Skip to content
72. Concentration Camps and Racist Rants episode artwork

Jun 25, 2019 30 min

72. Concentration Camps and Racist Rants

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

Rivky and Uri are back in New York and they dive right into some of this week's hot topics. First they talk about Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's heartfelt pajama-clad Instagram Live video where she compares the terrible conditions in migrant detention facilities on the US-Mexico border to concentration camps. The Tach Team asks if this comparison is accurate, and even if it isn't, is criticizing AOC more important than criticizing the conditions in these camps? Then, they talk about the latest college admissions scandal. Harvard has retracted an offer of admissions to Kyle Kashuv, for racist and sexist remarks he made in a private Google Doc when he was 16. Did Harvard make the right decision or should Kyle's apology be enough to allow him to keep his spot at Harvard? Links: AOC Concentration Camps: https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2019/06/18/ocasio-cortez_trump_administration_is_running_concentration_camps_on_the_souther_border.html https://www.newyorker.com/news/q-and-a/inside-a-texas-building-where-the-government-is-holding-immigrant-children https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/opinion/trump-migrants-camps.html https://www.jta.org/2019/06/24/politics/how-jews-reacted-to-alexandria-ocasio-cortezs-controversial-concentration-camp-comment Harvard Admissions Story: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qj_cSiDarDE https://twitter.com/KyleKashuv/status/1140605133346283521

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Rivky and Uri are back in New York and they dive right into some of this week's hot topics. First they talk about Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's heartfelt pajama-clad Instagram Live video where she compares the terrible conditions in migrant detention facilities on the US-Mexico border to concentration camps. The Tach Team asks if this comparison is accurate, and even if it isn't, is criticizing AOC more important than criticizing the conditions in these camps? Then, they talk about the latest co...

Ready to play

72. Concentration Camps and Racist Rants

0:00 30:57
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rivki. And you're listening to Talkin' Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So Uri, we're back in our home studio in New York City. Back in New York, yeah. How was the rest of your trip? It was nice. Yeah, I miss Israel, but it's always nice to be back in New York. Yeah, for me, it was a really short trip. It was only like five days. I was jet-lagged the whole time, and now I just got back, and I'm still pretty jet-lagged. So it's been a really great last two weeks. Okay. Well, I'm sure you've been losing some sleep over the latest...

Headlines from one of our new congresswomen. I feel like there's a rotation between those three. Every week, it's a different one of them in the headlines for saying something controversial. This week, it's AOC, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. Did you hear what she said? Yeah. It was hard for me to track because I think it was actually either during my flight or something around then.

She posted maybe first on Instagram and then it became a Twitter conversation and then just emerged to the larger sort of political conversation in the country. But comparing the internment camps that migrants are being housed in to concentration camps. Right. So here's the video and we'll play it and then we can discuss it. I'll just also point out that if this is relevant, I don't know, she's in her pajamas when she's doing this Instagram live thing. I think that that's common. She does that often or she'll be like running from the bodega. She's relatable. Okay. That's one way to look at it. I always Instagram live in my pajamas. Yeah. Well, here's the video. The United States is running concentration camps on our southern border.

That is exactly what they are. They are concentration camps. And if that doesn't bother you, I don't, I don't know, I like, we can have, okay, whatever. I want to talk to the people that are concerned enough with humanity to say that we should not, that never again means something. And that the fact that concentration camps are now an institutionalized practice in the home of the free is extraordinarily disturbing.

So Rivki, first of all, I want to start by saying, I think you're going to be very proud of me because I do not think that she is articulate. Wow. Look at you. Yeah, I think it's interesting because at the same time listening to it, I'm like kind of cringing because I'm like, be more clear, you know, speak a little faster, but also like it's very real. And I think people actually really relate to the way she, the way she communicates and shares information. Yeah. Like when, like when she said, if that doesn't bother you, okay, like whatever. Yeah. I mean, she says, okay, like whatever the same way I would say, okay, like whatever. You're not in Congress. Yeah, sure. But I think people like that. Whatever. That's not the point of this conversation. They like Trump also, so I shouldn't, I shouldn't say anything, but I wouldn't call him articulate either. But anyway, to the point.

So she's calling the detainment camps concentration camps. And she repeats that and says that's exactly what they are. So is that exactly what they are? So I'm not a historian. I'm not an expert in concentration camps or in defining semantics. But I think that conversation totally misses the point that she's making. And I find that so frustrating. What she's doing is purposely using a provocative term, concentration camps, which most of us associate with Nazi Germany. Well, you agree because she says...

if never again means something, she's clearly making a reference to the Holocaust. Yeah, that's what it sounds like. Some of us also associate that with the Japanese internment camps. Basically, concentration camps, from my understanding, is that people are being held and they have no possibility for mobility, for trial, anything like that. It's just to hold you until they decide what next steps are going to be. Maybe that's going to be in five years, maybe in 10 years, maybe in two weeks. There's no sort of way to know and you have no options. You're completely stuck. And that's why people also include the Japanese internment camps there because people were rounded up and just placed into these camps with kind of a shrug and like, we'll see what happens next. So she was using that term.

purposely a provocative term to talk about these camps and say these people are given absolutely no options, they have no rights, and trying to call our greater... eye towards looking at this problem and saying, this is a real issue and we have to recognize that. And then what happened is that people immediately started fixating on that term and saying, is she right about that term? Is she wrong about that term? Instead of actually talking about the issue, which is what I find completely frustrating. Was she sensitive or insensitive? I don't know. To me, that feels less important than what's actually going on. And is it evil and is it horrific or is it not? Why can't both of those things be in the conversation? Have you seen a lot of conversation on Twitter where people are saying, hey, I object to the use of that term, but actually it is horrific and we have to get to the bottom. I don't really look at Twitter, but I'm sure there are people saying that. I mean, people just take sides. It's very annoying these days. Yeah, it's ludicrous. She's trying to make a larger point about something really, really awful going on.

a lot of journals in the past few years, but also especially in the past few weeks, talking about the really horrific things. These kids, I don't know if you saw this, this happened over the weekend that this was published, that these kids basically were, a couple of kids had lice. So they were given lice combs to get out the lice. They were given two lice combs to share among the group of kids, which is like not what you're supposed to do. Obviously, people have lice. And one of them was lost. And the officers, to punish the kids after one of them was lost, took away their mattresses.

and they just sleep on the floor. I can't speak to that because I didn't see that. I'm not saying it didn't happen. That is the conversation. The conversation is not are we using the term concentration camp but we should be using the term internment camp. I don't care about the difference between those words. So I do care and I am offended as a Jew. I think just to go back for a second to what you said I think what you said is

inaccurate or insufficient because yeah, there are certain things in common with these detainment camps and the Japanese internment camps and then the concentration camps in Poland that the Nazis had Jews in. There are certain things that are similar and there are many things that are very different. Yeah, of course. That's how comparisons work. Comparisons are not always exactly the same thing. Well, when it's far enough away, it is irresponsible to make that comparison, especially when you're speaking in a public forum and you're a public figure and people don't know the details of what you're saying. Honestly, I think a silver lining to this would be if this, anything, I think that anything that brings the Holocaust into the national conversation is a good thing because I think Holocaust awareness and education is very important and just talking about it is important. But I mean,

We are talking about random people on Twitter, but we're also talking just between ourselves. Is what she said offensive or inappropriate? And we can also say the conditions in these camps are not... good and they're dangerous or and they're terrible we can say both can you explain to me so when you say that you think it's uh the historical comparison is is offensive and and to a certain extent i think i kind of agree i have that twinge of like oh that feels like unfair but i'm not sure why i feel that way what is it like do you have a specific definition of concentration camp that you have in mind it's the same way that when um israel is called an apartheid country aside from being you know defaming um israel it's also offensive to south african we know why i think like we've both been you know trained enough in hasbar to understand why israel is not an apartheid state so what is a concentration camp and why don't these fit into that category so it obviously comes down a little bit to semantics i don't know the exact definition of a concentration camp, but she clearly was making a direct comparison to the Holocaust. So she was talking about Nazi concentration camps, and I do know more or less what those were. Well, my understanding, just based on her Twitter and the few days after that, when she talks about what she means, she's talking about the first, she's not talking about death camps, right? She's talking about concentration camps. So I'm trying to understand what the distinction is that we're making here. Yeah, the distinction is that people in the camps on the Mexican border are not being starved. They're not being denied basic medical care. I think people on the border would disagree with both of those.

They're being given insufficient food and not given medical care. People in Nazi concentration camps were starving and dying on the streets. I don't think that's happening here. I'm sorry. That's not true. Maybe the proportion, we could say, oh, it's a much higher proportion in Nazi concentration camps, but definitely people are being given insufficient food, insufficient medical care, and people are dying as a result. That's absolutely true.

And we can also obviously post links to all these things. I will concede to a semantic difference. I just don't think that's true. I think it's just a mile of difference between them, and that's why I think it's offensive. You could say it's less common, right? Like, it's happening less often, or the food is insufficient, but still more than the regulatory concentration camps. Yeah, I'll send you these articles, and I'll also post these in the links, because, guys, we're not trying to convince you. We're trying to have a discussion about facts, and if you guys see these and think they're incorrect. So you don't think her comparison was inaccurate? Again, there might be a semantic academic definition of...

concentration camps that I don't know about, and that's very possible. But the fundamental issue about whether it's evil and whether people are being put into these awful, awful conditions feels like the most important thing, and it's accurate. I don't think the conditions are what people see as the ultimate problem here and the evil thing here. The evil thing is just the fact that they're being detained indefinitely. I think that is the issue, and we can talk about the...

evil and problems of that. But I don't think the actual conditions are the issue. And that is why it's a completely inaccurate comparison. What's also just very frustrating. You're saying that when she says concentration camps, what she means is that there's no freedom of mobility. She's not talking about the conditions. I'm not saying she's not talking about the conditions. I'm just speaking in a big picture sense here that the real problem people have is that these camps exist in the first place. It's not the conditions of the camp that is really at issue here. And I don't think if they improve the conditions, she would be any happier. Like, okay, now it's okay that we're detaining these people. She's obviously not going to say that. So I don't, that to me shows that the conditions, while maybe they are really bad.

That's not really the ultimate problem here, which is fine. That's not proving anything in terms of like she's wrong. I'm just pointing out the reality of it. I also just think it's very frustrating how like this is the thing about AOC, but it's not just her. It's like a modern thing now where people just don't apologize for things. Like why can't, if you're saying this, why can't she just say, I'm sorry for making the comparison. I'm sorry if that offended people. I'm sorry if that offended Holocaust survivors who were in Nazi concentration camps, but that shouldn't take away from the fact that these camps are really evil and really bad and people are not being treated well. She could just say that and then I would have a lot more respect for her, but she refuses to say anything like that. So that just makes me, you know, just not want to entertain anything she says.

Apologies. I actually, in this case, don't really think she did anything wrong. But I understand what you're saying is that it's not just about saying I did this wrong thing. It's saying there's a sensitivity to groups of people that I was not conscious of and I need to be more sensitive to that. Like, that feels different. Yeah, even a fake apology where she, quote unquote. No, those are worse. No, no, no, where she said like.

I'm very upset about these conditions, but I understand why some people might have been upset by that comparison, and I'm sorry, right? And I'm sorry for that. Even that, which is not like a total, complete apology, but even that I think would be meaningful, and she's not doing that. What I do find interesting is that this feels so much more than Jewish and non-Jewish. This feels like such a left-right divide, because what AOC has been doing and what many people on the left have been doing is been retweeting and sharing articles from all these people who are saying, I'm a Jew, I'm a grandchild of survivors, I'm a rabbi, I'm all these things, and she's absolutely correct. And then what you have on the right is people's...

Jewish or not, saying absolutely incorrect. And it seems to have no divide about whether people are actually Jewish, or people actually feel an intense connection to this, or whether people are academics and experts in the terms. It's just about where their politics are. Yeah, I think that is... a statement on our modern politics where, like, somebody was just saying, my brother was just saying yesterday how frustrating it is, how, like, it's basically like sports. There are teams. Totally. And you're on your team, and then when your team, you have to defend your team at all costs. That's what's so silly about modern politics today, where it's like, if I'm a Republican because I believe in certain economic policies, now I am suddenly also on board with the way they think about abortion and the way they think about immigration and the way they think about all of these things, and they're lumped into one, and Democrats and Republicans have very specific things that they're tied together on, and we no longer have, in some ways, big tent is a good thing, because it...

creates the incentive to kind of do more with different groups and different factions working together, but in some ways we tend to the bad thing because it means that we lose sight of nuance in kind of different departments. Right. Well, moving on to the other topic we wanted to talk about today, the college admissions process is in the headlines again. This time it's Harvard in the news because they rescinded their offer of admission to Kyle Kashuv. Here's a clip from The Daily Show with Trevor Noah explaining the controversy. College admissions.

That special time in a teenager's life when they ask institutions of higher learning to settle them with soul-crushing debt. Now, the issue of who does or does not get into prestigious universities has been in the news more than usual lately, mostly thanks to the third most popular actress on the Hallmark Channel. And now, and now there's another college admissions scandal making headlines, and this one makes even Aunt Becky look good. A fierce debate is raging now about whether Harvard University made the right decision by rescinding its acceptance of a Parkland shooting survivor turned gun rights advocate. Kyle Kashuk says that the university pulled his admission after texts and documents surfaced showing that he had used racist and sexist language on social media two years ago.

Okay, there's a lot going on in the story. We've got a Parkland shooting survivor who is a pro-gun advocate fighting about college admissions and racism. Basically, every hot button issue is crammed into one story. All that's missing is abortion, and then you get bingo. Done. So, Kalkashev, he had a bunch of private messages where he said racist and sexist things, and because of that, he got kicked out of Harvard. The good news is he just got offered a full scholarship to Trump University. Now...

You might be wondering how bad were these messages that they got him kicked out of Harvard? Well, this bad. Some of his text messages included racist and anti-Semitic language. He used the N-word repeatedly, including about black student athletes. In one thread, he used the N-word 11 times, joking that he was good at typing it because, quote, practice makes perfect. Holy shit. Are you seeing that? I've never seen the N-word written that many times in the same sentence. Even rappers would be like, yo, that's too much, dog. You gotta throw in some other lyrics, man. Libra, zebra, shit like that.

I mean, look at that message. Forget Harvard. It looks like he's plagiarizing one of Quentin Tarantino's scripts. What is that? And because of Kyle's profile, this story has gotten a lot of attention in the news, right? And he's come out. He's come out saying, although these messages are extremely offensive, in his defense, that was actually the whole point. Kyle Kashuv says he and some others were trying to be as extreme and shocking as possible when he used the N-word repeatedly. The person who wrote those things is not who I am today. Well, at that time, it was really a friend group where who could say the most shocking thing and most extreme thing for the sake of shock value? So he was competing with friends for shock value. Now...

Some people have come to Kyle's defense saying that it's not fair for the college admissions office to judge him for stuff that he did when he was 16. But that's exactly what college admissions does. They judge you for what you did in high school. Think about it. I mean, if they're turning down someone for failing pottery class when they're 14, you're definitely not getting in after you've been busted for saying the N-word 11 times. Everyone knows the limit is nine.

And I understand where Harvard is coming from. There's usually no way to know which one of your prospective students are racist. But if you somehow do know, then why would you admit that kid into your school? Now, Khashogh, for his part, did apologize for what he had written in those messages, right? He said that he's grown since then and he wishes that he could take it back. But at the same time, he's also pointing fingers.

For people who don't know, Harvard was founded in 1636 by slave owners. It has a long history of racism, sexism, misogyny. But I think that people can grow and people can change. And I don't hold that standard to Harvard. And I think that people can make mistakes. And I don't think that mistakes make you irredeemable, as Harvard showed for me. Can I give you a time out there? So you mentioned that they had slave owners in the 1600s. You using the N-word was what? A year, year and a half ago? Two years ago. A little more recent. Two years, 400 years, come on! That was such an epic fail.

What was also magic is how he tried to switch from N-word premium user to civil rights leader in one moment. So look, Kyle lost his spot at Harvard because of his old racist messages. And he feels like that's not fair. But the truth is, there are all sorts of reasons people don't get into Harvard. Sometimes it's because of your grades. Sometimes it's because you said the N-word 11 times. And to be honest, I don't think that he has a leg to stand on here. So if I were him, I'd practice my puppy dog eyes and start applying to other schools. Okay, so it's very clear where Trevor Noah stands on this issue. Rifki, what do you think? Do you think Harvard was correct in rescinding this offer of admissions?

I'm trying to think, like, if I were in charge of the department at Harvard, what I would have done, I don't think that I would have rescinded the offer, but I definitely, A, feel sympathetic to their choice, and B, I think his whole argument about how he's really the wronged party here is sort of ludicrous, and that's kind of what upsets me. But I also want to say, as an aside, that the way that Trevor Noah and others kind of, like, talk about this kid as a joke and just mock him and they're so mean feels like really... not right. It feels really disrespectful. This kid is 18. This kid is a survivor of a really traumatic incident. This kid has made a lot of mistakes and will continue to make a lot of mistakes. And I'm not happy with his mistakes. And I don't think if I went to Harvard, I would seek out trying to be friends with him. Or, you know, maybe I would be because I think that's also kind of like a productive thing. And I think it could also be good for Harvard and could be good for this kid to have him in a new environment, to have, you know, Harvard kids engage with different types of people. But I also really do understand where they're coming from. So I think that this conversation, we so often like lose, honestly, like similar, I think a little bit to the AOC conversation. We lose the thread of what the conversation is actually about when instead we try to make declarative statements of who's right and who's wrong. I don't know, what do you think?

Well, I appreciate the nuance that you're bringing into this conversation. But just to clarify one thing, you're saying that Kyle sees himself as the victim here or whatever. But I don't think that's exactly true because he fully apologized for his statements. He's not saying he's innocent. He very clearly said what he did was wrong and he apologized for it. He wrote Harvard a letter. This is all on his Twitter that will...

posted in the description, but when Harvard originally sent him a letter and said, we're reviewing your case, he apologized fully and he said, I'm happy and I would love to meet with people at the school or whatever to talk about how I can learn from this and how we can all move on and whatever. So he's definitely not saying that he's the victim. Well, he's saying that he's the victim in that he's saying, I apologize, why would they not? That's insane. So you're using that term. I want to quote his exact thing here. He did this Twitter thread of like 14, I think, messages in a row. And the last one is, so what now? I'm figuring it out. I've given up huge scholarships in order to go to Harvard and the deadline for accepting other college offers has ended. I'm exploring all options at the moment, which in some sense I actually do feel sympathetic for because, you know,

that sucks. He thought, I'm imagining if I, you know, were in June of, I just graduated and I was expecting to go to college in two months. And I was like, wait, what do you mean? That's not happening anymore. I would kind of feel bad for myself, but also, you know, this is very clear that he's like, I apologize. How are they doing this to me? How could they possibly be putting me in this position where now I don't know what I'm doing in two months? He's not saying, I apologize and there are repercussions. I apologize. I still think I could have been a good student. Well, obviously he thinks it was wrong that they rescinded the offer. You can call it wherever you want. Okay. I think that's totally accurate. He's not saying that he's the only victim. He's not saying I was right in everything I did, but he's definitely seeing himself as sort of like, I can't believe this call-out culture is canceling me. He's objecting to the decision of Harvard. I think what he did was obviously like...

very disgusting and it's like in a way definitely a good thing or the good part of this story being so public is like a warning I guess to other kids both on a moral level like this is really bad and don't use that kind of language. And also just on a practical level, like anything you say in any forum can be held against you and be aware of that. I think it's important to note a lot of these stories and people talking about it talked about like these were statements on social media, like a lot of these similar kinds of cases are. That's not actually what it was. It was in like a private Google doc that he had with some friends. So this was not in any way, shape or form, like a public statement of any kind. And he was 16 when he said it. That doesn't excuse what he said and what he did. But like, I think we both know that 16 year olds, especially boys, not to be sexist, can say really dumb things. Again, that doesn't excuse it. But I do think this was an extreme measure. I think it sets a very dangerous...

precedent that now college admissions are saying that anything you say in any forum, private or public, can be held against you. Sure, I agree with all those things. The problem from Harvard's perspective is Harvard's acceptance rate is something like 8%. And when this kid gets in and someone else doesn't get in, and then this kid is all over the news as doing these things and saying these things, if I'm rejected from Harvard, I'm like, hey, what just happened? He's definitely not entitled to go to Harvard. And I think that's a lot of the criticism coming from the left and that team, you know, that's like defending Harvard or whatever. A lot of them are saying, I saw a lot of people saying like, you know, there's no entitlement of this kid to be in Harvard. He isn't.

earn he doesn't deserve that spot just by right of whatever so it's a privilege and he doesn't deserve that privilege because of the things that he said like that's fine I mean I saw in one of the articles he got a 1550 on his SATs and he was like second in his class so clearly academically he's deserving but obviously we all agree that that's not all there is to the equation I think, Rivki, do you think that the fact that he came, and by the way, these statements were made, like the comments that he had in this Google Doc were before the shooting. Yeah, and he talks about that. He says he changed a lot as a person. He grew up a lot. He matured a lot. And I think all of that is important. And again, if I were in charge of, you know, Harvard's decisions, I don't think I would have resented it. I think I would have said this can actually be a really great moment. I actually want him in this environment. I want other kids to meet him and talk to him. I think that could be a really valuable thing. But I'm sympathetic to Harvard's decision. Well, so right. So my question to you is, I'm just curious, because he then after the shooting came out as a gun rights activist and he met with Trump in the White House because of that. And I think he spoke at like NRA events and stuff.

And then it was other classmates of his who brought this document to light. And then because of that and the uproar that it caused, Harvard rescinded his admission. So do you think because he was like a conservative right wing activist that had something to do with the uproar? And especially because he has most of his classmates, I think, who have been vocal after the shooting have been on the complete opposite end of the spectrum and would be very, I think, offended by somebody who's saying we need guns because they're all saying we need to get rid of guns. Do you think that had anything to do with the fact that he was called out for this? I am not convinced that it is, meaning I would imagine that if someone who had gone had been in the same school, got the same experiences, had the same academic.

impressive achievements and were totally on the left and were an advocate against gun rights, all those things, and then his other classmates had released these private writings, I imagine Harvard would have made the same decision. I didn't even think about that. To me, it doesn't seem related. I think it is related. That's just my gut feeling. Another question I have for you. What do you think about the point that he brought up in that interview that we heard in that clip and also in his Twitter thing, which Trevor Noah ridiculed, but the comparison to Harvard itself, that Harvard was founded by slave owners, Harvard has a very checkered past when it comes to racial and gender issues.

Yes, that was more than two years ago. That was centuries and sometimes maybe decades ago. Also, not that person. Meaning, like, I agree that context matters. I think it's absolutely important for Harvard to recognize its own sort of responsibility in history. There's that whole big thing with Georgetown University in D.C., which had used slave labor to build a university and many...

decades later, basically discovered all of these documents. And now they're going through this whole process where they're actually giving preferential admission to the great, great descendants of those slaves. And it's pretty actually interesting to follow that and to see what reparations could look like. It's actually interesting that reparations is right now, particularly in the news, because Congress is doing all these hearings about what reparations could potentially look like for descendants of slaves. But I absolutely think that those things are important. And I also think that even though Trevor Noah, I think, really came across a little bit like a bully, it is important to note that this is literally...

Kyle's words two years ago, as opposed to a group of people who founded universities several hundred years ago. I think Harvard absolutely has to take responsibility for that and see how they can kind of try to make amends, quote unquote, in whatever way they can. But it is obviously different than talking about this exact person. But at the same time, I absolutely agree with you that 16-year-olds should not be treated the same as, you know... 50-year-olds, even 50-year-olds can do chuva, but 16-year-olds are children. This is why we believe, or I strongly believe, in a different justice system for minors as for adults, right? Like, 16-year-olds make mistakes. 16-year-olds do things that they later regret. 16-year-olds make very immature decisions and say immature things, especially to get a rise out of other people, to make their friends laugh, right? I was 16, you were 16. Like, again, I don't think I ever did, I never said those things, but I did bad things. I did things that I'm sure if my university combed through every single thing I ever did, they'd be like, eh. Like what? Say that for obvious. But I think, like, that does matter, right? Like, the fact that he's a child does matter. I'm curious.

uh first of all what the record of harvard and other elite schools are in general when it comes to like things that have come to light like meaning is this an anomaly or has this happened in the past do they have a specific um protocol of like if things come up that were said in private right how that is especially like i doubt that anything in the past has had this much press right right and my other cynical question is did this whole thing happen and did harvard rescind the offer because of the public outcry and because they were scared of the mob, the social justice mob that goes after people who say racist stuff and whatever? Or did they do it because these are their principles and this is something in their protocol of how they operate? So I don't know what you think, Gary, but my cynical instinct is absolutely Harvard is looking out for its reputation, for its donations, right? If alumni see this in the press and say, this is ridiculous, they're going to stop giving so much money. So I think that's unfair and I think that's a sign of our times. There's a lot of things that universities do that is completely disgusting and unfair. This to me is way less bad than giving ridiculous preferential treatment to alumni, athletes, things like that. I think there's a lot of other things that universities do.

universities do that feel a lot less like they have a strong standing to make it than something like this. I think it's also interesting, like in that news clip, they mentioned that he said anti-Semitic things, but he's actually Jewish, which I think implies that like he was just saying provocative things that I don't think he could call him an anti-Semite. I don't, you know, if he's Jewish, maybe he could be. I mean, whatever. But I just think that's an interesting piece to this story. I mean, I think just like anything else, the distinction, you know, I think it's silly to say, hey, this guy's a racist. This guy's an anti-Semite. It's more like he was clearly using racist and anti-Semitic language.

So is he an anti-Semitism? No, he's Jewish. He obviously doesn't hate Jews, think they don't deserve to live, all those things. But when people use, I don't like, for example, when people say, oh, feminazi. I don't like language like that. I think it's offensive. Do I think the person who did it is evil and is, I don't know, I don't know what noun you would use about people? No, of course not. But I think that there's something problematic about the language. It doesn't matter if the person saying it is a man or a woman? No, I don't think it does. I think it's harmful. I think it's really bad. I think the same thing about when people say, like if I make a, you know.

really strong anti-women language. You know, I think that's really harmful. It doesn't matter if I'm a man or a woman. I think it hurts us. It hurts the culture. But anyway, that's kind of a separate topic, which we could get into a different time. Thank you all so much for joining us. And as always, we want to hear from all of you. Please be in touch with us via email at TalkingTalklessPodcast.gmail.com and join the conversation on our Facebook page, Talking Talkless Podcast. Thanks as always to Drive-In Productions. They have a sponsor of this week's episode and it's great to be back in the flagship studios in New York. We missed it. Yeah, and thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Talkless. Bye, everyone. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 30 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on June 25, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.