it's still immoral and crazy how far and what lengths they go to to help their kids in. And so for affirmative action, all we're saying is for people who can't afford any of that and have such a disadvantage, arguably, like give them a little bit of a boost to balance that out. Right. What do you think of that argument?

I think I definitely understand it. I definitely hear it. I think it depends how it's implemented to how big of a boost are we talking about, you know? And I also just think, because you can make similar type of arguments with like social welfare programs and socialism, and again, back to Bernie Sanders, about when you try to do top-down, you know, government... interference or meddling to try to level the playing field, I think almost inevitably you're going to have unwanted consequences and you're going to have people taking advantage of that system. And the more meddling you do, the more problems you're going to produce that weren't there before. Even if you solve one, you're going to create three more. So I think that's very complicated. Yeah. I mean, I think just in terms of like, you know, I think of like people I know who, when they applied to college, checked off African-American because their parents were Moroccan, you know, Spartac Jews who are kind of saying, well, it's true. I'm an immigrant and they are immigrants. Well, that's not even worse than that would be. Well, you know, a white person from South Africa.

Right, right. I think that was actually a lawsuit. And I think the South African won. I thought you were going to mention Elizabeth Warren. Oh, no, no. Well, we've talked about her enough. I mean, the Moroccan thing, at least, you know, they're not white. So maybe they, you know. It's a complicated question. Right. No, no, I hear what you're saying. African-American is not meant to be about immigrants from Morocco. Right. I also think that actually an argument that I heard this week was on the affirmative action topic. Affirmative action is seen as a racial thing, but a much more fair way of thinking about affirmative action would be an economic.

thing, a money thing. Like, if you're poor, if you can show that your family just has no financial means, you can't afford tutors, you can't afford all the things that come along with privilege, then you should be eligible for this kind of help. And it shouldn't matter what race you are. Obviously, the counter argument to that is like... Wait, isn't that what financial aid is? What do you mean? Yes. They should be more eligible to get in because they're poor?

Well, yeah, financial aid doesn't help you get into the school. If you're poor, you can't afford tutors. You can't afford to go to a private school. That's exactly what affirmative action is doing. It's taking people who are disadvantaged and giving them a leg up. So, you know, the counter argument would be, okay, like just the fact of someone having white skin gives them an advantage. Doesn't matter if they're dirt poor and they're starving and whatever. And so, you know, this is the counter argument to that. So again, it's complicated. What part is that, you know, you're going to end up with...

hundreds or thousands of different classes and everyone gets you know a point number and it's that you get this much plus you get this much minus depending on like what category and what box get put into which is both sort of something that I think makes many of us uncomfortable which I think is fair but also becomes really untenable but one of the things that I actually think is kind of interesting and that this just struck me now is that I've been reading a lot about you know affirmative action and a lot about you know colleges in general how this works and one of the things which is often said after their study of affirmative action and stuff like this is that elite schools are really only beneficial in like a, you know, you end up in a higher tax bracket, you end up doing better, you have a better career, you know, things like that for people who come from a more marginalized community. So really, it provides a strong leg up for black people, for women, things like that, who otherwise could go to immigrants. Sorry, that's also an important group. But for white men, let's say, sorry, who for them going to Rutgers or going to CUNY, they end up really about the same as if they had gone to Harvard or Yale or Princeton. But what I think is kind of interesting is that the reason that...

these other marginalized group ends up doing better at Harvard, Yale, Princeton, is not just because their classes are better. And who knows? Maybe there are other classes better. Who freaking knows? Really, it's about the connections that they make there. And if you don't...

let in those legacy or don't give the leg up to the legacy kids or to the money kids or things like that, then the class ends up looking different and those connections are not there in the same way. So it's almost like this catch 22. I don't know if I explained that very well, but do you know what I'm saying? You're right. The catch 22 is without the privileged kids there. They're the ones who have the connections. They're going to give the connections to the less advantage. I also am a little bit skeptical of that argument. I think it's, it is true, but what it's kind of overlooking is the fact that it's, I think what it's really saying is the difference of the poor kid.

either going to an Ivy League or going to a state school or a community college or whatever is much more of a drastic difference in life outcome to a rich, upper-class kid either going to an Ivy League college or not going to college at all just because they're already rich and they're already connected. That doesn't mean that they're not getting anything from the experience. It just means they're probably going to be rich anyway. But if you're going to say that the education is just going to make them a more wholesome, thoughtful person, that's still there. And I think it's a little bit unfair to say, oh, they're not getting anything out of it anyway, so why should they even be going there? Wait, hold on. Sorry. I want to understand what you're saying. So what's the difference between

Let's say I'm choosing between – I'm from New Jersey. You're from New Jersey. So let's say I'm choosing between going to Rutgers and going to Harvard. What do you think the difference is? Yeah. I mean, so that's a little bit of a different – that's a little bit of a different discussion. I don't know exactly. I went to YU. I'm happy that I went to YU. I think –

As long as a school is like a decent school, and especially if it's a big school like Rutgers, you can get an incredible education at Rutgers. Obviously, the degree from Harvard, just having that on your resume afterwards does a ton. And like you said, the connections are, I'm sure, also extremely valuable in terms of the actual education. They probably have more world-class people teaching there, I assume. Or, I mean, they just do. I don't know if that makes them better teachers just because they do better research. Especially because, well, Rutgers is a huge university, so it might be different. But one of the things that people often say about Harvard is that you don't really even meet your professors. Right, right. I've heard that. But I mean, look at the Supreme Court. Look at the Senate and Congress. It's, again, chicken and egg. But, you know, the Ivy Leagues and even specific...

Leagues are extremely overrepresented in those groups. And so people have biases and assumptions. But as you said before, especially for these parents who were cheating the system, this was less about I'm concerned that my kid get the best education possible and much more about I want my kid to be in the right school. I want to do this thing to create this persona to help my kid succeed in whatever ways that means for this family. There's a status thing. That's a big part of it, which is not a practical. But I do think you're right. I went to a pretty good university. I went to Johns Hopkins in Baltimore. And the truth is that I do think that...

If I wanted to interview someplace, I think it'd be easier for me to get in the door than I think for a lot of other people. And I think that most of my friends did not go to elite universities. And I don't think that I'm smarter than them. And I don't think that I would do, even if I were smarter than them, I don't think I would do a better job than them. But again, I don't want to say, I don't think I'm smarter than them. But I also, I think that it's a false recognition. But then I wonder if, even though I think it's a false recognition, if I'm trapped in the same thing, like if I'm considering applicants, would I?

give preference to someone who applied from Harvard versus someone who went to Rutgers? I actually don't know. Well, maybe you're an exception. I think most people just have these biases, have these assumptions. You know, even it's funny. I don't like it, but I think maybe I would. There was somebody when I was at YU who dropped out of YU to like do his startup. And what people joked about was like, no, it's not cool to drop out of YU. That's just sad. Like dropping out of Harvard is the cool thing. You know, we hear Bill Gates or Mark Zuckerberg and people like that, like, whoa, he dropped out of Harvard. Like he never got the degree. So he does, but in a way this is even better than Harvard. So it's just like all psychological, but you drop out of YU. It's like, oh, that's sad.

Right. Well, we had a teacher in high school who he was one of our rebeam and he had, I think he was supposed to go to Penn and then he just decided to go to YU instead. And we just would like riff on him. Like, we always made fun of him. Like, do you feel stupid that you made that choice? Like, what'd you do? And like, you know, obviously it's ridiculous because I'm sure he got what he wanted, you know, out of college. But I just think it's a tough choice. And again, I think about it also from a little bit of a personal perspective, and this is not about me, but I had a really good experience at my college. And to a certain extent, it feels like maybe it's somewhere to Frisch. And that Frisch, because it was...

Frisch was different. It was a private school, and they cared a lot about academics, so they gave you certain resources. You had the college guidance counselor. You had all these things. And Hopkins, because it was a smaller school than Rutgers, and also because it's an elite school, there are a lot of opportunities there for advancement, for intellectual things, for fellowships. There's a lot of programs that give you a ton of money if you want to study abroad and do cool research and all those things. But the truth is that most students, I don't think, even take advantage of those programs. So I think there could be more advantages. But also, even as I'm saying that, I think those things exist at every university. But I think most people don't know about them anywhere. I think if you're at Rutgers, there are also incredible opportunities. Yeah. I mean, there are certain schools, obviously, like YU, that have something unique to offer that you can't just...

get at any school. And that's the reason why people will go there, even if they could have gotten in somewhere else. But there's also the status thing that people just want to go to the most prestigious school they can get into. And so I personally think, on the one hand, I do think, you know, getting back to the morality and ethics of, you know, these parents that put, you know, thousands and thousands of dollars into their kids, you know, application process and test taking stuff. I do think there's a problem with that, but I don't think we can outlaw it because that's not how America works. I think the change would come.

by a cultural attitude change, which I think there is already. I mean, there probably always has been, but it feels a little bit more so with tuition going through the roof and also maybe with the Bernie Sanders stuff and whatever, there is a little bit of a pushback to like, well, maybe these elite schools are not the end-all be-all. Maybe we don't need that. You know, we have examples of people who are very successful who either didn't go to college at all, which has like always been that way, or have went to state schools or whatever. And that's cool too. I mean, I'm just thinking of people that I know and even that's a problem now for YU because YU has very high tuition. People can go to Queens and get a very good and not pay the tuition there, whatever it is. So I think that if we wanted to, if people, if the country would ever want to make it,

change and move away from, like, these overbearing parents, like, giving unfair adventures to their kids instead of outlawing it. I think it's just a question of making it more clear in our society that, like, that's not the ultimate thing to go to Harvard. They're much more important things. I think, you know, getting back to the specific case, Uri, I wanted to hear a little bit what you thought about just the cheating thing in general, because even though cheating to get into college is not something that I think we're so familiar with, like, you know, this is a pretty extreme case, but I think cheating itself is an interesting... it's an interesting phenomenon that I think also exists very much in the religious community. And I was thinking specifically about something that happened when I was in high school, which was there was a kid who went to another, and I want to say also that none of this is confirmed. This is just what everyone said when we were in school. There was a student who was in my grade who went to a different high school, and he was kicked out of that school, a different, you know, local Jewish, exactly, private school. He was kicked out of that school for cheating on the SATs. His parents then donated a lot of money to Frisch, which is where I went to school. Again, if Frisch wants to call us and say, this is absolutely not what happened, here's a real story, happy to hear it, but this is what every single person said.

He then was accepted at Frisch. He was a very, very good hockey player and I think became assistant captain or captain as soon as he entered Frisch. Frisch won the championships in the hockey league that year, which is a big thing, floor hockey in Yeshiva Day Schools. So I think about when I was 17 and the lessons that I learned. I mean, the truth is that I think 17-year-olds, a lot of them are already grappling with things like this, but I remember being so angry. Like, I remember being like, what the heck? It's not fair. It's so not fair. And what are you even trying to teach us? You're a school. You're trying to impart values on us and this is what you do. So what are you trying to teach us? And it's embarrassing.

Yeah, I mean, I agree. I think in one way that story is just objectively not fair and seems wrong. I will put in a couple of caveats. Like one is that we're talking about high school and not college. I think especially in the religious Jewish community, I think there's a mentality of like, we want to do everything we can to ensure that a kid and a family who wants to send their kid to a yeshiva is able to. And so, yeah, they had to be kicked out of that first school. But for no other yeshiva to accept that kid now.

could be problematic for their future religiously, not academically. And for all I know, he was in serious counseling. I have no idea. We talk about shuva and that kind of thing. We're talking about a kid here. And hopefully there was a shuva process of understanding what he did wrong and not doing it again. I think cheating is a big problem, unfortunately, in the religious community, like in all communities. I mean, I went to YU and there was actually a very big cheating scandal when I was there. And it happened. It was very embarrassing because the president of the university made this big announcement.

about zero tolerance for cheating. And then within a couple of months, I think, or that same academic year, there was this massive scandal and they didn't do zero tolerance because there's so many people involved. Very, very sad. I think without getting too much into it because we have to wrap up, I think part of why people rationalize and justify it is because it seems like a victimless crime. Like you're not taking money from anybody. No one is physically being hurt. It's not a victimless crime because it's unfair and you're kind of robbing everyone else in the system of a fair ranking and grade, obviously. But I think that's what people...

tell themselves in their head and that's why it might be a little bit different from other types of crimes and things. Well, I think in particular, with Frisch, that's a fair example because it's not like there was another kid who was getting displaced for him to come in. In that particular case, even more so, yeah. And... it's hard because again, like I think oftentimes I don't, I don't want to begrudge the kids. I think so often there's a cultural problem. This is a parent's problem. This is a sort of, my kid needs to be the best. And you know, we go back to the snowplow. Right. But I do think this is a difficult thing and I think you're, you're completely right. This is going to need a serious cultural shift. And I think this is the kind of thing where I feel like often, I don't know, or sometimes I don't know myself, you know, am I, am I liberal or conservative? Cause I think I feel very conservative about things like this. I'm like, if public college was good enough for my, my grandparents would have killed to gone to Queens college. And like, here we are, you know, talking about bribery to get into USC. And I'm like, what is this world?

Well, that's our show. And as always, the conversation does not stop with us. We really, really, really want to hear from you. Please be in touch with us by email. TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. Reading your emails is often the highlight of our week. I mean, my life's pretty boring. So I would say definitely highlight of my week. I don't know about you, Ari. Yeah, definitely. We highlighted Eitan last week and he followed up with another really long email, which we can't talk about him every week. But thank you, Eitan. Eitan, keep them coming. And whoever else wants to join in that conversation will give you a shout out as well. And of course, if you have not yet done so, please rate and review us on iTunes. Give us five stars if you feel so inclined. And once I said about the shout outs, we got a really nice email feedback from Avi, big friend of the show. And so I want to give him a shout out also. And thanks as always to

Drive-In Productions. They are the sponsor of this week's episode. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Coughless. Bye, everyone. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 34 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on March 20, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.