Skip to content
78. Live and Let Live? episode artwork

Aug 6, 2019 32 min

78. Live and Let Live?

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

In a few months, we will be celebrating the completion of the Daf Yomi, a seven-and-a-half-year cycle of learning the entirety of the 2,711 pages of the Babylonian Talmud. Last time, the largest gathering for the celebration took place at MetLife Stadium in NJ, where a sellout crowd of 90,000+ came to listen to speeches, sing, dance, and celebrate this huge milestone. This week, Uri and Rivky discuss a few videos that have been created and promoted by Agudat Israel, the organization that creates this mega event. The first shows a few of the men who are completing the Talmud, and speaks to how highly they value their wives' contribution to their learning. The second is a video of Rebbetzin Aviva Feiner, called A Woman’s Relationship to Limud HaTorah. These videos make us ask, how should men and women relate to Torah learning? And what is the appropriate reaction to feeling uncomfortable with the way others are choosing to live? And, what do we think of the daf yomi in general? Related links: Men talking about their wives: https://www.facebook.com/seth.farber.5/videos/2625174774168921/ Rebbetzin Aviva Feiner: A Woman’s Relationship to Limud HaTorah: https://vimeo.com/330799139

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

In a few months, we will be celebrating the completion of the Daf Yomi, a seven-and-a-half-year cycle of learning the entirety of the 2,711 pages of the Babylonian Talmud. Last time, the largest gathering for the celebration took place at MetLife Stadium in NJ, where a sellout crowd of 90,000+ came to listen to speeches, sing, dance, and celebrate this huge milestone. This week, Uri and Rivky discuss a few videos that have been created and promoted by Agudat Israel, the organization that crea...

Ready to play

78. Live and Let Live?

0:00 32:14
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rivki. And you're listening to Talking Talks, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So Uri, it was two weeks ago, but we still are getting constant feedback about this fish episode. Yeah, I've gotten a lot of feedback just in the last few days also. It's actually kind of crazy because, at least for me, I was a little bit uncertain. I was like, I don't know, it's a little bit strange. Are people going to like it? Yeah, it's kind of out of the box for us. And yet, a lot of our regular listeners and a lot of new people, I think, are very intrigued by it. I think it's just a very fun concept. And people are always intrigued by following cults. Or infuriated. Well, yeah, intrigued, positive, or negative. Yeah.

So I was at a synagogue this past Shabbat where I don't go so often, and I spoke to a bunch of people who actually knew Johnny, and therefore the episode had kind of spread in their circle. These were all fish people. And one of the guys, it was kind of funny, like he said, looking around the room at the Kiddush after davening, after prayer, he kind of said like, yeah, I think there are probably about 10, 15 people here that I've gone to shows with, which I thought was kind of crazy. 100 people in that space. So I thought that was kind of fun. Well, it was something about that shul in particular. Yeah, of course. I was at Nitzvot Shalom, which is the more liberal, quote-unquote, shul in Tineg. I said to him, oh, why do you think so many people at this shul are fish people? And he kind of said, oh, come on. You know, this is the liberal shul. The people are a little bit more, yeah, exactly. A little bit more comfortable, you know. And it was true. I was thinking, I grew up at Rina, which is a different shul in Tineg. It's much more mainstream, quote-unquote. Yeah, exactly. It's a lot more people who wear suits on Shabbat, no matter whether it's, you know, 30 degrees or 100 degrees, where, you know, Nitzvot is kind of a different flavor of people. So it was really fun because a lot of people said

people actually, I think, really were struggling with the same question about, you know, noticing the phenomenon and still saying, like, they're not really convinced one way or the other why this exists. Why the Jewish connection? Yeah. Why there are so many Jews, especially in the modern Orthodox Church. Struggling, I think, is the wrong word. I don't think they're, like, you know, they're not in distress about it. It's just like a curiosity that it's hard to pin down. Actually, can I tell you something a little bit funny? One of the people I was talking to, he told me that he had been in YU Smicha and that another Smicha student brought him to a fish show. He didn't know the band. He didn't know anything about it. And he said, that day was the last day he ever went to Shear.

Because he found that spiritual sustenance at the fish show. I thought that was wild. What do you think about that? Yeah, I mean, that's interesting. I've never heard anything specifically like that before. I guess the rabbis at YI probably wouldn't want to hear that, or they might not think so highly of fish if they knew that story.

I don't know, to each his own, you know? Yeah, I thought it was kind of interesting. Yeah, I mean, I guess, so Renat is the show where the kids go to fish shows, and if you vote, it's the show where the parents go to fish shows. Yeah, that's funny. Yeah, and one of the guys was telling me he goes with his kids. He does not partake in any substances, especially when he's going with his children, obviously. Also, I spoke to a woman there who's a big fan, and one of the things that she mentioned was she thought, you know, about the gender divide or whether there is a gender divide. She said she's a big fan, her husband is also. She thinks that there are a lot of female, and in the Jewish community also fans, but they're all married to fellow fish fans, whereas men in the Jewish community, in the Orthodox community who are fish fans, not necessarily true that their wives are into fish.

But that seems to generally be the way it goes. I know a couple of women who aren't married who aren't a fish, but that might be true. That's interesting. I also want to say that a couple of people said that how come we didn't talk about the drug aspect of fish? And just to clarify...

because we had two versions of the podcast, that was one thing that we cut out in the condensed version just for time purposes. But in the longer version, we did get into that, the drug thing and why do people do it and the dangers of it and a little bit of that. So if you want to hear that, you can listen to the longer version. Also, I spoke to somebody yesterday who was at the academic conference that we mentioned that was in Washington State. So he works in both publishing and so he was there like for work. And so he was telling me about some of the sessions that they had and then he told me about the Jewish sessions also and they dealt with these same questions. So just like, yeah, it's a question, there's no clear answer, but it's a fun thing to talk about and think about and check out Fish Music and see what you think for yourself. If Trey and the other members have theories, we'd of course...

I'd love for you guys to reach out to us. Please be in touch. TalkingTalkHospodcast at gmail.com. So, Uri, a very exciting event is coming up in the next few months, the Sium Hashas, a celebration of the completion of the Dafyomi cycle, which is a seven-and-a-half-year cycle of learning the entirety of the 2711 pages of the Babylonian Talmud. Last time we celebrated this event was in 2012, and the largest gathering for the celebration took place at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey, where a sellout crowd of over 90,000 people came to listen to speeches, sing, dance, and celebrate this huge milestone.

In advance of this upcoming completion of the cycle, a few videos have been made and promoted by Agudat Israel, the organization that creates this mega event. And we're going to highlight two of these videos. The first one shows a few of the men who are completing the Talmud and speaks to how highly they value their wives' contribution to their learning. Let's listen to a little bit of that video just to get a taste of it. People who learned after every single day. I would not have the encouragement and the support of my wife on a day-in day-out basis This wouldn't happen when a person is successful and happy with his learning his wife knows it and sees right through it and she Encourages him when he's down. He doesn't want to go. He's not feeling so well His wife will thereby encourage him to go go go do it because I know you can do it Sometimes it gets a little tough you know in the morning. We had a late night in El Khasano You can't get away in business you come back and if I miss or I attempt to miss the wife's like go because there's no way I could do it without her She's stuck with four kids in the morning and my kids wake up around 5 5 30 So she's dealing with them all by herself. So all the credit goes to her

And the second is a video of Reviton Aviva Finer, and it's called A Woman's Relationship to Limud HaTorah. And we'll listen to a piece of that video now as well. Hello, ladies, and I am so happy to be here with you and get you excited for this year's upcoming Siyom HaShath Halavai next to the Bayesh Lishi. I'm going to talk to you a little bit about our role as women in our relationship to Torah learning. And he bridges right from there to a very famous gemara that I think most of us heard in seminary, where the gemara asks in, Why are women, and how are women, able to merit zachyon? What are they meriting? They're meriting olam haba. And the answer is in...

gobbledygook Aramaic, so I'm not going to share that with you at the moment. But essentially what we're told, and we've learned this, is that the women are zochet to Olam Chaba because they wait and they send their husbands and children off to learn Torah. And Rav Elia quotes there, who asks a very obvious question that I think many of us could actually ask ourselves. We all know that we keep many, many mitzvot. In fact, we keep some mitzvot that men don't keep at all. We all know we do chesed. We all know we're responsible for the kashras of our homes. I'm actually speaking to you right now.

as it is just over a week before Pesach. Although dedication and commitment to learning is always an inspiring thing, both of these videos, I think to many of us, seem slightly discomforting and raise some serious issues, specifically about women's roles in Torah learning. Obviously, and I don't want to discount this, there are many women who take real spiritual satisfaction in supporting their husbands or sons or other men in their community in their learning. But at the same time, many of us don't feel comfortable with the fundamental principles that they are espousing. And when I say comfortable, I don't just mean, oh, you know, I don't personally want to live this way, but even more fundamentally, asking, is this really a good way to live? At the same time, though, we don't want to be judgmental and jerks. So, Uri, let's talk this out, right? How did you feel watching these videos? Did you feel totally comfortable, and were you just happy for all these men and these women? Did you feel weird about it at all? What are your thoughts here? Well, Rivki, I'm glad you asked me that. Before I answer that question, I just want to say, it's funny, because we used to, or I used to make fun of myself, or both of us would give disclaimers in the beginning, like, I'm not a woman, I'm not gay, but we're going to talk about this issue that we are not personally.

I am not a woman, and I know, and I am sensitive to the fact that I think for a lot of women who are, let's say, on the more feminist side of these kind of issues, they don't, they're not interested in hearing from a man telling them, here's why it's okay, or why this kind of thing is okay, that these people are doing something that seems to be misogynistic or whatever. Like, I saw something recently on Facebook that was dealing with, like, a slightly more sensitive issue, the issue of abortion, and there's a woman that I'm friends with on Facebook was talking about... Jewish sources supporting the right to have an abortion. And somebody in the comments said something about, like, you know, I think it's just important. A man in the comments. A man in the comments said, like, I totally respect what you're saying, but I think it's important. You're talking about Jewish law and abortion just to talk about Rav Moshe Feinstein's opinion, where he was pretty strongly against it in most cases. Like, you know, just because he was such an important figure in 20th century Jewish law. And the woman responded.

I don't need to quote any men when it comes to this topic. And so I think that's a little silly because she started the conversation talking about Jewish law. And now she's like, I don't need to hear from any men. At the same time, I get where she's coming from. I get the sensitivity to that. And this feels like a very personal thing that men just wouldn't relate to or understand in the same way. So if they're going to be pushing back against what she's saying, she doesn't want to hear it. And so to hear, I do want to be sensitive to that. But if you're asking me what I thought, I can tell you some of my thoughts. My thoughts on these kind of things. You asked me, did I feel uncomfortable? Did I think it was weird?

I'm all for people learning Dafiyomi, whether it's men or women. And I think it's great when spouses support and encourage each other, whether it's the wives encouraging the husbands or vice versa. I think that the people in this video seem to be in a more, like, I'm going to go to Israel also, a more yeshivish kind of community and mindset. And that's not how I was raised and that's not how I identify. So, yeah, it felt a little weird just in the sense that, like, that's not who I am and that's not my people necessarily. At the same time, and because I'm...

you know, friends with you and a lot of other people who are more on the liberal feminist side. Like, I'm so used to, you know, hearing why the feminist side of things and why the male-centered concepts of Judaism are so hurtful and damaging, whatever. When I see something like that or hear something like that, I do have all these voices in my head like, whoa, this isn't okay. How are they saying that, you know? But when I really thought about it, my question was, as you referenced in the introduction, you do want to be sensitive to other communities and other ways of seeing things.

But that being said, why don't you take that even further? Why don't you just say, this is not who I am or what I believe. But they're welcome to believe that, especially the video of the woman herself. Meaning when it's a man talking about my wife really supports me. I understand if you would say, well, why don't we hear from your wife? But if it is the woman talking about her experience and speaking to other women, and she's saying, this is how we can support, this is how we feel good, this is how I feel good supporting my husband. And then a more feminist woman comes and says, how could you say that? That is not how women get satisfied. Women get satisfaction from learning goodbye and doing that thing with themselves. Isn't that a little patronizing to her? You're saying, you think you know what you want and what makes you happy, but you don't really know. I know what makes you happy. Right.

First of all, I think a very, very fair point. I think it's often patronizing. I mean, I'm a Democrat, so I am absolutely patronizing. I think people don't know how to spend their money, right? I think all of that is definitely true. Yeah, I think sometimes you need oversight because people make mistakes when they're just thinking about, you know, their own thing. But I do think that's true. I do think that, in general, it's...

kind of not super useful for all of us to walk around, right? They look at the secular world in a lot of ways, and so do I to a certain extent. They look at the secular world and they say, oh my God, women are walking around in these kind of clothes. They're so exposed. They're this. And they're doing it to make men happy because men want to look at them. And these are the people who have no agency. We don't think about things that way. And I understand. Yeah, exactly. So I think, and to a certain extent, they're right. To a certain extent, they're right. There's a lot of truth everywhere. And for everyone to walk around criticizing each other's communities, I think is not super useful because it means we're not listening to the values that maybe have something to say in the other communities.

At the same time, in this particular case, I definitely was uncomfortable watching this video. So it's interesting that you, I think that's a very reflective thing to say for you to sort of like recognize like, it's not that I was uncomfortable, but I was uncomfortable thinking about the people who I know were, who were uncomfortable and thinking about why they'd be uncomfortable. And I kind of understood what they're saying. I kind of disagree. Like, I think that that's kind of like a hard position to straddle there. But I was uncomfortable with it. And I think, I think you're right that part of it was, you know, listening to these men saying.

oh, my wife is totally okay with me doing X. And my wife is very supportive when I do Y. Or she's so happy when I'm not at home at night. Exactly. She loves serving me dinner and putting the kids to bed while I run off. He didn't say serving me dinner. Yeah, he didn't use that language. And you guys should watch the video because obviously we only took snippets here. Here's a little bit why I was uncomfortable with it. I think first of all, kind of like you, I was uncomfortable because it's not my community and seeing it feels like, oh, I don't love the way they're talking about this. But I think even more so than that, what made me uncomfortable is thinking about the women in that community or really the men in those communities who really don't fit into this kind of...

selflessness, right? The women are seen as these women who totally give up any of their own needs or desires to help their husbands achieve this learning. They talk about like, oh, when I'm down, I don't want to go and I just want to stay home and, you know. My wife encourages me. Yeah, she pushes me to get out the door. She pushes me to do it and whatever and things like that. The women who kind of say to themselves like, you know, I kind of want my husband to stay home with me. Like, I would kind of love to spend a little time with him or for us to go get ice cream or for us to watch a movie or for him to take care of the kids and I'll go to a show or for him to take care of the kids and I'll go out with my friends. You know, those women are kind of seen as the ones who really.

don't epitomize the selflessness of what it means to be a good wife. And that's what makes me cringe a little bit. And at the same time, by the way, the men who don't do this, right, are seen as like, oh, maybe you're good at, you know, in other ways, but really, and especially in the video, the second video, which highlights... learning as this epitome of this incredible, incredible, incredible thing, women enabling learning and men doing the learning themselves, made me uncomfortable for what that says about the people who just isn't what speaks to them in their Judaism. And that's, I think, what was hard for me to watch. Yeah, listen, I think those are all fair points, and I understand what you're saying. I also think you're making some assumptions. You're assuming that just because these men are going to Adafiomi Shear every day, that they're not spending time with their kids and their wife, or not spending enough time, or that the wife has the burden of taking care of the household all by herself, that the husband's not contributing to that at all, or that the wife doesn't have any time for her things, whether it's to go to a Shear or to spend...

time relaxing or whatever. We don't know. But don't you agree with that assumption that generally these husbands and these wives are not putting as much emphasis on the women's learning than the men's learning? Yes, because they're in a community that has gendered roles. Yeah, so it sounds like we're on the same page about that assumption. Right. Yeah, okay, in a certain way. So I think I draw a big distinction between, let's say, if a man or rabbi or a woman gets up in one of these type of videos and says, and this has been done, whether it's in writing or in video or whatever, and says, like, based on these sources, and there are sources that people use, women are not allowed to learn Gemara. Or, maybe a little less strongly, women just should not learn Gemara for these reasons, okay?

That's one thing. It's very different to say, I'm learning Gemara, and I'm very thankful to my wife for supporting me. I don't want to assume, and I don't think it's true, that if you ask the men in that video, I would almost guarantee the majority of them, at least, if you ask them, do you think it's okay if your wife or your daughter really wanted to learn Gemara, would you be okay with that? I don't know. I don't want to make assumptions, but it's very possible that they might say yes. And so those are two different things. Meaning, if they go out and say, women cannot learn Gamara, I would personally have a problem with that. Like, you're trying to say, even though there are sources of that, which I'm not so familiar with, but just a gut feeling. I think that's very different from saying, I'm thankful to my wife for supporting me. I agree that they're different. I think the second one, I think that what you're saying is like, look, it's not so bad. And I agree, it's not so bad. But first of all, I think that you are...

Very naive about what these people would say. And I think that many of us in the non-Northodox community think that it's become so mainstream that we just kind of think it's more common than it is or more accepted, quote unquote, than it is. And I think that's absolutely not true. But I think second of all, even more so, this language of would you be okay with your wife or daughter doing X, I think it's part of the problem. One of the things that seems so clear to me in both of these videos is that women are so much...

Their main roles there are seen as supporting their husbands or their sons or their fathers or the men in their community. And women's roles and women's choices are not really taken as seriously. And again, I do not mean to demean or speak down to any of the men who are involved in this or the men who are learning or things like that. It's not about these people, but it's about the society that we currently live in or want to create. And I think that this society is not good, especially for many people. Okay, you're criticizing them and saying...

you have a right to live your life the way you want to live it and make the choices you want to make, but you're saying in that video they should have been more sensitive and more open and saying this is not the only way to do it. If you do it other ways, it's okay too, right? Is that basically what you were saying? I think that is a big part of what I want. Also, one of the things I want to add just because I was thinking about this as I was watching it and even afterwards as well, I'm not sure how I would have felt if in this video full of men being interviewed about how incredible their wives are, how I would have felt differently if...

there were also a couple of women being interviewed about how amazing their husbands are. If that would have changed the calculus for me. And I think part of that goes to, yes, it is beautiful when spouses support each other. And I think I would have appreciated the equality of, you know, men supporting their spouse, women supporting their spouse, you know, hell of I that there would be gay people in here. Obviously, that's not even part of the question. But I think even more so, I'm not even sure that that would have solved it for me because what made me uncomfortable with this video is a big part of what it looks like when someone sacrifices so much for the other person and that we see that as so incredible instead of a video in which we, like, I would love to have seen.

a married couple being interviewed saying like, and this is how he sacrifices for me, and this is how he's like, I think that would be so much more meaningful. Not just nice, not just like, oh, we're paying lip service to the idea of X. It would just be such a more meaningful expression of what partnership and support looks like. I get that. I think really just to be fair, in the same way that you're saying, they have a right to live their life, but they should be more open to other ways. But they should live my way. No, meaning if there was a video, an equivalent video of like from Jofa or whatever, like a super feminist-y thing saying like, you know, women should do this and that, I...

Again, I don't want to make assumptions, but you can definitely picture a situation where they would not be saying, and by the way, if you want to have more traditional roles and the woman wants to stay home and support the family and cook, that's fine too. If you ask them, is that okay, I think a reasonable person would say yes, it's okay, but they wouldn't put that in the video. First of all, I disagree. I don't think that's true. You think they would put that in those videos? You're giving Joppa an example. I think Dafka would do that. But I think second of all, even if they didn't, then...

Then I would say that was problematic. Do you think that I'm generally, I think I like to call people out for all, or I call myself out all the time. Like, I think there's plenty to criticize all over the place. That doesn't make me feel like I have to be less critical of this organization. Again, I'm not criticizing the organization. I'm criticizing the larger culture, which I think there are incredible people who are part of this, the men and the women, and they're doing it for all the right reasons. I understand. I mean, this is something that also came up when we were talking about the Jewish press controversy with the article that was like very insensitive to gay people in the Jewish community. And, you know, I'm not talking about that.

issue in particular, but the fact that we pointed out then that so many of the people who were so critical of the Jewish press were not people that ever have anything to do with the Jewish press, never read the Jewish press, but when they see something that offends them, they're all up in arms. And, like, you're allowed to do that. It's free speech, and it's still Jews, and it's your broader community. That's fine. But I also think it's relevant here that, like, if this video had been put out by a modern Orthodox institution, even why you, and you personally didn't go to why you would still, you know, our modern Orthodox world, I think there would be a lot more understandable to me of, like, we have to criticize this. This is not okay. As opposed to something coming from a yeshivish organization that we have nothing to do with. It's not our world. Or it feels so alien to us. Again, you're allowed to have an opinion on it, but I think that is also something

That is not my community. And therefore, that, you know, needs to be said. I think that's a fair point. I actually think that it's a really sad point, especially, you know, right now. They were so fragmented. Yeah, like, first of all, like, we're in the nine days. And second of all, like, remember, I remember seeing all the pictures and videos from the Seymour Shots last time, which I did not attend. Yeah, I was there. Oh, you went? So I was really not interested. I turned down to a Mumford & Sons concert that night to go to the Seymour Shots. Do you think you made the right call? Yeah, it was actually very inspiring. But I think one of the things that seeing the pictures and seeing the videos was, and I think, I would imagine if you were there, you would agree. But tell me if you saw differently, that the vast majority of people were not people who you'd be like.

Oh yeah, we're friends. Like they're just, it felt so for sure. I actually did feel very uncomfortable just in the sense of like, it didn't feel like my people and a lot of the things that were much more yeshivish. Most people were wearing black hats and like, yeah, it wasn't my world. And that makes me feel like kind of sad, like especially like in the way that you kind of opened your answer here, which I think is very reasonable, but like it doesn't bother you as much knowing that like it's not really your community. Well, I didn't mean it like that. No, I know you didn't, but I'm just thinking about the way in which we're talking about our community, our internal community, especially in the nine days. I understand what you're saying. You're saying it in a negative way, which I understand, but I'm saying it in a positive way of live and let live.

Me and our community and people should do what they feel is right and what makes them feel good and comfortable and spiritually fulfilled. And they have a right to do what makes them feel spiritually fulfilled and happy and whatever. I totally agree. And it's less about going to these specific people and saying, hey, here's why what you're doing is wrong. But I think to frame it, I guess, maybe a little bit more positively, if the ideal world in which we want to create, the ideal Jewish world, the ideal spiritual world, the ideal learning and mitos, how do you say mitos? Character traits. Yeah. And how that translates into action. Is this something that we would like to see in an ideal world? I'm not saying that, you know, then turn around and say, oh, you're not living up to the ideal that I want to create. I'm saying in the world in which we want to create, it feels...

This feels like not only not what I love, but it feels like there's part of it that I think does create a little bit of harm. Yeah, I think that's fair. I think in a broader picture, I think it's because of the secular feminist movement and because of the more liberal orthodox feminist push in the last couple of decades or few decades that they would do a video like this in the first place acknowledging women. You know what I mean? If it wasn't for those outside forces, I don't even think they would acknowledge the women at all. I'm not saying that makes it, oh, everything is the way it should be. I'm actually saying that you can't, even though I'm saying let's separate and live and let live, we do influence each other. And therefore, if you believe strongly in one thing, you're saying and putting out there a different message could actually influence that community.

in a positive way, and I respect that. I just think it's also funny, you know, maybe we can close up this part of the discussion of, like, we can ask the question of learning Kamara in the first place. It's obviously a broader discussion, but it's like, should that be the main focus? Like, if somebody has one hour a day to learn, as amazing as I think Dafiyomi is, and to go through all of Shots in seven and a half years, like... it's like a very quick cursory, you know, overview of the Gemara and you don't really go in depth at all. And like, if someone has one hour and they want to be like spiritually fulfilled, Jewishly, even let's say, not even specifically with learning, like, is that the best way to do it? Like, that's a question. I don't, I think the easiest answer to that is for some people, yes. And for some people, no. And clearly our community, especially the more yeshivish ones, like put the super strong emphasis on, first of all, learning Torah above all else and then learning Gemara specifically within that. And of course the personal choice. Some people I think really...

hopefully are spiritually fulfilled by that i think that it's really hard to get good data on any of these things one of the things that i was thinking about after i watched this video was i wonder right let's say you have thousands and thousands of people worldwide and in america who have finished the dafiomi cycle and some people even are finishing it now again for the second time or the third time which is i think really incredible i'm wondering if we compare those people to the rest of America, if they cheat on their taxes less often, if they cheat on their spouses less often, if they give more money to charity, if it generally impacts their behavior and makes them better, quote unquote, people, I would feel a lot more strongly that, you know what, this is actually a really impactful program. If the data was there, then you would say, I respect that data and let's keep going with that system? Yeah, totally. Like if I thought that it really impacted people. But if it doesn't seem to be, if it's either negative or if it's neutral or if we don't have data on it, which I think it's somewhere in between neutral and don't have data on it, that's my understanding. But obviously people...

listening you know correct me if you have if you have other data i kind of feel like and again this is kind of a personal choice and people relate to some things more than other things but i feel like if my spouse or my child or my something like came to me and said like look i have an hour every night from eight to nine and there's a dafiomish here and there's um packaging food at a you know food bank or there's you know something like that like you know which one should i be doing with my time obviously i think the answer is like you know moderation you know split up your time you know between things but if you could really if you had to do only one right I think probably for most people, you're going to create a stronger impact. And also you're going to be more changed by the experience of the second one, right? Of more doing and less learning. Right. I mean, I definitely hear that. And I relate to it also. I think on the other side, just the argument that I've heard people say, I've heard in yeshiva, whatever, like the reason why people encourage learning Gemara specifically and like in-depth learning Gemara, not cursory learning Gemara, it does require a lot of work and a lot of mental concentration to follow the steps and to understand what's going on. You can't just breeze through like a newspaper. And, you know, there's a general concept of like love or the more you put in, the more you get. And in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make, to quote the Beatles. So because Gemara requires...

so much mental energy to put into it, you get more satisfaction, fulfillment out of it. And it's also like, people say this is a gendered thing, but with men, if they're more susceptible to their minds wandering or their eyes wandering or whatever it is, by focusing their brain and their mental energy on learning Gamara, that's going to keep them in line or whatever. That's what people tend to say about these things. So I'm curious what you think about that. I mean, A, do you actually relate to that in your own life? And B, do you see that sort of as a larger phenomenon to be true? That men who are more engaged in learning, that it helps them focus and things like that.

I mean, there is a logic to it. And I do think, I do think of myself as like a relatively good judge of character and of people. And I did find that the men in this video seem to be sincere people. They didn't seem to be like big shot, like egotistical, whatever. They seem like sensitive people. They seem like on the verge of tears when they're talking about this kind of stuff. And I actually just want to say, that's why it really bothered me. And I reacted and got defensive. This whole argument of mine is a little bit of devil's advocate because like I said in the beginning, this is not really my community per se. But like one of the comments under the video, this was posted on like a more liberal person's Facebook page. And his comment of the video was like, this is why we need to encourage women to do that feel. And be like, okay, fine. And one of the comments right under that was a woman saying, I didn't know you.

had it in you. I just fell off my chair laughing. And I thought that was offensive. I felt hurt by that. Here are these men who are very sincere, and they're genuinely thanking their wives for supporting them and encouraging them in this spiritual endeavor, and they perceive it to be a joint venture with their wives, and they're acknowledging that, and you're laughing at them. I just don't think that's a mature response, and that bothered me a little bit. I totally hear that. I think mocking these individual people is not only not nice, it's not fair, because these people really are very genuine, and there's no reason to think that they're not also incredible people. That's not the conversation that I want to be having. I think we've done an okay job here separating the individual people involved in this.

the larger culture here. Even actually a friend of mine knows one of the people in this video and he said that he's an incredible guy. He really has changed people's lives with the stucca he gives or the charity he gives. So he's not just Learning Tour, he's also doing stucca and stucca and whatever. And I think that's amazing. And again, this is not about whether these people are, you know, well, it is about whether people who are doing Daph Yomi are really also living those values. That's like at least that guy and hopefully all of these people are. But I still think, you know, that there is that struggle. Anyway, of course, this conversation has so many more pieces and is part of it.

Many larger conversations. And we want to hear from all of you about the individual things that you noticed that we didn't get a chance to discuss. Please be in touch with us at TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. And of course, join the conversation on our Facebook page, Talking Talkless Podcast. Thanks as always to Drive-In Productions. They are the sponsor of this week's episode. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rach Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Talkless. Bye, everyone. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 32 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on August 6, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.