Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rifki. And you're listening to Talking Topless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So Uri, we have a big topic this week. We both went to the YU student march for LGBTQ representation. But before we even get into that topic, which is a big one, let's just go through a little bit of feedback from last week's episode. Why don't we just go back the week before for a second? Because we didn't talk about feedback last week for the week before. We actually got a lot of feedback on that one. Right, that's true. We talked about the death penalty. Right, in the context of the attorney general, Barr, announced that they would begin again to seek the death penalty in federal cases. And one of the cases that Barr brought up is that they're going to seek the death penalty.
for the Pittsburgh shooter, the man who killed Jews at service in a synagogue a couple months ago. And a lot of the congregants and survivors of the shooting are petitioning and calling for the shooter to not receive the death penalty because they don't believe in the death penalty. A lot of the victims who were killed didn't believe in the death penalty. It would be disservice to them and their memory. And a friend of the show, Ellie, made a really interesting point that I was not aware of. And I looked into it. The Mishnah in Sanhedrin says that to execute somebody, I mean, there's a whole list of criteria that are necessary to get a Sanhedrin of 23 people minimum and all these things. But one of the things on there, one of the requirements is that if it's a unanimous vote that all 23 people
people, or however many people there are on the Sunhedrin, all unanimously say that this person should be executed. The person is not executed. So what do you think is the reason for that? So Ellie, when he was explaining to me, said it's because if it's unanimous, then we suspect that something might be fishy. And if there's any sort of doubt whatsoever, we won't execute somebody because that's such a huge thing to do, so final, that we're not going to do it. I never heard that, and that's very, very interesting. As opposed to in America, very often with death penalty cases, they say, you know, life in prison can be, you know, seven to five, or, you know, however big the jury is, but...
For the death penalty, it has to be unanimous. So it must be that people universally agree. I thought that was very interesting. So now moving to last week, episode 82 with Rabbi Linzer. So what was some of the feedback that you got about our discussion with Rabbi Linzer?
So I really enjoyed this episode. I think it was interesting. It was troubling. But I think in all the good ways, I think a lot of the feedback actually kind of reflected that. Also, I feel like I heard from a lot of people who would consider themselves, you know, more traditional or more on the right or more conservative, you know, lowercase conservative modern Orthodox Jews who were kind of almost pleasantly surprised by Rabbi Linzer and kind of thought, oh, okay, you know, exactly. Oh, I think of him as progressive. But actually, you know, he's basically, you know, even one listener to the show even mentioned, you know, I have very yeshivish cousins.
He sounds exactly like them, so that was a little bit confusing for her. But I think it happened on both sides. People on the right were kind of pleasantly surprised by how traditional he was, and people on the left seemed to give feedback where they were kind of disappointed. They were like, this is as progressive as orthodoxy gets. Too traditional. Exactly.
People think of Rabbi Linzer, people think of Cholulay Torah as a progressive voice for, you know, really forward-thinking modern Orthodox Jews, but that he was kind of going along with a lot of the party lines in ways that they thought, okay, so where does that leave me? And I think that's what feels troubling to people on the left in some ways. Sort of like, I thought that this could be my home in Orthodoxy because I'm not comfortable with kind of the more mainstream. I want this progressive voice. But if the progressive voice feels like, oh, maybe this is kind of more to the right than where I am, does that mean I'm...
I'm nowhere. Does that mean I'm not in the Orthodox camp? And I think that was troubling to some of our listeners. Yeah, we did get that. But we also got, I mean, the other side of that coin, even though people, let's say, quote more to the right, were like, oh, he sounds very traditional. But we still got the criticism on that end from friend of the show Ari, friend of the show Pesach, saying things like, we think Rabbi Linzer is great, and we trust him that he's genuine and sincere in what he's saying. But he's not fully acknowledging a lot of the people in his camp, even some of the graduates of YCT, who would not say those things.
live those values in their practice and in their... Right. Like all of the pretty traditional things he was saying about, you know, divine authorship of Torah and things like that, where he was like, no, of course, you know, absolutely. We believe in all of the same tenets as, you know, Orthodox Judaism, where people both on the left and on the right were saying... I think you're wrong about what your graduates believe. Like maybe you believe that. And maybe a lot of the graduates, maybe the majority of the graduates believe, maybe it's 90%. But definitely there are plenty of people in the left-wing Orthodox camp who really do not believe that. One of the things I liked about this episode was how it really brought those questions to life. Sort of like, where do we see ourselves? Where do we see our community? Where do we see the boundary lines? Who's in? Who's out? And I think like even the troubling parts are worthy of really like grappling with. But I also just want to thank Robert Linzer again and say what I think was so great about our conversation. One of the things that's great about Robert Linzer in general is that he is willing to talk about things that are complicated and things that are troubling to him, to his institution, to our...
our religion, to our community. And I don't think no matter where you fall out on these issues, the correct approach can never be to shy away from it and to just not address it. That can't possibly be the right approach for a leader of an institution. And I think that might transition us into this week's discussion about YU and their policies relating to LGBTQ students. Okay, so let's dive into it. So as probably many of you know, this past Sunday, the Ashibi University College Democrats hosted a march and a rally to protest in support of more LGBTQ plus representation for YU students. And the march and the rally was called We Too Are YU, Student March for LGBTQ Representation.
And I'm actually going back and forth a little bit between LGBTQ and LGBTQ+, but I'm taking that language from their materials. Maybe to make it easier, we could just say queer, because I think queer in a lot of ways encompasses everything. I hope. I actually don't know if that's true, but we'll see. If people give us very negative feedback, we will know. The event began with speeches from two student organizers named Molly Mizels, I think that's how you pronounce her last name, and Courtney Marks, each talking about their own personal experiences as current students at Stern College, which is the women's undergraduate school of YU, Yeshiva University, and then a few others spoke, including Rabbi Steve Greenberg, who's the founder of Eshel, a nonprofit geared towards acceptance for LGBTQ Jews and their families in Orthodox Jewish communities, and Mordechai Levavitz and Rachel Fried. Mordechai is the founder of JQI, Jewish Queer Youth, and Rachel is the executive director of JQI, and, of course, or more importantly, both are friends at the pod. We estimate that the event was attended by between...
So practically speaking... The organizers of the march had several key demands from the university. And of course, we'll link to those as well so you get the actual text. But let me just summarize quickly. They were looking for the following from the university. A, a statement from the university president denouncing homophobia. B, events involving LGBTQ on campus being allowed to explicitly use the language of LGBTQ in their marketing for the events. C, an administrator whose job it is to promote diversity and inclusivity. D, for LGBTQ sensitivity training to be involved in YU orientation for new students. And E, a gay-straight alliance on campus also with the explicit language of gay and pride and things like that to make it very, very clear.
We're recording this on Monday evening, the day after the march, and this morning, a second piece of news hit. A group of alumni have created a group called Pledge Not to Pledge, with the explicit goal of gathering as many alumni as possible who will promise not to donate money to YU until those same five goals are met. This Facebook group became public only a few hours ago, and as of now, it has 162 members. But to be fair, I'm a member of the group, and I'm actually not an alum, so just like with anything else on Facebook, it's hard to get actual numbers. So, Uri, we clearly have a lot to discuss, but let's just start with some basic questions. How did you feel about the march, as you were there?
If you strip down the five goals that they're asking for, what do you actually think that the students and the alumni are really looking for? Do you think the goals are fair? And a separate question, do you think the goals are realistic? As an alumnus, what do you think about how IU was for LGBTQ students since your time there? And of course, just to say straight out, as we were interviewing people, we did record a lot of these and we're going to play some of them throughout the episode as well. Okay, well, Rifki, as always, there were a lot of questions there and there's a lot to talk about. You asked me about my experience or my reflections on the march itself. I think it's important for me to say right off the bat that I'm really glad that I was there and that...
I'm fully on board with the overall mission of this protest and what they're trying to achieve. I think what they're trying to achieve is for every YU student, in this case, the LGBTQ students, to feel safe, to feel that they have people to talk to, to feel that they don't have to hide their identity. And I think that's, like a lot of people were saying that we interviewed, that you'll hear, like, that's just a very basic request. And I'm fully on board with that. And I guess it's also important for me to say that, to be honest, I was hesitant to go in the first place. I know, Rifki, you were pretty, I think, on board from the beginning. And you were asking me, hey, you know, you invited me on Facebook. And like, hey, are you going to come? Are you going to come? And my hesitation was not because I don't agree with the basic tenets of, like, people who are gay should have, you know, be able to express who they are and feel safe. And obviously, I mean, not obviously, but I am on board with all that stuff. But there were some...
of the specifics of some of the specifics of their demands, some of the specifics of the way that this event came to be, and some of the materials that were publicized in connection to it, which hopefully we'll get to all of that, that made me a little bit uncomfortable. And then this actually kind of related to something that we've spoken about a lot in the past of when there's like a march or a rally for a specific cause, and you agree with the basic idea of the cause, but there are elements in there that you might not be so comfortable with, what do you do in that case? Do you just boycott or just not go to the whole thing? Or do you go and be part of that movement because you agree overall with what they're trying to achieve, even if you don't agree with everything. And so, I mean, that also could be a case-by-case thing. If we're talking about, you know...
fighting for women's rights, but there are elements of like BDS and anti-Israel, I wouldn't participate. But here we're talking about Jewish people. Why are you students? Why are you graduates? And they're fighting for equality. They're fighting for safety and representation. And then there's some of the wording that bothered me a little bit and maybe uncomfortable. I didn't think that that, and then I decided that's not worth not going. And I'm very, very glad that I did go. And I found the event to be very moving. I found...
all the speeches to be very powerful within the speeches. And again, we can get into there were some things that I wasn't completely comfortable with, but that I just want to make it clear that overall, I thought it was really an amazing event. These students are very brave for doing this. I'm very impressed with them in many ways for their ability to get up there and organize this thing in the first place and then get up in front of these people and give those speeches. And so, I mean, I think that answers your question. Yeah, definitely. One of the things that I also felt so powerful was just to jump off what you're saying, the second student speaker, second organizer, which was Courtney, she spoke about being one of the few out queer students at...
Stern and Yeshiva College, I think she said maybe there's one or two others. And as she was speaking, her hands were shaking so vigorously that the paper was almost shaking. But you wouldn't have even heard it in her voice. I was blown away by not only her eloquence, I mean, it was written down, so it makes it a little bit easier, but by the power in her voice. I mean, I found myself really, really moved. I was definitely crying on and off during that speech. Again, many of the speeches were really excellent, but it was really, really, really powerful, and I was very impressed by her. Right. So why don't we play some clips, and then maybe we can get into the discussion. My name is Kenny Wagner. Nice to meet you. And did you go to YU?
I did go to YU, and I also worked there for five years afterwards. Cool. As what? Assistant and then Associate Director of Admissions. Oh, very nice. And what brings you here today? It's really quite simple. This kind of thing did not exist when I was a student there, and I think that it's really important that the students who are there today know that they're not alone. So what do you mean by this kind of thing? I think that LGBT people, particularly in the Orthodox community, particularly in YU, think that they're the only person in the world who has their issue. And that is depressing.
dispiriting and just a terrible burden to bear, and it shouldn't be born alone. And so simply knowing that there are other people either who welcome you or who share your burden is a tremendous plus. It's a tremendous restoration of courage and strength. Thank you. So I think what Kenny was saying was very powerful and simple, and a bunch of people told us very similar kinds of things. I'll also just point out that, you know, as he said, he's an alumnus of YU, and I saw a lot of friends of mine who were there, allies and people who are gay, also alumni.
There weren't that many current students in our estimation. Some people were saying there were a lot of current students. I mean, there definitely were plenty, but it seemed like the majority was not current students, which I think is very understandable for a bunch of different reasons why a current student might be hesitant to publicly show up to something like this, whether they're gay or straight. But I mean, that's just something relevant, I think, to point out. Well, let's listen to more clips. So why did you decide to come to this march today?
I mean, I do think there's a really big problem in NYU with homophobia and lack of inclusivity and all of that. And now we have a march that's trying to get more rights on campus and just create overall better environments. And that's a cause that I really support. So I'm really glad to be here and fight for this change that hopefully we can achieve. So far, our listeners are talking to four Stern students here, four women. And you're all current students? Okay. So have you seen any homophobia on campus or experienced it?
I've heard definitely people talking about things more, like, not to me specifically, but I do hear, like, other conversations that I'm overhearing, for sure. And also a really big issue, like, when this issue is brought up in classes, a lot of times it's really brought up in a really abstract idea. Not necessarily homophobic in what they're saying, but when they're saying, like, we have to help them. And really, like, marginalizing a really big group of people that are probably in the classroom. And I guess that's an inadvertent way of, like, actually being really homophobic. Have any of you seen outright homophobia on campus?
I mean, just, like, comments that other people have said. Like, just really, like, not nice things. Like, oh, like, people are lying about their sexuality and, like, super, like, transphobic things. Things that students are saying? Yeah. And then there's also just, like, a lot of, like, misinformation. Like, I've heard people say, like, oh, like, the Torah forbids people from being gay, so therefore we can, like, close them out of our communities and discriminate and just be... Who's saying that? Students. Like, I've heard students. And some people are really far to say, like, um...
that like we shouldn't be killing them but like they bring that up as in like when having conversations saying like the punishment for the Torah is death so how can you like bring them into our community which is super super super bad and just like so not okay and yeah. Have any of you guys heard anything from rabbis or faculty members in support of gay students like anything of support? I've definitely heard rabbis come out and say things like you really have to give compassion and respect and all Jews are Jews. To reiterate what I said before is the issue of like, hi, we in this classroom need to help those not in this classroom. And again, yeah, that's marginalizing a group when you say really great things for sure, but in that kind of way is a kind of backhanded support. I mean, what do you think of what those girls were saying? I thought the last point was, I think, kind of felt most real to me. This idea of using language that kind of implies that the people we're talking about are not in this room and kind of the danger of that kind of conversation. Like I'm imagining, you know, being the one Jewish kid, let's say I went to public school and kind of talking about Judaism or the Holocaust or the Jewish.
experience whatever as if like these jews this like you know kind of like this like academic thing yeah as if like you know okay let's try to understand those people and feeling i can imagine feeling very alienated and i've heard other people talk about this in the context of a mental illness right like talking about people who have who struggle with this we have to treat them that way and kind of like not imagine they're people who are sitting in that class who are struggling with these very real things right also one of the presenters she also spoke about that about feeling sitting in the class and hearing not only other students but also the teacher speaking about people who are gay people who are queer and feeling like just so alone in that moment right so i mean what i wanted to say on this and again i felt it was i think it's very important that i first got out the way, in multiple different ways of saying it, that I'm on board with the protest. I think what they're asking for is very basic and essential. That being said, some of the language and approach that I did not love was the characterization, and tell me if I'm misinterpreting this, but the characterization of the administration specifically, or the faculty of the school, whether that's rabbis or others, saying outright homophobic or hateful kind of things.
either directly to gay people or about gay people. Well, I'm just curious, from your experience, have you ever heard YU staff, faculty, rabbis ever saying things like that? I mean, I haven't been in YU for a number of years. I never heard anybody... Well, that gets into what is homophobic? What kind of statement is considered homophobic? If you quote the Pasuk in the Torah that says, you know, a man may not lie with another man, it's punishable by death, is that inherently homophobic? I think it depends on the context and the way that it's said. I don't think...
it's fair to say that quoting a pasuk from the Torah is homophobic, inherently, objectively. But so, just, and we're going to get to that in a second, but what those specific students were saying, I do think it's interesting and important to note that, like, when I asked them, do you see homophobia, like, on a day-to-day basis, they were like, well, we've heard that it happens. Like, I'm sure it happens. I believe 100% that it happens, and it's not okay that it happens. But I think it's important to say, like, this is not, like, a prevalent, ever-present, daily, you know, anywhere you turn, you're going to, if somebody who's outwardly gay, visibly gay, is going to be receiving.
threats and harassment like I don't I confidently don't believe that's why you and also the examples that they brought were all from students and we're talking about teenagers basically again doesn't make it okay but that's very different from an employee of the school who was hired to be there for the students to then say something that could be heard as homophobic and these four students at least basically did not say that they saw that or it's not on a regular basis and they said that they saw a lot of support and I also acknowledge what that one girl said about like even when a rabbi is saying we love you know all Jews and all our students but But in a way that kind of othered them, I also acknowledge that that's not okay. Yeah, it kind of sounds like, you remember Rabbi Linzer last week talking about the word inclusion kind of being off-putting. That's very valid and real. But I think it's important to distinguish that kind of thing from outright, you know. You know, again, I didn't go to YU, so I can't talk about an experience there. I went to seminary and I heard...
homophobic remarks from faculty and from staff and from rabbis there. And that was also a number of years ago. A hundred percent. I actually, I brought it up a few years. I remember at the time, one particular comment feeling very uncomfortable. I remember a couple of years later speaking to this rabbi and reminding him of that statement and telling him how uncomfortable it was. And he didn't remember saying it and said, did he stand by it? No, he said, not only did he feel awful that he had said it, he kind of said like, I can imagine that I did say that. And he felt awful about it. And also said like, today there's just a different kind of consciousness in which he wouldn't speak that way. But there only is that kind of consciousness because of the advocacy of LGBTQ community. Yes. And I mean, it's also important to point out the obvious that that.
evolution and thinking is not isolated to the why you or the jewish world that's our whole entire culture has moved incredibly far in the last 10-15 years on this issue and obviously why you and our community have moved along with it and we might not be at the same place as other communities and we might not be where we need to be but to acknowledge that things have moved is obviously important i think this might be a good point to bring up a post on facebook that i saw from someone who was at why you at the same time as me her name is hannah and i I have a lot of respect for her. She has a blog where she talks about Jewish issues and controversial issues. And she was also the editor of The Observer, The Stern Paper. And I know she's somebody that cares a lot about Judaism and Halakha and also cares a lot about people and people's feelings and humanity and everything like that. So she wasn't at the rally, but here's what she wrote. I watched all the available footage of the We Too Are YU rally in March that took place today. The stories are affecting and moving and the passion is clearly there. That said, if the goal is actually to enact change at YU, someone should be advising on strategy. I listened to Courtney Marks' speech, which included the following statement. Okay, then instead of reading the quote, I'm actually going to just play that actual clip from her speech.
A few weeks after I came out to my family, I started at Stern. I was in a new city, a new school, a new city, a new country. I was so terrified of people at school finding out I would take elaborate measures to hide that I was seeing someone or talking about exes in gender-neutral terms. This is why I marched. First few weeks at Stern, I was in class where the rabbi said that sexual relationships such as incest, bestiality, and homosexuality are all sins punishable by death. I ran out of class to call my mom sobbing.
He spoke as if people like me were evil and as if our lives do not matter. This is why I march. So back to Chana's post. The first statement about being obliged to hide her identity and having to talk about her exes in gender-neutral terms is obviously upsetting. It's ridiculous that she has to resort to this. The second statement, in contrast, is more unclear, nebulous, and plays into all the fears that Rashi Yeshiva and people who observe halacha have about the LGBTQ plus movement. The rabbi stating that sexual relationships such as incest, bestiality, and homosexuality are sins punishable by death is quoting the Torah. It may not be Torah everyone likes, but it's still Torah.
Simply referencing the statement as a Torah law is not the same as calling someone evil or worse, saying that someone's life does not matter. There's a lot of missing context here. Was the rabbi saying this in a disgusted tone of voice? Did he make a face or raise his voice? Did it have nothing to do with the topic they were studying? Because if all the rabbi did was state this piece of Torah, and the assumption is that anyone who states this piece of Torah is homophobic, the thrust of Courtney's speech is not that Wayu needs to be more accepting, but that Wayu needs to rewrite, change, or ignore pieces of the Torah. And so, I mean, I think Khan was making a really good point, which is basically like...
Just quoting that story, I think, is a little misleading. I'm not defending that rabbi. I'd be curious to know who it was, and I'd be curious to know what the context of how that came up was. Like, did someone raise their hand and say, what do you have to say about gay people? And his response to that was, well, the Torah says it's bestiality, homosexuality, and what was the other one? And incest are punishable by death. That's what I think about it. Or were they, like, learning that chapter, and that's what he read? I think that's true, and it's true that we don't have the context. And yet, I really can't imagine a context. Let me just be clear.
Honesty about the Torah is important. And to skip a verse or to pretend it's not there, if you believe that it's divine, you believe that verse is from God, you have to contend with it, right? I think it's silly not to. But I imagine, and maybe I'm seeing something that wasn't there, I imagine that what Courtney was upset about was that there wasn't that sense of context. I imagine that Rabbi did not quote that verse and say, you know what, this is actually kind of challenging. We all know gay people. Many of us, or some of us maybe sitting in the classroom are gay, and this is something that we should really try to understand. But let's not lie to ourselves. This isn't the Torah, and that's something that we have to deal with. I would be surprised if that's the way that Rabbi presented it. I think we have no idea what the context was. I would be surprised because it would be an odd story for her to tell. See, the Rabbi spoke as if I were evil.
if what the rabbi did was quote it and say, this is challenging and troubling and we have to try to understand it because we have to have empathy for people who are sitting in this very room. Okay, I mean, I don't even know who the rabbi was. I want to give him the benefit of the doubt that that's not what he said. And so I also, I actually would be surprised if the context was in a... more like accusatory or incriminating kind of tone. But I think- I imagine it was neither. I imagine it was without context. Meaning I think that context is necessary. I think that anyone, unless you're laning, or maybe even if you are laning, but unless you're literally just reading verses and this is part of a larger thing, as anytime you're bringing up that verse, you need to be sensitive to the people who are in that room. Yes, what I'm saying is that I would honestly be surprised, and maybe we disagree on this, but this is all conjecture. I would be surprised if this rabbi speaking to a class of stern students that very likely could have a gay student in it, and he should know that, would come across that verse in whatever the context was. I'd be very surprised if he did not say, this does not mean that gay people are evil. And if somebody is gay,
Like, this is what the Torah says, and we have to grapple with that, but this is not saying anything about the person. I mean, I didn't go to YU, I didn't go to Stern, but from what she says, it seems like he didn't say that. That's what Khan is saying, that's my point also. Like, I don't think that as an example of the problems of YU should have been the example brought. Again, I'm not denying that homophobia is there, but I think the much bigger and more important issue at hand is that as a university or as a college, the school does not have...
these basic things in place of a club where people can be open about their identity, you know, the president making explicit statements condemning homophobia, like, those are all much more, like, clear-cut that that is lacking and also clear-cut of an ask of, like, this is what we need and this is very basic. I mean, if somebody in that position says they experienced something hurtful, I'm going to believe them. I mean, of course she was hurt. I think what you're saying is that it wasn't the teacher's intention. Yes, but it also gets into, okay, one of their demands, and this gets into what I was uncomfortable with even before the rally started, one of the demands is that the president of the university has to make a statement condemning homophobia. Now, that is very basic, and I agree, but...
What is homophobia? There are plenty of people, and Courtney might be one of them, who would say, the Torah is homophobic, and therefore quoting that passage in the Torah is homophobic. I don't know exactly what to do with that or what I'm saying about that, but I don't think it's fair to label a rabbi homophobic or unsafe if that rabbi is acknowledging that there's a passage in the Torah that says homosexuality is homophobic. But you're also saying that you don't think that you believe, Courtney, you don't think the rabbi actually said, hey, here's the verse in the Torah, it's challenging, it's troubling, we have to contend with it because we believe the Torah is divine. Well, Courtney didn't say that, he didn't say that. She said what he said, she didn't say what he said before that or after that, or what the context was.
Okay, my assumption, based on her saying... Well, respond to what Khanna said. What do you think about her assessment of that? And how basically she's saying that strategy is not helpful if you're working within the NYU system of Orthodox community. Oh, so the question of strategy? For sure. I think it could have been...
something more comfortable for the more right-leaning people right in the YA community. If Courtney said in her speech, my first few weeks in Stern, I was in class where the rabbi said that sexual relationships such as incest, speciality, and homosexuality are all sins punishable by death in the Torah. I believe that this is a verse in the Torah that we should be talking about. And yet the way the rabbi spoke about this was incredibly hurtful and painful to me to listen to because I felt completely outside the community and like the rabbi was dismissing me as a person. And that was incredibly hard for me. I ran out of the class to call my mom sobbing, right? If she added a sentence, I think that would have made all the difference. Do you agree? Disagree?
I don't know about all the difference. I think it would have helped a lot. I think it also would have been interesting to know if she approached that rabbi or asked him, what did you mean by that? Or do you think I'm evil? Or do you think maybe she'd want to be so personal about it? Like, if there was a gay student in Stern, do you think she is evil? Like, any of those things, I would be very... Totally true. I could also, I mean, my first few weeks in Stern, I imagine that means she's 18 or 19. If I were 18 or 19, I would never have done that. If she didn't do that, it's on her. Obviously, that would be very difficult to do. But I'm just saying, I would be very curious to know if she did that and what would happen if she did. And I would hope that whoever this rabbi is, if the rabbi hears the speech or reads the speech and can realize that it was him, I hope that he feels horrified and
that matters. Right, 100%. And the bottom line is that if Courtney was hurt by what this rabbi said, that that means he said something wrong. End of story. And it needs to be addressed. The only reason why I'm getting a little bit defensive and pushing back a little bit is because I know a lot of the people at YU and all the people that I know, all the rabbis there that I know, are all good people who care about the students and care about people. And I'm confident in saying that if one of the rabbis said something that was hurtful to a student, it may have been inadvertent. And if it was brought to his attention, I think he would apologize. We don't know who it was, so let's not dwell on that. I just think the major problem with the rabbis at YU is not...
hateful speech coming from them. It's more just silence and lack of support and positive things coming from them. I think that's the real issue here. And I think that is what a lot of the demands and the protest was focusing on. And I just think that is a better thing to focus on than trying to paint a picture. And I'm not saying this is what Courtney was doing, but I think it could come across that way. Painting a picture at YU as an institution, the rabbis at YU as people are just these hateful people who are calling students evil people. I just don't...
But I don't think that she's characterizing these rabbis as evil characters. I'm not saying she is. I'm just trying to give that bigger context, whether or not you or other people believe it or buy it. I'm just saying that's my perception. I think it's important to put out there. By the way, a plate of brownies to whoever can convince Rabbi Berman to come join us on Talking Talks because I would love to talk to him. But anyway, let's listen to Dina's parents. I'm Connie Klein, Dina Klein's mom. Shimmy Klein, Dina Klein's dad. The parents of the proud co-host of our most popular episode of Talking Talks. Dina's here also. Dina, you want to say hi? Hi, everybody. We are not surprised. So why did you guys decide to come to the march today?
Hani and I have been part of the YU family for many, many years. We sent our kids to YU. We've been at Champions Gate and YU Shavuos and the Hanukkah dinners. And we really feel, even through today, that we are part of YU and love, not just empathize with all of YU's values. And I actually never thought it would be necessary to come to a march like this today, just because of everything I've heard from YU over so many years.
But really as a father and also as a member of the YU community, I just felt that the time came. I never thought I would march against YU. I don't feel like I'm marching against YU. I feel like I'm marching for YU. And I don't really understand. I don't know Rabbi Berman that well. The little I know of him is that he's much more compassionate than the way YU is behaving. And I don't know whether it's Rashi Yeshiva or donors or the board, but all the Rashi Yeshiva that I know that are in positions of influence, I know them very well. And I know Michelle Strauss. I don't know the donors, obviously. I can't imagine who is holding YU hostage.
that they can't just act in a compassionate, sensitive manner to everyone and display the level of a Havaz Khinam that they talk about so proudly and that we all believe in so much. And so even though I never thought this day would come, we're here. You know, you go on a journey in your life, no matter what happens to you, no matter who you are, no matter what your experiences are, it's a journey. And part of my journey has been with YU for practically my whole life. My dad got Samicha there. My children went there. Shemi and I feel very much a part of the YU community. But it seems that somehow their journey is at a halt.
And that they just parked and they're not making, they decided we're not moving. And in my heart, in my mind, I'm like, who are these people? This is the YU that has been the umbrella for me for almost everything I've done, almost everything religiously that I've looked up towards. And now... They're just silent and they're so pacifist and so the opposite of leadership that I'm stymied by it. And I'm also hurt by it because these are our children, not just mine, not just the person next to me. These are all our children. And all our children, I don't care who they are or what they are, deserve Avakhinam from all Jews and especially a place like YU. I mean, to me, what was so powerful speaking with and hearing from Dina's parents was that these are people, this is a family that is so enmeshed in YU's ideology, YU's...
story, YU's community. Like, they are the poster family of what YU aspires to. And they've supported YU, they send their kids to YU. The only difference between them and the, you know, hundreds of other YU families who maybe aren't on board with this movement is that their daughter is gay. And that's something that I just kept thinking about because that could have been anyone's daughter or son. And I think in so many other ways, one of the most beautiful things I think about, you know, the Jewish community and our community is how tight-knit everyone is and how much concern there is for other members of the community.
almost to the extent that, like, you know, I'm not a parent yet, but, like, the feeling that, like, just because this child is not my biological child, I still feel connected to them. They're basically, like, my family, and I care about them. And so I think there's so many other people out there who are good, caring people in the YU world who, if they would have been to the rally or spoken to Dina or anyone else there, or, you know, would have, would come to the exact same conclusion. Like, all we're asking for is dignity and respect and safety and, like... feeling part of the community just like everybody else. It's just so basic. And so that's what really hit home to me. These are not outsiders. These are not people who are saying what YU represents is problematic, is foreign. It's like basically every other way. And I mean, the best part of their interview, I'll just play and then hear what you think about what they said. And Dino, how did... Yeah, sure. I just want to say I listen to all the Talking Topless podcast. And first, I want to say I'm not an expert in this issue because I know you guys like to qualify everything you say by that. And second, 98% of the time, I find myself agreeing with Erie more than Rivki on most issues.
Thank you, thank you. Much appreciated. Of course, that's your favorite. I mean, obviously, these are extremely intelligent and thoughtful people. Mainstream, you know, boring, you know, they can't think outside the box. No, I mean, I think I agree with you, and I think what, to me, Dina's parents represent are people who have gone through this experience, and they kind of were people who hadn't really thought about this because they'd never been exposed to it. It was never kind of presented to them. It was just kind of like, yeah, of course, yeah, sure, I know there are gay people, but I don't know, it's not something that is so relevant to their lives that they're losing sleep over it.
Many of us who have family and close friends who are gay talk about how, honestly, it wasn't something that we really thought about so much until we were forced to. And then when we were forced to, it kind of chipped away at our sort of certainty or comfort because then we were really kind of forced to say to ourselves, like, what do I really believe? Like, the empathy needs to kind of take over at a certain point. I think what's so incredible about Dina's parents in this, and in many ways it was really like an amazing conversation with them, but it was that their daughter, who they love so much, forced them to really think, like, what are my most, you know, closely held beliefs and how can I reconcile these different parts of myself and not lose relationships with the people? the institutions and the organizations that matter most to me and how can I make all of these things work well I think what yes but also I think what he was what they were actually saying was it's not just about what do we believe it's sort of like beyond that it's like figuring out what we believe and how this fits into the Torah and halacha is something that we need to talk about but in the meantime let's just let's have compassion and acceptance for our children that to me what was most powerful yeah absolutely so like I don't know if this is different from what you were saying no I think it's the same thing it's not about saying like
Our daughter is gay. Therefore, we have to reevaluate our whole belief system. No, it's not. It's less that and more like our daughter is gay. We love our daughter and we're going to accept her. And why you need to accept her. That's number one. Now let's maybe talk about when I say sort of belief systems. I think that to a certain extent, there's a sense of people thinking about insider and outsider.
People sort of like saying it kind of like the way some of the people we interviewed were saying it's sort of like, oh, people who are gay or people who are loud about it, whatever, like they're trying to be troublemakers to a certain extent. They're trying to sort of, they're setting themselves up outside the system. And like, you know, there's a tension there. But seeing someone like their daughter who is so in it and they're so in it forces them to kind of ask themselves, like, how do I really think about this? Like, this is someone who wants to be in it, who so badly wants to stay inside the community. And now we have to figure out what that looks like. I mean, you mentioned the pledge before. Right, I was thinking about that too. The pledge to not pledge. You know, so.
I think people like Dina's parents and a lot of other people that I know that have given a lot to YU in the past and want to give more in the future, they want to help support this institution, just now feel that they can while this is unresolved. My concern is that there are also a lot of people who, like with this pledge to not pledge, like I wonder how many of these people will actually give to YU if this is resolved. Meaning like when I saw that group, my thinking was like, instead of saying... we are proud YU alumni and we will not give anything to YU until they change these policies, I thought it would be much more powerful to say, we are proud YU alumni and we pledge that we will give to YU when they change their policies, you know, to show that we do actually care about this institution and this school. That's why, again, I get a little bit defensive and worried because I wonder, and again, I don't want to not trust things that people are saying and I want to put words in people's mouth, but I wonder when it comes to people that were at the protest, people that were organizing the protest, a question that I would be curious to ask them or just to know how they feel is, if tomorrow...
why you closes its doors and just falls through and disappears either because of this protest or because of whatever else financial and otherwise they're in plenty of trouble in other areas if why you shutters its doors and closes down would that be a tragedy would that be a loss would you would you personally feel a loss would that be a loss to the community or would it not be such a big deal because i don't really like what they represent anyway well this is pretty easy we have an audience right this is a podcast why you students and alum who are listening to this okay very yeah very curious i'm just very curious again i'm not putting words in people's mouth and making assumptions that's just something that i'm i mean i would imagine maybe i'm being naive but i would imagine that people who are saying we are proud This is something that we are not proud of. This is something that we do not like about the university, but we're generally proud alumni. They would not be thrilled if the institution closed, but maybe I'm wrong. I'm not saying people would be fine with it. Would you consider it a...
huge loss to the world and to our community if YU closes down. I mean, I am not an alum, and I've never given money to YU, and I don't currently have plans to give money to YU, but I think it would be a loss to the community. Like, there are a lot of institutions that I believe with 30% of what they stand for, or 50, or 70, that I would think of it as a loss if they close. It feels like that's kind of an extreme question, but maybe I'm wrong. Maybe there are a lot of people who are going to say, actually, yeah, I would be totally fine with it. Well, because the extension of that is when it comes to criticizing YU and its policies, I think it would be a lot more compelling to hear from people like Dina's parents who...
are very on board and love YU and on board with their ideology and what they represent, but this is just something that's so painful and so difficult for them. I want to hear, okay, if you're a proud YU alumnus, what do you like about this goal? Tell me something that they did right or that you think is okay, as opposed to what it could be is that... I don't really care that much about the school, but this particular thing is so bad that I have to protest it, but there isn't really much there to praise. I mean, I'm sure there are people in both camps, but to me, every year, what YU does is this, like, you know, pledge and giving day, right, where they not only kind of, like, raise these huge donations, they have matching funds, right, and part of it is that a lot of people post all over social media, you know, here's why I gave to YU, I am YU, here's why YU is so important to me, and what a lot of these people who, friends of mine or people who I know who I see in this pledge not to pledge group are people who have done that in the past, who have said, here's why I gave to YU, here's why YU is important to me, here's why it was influential in my life, right, and they're not, it doesn't seem to me like these are people who are saying, already hate yu it's like the person who organized this who's a friend of both of ours worked at yu for years yeah exactly he worked about you for many years he just stopped working there this summer and i think he cares a lot about 100 i agree 100 and i'm not all i'm saying is that i would rather the motivation matters
By matters, meaning anybody can believe whatever they want, and that's totally fine. I'm just saying for me personally, I think for a lot of other people, maybe more importantly for other people who are not yet on board with this cause, but should be and can be, they're much more likely to come on board if they hear from people that they can relate to that also have a genuine love for this institution, this school, and that share their values for the most part, but are pointing out, hey, you should be aware this particular issue is not okay with the way they're treating it. And here's the catch-22 that we talk about very often, is that when the group of people who are involved in this are people who maybe are not the... People who are seen as a pride and joy, right? And people who march alongside why you in every single other way. Then people who are that way, who people who are much more like why you censure completely, who look at the people who have already signed on, they kind of say, these aren't exactly my people. So even though I kind of agree with what they're saying, I'm not necessarily going to sign on. And then the cycle just continues, right? And it doesn't become a more cohesive group that becomes larger and larger because there's this sense of, oh, I don't exactly feel like I align with those people, right? It's the same thing as the women's march. It's the same thing we talk about very often. That's one way of looking at it, yeah. And I think that's...
It's understandable, but it's still scary because it's focusing on like, maybe I agree 90%, but this 10% makes me feel like I can't really join that group. Right. And, you know, as somebody was saying on Facebook that I saw, I was like, he was against the whole march in general. And he was saying like, this is ridiculous because students should not be setting university policy. And I hope that, you know, they do not succeed and whatever. I don't agree with that statement. But what I do think is that the students here are, you know, they're saying their list of demands. They're saying their perspective and their lived experience as students on campus and alumni and stuff. And the school is not.
responding for the most part, and therefore the entire conversation is just a one-way conversation. The students are setting the tone for everything, meaning it would be very, very different if the president was more on board in this conversation, was saying something, the school was putting out statements, and was saying, here, come to the table, let's speak, let's do a panel, let's talk about this, and then the school said, well, here's where we're coming from. here's, you know, the halacha as we see it. We want to accept all people. Like, there's a million different things they can say and there could be all kinds of compromise. Like, I actually spoke to Molly afterwards about, you know, her experience at YU and organizing an event. One of the things I asked her was, would you be willing to compromise? And she said, yes, of course. Like, all protests are built on... If you're an advocate, you have to realistically understand that you're not going to get everything, but everyone will find something. When I asked her, well, what would you be willing to compromise on? Like, that was a little bit harder for her to answer. But like, that's understandable. And I'm not holding her, I'm not holding that against her in any way. I think, again, what she's doing is amazing. And it's embarrassing that on the other side, there's just silence. That's just what I wanted to say is that it's not a conversation. They're not coming
be a little bit too much, far-reaching. You're asking a school that's in dire financial trouble, I think, to hire an additional thing. Maybe they can't do that. I actually don't think that's a big... I don't know, whatever. This is not a lot of money. But again, there's a million things they can do that might not involve hiring a new full-time person. And then the students can say, that's okay, that's not okay in terms of what we think. But they're not doing that, they're not responding. And that's the main problem here. And I guess my summary is that I think this rally and this protest was very important. It's almost surprising. It's like one of those things that once it happens, it's like, wow, how did that not happen five years ago? But I really hope that it has positive change. I hope it doesn't do...
lasting damage to a school and an institution that I care very much about and I think represents a lot of really good things and a lot of really good people there at all levels, from the students to the president and everyone in between. So I just hope that they're able to figure out a way. President Berman, it's a very difficult position he's in, but that is his job, to know what to do in difficult situations and to be able to say something. And I definitely don't think... The correct answer is to not say anything. Well, that's why we have a podcast, Rabbi Berman. We'd love to have you. I'm sure you're an active listener. Before we finish, I'm actually just really curious about this because obviously we've spoken before about queer issues and the Orthodox community. We've spoken obviously explicitly about Rabbi Dan Atwood who had been a Choveveh student and then was told he was not going to be given smichel from Choveveh and that became a big issue which we've talked about. And I'm kind of wondering why U is obviously a really unique institution, right? It has a rabbinical school. It has an undergraduate school. It has plenty of graduate schools that really are secular, plenty of non-Jews, right? Go to the med school, go to the law school. I'm wondering if you see why U here as...
different than in any of these things. Like, I imagine when this whole Dan Abbott thing was happening, while you was kind of looking at that, being like, God, that's not happening here. God, we can avoid that. Yeah, I'm glad you asked that. What do you think? Because I was thinking about that. I mean, one of the speakers actually at the protest was, I think, a gay student at Furkauf, one of the psychology graduate school. And she said something that was interesting. It was like, you know, when I found out that, you know, this is the university, this is the name that's going to be on my diploma, and now this is what they stand for, I was shocked. And it's like, yeah, if it's the homophobia, they're not...
acceptance of gays like yes that is shocking to me also but like the fact that they're an orthodox institution and might represent other things that you might not be totally on board with like you should have known that when you signed on i think most people don't but that's on them meaning and i think there's a big distinction between graduate school and undergrad and i think um you know so that you're talking about like the yct thing i think for why you undergrad um and it is an important thing to say because this came up in some of our discussions some of the speeches like if you have such a problem with why you then leave or don't come here i think there's a for graduate school i think that might be a valid thing to say in some kind of way for undergrad not because people wind up at YU for all kinds of reasons. And it could be because their parents really want them to go. And if your parents are paying for your college and it's where they want you to go, you don't have that much say. And you want to be in New York. You like other things about the school. There's a million other reasons. And all of them are valid. Meaning once a student is there, they deserve to be treated with respect and dignity. So what I think is, to answer your question, I think a lot of these issues are actually very easy, should be very easy for YU to address because we're not talking about the rabbinic school, even though YU has a rabbinic school. If they had that kind of situation, it would have to be dealt with. I think that would be much more complicated. Undergrad, we're not talking about rabbis. And we're also not talking about marriage as much.
something come up like a gay wedding or whatever. We're talking about 18, 19, 20-year-olds. I don't think any of them should be getting married at that age, gay or straight. And for the most part, it's not something that really comes up that much. So meaning all we're talking about is acceptance of people. And so I actually think in those areas, and Dino's dad was saying it, and also Mordechai Levovitz had a point that this is sort of like a JQI talking point. And I think it has a lot of validity to it, which is that if you, he's addressing the world, the community, if you hear...
LGBTQ and all you think about is sex, then you're the perverted one, not us. You know, like, yeah, we're talking about people and we're not talking about sex. And like, if the Torah prohibits sex, like, that's one thing. Let's put that in a category. And then there's everything else about dealing with people and dealing with them as people and, you know, human dignity.
and respect. I think I'm answering your question, which is that, like, I think a lot of these things should be actually pretty easy for YU, because they don't have to come to conclusions on the halacha, and they don't have to come to conclusions on some of the more complicated, like, quasi-halacha things of, like, officiating a marriage, ordaining a rabbi. Like, we're talking about undergrad for the most part here, and all we're talking about is making students feel safe and accepted and loved, and so I do think that that shouldn't be... complicated regardless of what you think about the actual halacha. Does that make sense? Yeah, so it sounds like what you're saying is that the major difference between YU and Chovey is that what Chovey went through, it makes sense that it was complicated, right? Because they're talking about rabbinical school, they're talking about marriage, they're talking about kind of halachic things, you're saying? Yes, the issue was more complicated there. Where with YU, it shouldn't be complicated. It should be an absolute no-brainer. It's about love, it's about compassion, it's about people. I don't want to say absolute, but I think it's a lot more straightforward. And even though there are sort of policy things that these students are looking for, these policy things are all kind of representing that same idea of acceptance and inclusion and everyone being kind of like seen as part of the YU community. And that's why it shouldn't be super difficult.
Yes, I mean, I don't think it's that simple. I mean, you are representing what I just said, and I do agree with that. It isn't that simple because it's... there are still going to be many people who, you know, even if you say, like, we love you, we accept you, you can have a club, you can call whatever you want, you can have speakers, you can have a gay straight alliance, we're going to condemn homophobia, but there's still going to be people who say, like, if you still say, if you rabbi, whatever, whoever it is, still say that according to Jewish halacha, like, gay sex is prohibited, that's still homophobic, that's still not okay, and that's sort of like, you can't go much further than that. And it could be that in five years and in ten years, and maybe already starting, that is the conversation, and people move beyond sort of accepting this. Right, and so I think what makes it a little more complicated is that there are a lot of people who are scared of a slippery slope type of thing, which I think is always,
you know, is not a reason to not enact change because we're worried about slippery slope. But I do also think it's important to acknowledge that is where some people's fear is stemming from. Right, I agree. I think just understanding where people are coming from, whether you agree with it or not, is really critical. And even though I'm with you already. That they're not coming from a place of hate. They're coming from a place of tension and concern. I mean, that doesn't mean that they can be presented, you know, as either teasing or as, you know, hate or anything like that. But yeah, I agree with you. I think that unfortunately, often halacha is used to mask. But I think overall, we have moved as a...
as a modern Orthodox community, and I imagine why you, as part of that, moved away from that, hopefully, mostly. But, you know, I do think it's interesting. Yeah, and I think it is interesting to see, because I do think you're right, that the next frontier is like, okay, of course you have to accept us, and of course these changes that we're advocating for are absolutely necessary, but now we are not going, we want to be fully included, and how could we be fully included if you will not? Let us get married. How can we be fully included if you will not let us be rabbis? How can we, you know, all of those things, you know, how can we, if you're not going to send out, let our children go to the day schools, right? Things like that. And I think that is kind of the next big battle that we're gearing up for. But I don't know if the undergraduate school at YU will ever have to deal with a lot of those things, which is why I think it should be easier. Right, this should be easier. It should be a given for them to, like, give in. Like, you know, just agree to these demands. It's like, you know, it's funny also to say, we were talking about, I asked Amali, would you be willing to compromise? And I was thinking about it afterwards. It's like, maybe that wasn't the best question of me to ask her because
these requests are very basic. And so the compromise would be on those other things, potentially like the marriage and the ordination and the day schools. Like those are things that I think require compromise. asking for acceptance, asking for the ability to have a club, for people to speak to each other about these issues, that shouldn't have to be compromised because that's as basic, I guess it's as basic as a request could be. Right. Okay, so I guess we're ending this episode with a couple of requests to everyone listening. First of all, we really want to hear from alums and from current students and give us your perspective on all these, especially the specific questions that we were asking before. And most importantly, Rabbi Dr. Berman, we want to talk to you about this, we want to talk to you about other things. We would love, love, love. Please be in touch with us, everyone, at TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. And of course, join the conversation on our Facebook page, Talking Talkless Podcast. And a special shout out to Dina Klein's dad, who I'm pretty sure at this point has probably switched over to my side.
Do you think that's fair? No, I don't think that's accurate. We'll wait to hear his email as well. Thanks as always to Drive-In Productions. They are the sponsor of this week's episode. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Top Talk List. Bye, everyone. Bye.