Hi and welcome to classical stuff you should know a podcast about the ancient world classical education and Old stuff put on by three classical scholars. It's like a bold. My name is Graham Donaldson I'm here with Thomas Fletcher Maggie. Hello classical scholar.
Yes, indeed CS CS Arthur yawn otherwise affectionately known as AJ Hannenberg CS. I like this boys. I like this We teach at a classical Christian school in Austin, Texas called Veritas Academy and we come every week into your car Your homes your cell phones in order to bring you the best of the ancient world and our hot takes the best of the ancient world Where the arbiters were the operators? Yes, we're creators of the world.
Yes. We haven't talked about it It's not worth right now nothing seems about right anyway And gentlemen, I promise myself that I would be above board and then I would not make any jokes even though that this is the number two podcast about duty on duty on duty number two and Could you pretty much teach us about Cicero and duty our aughts? Okay, somewhat convicted of the disorganized nature of my last podcast on Cicero I just didn't think it was very good. So I've endeavored to make this one better.
So if it's not I didn't do it I tried really hard to be good. So let's let's just jump right in so last time We talked about Cicero's on duty book one and on duty book one So much on duty book one is about how to just be a good person right and it has our four different divisions of how to do that Number one a full perception and development of the true in other words be smart not dumb number two Congression of an organized society be kind just and charitable Number three have a great noble and strong soul right do hard things with an indifferent spirit and number four Generally be a gentleman in all sorts of other things manners. I'm into it So good be smart be kind Justin charitable do hard things and be a gentleman be smart not dumb as how I start every one of my classes I was beginning of every year. He actually it's a con response be smart.
No. Yeah. Oh, I'm adding that to my cataclysm Okay, it is it has been somewhat convicting for me on a personal note because this comes like reading this comes right in the middle of sort of a Self-infantry about virtue and vices so I don't know reading Cicero has been especially effective for me recently Right, so if you are out there thinking about your own virtue and vice and needing to go through sort of a rundown of everything He might not be the best but it certainly doesn't hurt to hear what Cicero thinks on all these are definitely worse people You can go to then Cicero Tony Robbins Yeah, there's all kinds of bad self-help out there and this just I mean it's ring it's not ringing any new bell It's just saying again and again the same old thing have the virtues be just be charitable all these things were important to men who weren't even Christian Right, right? I think I'm pretty sure he was pre-Christian wasn't he?
I don't know Yeah, yeah, you know fairs. I've never written on your own team. Maybe the Cicero over times and I have no idea I love him. Yeah, you know, I feel like Silicon Valley entrepreneur type right?
I don't know if that means anything. Yeah, right so jumping in let me ask you boys a question Mm-hmm because we're moving from what is good to what is expedient? That's what book to us all about what is expedient what is practical podcast Yes, obviously, you know, that's why we're here What is the best way to get what you want material goods wealth success? What is what is the best avenue to take to get there help enough people get what they want and then you'll get what you want?
That's a zig-zigler. I think Cloak and dagger back channeling. Okay, so back China By the way, listen if you hear random yells and hollers were right at the end of the school day and the kids are you know stumbling down the halls And dragging their backpacks and they don't sound the dragon their backpacks. They sound like it's an organized flash mob out there They are kicking and screaming and singing and dancing and there's a wall somewhere okay So you you say help enough people get what they want and you get what you want.
Uh-huh, so how does that reasoning work? so If your goal is profit you get profit by selling something that people want that meets a need so by meeting enough people's need you get money Which is a goal of business? Which is what so this is more of a business oriented thing if I sell enough products I will get what I want Or even if you're trying to make your way up through an organization You have a boss if you help that boss meet their goals and that boss will like you and promote you You can get what you want through promoting that way if you are in politics and you want to get something passed You do favors for other people and then they They want to help you back. They pass your legislation.
You help them so that they want to help you So it seems like all of that is based a little bit on self-interest Yes, that right okay, so help enough people they will want to help you which way you start from a place of everyone is self-interested But for you to achieve your self-interest you must help other people's just like how to win friends and influence people Yeah, yeah, and again I'm not making a moral claim. This is a how to win friends and influence people is like say people's names a lot And they like you like it's it makes no judgment of the type of friend you're making yeah, Thomas. I think you're right on that Tom. Thank you.
I appreciate that Graham. That's okay I think whatever you want. It's good. Thank you.
That's a great point. Yes, Graham Why the back channeling I assume you're being facetious a little bit But I mean like it's sort of maybe the Machiavellian way of thinking about getting what you want And I think maybe Machiavellian the Machiavellian way is also Thomas He would agree with what you're saying which is you know get people on your side and then they will do favors for you It's like very Italian mobster. I was being a little yes I was being facetious, but it's the idea of you know, it could be just as purely basic as like Set a goal and like go for it like a lot of people don't think I'll go see what you want and get yeah, yeah, so I mean And brush up to the borders of your own personal Capacities for ethical behaviors or go as far as far you'll push you envelope as far as you're willing to push it Okay, I think a lot of people sort of operate with that mentality. All right.
I got you all right Cicero says that I think he aligns more with Thomas The back channeling point Maggie he pretty much says men are the way to get everything But he gets do it in a different way not necessarily through self-interest But he says everything there is everything we have or want comes through the artistry industry or concern of men How do we get gold well how do you mind how do we mind it? Well do you do this people if we want to be a lawyer we got to learn laws that involves learning from people it involves having People do things they probably shouldn't do how do we get clothing while we have to grow crops? That's people we have to harvest the crops that's people I mean yes some of it now is automated it wasn't as much in their time Do you hear that sounds like a ghost maybe is that It's a ghost Cicero 15 year old boy So I don't know if the listeners can hear that But it's just a sort of a whoo like howling outside Yeah, so he says because everything there is even material goods that we could want or be concerned with comes from the industry of men Men are the way that you get the things that you want right? So here's a couple of quotes One either as a general in war or as a statesman at home could have accomplished the great things of the benefit of the state without the Hardy cooperation of other men so who is there that would say that's not true right?
So the men is the way you get to the top of business man is the way you get to success in war Here's another one since therefore there can be no doubt on this point that man is the source of both the greatest help and the greatest harm To man I set it down as the peculiar function of virtue to win the hearts of men and to attach them to one's own service So not only do men provide the avenue for success They also typically provide the greatest hindrance right there the guys can bring you down right political opponents people that don't like you People that steal from you it's all men. Yes granted there are catastrophes right the window below your house down That's a bummer, but it is men that will help you to put it back up right or even that weather is so out of your control It's not even worth trying to predict but yeah People get to treat them differently right you can treat men differently and then they'll like you or dislike you based on how you act When that you're focusing on what you have control over yeah exactly so the hearts of man because they are statistically the most likely to benefit you Were you yeah? I mean he goes to wasting time studying jaguars Terrified jaguars apparently they're stair tourists here. They are statistically low in Destroying me in Texas they are statistically low, but I would say that the person that can really hurt you as the zookeeper Yes, he's the guy that's the jaguar right so he actually lists he says God there are gods there are men there are animals and there's inanimate objects Well, all of those things are typically wielded by men and the gods people say they generally want to do us good So you know we're gonna leave them out.
It's man that can do the greatest good and the greatest arm So well he I'm just here so green brought up monkey value so and Jack wires and Jack wires I'm gonna focus on the Machiavelli part so Machiavelli will eventually say that it's better to be feared than loved But you're talking about going after the parts of men this is row. Would you say that he's saying it's better to be loved than feared? Oh man, you are preempting whoa you are exactly like you in Cicero same way You know it's Machiavelli reimagining like is he reinterpreting or is he in conversation with Cicero on this could be I have a ready Machiavelli a lot of people yeah because Machiavelli is pure pragmatist. Yeah, so Yes, but that's the thing is this rose saying.
Oh, this is what's practical. Yeah, he is saying it is practical to win the hearts of Alright, so let's keep him. Sorry. Yeah, he says there are Three ways to win men, right?
We win them by wisdom and virtue so he breaks us down into three heads wisdom the ability to receive What in any given instance is true and real what's relations are its consequences and its causes So just basically known what's going on so having wisdom having temperance which is the ability to restrain the passions and make the impulses obedient to reason So again going back to the tripartite So being able to make sure that your impulses stay where they're supposed to be and three justice the skill to treat with consideration and wisdom Those with whom we associate and all of this is in order so that we can do the following things supplier natural wants ward off impending trouble Avenge ourselves when we need to and visit them with the retribution as justice and humanity will permit wow So I like that he takes a he takes a big hard line on you know retribution But it's weird that the way we get there is wisdom and justice and virtue right yeah temperance wisdom and justice all right He says so moving further into how to get people to give you what you want He says there are different ways that people will either give things to you from their good will from if they're in higher position Or will submit to you as a person in higher position and that's what you're going for right either They give you goods when they are in position over you or they will submit to you under your position So the six heads to get people that are maybe above you to get you to give you stuff number one good will number two esteem Or some vague notion that you deserve it. Maybe you're working really hard right so maybe they're like I got a good working thing I'm gonna give them a raise three they have confidence in you and it's for their own self-interest So this is going back to what you said maybe where if I do enough things for other people they're gonna they're gonna do it for me So maybe he says like if I get this guy raised he's gonna work harder and I'll get that return or like work your way into a position where They eventually realize that they kind of need you for them to continue working at their capacities or whatever Yeah, exactly you're necessary. You're a nice little to them now. Yeah number four.
They may fear your power I call this the mugger clause right one way that you give stuff to you is to threaten them Yeah, right or blackmail right that that's one surefire way number five. Well, is that is that all he says about fear your power? Is you know there's more than that and we'll talk more about power a little bit But he's just listing the different ways of people get stuff to you Number six they may be moved by promise or payment of payment or reward so you can bribe them You can say give me a raise and I will let you use my beach house in the summers, right? There you go.
There's your six reasons and then the ways to get people to submit to you number one good will same as above number two gratitude for generous favors Right if you're like, hey, I'll do all this stuff here They're like great. I'll follow you in the battle number three the eminence of other social position or again self-interest Yeah, so yeah number four fear that they might be forced to submit so they're like yeah, I'll follow you just don't know hit me Number five they might be captivated by the hope of gifts of money and by liberal promise number six bribery so like the exact same Yeah, there's a lot of repeat they kind of mirror each other all the way and he says that the best way is number one good Well, good will right nothing here is better than love and nothing is worse than fear number four fear That they may be forced to submit or they might fear your power the mugger clause that he says that is the no the worst I mean, but it's good will worst is fear fear is the my killer But those who haven't read doing you should read doing it's really yeah, but it still works He says you can still use bribery you still can use rewards. Yeah, it's not very good He actually says that with servants you might have to use fear if nothing else works Right, they don't love you and they won't submit to any of those other things you might just have to threaten them about Students I was thinking about this like do you so just following that then so like in Graham's class Should he be starting with good will from day one and then good will doesn't work move down or should he start from the bottom and like You really mean bottom good. He should absolutely start with good will start with good.
Well, yeah I mean makes the most sense in terms of students wanting to work or just You know, yeah, yeah, good. Well if the students have have love for you or the class or the or somehow the subject material that will Write a lot of wrongs that just the fear of a bad grade won't but I'm asking will do they come in from day one and good will Works perfectly or do you have to start? Oh, I think you have to build up good will yeah? Yeah, there there are ways as teachers that for the first couple of weeks.
I'm very careful about the way I Act the way I treat them. I think it's easier different It just like the seniors I think are easier with goodwill because they're seniors. They're kind of one foot out the door They've been doing this for a while. We have had them before as students But maybe you want to say maybe your experience is different But my I guess is like ninth graders probably have a heart like you need to build my experience I don't teach in other classes my experiences that they need is that that you have a more of a challenge to get goodwill because they're just kind of Grumps, yeah, I think you just have to prove that I'm high school and they're terrified of bigger kids and all sorts of things Yeah, you have to prove that you sort of understand them and you were one of the most important is that you are just mm-hmm Teenage or suffer injustices so terribly yes, right and there's very little mercy for those above them who should be just right if you're Teacher and you screw it up They have very little mercy for that so you have to be absolute with your rules and then just leave all of them all the time because if you're not You're in big trouble Okay, so why why not fear?
Well, he says those whom they fear they hate and whom one hates one hopes to see him dead and sooner or later that hatred will exert itself The moment they have freedom they will exert that hatred upon you and you cannot keep them You know caged at all times. There's a really good quote He says freedom suppressed and again regained bites with keener fangs then freedom never endangered Yep, it's good and those who mean this is practical for jaguars, too Okay, no, this is really a thing with no no, I was really open man So he he says those who would be feared must eventually fears though fear those who they intimidate and this is absolutely true Right if I am a tyrant over my classes. I'm going to a fear that eventually they're gonna tell their parents They're gonna revolt against me. They'll come back and put hand sanitizer your coffee.
Yeah, it's gonna come back to hurt you Yeah, tax on your seat like it's just not gonna be a good situation And he tells a story about a fellow who had a wife that he didn't trust and he had to go into her with a barbarian with a Bared sword and then search through all her drawers for weapons before he spent time with her Oh gosh, she did eventually kill it Yeah, but she killed him because she thought he was cheating on her No, so I there didn't seem to be a whole lot of trust in that relationship wasn't a good situation And then he kind of vaguely hear references Caesar because he held people in fear and then eventually those people Revolted and it ended in his murder and then he has a whole bunch of stories about ways that they used to treat their allies Like Rome used to fight for virtuous reasons and have people love Rome and then eventually when they became such a grand empire They fought to continually hold those people in fear and now they've sort of lost it And so here's what he says at the end of the I'm gonna skip the lengthy quote He says and so in Rome only the walls of her houses remain standing and even they wait now in fear of the most unspeakable crimes But our republic we have lost forever But to return to my subject it is while we have preferred to be the object of fear rather than of love and affection that all these miswortunes have fallen upon us have you guys ever had an experience of being in competition with somebody or a school or a group or something and maybe you lost to them, but They did it in such a like noble and gallant way that you and you actually loved I mean loved is the strong word But you were you know had immense respect for them even though they they crushed you they beat you or whatever I was just you talking about that. I was just asking myself the question wait Can you can you be in war? Can you be in competition where the enemy ends up? Seeing how you carry yourself and respects you so much that like I don't I ain't even mad I mean mad I'll be or whatever I'm not I can't think of experience maybe small ones of like sports teams where at the end they were magnanimous or whatever not personal ones But King Richard the Lionheart yeah, I was like you know sending ice cream back and forth to each other Yeah, like they were definitely respectful.
Okay, so the question is if fear is no good and good was the best How do we win it right? How do we win men to our good side? He says there are three ways He loves these lists. He's just totally into it So affection or good will confidence and the mingled admiration and steam of the people are history breaks them down so good will through kind services you do to someone and You know it's it's best if you can actually do this service But if you attended to and do it you still get most of the credit true So that's a that's a solid and people are generally attracted to kindness justice honor all the virtues So in general you win goodwill by being good and admirable you in the confidence of people by if they think you have practical wisdom and justice Which he I think the most interesting thing under this head is when he talks about if you're gonna have them separately It's better to have justice if you have wisdom with no justice It makes you shrewd right you're a contriver your clever and people suspect you if you have justice without wisdom They can still trust you with their lives and their property you just might be kind of dumb right?
Yeah, so if you're gonna have one of the other and you know like flint edged like you are hard You are hardcore and you have no but that's not that wouldn't be just right really Can't just this like you know to hot the eye of heaven. I mean because justice if justice is a virtue There's no excess of justice so it'd be giving people exactly what they deserve would that be flint edge? I don't know. I don't I'm just thinking of Cato.
Hmm. What was Cato to just that wouldn't be though right? He was just like unflinching and yielding That's awesome. We got a quote from Cato later.
Yeah, oh maybe different. There's a lot of cateaus No, he's probably the contains probably the cateaus that you're thinking the contemporary who also killed himself when when the republic fell He was like well, I'm sticking around for tyranny All right, and the third way is the third thing is the esteem of your fellow man This one is a little bit more like he goes more into how to gain the esteem of your fellow men He says we esteem those with extraordinary talents, but we look down on those with no ability no spirit and no energy So weirdly enough we think ill of men who are slanderous and dangerous and unscrupulous But unscrupulous, but we don't despise them We despise those people who are of no use to their neighbors the idle lazy and indifferent so think of like the Maybe somebody across the the political spectrum from you that holds different ideals, but maybe conducts themselves I mean, they're dangerous. Maybe you think they're they're a hoxeter But at least it's better than like the 30-year-old stoner down the street who's never held a steady job and doesn't do anything for anybody right You despise one and you might be suspicious and kind of hatey, but right you might think ill of him But you're not gonna despise him as a nothing. Yeah, so that was a fun one to sort of think about He says how much time I left?
Okay, all right cool. So in summation of how to get goodwill for all these things is just generally justice It's the best way to get all three be a just person and he so here's his quote sort of in summation How do people love us? Justice and be just so so even and I quote so even to a man who shuns society and to one who spends his life in the country a Reputation for justice is essential even more so than to others for they who do not have it but are considered unjust We'll have no defense to protect them and so be the victims of many kinds of wrong So if you live in the country and people think you're unjust you don't even have friends to protect you right here in trouble So also to buyers and sellers to employers and employed and to those who are engaged in commercial dealings generally justice is Indispensable for the conduct of business. I want to come back to that because that's not necessarily still thought yeah Because think of it this way if you're in a class of 30 kids and one kid does something that is outside the rules and 29 pairs of eyes look to you to see what you're going to do if you give the one kid mercy you have gained like the good will of One but if you give justice you've probably gained the good will of 29 because they all now you know they all see that oh There is law in order to this space and it actually ends up becoming creating a safe space Let's be that poor kid just broke up with their boyfriend or girlfriend in which case being too rigid That was what you made me told me there's no such thing as too much justice.
I would I don't know that's too much justice I'd say don't even yeah, it's too much rigidity is it is it just to not give mercy right now again when it's when it's Just to do so one definition of justice is giving what one deserves so in that action they deserve It's a undeserved mercy. Yeah, yeah through there through whatever circumstance are going through all right Well, then you have given me a sufficient loophole is that Yeah, and he points out that even pirate kings in robber bands those guys got have justice Yeah, because if they get a bunch of money they don't do it out evenly Oh, they go get lynched you got it you have to have a code a man's got a guy got a have a code What's that from like every time I have a code like every western ever a man's got have a code What's that I can't remember yeah every western ever but yeah anything that has the wire things on the wire I don't know what's the first thing that popped up on the Google it yeah And that was a good show you know was so he points out that nations choose kings because they're just and they do it So that they can enjoy justice right so think about that If you want to if you want to go high up the ladder the nation will choose you because you are just because you do just things Right so they can enjoy that same kind of justice. Do you think the children would crown us as kings of their toss? I think we just men We are trying to be yeah, we are not perfect in it But that's part of teaching is showing that we strive after something we don't always achieve so there's a justice in that of when we are wrong We seek to make it right I think there are some students who will who would respect that and you don't want to count as king or whatever but I think it's a little fuzzy when talking about students why I was still training them up yes This is part of what you're talking about because the source of the respect you're talking about AJ are other just people right like it's the It's the respect of people who you want respect from and I think that matters also I think even like this is still reflected in elections even right even elections that may have surprised you considering our last one So I think there was an element of like people feeling neglected by Washington I think that came back and said like we need justice too was part of the motivation behind this last election I think there's a lot of a lot of justice in the political process that we don't think is there But I think it's our natural meant to want to elect leaders who are just and I think on both sides Democratic and Republican people levied the injunction that the other side was not just right so Hillary was accused of a bunch of stuff and Trump was accused of a bunch of stuff and it was primarily aimed at proving that they were unjust or Unjust worthy so I think that it's it's more important than you probably think it is And so there's a quote he actually quotes Socrates in this he says the nearest way to glory a shortcut as it were is to strive to be what you Wish to be thought to be for any he continues for if anyone thinks that he can win lasting glory by pretense by empty show by hypocritical talk And looks he is very much mistaken true glory strikes deep root and spreads its branches wide But all pretenses soon fall to the ground like fragile flowers and nothing counterfeit can be lasting and somewhere in here I don't know if it's right here, but he talked about how you cannot have one virtue Right, he's like it's kind of silly to talk about these separate because if you have one virtue You have them all and if you are lacking in one spot, it's gonna It's gonna spread right either you are going to become virtuous or you are going to become vicious right?
They don't come alone What was that you you said a quote we just had our big retreat and our lovely Graham over here did some great job He did a really good job one of it was you are going one day you are going to become what you are becoming yep Right, which is true and I think is as high schoolers It's hard to understand that right you can you can dab a little bit and not have it affect you so deeply But put two decades on that progress Yeah, and you will become what you are becoming and so if you're if you're heading down a road and that road leads to a place You don't think is good you can't you can't maintain yeah happens of behavior are sort of get worn into your The way that you operate in the world so that like think about and then there's sort of a vicious cycle like lies be get lies Like to keep up one lie you got to like have six or seven other lies Well now you've developed a pretty good habit of lying if you want to hold up that lie for the next five ten fifteen years If it's a big enough lie that's you need to sort of keep up then you're just gonna have this huge Habit of lying to the point where you can't remember what existing in the world without having to lie is and now you are a liar right? And it's true with all vices It's also true with all virtues and that's the things once you become a liar it gives opportunity for other virtues to take root or other Other vices to take root like it's not just gonna stay that you are untruthful You will eventually become greedy and envious and it will spread can't just stick to one Right to review good will it like goodwill is better than fear and fear bad love good and the best way to get those three is justice That's that's the far as far as we've gotten but he says there's a problem though What if you're super just and you're really good and nobody knows how do you make people around you know that you are good? How do you get a reputation just got to eat it out there's a remote marketing marketing answer Well, it's funny he actually he gives like some here here's how to do it kid number one military career Remember this is Rome. I don't know doesn't feel kind of wrong isn't like using the military career to get something out of it I mean, it was the Roman way, right?
You want to go high and Rome now it's show this baby I know well, maybe okay. Let's go back to the military thing. I like that a little better that we'll get there Number two you can attach yourself to a man who is wise or noun so become a page or assistant You know get with those guys who understand what's going on and sort ahead that way number three That's why you guys are going to be around you I'm just I'm aiming to eventually become second Joe Rogan He's gonna be like this is a Joe Rogan podcast and I'll be like with AJ Well, you have you heard that? There's this old Spanish phrase in Spanish that I can't remember it in Spanish but translates to like to the master goes the knife And it's this idea that eventually every Sort of Apprentice has to best their master and if the master doesn't make it possible for the parent is to best him naturally The parent is is gonna do it it's gonna manifest itself in like the apprentice So I think the master either killing him or just getting a better career than him and and sort of you know And so the phrase is to the master goes the knife or something like that is that oh my Astro Kuchiyata to the master goes the knife, you know, it's not ominous which is gracias.
Yeah Found on Twitter so I must be real He also says that the so the third way is conversation and oratory so be in the courts help people right you can You can tweet it out. He says you should never be a prosecutor ever you should be a defender So here's this quote again the following rule of duty is to be carefully conserved or observed never prefer a capital charge against any person Who may be innocent for that cannot possibly be done without making one self a criminal for what is so unnatural as to turn to the ruin and destruction of good men The eloquence bestowed by nature for the safety and protection of our fellow men So turn your own eloquence to the downfall of another especially in the courts is to be despised How can you how can you rectify that with this sense of justice like at some point you need to prosecute the bad? Well, someone who may be a defense attorneys for life Well, I'm all someone who may be innocent and that's a funny thing is now We've sort of switched yeah, I turn these other ones who are crummy and now it's prosecutors who are seen as upholding the state Defending the state is weird I think our court system is probably a little different than there's less sure it also depends if you're defending people who are probably guilty Right when you probably say you shouldn't defend people who are guilty Yeah, yeah probably now But then even then use you are seen as a defender of your fellow man right you were helping another yeah rather than prosecuting someone yourself Got you I was gonna ask what is the what is the modern equivalent of what is the best way to I guess what do they call this like virtue For you signal virtue signal, but you know virtue signal is a negative thing. It's where you don't actually have the virtue You just sort of realize Where people you just are you can graft yourself onto the cultural you're basically rent seeker at that point.
Yeah, so what's the best way to? I refuse to take part in this course. What's the best way to make sure that people know what you really are if you are virtuous How do you make sure that like and you want to go far in your career? How do you make sure people know?
It's a great question. What are the avenues? What are the avenues to Twitter? Is it is it Twitter is how you show so your personal greatness my reaction to all of this is the Benedictine in me?
That's like why are we why bother like isn't it better just to be good than to be perceived as good like I Have sympathies with that argument that also I always think that cream will rise to the top eventually And so whatever sphere you find yourself in like the quality of the men quality of quality of man is going to reveal itself eventually This is also why I sort of jokingly when we were doing the Plantagenet podcast around I think it was President's Day I jokingly tweeted like we shoot no thanksgiving should be thankful that we are not men in power just because like you are when you're in the public eye I don't know. It's just you are in your own ill temperance or whatever your own personal vices are gonna be magnified and picked over But I don't know what do you think it is if someone if someone was wanting to I Guess this he's he's advocating for public life Like he's talking about how does somebody gather a steam in the populace in the Republic of Rome so that they can Weald some kind of cloud and power and I I don't think it's a bad thing I think you need otherwise if you don't have good men wanting to wield cloud and power you will have Batman wielding cloud and power But I also have been a ditin sympathies Thomas, which is like well, you know, let the dead bury the dead and But I kind of feel like it's a joke at least that show business that isn't that the answer Yeah, it's not the awkward it's just terrible or and it's hard to do it in the 24 hour news cycle Cuz even if you say the most wonderful things people will sound bite it and then you know binders of women will go viral Oh, I'll be a few said it's me fine or now we're in the world of deep fakes, right? You know what deep fakes are you sure that's where you like pretend like you're gonna shoot and then go around and break the cycles? No, no, that's a deep fake.
That's a basketball. Yeah, that's true. No deep fake is like or like in football You're gonna throw really far, but you don't you throw really close Do you think going deep? No, this is where you have like learning algorithms who can very easily mimic the voice and the facial Features of somebody in a video.
So if we have seen these yeah, so somebody if we started recording our podcasts video with a video Some like you know 15 year old kid could download all these videos and then have us sitting there on Making news that's good. Yeah, just saying terrible things and like plotting bomb threats and all kinds of terrible stuff and then we get fired From our free pod Deep fakes maybe I've always had a fear that a student was just gonna make like a soundboard of take F sentences that we've said and take the med of context sometimes students will bring up things outside class and like oh Little shirt tugging hope they're not you know Video file that gets emailed to us is like give me an a or this file goes live. It's just like I like what? Take it straight out and you know how many sound clips of us saying duty there Oh, yeah, so I don't know if I would call it show business But something creating some type of content putting it I think online is the right place for it So something like a podcast something like a blog something like YouTube something like what you're looking I'm just saying is that what we're doing right now.
Kind I mean, Hanenburg, Maggie 2020. There it is. Wait, why don't you run this? I do run for sure.
You can't run. Sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.
I don't mean to rub it in. Sorry. I'm an immigrant You can be an advisor. They have those right?
Yeah, well, we can dig about channel. Come on guys. Yeah, yeah Those can be foreign, right? If I was gonna be for an event levels to anything your advice is foreign good.
Good. Good. I'm the fox I was listening to a talk from a guy. He's a he's a nice name's Wilson New St Andrews and he's doing a series of talks on like why he founded the school and why Why classical white Christian things like that anyway?
He had this idea where he's like everyone should write well people should write books and then you should see what type of person reads your books And that's a reflection to you of the type of person you are so it's like a lot of effort to figure out what kind of people Well, think of it this way like when I don't yeah I'm super impressed with emails that we get and so some part of me is like I'm humbled whenever we get emails and how thoughtful They are and how mostly because it seems like those people are way smarter than us Totally, yeah, but emails from m-divs and people who really know their stuff better read the notes that I should is Stop talking about this stuff. Yeah, but I think that I don't know the right way to say it But if you're gonna do a podcast that's the kind of person you want listening to it And so that's a piece of your answer you see who respects you who listens to you by putting something out there and then seeing what the response back is So we got like an email. I was like I love lip gloss. Yeah, we're doing it wrong.
Yeah, which is in this whole thing Yeah, I'm liking the quotes that you're putting on here. I could use some ringtones. So that would be great My lip gloss be cool. Thank you.
The pop-in. My lip gloss. You're popping. I guess it is cool.
Yeah, yeah, yeah I'm sorry I apologize I questioned your knowledge of the lip gloss be popping song. Did you know about me? Apparently not it. All right.
Thank you. The next next bit he wants to talk about is service right serving people How do we do it? What's the best way to serve people? Let me ask your question.
Should I give money or? Deeds deeds. Why deeds? Why not money because money seems like the right answer so it must be the wrong one because It's got the personal touch.
I don't know you have people If they see a doing stuff I feel like that Yeah, maybe people think that giving money is cheap and deeds are more costly or show a reveal more of a heart for the specific Person or thing that you're doing deeds for okay. All right. Here's what Cesar says the manner of showing it is twofold your generously He means kindness is shown to the needy either by personal service or by gifts of money The latter way is the easiest especially for a rich man sure But the former is nobler and more dignified and more becoming into a strong and eminent man for although both ways alike Betray a generous wish to oblige still in the one case the favor makes a draft upon one's bank account and the other upon one's personal energy and The bounty which is drawn from one's material substance tends to exhaust the very fountain of liberality Liberality is thus forced all by liberality for the more people one is helped with gifts of money The fewer one can help so basically if you give money eventually you're gonna run dry right more money you give the less you can But if people are generous and kind in the way of personal service that is with their ability and personal effort various advantages arise first The more people they assist the more helpers they will have in works of kindness true and second by requiring the habit of kindness they are better prepared and in better training as it were for bestowing favors upon many I Love the point that the more people you help the more helpers there are right like that's great And an awesome little quote that comes a bit later one's purse then should not be closed so tightly that a generous impulse cannot open it Nor yet so loosely held as to be open to everybody right you should be a little bit judicial about where you spend your money You should still give those just be smart about it He says of those who give money there's two types the lavish and the generous in Rome You know they use the throw games and glad it gladiator stuff into parties and that sort of thing He says those are the lavish and people generally forget it almost immediately as it happens Right you go to a big party you have a good time you get drunk you wake up next morning and that person has spent ten Thousand dollars and you barely remember the general like I think the guy's name was so and so who's outside was that I can't Yeah, who knows whereas the generous if they give it for real material game right to lift you out of poverty to help you give a dowry for Your kid something like that Santa Claus. Yeah Santa Claus exactly or you give it to the community right you build a new pool hall that anybody can use They are they'll remember that forever.
Oh, yeah, the girl fashion very tough pool hall. That's no Hi, I feel mocked. What about with your fish that coughs Like a neighborhood pool you buy your neighborhood of pool. Oh, they're gonna be thankful Yeah, yeah So he says that's the best way to do it and as for your cool as for your actions Some of the best you can give with you know with not spending money is legal counsel and oration right helping people vocally I don't know if that's as much now as it used to be right how often do I get the chance for legal action on the lawyer Right, you're not a lawyer that avenue is kind of close to you right except maybe as a witness and how often does your oration really help anybody?
No, rarely. I mean maybe conversationally right but weddings like you're giving speeches right your best man speech right sure Yeah, so so very very rarely I so what is what sorts of actions can you do now that those two are close to you that don't necessarily require your money What ways can we do what ways can you give actions? I think like help people build stuff just general labor Isn't one right? I mean that might not be as material as materially beneficial as helping them with their legal stuff I can't do that.
This is real good. I can't but I certainly can go help somebody move on again That's the kind of thing that and they'll remember you are super generous if you come and work for 10 hours straight lifting their couch Sure, but if you had given them say like 200 bucks for moving service, they'd forget that yeah, right? Or wouldn't have less it wouldn't leave as deep an impact on as you're friends You won't be as as built well boys. I'm gonna remember this as someone who's currently building a house Oh, no, I'm all just I'm just like back on the spot.
Yes to appeal to the angels of your better natures All right, another question. Okay. It's better to give to the rich or the poor I mean like do do deeds for men who are who wealthy or men who have nothing nothing But when who are wealthy can help you before you can do more for you But like so people who are well off of lots of people who are offering them things It's true or giving them free it people get free things don't need them And so if you're doing it for those who can't help you in return like people will notice that and that will mean more Well ever since you became an Instagram influencer, I know you've been getting free like weight loss T That's been the best there's weight loss T. I don't know sure that I'm never running again That you're gonna be on Instagram.
Yeah, and all those free clothes from being an Instagram answer. Yeah, that's the best Yeah, love Instagram. I've posted three photos on Instagram in my life Listed zero and Instagram is my favorite thing ever. Yes, but that's because you follow cat pictures dog memes Uh-huh the onion the Babylon Bee and fail blog.
Yeah, that's great. It's just a joy to scroll through my birthday every day I don't follow friends. There's no fear of missing out. I'm not jealous of anyone's life because everyone that I see is failing Oh, it's great.
It's just constant joy. It's yeah I think you got the internet figured out hand number. Yeah, I try okay, so what was it? Is it the real the poor the answer is the poor?
Whoa, whoa, if you give to the rich you they could suspect that you are doing it for favors And they could feel that they deserve it right you are just doing this because I'm rich and you want a friend Right, so they're not gonna show the exact same gratitude If you give it to the men who can't give back to you that's better and even makes it distinguish this distinction between like the wealthy and the good You should always give it to a good man Yeah, and he has a fun little quote he says but if it comes to a conflict of duty on this point I must I should say follow the advice of them stocklies when someone asks for his advice whether he should give his daughter And marriage to a man who was poor but honest or to one who was rich but less esteemed he said for my part I prefer a man without money to money without a man Oh, I thought I was so good. Yeah, I'm still not one And then he has a big link to think about how do you give to the state and unless your statesman doesn't matter much but basically Protect individual rights. He was super against property tax thought that was horrible He said the point of the government is to protect individual property rights, right? Which if you think about it kind of is protect the borders and protect your property and the reason you protect the borders That's pretty much a property That's what all justice is and he so he says avoid self-seeking generally Don't be greedy like if you overthrow another town and you bring all that back for your community Don't take any yourself because then you're giving it all right You're generous to the general populace and make sure people pay their debts And I think this was actually a jab at Caesar who when people fought in his wars He would come back and take land and give it to the people who fought for him And so he is like making sure people don't pay their debts and he would get rid of debts for the populace And of course those people would love him right because they don't have to pay their their mortgage Right, but he says like that's the very foundation of a good society is making sure debts are paid and in a in America Like our whole financial system is based on debt So you have to kind of make sure that it's it's happening.
Yeah, right we're near the end here So to review basically what's better love or fear totally love fears bad good and you want to be esteemed by people you want to have their respect and The best way to do that is works of service and generally being just and How you get your reputation out there is apparently Hollywood now? I guess for us anyway And then the last thing is how you tell which thing is better than like he says of all these things right? You can always have choices about which is better right should I do this or should I do that which is more expedient? Which won't make people love me more?
I guess in this case and he doesn't really say much on this head He just says it'll happen that you'll have to choose and then he gives a quote to this class of comparisons belongs that famous saying of old K toes so here's Kato come back for you when he was asked what was the most profitable profitable feature of an estate he replied raising cattle successful what next to that raising cattle with fair success and next raising cattle with slight success and Cops and when his questioner said how about money lending Kato replied? How about murder and from this as well as many other incidents we ought to realize that Expediencies have often to be weighed against one another and it is proper for us to add this fourth division in the discussion of moral duty So he's like sometimes that'll happen and I doesn't really give you any guidelines for how to do it So I wanted to end kind of coming back to a question you asked earlier, which is isn't isn't it kind of? Silly yes self-seeking to try get your reputation out there because once you become a virtuous man Do you like you shouldn't want all that anyway greed is not a part of your person and you are indifferent to your outer circumstances? What's the point of shopping all that around right?
Isn't there a weird conflict doesn't all this seem kind of silly all of this effort all of this making men love you to secure Glory reputation and wealth of it if you are virtuous you don't want I Don't agree with what I'm about to say but maybe one way to answer it would be someone has to rule a city This is what Graham said earlier someone has a rule a city might as well be a virtuous person Someone needs to be captain of industry might as well be a virtuous person that society is better for having these type of people in command in control Then having the vicious in those positions But my thought is this makes me think of the Athenian lawmaker Solon so when they went to him and they asked him to be king He said no, I was like David Yeah, I want to I want to raise my crops you guys leave me alone I want to be virtuous by myself and being a statesman only brings danger and care I all I can do is get scared of everything and be worried all the time that sounds awful and they actually I think under arms Compelled him to be king like went and got him instead if you're not king you're in trouble And I can't help but think that for virtuous men they will be put in those sorts of positions You'll be elected by CEO boards. You will be promoted by committees You'll be elected Pope, right? Like that's kind of the thing that happens and isn't it a shame that we give our highest positions to those men who most Most disastrously want it You know I mean the men who want money the most are the ones that we put in charge of our companies and what can we call that agreed? so I think I Don't agree with these what I'm about to say on this side so Progesions like you're fascinating psychological study.
We think we need a bell that you can ring when you're playing The umbel which a few times I said in AJ's class I get that rank wrong at me all the time. It's unfortunate So I think we are made for more than There's seven half minutes left in the podcast. I'm not I'm gonna drop a bomb and then walk away I think we're made for more than just our own personal virtue and personal actions I think that's the first thing we need to tame to prepare us to exist well in the world but You one of your quotes earlier said something about the glory of man something says rosaming something about how like we're supposed to There's supposed to be glory in us and I think there's something to that of yes. We need to tame ourselves tame our hearts Deal with our own sin vice whatever but then we're supposed to do something with it And I think there is a greatness that we are called to there we are supposed to achieve things and We are insufficient to only deal with myself What an example I married and if I were only a super virtuous man, this is a w-tozer I think it's tozer was super holy man wrote what's the tozer book?
I know this guy um she asked a w he wrote um, oh shoot pursuit of God is it no isn't it pursuit of God? Why is this so annoying? Whatever he wrote pursuit of God does that what you just said? So he wrote a book pursuit of God It's really great, but a w-tozer was married.
He was married and he loved God But he did not love his wife. Well, he was cold and he was distant to her So he himself was holy in that sense of being like virtuous and like he proclaimed God and that was great But he wasn't a good husband a w-tozer died his wife had eventually remarried and I don't remember the guy's name The kick the kicker to the story is that the wife said that whoever the second husband was A w-to she would say my first husband loved God But my second husband loves me and I think there what I would say is that I could I mean I'm not necessarily leveling this at a w-tozer himself, but how can we call him in like that virtuous right that you would both lack both love and Charity my point yeah Something that there is a type of virtue that exists just within the person But then I mean when we throw around the word virtue the word virtue means excellence and so excellence doesn't only exist on a moral plane Excellence exists on a physical plane. We are in a building right now and we need a virtuous building We need an excellent building to be in and we need excellent builders to build that building is that there's more than just us being moral beings There's also us being active Yeah, I think that's that all coincides with everything I've been saying about I think you set up a system So I mean like if we look back to book one remember the second part was maintaining maintaining a good social structure Your job is to be kind to your fellow men that is part of your duty as a virtuous man It's it's not only our job to be atomized Individual moral beings we are to be moral communities also but not only moral we need to make good shoes for each other We need to make good crops for each other like there's more there's more to virtue than just the moral aspect of it. Yeah, this is why from what I understand about the American system is it was an incentive you sort of incentivized the Sort of virtuous landowner to spend time in Congress.
Okay now for the next three six years however long your term is I'm going to go and I'm gonna be I'm gonna represent my community in you know in the government for the set period of time and You sort of instilled I think if you had Maybe less of a if it was less easy to be able to stay in government for the entirety of your career So if you had like if you had term limits and also coupled that with a strong sense of personal responsibility our civil responsibility in the populace and you had if we sort of measured the success of our democracy by the amount of turnover that we had in In the government by the the sheer volume of different kinds of people representing their communities and in the Senate and in the Congress Like there's something that seems virtuous about that So you would have less rent seekers or less career politicians who are doing it for self-aggrandizement And you would have it you would have more people doing this out of a a sense of duty and they're saying okay I'll put in my six years and then I'm done and then you can't ask anything of me again I'm gonna go back to sort of my private affairs and so we have the We sort of have the systems that set up for something like that to happen more so than say you know 17th century France So but whether or not we are producing enough Of the citizenry that have that sense of burden and civic responsibility is I don't think we do But well the funny thing is according to Plato's Socrates said that the man who actually wants to pursue pursue virtue Can't have a position in the state. Yeah, which we can talk about another day. It shows up in his apology But I think that's probably gonna be after we finish you know Cicero that's what I'm gonna do next But yeah, he says that there pretty much can be no virtue statement I've always found campaigning to be slightly kind of off-putting even no matter how virtue or how like Noble you think that the person campaigning is it's always just sort of rings a little black to me sure Okay, so to bring it all together, you know be nice to people and that's the best way to get the things That you got coming to you and that's my last bit of moralizing You know do be the thing that you want everyone to think you are and that's that's the way you go for it So more lies over go get some ice cream or something But as you know, I go through my own personal inventory doesn't hurt to do your own so that's last of it We have oh we boys have a classical stuff. We got wrong that we got wrong So in fact we were right and Hanenburg this goes back to you and this goes all the way back to an off-the-cuff comment You made so I have been reading the history of the American Civil War and there are definitely definitely Tennessee Yankees If you said a Tennessee Yankee in King Arthur's Court even though that was not the top of the book there are being said There were definitely Tennessee's Tennessee's Tennesseans who fought for the Union or me tenesians It's a People from Tennessee who fought for the Union who would definitely be called Yankees fair So you were very excited to share this one that that feels just I feel like it's a new dawn voice right now It's about a 50-50 toss up if I edit in vindicated Indicated all right well, I think you know close to talk.
Oh, yeah, so thank you everybody This has been classical stuff you should know with Thomas AJ and Graham thinking about the odds in our life I hope that this is at least got you interested in going and reading some sister I know definitely it's got me going interested in one reason sister and I never have in my mind he is dry and boring But you might not be wrong Still I'll still struggle through so you can tweet at us at a close stuff at Twitter You can tweet your own self-aggrandizemen if you like and if you do we will like it or retweet it if we agree with it if we think you are Virtuous we will give you we will pump your tires Yeah, if you never have never been a new question if you want to email us you can email us at classical stuff at veritas academy Dot net and we will eventually get back to you and you can find these episodes at classical stuff dot net or on any disseminator of podcast except spotify. I don't know. Yes, I'd say the biggest reason to go to classical stuff dot net is I pick a painting forever No, most of those have to do with the actual So I'm sort of a beautiful work of art. I gotta find three separate ones on sister.
I believe in you. Yeah, yeah, buckle up for gootling Okay, this is classical stuff