Skip to content
80. Are American Jews Disloyal? episode artwork

Aug 28, 2019 30 min

80. Are American Jews Disloyal?

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

This week, Uri and Rivky first touch on the new HBO series "Our Boys." Don't worry, no spoilers, but watch along with us! Next, our topic at hand: as Jewish Americans, many of us feel a connection to Israel. But how does that relate to Jewish dual loyalty? Is it real? If America and Israel came into conflict, would we pick a stand? Where? And, are other groups and religions accused of dual loyalty in the same way that Jews are? Related links: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/trump-doubles-down-calling-jewish-democrats-disloyal-israel-n1044861 https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/21/us/politics/jews-disloyal-trump.html http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2019/02/omar-israel-hawks-allegiance-foreign-country-anti-semitism.html "Our Boys" trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a4AVfDnwCIE Music: "American Idiot," Green Day: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ee_uujKuJMI

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

This week, Uri and Rivky first touch on the new HBO series "Our Boys." Don't worry, no spoilers, but watch along with us! Next, our topic at hand: as Jewish Americans, many of us feel a connection to Israel. But how does that relate to Jewish dual loyalty? Is it real? If America and Israel came into conflict, would we pick a stand? Where? And, are other groups and religions accused of dual loyalty in the same way that Jews are? Related links: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/trum...

Ready to play

80. Are American Jews Disloyal?

0:00 30:50
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rifki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So, Rifti, have you heard about this new HBO show, Our Boys? Yeah, I've been reading a lot about it. And have you seen the ads? Like, they're plastered all over. On the subway, I've seen them. Yeah, and buses also, like the side of the buses. It's this new HBO show about that summer a few years ago when those three Israeli boys were kidnapped. And there were a few weeks where none of us knew what happened, where they were, what was going on. And then after they were declared dead, then a Palestinian boy was taken and was also murdered. And the show is more about the second half of that story, if I understand correctly. The investigation into the murder of the Arab teen, basically. Okay. And so only a couple of episodes have aired so far. Three so far, yeah. And you've watched them all? I have.

Okay, so no spoilers, but how are you feeling so far about it? Very distraught, very upset. I think, well, by the time this podcast airs... Oh, let's also clarify. This is an Israeli production. It's also being backed by some, like HBO is part of it, but it's Israeli, and I think two of the filmmakers are Jewish-Israeli and one is Arab-Israeli. Is that correct? It's in Hebrew, but HBO was involved and it's being shown on HBO in America. And like we mentioned, it's being advertised in New York and I'm sure other places also outside of Israel. And by the time this podcast airs, the fourth episode will have aired also. It's Monday nights. How many episodes total? It's a 10-part miniseries total. Yeah, I mean...

It's very upsetting. I do want to talk about it, but only if both of us watch it. And after they have all aired, because I think it just makes more sense to wait for that. Okay, so we're giving warning to all of you that this is definitely the episode when it eventually airs. It will be filled with spoilers. So start watching. But in the meantime, yes, we definitely encourage all of you guys to watch the ones out so far, unless you choose to boycott it, which is your right. Oh, wow. I thought you were saying unless you choose to binge, which is kind of what I'm thinking about waiting for little things done. That's your right also. Or maybe I'll boycott.

But it has been discussed a lot. Not as much as I may have thought. I'm curious how many people are actually watching it and how many more may or may not watch it as it goes on. But we both heard it being discussed on the Promise podcast, which we talk about a lot. And I've seen things written about it. I think the directors have been interviewed and talked about it. It's very controversial, especially in Israel. And so it's really a focus on Israeli society, the racism, I guess, in it.

people didn't want to acknowledge that Jews could have done something like that. And that's really stressed in the show, like that whole concept. Well, I also remember that from that summer. Like I remember when that boy was missing and it was a pretty short window. Maybe it was only a day or two. But I remember everyone saying, and I also kind of thinking like, nah, there's gotta be something else going on. There's no way. Thinking slash hoping that it wasn't Jews. Yeah, upsetting. So yeah, so stay tuned for probably a few months. But also if you guys are watching, let us know what you think. We can have off-air conversations as much as we can. I guess that means I can't boycott. Or boycott and tell us that you're boycotting it. And of course we'll also include links to some articles discussing the show. Yeah, exactly. So you get a chance to really see what it's like.

Hello? Hello? Hello? Hello? The issue of Jewish loyalty and the anti-Semitic tropes that go along with it are once again in the news this week, but this time with a strange twist. Last Tuesday, during a discussion about Israel's decision not to allow representatives Omar and Talib into Israel, President Trump took things in a very shocking direction. Here is a short clip, but we will link to an extended clip in the description. Where has the Democratic Party gone? Where have they gone where they're defending these two people over the state of Israel?

And I think any Jewish people that vote for a Democrat, I think it shows either a total lack of knowledge or great disloyalty. Trump's comment about Jewish loyalty understandably sparked massive outrage from all sides. And one question people were asking was, which loyalty was Trump referring to? Jews who vote for Democrats are not being loyal to the U.S.? To Israel? I think in the context of his remarks, it was obvious what he meant. But the next day, Trump himself doubled down on his statement and also clarified it. In my opinion, the Democrats have gone very far away from Israel. I cannot understand how they can do that.

They don't want to fund Israel. They want to take away foreign aid to Israel. They want to do a lot of bad things to Israel. In my opinion, you vote for a Democrat, you're being very disloyal to Jewish people, and you're being very disloyal to Israel. And only weak people would say anything other than that. It sounds like what Trump is saying is that Jews who vote for Democrats don't have enough dual loyalty, as opposed to the classic line, which is that they are, that they have dual loyalty. So today, we want to use this case as an opportunity to discuss not just Trump's assertion, but this issue more broadly. As Jewish Americans, what do we think about the question of Jewish loyalty?

In March, while in a discussion about her previous tweets and remarks about Israel, Congresswoman Ilhan Omar said, I want to talk about the political influence in this country that says it is okay for people to push for allegiance to a foreign country. Omar was widely condemned for invoking the anti-Semitic trope of questioning Jewish loyalty. But honestly, was she wrong? Of course many Jews and non-Jews in America have an allegiance to Israel. It is also obvious that supporting one of America's closest allies does not necessarily detract from one's allegiance to America. But what if the two countries came into conflict? Where would we stand as Jews?

To add one more layer to the discussion, Trump said that Jews who vote for Democrats are being disloyal to Jewish people and disloyal to Israel. Those are not the same thing. And in fact, the anti-Semitic trope of Jewish dual loyalty goes back way before the state of Israel existed. So how do we differentiate between these two? And finally, why aren't other groups and religions accused of dual loyalty in the same way that Jews are? Rifki, what do you think? So many questions. So I'm actually very curious about that last part. You know, why aren't other ethnic groups accused of dual loyalty in the same place? Or what does it look like when other groups choose loyalty over something else, over...

America, let's say. Like the example that I thought about was the Colin Kaepernick thing, which we've touched on briefly in the show. But when Colin Kaepernick chooses to kneel and chooses to protest and chooses not to stand or salute for the national anthem, and people say that he's not being loyal to America, that he's being loyal to another group, right? In this case, what he's saying is to his community of black people who he thinks are disenfranchised and who he thinks that, you know, obviously racism and police brutality and all these things. I'm wondering if Trump would also say, I mean, I'm not really wondering, but would Trump, why in that case does Trump not say, oh yeah, like he's being loyal to his group? That's totally appropriate. Like why is that?

inappropriate and why is it more appropriate for Jews to be loyal to their ethnic group? I mean, I think without getting too deep into that issue, I think the accusations are there. They just take a different form. First of all, even if it's even though it's implied that when people criticize Kaepernick, they're saying he's more loyal to his people than to the country. They don't say in those words. All they say, tell me if you disagree, but I think all they're saying is he's just not loyal to America. End of the sentence. And that's because he says things like America is a terrible place and whatever. That's not a direct quote or maybe it is. I'm not sure. But like, yes, it is. That's not the same thing as if he went around saying like, you know.

Black people or other ethnic minorities have to stick together and stand up for our own rights. In that case, people, I don't think, would accuse him of not being loyal to America just because he's talking about his loyalty to his people or his ethnic group. I think it's specifically his direct and overt criticism of this country that upset people. Whether or not that's justified, I think that's the difference. Sure, but I guess the question that I'm asking or the thing that I'm really grappling with is what is Trump's goal? Or really the goal of any sort of like, let's use the term nationalism, right? This idea that people should have allegiance and people should have loyalty to their ethnic group and every ethnic group should sort of...

be aligned as one community. And then those groups should kind of like engage with one another. But first and foremost, your allegiance or your loyalty should be to your group. Right. I mean, that's giving a lot of credit to Trump that he had that this was thought out. Step aside from Trump for a second. Just talk about this idea of like nationalism. You hear that a lot with like white nationalism where they're saying like, we're not racist. We're not anti-black. We're just saying we don't want them in our group. They should have their own group. And that's great. Right. I can't speak to white nationalism and why they believe what they believe. I honestly don't really know or care.

Well, I guess I care, but it's funny you said the Kaepernick thing was what you thought of, what I thought of in trying to, I mean, generally when we try to understand a specific case, we try to understand the general idea or other examples of it, right? So the case that, the thing that I thought of was, I know with John F. Kennedy, when he was running for president, there was an issue of his Catholic identity. Right. Is he going to take direction from the Pope? Right. And I know that historically in America, Catholics were persecuted or discriminated against in various ways. And so they did ask him outright if, and I don't have the quote in front of me, but he basically said, I'm an American. I'm not loyal to the Pope. I'm loyal to this country. I also...

And again, I don't know that much about JFK's personal religious identity. I don't think he was an overly devout Catholic who consulted with the Pope or the Pope's words on a regular basis. You know, in terms of the Jewish side of it, it's interesting to think about Jewish politicians. And I remember in the 2000 election, a lot of people were talking about Lieberman, Joe Lieberman as Al Gore's vice president. If Gore would have won, what would that be? Would that be good for the Jews or bad for the Jews?

You know, after he lost, a lot of people were saying, well, maybe it was for the best because, like, it's better to have a George Bush who's very pro-Israel but not Jewish and therefore can't be accused of, like, a dual loyalty kind of thing as opposed to a Lieberman who might have to go out of his way to show that he's not more loyal to Israel. And it's also funny how now we have a major Jewish candidate for president, Bernie Sanders, but nobody seems to be concerned about that problem, if anything, the opposite. But I think Bernie Sanders is someone who people do say does a similar thing, right? He's a little bit more critical of Israel. No, a little bit more.

No, he's the one who said we want to take away funding from Israel in order to protest their policies. Part of what it is, I think, and this is armchair therapist that people have been talking about in the media, but that he's a little bit more critical of Israel than maybe he would be otherwise because he is a Jewish candidate and he's being sensitive to that. Right. I guess I might say it more like his views are the same as most others in his camp, but he's bolder in stating them explicitly because he doesn't have to worry about being accused of anti-Semitism since he's Jewish. So the JFK thing, I guess, are you questioning why is it that maybe JFK was accused of dual loyalty, but nowhere near with the same sort of suspicion or animosity in which Jews are accused of dual loyalty? Again, I'm not an expert on JFK. That's just one example. And so it's hard to make generalizations from one example. I'm just thinking of, let's say, with a flag. Sometimes when I go to my parents' house in Teaneck, I see houses.

I think at least one on my block that has an Israeli flag waving, hanging from the house, the front door or something. And I think technically there is some kind of law that says if you have a foreign flag waving, you have to also have an American flag. If it's not a law, then it's just American tradition, which is understandable. And then so sometimes when I see that, there is part of me that's like a little bit uncomfortable, more from the sense, from the place of like, oh, I hope somebody doesn't see that and get the wrong idea or think, you know, bad things about. you know, Teaneck Jews or whatever. But then to put things into context, like, you know, you go through Washington Heights and you see Dominican flags everywhere. You also see some American flags, but it's not like every time you see a Dominican flag, you also see an American flag, but nobody questions their loyalty. And, you know, bring it even, you know, stronger point, I think, Rashida Tlaib. Well, let's also just clarify, the Dominican flags are by and large from either immigrants or the children of immigrants from the Dominican Republic. The Jews who are hanging flags in Teaneck, some of them are Israeli and many of them are not Israeli, but they're Jews. That's an important point, but for the purposes of this discussion, I don't know how significant it is. Bottom line is we're talking about flags of another country.

Sure. Totally agree. Yeah. And then, you know, just because I have to bring the squad into every episode, you know, when Rashida Tlaib won her seat in Congress, there was like, you know, the video, the footage of the celebration and her mom was there and her mom was draped in a Palestinian flag. And yes, some people, mainly, you know, Jews and more specifically right-wing Jews were kind of like talking about that and saying like, what's up with that? What's the deal? But nobody really was accusing her of dual loyalty because of the Palestinian flag. But can you imagine if a Jewish congressperson was draped or their family was draped in an Israeli flag? That would be very controversial. Someone wrote about that imagining like if Schumer...

and Schumer's parents were... I think I said that. Oh, really? Oh, now I'm quoting you as a son. As I was saying it, I'm like, was that you? But I think it's actually really a fair point. I think what makes it a little bit interesting... I'm getting excited. The point with bringing those examples is just like, in my perspective, I don't think similar scenarios and situations in other ethnic groups or other national identities in America are treated and viewed the same way as with Jews. It seems to be uniquely with Jews that there is this question, this perpetual suspicion of where is their loyalty. And I think that for Jews, and when we talk about loyalty, I mean, Trump made it about loyalty to America versus loyalty to Israel, but the other...

thing he said was loyalty to America versus loyalty to the Jewish people. What do you mean loyalty to America? He was saying the Jews aren't loyal to Israel. Right, right. But I'm saying when he was talking about dual loyalty, he's saying they should be more loyal to Israel. And dual loyalty was saying in contrast to what they see as these other things. Meaning, to be more clear, the idea of being loyal to the Jewish people is not necessarily about being loyal to a state. Well, that's what I said at the end of the introduction, which is an interesting question also, is that...

Historically, this trope goes back many centuries, which is part of the answer of why it's more sensitive with Jews, because it's so historically sensitive. And there was no state of Israel for most of that history, but Jews were still accused of very similar things of loyalty to Jewish people. Because Jewish peoplehood was always a very critical part of a Jewish person's identity across different countries. I think basically what I'm saying is I understand why if an everyday American not Jewish looks at me and my home and I'm hanging an Israeli flag, that they would be like, that feels weird. That's not great. I'm not super thrilled about that. But let's say I were hanging a flag that were not political. It were not about a state. It were like a Jewish flag. I don't know. Let's say they were a Jewish flag. Let's say we had like a menorah on a flag or like a...

I don't know, anything like that. Yeah, then they would not feel... Then I don't think that people would feel... Or then if I were a random person, I don't think I would feel weird in that way because I'd be like, oh, there's no sense of conflict that could even be possible, right? It's like saying I feel affiliated with a certain... But you just said with Colin Kaepernick that there is a conflict between his people and the country. No, I don't think there is. The same way I don't think there's a conflict between Judaism and America. I see a conflict between countries, right? Between states that have political organizations. But what if this country has policies that discriminate against a particular ethnic group, in theory? So a different ethnic group is something different, right? The same way... Jews are an ethnic group, aren't they?

Totally. But Israel is not an ethnic group, right? Israel is very different. No, but you're saying a Jewish flag would not be controversial, but an Israeli flag could be controversial. Yes. But I'm saying, why can't the Jewish flag also be controversial? Because we can imagine a case where there would be some kind of tension or conflict between the country of America and a people within that country. I mean, I guess we can go back to Colin Kaepernick and use it as a practical example. Right. If he had a black power flag on his house or something, would that be considered problematic as an American?

I don't know, considered by whom? I don't think so, because I think that doesn't necessarily mean that there's a conflict there. It means that he's feeling associated with a particular ethnicity or community or group. To push back a little bit, you see it as the problem is specifically if there's a different country involved with the... allegiance here. But if you, let's say you were from Australia and you moved to America and you had an Australian flag, I don't think anybody would drive by and have a problem with that. They'd be like, oh, cool, Australia. Obviously, because Australia isn't really involved in that kind of controversy, Israel is very controversial. I guess I'm talking about a hypothetical person who is very thoughtful. But meaning, I think hypothetically, it should be the same. It should be the same whether I have an Australian flag or an Israeli flag. Well, the question is, why isn't it?

Right. I mean, I don't think either of us have answers for why it is or isn't. But I want to push back. Push back is too strong a term. But even just going back to sort of like what you were questioning in your opening was sort of like Trump is saying Trump is calling out something that kind of does exist. This dual loyalty a little bit does exist. And we can a lot of it. Yeah, sure. We can be a little bit honest. But obviously, it's not true for all Jews. But for many Jews, there is this sort of like tension. Even tension feels like too strong word. But there is this sort of like.

way in which I do feel very American, I feel tied to America, but at the same time, I do feel tied to Israel, I do feel very connected to Israel, and I feel connected to Judaism, right? And all these things are sort of like... So it's not even dual loyalty, it's triple or more. Yeah, there's a lot going on. But then I was thinking about it, and I'm like, but I also feel a strong sense of kinship and loyalty to women, you know? And I also feel a strong sense of kinship and loyalty to New Yorkers, right? Like, there's a sense... Yeah, sure, there's a little bit of that too, less of that. But, like, you know, Yankee fans, like, I'm saying, like, there's always a sense of, like, these, like, minor, minors, maybe minor... Concentric circles of loyalty. Right, exactly. And so for Trump to talk about, like, oh, you are not being loyal to America, instead

women, is obviously ludicrous. We both agree that what Trump said was absurd on many levels. And I don't just mean Trump, but I mean like, oh, you're not being loyal to America, you're being loyal to black people. You're not being loyal to America, you're being loyal to Jews. As if it's one or the other. Right, it's all ludicrous. But you're not being loyal to America, you're being loyal to Israel. I think there's a little bit something more that, like I see the conflict there more. Yeah, I mean, I think to your point, I think this is basically what you're saying is even the phrase dual loyalty I think is misleading because, first of all, it's much more than two loyalties that...

Jews have. But all people, just about, I think, in America, have multiple loyalties to their family, to their country of origin, if they're from somewhere else, to their religion, ethnicity, city, state, region, sports team, a million things. And for the most part, those things don't conflict. And sometimes they do. And that doesn't make you a bad citizen. Actually, when I was preparing for this episode, I was thinking about one of our first episodes we did, where we discussed a talk that was given by Dr. Schwartz, Dr. Rivka Schwartz, where she was talking about what are our obligations as Jews or as Orthodox Jews to this country. And we talked about taxes and political activism and all kinds of things like that.

of goes off topic a little bit my point is that like just having multiple loyalties it doesn't inherently make somebody a bad citizen at all i don't think and so i think it would be discriminatory or anti-semitic to only focus on jews and for you know ilan omar to say jews have an allegiance to a foreign country she actually clarified her remarks and said she wasn't talking about jews she was talking about just members of congress who were trying to vote down bds and they weren't necessarily jewish but i don't know i don't buy it right but anyway but my point is um i want to i want to make a very provocative point and this might this might hurt or ruin my chances of running for any political office in this country in the future. I would hope so. But, I mean, the perpetual question that I raise in the intro that people always, you know, talk about in these kind of discussions is, yes, it's okay to have multiple loyalties, but what if, hypothetically, the U.S. and Israel had conflicting interests or something came up? Really, the most obvious example would be an actual war, God forbid, between the two countries. Anything below that, you know, could be explained away and just debated in different kinds of ways, but where would we fall? So, I don't think that's like, I feel like that's like a classic exercise, but the truth is that here...

I think you're going to think that I'm avoiding the question, but I'm really not avoiding the question. My answer is Israel, to be honest. That's why I can't run for anything in America now that I've said that. So it kind of sounds, I mean, maybe you're going to think that I'm sort of avoiding the answer here, but what I really think is this feels like such a silly question to me, and here's why. It feels like we're setting up like two warring families, right? The Montague's and the Capitals. Who do you stand with, right? Like, who is your devotion to? And it feels like the ideas...

completely don't matter. If Israel and America suddenly tomorrow were to fight a war, who would you stand with? It's a ludicrous question because presumably if America and Israel suddenly went to war, there would be a reason. Someone would do something that would cause a war. So when you say who would you stand with, I don't think I can firmly say I would stand with America or I can firmly stand with Israel. I would stand with who I think was right, right?

Ultimately, it's like saying, who would you stand with, America or Iran? Presumably, we would all say America, right? Not Iran. But what if America did something completely insane and dropped 60 atomic bombs on Iran? Or whatever, I'm making up something totally ludicrous. But then you wouldn't just stand with them because you feel loyal to them. You have to be loyal to something bigger. You have to be loyal to righteousness, to ideas, to truth. You're not just loyal to America because you were born here. You're loyal to America because you believe that they're doing something right. And same with Israel. Otherwise, it's the mafia. Otherwise, it's about family, allegiance, and loyalty, and blood. And that stuff is just very cringy to me. Right. Well, I completely agree with what you're saying, I think. You heard it here. Aside from whether I agree or not, I think what you're saying is a really, really, really good point.

And it's funny that you say that because I was also thinking something like that. And it reminded me of something we talked about last week and the week before where you kind of posed the hypothetical question of what should, would we still advocate learning Torah if learning Torah did not in fact, you know, bring... people to be better people or better morals. The reason why that question bothered me was for that same reason. It's an unfair question because what you're basically asking is, what if the Torah, because I believe the Torah does stand for values and ethics, so you're saying what if it didn't? What if it's not living those ethics? It's not about the Constitution. It's about whether America is doing good. That question is asking, if the Torah wasn't the Torah, would you still like it? And here what the question is, if America or Israel weren't America or Israel as we know them, would you still have allegiance? And it's impossible to answer that because that's not what the case is. I don't think that's what I'm saying. I don't think with either of them it's what I'm saying. I don't think I'm saying if the Torah weren't the Torah. I'm saying if the Torah didn't affect people's lives and make people better people the same way I'm saying, if America...

didn't have good, just values, should we support the Torah if it's not actually making people better people? And should we support America if it's not actually on the side of justice? I feel so consistent. I feel so righteous. I'm actually sort of pointing out a... But I think you're pointing out poorly. Maybe I'm misunderstanding what you're saying. The analogy is not really so important. Let's talk about this issue. I think the reason why I think most of us and myself are patriotic Americans is because we believe in the values of America and we believe in what America stands for. If we didn't, then we probably wouldn't.

be that patriotic to America. But the reasons why we believe in Israel are a little bit more complicated than that because it's those things plus our ethnic and historic and cultural and family allegiance to the Jewish people and to Israel. But at the end of the day, Israel is America's closest ally and their values really do line up. We have the same enemies, the same people who want to destroy Israel, want to destroy America. And I think standing for a strong Israel is synonymous with standing for a strong America and vice versa. And therefore, you know,

I think if Rashida Tlaib, she's entitled to be proud of her Palestinian heritage, but I think that dual loyalty is a lot more problematic because the Palestinian Authority is not democratic and does not believe in most of the freedoms or many of the freedoms that, as Americans in a democratic country, we believe in. So I'm not calling her a bad American. I would think that would be a lot more problematic. I don't think when she has Palestinian-American pride, what she's taking pride is, is the political system in Palestine. We don't need to get into her head, and I'm just saying. I hear what you're saying. But I like that it's about the values. That's, I think, what's critical here. So what I'm saying is, to ask the question, even though I answered the question, I'd say I would choose Israel, to ask the question, what if America and Israel were at war with each other? I think what...

what you're saying or what I took from what you're saying is like, it's really an impossible question to answer because the America that we know and the Israel that we know wouldn't do that because they stand for basically the same things. And if they did come to war or major conflict, something like that would have to change. I also think I heard something interesting, which is that the question of is anti-Semitism the same thing as anti-Zionism? So an answer that I heard someone say recently was before the Holocaust and before the founding of Israel, there were legitimate Jewish opinions and viewpoints and non-Jewish against the founding of the state for various reasons that can be fairly said were not anti-Semitic reasons that there should not be a state of Israel. whatever those reasons were, after the founding of the state and after the Holocaust. And now that the plurality of the Jewish people live in the state of Israel, those two things have converged because now the state of Israel is also the plurality of the Jewish people in the world. And therefore you can't separate the two. You can't, so therefore you can't, if you're so anti-Israel by default, you are also being anti the largest population of Jews in the world. And it's much more complicated, therefore, for someone to say, I do not believe the state of Israel should exist, but I have nothing against the Jewish people because by endangering the state of Israel or by calling for policies that...

will very likely endanger the state of Israel, you are also therefore going to endanger the largest population of Jews, and therefore there is anti-Semitism there. Do you not see that connection? I definitely disagree with that, but because it's not exactly our topic, we can save that for another time. Guys, if you're really interested in us pursuing that particular topic, email us, because I have very strong feelings disagreeing with that particular thing. Well, the reason why I brought that up was because I think that concept may help us in understanding what, if anything, is unique about Jewish allegiance, loyalty to other Jews, to the Jewish people, to the state of Israel, but also the question of what about Jews who...

don't believe in the state of Israel. How do they fall into this? And we're out of time for today, but there's also a few other things I think we might have to talk about briefly in the beginning of the next episode, including the experience of Japanese and German Americans during World War II and what that tells us about patriotism. And much more recently, post 9-11, the experience of Arab and Muslim Americans and how their loyalty was and still is in some ways called into question. That's something that I think is important to acknowledge. But anyway, that's maybe for next time.

Well, as always, thank you all so much for listening. Please, please, please be in touch with us by email. TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. And join the conversation on our Facebook page, Talking Talkless Podcast. Thanks as always to Drive-In Productions. They are the sponsor of this week's episode. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Talkless. Bye, everyone. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 30 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on August 28, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.