Skip to content
69. Why Do We Watch Game Of Thrones? episode artwork

May 21, 2019 41 min

69. Why Do We Watch Game Of Thrones?

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

[Disclaimer: while there are no spoilers in the description, there will be spoilers in the episode itself!!] This week, we all finally watched the series finale of Game of Thrones, HBO's hugely popular epic fantasy TV series, based on George RR Martin's series of novels, "A Song of Ice and Fire." Uri and Rivky talk about their experiences of the show and ask, is it weird that, as religious people, we are so casually and publicly invested in a show filled with graphic violence, graphic sex, and graphically violent sex? They also ask about the show's treatment of women, and religion, and explore what the implications of both have for our society today. Related links: https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/bergen/teaneck/2019/05/19/israeli-ambulance-service-fundraiser/3709830002/ https://groknation.com/culture/game-of-thrones-is-back/?fbclid=IwAR2Pwv0KUNY4wh0bZh3NwWM7KGVAUR7UeoCv7RYSEswJkDXZoHXnGimBMxY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6YFcwzOubM

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

[Disclaimer: while there are no spoilers in the description, there will be spoilers in the episode itself!!] This week, we all finally watched the series finale of Game of Thrones, HBO's hugely popular epic fantasy TV series, based on George RR Martin's series of novels, "A Song of Ice and Fire." Uri and Rivky talk about their experiences of the show and ask, is it weird that, as religious people, we are so casually and publicly invested in a show filled with graphic violence, graphic sex, an...

Ready to play

69. Why Do We Watch Game Of Thrones?

0:00 41:54
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rifki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So, Uri, our mutual hometown where we both grew up had a very special visitor this week. Yeah, well, we spoke last week about Rashida Tlaib and the very controversial things that she said on that Yahoo podcast. And then out of nowhere, she shows up in Teaneck at a mosque. I mean, I have to imagine she heard the podcast. She wanted to chat with us. She assumed we'd be at home. Yeah, so I think there was just, you know, cross-liars and miscommunication that didn't work out. Actually...

I have, I remember seeing that mosque in Teaneck for the first time when I was like a senior in high school, just like going for a walk and being like, what is this place? Yeah, but it's huge. I think it's like a Bergen County kind of landmark for the Muslim community, but it's not in the center of like where a lot of the Orthodox people live and worship and stuff. Hebrew Hills. Yeah, exactly. So it's a little bit further out. But yeah, I didn't know about it until I was a little older. Yeah. So I saw it was the, actually listener, Rina, friend of the show, sent me the cover of the Suburbanite, which is the local Teaneck paper. And Rashida Tlaib is there wearing a head covering and she says- Which she doesn't usually wear. Doesn't usually. And she made a surprise visit to this mosque, but it did say that she didn't take any questions. She gave some sort of short speech, but then she didn't take any questions

But then there was another incident in Teaneck. We're recording this on Monday. So yesterday, there was a fundraiser at a local shul in Teaneck for Magen David Adom, the Israel ambulance first responders. And there was a protest against that fundraiser, I think actually led by a Teaneck resident who was Jewish, but it was pretty small, about a dozen or so people, basically protesting Israel, waving Palestinian flags, calling Israel a terrorist state. We'll include a link to an article about this in the description.

And what was really sweet, and a couple of listeners sent in these pictures, was that the house next door to this protest, this pro-Palestinian protest, the family that lived there set up, like, a lemonade stand with Israeli flags, and they were raising money for Maghainte Veda Dome. They posted on Facebook they raised over $1,000 just from that lemonade stand, which is really sweet. And apparently the Palestinian people left, but the Israel people stayed longer, and more people came to support them, which was a nice Teaneck-Israel representation. That's interesting. I didn't realize that it was a Teaneck resident who had started the protest. That's what it says in the article. It actually says his name, but you can look at the article. It's not at Princeton, Newark, or Fort Lee.

Hackensack or Parsippany. But after traveling around, I'm so glad I found T and N and J. I don't need my walk. T and N and J. Jersey's got ya. T and N and J.

For the main topic this week, we thought we'd do something a little bit different. Many of you may be aware that this past Sunday was the series finale of the show Game of Thrones that kind of over the last couple of years has really become a phenomenon. I think maybe the biggest show on TV or one of the biggest. Yeah, I think Big Bang Theory actually is the biggest show on TV. But Game of Thrones, definitely the most talked about on internet the next day. It's a huge cultural phenomenon in a way that is outsized compared to just the number of viewers. Right. So, I mean, it's a very interesting thing. This show's been around, I think, since 2011. And it's obviously based on books that were written years before that. That actually is not...

completed yet so about five or six years ago when the show was already kind of a big deal I heard people talking about it I saw people posting about it so I said okay I'll check it out and I'm definitely not judging anybody who watches it or doesn't watch it but I watched the first episode and I was just really really grossed out disturbed on many levels in all kinds of ways it's just like really like gratuitous sex and violence and even more than that, just like disturbing ideas and images and storylines. And so I was like, okay, I'm not watching this show. And then I didn't until a few weeks ago when everybody was like so obsessed with it. I finally caved in and I kind of binged the whole thing. But Rifki, do you watch it? So just want to also add that we're going to try to avoid spoilers, but...

It might happen just because this is an episode about Game of Thrones. So if you're not interested in hearing anything about the show, turn it off now. We won't be offended. So I, like you, I didn't really watch the show from the beginning. I had read the books. And I basically just picked up the series starting from season seven last year because my then boyfriend, now husband, was interested in me watching it with him because he was very into the show. And then as I was watching season seven and now season eight, I kind of also started again from the beginning and have been kind of slowly catching up. So I'm sort of simultaneously in two universes. And it's kind of interesting to watch it that way. It's a different experience. Okay, interesting, yeah. One thing that I'm really struck by in regards to the show, and Rifti, I'm really curious to hear what you think about this. I'm really surprised how mainstream the show is. I'm like surprised how it seems like almost everyone.

Everybody is watching it and everybody is just so open about the fact that they're watching like like even like rabbis. And I'm not talking about anyone in particular, but like people like this show is so graphic. I think it's very ironic that the over the years and last few years, our society has become so sensitive and politically correct in so many ways. And especially in terms of assault and violence against women and people in general, but also things like the anti-bullying movement and just like this general aversion and move away. from traditional power and its place in society. But yet the TV show that everyone is talking about and that everyone can't stop watching is really like the exact opposite of all those things in such an extreme way, in a way that I think TV and movies haven't really been in the past. It's really to a new level. And yes, you could say those things are portrayed kind of negatively in the show, more or less. But there's definitely an element of enjoyment that people are getting from watching this. Otherwise, they wouldn't be watching it. I mean, Rifki, do you agree? Do you see like an irony there?

I think there is something there. What's difficult about Game of Thrones is that you're surrounded by depravity and you're looking at all of these characters and you're disgusted. You're disgusted at the way many of these men are treating women and you're disgusted by the way that these people are treating anyone who isn't in a position of power. And you're also disgusted at the way that women in positions of power are treating others, right? There's a lot that is really, really awful in addition to the gratuitous sex and violence and nudity and not just gratuitous nudity, by the way. I also want to be clear, like really disturbing depictions of rape and assault and killing in just really the most horrific ways you can imagine. And I think what's confusing about this is that these things are so disgusting and so depraved, but you also, you're not meant to like the...

characters who are perpetrating these evils right it's not like you're supposed to look at them and be like oh wow that's kind of cool you know but at the same time it does seem a lot more disgusting and unnecessary than is necessary in a way that probably that's because they know that people kind of want to watch those things, which makes it harder to sort of grapple. That's my question. That's what really intrigues me. I think a lot of people would probably say that they watch the show in spite of all of the gratuitous nudity and violence, basically the overall depravity of the show. And I wonder if that's actually true. I wonder if the show would still be as popular if it wasn't for those elements. There's no question that the show is incredibly well made in terms of the story and the character development. Just the cinematography alone is really incredible. And I've watched some of the behind the scenes.

huge amounts of money and resources and talent into this show. I think a lot of things were done on the show that have never really been done in anything before in terms of some of the special effects and things like that. But I really wonder, does this say something about our society? Like, you know, in Roman times, they had gladiator fights. And we see that as so barbaric that like people's entertainment was to watch human beings being ripped apart by either animals or other people. And we look at that, we look down on that as like, wow, that was like prehistoric, horrible. But this is in a way the exact same thing. Like, yes, it's not quote unquote real because nobody's actually getting hurt.

But we are viewing basically the same thing. And I think a lot of people, maybe everybody on some level, derives that kind of enjoyment from seeing that. And I think the interesting thing is that most people, I think, wouldn't acknowledge that. But I still think it's happening. Well, one of the things that I think feels a little bit different about Game of Thrones, and tell me if you disagree with this, is that I think one of the reasons we watch Game of Thrones is because these people often are so bloodthirsty, but the good guys are generally bloodthirsty for sort of vengeance purposes, right? There are good people who are wronged, who are either killed, who shouldn't be killed, or put in positions of victimhood that they shouldn't be. And then you have other good guys who are out to sort of...

either avenge their murders or rescue them or save them. And I think many of us watching, I think I kind of feel this way, is I'm kind of watching with the hope that the bad guys will get their comeuppance. And I don't want to see the violence, but I also want to see these bad characters be killed in such a gruesome way. And I'll cover my eyes and I don't really want to see it, but I also want to see that the good guys are going to come out ahead. I want to see that when they murder and when they rape and when they do these awful things to innocent people, that eventually they'll get what's coming to them.

That's interesting. But I think that's a bad thing also, right? Like, I think even that impulse of me saying, I want to watch violence be done to them because violence, because they committed acts of violence to other people. I don't want to be thinking that. Like, I don't think that's a great approach either. Right. Well, I actually think part of what makes the books and the show so...

interesting and popular also is that there are there aren't really clear good guys and bad guys for the most part I think people contrast it like clearly the series was heavily influenced by Lord of the Rings and J.R.R. Tolkien and I think George R.R. Martin he took the R.R. just as a tribute to J.R.R. Tolkien but what made it different and the new spin that he put on it was that Lord of the Rings has very clear good guys and bad guys for the most part and this is not like that this is much more complex much more modern in that way you see that on a lot of dramas nowadays so therefore you have quote unquote bad guys who you at times will sympathize with and who also do some good things and the reverse is also true you have quote unquote good guys that you thought were good but and then they'll do a really bad thing and then oh well are they good do I like them and that in itself makes for a very interesting story but in terms of just again you know the depravity of it and what that says about society so I mean yes a lot of people have in the past few years I'm spoken out against this one of the main ones that I've seen is Mayim Bialik wrote a whole write-up about how horrible Game of Thrones is she acknowledges and the thing this actually reminded me of something that we did last year but she talks about it but she acknowledges that she never actually saw the show and we

Talked about a movie last year that we had seen. We're not going to do that again. Don't worry, guys. But so, I mean, let's talk about some of her criticism and what we think about it. She focused very heavily on the portrayal of women in the show. Right. And especially the sexual violence, but not exclusively the sexual violence. Right. Yeah, so Mayim kind of breaks up her issues. It is funny because she doesn't watch it, but she's spoken to a lot of people who watch the show. She kind of breaks up the issues into separate points of contention. The first thing she says is women are generally used as wallpaper. I mean, I think that's true. Like a lot of scenes take place in brothels. You have a lot of naked women just kind of sitting around. They don't really have lines. Or if they have lines, they're kind of, you know, one note. They're not seen as main characters. They're just kind of there.

naked um the second thing is that gore is used repeatedly and that's gore in sexual violence but also just in violence generally and i think that's true too you know you have eyes that are gouged out you have people's entrails just spilling out into the open in a way that i don't think i've seen before in another show and definitely is disgusting obviously you have beheadings you have other really intense sickening deaths all the time and not even just that it's also that uh rape is almost a tool in ways like i think you even have a character in this current season who someone said to her that he felt so awful for her for the way that she'd been treated she'd been you know raped repeatedly and her response was no no that actually I wouldn't be who I am if it weren't for that. And a lot of people came out very strongly against that in cultural criticism, talking about how disturbing that is as a way. And you also have the counter argument of saying, no, that's how she views herself. That's not necessarily what we, the showrunners, are saying, but it's kind of like a difficult situation. So she brings these arguments, and I think some of them feel a little bit weaker. Ari, what do you think about this? I think overall...

I very strongly sympathize with her perspective because I was the same way or a version of that up until a few weeks ago where I had my one, you know, episode of the show that I saw was, I found very disturbing. I'm like, I don't want to watch this. And I think this is just a weird thing that how is this the most popular thing that everyone's talking about? On the other hand, just in a way to play devil's advocate, I think her real problem or part of her real problem is just the pornographic element of the show. And she basically says that in so many words, but she, she, you know.

phrases it in a way of like violence towards women. But the one scene that she did see that she talks about is not a rape. It's more just pornographic. And then she actually talks about pornography. That's like an analogy that she makes to the show of like how the show is sort of like mainstreaming that kind of content. And I totally get the discomfort or the opposition to like a show, a mainstream show having that kind of stuff on screen. But like...

In terms of showing rape or rape being part of the plotline, I don't think the writers of the show or the books want us to think that rape is a good thing, obviously. I think it brings up a lot of things in the show. There's an extended plotline about somebody who's tortured, and the guy who's tortured is actually a pretty bad guy, but you definitely are supposed to feel bad for him. I came away from that, obviously disgusted, but also like, wow, that actually affected my perspective on torture, even torturing bad guys. My question against Mayim is, is she saying that we should never show racism on screen? We should never show torture? We should never show anything bad that we don't agree with? Meaning, what if the purpose of it is to walk away seeing how horrible it is?

these things are, I could see that being a constructive thing. I don't fully understand the argument to say this should not even be alluded to or shown. You know, what if it just wasn't shown as graphically, but rape was still part of the story? Like, would her opposition be just as strong? You know, not to mention the fact that, yes, this story takes place in like a fictional alternate universe, but it's obviously supposed to sort of be like the Middle Ages. And of course, in those times, and also now, but especially then.

violence against women and power structures and patriarchy, let's call it, was obviously a massive part of the world. And that was just everyday life in a lot of ways. So is she saying that if we're going to depict that time period, we shouldn't be true to what it was actually like? You know, that's why I didn't fully understand. Also, the fact that she didn't actually watch the show, I think she mischaracterized certain things. The fact that women are like, you know, wallpaper or whatever, like, first of all, there's...

Tons of men that are wallpaper in the show also. They're not naked. It's not the same. But also, most many of the main characters in the show actually are women. There are a lot of powerful women. There are good guys. There are good gals and bad gals. Women really represent almost every possible role here in the show. And so I do think, just from the purely feminist question, I don't think it's as simple as she is portraying it to be, if that really is her main problem with the show.

I think some of that feels fair. I don't think that, I mean, you guys can read Mime's article and see for yourself. I don't think that what she was saying is you should never depict rape and you should never depict racism and you should never depict anything bad and the only things on TV should be rainbow puppies. I don't think that's what she was saying. I think she was saying that in some of the ways, right, like she called out certain things where there are, you know, a YouTube video which just shows the rape scene where a specific character who is a bad guy, quote unquote, or bad gal, is raped. And you have people in the comments saying she deserved it. You know, things like that. Because she was bad, she deserved it. And that, to her, felt very disturbing. And I totally agree with that. You have other scenes where there's also a really intense rape scene, which is...

To me, one of the most disturbing scenes in the show. I don't even want to say what it is. It's really, really, really awful. And you have women in the comment section saying, this is what I want done to me. And you have men in the comments saying, this is the way- Okay, but that doesn't mean that the show shouldn't have been made because people are making like- ridiculous comments on the... Meaning, she's not saying the show shouldn't have been made. She's saying shows like this are harmful for society. I think that's really, in some ways, a fair claim. And what's hard for me, and I want to hear what you think, but for me, I struggle with it. I do like the show, and I do watch the show, and I do think the show does bring up interesting and important things, but it also puts me into a place where I'm watching really disgusting, awful, terrifying things, and I'm not turning it off. And I don't love that I'm doing that. Well, Mayim also talks about how things like this cause us to become desensitized to these types of things, which does make sense. Also, the porn analogy there as well. Right, desensitized. And then the question is that she doesn't...

directly addressed, but I'm wondering is what is the, what are the repercussions of that desensitization? Like, You know, people talk about violent video games making society more violent. And there is a logic to that. I'm not sure if it actually is demonstrated in the data. So I think my issue that I would take with the Mayim piece is not that I disagree with her point that, you know, maybe we shouldn't be watching this or maybe this is not what should be, you know, on TV and kids watching and whatever. I guess I just think that she a little bit missed the point. Like, she seemed to be really, she really was focusing on the way that women are portrayed. And that is the main problem here. And I actually think, first of all, showing people and women being treated horribly.

is not inherently a bad thing because stories are supposed to make us uncomfortable in order to get the point across. And in the same way that, like I said, like torture and other kinds of violence and racism and whatever, like it's important for stories to address those issues. And I think she also, I think if the argument that she's making would be stronger, if it was more about just like the general, the graphic nature of the show in general, whether it's the violence, whether it's the sex and questioning, like in order to tell that story, do you need to be that graphic? Do you need to show that much? And then, and I'm wondering if.

all the violence and the sex is sort of like secondary to the story and secondary to the fact that the show is so popular, or again, if that's really the reason it's so popular. Right, if there's something sort of depraved in us that that's sort of what we're attracted to, even though it's what we say is the reason that we kind of turn away in some ways. I mean, there's no question that people, like sex sells, everybody knows that, and it's always been true. I think it's just like each show and movie that has come out over the years has to one-up the previous one, and so it just becomes more and more graphic, and ironically, as society has become more and more sensitive. To these kind of things. It's interesting. I mean, I think we have to separate issues because I think we are more sensitive to the idea of, you know, sexual assault and rape and things like that. But we're not more uptight about nudity, right? Than we were. Yeah, I don't think that part is true. And I actually think that that's the part that I find more disturbing. The part that I kind of agree with my.

and really sympathize with, is I do think that there are, even though it's true that there are strong, powerful women who are really complex figures, you know, we've talked about, I think, the Bechdel test on the show before, that it's a test that I think is from the 70s or 80s by Alison Bechdel, where basically a movie or show passes, quote unquote, the Bechdel test, if there are a couple of criteria that are met. If it's multiple women in conversation with each other about something other than a man. So all three of those criteria needs to be met. Multiple women in conversation with each other without... I think the show passes that. Absolutely passes that. It is with flying colors. And a lot of other shows that we think of as more progressive, you really don't have that. When women are talking to each other, it's about a male character very often. Because there are multiple women here on all levels of character. And they really matter. They're talking about real things. They're talking about war strategy. There's real stuff going on. And I think that part is amazing. But I agree with her that it's true that there is a lot of gratuitous nudity unrelated to rape in which you're just supposed to see that in the background of two people speaking. Yes, of course, that's because the scene is in a brothel. But the scene doesn't need to be in a brothel. The word gratuitous is the key point here. The question is, why do they choose to put that in? And is it necessary? Very famously,

Schindler's List came out in the 90s. It was a little bit before our time. A lot of high schools, public schools and Jewish schools, including the one that I went to, took the entire student body, or maybe it was just certain grades, to see the movie. And that movie has nudity in the concentration camp, which is obviously very essential to understanding how horrible that experience was. But they're also like...

There's a sex scene that has nudity that has nothing directly to do with that. And I read an interview. They asked Steven Spielberg why did he include it in the movie when he knew that a lot of people would want to bring their kids and whatever. And his answer was very unconvincing to me. He said he wanted to make sure that the movie got an R rating. So he included that scene to ensure the R rating so that people would treat it as like, you know, they wouldn't just bring little kids and stuff. There wouldn't be an R rating just from the violence in that movie? I don't know. I'm just saying that's the answer he gave. I don't work for whatever the rating association is. But that's just like an interesting example also that goes back to that question of was this necessary for the story? Why was it included?

And the fact that it was included, and these are massive budgeted things with, you know, a lot of people working behind them, they thought very carefully about what to include, what not to include. Everything's very deliberate. And the fact that it's included says something about the audience, the target audience, what people want to see. So let me ask you a question. I mean, as a religious person, as someone who generally tries to maybe be careful about things, you see things you don't see, you know, something that like I think is, it's definitely something that I kind of value a little bit. I would imagine maybe it's something that you value a little bit. Are you at all uncomfortable with the depiction?

kind of feel guilty about it? Do you feel like, I think you kind of alluded to this in the beginning, but do you feel like it's weird that we are so sort of public about it? Like, what are your thoughts about this? Yeah, I definitely feel uncomfortable about it. I mean...

I don't judge anybody for anything. I try not to. And it's sort of like, if everybody that I heard, before I watched the show, if everybody that I heard from said like, oh, this show is like really gross and disgusting and whatever, like either I wouldn't watch it or if I watched it, I wouldn't tell people that I watched it. You'd like be a little embarrassed. Yeah, for sure. And I've just been so surprised how mainstream it is. Everyone's talking about it. So it's like, if everyone else is doing it, all these people that are like totally religious are all watching and talking about it. Like, I guess I'll watch it. I guess I can talk to them about it, you know? It's like, yeah, I'm definitely uncomfortable with it. And I guess it says something about, you know.

where we are in the world modern orthodoxy you could say that like you know that question of how much to let in from general culture and it's like if this is the mainstream general culture right now then what does that say about the lifestyle that tries to incorporate mainstream culture with traditional judaism like is that even possible in a way it's a question i'm not sure it's interesting i actually have a good friend i'm not sure if he would even remember this story but i have a good friend who about seven years ago i guess when the show was already becoming popular and i was definitely not watching the show and he mentioned something about game of thrones and he said You know, I watch an episode or two, but honestly, you know, I just don't I don't feel comfortable. I don't think it's for me. I don't think it's something that I want to engage in. I just I don't feel like that's right for me as a religious person. He's a very religious guy. And now I don't think he remembers that conversation. And he is an avid fan. And we talk about it every week. Right. Like this season, we've been sort of like talking about a lot together. And I think it's kind of interesting because I think you're right that I think sometimes something with my orthodoxy does a lot of things right. And I'm not saying this is going to do wrong. Again, I am fully engaged in it. I am in it. I am watching it. But I think that when.

people more to the right, quote unquote, or people from yeshivish communities or people from, you know, Haredi communities or chassidish communities when they talk about, oh, modern orthodoxy thinks that they're so intellectual. They think they're so, no, they just want to watch things like Game of Thrones. This is just what they want to do and they're lying to themselves about what they really stand for. Right, or on the flip side, when they have the attitude of we have to close off TV and movies and like, there is something to that and we shouldn't just dismiss it as ridiculous. Yeah. I think on that point, it's a good transition to a subcategory within the show, you know, moving past just the general idea of like, how are we even watching this thing and how gross is it?

It is really, really well made. And in terms of, like I said, the story and the cinematography, one running theme throughout the show that comes up in a lot of different ways is the idea of religion. In this world of the story, I guess you could say polytheistic, different kingdoms have different belief systems, different gods and whatever, but it does come up a lot in different ways. My overall impression when it came to that was that the writers of the show and the books portray religion pretty badly, meaning... The people who follow religion are not really the good guys. They're not really seen as very moral people. There isn't even like a direct connection between God and morality. And more than that, a lot of really bad stuff is done like in the name of religion. And also a lot of the main characters kind of like ridicule.

the people who take religion seriously. Was that your impression? How did you take that whole element? Yeah, I mean, I definitely think it's true. I think looking at the gods and how the people relate to the gods in Game of Thrones, it seems to me very clear that gods are about power. Gods can give you power. You worship the god. You sacrifice to the god. You give these things to the god. You have a relationship with the god only to gain more power. There's no sense in any of the people vying for power or in any of the people just vying to do good for themselves that they're looking to god or to their god for any sort of moral clarity of sort of like, oh, I don't know what to do. I don't know how to behave. I'm going to look to god. It's much more about...

This God promises me that I can win this battle if I do X thing, so I'm going to do X thing. It's meant to be sort of a throwback to Egyptian gods or to any sort of polytheistic system in general. Greek mythology. Yeah, absolutely. It's a trade, right? I do this thing for this God because then this God will do this thing for me. And it really isn't about creating a moral system where when I think, I hope, when we talk about something like Judaism, we look at it as really a moral system. Yes, maybe there are some laws and maybe there are some obligations and we do certain things, but really it's about creating a better society and creating better people internally. And that's not at all how the writers or how the characters envision a relationship with God. Well, I mean, I agree with that for the most part. And I think what mainly just struck me was that

I perceived it as this is the writers and the writers reflecting general society today of like not seeing religion in a very good light. There's actually a whole plot line of like these religious fanatics who take control of the capital city in King's Landing and they imprison a guy basically for being gay and they imprison his sister for sticking up for him. And they're like, on the surface, he's almost like a Jesus type. He walks around barefoot and he wears like rags and whatever. But the show really wants you to feel, and he is in the world of the show, just really cruel, evil, evil person. There's also a funny thing that, it's not funny, but in the show, there's basically a child sacrifice thing where like this guy, he wants to be king.

witch is helping him and she's like, well, the God of light needs you basically to sacrifice your daughter, burn her at the stake, and then that's going to appease the God and going to help you in your victory. It was actually very reminiscent to me of Akedat Yitzhak. Really? I think you said you missed that season or you didn't get up to that one yet. Yeah, so for the listeners, tell me if you agree. But it's very reminiscent and it really made me think because the truth is...

The concept of God asking Abraham to sacrifice his son, yes, in the end, he didn't have to do it. But even just in the first place, like, I mean, obviously, everybody talks about this, and all the Jewish thinkers throughout the ages have talked about this. But yeah, it is disturbing. And to an outsider, let's say, learning about Judaism, reading the Bible, and you're like, oh, this is the God that you're saying is so great. He tells Abraham to sacrifice his son. Right, again, I mean, it's speaking about God in terms of power. It's like, well, this deity, this power wants something from me, so I have to do it. And it's not at all about creating a sense of morality. And I think that feels like the strongest contrast, I think, to the way I really think about religion. And I think of, I look at the Torah, I look at the Bible, and I look at some of our greatest leaders. So we look at someone like an Abraham, which is kind of

like the Binding of Isaac, or we look at Moses, we look at Moshe, we look at, you know, so many of our leaders who one of the things that we talk about so much is how humble they are, right? Moses refused the leader, the mantle of leadership, right? I was gonna bring that up. And I think it's like the opposite, right? All of these characters who all they want is to sit on that chair. Right, but I think, but that's also, I think part of the depth of the show and the story relates to that. And they acknowledge, again, the writers want you to feel that power breeds corruption. And somebody who starts off with good intentions or you think has good intentions, when they get too much power, just go crazy and just start killing innocent people. It ends up being...

Either Jon Snow or Bran, who you think is going to be king and the guy who ends up being king, both of them didn't really want it. And the show clearly has a message of the person who is most appropriate and suitable for the power is the person who resists it and doesn't want it. That's very reminiscent of Moshe, who we call the greatest leader that the Jewish people ever had. That was exactly what he did. He didn't want the power. That was another parallel to Bible. I'm about to do a spoiler for the last episode. Well, I just spoiled it. But I want to say something a little bit more explicit. I do think it's interesting that Jon Snow, who is the one who ultimately, you know, a lot of people are like, oh, he's going to end up on the iron throne. And he said, I don't want it. I don't want it. Even he kind of admitted.

Well, that's him being humble. Maybe, maybe, but also it's him recognizing his own humanity. Bran isn't human. Bran doesn't have those same... Well, I thought that was so dumb. The last episode really disappointed me. Well, whether it's dumb or not, I think what they're saying is fundamentally it cannot be a person at all because no one is capable of letting go of those flaws. No one is capable of letting go of personal slights. And I think that's really intense. And I think maybe there's something to it because even Moshe Rabinu, he messes up, right? And he too sometimes has pride. Overall, I think that's really not his issue. And I think that's what's so beautiful. Bran becoming king was... One of the reasons it was so disappointing was because if we're supposed to take messages from this into the real world, that's not something we can take because Bran is not a person that we can relate to. He's not even a real person.

so you need every leader is flawed even the greatest leaders are flawed and that is the point look at Sansa who becomes queen of the north and even her like and I think in a lot of ways she really deserves it right she's been incredible lady of the north I mean this is a lot of spoilers sorry guys but she's done a lot for her people and for her kingdom quote unquote well now it really is a kingdom but even her you know when she's walking down and everyone's you know bowing to her she's got that smile and it's a little scary because even someone like her in a lot of ways she is very good but anyone You know, absolute power corrupts. Absolutely. And I think it's scary and it feels very real. Right. Well, there was that funny scene when they're having like that board meeting and Sam proposes that they do like democracy and everybody laughs in his face. It's a little bit too much because it was very clear what joke and message they were trying to give to us, the modern audience. Yeah, for the viewers. Right. But I mean, I guess that's the point of any kind of monarchy. You know, it reminded me of the thing with Daenerys, you know, flying around on the dragon and killing everybody. It reminded me of, you know, like Soviet Russia, where like their stated goals and ideals were very lofty. And there are still people who, you know, are Marxist. Lots of very left wing people, you know, care so much about the world and about people call themselves Marxist because they have.

have these lofty goals. But when it was actually put into practice, because it wasn't a democracy and there weren't those checks and balances, tens of millions of people ended up being killed in the name of those high lofty ideals. It was kind of very similar to what happened in the show. So just trying to think about the analogy of someone like Bran, who really isn't human, right? Bran really doesn't have the same failures or the same sort of positives that a person should have. Yeah, the idea is that he couldn't fall into it.

But I think that's actually a really good point, that what are we supposed to take from it? You know, like, I think maybe democracy is always a stake for it, so you don't give someone absolute power. You give someone power that's very much checked, and also it cannot be forever, right? There are time periods to your power, and you have to build a larger system, and it's not about you. Well, not all countries have term limits, as we recently found out in Israel. Well, just like another irony, kind of on the religious front, is that, so I really, like I said, I felt that the writers have a very cynical view towards religion. I think in our...

Our current day, even just like last week with the abortion thing that everybody, you know, was up in arms about how these Alabama, I think other states are basically making abortion illegal. I think I'm not defending that, but I think in our current society, you know, in our enlightened circles of society, people really see religious people, like evangelicals in particular, but just religious people in general. It goes for Jews also as like these fanatics and actually evil. Not only are they like dumb for believing in this backwards ancient thing, they're actually evil and have bad intentions. I don't think that's fair. I don't think people are saying, oh, these psychos are fanatic. I think what they're saying is these people are hypocrites.

You didn't see people say that they're outlawing abortion, not because they care about the lives of the fetuses, but because they just want to control women's bodies. You didn't see anyone saying that? I think that that also is related to hypocrisy. It's the idea that it's not really about God. It's not really about religion. That's what I'm saying. I'm calling that evil. I don't think it's a stretch to portray it that way. All I'm saying, well, I mean, I just find that interesting and you have that portrayed in the show, which I think is just a reflection of those enlightened circles of society now, which the writers are probably a part of, how they see religious people in our world. That's how the people in the show see religion in their world. And the added layer of irony there.

is that those religious people in our world are the ones who are saying, like, how could you watch this show? Like, we don't watch that. It's so inappropriate. And it's the enlightened ones who are supposedly the ones who care about people and human rights and dignity and all those things. They're the ones getting this, you know, satisfaction from watching people's heads be cut off and people being raped left and right.

Do you not see an irony there? I'm just pointing it out. I'm not making a point, really. I think it's a little bit confusing and it's a little bit complicated. I'm not exactly sure. One of the things that we posited is maybe there's something a little id-like that people do like watching that. But I'm not sure that's what it is because I do feel like generally I think there is this desire with all of us is that what we want to see ultimately is these bad guys who keep doing bad things. We want to see them get screwed. And again, I think that's a little id also. But I don't think that the reason we're watching it is because we kind of like seeing the rape. Or at least I hope that's not why we're watching it. So going back to the original question, you believe people when they say that they watch the show and they like the show in spite of the gratuitous sex and violence, not because of it?

Do I believe people? I mean, do you think that's true? I think... And do you think the show would be as popular as it is if not for those graphic content? I'm not sure if it would be as popular, but I do think that I believe that the reason people are watching it is not because of the gratuitous sex and violence, but I do think that when people see the gratuitous sex and violence, it's not that they're turning it off, but it's that they're feeling this desire.

to keep watching to see if these people are going to end up getting screwed. If these evil people who are doing these evil, evil things are going to end up getting what's, you know, quote unquote, coming to them. And I think that's also, again, a negative thing, but I think that's part of what we're watching. The reason why I think that's an oversimplification. They talk about it even on the show, also this season, I think in the latest episode, about sort of like, we like to see evil people get killed. And I think when Tyrion, who says this to Jon, and he says, we see...

Daenerys, who's the queen, we see Daenerys murdering evil people and we cheer. And I think that's the audience also. We see that and we're like, yes. And we're like, yeah, it's a little bit complicated, but yes, they deserve it. And we want to see that in our real lives also. I mean, it's like the death penalty. You know, these enlightened people in our world are the ones who are supposedly against the death penalty, but all of a sudden they're watching a TV show and they're like, oh, that guy's bad. Let's chop his head off. But we don't like that instinct within ourselves, right? We, Rifki, like, I don't like- You're saying we don't like it, but we like the show and the show is doing that. We like the show, but we don't like that part of it that is about vengeance. That's what I'm saying. Like, I'm saying, like, I kind of want to see these evil people get their

And it's not that I disagree with you necessarily. It's that I think it actually goes further because I don't think in this show in particular, there aren't clear good guys and bad guys. And there are plenty of people who have done things that on paper make them a very, very bad person, but we still sympathize with them and we still want, you know, them to get what they want. And I think that actually makes it even more disturbing on an id level that, you know, we're, and there are good guys that are annoying because they're too good. You know, that's the flip side of it. Like Robb Stark, when he was killed, I didn't really, I was surprised. I was like, okay, he was kind of annoying. I think most people really loved Robb. I'm not saying I didn't like him, but I just found him a little bit annoying.

All right. Well, there's so much more to talk about, obviously, but we have to have it here. But really interested in hearing from all of you. Do you watch the show? Do you not watch the show? If you didn't watch the show, sorry if this was really boring. But if you do watch the show, do you feel weird about it? Do you think that this is actually an incredibly feminist show? Do you think it's actually really anti-feminist and it's disturbing? We really want to hear from all of you. Right. Like, what does this say about our society? Is it a good thing for the world? Is it a bad thing for the world? And also, I think I'm really interested in the religious part. Not only like, oh, how do we watch this? We're religious, but really the way they portray religion. So I'm interested if other people think about it differently. And it's a kind of relationship with power. So email us at TalkingTalkersPodcast.gmail.com or join the conversation

Thanks, as always, to Drive-In Productions. They are the sponsor of this week's episode. And we've been talking about TNAC a lot. Thank you to Bergen County Jusa News, their Facebook group that you can check out and find out more stuff that's going on in the TNAC area. And thanks, as always, to Drive-In Productions. They are the official band of Talking Tachlis. Bye, everyone. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 41 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on May 21, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.