Hello and welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rifki. And you're listening to Talking Talkless, the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. So Rifki, last time we spoke about alcohol and LSD and other drugs in Judaism, kind of a juicy topic. Did you get any feedback? Yeah, this was exciting. We got a lot of interesting feedback on it. I think it was kind of an interesting conversation because I'm kind of like rigid. I'm a rural person. So I'm really, really not into this stuff, but I...
definitely don't believe in the way that society and, you know, often religion has approached it. But there was a larger conversation that we started in the podcast and that other people chimed in on in emails and in continuing conversation that the Jewish tradition seems to be a lot more flexible with things like this than we had thought. And it was kind of cool to see all those different approaches and see how they really changed at least my perception. Right. I think on this topic, like many other topics, Jewish tradition and texts are very broad and rich in their content and their different opinions and ways of seeing an issue. So if you're looking to permit and encourage substance use, you'll definitely find things. And if you're looking to prohibit it, you will also find...
Yeah, I think in thinking and discussing our episode with other people, I think one of the things that struck people a little bit was less about whether something is permitted or not, but how to best approach it. So the CRC letter, I think, seemed to be universally understood to be not a great way to approach the conversation, but the idea that you should approach something like this, especially because of the varied history and texts and the different traditions and their way of approaching it, that you should be able to approach it with complexity and seeing it as something a little bit more complicated than getaway. Right. Well, you can look at our Facebook page. We had some interesting discussions and comments there. I think there's also a couple of articles that people posted that I found very interesting. And so you can check that out for further reading.
And I said, no, no, no, no, I don't smoke it no more. I'm tired of waking up on the floor. No, thank you, please. It only makes me sneeze. Then it makes it hard to find the door.
This past Sunday marked the one-year anniversary of the mass shooting in Pittsburgh, in which a right-wing gunman entered the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and killed 11 people and injured six more. Now, one year later, there have been a number of articles and think pieces published about the anniversary with different angles. We mentioned before on the pod the columnist for the New York Times, Barry Weiss. She's a relatively right-wing columnist for the Times and a native of the Pittsburgh Jewish community. And her new book, How to Fight Antisemitism, was actually prompted by the events in Pittsburgh. Zach Beecham, a reporter for Vox who actually got married literally on the day of the killing last year, he wrote a sort of article, a sort of reflection about being Jewish one year later.
It's kind of long, but I don't want to take any of this out of context, so I'm going to quote it directly. He wrote, My conversations with Jewish leaders, scholars, and citizens reveal that many of us have been shaken to our core by these events. Traumatized by a long history of persecution, Jews are acutely aware of how vulnerable we are, given our tiny numbers. We are not close to abandoning America, but we are closer to feeling like America could abandon us. But this fear is coupled with a renewed sense of Jewish purpose and identity, a sense of threat serving not to quiet Jews but galvanize them.
In my experience, the Jews most unsettled by the year of anti-Semitic carnage have grown closer to their community as a result, becoming even more committed to their Jewish identity than they were before. The American Jewish community is hardly monolithic, and as such, this revival has taken many forms. I'm inspired by the surge in activists uniting Jewish causes with those of other marginalized American groups, a callback to the civil rights era that connects Jews not only with each other, but other communities threatened by the rise of the violent far right. I've also been frustrated... with the vocal efforts by some Jews to use the post-Pittsburgh moment to push hardline defenses of Israel, or to paint a false equivalence between anti-Semitism on the American left and right. But these divergent reactions, along with many others, speak to something deeper and unequivocally good, a growing consensus on the importance of asserting oneself as a Jew in personal and public life. We are in the midst of an acute re-emergence of the American Jewish self-understanding as a minority, with all the sense of insecurity and collective purpose that status entails.
At this moment, there is a core sentiment uniting anti-Zionist leftists in Brooklyn with ultra-Orthodox Trump supporters in Brooklyn. We may be scared by the rise in anti-Semitism, worried for our communities and families in a way we've never been before, but we'll be damned if we let it scare us out of being Jews. That's the end of the quote. And of course, we urge you to read the article in its entirety. It's on Vox, and of course, we'll put a link to it.
And, of course, Uri, recent violence perpetrated against Jews in America didn't start in Pittsburgh, and it hasn't ended with Pittsburgh either. Of course, there was also a shooting in the Chabad of Poway, California, and in the last year, we've continued to see violent acts perpetrated against Jews. We've seen videos, and the media has been publishing about visibly Orthodox Jews being attacked and beaten in Brooklyn, sometimes incredibly violently. Dr. Deborah Lipstadt, a professor of religion and Holocaust studies at Emory University in Atlanta, also published an important piece in the foreword about anti-Semitism today. She noted that though anti-Semitism feels like it's on the rise, there's a danger to us using anti-Semitism as a fuel for Jewish identity, which is kind of exactly what...
Bicham was saying. He was saying that it does feel like antisemitism is linked, in his mind, to Jewish identity. And that's a positive development. Right. I don't know if he was saying positive, but I think he was saying like... He was saying, I feel much more Jewish now and I'm expressing that Judaism because of the antisemitism. Right. She argues, Dr. Lipstadt, that the Jewish identity must come from a positive place of love, not of fear. Or, as she says, we should not be, quote, motivated by the oy of Jewish life. We should be motivated by the joy. So, Uri, there's a lot to talk about. Let's just talk about a few of the difficult related issues for this topic. One.
Beecham wasn't using data or evidence to back up that this is how American Jews feel overall, but he did speak to many leaders in the Jewish community, and my sense from seeing his article being posted and reposted all over social media, it seems to resonate, at least in my little bubble. What do you think? Did it resonate with you? Two, related, do you see or feel any changes one year after Pittsburgh? Do you feel differently when you're in synagogue? Do you feel differently about being visibly Jewish? In the past, we've spoken about wearing a kippo, wearing a hat, what that looks like. Does it feel any different after Pittsburgh, after Poway? Do you feel like this changes the way you or others even think about Aliyah or think about Israel as a safe haven? Three.
It seems like a lot of people are speaking past each other. A lot of people on the left seem to think that we need to focus on right-wing anti-Semitism, like the marchers in Charlottesville who were shouting Jews will not replace us, or obviously the Pittsburgh shooter. At the same time, people on the right seem to think that we need to focus on left-wing anti-Semitism, which they see is a much worse, growing, more dangerous movement, like the often intense hatred for Israel among the far left. Do you think that's a fair characterization? Do you see one as a bigger issue? And lastly, what do you think of Deborah Lipstadt's argument? Is there room for fear or negativity in Jewish life or in Jewish community, or do you agree that we have to focus on the positive? I know there's a lot, Uri.
Take whatever you want. All great questions. And something that we've tried to get better at is to address all the questions that we raise. Sometimes we're not so good at that. So let's start from the beginning. The first two questions you asked were about like, do I or people around me seem to feel more scared as Jews? And has this had like a noticeable effect on our communities? Yeah. Also, I didn't address this, but one of the things that I would be curious to hear your take on is if you think that this is any different at all in the Orthodox community versus the non-Orthodox community. Because Beachum, I don't think affiliates as part. I think he talks about his reform synagogue. Yeah. So I would say because the Pittsburgh shooting happened in a synagogue.
I mean, there was already a lot of security in many synagogues. And after last year, that's gone up through the roof, I think. And so now you can't walk into a synagogue anywhere in America that I've seen without seeing guards, without seeing security measures that were not there one year ago, five years ago, 10 years ago. And so if you go to shul every week and every time you go in, you see growing levels of security, you can't not see that and not think about being safe or being unsafe and feeling safe. You know, so I definitely would say that it's on my mind now more than it has been in the past. That being said, it's interesting that you ask about Orthodox versus non-Orthodox. From what I've seen, and you can tell me if you disagree.
Most of the articles or statements that I've read and heard of people saying like, I no longer feel safe presenting as Jewish in public or walking down the street as Jewish. It's almost always non-Orthodox Jews who are saying things like that. And Jews who like grew up or are like, let's say Orthodox and they wear kippahs or black hats or whatever. I haven't heard any of those people say, I no longer feel safe wearing my kippah. I no longer feel safe wearing my black hat. It's more like people who used to wear a Jewish star or something like that now will no longer wear it. And I'm not exactly sure what to make of that. I think it might have something to do with politics. Maybe we'll get into that a little more in the conversation later on.
But in terms of just like being Jewish, going to Jewish events, school, whatever, I don't know if we're at the point yet that people are scared, as opposed to in Europe, where I think it's a completely different story. I don't think we're anywhere close to that. I'll tell you an interesting story. I'll decide if it's interesting. Okay, so Mount Sinai, shul, synagogue in Washington Heights, where I used to go to, and I think you still do sometimes at least. So a few years ago, this was probably four, five years ago.
one of our friends who's a veteran of the Israeli army organized a kind of like community security watch at shul. There hadn't been any official security up to that point. And he put together like a group of volunteers as men and women. Many of the men who volunteered were also veterans of the IDF, including myself. None of the women? I know that there were women who did it. I don't know if any of them served in the IDF. But anyway, we spoke to Rabbi Schwartz and he said like- Who had been the rabbi. Who was the rabbi of the shul, right? And he said- We talked about him stepping down in an earlier episode. So he approved of the security.
measures but like you said we can't have phones we obviously no guns licenses but basically we stood there and uh you know in shifts and stuff and there was protocol locking the doors there's a phone right inside whatever somebody um more than one person one person in particular that i'm thinking of um was like we were talking about this and they were very uncomfortable with it because they said things like that people standing outside and like we would wear sunglasses because like you know try to look like a security yeah more professional a little more intimidating and for various things the sunglasses other things just the very presence of people standing out there this person i was speaking to had a problem with it not because they didn't think safety was an issue but because kind of what you were getting at in the later question about, like, having the anti-Semitism constantly on our minds, like, they're always out to get us, this person thought was a dangerous... Like how that could affect the psyche of the people who are walking into synagogue. Exactly, exactly. And I guess they're weighing the balance of, like, yes, there is obviously some level of risk, but is that level of risk worth putting this idea further into people's heads that we are all in danger and everybody's out to get us? I just think it's interesting that...
That person, I don't think, would say anything like that now. And this was only a few years ago because of Pittsburgh. But I'm just putting that out there as an anecdote. That is interesting. I was also, I thought you were different. Yeah. Rabbi Schwartz at the time, a few years ago, when this was coming together, there were certain limitations, as you mentioned, that people weren't, you weren't allowed to have phones. There wasn't allowed to be anything like, you know, no earpieces or, you know, things like that. And I wonder, and that was because those things, obviously, on Shabbat are a little bit more complicated. He didn't think the risk warranted. And I wonder if he, I mean, he's not the rabbi today, so he doesn't have to make this difficult call. But I wonder if today he would still make the same assessment after the more recent things have happened.
Rabbi Shorts, if you're listening, we'd love to hear from you because I actually am pretty curious about that. So it sounds like you're thinking that it hasn't really affected the way you think or the way people who often have seen themselves visually as a, not a target exactly, but they've always seen themselves visually as different. You don't think it's really affecting that population in the same way because maybe because they've always felt themselves to be outside. It's like, what do you think it is? Like, why do you think it would be that people who, let's, you know, to generalize, why would people who are members of reform synagogues suddenly feel more nervous and people who are members of Orthodox synagogues wouldn't feel as starkly like things have changed? That's interesting. What you just brought up was kind of interesting. I think.
I can't speak to non-Orthodox day school education or Sunday school, but I know in our upbringing, we both went to the same elementary school. Anti-Semitism was spoken about a lot. And so I think we did grow up thinking there are people out there who don't like us and want to hurt us. We had a very intense Holocaust curriculum in sixth grade. So that was definitely always something that we were familiar with. But I think non-Orthodox Jews are aware of anti-Semitism. But I think another interesting side of it might be that I think in the last few years, because of the rise of intersectionality and various ideas and movements, let's say within the left-wing political camp, there's been a lot more...
focus on oppressed peoples, oppressed minorities, oppression in general, power. And I think this is a very crude way of saying it, but being oppressed has become very cool in a certain kind of twisted way. And I think a lot of Jews who didn't previously identify with being victims and feeling anti-Semitism, I think now because of that change, that shift in the culture combined with the presidency of Donald Trump, which many people and many Jews find extremely disturbing, I think that all kind of combines into a mix of like, We are persecuted. Our president is a white supremacist. We're under attack. And that's generally not the way Orthodox Jews affiliate. And so they're not saying those kind of things. That's obviously a broad generalization, but that's my take on it. Okay, yeah. So wait, I just want to see if I can follow it. So you're saying that, and I don't necessarily even disagree. I'm just trying to make sure I have a handle on it. So you're saying that maybe there's something in the emergence of this sort of like power dynamic in which people don't, no one wants to be the powerful one, right? No one wants to say, I am the rich white man. So there's something to a shifting dynamic in which minority groups, whether they're racial minority groups or they're religious minority groups.
that feel a sense of oppression there's a sense of not only solidarity between them but a way of marking to themselves hey you're not part of that powerful mean group you are part of that oppressed minority group and that way and Jews first of all because there's a tension in Jews in that they are not the same as many other minority groups, right? They obviously visually generally look a little bit whiter. They generally have a little bit more money and integrate more into the upper echelons of society. Jews don't still, because of their general liberal tendencies and for other various reasons, they want to affiliate with the minority groups more. And this is a way for them to sort of do that, especially with the rise, I don't know about numbers wise, but definitely in our media and in prominence of the far right that has often come along with Donald Trump, even though he wouldn't say that, you know, he...
wants to stick with them, but, you know, the far-right has gained a lot more media attention. Right, exactly. Is that the argument that you're making? I think that's basically what I'm saying, and that's, I think, maybe a good transition to the next question on the list. See, we're going to get them. Yeah, and it's something left to right. I mean, just, like, a brief thing about Jewish people and whiteness. You know, I think we've spoke about this on the podcast before, and it's something that comes up a lot these days. But, you know, in Nazi Germany, and now, still, among, like, neo-Nazis, Jews are not white. Jews are Middle Eastern. Jews are whatever they are, according to those people. And on the left, Jews are not only white, but the ultimate.
whites. Jews exemplify whiteness because of the power, because of physically the way they present, which is obviously very Ashkenormative, but that's how a lot of them see it. I never actually heard that. The Jews are the ultimate white people. That's basically like a Louis Farrakhan kind of thing, where they blame slavery on Jews. They overemphasize the Jewish involvement in the slave trade and basically say that all the problems that we credit to white people actually originate with Jews, which means Jews are the ultimate white people. You can't win, obviously, being Jewish, but that's just the reality of where we are. So Rivki, in terms of your question from the introduction of...
anti-Semitism from the left and from the right, and which one is worse, and do people on the left acknowledge the other one and vice versa. My perspective, and the way I see the discussion happening, is that people who, let's say, for the sake of this argument, are more on the right, like the Barry Weiss, and Deborah Lipset, I don't even know her political affiliations, but the way she starts off her forward article by saying there's anti-Semitism on the left and on the right, and they're both dangerous, and we have to address it. And Barry Weiss says very similar things. Right, I mean, her different chapters are about left-wing anti-Semitism. Right, she has a chapter about anti-Semitism on the left and on the right. So I don't really see people on the right, at least the kind of people that we're talking about, I don't see any of them denying.
or not addressing right-wing anti-Semitism. I mean, it's almost impossible to do that because the perpetrator of the Pittsburgh shooting was clearly a white nationalist and he murdered 11 people. You can't, obviously, that's a very huge danger. Even like the term, like, neo-Nazi. Like, the Nazis. You can't be like, eh, they're not anti-Semitic. Of course they are. Yeah, I mean, neo-Nazi, white supremacism, and anti-Semitism, it's synonymous. However, I think when it comes to people more on the left, like Zach Beecham, I think there is a blind spot to left-wing anti-Semitism. So Beecham says in his article how he's uncomfortable that the response to some of these attacks are support for what he calls...
hardline defenses of Israel and people who paint a false equivalence between antisemitism on the American left and right. So in his article, all he addresses is right-wing antisemitism. He doesn't give any specific examples of left-wing antisemitism. He doesn't say explicitly that it doesn't exist, but he very much addresses the right-wing antisemitism. And he says, it bothers me that people want to equate left and right antisemitism because they're not equal. Okay. I think the problem there is that he's not acknowledging a very real element of antisemitism. And he's sort of sidestepping it by saying, because they're not equal, therefore, I'm not going to address it in so many words. And what's even more problematic for me is when he actually gives the examples of
What do I mean when I say there's rising anti-Semitism? So obviously the first example are there's two shootings in the synagogues in the last year. And those are obviously perpetrated by white nationalist right-wing types. Okay. But then he says there's been an epidemic of physical assaults on Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn. Okay. The people who perpetrated those assaults were not white nationalists. Right. Right. They were African-Americans in Brooklyn. I don't want to say that. Is that actually like universally understood to be true that all of them are?
perpetrated by African-Americans? As far as I know, yes. I don't think those are politically motivated. I mean, they're awful. No, no, no. What I was about to say was it's not even relevant, I think, to say right-wing or left-wing. Excuse me? What are your politics? Except to say that that is not a white nationalist thing. Definitely, Jim. Obviously. So he's bringing that as one of the prime examples, which is clearly not coming from a right-wing, right-nationalist thing. And the other thing he says is the rise, which a lot of people have been talking about, the very scary rise in anti-Semitic incidents as reported by the ADL, which seemed to be skyrocketing in recent years. And a big part of that is because of campus anti-Semitism. And I think it's very clear that that as well, a decent...
percentage of campus antisemitism is coming from Israel-related things, groups, such as Students for Justice in Palestine and other Muslim groups or even left-wing political groups geared towards, let's say, Zionist events or Jews who they think are Zionists and supporters of Israel. I don't know the numbers of what percentage they are, but I know that they are a significant percentage of those statistics. We can include some links to that effect. But my point is that in Beecham's article, two of his primary examples of the rising problem of antisemitism... are coming from places, at least in large part, that have nothing to do with right-wing antisemitism, yet he does not, not only does he not acknowledge left-wing antisemitism, he dismisses the notion of, oh, well, people equate them, and that's so wrong, and that's the extent to which he addresses it. So, just to clarify, are you saying that because he's saying, just to quote it, that he doesn't like that people are, quote, painting a false equivalence between antisemitism on the American left and right, end quote, are you saying that you think that...
He doesn't think that there's a problem of antisemitism on the American left? Well, that's all he says. So the least I can say to criticize him is, well, why don't you tell me how you see left-wing antisemitism? Oh, sure. And tell me what the problem is. But he doesn't address that in the article. True. It is a long article. He talks a lot about right-wing stuff, and he doesn't mention any left-wing examples. Yeah, it definitely seems. I think that's problematic. Well, I'm not sure that's problematic. It definitely seems from his article that he thinks that there is a much worse problem on the American right, right? Which is one of the things that I was...
I was claiming, right, that I think that people on the left generally see it as a bigger problem on the right. People on the right generally think it's a bigger problem on the left. People on the right... I don't think it's true that people on the right think it's a bigger problem on the left. From... This is a generalization, but I follow a fair number of right-wing people on Twitter who are involved in either, you know, politics or whatever, things like that. And, like, they're constantly talking about Ilhan Omar, Rashid Ali, right, things like that. They're not talking about the Pittsburgh massacre in the same way. They're not talking... Like, I just... I don't see that. That's not because they're dismissive of the problem. No, because they think it's a bigger problem in one than in the other. No, I think it's because they're concerned about the fact that people on the left are not acknowledging the existence of... Can you make the same problem... Can you make the same argument
problem, so I'm going to prop up this problem because I think it's bigger and I think people are ignoring it. No, because no right-wing people are saying the Pittsburgh shooting is not a problem. Not that it's not a problem, but that it's not actually the main issue, right? I think to say that because he's claiming that there should not be a false equivalency means, oh, he doesn't think that there's a problem on one of them feels like a straw man. We're going in circles. Barry Weiss actually speaks about this at length in the book, which he talks about how obviously right-wing antisemitism is a huge problem. It always has been. I mean, the Holocaust, you could say, was the same kind of thing, white nationalism, whatever. The danger of the left-wing antisemitism is they're not explicit in the way that neo-Nazis are. Neo-Nazis have no problem saying Jews will not replace us and...
kill the Jews or whatever. I'm talking about violence. Or even self-identifying as anti-Semitic. Most people on the left, I mean, Louis Farrakhan might be an exception. I don't know if he's considered on the left. Let's say not. He's such an anomaly. It's like hardly even... Not about him. But most people on the left, let's say, who are extremely critical of Israel and things like that, would never self-identify as anti-Semitic. And that's why, in a way, it's more dangerous. Because if they're saying things that are either going to put Jews in danger, put Israel in danger, things like that, and that many people would see as anti-Semitic and very dangerous to Jews, but yet they are...
using the wording and the language of equality and anti-racism, that is a dangerous thing because they're saying words that are one thing but meaning something else. So I'm not sure that I even disagree with you, but I'm just trying to understand. So what is the danger? Like, what is the danger of talking about, like, anti-racism and equality, whatever? Like, what's the subliminal danger? What's the worst thing that could happen with all of that left-wing talk? The worst thing that could happen is Israel continues to be demonized to the extent that
it's dismantled and ceases to exist as a Jewish state. And that could come from world pressure, in the same way that South Africa was put under such intense pressure, and that ended apartheid. I mean, a lot of people want that. They obviously equate Israel to South Africa. I'm like, ooh, don't do that example. That's exactly what it is. And they want that to happen to Israel. I hope, and I don't believe that that would ever happen, but it's obviously a realistic possibility. And if Israel ceases to exist as a Jewish state, you now have 7 million Israeli Jews whose lives are in danger. Who knows what's going to happen if Palestine becomes a Muslim state and they have the majority?
I think that's a reasonable concern. I mean, I guess I don't really, but I also think like... You don't think that's a reasonable concern? No. Okay. Definitely not. Okay. But I also think like someone like Zach Beecham, right, who writes that he does not think that there's a good equivalency, that we should be making the equivalency between left-wing antisemitism, which if you're... The argument you're making is that left-wing antisemitism is this subtle way that could eventually lead down the road to America and the world disavowing Israel and therefore Israel being completely on their own and therefore obliterated and therefore these millions of Jews are in physical danger versus right-wing antisemitism, which Zach Beecham is... I mean...
obviously rightly so, as we all agree, like literal physical danger that has already happened and that has continued to make sure that we now need to have much more security in our schools, in our schools, there's government grants for all of these things. Like him saying they're not morally or not even like literally equivalent, it sounds like you're agreeing that they're not actually equivalent. I have no interest in saying that they're equivalent or saying one is worse than the other. Then why do you dislike that he said that people are painting a false equivalent? Because I don't think people are painting a false equivalent. I mean, some people maybe, but I don't think Barry Weiss is or any of the other people that I'm looking for. He wasn't talking about Barry Weiss. I think it's just a silly...
defense, because that's not the point. The point is, is there a danger? If there's a danger of left-wing anti-Semitism, then it needs to be addressed. It doesn't matter. I agree. It doesn't matter if it's less pressing or less significant. I agree. There is a danger. It took a long time to get to this point. All right, sounds like we solved it. No, I think it's totally true that people on the left are definitely, like, you know, raising all sort of, like, banners and saying, like, look at it, look at what's happening on the right. It's terrifying. This anti-Semitism on the right is, like, a huge problem, and people are not addressing it. And I also think it's true that people on the right, they're not saying it doesn't exist on our side, but they're saying, look, you don't understand, because it's subtle, right, as you mentioned, because it's not as obvious. There aren't people being literally
I think both those people are having a problem more. I don't know. The way you just described it might be true in America right now. I know that, but I'm just saying, let's just say looking at Europe, that's not the case. And Jews are being killed on a somewhat regular basis and attacked and harassed on a very regular basis.
from right-wing and from left-wing and from radical Islamic people who are not necessarily right or left, but who are oftentimes overlooked as a problem from people more so on the left than on the right. And, you know, when you had the shooting in Paris a few years ago in the kosher supermarket, and Obama famously dismissed it as saying, like, some guy randomly killed some people, and at first they kind of dug their heels in, and then eventually he and the White House apologized for that. A shooting takes place by a Muslim person in a kosher supermarket, and the President of the United States describes that as some guy shot some random people. That's called being dismissive of a very dangerous and immediate life-and-death problem of anti-Semitism. that was not acknowledged because of the political ramifications and it didn't fit the right narrative and it wasn't coming from the right place. That's all I'm saying. I agree with that. I agree with that. And there's a blind spot when it's not addressed in all of its forms. I totally agree. I just think that there's a blind spot coming from everyone about the other side. And I think that's what, to me, and look, I don't know where the blind spot is coming more from. Maybe it is coming more from people on the left that they are being more blind to the issues of antisemitism in their own party. That could very well be. I just think that we need to acknowledge that everyone is having this issue. Everyone has trouble with stories that don't fit into their narrative about the way the world works. I mean, I read the Barry Weiss book. Except for me and me. I recommend the Barry Weiss book to everybody. I don't think anybody can read that book and say that she is dismissive or not taking...
seriously, the threat of right-wing neo-Nazi whatever anti-Semitism. I don't think that's a fair statement. I didn't say she wasn't taking it seriously. You said everybody is dismissive of part of the problem. I'm saying, yeah, okay. People on the right take often take more seriously people. There are people on the right and there are people on the left who both have a problem with this. Yes, sure, but not just more of a problem. It is harder. This is human nature. I'm not blaming any of these people, but it is human nature to see issues and want them to fit into the narrative that we painted about the world in which we and our team, quote unquote, are the good guys and the other team are the bad guys. So if something doesn't fit into that, it's hard for any of us to reconcile. That's all I'm saying. So we both agree that everybody has to address anti-Semitism no matter where it comes from, no matter who is doing it. Yes. Why don't we just very quickly reach your last question. Oh, we're going to get him.
About Dr. Lipstadt's argument. Yeah, about the idea, as opposed to Beecham's argument or point, that his Judaism has been strengthened. Right. His Jewish identity has been strengthened in practice by the rise in anti-Semitism. Yeah. And what we think about that phenomenon. Yeah. What do you think, Ari? I mean, I think you made it clear that you have a problem with that. And... Why did I make that clear? Okay, well, maybe... I don't need to steal your thunder. Maybe in conversation. It's come up in the past also. Yeah, that's true. Barry Weiss has an interesting line in the book. And she says, if one's Jewish identity, and this is not word for word, but if one's Jewish identity...
is solely consists of being anti-antisemitism, then that is not sufficient and that's going to fall apart eventually. And I totally agree with that. And there are, you know, that does seem to be a little bit of a movement. Like, oh, because of this antisemitism, I'm now going to start wearing a kippah. I'm now going to wear my mug and david necklace. I don't think that's a bad thing. I just think there has to be more than just that. I think, I mean, historically, it's just the reality of Jewish history that at times of more persecution, that's when, like...
in some ways, Jewish identity was the strongest. And at the times of the most openness and acceptance of Jews, that's when assimilation was the strongest and the highest rates. And that's like a sort of a paradox and sort of a difficult thing to think about and accept. But it's obviously human nature. And if somebody persecutes you for being you and you don't even realize that that was what you were, but now they're saying, I want to kill you because you're Jewish and you never really thought so much about your Judaism, that's going to cause you to think like, well, what does it mean to me that I'm Jewish? That's just going to raise those thoughts and those questions. And for a lot of people...
It's going to raise, you could say it's defensive, maybe, but I think it's more of a pride thing and a pride in where you come from and who you are. And because anti-Semitism raises a lot of those issues, it often causes people to strengthen their Jewish identity. It's a way of fighting back against anti-Semitism. You know, the response to anti-Semitism, I think we both agree, the much worse response would be, oh, now let's go find some neo-Nazis or let's go find some radical Islamists and let's attack them. I don't think that, you know, just escalate the violence. I thought you were going to say something. I thought you were going to say, like, you know, in...
when there's a rise of anti-Semitism to sort of say like, well, you know, I never really affiliated as so Jewish anyway, so I'm just going to slip out of it. I think that would be worse also. So between going back and attacking the other side or just erasing your Jewish identity altogether, I think we would agree that it's better than both of those. I agree. I also agree with what specifically what you just said is I think the best case scenario for these like awful anti-Semitic attacks and everything that has been happening with the rise of all these incidents, the best case scenario is that it should cause every single Jew and honestly every single person to stop and say, what is it that they're attacking? You know, honestly, like I don't know as much about Judaism as I would have liked to or I haven't been as affiliated as I don't know, maybe my grandparents would have wanted me to. So let me take, let me stop and see.
like what it actually is and maybe let me like kind of like reemerge myself or maybe emerge myself for the first time in something like Judaism. But my fear is, and Deborah Lipset speaks to this a little bit, is that when people, let's say A, from a practical perspective, when people kind of say, oh, I'm being attacked for being a Jew, I'm being attacked for being, I don't know, Asian, black, any of these things, any sort of like affiliation or identity thing, then I'm going to then feel more like that thing. I'm going to feel more Jewish and therefore I'm going to- And express that. Yeah, I'm going to marry another Jew because I feel afraid or I'm going to- No, it's not because they feel afraid, it's because they feel proud. Yeah, maybe afraid is not the right word because I feel more connected to my community and identity in that way. So therefore, I'm going to marry another Jew. Therefore, on Friday night, I'm going to go to synagogue, right? Things like that. But if it doesn't feel, if it's not really an emotion of like actually one that gets translated into love, into excitement, into like this is what Judaism stands for and these are the things that I'm excited about, but more it stays at this like cultural affiliation, then I actually just don't think it's particularly a...
practical. I don't think that something like that lasts from generation to generation because when there's a little bit less anti-Semitism, the children are going to like kind of ease out and say like, oh, mom, dad, what are you so worried about? And they're going to get away from it. And so one, I don't think it's super practical for like continuing actually like a movement. And B, I don't think it's important.
I think we talk about this a lot. You don't think Jewish continuity is important? I don't think Jewish continuity is important unless it stands for something, right? We talked about this in the Michael Chabin episode, right? Where we talked about, like, he very firmly, he was speaking at the Reform, Revival School graduation, and he was talking about building walls, and he was saying we shouldn't build walls, right? In Israel or in Judaism in general, we should always be striving to connect with other people and join with other people. And some things about it we both found problematic. And he kind of encouraged, he said he wants his kids to marry thoughtful, kind, intelligent people. Yeah, exactly. And if they happen to be Jewish, that's okay. Exactly, exactly. But he doesn't necessarily want them to marry Jews. Exactly. He didn't think intermarriage was such a bad... Which was a very outrageous thing for a lot of people. Right. People found that problematic. Yeah, people found that problematic. And the argument that I made then
shockingly, have not changed my mind that much, is that if Judaism doesn't stand for something, then it doesn't matter whether you marry a Jew. Marrying a Jew because you're like, oh, I feel proud of being Jewish because people are trying to murder my people is not important. Important is to marry a Jew because you think that you're building something because you think Judaism means something and you want to perpetuate that. I agree with your conception of what the ideal is. I'm saying that's the only thing that it should be. Well, my problem with what you're saying is that you're saying if it's not perfect, if people aren't doing it for the perfect right reason, then it doesn't even matter that they're doing it in the first place and there's no value to it if it's not the best reason possible. And I very strongly disagree with that. If people want to marry a Jew and identify as Jewish because of anti-Semitism, there's nothing that might be...
complete as a full Jewish identity, but I don't have a problem that it's not bad. So make a distinction for me between, in that case, being Jewish and being a Knicks fan, okay? Which, obviously, I think neither of us feel like it's the same thing, but let's say everyone... I think that's an accurate comparison. How about being African-American? Okay, let's do it. I mean, that's just... Great, great. Let's say I feel, like, oppressed because I'm black, so I'm like, you know what? I feel so oppressed, therefore I feel more prided, and therefore I'm going to marry a black person. I don't know about marrying a black person, but I know that... I'm trying to make the analogy. ...incorporating various more traditional elements of dress, or, you know, Kwanzaa as a holiday being incorporated into American culture, or, like, black is beautiful, and a lot of these type of...
movements and ideas and fashions of people embracing their African descent instead of just trying to blend in with American white culture and try to be as white as they can be, you know? And a lot of that was obviously in response to... racism, and persecution, and oppression, and being brought to this country in the first place as slaves against their will, and that whole thing, do you have a problem with that? I think the problem, I think there is, yes, I think there's a problem with groups saying, we are feeling oppressed, therefore we are going to kind of be insular in this way, in which we really only want to connect with other people, and I'm using marriage as the example in particular, because I think marriage is often about perpetuating something, and continuing sort of a legacy, right, because so often we associate culturally marriage with children. It's a very extreme example, because I don't know if all other cultures say, in order to perpetuate our culture, you need to marry the same kind of person. I mean, the fact that Jews say that, I acknowledge, is pretty extreme, a lot of people don't.
don't understand or think it's fair. They would even call it racist to say like, oh, what's wrong with non-Jews? You can't marry non-Jew. Right. And I'm going so far as to say, I too, unless you're trying to perpetuate something meaningful going forward into the next generation to say, I'm going to marry another Jew just because, because I think it's important because like, this is just like critical to who I am. I think he's racist. I think there are elements of that that are accurate. And I'm trying to understand why, why that isn't true.
I think you're just not acknowledging some elements of basic human nature. This isn't even getting into any of the ideas of Judaism itself. Oh, I'll acknowledge human nature. I just don't think it's good. Okay. Well, I think human nature is to feel an affinity and a connection and a pride, as long as you weren't traumatized as a child or whatever, to your family, to your roots, where you come from. And when persecution is being perpetrated against those roots and that family, either on an individual level or broadly to your broader family, the natural reaction is going to be, for a lot of people,
more identity, more pride, and more perpetuation of that group. But I totally agree. Think about white nationalism, right? They feel under attack. They feel like they're this oppressed minority, so they're saying we have to band together, and we need to feel power because we feel under attack. Don't we think that's a bad thing? Yes, because if your self-expression involves hate and persecution against other groups, then I don't think it's okay. But what about the white nationalism that says, oh, we don't agree. If it just involves wearing a mugging david, wearing a kippah, going to shul, marrying a Jew, that's not hurting anybody else. So what about white nationalism who say, we don't want to kill anyone, we don't want any of that, we just think that groups should be separate, whites should marry whites, blacks should marry blacks, we should all just do our own thing, we shouldn't be mixing. If a white person wants to marry another white person because they believe in white identity,
I think that should be allowed and that shouldn't be... Do you think that's the same as Jews marrying other Jews because they believe in Jewish identity? I don't want to speak to it because I don't understand white nationalism and white identity. I don't know exactly what that comes from and what it means. All I'm saying is, broadly speaking, if it doesn't involve hatred and persecution of other groups, then I think it's fine. We could aim higher than that. I don't know. I think we have to end it here, obviously. I think to a certain extent we're just rehashing our points. But I do think that this is something that I feel weird about.
And to a certain extent, when I'm arguing this point, I'm arguing on myself also because it is something that I feel like has been ingrained in me for a long time. And I'm trying to understand why it's so ingrained in me and in our culture and whether I think it's a good thing. Because just because it's human nature doesn't mean... Okay, that's fine. I think you're being hyper-idealistic. Thank you. I think there's nothing to be ashamed of in being proud of where you come from and proud of your family and wanting to continue the traditions and the identity of your family. In Judaism, Jews are a family. That's how we see ourselves. And so I don't think there's anything wrong with that. No, I have a friend who said to me, you know, I would just never marry a Sparty guy. And I said, why? And she said, because. It's just like, we have different cultures, we have different traditions. And honestly, that's just not what I want in my family
And like, I don't know. I think that's not a good thing. That might be closed-minded. I don't think that makes that person a bad person. When did I say that person's a bad person? I'm just saying I don't think that person's a bad person. Wow. Radical argument. Neither do I. Okay, fine. But I think that's problematic. I think it's problematic to say there are things that I want to... I would never marry a Mets fan. You know, because like I want to perpetuate the Yankee name. I think you're allowed to feel that if that's how you feel. I think it's an immature way of going about the world. Of course you're allowed. I'm not saying we should jail them. I'm just saying it's not a very sophisticated way of thinking. We can do a little bit better. I think it's a little bit patronizing because... I agree. I'm a Democrat. Do you think it is sophisticated?
I don't think it's unsophisticated necessarily. Well, honestly, I think the vast majority of our listeners also think that it is perfectly acceptable. And I would love to be convinced otherwise. And of course, of course, of course, we want you to be in touch with us. Tell us what an idiot I am. I can take it. Be in touch at Talking Talkless. You're just naive. I'm just naive. Talking Talkless podcast at gmail.com. And of course, join the conversation on our Facebook page, Talking Talkless podcast. And most, most, most, well, no, most importantly is talking to us and engaging with us. But the next step beyond that is if you have not yet done so, please subscribe to our podcast so that you won't miss a new episode. And please like and review us on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your podcast because it really, really, really does make a difference.
Thanks, as always, to Drive-In Productions. They are the sponsor of this week's episode. And thank you to Triple Threat Trio featuring Rage Brigade. They are the official band of Talking Talkless. Bye, everyone. Bye.