Skip to content
8% vs 4.99%: Which Mortgage Future Are We Facing? episode artwork

Aug 30, 2026 15 min

8% vs 4.99%: Which Mortgage Future Are We Facing?

from One Rental At A Time Hosted by Michael Zuber

Links & Resources Follow us on social media for updates: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Instagram⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ | ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠YouTube⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Check out our recommended tool: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Prop Stream⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Thank you for listening! 💡 If you enjoyed today’s episode, please rate, follow, and leave a review—it really helps us grow. And don’t forget to share it with friends or colleagues who would find it valuable. 👉 Stay tuned for more insights, strategies, and stories in the next episode!

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

8% vs 4.99%: Which Mortgage Future Are We Facing?

0:00 15:41
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

All righty, folks, we have no idea where the 30-year mortgage rate is going. So I want to do a mental exercise with my good friend Jonathan here from Convoy Home Loans. And we're going to play the what-if game. We're actually going to do it two different ways. The first way is what happens if the 30-year mortgage rates for homebuyers hit 8%? And he doesn't know this yet.

But we're also going to do one, what happens if mortgage rates hit 4.99. We're just going to cover both of those. Because I think what you'll need to understand is the market will react to either extreme scenario. So Jonathan, I would argue today that 8% mortgage rates and 4.99 are both extreme, but I think both are possible. So let's start with the high end. What do you think the market does? What do you think lenders do? What do you think Wall Street does if the 30-year mortgage rate? Again, I'm talking 30-year, owner-ock, best credit, all of that is 8%. So most rates are going to be higher than that. So what happens if that comes to me?

the world's over it's done um no i think i think i mean this isn't too far it's not even hypothetical because again we talked about it before but i think like two years ago we were we were writing in the eights so this is not october of 23 i think yeah this is not like an unknown situation what happened at that point in time right was a lot of the lenders a lot of uh wall street and this is where the two to one buy down and the three to one buy downs for primary owner occupied like those things became very popular and rolled out during that time to allow buyers to get, you know, introductory rates that are lower, credits a little lower, and try to make the loan products a little more, a wider range so that more people can take advantage of it. And I think that that'll happen again, right? We've already kind of been in the 3-2-1 market, the temporary buy-down market, buy it down, or, you know, get solid credits to do permanent buy-downs. Like, we're going to see more of that, but we're probably going to see a different product rollout that allows for payments to be lower and allow for more buyers to still take advantage of the market because they're not going to let housing...

freeze in the way of, you know, be dead, right? So we were talking about, I mean, just think about two years ago. Was it a year ago, two years ago? They started talking about 40-year fixed mortgages that, you know, the conventional was Fannie and Freddie were entertaining and FHA was entertaining. Everyone's freaking out about it. Like, you know, but again, like that stuff happens because they see a problem occurring with the market. And so they're probably going to react with some type of product that tries to bring, you know, demand back into the picture. Yeah, it's funny.

You know, when I think about 8% mortgage rates for homebuyers, it probably means investors are at or above nine, right? Let's just be real. And it's funny sitting here thinking about that. First and foremost, I would love rates at nine or 10% because that just means demand disappears. But that's a selfish want. The other thing I think about is I'm at the end of my investing journey. And I mean, if we have mortgage rates at eight, investor loans at nine, I'm going to guess private monies at 12 or 13. Maybe I should just become a lender, right? Maybe I should take my seven figures and just become a lender. I mean, what do you think? Yeah, I mean, why not?

Right. Why not? Because at that point that would give a better return than even real estate. Right. Oh, for sure. Yeah. Do some short-term flip money deals. Yeah. Yeah. But the chances of them, are they going to be able to sell or exit right on the back end? Are you gonna have to go through the headache of foreclosing? Right. That's the, that's the, always the, uh, I mean, there's no free money. Come on. That's always the, uh, the thing. But I think, um, with investors, you know, that is going to be, like you said, a very opportunistic time, I think more than now. And if anything.

everyone's going to look back to today and be like, shoot, I should have bought more when rates were at 6%, right? Like this is, it's always going to be a little bit of that. And, you know, it might sound crazy, but at 8%, I mean, is it, is it? It's unlikely entirely that perhaps for a short period of time, while it's inching up to eight, we might see more people flood into the market before it shoots up higher, right? Yeah. Mom and dad have proved historically that the only time they're going to jump into the market, or not the only time, generally speaking, when they think rates are going up, some people will fly off the sidelines. Absolutely. Because they'll take 6.9 because they don't want 7.1. It's just human nature. The other thing I was just thinking about, because again, I was seriously, you know, during this conversation, wow, if they're eight, I could get 12. But if we step back and look at Wall Street.

Wall Street, I think it's fair to say, is a greedy, profit-driven engine. That's not a bad thing. That's just who they are. And the first thing I thought about at 8% mortgage rates is they already have a pile of capital ready to lend. And I think you nailed it. They would get more creative. 3-2-1, 10-year IO, 30-year fix. They would just lean into new and different products. But the other thing I thought about is if rates stayed above 8% for a longer duration, I'm going to guess that pile of capital grows. Because again, that's a pretty juicy return.

So you're going to get Wall Street uber aggressive on creating products to invigorate the market, don't you think? Absolutely. And they've seen this before, right? And it hasn't been that long since they've seen this. So they know that if they hold paper at eight and all of a sudden...

they hold it for long enough, let's say, then at a certain point when rates do come down, they're going to make an extremely flat spread on that paper. And if they do that, I mean, the profit just keeps churning, right? We're going to see better earnings calls for all these hedge funds that are way more liquid now because they just offloaded some paper at a certain higher rate that now the market's paying like quadruple what it was when they actually wrote the note. So we're definitely going to see more. But I think what we might see more of too is if rates go to eight, we might see leverage start to increase.

We might see people in Wall Street itself. We might see them try to leverage more for everything. I bet seconds. I mean, seconds are already a pretty big deal today. They might go nuclear. Because again, if we're talking 8% first, you got to be talking about 10% seconds. They'd go nuclear. Yeah. Yeah. All right. Well, let's flip the script. 8% is fun. Again, as an investor, I would love it. I'd love mortgage rates to be 10% because I'd go hunting. But let's flip the script and say, magically, whiz, bang, boom, Trump's right. Mortgage rates are 499.

Again, owner rock, first time home buyer, all of that. So maybe investor loans are five and a half. What the heck happens then? Do you think Wall Street just pulls back? Is that rates too low? I mean, we've seen this too, right? Yes, we have. Little snippets, right? Obviously, the snippets of being at that 499 have been a lot smaller than the snippets of being in the sevens and eights. But I mean, it was a flood in the market, right? Listings that were sitting stale for months all of a sudden got 20 offers. And that's what happened when rates were down. Now, what Wall Street is probably going to do is they're going to hate it because all the paper they wrote in the short term now is worth less.

And now they're gonna have to pay to close these and fund these deals. So they might actually pull back, right? No, this is exactly what I was thinking. If rates fell fast, Wall Street will be offsides, right? And the other thing, you talked about purchases. My brain doesn't even go to purchases. My brain goes to refinances. We've had essentially three years where there's only been a couple of windows where you could refi. There's gotta be millions of loans that would step up to be refied at 499 now. And maybe if you're at 499 average, it means you probably could buy down to four and a half pretty easily.

dude, that your refi business would explode. I'm guessing. Yeah. Yeah. Back to the same 2021 type action machine. Yeah. We got to go hire a lot of people. Yeah. And I think, but I think the biggest danger to that is valuations. Okay. Yeah. So I think, I think the reason I brought up purchases is because that is what's going to drive values to, for the people to, for the ability to refinance. Right. Correct. So like, there's always like, people are always trying to use the idea, like realtors try to do this a lot. Like just, it's okay if you buy it at a higher rate, just obviously date the rate later on. Yeah. But when you,

But their assumption is if the rates come down, values are going to come up, right? And I think from its per pocket of the country, some might go up, some might go, you know, sideways and stay flat. But in general, like we've seen it happen, the little snippets of 5%, 499, like that little pocket that has it, like prices, people were starting to get aggressive. So if that is kind of the breaker, right, that is keeping people kind of from going, you know, balls to the wall, I'm going to pay whatever I can for this. And remember, primary homeowners are going to be willing to pay a lot more than investors will be for a home, right? Because they don't care whether they lose money in the short term.

Now you're going to be seeing inflated values. Wall Street in the interim is probably going to do a full step back and say, you know what, we're just going to put a pause really quick. And then we'll see how that affects the rest of the products. Because if Wall Street loses, they hate losing, by the way. They hate losing. So once they start losing, what products do we lose? That's my assumption. Because what we've been talking about, especially DSCR now, has become so institutionalized. When we first started talking about it, it was not.

But now it's so institutionalized. The difference is, okay, what happens when all those loans that were in DSR all of a sudden try to refi at a lower rate, right? Is that product still going to be there? Are the non-QM products still going to be there, ready to go because Wall Street doesn't want? to lose all that money. So I think the products will start rolling back. No, I agree. It's really, it's kind of a conundrum. At 8%, Wall Street gets more aggressive and creates more products. At 499, they pull back because they have to lick their wounds. The last thing I'll say about 499 is the move up buyer would reinvigorate the market. And real estate agents, real estate agents are going to like 499 a lot more than 8%. Let's just get that on the record. Well, we're actually at neither. And right now I do think the market Wall Street again is getting more and more aggressive because

Rates have been trending higher and demand for lending has been falling if you look at the weekly mortgage data. So what does Wall Street do? Well, they create more products. So you just told me about a new product with 85% LTV. What the heck is going on? They're pushing on LTV now? Yeah. So, I mean, it's kind of counterintuitive because before in the past, they've always restricted on LTV first. More skin in the game, right? 85% loan-to-value, and this specifically for DSCR purchases, has been around. But rates have always been like in the sevens or you've kind of taken a hit on that. Now there's a pocket. The minimum loan amount is $250. So big loan.

So bigger loan. Yeah, bigger loan. But again, loan amount, not purchase price. So $250,000 loan amount, not purchase price. However, now at 85% loan-to-value, so that's 15% down. If that covers, right, meaning obviously the rents are greater than the actual payment, including tax and insurance. The par rate, which is without buying it down, is 6.875. Now, just so I'm clear, DSCR of a one is good enough? Correct. Correct. Wow. Not even one-one, just a one. Just a one. That is aggressive. One rental at a time, family. We don't want to be just that one. No, we don't want to be one. At 85% loan-to-value, we do not want to be just that one. That's great.

The minimum is there at one. If you have a tenant that's transitioning out and you're going to make improvements to the property, build that equity there, then yes. This is great for obviously people that are trying to buy properties that have existing tenants that are paying less. Or if you have a current property that you know you're buying below market value. So you buy it at 85% because you know that you did the work and you know as soon as you buy it, next day it's already going to be worth 30% higher, 20% higher. And so you have that baked in equity and you get to buy that property for 15% down and beautifully cash flow on it.

No brainer, right? I would say that that is where this product succeeds for a lot of people. But that is 6.875. And then it wasn't even crazy. If you got the seller to pay your points to buy it down, 6.375 was only like two points. So, I mean, it's like, you know, half a percent. So is it worth paying it? But if the seller's paying for it, why not? Yeah, exactly. So I think it's just another option for buyers, again, especially for the one rental at a time family, like make sure that you're doing the work there. So you're building that equity.

Don't take this as like a sign for you to buy properties with 15% down, only putting minimum because that's all you have. Like that's not the way that you want to approach this. This is not permission to do something stupid. Yeah. This is just another tool to allow you to expand your investing, you know.

chamber of bullets, if you may, right? That's kind of what it is for. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I love that. Again, the thing I love about you and your partner being on the channel is you guys are always bringing us new and different things. Cause again, the wall street, wall street wants to do business. Wall street sees the lending market drying up or getting harder. So they're getting more creative. I'm always shocked that you guys can bring us new products each and every week. If somebody wanted to reach out to you specifically or your partner, Dustin, what should they do? Go to convoyhomelands.com and slash or at, and just let us know you came from there.

Yeah, folks, again, he has created a webpage for the ORAT family. Go there, tell them you came from ORAT, which they will, and then you will get this fine gentleman or his partner, Dustin. He takes care of us. Thanks, man. Have a good week. Thank you, too.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of One Rental At A Time?

This episode is 15 minutes long.

When was this One Rental At A Time episode published?

This episode was published on August 30, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this One Rental At A Time episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.