Hello and welcome. I'm Bri. And I'm Rifki. And you're listening to Talking Tothless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So we're recording this episode from different countries. It's the first time we're doing this. Hopefully it'll work. Yeah, I'm a little bit nervous. I think we can handle it. Uri has left us. He's gone to the promised land, to Israel. And well, I'll actually be joining you soon, Uri. I'm getting there next week, right after Shavuot. But until then, we're trying our first virtual experiment. Maybe next week we'll record with both of us in Israel. That'd be interesting. That'd be beautiful. I'm sure we, you know.
Our incredible studio actually has satellite offices all over the globe. So I'm sure we'll be able to set up in no time. I'm excited to check out the new studio. Definitely. So Rifki, in our last episode, it was a little different than usual. We talked about Game of Thrones and some of the religious and philosophical implications. Did you get any feedback on that? Yeah, I spoke to a bunch of people actually about the episode. And, you know, people had different sort of musings on death or maybe our fascination with sex and, you know, kind of different ideas about why this is so intriguing to us. A lot of people, I think, actually really...
disagreed or did not like my premise or maybe even my hope that we were watching because we wanted just the bad guys to get their comeuppance, they kind of thought that it was much more it. It was much more that, no, we're actually just gross and we're attracted to these things. And actually, some people said the opposite. I actually got some feedback from some friends of the show who said, no, that's actually not what it is at all. I do cover my eyes. I do cover my ears. I don't like that stuff. So it was interesting to hear the full gamut. What about you? What kind of feedback did you receive?
Yeah, some similar stuff. You actually mentioned to me that we forgot a major religious implication of the Jon Snow as the Jesus figure. Right. Yeah, you know, when thinking about the show more, I just felt like that was such an obvious thing. And I think your comment to me sort of in response when we were talking about it was like, oh, it's too obvious. Scooby didn't say, you know, it's too ridiculous. Almost every fantasy story, let alone a story in general, has something along those lines, I think. But also we're Jewish. We're not Christian. So that's why we didn't think of it. I don't know if you know, Jesus is actually Jewish. A lot of people don't know that. Oh, OK.
So, Uri, you know, I'm actually kind of curious. You're in Israel now, which is in some ways, I'm sure, kind of similar. You know, you've been to Israel a lot. You have a lot of, you know, Anglo friends, I'm sure, while you're there. But obviously, Israel is also a very different experience and, you know, kind of want to hear some musings for you about how it's been different. How has the community been different over there? What have you been hearing? Obviously, there's a lot of election stuff going on right now. What's been going on for you being in Israel right now?
Well, yeah, everyone was talking about the Israeli political situation. There's going to be new elections because the Netanyahu couldn't form a coalition. But so I was actually staffing a birthright trip last week. And one of the really interesting things that I observed in the Israeli participants engaging with the American participants was that pretty much all of the Israelis who are contemporaries of ours and in every other way would be considered pretty liberal people. They're all pro-Trump.
And the Americans on the trip, like, just couldn't wrap their heads around that. Like, how these people that they relate to as their, you know, contemporaries could possibly see Trump in a positive light. And I thought that was just, like, very fascinating kind of observing from afar. Right. Because I think I understand it. But these Americans just really didn't get it. Right. This is a very specific sort of social experiment where these Americans who really don't know so much about Israel or Judaism, you know, they have this interaction with these Israelis. I think probably, was it soldiers for you?
Well, so the group was a little bit older, so the Israelis were post-army. Ah, okay. So it's also sort of like young adult Israelis, and both of them often having never had interaction with the other group before, kind of meaning for the first time. And at least in the birthright trips that I've done, it's been an incredibly meaningful and interesting experience kind of hearing the way in which they talk to each other about related issues. And often, at least what I found is that they're socially aligned, right? Social issues. And I think when you, I imagine, or when you say that they're, you know, generally you would think that they're similar and progressive in some ways, it's really talking about social issues. I imagine they're not like having fine arguments about economic policy.
Unless they are, which would be a cool bus. Right. Yeah, we didn't get into economic policy. I guess I was thinking more along social lines. But, I mean, what do you think about the Trump thing? It's interesting. I mean...
The people who live in Israel who I interact with on a most regular basis are not Trump people, as I guess you would imagine, right? It's Americans, right? And it's liberal Americans who made Aliyah. But the truth is that I actually think that the people I know are the exception. And the truth is it's also not everyone I know. I also obviously have family and friends who are more pro-Trump. But the truth is that there have been a lot of sort of think pieces and studies that have been coming out about how Israel is moving more to the right and what that looks like, right? That the younger generation in America is more left and the younger generation in Israel is more right and how that has created almost a disconnect between Americans and Israelis when it comes to Israeli policy.
But I think it also carries over into more things like Trump, right? This idea that when Trump does certain things that get huge positive press in Israel, like moving the embassy to Jerusalem, right? Or like being very, very... Recognizing the Golan. Exactly. Being very happy with Netanyahu when he recognized things like when he annexed the Golan, Israelis...
That's really what they focus on. And they see that as a really positive thing. But Americans, especially American liberal progressive young Jews who don't know so much about Israel, and they see so many other negatives about Trump, and especially their cohort and their friends and the people who they align with on other social issues, the fact that they are often so anti-Israel, which we've obviously discussed many times, and whether they are right to be or not right to be, that sort of by definition puts American left-wing Jews in a position where they feel uncomfortable with it. They don't even know enough to know why they're uncomfortable with it, but they're uncomfortable with it. So I think that helps to create that disconnect that is sort of sad. I don't know. What's been your impression on the ground?
Well, I agree that there is a growing disconnect, which we've discussed before on the podcast, and I agree that it's sad. I think it's an oversimplification to just say it's because Israelis are moving more to the right or becoming more conservative, because I think they're only becoming more conservative when it comes to matters of Israeli national security and not in any other areas. I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that Israelis felt very traumatized by Obama and the Obama presidency. The biggest example was probably the Iran deal, but there are a lot of other things where Israelis just felt that Obama threw them under the bus. And now they see an American president who both in words and in action has been very supportive of Israel. And that's such a relief, I think, to a lot of Israelis, especially given all the anti-Israel pressure that's been growing both in America and around the world, that despite all the baggage that Trump comes with, they're still supportive of him and they see him as a positive figure for Israel's national interests. And this has gone to such an extreme that there's actually now this new song. I thought it was a joke at first, but apparently it's real. I sent it to you, I think.
You were a little bit turned off by. I could only listen to half, and I got terrified and sad. Yeah, but maybe we'll just close out this little segment by playing this song. Obviously, the sentiment in this song does not represent all Israelis, but the song is by a group called Jerusalem Boys Choir, and I have a feeling this is not the last we'll be hearing of this song. It's called Super Trump.
So if you didn't catch the Hebrew chorus there, it's Super Trump. He's the Prince of Jerusalem. Super Trump. He also touches the sky. Songs of praise from the city of Zion. And he is also blessed by God. A little bit over the top, if you ask me. I'm crying right now. Oh, you think it's over the top? I mean, it's not over the top. Well, I don't know what it is exactly. I would think it'd be over the top for Obama also, in case you're curious. Okay. It's obviously insane. Well, another thing that I experienced while here in Israel yesterday was Yom Yerushalayim.
Right, so Yom Yerushalayim in America, you really missed the ultimate Zionism, which is the Celebrate Israel Parade, you know, the March on Fifth Avenue. Yeah, I was bummed that I missed that because I do like the parade. What kind of Zionist could you really be if you missed the parade? Well, there was a parade here, the Yom Yerushalayim Parade, the flag parade. Different kind of vibe. Yeah, so for those who aren't familiar, I don't remember doing this when I was learning in Israel, but most, apparently, you were telling me before that all the yeshivas and seminaries participate in this flag march. So I'm not sure about the yeshivas, but definitely the seminaries, or at least the modern orthodox-affiliating seminaries.
They start outside the old city walls, and they're basically singing and dancing into the old city through the streets. Then they separate men and women, more or less, at a certain point. Then they go down to the hotel, and then there's a big... mass like davening and there's a concert and whatever, a lot of flags and stuff. So I don't remember ever participating then. I went yesterday with my cousins. Yeah, I'm actually not sure if that's how it was when I did it. It could be that they changed the route or changed it slightly. But basically, it's an incredibly joyous and exciting occasion. I remember we were all obviously dressed in blue and white, which is the colors of the Israeli flag. Many of us had flags wrapped around us and had, you know, face paint on and stuff like that. And we were really dancing with our friends, with our teachers, with strangers. There was a real joy in the air celebrating Jerusalem. And of course, Yom Yer Shalayim is the day of commemorating when Jerusalem was...
liberated, you know, when we won Jerusalem back in 1967 in the Six-Day War. And at the time, I really didn't feel, you know, much of anything about it. I didn't know it was even controversial. You know, I never heard of it. I just thought it was this really beautiful thing. But it wasn't until afterwards where I was, you know, reading about it more and kind of understanding, like, for example, the parade, it goes through the entire old city, which was, of course, you know, a big part of what was liberated that we hadn't had control of for so long. And that includes the Arab neighborhoods, which the Arabs are, they have curfew. It does not go through the entire old city. Right, I mean, you can go literally on every street.
It goes to certain areas that Jews usually don't go to. Right. Like you go past many, many Arab homes. You also go through a bunch of gates which lead to the Arab quarter, which normally are thought of as kind of unsafe. And most especially like Americans who are in reserve for the year, we were definitely told that you should not go through those gates on a regular basis or ever unless you are.
It's explicitly Yomir Shalayim. So it's kind of jarring because on the one hand, I have these really beautiful, amazing memories of such an incredibly exciting and happy day. On the other hand, there is something kind of difficult there in kind of knowing that there are people on the other side. There are people who are sitting in their living rooms looking through their windows and kind of seeing that. And there's a lot of celebratory, you know, Jerusalem is ours and, you know, kind of language that's very Jewish supremacy, right, and stuff like that. And I mean that in both a positive and a negative way. So I guess, Uri, I'm really curious to see how you experienced it much more recently and kind of how you thought about it.
Yeah, well, so I went because my cousins were going and I thought it would be a nice thing. I also was curious to see. Are your cousins Israeli or American? Well, they're Americans who moved to Israel. But they live there. Yeah. But I was curious to see, you know, that side, the controversial quote unquote side of it. And I wanted to judge for myself if it seems that it was, you know, harassing the Arabs or being overly aggressive. Sure. To be honest, my main experience in the parade, I guess, I don't know if I would call it a parade. It's a little bit of a mob. It was annoying because it's mostly teenagers. And I think when these people criticize the mob for harassing Arabs, I think you have to take into account that the mob is...
The vast majority of them are like yeshiva and seminary students, mostly like male from what I was seeing. And so like they're rowdy teenagers and teenagers are inherently annoying. And like they were I was annoyed by them. They were pushing and being rude and just like yelling and stuff. You're talking about rude teenagers compound that by the fact that they're also Israeli.
Yeah. I mean, I don't want to be I don't think it would be racist, maybe xenophobic. I don't know what. But like, honestly, like Israelis, some of them don't use deodorant. Like it did not smell very good in that crowd. And at a certain point, I was like, I don't really want to be here. You know, it's like all of that exists completely irrespective of the harassing the Arabs part. And then when you know you get you have rowdy teenagers and they're passing by Arabs. I honestly didn't see any specific Jews yelling at any specific Arabs, but I'm not I've seen videos of it and I'm not denying that that happens. Right. Sure. But I also, you know, and I'm less blaming the children here than blaming the system here. But.
I think this parade is meant to be an educational experience. And I think that's why a lot of the schools, the Israeli high schools, the seminaries, the yeshivas, these are all kind of these teachers and these administrators are bringing the students because they're saying this is an important educational experience and we believe in Jerusalem and this is something that's important to us and therefore we're doing this. And for us to say, well, it's not their fault, they're just kids. I mean, you're right. Let's not blame the 15-year-olds. But if you're an administrator of a school, you make a decision to bring your children, knowing what they're going to do and what they're going to see.
Let me go back a little bit. First of all, like I said, I did not see any Jews harassing any Arabs. Did you see Arabs? Yeah. So actually, another thing is that people talk about like, oh, the Jews, the parade or the mob goes through the Arab shuk on the way to the Kotel. So actually, when I went, I can only say what I saw in the time that I went, the shuk was actually, it wasn't completely closed off, but there were soldiers at the top telling people not to go in.
and directing almost everybody around. So they actually were not going through the Shook. They were going through, I guess it's officially the Armenian court, but basically the way that you usually go. Right. Oh, so interesting. Maybe the route changed because I don't think we went through the Shook. I remember going through actual streets of the Arab quarter. Okay. So I didn't see that, but...
Anyway, I also Googled afterwards trying to find, you know, people complaining or criticizing, and there was actually very little of that. So I'm assuming not much happened. I did see some people post on Facebook, you know, the usual criticism of like, oh, this is a desecration of God's name. This makes Jews look bad. This is not who we are. You know, but I didn't see those same people mentioning the fact that there was actually a stabbing, two stabbings in the old city on Friday. I don't know if you saw that one.
person was hurt seriously and one person not as serious. Like Arab stabbed Jews? Yeah, one Arab stabbed two Jews in the old city. I think that's worse than singing songs. That's crazy that I didn't even hear that. Yeah, I mean, I guess it's just not that newsworthy when a Palestinian stabs a Jew in Israel, especially if, you know, nobody's killed, even though it was a very serious injury. You know, not to mention all the rocks that were thrown at the Jews on the Temple Mount on Sunday, just for the audacity that those Jews had to go up to the Temple Mount, our holiest site, on Yom Yerushalayim. They got stones thrown at them. So I think stabbing and throwing stones is a little bit worse than singing songs too loudly.
But that being said, once we got to the hotel, like, again, it was very crowded and a little bit smelly, but it was nice. And there was like a communal prayer that everybody prayed mincha together. There was a concert. I left pretty early because I didn't want to stick around in the mob. But that was basically my experience. And it was interesting. I don't think I would want to go again, mainly because of the, you know, the crowd aspect, not because of the political aspect. And I don't think there was anything like this horrible desecration that some of these people are trying to portray this event to be.
I think, and it's great that you say that you didn't see anything in person or that you didn't see anything, you know, later on in the news or on YouTube or anything like that. But I think that the main criticism always has been, and I think should always be, really about any sort of violence or language that's directed at Arabs, kind of making them feel less than. And I think the way that I remember feeling kind of, I think it was my second year in Israel, where I left before Yom HaShulayim that year. I left in around March. But I remember having a conversation with the head of my seminary, kind of.
already feeling like, look, it was an amazing experience and I got a lot out of it and I loved the parade. But I think kind of what felt so disconcerting to me was about, obviously, I think, I'm not sure if there was a curfew, there might be a curfew, there might not be a curfew, but even if there is no curfew, obviously, I mean, if you're out, you wouldn't want to be out and about, I would imagine. I imagine you'd feel unsafe or feel weird unless you have particular reason to be out. And then the danger of knowing that, even if it's the vast minority, which I hope and pray that it is, knowing that there might be someone who's either screaming at you or spinning at you or screaming sort of nationalistic things at you. And I remember, it's weird because I...
I sometimes don't know whether my memories are real or they're kind of fake that I remember later based on watching YouTube videos or reading about it. But I have this distinct memory of when we were, you know, kind of running and dancing past these Arab houses that there were these yeshiva boys who were banging on doors and screaming, you know, screaming, you know, obviously seeing graffiti, Mabat Laravim, right? Death to Arabs and hearing things like that, which is... But you saw that graffiti? So again, I have a memory of seeing that graffiti on Yomishlein, but it might be implanted, right? This might be something that I... But even if I didn't see it, I've seen it in the news or on YouTube, right? That this is something that happens. Hopefully, it sounds like you're saying it didn't happen this year, which is great. But just knowing that something like that happens, right? Knowing that... And let me just also...
clarified. The reason I think that happens is because what we are doing is, even though we are celebrating this sort of spiritual victory in we, that's because, that's why Yom Yishalai is often associated with religious people, even more so than with nationalistic people, because we see it as this incredible, not military victory, but spiritual victory. The Six-Day War came out of nowhere, we were supposed to be annihilated, all of these things, and that's why it's such a religious experience for people, and when we take that and then turn it into a parade of, God has given us this place and you people mean nothing, I think that kind of language and that kind of idea is what really scares me and what makes me feel really sad for the Arabs, even though I feel conflicted about it, because I also... do impart this spiritual meaning to Jerusalem. So I don't know. That's kind of where I'm coming from in the tension. Yeah. Well, I don't think anyone was saying to the Arabs, you mean nothing. I think people who write and say, ma bet la arabim. Okay, I don't even...
I don't even think that happened this year because I looked for it on Google afterwards in the news and whatever. I didn't see it with my eyes and I didn't see it in the news. What I did see were people being obnoxious and just singing regular songs, but just in a loud, obnoxious way. And I guess if you're an Arab and you see a huge crowd walking by singing, it's going to be a little bit annoying, if not a little bit scary. Do you remember any of those songs? Do you remember what particular songs you were? Really just standard songs about Jerusalem that are sung in Jewish schools and yeshivas and whatever. If somebody wants to say that Jews singing songs recognizing Jerusalem as being central to our identity as Jews, if someone wants to say that's controversial, then okay, I can't really argue with that. That just is what it is.
This stuff just reminds me of, I think it was George Bush Jr. who coined the phrase, the soft bigotry of low expectations. Like, why do we just take it for granted that, you know, we can't upset the Arabs because they're going to get violent if we do something that upsets them. You know what I mean? Like, how about we just say, like, violence is not okay and Jews should not be violent against Arabs and Arabs shouldn't be violent against Jews. And let's not make assumptions that one side is just going to be violent and that's taken for granted and we're not going to criticize that.
Just to push back a tiny bit, even though I definitely agree with the overall sentiment that we need to have higher expectations of everyone and everyone's decorum and everyone's behavior, there's a power dynamic at play, right? I think it would be lying if we didn't recognize that and understand that, right? The dynamic of the Jews in Israel really having the power, even though the Temple Mount is a little bit more complicated because they gave the power back to Jordan after the Six-Day War, but it's still in general. The fact the power really lies with these 15-year-old kids on Yomishalim and the power does not lie with the Arab homeowners or renters in that neighborhood. I think we have to recognize that. I totally agree that...
the Jews or Israel does have the upper hand in terms of power in this situation. And because of that, we shouldn't rub it in their faces and we don't need to be, there's no reason or no condoning of being obnoxious or worse in front of Arabs or Arabs' homes in the Old City. On the other hand, I do think it is very important for Jews and Israelis to make it very clear that... Jerusalem is very central to our identity. And if we listen to every time when people or leftists or whoever said like, oh, well, you shouldn't do that because it's going to upset the Arabs. You shouldn't walk through the old city. You shouldn't go on the Temple Mount. You know, it's really not right. Whatever. If we listen to everything every time that people said that, we would never be, you know, in those areas. And then nobody would even know that this is important. So they could then say, oh, how could it be important to you? You never even go there. You know what I mean? Like, again, chicken and egg. But I think there's a balance, you know, and obviously I think you do too. I think like this idea of.
This is important to us. Jerusalem is important to us. The old city of Jerusalem is important to us. I think that is absolutely abundantly clear to us. I'm not sure if the way we show it sometimes is done in as much respect as it could be. Because even if you want to say it's more important to us than it is to you, which I think is kind of like a little bit of an immature argument. Well, no, I don't think we have to say it that way. And I think the idea of sort of like reminding Arabs, Arabs don't need to be reminded that Jerusalem belongs to Israel.
It actually kind of reminds me, even though it's a very different situation, it reminds me of, I had a conversation once with someone who was a little bit right-wing on LGBTQ issues and very halakhically minded and said, you know, sometimes someone needs to stand up and make it clear to LGBTQ Orthodox Jews that it's us-er. And I remember thinking, and I think I said out loud, like, you think they don't realize? Like, you think that's something that they need to be reminded about or else they're just going to think it's totally fine? They're reminded every day. Arabs in the Old City and Arabs in Israel are reminded every day about the fact that they do not have this land, that they live in this land, but that Israel has the political authority over them. And I just don't think that...
Again, I'm not talking about this particular Yorushalayim. I'm just talking about the general experience is not one that I think creates a productive environment in which to have real conversations. Right. Well, I would agree in saying that maybe I could definitely be done in a nicer way. From my own experience, I thought it was a little bit unpleasant for myself. It could be nicer. Like, they should give out deodorant.
Among other things, yeah. But unfortunately, I disagree with what you said, because while it may be clear to everybody that Israel has the upper hand when it comes to the power and authority over Israel and Jerusalem, there's actually a very shocking movement among the Palestinians and a growing number of people around the world, including obviously the UN, who deny that Jews have any right, historical or otherwise, to this land and to Jerusalem. So I think actually making a statement and going there and having a parade, it actually is very important to demonstrate. the centrality of Jerusalem to the Jewish people. I totally agree. We can have a whole episode about the Temple Mount. I think it's incredibly insane that Jews in Israel do not have access to the Temple Mount in the way that I think they should. In the same way, by the way, that I think it's crazy that left-wing Jews do not have access to the Kotel in the same way I think they should. So, you know, I'm definitely up for more access and, you know, libertarian over here. Yeah, one last thing I would want to close with is that there's an interesting phenomenon. I don't know the full, like, history or the reason why this ended up happening was because on the one hand, I think the overwhelming majority of Jewish Israelis are very much in favor of Jerusalem.
being you know part of israel and being the capital of israel but on the other hand Yom Yerushalayim, Jerusalem Day, which commemorates the reunification or the recapturing, whatever you want to call it, of Jerusalem, is basically only celebrated by the Dati Luumi, or the Nationalistic Orthodox in Israel, and not the secular Israelis, who might be just a Zionistic, but for whatever reason, they don't really participate, at least in the flag parade, maybe in other things, but not really. Yeah, I don't think so. I think Yom Yerushalayim, Jerusalem Day, is really something that Orthodox people, and Dati Luumi especially, focus on, and to the exclusion of really every other community, including the more right-wing, and including, you know, very, very, very Zionist and pro-Jerusalem people.
Right, so I think that's unfortunate, and I'm not exactly sure why that is, but I think, yeah, maybe it would be in everyone's best interest if the way it's celebrated would be modified a little bit or mellowed out a little bit. Maybe we can agree on that to some extent. Yes, that's a fair point. All right, well, I guess we want to hear from all of you. What was sort of...
People who live in Israel and people who have spent time in Israel, especially on Yom Mishalai and Jerusalem Day, have you spent time at these parades? Have you been uncomfortable? Have you loved it? Do you think we're crazy for even being uncomfortable? Do you love dissent? Share with us your thoughts. We want to hear from all of you. Of course, email us at talkingpathlesspodcast at gmail.com and be in touch with us on our social media, especially on Facebook. And because both Ari and I are going to be in Israel next week, we'd love restaurant recommendations. Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, hit us up. We want to hear everything. Thanks as always to Drive-In Productions and to the Satellite Studio in Israel, just as nice as the one in New York. Maybe even nicer. Got that holiness built in. Exactly, yeah.
Thanks as always to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Talkless. Bye, everyone. Bye.