Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rivki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. Rivki, happy new year. Thank you so much. Happy 5780. Yes. What a year it's going to be. I hope it's a good one. Do you have any resolutions? Yeah, I have plenty. Share each one of them right now. Maybe off air. Yeah. Actually, I was at a Rosh Hashanah meal where Sivan, who is a friend of the pod, she asked everyone to talk about this past year and reflect a little bit. And one of the things that I mentioned was it felt like it was a big year for things that I was just excited about growing. And one of them was Talking Talkless. It was something that like...
This past year, I think we took really seriously. And thank God it's been really an exciting year. And it's exciting to see what next year is going to be like. Yeah, it's very exciting. We have some very interesting guests lined up that I'm very excited for. And of course, suggestions for guests, please keep them coming. Email us, talking.podcast at gmail.com. Because a lot of these guests that we're having came actually from suggestions from all of you. So keep them coming.
Definitely. Well, so Rifki, if you remember all the way last year in episode 84, we talked about Rabbi Gil's student's piece, sort of critiquing 929 and maybe advising people to be aware of what it is. And we talked about that. We referred to that episode to find out more. We got some interesting feedback, as usual. We got one from a friend of the pod, Shlomo. Yeah, so Shlomo said a bunch of interesting things. I'm just going to read a small excerpt. He paraphrased what he heard from Rabbi Chaim Angel, who's a professor of Bible at YU, who was talking about belief and kind of divided thinkers into beliefists and truthists, sort of like people who kind of lean in one direction or the other, sort of like a truthist is someone who needs to find that.
absolute truth right he used the example of like you have to turn over every single rock to get to that truth and Shlomo said something that I thought was pretty interesting he said In all other contexts, most smart people would be skeptical if a teacher was telling you, don't look over there at that stuff. We don't study that perspective on political science that has been analyzed at universities for decades. It doesn't fit with the storyline I'm trying to tell. Students would be like, I'm dubious of this guy. What's he trying to hide? And he was trying to say that in the same way, when we talk about Bible, he thinks he, Shlomo, who's a truthist, believes that it's a little bit dangerous for us to say, okay, so study Bible the way we want to study Bible and just ignore all these other Bible scholars because they're doing it differently and that's dangerous for Yeramuna, which...
feels like it's talking about belief and not about truth. And he thinks that truth is fundamentally what we're looking for. And I think he definitely got to what I was saying. And I think you're kind of also a little bit on this side on this one. I'm on Shlomo's side? Yes, and Rifki's side. No, not actually. Oh, you think Shlomo's wrong? Yeah, well, first of all, what Shlomo pointed out in the private message to us was that he sort of said he's usually on Team Uri on this one. He's totally on Team Rifki, which is like, okay, cool. I think it's a definitive change at this point. I give him credit for that. Well, we'll see moving forward. Welcome, Shlomo. So Rifki, would you consider yourself a truthist? Not a truther, but a truthist. I would absolutely consider myself a truthist. Okay. I mean...
I don't think, I didn't hear the Rabbi Angel speech. I don't think what Rabbi Student was saying is that, hey, don't look over here. There's people over here that we shouldn't, nobody's allowed to see what they say because there's something that we don't want you to know about. I don't think he was quite saying that. And I think there might be some people who say that, but I mean, I don't say that. I don't think Rabbi Student was saying that. But I also think, without getting too deep back into the topic we already talked about last time, last year, I think there are different kinds of truth. And as a modern, postmodern thinker as yourself should agree that the truth is relative in a certain sense. And there are also multiple truths and belief is true and facts are true and archeology is true and criticism is true.
It depends what you choose to focus on, and there's always going to be more out there. I also think that, yeah, he's saying in all other areas of our lives, like maybe in medicine, I'm not sure exactly who's referring to it, history, and, you know, we want to know the full truth and we want to investigate all the facts that are out there. Obviously, belief, by definition, has some elements to it that are beyond our grasp. And at the end of the day, the most knowledgeable scholars in the world still take a leap of faith, I think, whether they choose to believe or not believe in, let's say, the supernatural or things that cannot be proven in the conventional scientific method way. So I think he's missing a little bit of the story there by saying, no, I'm a truthist, and therefore I want to know everything. That's great. And I think it's important to search and to investigate. But that's a lifelong pursuit for thinking people. And in the meantime, you have to live your life. And you have to decide, are you going to follow Judaism, your interpretation of it, without having a complete definitive knowledge of is this true or is this not true? Because I don't think anyone has ever or will ever have that definitive knowledge. That's what belief is.
I agree with you, Ari, and I think that is definitely true. But I think that what Shlomo was, I think, alluding to, and I think, I mean, Shlomo, of course, you know, be in touch if you disagree, is that there's something intellectually honest about saying, look, like, you know, we're stopping here. There is more information out there. There are other people, there are scholars, there are people with doctors in this, there are people who have spent their careers studying this and have written books and articles and essays, and there's a lot of information out there, but like... Let's take a step back from that because that is not quite the direction that we're trying to guide people in right here. And there's something a little bit dangerous about that intellectual dishonesty. And I don't think Shlomo was saying this, but I feel comfortable saying that I don't think that that kind of belief is very good belief. I don't think we want an army or, you know, millions and millions of Orthodox Jews who believe so strongly, but we haven't actually given them all the information and we actually kind of just trying to dissuade them from getting that information. I don't think that's a good thing for religious people. Okay. I mean, obviously it's just a question of emphasis, at least in the discussion, the back and forth that we're having, where I think each of us stand. We're not standing in the same spot. We're just on different points of the continuum of knowledge is important.
truth is important. It's important to know what's out there. How much of your time and your effort and your mental energy should you expend in pursuing the critical elements and angles of tradition and the Torah versus how much should we go the traditional route? I think that's totally true. But I think the sort of danger, and danger is I think too strong a word, but in Rabbi Student's article, which as we discussed, I don't think it was like such an inflammatory article, but I think the danger there of saying like, hey, just be warned, maybe this isn't a great idea for traditional Orthodox Jews, I think is trying to sort of say like, hey, there's more truth out there, but maybe it's not for you. I don't, I don't, my instinct is to say that is not a great thing. I don't think he's saying we have something to hide. He's saying, he's acknowledging that there are difficult things out there. You know, we spoke to Robbie Linzer, he said it's like a inoculation or like a vaccine. Didn't like that either. I know you didn't like that, but I did. He had some of the stuff, know what it is to know what's out there and what people say. That's obviously very important. And I don't think either of them was hiding from that. And I think so. It's a little bit unfair when Shlomo or you or somebody else.
I think may mischaracterize that viewpoint sometimes as saying, well, what are you hiding? I don't think they're hiding anything. And I also wanted to say that my student himself, I thought was very cool of him, posted our episode on his Facebook page. And I'll just quickly read what he said. I don't agree with much of what they say on a variety of topics, but I appreciate that they actually read my words seriously and charitably and did not attribute to me things that I did not say. The first step to disagreeing is understanding what the other person is saying. Thank you for doing that.
Also, I don't blame them for not being regular readers, but those who are know that I quote non-orthodox and Christian biblical commentators frequently. I just don't believe that those who are novices at biblical studies, often encountering the prophets and writings for the first time, should be exposed to non-traditional views. There will be time for that when they are intimately familiar with the primary texts and traditional understandings. So we were talking before, you know, we started recording about like, what exactly does that mean? And some of the background of what he's referring to in his writings. And that's not, my point in bringing that up is just like, I think it was cool of him to listen, to start with a compliment that we, you know, took him seriously and mostly got what he said right in his opinion. And I think obviously that's like...
what real dialogue is about, listening to the other side or other people. And of course it's true that you can't get one person's entire philosophy and nuance and hushkafa just based on one short article, which this was. It was very short, and obviously he's a more complex person than that. I actually have been reading his articles for many years, and I don't read every single one, but I read every headline and the first paragraph of every single one. And he's now actually, there's other people who also publish on the site. But it was an interesting conversation that I actually really enjoyed. I had kind of back and forth with a bunch of listeners after this episode who were interested in talking more about this topic and sort of the limits of orthodox conversation or philosophy.
who we learn from. So it was an exciting thing to find kindred spirits among our listeners. So thank you all so much for being part of that conversation. So Riff, we find ourselves right now in the days in between Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, the 10 days of repentance. And this is obviously the perfect time to talk about repentance and apologies and mistakes and looking back on our actions, other people's actions. And so in that spirit, we want to talk a little bit about some well-known or famous people or apologies from the last year or so and how they were received, what we think about them. I'll also give a shout out to good friend of the pod, David Byshevkin, who we had on back in May. He wrote a book that we spoke about on that episode.
called Sin Agag, Sin and Failure in Jewish Thought. And we had a very interesting discussion with him on our show about that. So he had actually, it was very cool. He had a piece published in the Wall Street Journal this week. He had his book reviewed on tablet. He was on a Tikva podcast, which I also listened to and find very interesting. And that was a great conversation. It's also fun when like something you don't expect just shows up in your feed. And I'm like, hey, I know that voice. And in the book and in these conversations, he also talks about these public apologies. And to start off this conversation, we're going to play a short clip. This is from the great 20th and 21st century poet and philosopher, Sir Paul McCartney. Shalita. Shalita. Admey Vestrim. She'll live and be well. He was on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert.
He told a story that I've actually heard him say a few times in concert, so I guess it's a story that he likes to tell, but I think it's pretty fun and interesting. And relevant for this time of year. Very relevant. I think I like Marvin's best. But, you know, the funny thing about Sinatra, Marvin, and Elvis, they change the words. In the middle, I go, I said something wrong. Now I long for yesterday. All of them said, I must have said something wrong. They're not owning up. I must have said, I don't know. Search me. That's like those apologies that are like, if anyone was offended.
Yeah, exactly. Wow. I must have done something wrong. So Paul's obviously talking about the song yesterday and some of the famous covers of it. And then Stephen brings it right home to our topic of these public figures who just can't get all the way there. Even when they're apologizing, they can't seem a lot of times to really fully do it. I actually had an incident. I definitely don't want to go into the details, but an incident with a close friend a few weeks ago where I told her how much she had done hurt me. And basically her response was, I'm really sorry that that hurt you. And it felt like...
It felt like such a classic example of feeling so unheard, where it was not like, I understand why that hurt you, and here, let's talk about the next steps, and let's talk about repairing. It was just like, I'm sorry that you experienced that. Did you point that out? Maybe not as articulately as I could have. That's something that I can apologize for. You noticed that. Yeah, and I think that's, and I want to also be clear, I've done the same thing, right? It's very hard, especially when you feel like,
look, I didn't exactly do something wrong. Like, okay, maybe I could have been a little bit better, but it's not like what I did was so bad. Like there's a little bit of fault. You know, there has to be a little give and take here. It's very easy to sort of like disassociate. And I think that what I think he's pointing out very well is that our responsibility is not to disassociate. It doesn't matter if the other person could have addressed things differently or could have reacted differently or is being too, too rushing to blame, even if it's only 40% your fault. It's still sort of on you or on me to take that 40%. Right. Yeah. I mean, I think apologizing, we're going to see with some of these examples, it can be a really good feeling. Like it's almost like something that people can overdo of like,
Oh, we all love each other. I'm so sorry. No, I'm more sorry than you are. No, I'm more sorry. You know, and overall, I mean, I think that's nice. That's okay. That's not like the worst thing. But like, it could be a really good feeling when you connect with somebody that you had, you know, connections with. And before we get to that example, I just want to do one more thing from Colbert on his old show on the Colbert Report, which I personally think was much better than his current one. Just it was more out there, more creative. Very different style. Very different style. He used to have a thing. Did you used to watch the show?
Occasionally, not regularly. He had a thing for a number of years in a row during this time of year called the atonophone. Are you familiar with that? No, that's amazing. So he had a lot of Jewish references. He himself is raised Catholic, but he seems to be an ohiv Yisrael, I would say. And there's certain elements of Judaism that he loves. And he also poked fun at things, I think, in a loving way. And in the days of repentance, days of awe, he would have this thing called the atonophone where it was obviously staged, but Jewish celebrities would basically call up the phone and apologize to him on the air for things that they had done. So I want to play a short clip from that. So this is from September 17th, 2012.
Welcome back, everybody. Thank you so much. Mason, please. Mason, yesterday was the beginning of the Jewish New Year, or... The Jewish New Year is just like the regular New Year, only instead of waking up the next morning filled with regret, you go to bed filled with it. And I'd like to honor my Jewish viewers by blowing the traditional shofar. That's not bad. He's amazing. He really is.
Dead ram. Folks, Rosh Hashanah is the start of what is known as the Days of Repentance, which ends on the Holy Day of Yom Kippur, which is when the Jewish baby New Year is circumcised by that old moil with a scythe. Oh, children of Israel, once again, I look forward to your apologies to me. That's why I am once again offering my Atone Phone hotline. If you're Jewish and you gave me surus during the year 5772, just pick up the phone before Yom Kippur and dial 1-888-667-7539. That's 1-888-OOPS-JU. Wow, the calls are started. It's coming already. Shalom, how have you wronged me? Ira Glass, host of Public Radio's This American Life. I recognized your voice because I had the sudden urge to pledge $50 for a Doctor Who fanny pack. So, Ira, what's your apology?
Well, Stephen, I apologize for never having you on This American Life. Yes. So tonight, my apology to Stephen Colbert, fact one, the apology, fact two, you forgive me. Well, of course I forgive you, Ira. Oh, thank you, Stephen. I really come to realize that if anybody should be a guest on This American Life, it's you because you are America. I learned it from watching your show. Thank you. I watch your show, too. So my show is on the radio. Of course it is. I turn the sound down and I watch my radio.
So that was Ira Glassos of This American Life, our colleague, I guess you could say. We have a podcast. I just think it's very cute of Colbert to do that every year with different people. Honestly, I think it was also like a big kid of Hashem. It made Jews look really good because he's saying part of our tradition is...
we have to apologize to people, which is true and is so important. And I think that's something that everybody can agree to. And he's highlighting that, which I thought was very cool. Yeah, I agree. I do think that's really cool. And I think what's so essential to apologizing, and I mean, we talked about this before, obviously, we always talk often about, you know, people make good apologies, bad apologies, what makes a good apology. But in Rambam Maimonides' laws of chuva, laws of repentance, which is what basically, generally, when we think about chuva, when we think about repentance, we go back to his framework. And the way that Maimonides set it up is that there's a several fold process in which you first have to go through this sort of like introspective analysis of sort of like really recognizing what you did that was wrong.
If you haven't gone through that internal process, the apology doesn't mean anything. You actually have to change, which is something that I think about often in public apologies where there's often this sense of emptiness because it feels like they're performing an apology and not really going through any sort of sense of change. Not really trying to become a better person through it. Just more sort of like, okay, the public needs me to apologize or else I can't, you know, keep my job at this TV show, right? Or I can't keep my job in the Senate. And that's hard to know a lot of times also. That's definitely true. But it's not a great feeling when it doesn't. But Ira Glass obviously went through a serious, you know, introspective, you know, experience. Okay, so what's one that you want to bring up?
So this past Shabbat in synagogue, I was at the Fort Ryan Jewish Center, and Rabbi Guy Austrian, who's the rabbi there, he's a very good speaker. I've only started going to that synagogue in the past few months, and I really, really, really enjoy his speaking. That's a big part of why I like going there. And this past week, he gave a really, really powerful speech where he talked about chuba repentance. And I just want to quote a piece from the beginning of his drusher that I thought was really powerful. He opens up by saying, okay, he's going to be talking about politics, but he kind of warns us, you know, it's not really about politics. And then he goes into a story.
With a hurricane developing in the Caribbean, it seems that at some point the president had seen some complicated weather maps with some kinds of lines that radiated across the southeastern U.S. A few days later, he urged people to stay safe in Florida, Georgia, South Carolina, and Alabama. But it turned out that Alabama was not going to feel any effects. So the Alabama office of the National Weather Service issued a quick clarification on Twitter. That could have been it. He could have just said, oh, good, glad to hear that. I misspoke. Or even, I misunderstood the maps from a few days ago. Alabama, lucky you. Florida, Georgia, South Carolina, we're rooting for you.
But the president insisted he had been right all along. He got his White House chief of staff to direct the Secretary of Commerce, to direct the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, to issue a public statement criticizing the Alabama office and saying that the president was right. He even took a Sharpie to modify a weather map that he displayed in a press conference in the Oval Office to make it look like the hurricane's path would in fact reach Alabama. At this point, a small mistake had become a major incident. But it's an important principle that when we see people doing something wrong, it's not for us to look at and laugh. Rather, it's meant to help us recognize that behavior in ourselves.
So I'm raising this episode not to criticize the president, but because it was such a tremendous public example of our own behavior. I actually felt bad for him. It was all so avoidable. What was happening to the president was something so simple, so common, so human. He just didn't want to admit that he had made a mistake. And we should recognize that reluctance in ourselves. So Uri, when I was listening to this, I felt like so seen in like a bad way. Like it felt like that. You know what happens sometimes where you're in an argument with someone and you kind of come to a point where you're like, oh, I kind of hear what you're saying.
It's very hard, at least for me. I don't want to speak for anyone else. It's very, very hard for me to sort of stop and say, you know what? I didn't think about it that way. I kind of hear what you're saying, and now I need to think about this more because I think maybe I'm wrong. And what I thought was so powerful about what Rabbi Guy was doing here was he's bringing this example not to make fun of President Trump, though honestly, it was a room full of people that probably was...
were very primed for that and would have laughed at any making fun of Trump joke. He was saying, it doesn't matter whether you like Trump or not. What he did, exactly. What he did is something that you do and that I do and that all of us experience and make that same mistake every single day in all of our interpersonal relationships. And I thought that was really powerful. Yeah, that is very powerful. I mean, just to be fair, I want to just now play a compilation of all the apologies that Trump has made since taking office. They're probably really powerful. Wait for it. No, I'm just kidding. That was good. He made that apology for the Access Hollywood tape, but then since then has said, actually, that's not my voice. Right, so.
When we talk about apology and it's about, you know, changing oneself. I don't know if he's the person that we should be looking to for learning lessons. Well, we can learn lessons about our own failures. But yeah, he is the failure example. But what do you think? Are there any other examples that we should turn to here? Yeah, I think there was a really interesting one that took place on Saturday Night Live last November. So it was during the Weekend Update segment. And Pete Davidson, one of the cast members, was kind of giving a rundown on some of the newly elected congresspeople and just, you know, giving out some short quips and jokes at their expense. This guy's kind of cool. Dan Crenshaw.
Oh, come on, man. Yo, hold on. You may be surprised to hear he's a congressional candidate from Texas and not a hitman in a porno movie. I'm sorry. I know he lost his eye in war or whatever.
This is why I actually don't like him. I think his humor is so immature. Okay, I mean, to be honest, in the realm of, like, jokes that go too far, I actually didn't think that one was so terrible. Just to be clear, Dan Crenshaw is a veteran of the U.S. Armed Forces. He served in Afghanistan. He was a Navy SEAL. And he was injured and lost one of his eyes. And because of the type of injury, he has to wear an eye patch. He can't have, like, a prosthetic eye. And so Pete Davis was making fun of his eye patch. Right.
But it's the same immaturity of comedians in general who make fun of looks, who make fun of like, oh, this guy is fat. Obviously, people are very sensitive to veterans, injured veterans. It's a very sensitive topic. I think Pete Davidson, people often think he has a little bit more leeway with these things because his dad died in 9-11 and he makes 9-11 jokes all the time. And he's allowed to, quote unquote, because his dad died in 9-11, which is a very interesting concept in itself. Like if the thing applies to you, are you allowed to then? It's like he's making Holocaust jokes. So here's a clip from the following week on SNL during Weekend Update. Well, last week, Pete Davidson did a feature here on Weekend Update that caused some controversy. Here to set the record straight is Pete Davidson.
And what I'm sure was a huge shock for people who know me, I made a poor choice last week. No, I did. I made a joke about Lieutenant Commander Dan Crenshaw. Dan? Dan Crenshaw. And on behalf of the show and myself, I apologize. My poor mom. Can you imagine being my mom? That must suck. Can you imagine being Pete Davidson's mom? It can't be easy when everyone's mad at your son and roommate.
No, but I mean this from the bottom of my heart. It was a poor choice of words. The man is a war hero He deserves all the respect in the world and if any good came with this Maybe it was that for one day the left and the right finally came together to agree on something that I'm a dick You think? So now Dan Crenshaw rolls up to the desk and he's there next to Pete Thank you so much for coming. Thanks for making a Republican look good. You gotta stop saying that, man. You've been saying it all day. Please. Look, I just wanted to say, for people that don't know, the reason you're wearing an eye patch right now is that you lost your eye to an IED in Afghanistan during your third combat tour. And I'm sorry. Thank you, Pete. I appreciate you saying that. So we good? We're good. Apology accepted. It's Ariana Grande. The joke is that Pete Davidson was engaged there and they broke their engagement. Big break up.
So again to be honest I didn't think the original thing he said was that bad in the context of he's making a joke it's a stupid joke it's not that funny but that's what comedians do but the fact that they apologize in such a public way I thought was really beautiful and things like that is sort of what I was alluding to before like that makes apologies cool And Dan Crenshaw came out looking great. Pete Davidson came out looking great. And then more or less. Better. And I think if there's, I mean, there are examples like that. My fear was that Pete Davidson was going to stop after saying it was uncool. I'm sorry. And then just stop there. And I thought that I was like, that felt very weak to me. But I think what made the apology, if I could just break it down a little bit, tell me if you agree. I think what made it so powerful is he kind of said like exactly why it was so inappropriate. Like the reason that he has looks that someone could even make a dumb joke about. And I think that's what's so critical about it. And yeah, they did it in kind of like, you know, a funny bantery kind of way. And Ariana Grande said that I think it's great. But I think that to me feels like.
the essence of what makes such a critical apology. Just to conclude this discussion, there's other examples that we had that, you know, maybe we can include some more links to some of these public apologies. I want to flip the conversation a little bit and maybe ask you, Rifki, to start off. Do you think there are times where we should not apologize or where apologizing could be detrimental? I mean, not to get too deep into that, but just broadly speaking. My instinct is no, because I'm an extreme person and I...
genuinely believe that apologies are the key to recognizing our own flaws and that's how we can change and that's how we can make our relationships better and that's ultimately going to be a good thing. Obviously, I'm open to, you know, examples in particular where, you know, it actually would hurt relationships or would actually hurt people. But overall, I don't really think so. Like overall, if I don't think I did anything wrong, I shouldn't apologize because it's a bad apology. But I think ultimately, things are always more complicated than you are 100% wrong and I am 100% right and therefore I shouldn't apologize. Even if you're only 2% wrong, I think you should apologize. I think it's a good thing for you and for the other person. Well, here's a couple of things. One I think you'll probably be more sympathetic to.
be less sympathetic you don't know me i'm guessing judging you okay the first one is you know there's a thing that people say like a more feminist kind of thing is that women tend to over apologize when they haven't done anything like you know you bump into somebody on the subway they bumped into you but then the person it could be a woman i do this also whatever but i don't think it's just women like oh i'm sorry you know you didn't whatever and then so that's like a movement or a thing that people say like don't be conscious not to apologize when you didn't do anything it's about standing up for yourself being confident in yourself and your self-image so i mean what are your thoughts on that so there are a couple things that i think go along with that like um especially for women there's been a movement you know quote unquote of saying of taking um apologies out of emails like oh sorry i'm responding late or you know i think maybe the answer is this like be more assertive you know make stronger affirmative statements you know things like that um because i think that's more masculine and therefore perceived as more strong i actually really Don't like it. I don't like receiving emails that make very strong statements that I think like, wait, that's not true. Like it's a little bit more complicated than that. And I like it when people bump into each other and everyone's instinct is to apologize. I think that's a good thing. I think that men could stand to be a lot more like women. I mean, obviously you're right that it's definitely not only men or not only women. But I think in general, the movement to be a little bit more sensitive to everyone around us, maybe even to a fault, is a good thing. What do you think about that? I totally, I respect that. I agree with that. And I like that you are consistent in that way. And you did not fall into my trap. Congratulations. The other thing I just wanted to bring up briefly is actually over Shabbos. This is a good time to do a segment that we do every week.
week. It's called, did you read it? Did you read the New York Times? Yes. New York Observer? Yes. Washington Post? Yes. Wall Street Journal? Yes. Did you read that steampunk article in Boing Boy? I did not like the end of it. So this past August, I read Barry Weiss's new book called How to Fight Anti-Semitism. It's a pretty interesting book. She kind of critiques anti-Semitism from the left, from the right, and radical Islam. Those are kind of her three categories. But then at the end, the book is called How to Fight Anti-Semitism. At the very end, she actually gets to how to fight it instead of just describing what it is. And she quotes somebody who I actually admire greatly. His name is Zev Magain. And he wrote a book called John Lennon and the Jews, which I really love. Who's John Lennon? He was another great 20th century philosopher and thinker and poet. So.
She actually quotes an earlier essay that Zev Magin wrote when he, I think, was a student at Columbia. And his basic thesis of that paper, which she latches onto, is when there's anti-Semitism and there's critique of Israel that delegitimizes Israel or calls Jews Nazis and stuff like that, our response to that should not be to hold up signs and do a protest. No, we are not Nazis. We are not Nazis. And the analogy that he gives that she quotes is like, if somebody accuses you of being a pig, are you going to go back to them and say, no, actually, I'm a human being. I'm not a pig. Like, no, certain things don't deserve a response and shouldn't be responded to from a defensive, apologetic place. And his...
problem is that he feels many times Jews or Israel supporters are way too defensive and too apologetic in their defense of Israel. And he says instead, and Barry Weiss kind of echoes this, is like, your response to that should be to be a proud Jew, to be Jewish, to be more Jewish, to wear a kippah in public, to whatever it is. And I thought that was interesting. It also reminded me of that ad a few years ago put out by Naftali Bennett, the Israeli politician. And the theme of the ad is Mufsi Kimlehid Natsal, no more apologizing. And he was basically saying Israel has to stop apologizing to the world for existing.
I think people who liked Paul Bennett thought that was awesome, and people who don't like him thought it was terrible. But I think it's another— And how many votes did he get in the— Well, he didn't do so well this past time. But I think that's just something also just to think about. And, you know, I'll be curious of your thoughts. And, like, sometimes apologizing—you know, Trump takes this to the extreme. He thinks apologizing is a sign of weakness, I'm assuming, and therefore he will never do it.
for the most part. And there might be some truth to that, is what I'm saying I am gathering from some of these examples. So I didn't read the book, and I'm interested in doing it, but just to respond to that particular thing, and not to respond, I'm sure the book is obviously more complex than this, but what I'm hearing there that makes me a little bit uncomfortable is her saying, hey, people are coming at us with no nuance. They're saying X. They're saying Y. They're saying Z. They're saying Israel is Nazis. They're saying Jews are X. Those people are obviously ridiculous, and they have no nuance, so therefore we should respond with no nuance, and we should not even pretend like there's a nugget of anything that they're saying that has value there. I don't think that that's a healthy approach, and I don't think it's a right approach. I don't think it's healthy from a political perspective, but also from an internal perspective, because then it stops.
Stops us from actually listening and actually making any sort of change. You know, Barry Weiss, right? So she has a column in the New York Times. She's mostly center-right, but obviously is a more nuanced and complex person. I think center is a fair assessment. Okay. New York Times opinion writers, she's center-right. How about that? But I think what would be much more productive is if in her column she said, okay, this is what people are saying. They're saying X and they're saying Y and they're saying Z. Those things are ridiculous. And I'm not even going to address whether Israel is Nazis because they're obviously not Nazis. But here is...
actually something to address. Here is a real issue. Here are the things that actually are a little bit more complicated than that. And I think we should be talking about those issues. Those initial things, those are ridiculous. But let's talk about the things that actually are worth discussing. I think that would be much more productive. I don't disagree. And I don't know if Barry Weiss would disagree because I think maybe what she's saying is when the people on the other side are saying these like really black and white inflammatory statements, let's not respond with nuance to them. But then when other people are criticizing from a more balanced, nuanced place, then let's give the nuanced, balanced criticism to those people. Well, yeah. If I run at you and start screaming, you know, ur is a pig, ur is a pig, ur is a pig, it's true that you shouldn't be like,
all right, let's talk this through. But also, you shouldn't stand up with a placard. Holocaust deniers, a lot of people will say, should not get a platform. Let's not engage with them. Let's engage with people who actually want to talk about the influence of the Holocaust and how it affects the Israeli mentality, maybe, and the IDF. Those are all, let's say, legitimate conversations that should be had, but certain conversations, certain accusations against Jews and Israel do not deserve a nuanced response. So, I don't want to dive too deeply into this topic, but I'm just thinking specifically about what you just said about, like,
about Trump, about sort of like the power, sort of like, oh, apologies are for weak people. And I was thinking about how with Justice Brett Kavanaugh, when he was trying to go through his confirmation process and when all of these things were coming out and when they had this whole... This is like the one-year anniversary of that. Right, right, right. I think it was just a bit over a year ago. One of the things that people said is that they were advising him, Trump doesn't like weakness. You cannot show any weakness. And in his hearings, when they were grilling him about Professor Blasey Ford, Dr. Blasey Ford, and the testimony that she had just given about the sexual assault that she claimed that he had done to her, he was...
So incredible. Did you watch it? He didn't want to give an inch. It was very clear. Right. It was like... Either because it didn't happen or he chose to not give an inch. Right. But what I found so striking about that was whether it happened or not, he had no... Right. He didn't show any empathy of like, look, this isn't something that I did. But you're right that there was a really problematic culture. Or it's something that happens a lot and it's a terrible thing. Nothing like that. There was no sense at all. And again...
These things are never zero, 100, right? So there was no sense like, no, maybe I was 1%, maybe I was 20%, maybe I was 40%, but here's how I've changed, here's how I've grown, here's why I'm different, here's why I still should be on the Supreme Court. There was no sense of that. And apparently, you know, the news basically all reported the next day that Trump loved it, right? Trump thought like, oh my God, this guy's a fighter, this guy's a winner. And there was no sense of humility at all being something we should strive for in our leaders. Okay, I mean, I hear what you're saying. At that point, he had no reason to suck up to Trump because it's a lifetime appointment and it was out of Trump's hands. No, Trump could have pulled him. Not at that point? Yeah, good. During the hearing? Yeah. Okay, I mean, I don't think that would have been likely. He was going to a vote in the Senate.
Okay, well, anyway, I hear what you're saying, and that's a fair point. Sweet. So there are so many more examples. You know, we each were coming up in preparation for the show about a bunch of public examples and private examples that we thought were particularly important, either because they were amazing or because they were lacking in some way. And, you know, Talking Talkless, it's interesting, like, just a peek into what happens inside. After every episode, we're always kind of, like, racked with this sort of, like, I don't think I was fair to this person. And, you know, stuff like that. And I think that's something that we always strive for. And I hope we're getting better. Maybe we're not. Maybe you're getting better and I'm getting worse. But if there are things that you guys think about, please, please, please be in touch with us at TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com.
And of course, join the conversation on our Facebook page, Talking Talkless Podcast. Last but not least, please subscribe to our podcast on iTunes, Stitcher, SoundCloud, whatever you still listen to podcasts. And of course, please rate and review us in the iTunes store. Thanks as always to Drive-In Productions. They continue to be our sponsor going into this new year. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are still the official band of Talking Talkless. Bye, everyone. Bye.