Hello and welcome. I'm Marie. And I'm Rifkin. And you're listening to Talking Talks, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So, Uri, I think we got a lot of feedback about last week's episode where we talked about two pretty interesting topics. We talked about AOC's comments comparing the detention centers at the border with concentration camps, especially triggering us all to understand she's really...
comparing two concentration camps, Nazi concentration camps. And also our topic about Kyle Kashuv, whose acceptance letter from Harvard was kind of rescinded after a bunch of his comments came out that had been racist and anti-Semitic and, you know, offensive in light of that. So what kind of comments did you get, Ari? Well, so first of all, in case anyone didn't hear the original recording, here's AOC on Instagram talking about these detention centers. The United States is running concentration camps on our southern border. And that is exactly what they are. They are concentration camps. And if that doesn't bother you, I don't...
I want to talk to the people that are concerned enough with humanity to say that we should not, that never again means something. So over the last week, this came up in a lot of different conversations. A lot of people that I heard were also upset about it, but a lot of people were upset at the Jews who were upset, you know, and were saying like, you know, if AOC is bringing awareness and positive change to this issue, then why are you criticizing her? You should be praising her. I mean, is that kind of some of what you heard also? So what I thought was so interesting early in this, I think, is in the responses that, in conversations I had in person, also in a lot of the responses that we got to our page, is that people felt very, very viscerally emotional about this. And that's people on all sides. And I think, I don't think that's a bad thing. I think that's a very good thing. Of course, when you're emotional, you also want to be able to hear the...
emotion behind the other side also. But people, I think, were very, very, felt very connected to this and felt very viscerally, like, how can they be doing this to us? And also viscerally, how can you be attacking them? You know, they're trying to protect children, right? So there's a lot of, there's a lot of really raw emotion behind this entire topic. One of my favorite messages was from a friend of the show, Rachel, where she wrote a really, I think, impassioned, impassioned message, pretty upset about the idea that people are focused on the words concentration camps. And she really wants us to be talking about the deeper issues. And let me just quote one particular part. She wrote, I have to point to the Dara Horn article recently published.
and Sideshow will put a link to that article, of course, where she points to how we can be as educated about the Holocaust as we want, but if all that tells us is that what we see today isn't as bad as the Holocaust, then we are missing the point. There are thousands of microaggressions of anti-Semitism or horrible ways that people are being treated, and they should not be negated or ignored by the fact that they're not as bad as the Holocaust. So I'm sorry that the word concentration camp hits a nerve, but it's supposed to, to wake us up to what's going on. The fact that Jews survived the Holocaust should not mean that we are untouchable victims forevermore. It means we should be the advocates for others being persecuted. So the reason I quote that particular piece is because I think she touches on really the two responses that I think many Jews today have to the Holocaust, right? There's the approach of our people were persecuted and six million of us were killed. And what that leads me to believe is that we really have to look out for ourselves because other people won't. So we have to look out for the reputation. We have to remember the Holocaust. We have to remember that people are not going to be there for us. And we have to protect Jews. And we have to make sure that the memory of the Holocaust and what happened to us Jews is protected. And that's also that I think comes also with this defense of Israel in a lot of ways. And remember, the rest of the world isn't going to be there for us. We have to be there.
for us. And then I think that the flip side of that is sort of the more liberal quote-unquote approach, right, of saying, look how terrifying and scary and awful the world could be, because look what happened to us, and therefore we have the responsibility to make sure this doesn't happen to other people, right? Look out for our justice. The part that really upsets me, though, is that I don't see why those two approaches are mutually exclusive. Agreed. And so what bothers me about AOC is that I just think she's immature and not very intelligent and not very articulate. But so all she had to do was qualify her statement and say, this is not as bad as the Nazi concentration camps, but it reminds me of that, and there are certain similarities. That's all she had to say. And then after she got the criticism, she doubled down, like we said. And her doubling down, I think, was very interesting.
way she said it was last week this is on twitter last week we called the concentration camps at the border for what they are in the week since acting director of customs and border patrol resigned bank of america announced they will stop financing for-profit immigrant detention and private prisons words matter so she ends her thing by saying words matter which is so opposite of like the point the point is that yes words matter and so don't make direct comparisons when they're not accurate and so she's just doubling down on that and so it upsets me that there's so few democrats or liberals who are willing to criticize her there are some but they can't like they can't just say she's right that this is a crazy humanitarian crisis and we need to do something about it and she's wrong for making that comparison like why can't people just say that what's so hard about saying that I mean, I think you know what's so wrong about that, right? Because in our political environment, people choose their camps. And when someone in their camp does something wrong, everyone in their camp defends them. And when someone in the other camp does something wrong, everyone in the other camp attacks them, right? Because that's how it works. You're right that people in general are not going to be as nuanced as maybe we would have liked. Maybe I wasn't comfortable with the language that AOC chose to use, but I absolutely think it was okay for her to use, even though it's not language that I...
viscerally love, right? I don't think it's evil. I don't think she's an idiot. I think she's drawing attention to a cause. And I think, as she just put it, she succeeded. When she says words matter, she's saying words matter because they create action. Okay, so even if the words aren't true, she's basically saying the ends justify the means. That's what's implied. But she doesn't think the words are untrue. It's a comparison. She's not saying equals. She's saying it's key. I've seen that's what people who are defending her are saying. The ends justify the means. Yes, what she said was not technically true, but because it brought about a good outcome, I think that's implied in a lot of the responses. I also think, you know, if you just take a step back, like, I think it's just to close this out. It's interesting to think, like, okay, so AOC is not Jewish. And she, even though she did allude to
so it's controversial, fine. And the people she's talking about are not Jewish. So it's an interesting question, like... change up some of those variables, what would be different? Like, if the victims here were Jewish, if AOC was Jewish, you know, if Bernie Sanders was the one saying this, like, would that change anything? It's hard to say, but I also think it's important to recognize, and this is obviously up for debate, but if it was a different minority group, you know, if this was a black racist issue, would we be saying, hey, look, there's lots of black people and black academics who say that this is not racist, whatever the issue was, and therefore we as a society don't have to consider this racist when there are still many people who said it was racist. Like, here you have the U.S. Holocaust Museum, you have the Simon Wiesenthal Center, as well as many, many mainstream
Jewish individuals and Jewish institutions who are all saying this was inappropriate and offensive and harmful. So just because there are certain also prominent academics and Jews and whatever people who are saying it's okay, that does not mean that there's no issue here and that we don't have to be sensitive to it. That also upsets me. Yeah, I understand that. I think that it's complicated, especially because so much of it has gone along party lines. It's true that these are major organizations that deal with the Holocaust, which you would hope and I think would think that these generally don't fall along party lines. People are making some talk about the Holocaust Museum being associated with Trump. I think the director was appointed, something like that. And we'll put a link to that because I don't remember the exact thing, so I don't want to say anything incorrectly. But I think...
More importantly, my cynical take is that AOC has a lot of Jewish supporters who are saying, you're exactly right. These are people who are on the left wing, and they are very, very much Jewish, and a high proportion of Jews, as we discuss very often, are liberal and are left wing and are the kind of people who are sending AOC messages saying, you're exactly right. My grandmother's a survivor, and you're exactly right to say everything you're saying. So I think it's a little bit hard. You also obviously have people saying, this is offensive, this is ridiculous, but because those are in her camp anyway, if more people internally from her camp return to her and saying, look, I'm on your side, but I'm not comfortable with what you're saying, then maybe she would think a little bit differently. And I understand your frustration of, why aren't people doing that? Why aren't people seeing the nuance? But unfortunately, that's the political reality we live in, and it's bad.
Right, but forget about AOC. My question is, how come the Jews who aren't offended by it, and I understand why they're not, why aren't they sensitive to the other Jews and the survivors and whatever who are offended by it? You know what I mean? Why can't they say, for the sake of the other people who are offended, let's try to modify our statements a little bit? Because they're saying, for the sake of these migrants who are in these conditions... No, we can still talk about the migrants. But I understand. If they're saying, like, I'm going to make a big public support for people, and I'm going to say it's more important to save these migrants than to talk about the memory of your blah, blah, blah. Well, one final thought that I wanted to say on this is that...
In one of the segments on the Promise podcast. Our favorite podcast? Yes, last week that we talked about last week also. They were talking about this topic. And Noah Ephron, the host, he was very ambivalent about the issue. Like, you know, he's obviously very sensitive and upset about what's happening in these camps. But he was also upset that AOC used this terminology. And he basically made a point that I thought was a very good point, which is that Jewish suffering has been...
marginalized and minimized to a certain extent, especially in recent years. Like, that is obviously a controversial statement, but I think there are examples of it, whether historically Holocaust-related or, like, you know, persecution of Jews, let's say, in Arab countries that is not really talked about a lot, to, like, more recent things, like terror attacks in Israel that are, you know, seen as, like, you know, are they terrorists? Are they freedom fighters? Like, that's something that Jews are very sensitive to, and that, I think, also explains why people were very worried about this, that this could somehow be minimizing. Right, like, it's another example of marginalizing Jewish suffering historically. Yeah, I think that's at least how a lot of people feel. It's funny, like, I was thinking recently about how, like, when Christians talk about the Crusades, like...
It's such a different perspective than when we talk about the Crusades. When I think about the Crusades, I think about the bloodshed and how Jews were always the victims and they were always caught in the middle and everyone was trying to conquer Jerusalem and the Jews were just these pesky people who were always in the way. Where Christians talk about the Crusade of liberating the Holy Land and stuff like that. It's used as a metaphor for a positive thing. For the piety. Right. And I think that the lesson is just being sensitive to other groups, especially minority groups. And if a lot of these liberals and Democrats are so sensitive to every other group, I think they should also be sensitive to Jews. Yeah, it's an interesting point. And one, I think that is made more complicated by the fact that so many Jews are on that side also. So that makes it a little bit harder. But yeah, okay. Uri, I'm glad we talked about this again. Hopefully over the next week or two, there won't be any...
AOC, Ilhan Omar. Well, we have something to talk about on the show. Yeah, hopefully we'll find other topics. But, you know, they do give us a lot of material. And, Uri, before we get into our next major topic, I just wanted to mention, one of the things that we've talked about before is we talked about the U.S. women's soccer team. Yeah. The World Cup is currently going on. There are four teams left, and USA is one of the final four. Have you watched any of the games? I have not watched a single game. I actually, I was thinking about it today. I find soccer very tough to follow because it feels very hectic. Like, you never know where the ball is going to go. There's so much less control than in a sport like, you know, baseball or basketball where there's a lot more. You're using your hands. Like, it's a lot more measured. You have a lot more control over what's going on. With something like either hockey or soccer.
I feel like I don't know what's flying. Like, I mean, the ball. Yeah, it probably takes getting used to, but I guess I sort of hear that. But when I was in Ghana, I had a lot of fun watching soccer, and I kind of, like, got into it more, especially because, like, everyone there was so excited about it. I think because sports is such a collective thing, if I had friends here who were into it, I'd probably be more into it. Was there women's soccer there or just men's? Both, but definitely men's. I was there during, like, a big, like, I think during the African Cups, it was, like, a really big deal, and I think Ghana was in the final and lost. And that was men's. Yeah, yeah, and that was really exciting, and so that's why that was a major thing on it, but the truth is that, you know, people really follow everything, and everyone plays, so it's a different experience. So one of the things
of the things that kind of makes sense kind of feels weird but like i think is understandable but it's like a little bit confusing is that to a certain extent even though what they're talking about is institutional gender discrimination they're talking about not being paid the same way not getting the same benefits not getting the same playing time right practice time access to fields all of these things um that honestly if women's soccer wins the world cup that will help them in their suit even though their suit isn't exactly about who's a better team right especially because the women's team is clearly so superior to the men's team didn't even make it right to the right well you're saying you're saying superficially um On paper, they're saying we should be treated and paid equally just because we're all people and we're all working hard and whatever. The implicit thing is, by the way, we're also so much better than the men's team. So why are they making so much more money? Is that basically what you're saying?
Yeah, exactly. I mean, I don't think, and we'll put a link, obviously, to the actual text of the suit, but I don't think they mention anything about, oh, we're so good, you know, how come we don't get treated the same way? But they talk about the Equal Pay Act, right? And they talk about the Civil Rights Act, right? So it's things like that, which says that they should really be getting equality. They should get all the same resources. So I think even though they're hypothetically unrelated, I think it feels very clear to me, and I think to many of us sort of cynically watching, that if they do win the World Cup... It's going to help their case. Yeah, it definitely will. Well, yeah, I'm curious to see what their ratings are going to be like and what the response and reaction from the American public will be like if they win. They're heavily favored to win. And I'm sure it's going to help their case. The question is, how much will
winning the World Cup, you know, bring U.S. women's soccer, like, to the forefront of, like, fandom or, I mean, they've won plenty of times in the past and that hasn't exactly happened. Well, they are more popular. Like, a lot more people can name women's soccer players than men's soccer players. They're all still very low compared to other sort of national sports. And I think this case is actually going to go to mediation as soon as the World Cup is over. So it's interesting, because it's going to mediation, even more so, it's really about the conversation that the different parties are going to have as opposed to just the technical law, right? So I think we're all watching with bated breath. Go USA. Yeah, good luck to them. Yeah, maybe we'll do, like, a Talking Talkless viewing party in the finals. We'll host it at Drive-In Studios. They're so good to us.
Now we're going to bring in two of the stars of the U.S. Women's National Team, Megan Rapinoe and Kelly O'Hara. Hey, can you guys feel the love? Can you just feel the excitement back here? What are the feelings and the emotions going into that big match against England tomorrow? We're definitely feeling the love. Obviously, we have a lot of our friends and family here, but we have so many people back home and just kind of the country at large. We're feeling that love, so keep it up. We love that. We wrote a little note to all the bosses and supervisors to ask for employees to get the day off, and I think a lot of them listen to us, so we're excited that everybody's been super stoked and has been getting out of work to cheer us on.
So Yeshivat Maharat, which is the major orthodox institution that ordains women as clergy members, we actually discussed this maybe like two months ago when there was that whole flare-up in Teaneck, New Jersey, where the RCBC, the Rabbinical Council of Bergen County, was uncomfortable with one of the rabbis who was a member of the RCBC, Rabbi Halfcott, that he, at his shul, at his synagogue, had an intern who was a student at Yeshivat Maharat. So that caused a little mini uproar. So recently an article came out by a Maharat who... got Samicha maybe four or five years ago. Her name is Rachel Cole Feingold, and she works on a clergy team at an Orthodox synagogue in Montreal. She recently came out with a piece that explains that though for the past several years working at this shul, she's been using the title Maharat, she has decided to begin using the term Rabbah before her name, which is slightly interesting, controversial, right? Because Rabbah instinctively for many people feels a little bit too close to Rabbi, which is I think why they chose the name Maharat. And I think Maharat has an official policy that they let the women choose their titles. And she explains why she changes her title from Maharat to Rabbah. And let me just read a couple of pieces of the article from different spots.
And she goes on to explain why she likes the title of Maharat, right? She says... I have grown accustomed to the way my congregants call me Maharat Feinbold or Maharat Rachel as a sign of our closeness. I love being greeted by our preschoolers, some with those adorably early speech patterns, which I think is like a really cute thing to imagine. For a three-year-old, it's quite a mouthful. And yet, the title has also created some confusion. It's hard for people, even native Hebrew speakers, to know what the word means and sometimes even to remember it. When people joke that they call me Maharaja, I know they mean it endearingly, but it reminds me that this word still feels foreign to their Jewish life.
If being a maharat has been a delicate dance, then six years after my ordination, I no longer need to dance quite so delicately. Members of my community fully accept my presence as part of the clergy and as a halakhally observant Orthodox woman. The time is ripe for me to move toward a title that is more rabbinic to the ear and more familiar to the tongue. And Uri, I think this to me felt like what was most striking. At the end of the article, Rabbah Rachel says, As I begin to utilize my new title, I wonder how it will feel and sound to my community. And to be honest, I worry. I worry that my colleagues to the right in Yeshivish and Chabad and other right-wing Orthodox communities who have always offered me only support and respect might begin to turn away from me.
I worry that I will lose the trust and acceptance of those with whom I've worked to build relationships. I worry that the term Rabbah might alienate some young women who are excited by the idea of serving as clergy, but for whom the title sounds uncomfortable. And yet, Maharat or Rabbah, I'm still the same person I was before. There are already many women using this title, so I'll be in good company. And over time, I'm sure my preschoolers will run over to me just like before, give me a hug, and say, hello, Rabbah, Rabbah, and all will be right in the world. So, Uri, I thought it was a pretty powerful article. I kind of like that she made it very personal because you can kind of feel the conflict that she went through, you know, both when she chose the title originally and as she went through the process. I think there are a lot of interesting kind of directions to go in. But the first is something that I think we kind of debate within our community very often as topics like this come up. And I'm kind of wondering how much you think titles really matter in this case, right? Do titles kind of influence the way we think about things? Are titles the way in which...
We communicate the opinions that we already have, right? I don't know. What do you think, Gary? Yeah, I think it's really interesting. And I definitely sympathize with the conflict and the struggle that she finds herself in. I don't think she, you know, on the one hand, this whole article, she's talking about herself and how she wants a different title.
I don't think it came across as arrogant at all. But at the same time, it is a slightly awkward thing to be talking about yourself in that way, as opposed to, let's say, the rabbi of her community talking about, hey, listen, everybody, we have to call her rabbi from now on because that's her title and whatever. Then it would be a man talking about a woman. I think it gives her more power to do it yourself. But I see what you're saying. I think it's also interesting, as you alluded to, I think in modern times, this is a gradual thing that's been happening for the last whatever. Our society doesn't have the same kind of reverence for authority that it once did, if anything.
people are very suspicious of authority and especially like titles and honorifics and things like that. And, you know, in that vein, it's like, I know it's in the academic world, especially like in universities, professors are always like very, maybe like overly humble to the point where they come across as arrogant, but like insist on being called by their first name and not doctor or professor or whatever, things like that. I never had a professor like that. Your professors insisted on being called by their first name? A bunch of them. And it was specifically the ones that were the most accomplished and the most senior who were more likely to be that way. And same thing with rabbis. I have come across a lot of very... Interesting.
successful accomplished rabbis who like just want to be called by the first name because they don't feel that they need the title and but at the same time titles are very important and like this is the kind of situation where like because this is a new thing and because so much of it involves like breaking stereotypes and trying to change people's minds about seeing things like it is i'm not denying that i agree that it is important what we call her and and what the title is and stuff like that so like you know what i mean like there's a lot going on here yeah so that's interesting right i mean i think about when I was in high school, right? Let's go away from professors. I'm imagining if one of us ever called, you know, let's say, let's say a teacher named Rabbi Shulman, right? If his first name was, you know, Yaakov, if we would ever call Rabbi Shulman. Right, not in high school, yeah. Right, meaning, but what I'm talking about specifically is the rabbi title, right? Like many of us would call our female teachers by their first names. And I think it's a good point, actually, Uri, that many of our female teachers also said, oh, just, you know, call me Rachel, you know, call me Yal, whatever. But our male teachers would never say, call me Yaakov, call me Moshe, right? It was very much, my name is Rabbi Shulman, my name is Rabbi, whatever. Right, this might be a high school versus college thing. Right, and it's also definitely true that I had a bunch of male teachers in high
wait, he doesn't actually have smicha? But the schools made the decision that even though they didn't have smicha, that we would respect them more. So it's like the opposite. You have men who don't have smicha who are called rabbi and women who do have smicha but are not allowed to be called rabbi, which is very interesting. And that idea of the title sort of signifying a specific type of respect, I think it's sort of what comes into it. And I think gradually many of us have sort of...
come to agree, because I think the instinct that many people had years ago, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think the instinct of, like, who cares? Why does the title matter? I think more and more, I think we're kind of saying, okay, you know what, maybe it shouldn't matter, maybe we shouldn't use it as sort of a signifier, but it does. You know, it affects salaries, it affects respect, it affects the way people think about you. Right. I know that it affects salaries, because I've heard of specific cases where, like, women are doing the same job as men in these yeshivas, but they're not paid as much because they don't have the smicha degree, but they don't have the option of getting the smicha degree, so that's not fair. But I mean, I think you would agree, in an ideal world, it's not the person's title or even their education that determines their worth in a community, it's their actions, and it's what they're doing for the community
in a position of clergy for a shul, she herself obviously would agree that what she is called is not really what's important. It's the work she's doing and the way she's perceived. The argument she's making is that it's just because of human nature and because of whatever the words and the titles influence the way she's perceived. There's obviously truth in that also. I guess the question would be, and I could see the counter to her.
Argument being, why are you so fixated on your title? Why don't you just do such a good job that people will gain respect for you based on that and not based on she's calling you Rabat versus Rabat. So I think what's so compelling about her argument is she kind of says, like, that's what I did. I didn't want this controversy about, oh, she's calling herself Rabat, whatever. So I just took the simplest title, and I didn't want to make waves, and I did a really killer job. And she talks about there are people in the community who say, you know what, honestly, I was wary, but you kind of changed my mind. And I've personally heard that from friends of mine who say they were a little bit...
put off or a little bit confused. And then once they actually met people who were maharads, who were rabbis, who were working in their communities, they said, you know what? They're not trying to make waves. They're just trying to teach Torah. So I think that to me felt really authentic and really interesting. And I guess what I'm kind of wondering, Uri, and this is obviously very subjective because the two of us, as we talk about often, we both live in New York, we live in sort of fairly left-wing communities. But I'm wondering, has there been a sort of change since maharad has come around the past five, six years? Do you think that communities in general are more open to female leadership, even with the terms that feel more charged? What do you think about that?
Yeah, I think it's hard to say. And like, as you said, it's hard for us to really have perspective because we are in some sort of a bubble. I think there definitely has been a shift. It might be a slow shift or a gradual shift because meaning there's different kinds of institutions because there's also... There's the Yoet Set program. There's the GPATs at YU. There's all kinds of different variations of women having a more prominent role in communal life. And unless you know the details, they all kind of sound the same to you. Like, oh, it's a female binic-ish leader. Exactly. So my point is, I do definitely think that the concept in mainstream, let's say, modern Orthodox Judaism, the concept of women having some sort of communal role has definitely moved a lot. I think the terminology people often get hung up on, which is really much more cultural than halakhic, I think. I think that's a really good point because I think there is probably a...
you know, more, let's say, right-wing YU crowd, quote-unquote, that they might go to a shul and see a woman as a rabbinic leader and say, oh, hold on, where did she get her certification? Or where did she study? Oh, she studied at Nishmat? Okay. And also what's she being called? Yeah, exactly. And things like that, much more than the idea of a woman being a rabbinic leader. What's she actually doing? Right, exactly. So I think that's an interesting point, that a lot of it feels cultural and social. And the OU still, you know, very much comes out with very strong statements against, and obviously the RCBC thing a few months ago, we saw that this is still very much an issue. And still having a, you know, as the RCBC showed us, having a female Orthodox clergy only happened at one shul and quickly became this huge, you know, as soon as it blew up in the media, it became crazy. So in that
It's not as mainstream as maybe we would assume just, you know, in our bubble. But I do think that whether you agree with her choice or not, I think she wrote a really compelling emotional take, and I respect her very much. I mean, I don't know her, but just reading her. I've met her. She's an impressive person, for sure. Well, there you go. Problem solved. Talk and talk. Figure it out. But, of course, we want to hear from all of you, especially Rabah Rachel. I'm sure you're a listener. We want to congratulate you on your new title. Please be in touch with us if you want to appear on the show. And, of course, everyone else, we want to hear what you think about all of these topics. Send us an email at TalkandTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. And, of course, be in touch with us on our Facebook page, Talk and Talkless Podcast.
Thanks, as always, to Drive-In Productions. They are the sponsor of this week's episode. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Pong Tachos. Bye, everyone. Bye.