Hey everybody, and welcome to Classical Stuff You Should Know. This is what we're going to say. Wow, you sound rough. Seriously.
Oh man, yeah. This is how we feel. Yeah. There's a little bit of sickness floating around today.
I feel great. You said you're going to go home taking a nap. Well, that's because I did detention school this morning. What did you do?
I mean, you know, I just lost my temper on Friday and had to come and do, for those of you who do not know Veritas, we have a Saturday school, much like the breakfast club. No. We don't leave them in a room together. We don't leave them in a room together.
No, we don't just sit in a library and do nothing. No, we've got Saturday school where we've just moved to a new campus and we've got lots of chores to do, and the kids that have accrued a number of marks, which are our version of demerits, have to come. And so at quarter to seven, I and many of our vaguely disgruntled youth descended upon campus and picked up trash and moved things into storage containers and washed windows and all this stuff. And I can't tell you, you sound deeply unhappy as you describe this.
I'm sleepy, but you guys, you guys, I'm pretty long. I think I missed my first few days of work since I started here. I'm actually sober. So, well, actually, AWB recently watched a movie related to this, so I get excited.
So, elementary, middle, and high school, I never miss a day of school. You are unbreakable. According to M. Night Shyamalan, what am I?
You're a superhero. I'm a superhero. And then, as a last week, I was no longer a superhero. So, that happened.
Well, at least you don't have to tangle with Mr. Glass. Yeah, see, I've only seen the first one. Does he tangle in the first one?
Yeah, I mean, it finds out that Mr. Glass is bad, dude. Yeah. But then, anyway, they're not really against each other.
Did you go and see the new one? I did. And it was a movie. A movie.
It was good. I don't know. It was not bad. I enjoyed it.
Not bad, Raves. AJ Handenberg. So, for those of you who are- We like old books. We like old philosophy.
We like art and architecture and all kinds of things. The music and all kinds of old stuff. And that's what we're all about. And we try to bring that to you in a way that is totally palatable.
So, my understanding is that today we are discussing barbers from ancient times. Barbers? Yeah, like the ones who cut your hair. I don't make connection for them.
And then they have fashion shows? Wait, we're talking about heresy. What's the name it's called? The heresy.
This is upsetting. This is every time. It's just a punch in the gut. Okay, so.
No, I feel like I make worse puns than you all, so I should be laughing more often. That was really bad. It was a stretch and a half. That's why I was thinking about it as we went.
That's not the hair connection. Anyway, here we are. Here we are. Oh, that was a story.
Okay, so. Yeah, so today we're going to be talking about heresy. This was prompted first by. You smoked.
I don't understand why. I'm chuffed. I just want to hear all about modalism. It's not on the list.
You love modalism? So, this is a fun time. So, now I've destroyed your happiness, so I'm glad we could do this. So, what prompted this?
This was first prompted by, AJ, your episode on St. Nicholas, and you talked about the literal story of St. Nicholas punching Arius in the face. 100% true.
It's what happened. Don't deny it. It's not. It's not what happened.
Okay, so you talked about that, and then Graham said some untoward things of, you know, Arius, and I stood up for Arius, which was kind of a silly thing, because he's a heretic. But, there's something to that of, the way we remember Arius is like, he was a bad dude, right? In the way the story goes, he wanted to destroy orthodoxy, and so he persuaded people of these wicked things. We have no idea what he actually said.
The story I knew is that he was a real good salesman, and had like jingles, and helped his second people's minds. Maybe I'm remembering somebody else. Yeah, when I said it, he was real clever, and he had like really great three-point sermons that you remembered. And he was charismatic, and he had like little pithy sayings that would be like, he's a different substance, not original created.
But even when you say it that way, it's more that his rhetoric was good. So he was more of a socialist than anything. God and Christ are different stuff. Different stuff is God and Christ.
History of the musical. I don't like this. Why hasn't anybody written this musical, is my question, because it would be so boring. Have you ever seen the musical?
It sounds awful. Oh, no? There's a Mormon musical. The Book of Mormon is...
I think it's actually called a Mormon musical. I've never seen it. I just assumed it's about Mormons. It's about Mormons.
It's about Mormons. It's by the people who do South Park, so... I think you'd call it reverend. Irreverend?
Yeah, it's incredibly respectful. None of the characters are overblown. I'm exaggerating. This is uncomfortable.
Remind me, the way through this podcast, I tell you when I accidentally stumbled into a Chinese religious revival game story. Why don't you tell the story now? Wait, so, okay. There's this banned religion in China.
Oh, what's it called? Is it Falun Gong? I think it's what it's called. Falun Gong, yeah.
And I used to live in Toronto, and a lot of adherents to it would be in Toronto, and they would hand up a pamphlet and nothing about it. Anyway, so there's this traveling dance show that comes to Austin, and it travels around North America, and it comes at Christmas time, and it says, you know, come watch traditional Chinese dancing, and, you know, the adverts have people doing, like, flips and throwing swords and stuff. I'm like, oh, this sounds awesome. So my wife and I got tickets to it.
Halfway through it, we realized pretty quickly that this was, like, the Falun Gong's version of, like, vocational Bible school. Like, there was a hard sell on, like, joining. Not joining, but I'm just, like, being sympathetic to it, and this one guy came on and, like, sang a song about how the end of history is going to happen, and we're all going to be vindicated, and everyone in China is going to realize that they should have been following us. And then the last dance number was this very heavily changed apocalyptic, like, basically, where all the faithful were taken up into heaven, and there was, like, floating Buddha statues and stuff, and my wife and I were like, what are we watching?
Anyway, that's, um... Did they throw swords? Yeah. Then I'm on board.
Okay, anyway, sorry. I've derailed this. No, it's fine. We'll also be talking about Falun Gong in this.
That's not true. So, heresy. So, kicked off by AJ's podcast of talking about Arius in relation to St. Nicholas, and then in our last episode, AJ made this super great comment about not treating the unknown as known, and I would say the title of the last podcast, if I trusted myself not to be able about it, but if you look in your podcast feed, you'll see.
On due time. Thank you. Much appreciated. So, that idea of not treating the unknown as known is important in talking about heresy as well.
So, I'm often accused of doing book reviews, so today we will continue in our tradition of... Don't let my wife bully you, Thomas. She already does all the time. I just cry about it.
It's okay. She was a goalie. She doesn't take any up from anybody. So, hack the bone.
Hack the bone? Is that something they say about it? Yeah, yeah. If their shin guards aren't on properly, just get to stick in there and...
And hack the bone? Yeah, chop that tree. It's horrible. Hey, if you're standing in your crease, all bets are off.
Standing in your crease? What is that? If you're a goalie, you have a crease. And if you have someone in the blue paint, you can hack the bone.
Are you speaking? Hello? Graham, are you okay? Boys, you've got to give her 110%.
A4 check, back check. Just get the box in the heat. Okay, so, speaking of books. So, what is...
Since we're in our discussion today is a book called Heresies and How to Avoid Them, and Graham and I got to kick out of their names when I first heard this with them, so hopefully that's a little legal. So, the author... Yeah, this book is edited by a few people. One of them is named Ben Quash.
Anyone? And Michael Ward. So, today we're going to... Ward and Quash wrote heresies.
Yeah, Warding them off and quashing them. So, heresies and how to avoid them, why it matters what Christians believe. That is what we're talking about today. So, what is a heresy?
Is there a good definition? Yeah, and so part of this, part of my confusion as to why you all are excited about this is that almost the least interesting thing about the talking about heresies is the heresies themselves, but I'm worried that you... Anyway, I have, like, three or four, like, main ideas related to heresies that I guess we'll get to at the end. I guess we'll get there by talking about the heresies, but, you know, we're talking about mostly early church heresies.
The book is split into two different sections. The first section are four heresies related to the character of Christ, and then the back half is more about, like, church life. So, think about how we think about the Old Testament. I guess we'll get into that in a little bit.
So, yeah, sure, we should start off with a definition of what is a heresy? Does anyone want to explain, like, to understand the idea of heresy? I will take a crack. Go for it.
My understanding of heresy is, specifically regarding, sort of, Christian faith, is a belief about our interpretation of the story, that if that builds into a theological premise or theological position, and if that theological position is held and believed and, sort of, works itself out into a community, it makes salvation impossible. Like, it undercuts the rest of the story. That sort of, the... Makes salvation impossible.
You know, like, or it makes, it's, it makes, not, it puts a disjointure into the rest of the story. So, like, for example, Arians say that Christ is of a different nature and a different substance of God, and you can have proof from the text, you can have sort of things that you cite, like he was the firstborn of creation, you know, and I think it's in Colossians. And I think that kind of is the big, the big maybe cited Arian verse saying that Christ is a created being, he's the firstborn of creation, different from God. But, so if you hold that belief, it makes the rest of the salvation narrative not work, because if, if, if God had to be man, you needed the perfect sacrifice only God could do, you needed the perfect representation of the accused, a man, like it, you couldn't perfectly wipe away the sins with a goat, and you couldn't perfectly wipe away the sins with an angel, because the angels weren't representative of the accused party.
So you needed a perfect man, and so God, you needed a God-man, and so if he wasn't God, and was a different substance of God, then you still don't have a perfect sacrifice. So that's my understanding, that's what I mean by this, is that it's a, it's a, it's one thing that you said about Jesus, or it's one thing that you said about the nature of God, which is often what the heresies are, but if you played it out to its logical conclusion, it throws in disharmony into the rest of these other theological positions, so that, like, the full understanding of the gospel and how it works doesn't, isn't going to work, because now you've, you know, taken it apart. I like your definition, I was just untrue things about God, right, the heresy. Yeah, so I think Graham was getting at why heresies matter, and then, AJ's is more, there's a more fundamental definition, so this is, I feel like so few books are clear on things in the way that this book is, so literally the first sentence of the first page, ideas achieve the status of heresies in Christian tradition because they are thought by the church to be wrong rather than right teaching or doctrine.
A heretic is a baptized person who obstinately denies or doubts a truth which the church teaches must be believed because it is part of the one divinely inspired and Catholic that is universally valid Christian faith. So that's to be a baptized person? To be a heretic, yes. Otherwise they're just a non-bleep.
You want to say more? Yeah, I think this distinction matters to say that. He does too. Because you meet some guy on the street and he's like, God is a giant turtle.
You can be like, you do you. Yeah, the appropriate reaction to that is not to call him a heretic because he's not saved, he's not baptized, he's not in the church family yet. So that, I think it's an important distinction to say that this is, so when we're talking about these things in this podcast today, it's their inter-family conflicts, is that the right way to call them? Like brothers fighting brothers.
A family squabble. Yeah, family squabble is the right way to put it. So it does not relate to religions outside of Christianity, it does not relate to people outside of the Christian faith. So I think that's an important thing to point out.
What Graham was talking about is, especially why the, it's kind of why the book is split into these two sections of heresies about Christ and then heresies about stuff that's not Christ, because if there are things that aren't true about Christ in these first four chapters, then it messes with the substitutionary, that's what I was going to say, that's a goofy word, it messes with his ability to be our representative in sacrifice, it messes with the ability of that sacrifice to pay for our sin. Yeah, so if God was just like a spectral projection of a man and not actually a man, if it was like Luke Skywalker in the new Jedi movie, whatever it's called, the last Jedi movie. Your favorite one, yeah. Oh, that movie sucked.
Anyway, if, you know, so he wasn't actually, I think it was a heresy that was, oh, Jesus, he wasn't actually a man because his flesh is evil, so he was just like a real good hologram. Gnosticism? I don't know which one it is. I refer to my expert.
Is that me? Not Gnosticism, but yeah, we'll talk about it later. You want to? No, that's just, yeah, all these different heresies regarding Christ, that's like the opposite.
Anyway. Yeah, just a few more as preface before we go into the heresies themselves, or the heresies themselves, I thought this echoed really well what Ajo was saying in the last episode, when all is said and done, orthodoxy is the hard discipline of learning to say what needs to be said and no more. Too often those we want to call heretics have tried to say more than can be said. They have succumbed to the temptation to say too much by explaining what cannot be explained.
And that's the majority of them, is that they want to go too far. There are a few of them that don't go far enough, and the book kind of splits this out. But more often than not, there's a mystery to God, and the heretics go too far in wanting to clarify the mystery. Are we going to do a quick show?
That's what the heresies are? Yeah. Are you going to tell us the heresies when you tell you the name? Or are you going to tell us the name when you tell you what the heresies is?
Yeah, I'd rather do it that way. Can I give you one last thing? I think it's related to this. This might not be interesting.
So there's another thing called a schism versus the heresies. Do you want to take a swing at that one? As far as I know, a schism is a disagreement within the church that causes a break in an organization. Yeah.
And is it something that is a difference of opinion on something that is not centrally orthodox? So the grand schism was between icons, right? And so the Eastern Church saying that these icons had a... Was it that they had a...
They almost had the same kinds of things that happened at communion? They had a sacramental presence, or they had a sacramental authority? The Eastern Church said this, and the Roman Catholic Church said, no, they don't. They're just nice pictures.
I can't remember. The schism was over the icons. Schism is a divorce in the family, whereas a heresy is a spat. Yeah, so the goal...
I guess this story will be repeated over and over again. So what happens in heresy is... Even using the word is complicated, because it raised us at some point a few episodes ago of... I forget what the topic was, but it was something to the effect of people believed something before the church made a formal stance on it, were they heretics at the time.
Do you remember this? I think it might have been the same number. I think it was talking about Arian... About Arians of...
So people held the position of Arianism before the Council of Nicaea, were they heretics before the Council of Nicaea? Maybe, but only in common practice. And much of the church's doctrine was defined in reaction to contrary doctrines. Many of the councils happened because the Gnostics were being popular, because Arianism was becoming popular, because...
I agree on, you know. It's on camp. Yeah, there are very few of those. That's great.
It's like a networking session. So my answer... Pass out your LinkedIn. It's like, I'm the bishop of Milan.
It's like... That's miserable. So you all should push back on me if I'm wrong, but I believe the answer is no, that this... They were not heretics until...
Until it is established as doctrine. Well, it wasn't contrary to orthodoxy yet. It wasn't... It wasn't...
So this is the complication. So Arianism was wrong all along, but it wasn't established as doctrine until the Council of Nicaea. Is that... So the view of post-Arianism was always right, but it was not established as orthodoxy until the Council.
Well, these things need to work themselves out, right? Like, you need to... There's... I wonder if there's even, like...
Theoretically, there should also be a practical aspect of heresies, right? Like, if a heresy is, in fact, not true, but it's held in belief in the Church, then theoretically, you should not see the Church grow spiritually or have the fruits of the Spirit, like, growing in its members. So if you didn't... If you deeply believe that...
That it is some sort of Gnostic heresy, and deep in your core you believe that, like, the human body and the created natural world is somehow inherently sinful, and you act out of that belief, then there should be no outworking of... of fruit in your life. I can see how that could be a really controversial statement to say, but there's probably something to that where you need to sort of see how heresies have worked themselves out in this community, and then the Council of Nicaea can say, all right, this Arian thing is not only against the story that we have received in Scripture, but all the people who are Arians are, you know, have this view about... aspect of creation that is meaning that they're not taking care of the poor or whatever it is because they've got some excuse to not do it.
The book will eventually end with some statement to a similar effect that right belief should live itself out in right action. There are situations where, so again, for some reason arianism feels like the perfect example to point to, arianism spread very quickly and it's just easier to understand than the orthodox Christian position. Yeah, maybe to further make a point, so I'm a big believer that we currently in the church right now are living in the midst of a time where lots of people don't realize that they are essentially functionally Gnostic, they think that bodies and the physical world don't matter and so you see this play itself out in Christian traditions that say things like well, God's just going to destroy the earth one day and so we don't need to take care of it or I believe in my heart but I don't need to act it out of my body because my heart and my body are not maybe they never say it this way but they're acting out functionally my heart and my body are not linked the things that I do with my body don't necessarily affect the beliefs that I have in my mind and so you've got this sort of hard disconnect and then that's not going to bear itself out in the growth of virtue and so you can say well, the reason why it's not growing itself out in virtue is because you are holding wrong understandings of what it means to be a created in God's image being and you think that the things that you do with your body are not going to have an effect on your soul that's a heretical position because it does have an effect on your soul and you are the sort of unified creature made under God and your body matters so that's kind of that I'm making I think that's also helpful because again I think most of the reason we're even talking about this is that I think it's important to have because every time we ask students questions about basic theological problems they work themselves into heretical statements there is that but the other side is that I think we should have some level compassion feels like the wrong word but some level of understanding for why there have been heretics or why there are people that we now call heretics more accurately we would say why were there disagreements in the church about certain theological issues and the reason is that there were valid points on both sides there's one of them that is that but otherwise it is two people who are just having a disagreement and one thing that's interesting in the definition that we started with heretic is a baptized believer who obstinately denies our doubts of truth which the church teaches must be believed so it's that obstinacy which they don't start out obstinately disbelieving because the orthodoxy hasn't been established at that point what's helpful in what you all are saying is that if we are now a Gnostic that's a bigger problem than if you were a Gnostic a thousand years ago before the theology or the orthodoxy was more left out so thank you for it again let's dive into I guess some specifics we will spend more time on Gnosticism I guess because we've been talking about it more but let's kick off so there are four heresies related to the character of Christ so the first of these is Arianism so what gentleman is Arianism? Jesus Christ is the he is a created being not an eternal being and he is of a different substance than the Father meaning that they're not they're not the same creature he is I think the preeminent first creation is the doctrine but he is a creation which makes him subordinate to the Father not on equal terms and not subordinate in the way that we understand the Trinity to be subordinate by choice and hierarchy but subordinate in that there was a time when he wasn't and there was a time when he was and he depends on the Father for his very creation so that's as far as I understand so Christ being created is kind of the key part yes exactly everything you said with justification he's the firstborn of creation or the very fact that yeah I guess this would be the big one said that any language partaking to Christ being born and I think it's a basic understanding of fatherhood that your kid hasn't been there since for the whole time that doesn't make sense so I understand how God the Father, God the Son would be confusing to everyone if they have been there at the same time and I feel like we've beaten Arianism probably into the ground just again the main points that are just some quotes to run through as we move on to the next one is again some form of compassion for Arius a quote I find lovely on the third page of this chapter unlike me Arius started from a position of strong faith and orthodoxy he was a well educated in one of the leading churches in Alexandria at the beginning of the 4th century so I thought it was such a sweet sentiment to have even though he gets a lot of bad press Arius was as far as we can tell scrupulous and careful in his study of the Bible Graham just made a comment a second ago I think about we don't have his writings so the only way we know what Aries believed is about what other people said that he believed but his opponents were not presenting him the best light so it's the I forget if I made this comment on the recording or just in our conversations it's the same with the Sophists where they get a bad rap all the time but we don't actually have the writings of the Sophists so maybe they were actually that bad or maybe everyone just hated them because they were rich you know what I mean we don't actually know how bad of other people they were so anything else on Arius before I keep moving on don't get it confused with white supremacy that's very helpful yeah how'd that get connected with the Aryan nations so that's a completely different thing is this spelled differently oh buckle up for some Google ladies and gentlemen because that's about to happen in the meantime so our next heresy is Docetism does anyone know about Docetism?
hmm this is also one with Christ's nature yeah so these first four are all the way to Christ is this the one where Jesus is just like a spectral projection I don't know if I would say and he's not actually he doesn't have a body it's just a big old trick and he doesn't actually die it was just like a whoops yeah so Docetism is the heresy which denies the whole humanity of Jesus Christ the name contains this Greek verb which means to seem yes Jesus only seemed to be human so it became popular around the Gnostics which we talk about way later so the part of it is the seeming so not actually being human and if I understand correctly it's coming out of a reverence for divine for the divinity of Jesus it's coming out of a reverence for divine there's something so distasteful of the idea of God dying of God eating and burping of God getting dirty with dust on his feet that the very thought of God's nature of the Godhood intermingling with dirty humans so I'll put him up they say well it was just a big old trick it just seems like he was human wait so what was it again the appearance of Christ being human he's not actually he just seems to be human oh he's like something else okay so like I was googling the Aryan Nations oh you were getting fired so the Aryanism is still with an I the Aryan Nations is still with a Y and it comes I think from some really old Indo-European script that basically means you're from Iran oh really I think something like that that's like the when you say Caucasian the Caucasus mountains aren't they in Iran I mean that was that was the most cursory Google you've ever seen so I might be probably wrong about this so he's just he's just an illusion human he's fully God not fully man it appears to be human but it's not actually human it's actually you know if you Graham and AJ here you see that I flagged like a hundred things I flagged nothing in this chapter so anyway sorry so he's like Beyonce here's human but it's not actually human is she superhuman a little more I'm not sure if you're recording a song right now no I've seen her Super Bowl performance and she it was a classic she broke the Super Bowl in what way did she break the Super Bowl she really used up all the power and the lights all turned off and that changed the momentum of the game because one team had been winning pretty handily and then it gave I don't know half an hour for the other team to collect themselves do some stretching get a little motivated drink some Gatorade and then they came back and won the Super Bowl I fully blame Beyonce for the outcome of that look it up wasn't Atlanta versus Seahawks was it Seahawks yeah it was probably Sports Ball you all watch the IT Crowd there's that one part where one of the characters is like she's not into sports and so he gets this like cassette tape and it's how to talk about sports without knowing anything and you remember what it is you see that ridiculous display last night he just tried to walk it in and then he meets someone who like had the same cassette tape and they talk about how much they hate sports it's wonderful that's how I feel about sports ball okay so the third one is Nestorianism Nestorianism oh god I think I know this one Christ is some sort of indwelling being that possessed a man named Jesus and then left just prior to the crucifixion or am I thinking that might be a form of adoptionism which we'll get to later I don't think I'm messing this one up there's just so many we need to do like trading cards for heresies so this is a heresy which denies that Christ was a single person and was God and man so it's to say that there was a split identity that there was a separate God nature and a separate human nature that were not intermingled so kind of like that yeah it sounds similar to it I don't think there's anything here about the there's two natures yes two separate natures so like not monophysite tell me what that monophysite means there's one nature yeah I guess one nature that's 100% God and 100% yes so our fourth heresy I'm for sure going to butcher this and I did and I forgot how to pronounce it there's a hybrid nature that is inside Christ so that hybrid nature is the mingling of God and man so he's not God he's not man he's God man it's a separate it's a third type of nature oh so it's like it's like if you've ever seen the underworld movies it's when the vampires and the werewolves get together and they make a third thing that's more powerful than both yes you can't reference that on this podcast that's a no no well I guess if people recognize the reference they're good that's their fault right I hope no anyway so those are so again so far we've referenced really bad TV shows and rated R films and Aryanism and Aryan nations this is what happens when you start mingling with heresies you guys it just takes you down the primroth path primroth? primroth are you okay? are we all losing our minds right now? you good?
okay so again so the question says to the identity of Christ what his nature was so this is why I was separating out Aryanism is more about his creation versus not creation and we get later to these issues of what is the substance what is the nature of Christ so either that he has a fully split human and divine nature I don't know if you've heard people do this sometimes they'll be like well you know this is his human nature here this is his divine nature here and they're like back and forth doing this too that's not a fair way of talking about him because he's fully both at all times it's not like he's only one at one time and he drinks a soda he's drinking it as God and as man yes this one's like he's got a partitioned hard drive like this time he's working on like Windows 95 and this one he's working on Linux he's emulating there's like a solid state drive the solid state drive is clearly divine clearly divine you can even drop it unless you're damaged you are the weirdest people okay so those are the four heresies related to the character of Christ so this has been summarized by theologians so what is the orthodoxy then? yeah I'm going to give you so in four words orthodoxy can be summarized in contradiction to these four views that I was going to give you in four words truly, perfectly, indivisibly, distinctly the first applied to his being God so he's truly God the second to his being man so he's perfectly he's a perfect man the third to his being of both one so indivisibly and the fourth to his still continuing that one what in the world? sorry this is my illness coming up do you feel like your brain is putting when you are ill? no right now I feel like there are two bodybuilders who are they both have a palm against each side of my head so there's pushing yeah or like I start reading and then like I jump three lines and don't know how I did it okay I'm doing great so that sounds like you become a superhero for a second I don't know I just blank out and I jumped the house I don't know how I did it well again I wasn't broken until last week so that's gotta be a hard truth to no so let me try this one more time so starting with the third the third to his being of both one so he is both God and man indivisibly and then and the fourth to his still continuing that one both and that's distinctly so that's there's not a melding of the natures but they like he's distinctly God and man we may fully by way of a briefment comprise whatsoever in antiquity hath at large handled either in declaration of christian belief or in refutation of the foresaid heresies wow that doesn't make no sense the summary of what is orthodox belief is again truly perfectly indivisibly and distinctly he's truly God he is perfect he is perfect he is indivisibly God and man and he is distinctly God and man that's not an amalgamation of natures in many ways like the heresies are attempts to get us out of paradoxes yeah this is great and to get us out of statements that are yeah they're paradoxical like how can he be both you know his natures are 100% God and 100% man but how are they indivisible how are they not mushed together so we get these paradoxical statements and then heresies are often these attempts to try to sort of close the loop and really finish the circle and say well here's what's really going on and it's kind of this one thing but like we've mentioned before that if you actually hold on to that especially when it comes to Christ's nature to actually hold on to any of those heresies then substitutionary atonement doesn't work anymore and then and not only that but I think it simplifies God to a point where it would be discouraging for me I like that I can't understand God and he doesn't fit in my brain because if he did if I fully understood everything that was going on there I feel like you know having a lockdown on how God works would be discouraging as a deity you'd hope that at some point since you were talking about an infinite being of immeasurable power that at some point like language and your ability to comprehend it should reach its outermost bounds because if it didn't then what are we then what are we talking about so really fast side note when we're talking about paradoxes one of the things that comes up with students all the time is that God created a rock so large he couldn't lift it and that is for the record not a paradox it's not even really good reasoning because God is infinite therefore he can create an infinite rock and if he created an infinite rock there's nowhere to move it to so it cannot move because it occupies all space so if anyone ever asks you that question say God can create an infinite rock and no he can't move it because it would occupy everything dumb dumb and walk off the answer make sure you say the dumb dumb part yeah that's the important one is really just put them in their place the one that students really just grind down you really really press them into the dust with your phone so no the one that students come across especially when we're talking about paradise lost is okay if God is a standard of goodness was it just is what we call good sort of this arbitrary thing that God made and therefore can change can he change the standard or is it of his nature therefore it is an unchangeable standard I was laying on the second one that's just of his nature so there's logic is logic something that God is beholden to or does God write like constitutions for himself that he himself can't break like in paradise lost God says I made man unchangeable I made man free and if I wanted to if I wanted to have him not fall I would have to revoke revoke my law unchangeable that I have decreed him free and I'm not going to undecree him free so it's like wait but God can do whatever he wants why doesn't he just say like not to my law and then that opens up the question of can God can God say can God say I promise to do this and then be bound by it I think he can Boethius would agree with you that God's goodness and his nature are inseparable because if there is a separate goodness from God to which he is subordinate then he is not the greatest and most powerful thing he is submitting to something else and therefore he's not the most powerful there's a rule that has to rule him and that's a problem at least that was Boethius' reasoning and I'm not saying Boethius is the best he's got some other problems like because you don't want to be dismembered you clearly seek God like that is that's some squippy reasoning this is a great reasoning I don't think one necessarily leads to the other but he kind of uses some some equivocation to get there in any case I think in this particular spot he reasons pretty well but let's keep up sorry your question before was about a person being I forget the phrase that you used that there was a human baby and then like a God nature into the baby when he was born is that what your question about Nestorianism that's what I thought Nestorianism was I think that's actually prognosticism well I can just say Nestorianism was a reaction to the Virgin Mary being called Theotokos which means Godbearer and so at some level what you're saying is right he was worried about people saying that Mary had God inside of her he wanted to say that there was a Jesus that was inside of her which was a human child and then as that child was born then became God so she didn't have God inside of her God came into this child after leaving Mary so this is all motivated to knock Mary down there was what the chapter describing that there was like rampant Mary worship and so part of that Mary worship came from seeing her as having God inside of her like the literal like she was the I'm trying to she was the ark you know what I mean there was great honor given to her because of God being inside of her and so to knock that down a few pegs he was trying to say that no she had this human child inside of her that was in Christ like became God after being birthed so yeah so maybe so yes so to add more to what you're saying yes that is a piece of it okay so let's move on to I'm going to breeze through a few and then get us to Gnosticism well it came out of Gnosticism I'll make some raping upper marks and then we will be done with this so just to name a few of the other heresies this agent might relate more to what you're talking about adoptionism is Jesus Christ the son of God by nature or by adoption that is to say was he born the son of God or did he become the son of God people often will point to his baptism at the point where he becomes the son of God at that point in a sense that he was just a dude for 30 years he was baptized he becomes the son of God and that gets shut down the answer is nah the next one is why what's the getting assumed into the who are the masons like you have a ceremony then you're a mason there's a term to it of that Christ is in fact one of the people he is I love that for 30 years he was just like a carpenter probably like a really awesome carpenter but like there wasn't anything I see that my students say this from time to time it's like when Jesus played basketball he just drained threes all day and it's like maybe I doubt it I mean that doesn't seem to missing a three doesn't that's not sin yeah in some very literal sense not getting in the hoop is literally missing no but missing is not a sin like getting something wrong in math isn't sinful it's not so in our professional learning community in our training as part of Veritas AJ and our intergroup together we're reading through Tim Keller's the book about work I don't remember the name of it about work anyway AJ was asking about will light bulbs have to be replaced in heaven and my answer was no because light bulbs won't break like sin the sin of the light bulbs is that it breaks like the fall in nature of the light bulbs is that it breaks like in Dante's Purgatory there are all these instances where every time he takes a fruit from a tree it grows back immediately because the perfect form of that tree is the tree with whatever its fruit is in the same way with I think someone way out holy to me was like there won't be any light bulbs because that'll be the light of the city which is a good answer but just to say that the fact that things break down is because of the fall that's fine but the fact that we get things wrong I don't know there's a difference between getting them wrong and learning this feels like a separate episode I don't think that that doesn't to me indicate that he is not divine I don't think an unlevel shelf even has to do with the sin curse of the world it's not like unlevel shelves came in with sin or at the end if you talk about the perfect form of the tree I think again we're letting some Greek ideas I think the perfect form of the tree is one that is growing and produces fruit not necessarily one that has all its fruit it's not sin to have someone eat the beautiful fruit you've produced because there's that moment when he plucked the fruit the split second before the new fruit automatically grew back like some kind of the tree's sin that doesn't no but I don't know I'm happy to return to this another time so moving on in heresies the next one which I will for sure we're going to have to return to this I don't think I can credit at this point okay this is awkward Theo I'm going to I'm sorry Theo, pastitism is Jesus Christ able or unable to suffer in his divine nature this is a fun one so when Jesus is on the cross what is suffering and the answer is that it is not his divine nature what this point is getting at is that the divine nature of Christ is immovable so God can choose to change his mind God can choose to love God can do all these things but he is not impacted by things outside of God the vicissitudes of life yeah that so the suffering on the cross yes was very painful but did not impact them the divine nature of Christ which is a deep mystery as to how that works but just say that and that's the heresy the heresy was saying that Christ suffered in his divine nature on the cross that's the heresy is that the divine nature suffered?
yes because it was impacted by something outside of yeah to say that the divine nature suffered is to say that something outside of God can impact God and that's not true you all are looking at each other well I just realized we may be heretics I'm going to have to go do some thinking yeah me too like Jesus wept right John 11 where he sees where Lazarus is dead has died we're to say that God is not moved by suffering or is his being moved by suffering a suffering like if you to be sad to suffer alongside somebody is that suffering? yeah let me try God suffers not in his divine nature the impassable divine nature was not infused with or changed impassable human nature in the person of Christ but the impassable divine nature was united with his human nature indivisibly and inseparably so that as a whole person God could suffer in Christ as a man so yes Jesus wept but God doesn't weep God the Father doesn't weep someone's going to send this email about this one alright listeners does God the Father weep here's my other one there's one about God loving yeah but this is not so God isn't loving despite being impassable he is loving because he is impassable remember our definition the impassable God can't be acted upon from without and he can't change himself from within if God is love that's good news because nothing can change that so the notion depends on suffering being able to change God is that outside of God yes is that the idea well the idea is that something outside of God cannot change God but suffering therefore in this conception is that it changes God yes I would have to have someone explain why suffering changes someone why suffering changes someone because it hurts because it's an outside you you're hurt right I haven't changed you have been hurt still me bro but you've been hurt like I've impacted you literally okay I get you but is the crawler issue like if we if we give praises to God are we not changing him is he not pleased by it and is anti-suffering he's ultimately pleased all the time I think we can answer that he's having a great time he's having a jolly jolly guy yeah that's what about loving he is loving no matter what there's no changing that from the outside I gotta think upon it okay this is my problem of carrying all these I now regret this and I'm not going to do it let's skip to Gnosticism so would you all please tell me what Gnosticism is I mean Greek so the word Gnosis means to know is it to know knowledge and it's based on wasn't it a secret knowledge cult yeah it's a secret knowledge cult and has a couple of wings for those who are like super into Christianity that's one part of Gnosticism and then the other part is a strong belief in the sort of evilness of matter and creation and the goodness of pure spirit and the goodness of pure spirit and part of what God has called us to is to escape the bonds of our meat prisons and you know be with him in in a pure matter spiritual realm so it has lots of lots of ties over to a lot of eastern or eastern religions as well and if I remember who doesn't probably being the closest one if I remember right in the higher echelons it's the doctrine that Jesus or whatever spirit in the world Jesus which I'll give to in a second wasn't even the highest most preeminent God he was sort of a sub-god of several so the big problem with Gnosticism and this is what got everybody up in arms is that the Christology changes because matter is so evil God could never become matter because it's evil and gross and terrible and pure spirit is way better so Jesus was just some regular dude that got possessed by pure spirit that sort of walked him around like a meat puppet and at the moment of crucifixion abandoned him right before he died so this poor Jesus fella got indwelled by a spirit possessed and walked around and then woke up right before he got smoked on a cross and that because they didn't think that pure spirit could die it couldn't be a part of this thing called death right it's eternal and so only the matter they get sort of swept up into sort of ecstatic expressions of spiritual indwellings and oftentimes in the ancient world that had expressions of you know sort of perverse sexual rights and that kind of thing every once in a while you would get you would get this sort of prophet person that would say I am also indwelt by some strong spirit and I've got this new message to add to it and you get this sort of cult following I think the attraction was the secret knowledge thing everybody wants to know all the secrets and it was attractive at the beginning because it says matters gross and everybody doesn't like having diseases and you know you got your bum toe and you think yeah that is pretty terrible and I like to think my pure spirit is separate and eventually I won't have to deal with this new prison and plus there's secret stuff to learn later and all that's attractive yeah and it's practically it works out to keep adherence because you've got you've got you know the next level to get to and people will be like okay well if I just keep doing this thing that my upper my you know the people above me keep telling me to do then I'll get like you know level up and I can learn the next little secret knowledge and so it's you know keeps a good retention rate on the old mystery cult which someone brought up before but kind of feels like in the same vein feels to me more like the greatest secrets are kept to the highest you have to be so far indoctrinated already so we pretty much nailed it is what you're saying so they're currently holding hands so yes problems of Gnosticism is that it's teaching that you can't trust what's been handed down in the church it's all you know these are general truths but they're actually special ones that you can find out and yeah you've gotten to the allure of it of getting that special knowledge there's some it can be highly individualistic so people can claim that they've got their own special knowledge and they've got their own sort of their own take on it and it's been revealed to them privately and the parts of what you are talking about are heresy of the free spirit which we're not going to cover today or probably ever but free spirit is where you get into there being two different types of wills like the one that most normal people get and the one that special people get but that's a good point so Graham you brought up a hot take on narcissism being some form of modern heresy do you want to say more about that I think just the sharp separation between mind-body and modern our sort of modern take on it the other one being that a strong willingness and ability or desire to say that my own that I've sort of come up with my own personal take on this thing that does not need to come under any sort of outside authority and I can just kind of do it on my own so the sort of cafeteria or the cafeteria model of taking this little piece of this and this little piece of this and this little piece of this and wishing it together into my own private spirituality I would say is a form of narcissism but the biggest one I think is the separation of that you've got a spiritual reality as a person and you've got a physical reality as a person and those two things do not necessarily have to have any currency that there's a real true magbee deep down inside that is separate from the meat magbee that we see in front of us and your physical body does not have any bearing on the spirituality of your heart and we have secular versions of bouncing around in a lot of the philosophy around identity and the idea of what is a person how does some person come across their identity and a lot of the language is talking about that there is a psychological identity on the inside that does not necessarily need to be beholden to the outside realities of the physical space I think a lot of this is finding a lot of currency on the internet because the internet can basically separate the real world from the online world and it can help train that disconnect where you can have your avatar life and you can separate that from your meat space world and things like virtual reality is going to amplify those habits of fracturing the self another form of this is there a modern day version of Gnosticism that Christians should seek to avoid a psychotherapy which suggested that the knowledge that we gain of ourselves in the psychotherapeutic relationship is itself what makes us whole human beings would perhaps be a genuine Gnosticism in a contemporary form it would have substituted self-knowledge for God's redemptive initiative in Christ for Gnostic's ancient and modern Jesus redeems us by teaching by helping us understand ourselves for the church Jesus is not just a teacher but the Christ the risen Lord the word made flesh for the world's redemption and this is although we were talking about this before the podcast this would be where I find personally the break that I have with sort of popular psychologist I think Jordan Peterson who we've never talked about on the podcast before but I know we all at some points listen to this would be personally my break that I have with him is that at the end his conclusions are that it is the self-responsibility if I understand him correctly it's the self-responsibility and the self-knowledge that has one about themselves which is the locus of salvation and Christian orthodoxy would say the locus of salvation is outside it is a repentance to God and a salvation by means of his spirit and so that would be I don't know if I'm calling Jordan Peterson a Gnostic but that would be at least the seeds of that kind of idea that salvation comes from self-knowledge and then picking that and then doing that or believing that you can do that and it is going to happen apart from God alright just to wrap up on this so what are some of the main why does any of this matter so a thing that we've said before is that we only get to a place of theology by having these disagreements so because of heretics we get orthodoxy we get the creeds we get confessions we get the statements of faith through heresy through disagreements in the church so there is a benefit to heresy which feels like a weird thing to say but something that the book likes to bring up every once in a while is that the word heresy is used in the Greek translation of Greek translation is the right way to say that yeah I think that's where a lot of people stumble is the idea that is the pejorative use of it I mean I think every Christian at some point has a heretical belief that they need to work itself out or they need to understand even AJ and I on this podcast thinking about God's suffering right like now we need to sit down and sort of think through this what's at stake what's at stake by saying God suffers and what isn't at stake by saying God suffers and working that out if we are obstinate in the face of it and we hold to one thing I don't know because of a sunk cost fallacy or whatever then that's where it becomes a personal problem or a relational problem with you and the church and you and God but honestly working out your understanding of how these things work and I think is part of faith for our listeners two notes first the sunk cost fallacy if you don't know what that is I think it's that you stick to an idea because you've already already put so much effort or money into it. We've got to keep on keeping on because... It's the 4 a.m.
this essay's crap, but I'm going to keep on with it. Yeah, I can't start a new one. And then, if you are not a Christian and listen to the podcast, I know there's some of you out there, then I think this information is still valuable in understanding the progression of the early church and understanding just the historicity of how the church deals with different opinions and how those opinions in the church came about. That's still pretty valuable.
I agree. I think the broader point, though, is that if someone disagrees with you about something, that you should seek to understand why they disagree. And that's the history of parasy. It's two people with valid points on both sides coming to eventually say one is right, but you don't understand the other side first.
And I think that's... We like to make fun of people who read classics poorly because they approach it with a political lens before they approach the work, but there's a value in understanding why people are approaching it that way. There's a value in understanding it. Yeah, it doesn't mean you should read a word so far over time.
I have much more to say, but I won't. Just to wrap up, so one piece of it is that we understand our beliefs by engaging in disagreement. That's the first point. And that's not only for Christians, that's for anyone.
And the second, I think, also broad point, is what happens to these heretics? Are they all killed? Are they all kicked out? And here's a quote.
What happened to these people? Arius was banished, but later recalled, and Athanasius was afforded to receive him back into communion. Seriously? I didn't even know that.
Yeah, we have this idea of the inquisition when it comes to heresies, but that's not with the early church. What's happening now? It's not what they wanted. They desired reunion.
Yeah, so they didn't need to hunt their own. But just to say, it was not all killing a few people who disagreed with them. There was a desire to be reconciled, and more often than not, whoever was eventually branded a heretic chose to leave themselves. So, I think that matters.
Anyway, that's cool. Well, thank you, audience, for tuning in to this heretical episode of Classical Stuff. You should know. You can email us at classicalstuff at veritasacademy.net.
You can check us out on Twitter at at C-L-S-S-C-A-L. Check out our website, which is classicalstuff.net. And you can see us about town. About town.
We are men about town. Swinging our canes. Doing things. Wearing our capes.
Holding our monocles out of our poor eye. That's us. Well, thanks for listening. Let's just stop.
Bye.