89. Shaker's Cigar Bar
It's time to hit Milwaukee! Hiding place of mobsters apparently and the former home of notorious serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer. Nestled in there with a supposed connection to both is Shaker's Cigar Bar that boasts a healthy stock of spirits of all kinds. You have a small girl bothering you in the bathroom, some men causing a nuisance in the basement, and a murdered sex worker who re-arranges things in the upstairs AirBNB. A lot of rumors have made Shaker's Cigar Bar a popular haunt, but does it have the history to back it up? Find out! We'd appreciate it if you took a moment to help our podcast by rating and reviewing on apple and NOW on Spotify! Don't forget to check our show notes for our social links! Definitely check out our Instagram (@hauntedorhoaxpod). We post all photos and videos talked about in the show there!
Episode 89 of the Haunted or Hoax podcast, hosted by Jennifer Davis, Kristen Jackson, titled "89. Shaker's Cigar Bar" was published on September 26, 2023 and runs 53 minutes.
September 26, 2023 ·53m · Haunted or Hoax
Summary
It's time to hit Milwaukee! Hiding place of mobsters apparently and the former home of notorious serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer. Nestled in there with a supposed connection to both is Shaker's Cigar Bar that boasts a healthy stock of spirits of all kinds. You have a small girl bothering you in the bathroom, some men causing a nuisance in the basement, and a murdered sex worker who re-arranges things in the upstairs AirBNB. A lot of rumors have made Shaker's Cigar Bar a popular haunt, but does it have the history to back it up? Find out! We'd appreciate it if you took a moment to help our podcast by rating and reviewing on apple and NOW on Spotify! Don't forget to check our show notes for our social links! Definitely check out our Instagram (@hauntedorhoaxpod). We post all photos and videos talked about in the show there!
Episode Description
It's time to hit Milwaukee! Hiding place of mobsters apparently and the former home of notorious serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer. Nestled in there with a supposed connection to both is Shaker's Cigar Bar that boasts a healthy stock of spirits of all kinds. You have a small girl bothering you in the bathroom, some men causing a nuisance in the basement, and a murdered sex worker who re-arranges things in the upstairs AirBNB. A lot of rumors have made Shaker's Cigar Bar a popular haunt, but does it have the history to back it up? Find out!
We'd appreciate it if you took a moment to help our podcast by rating and reviewing on apple and NOW on Spotify! Don't forget to check our show notes for our social links! Definitely check out our Instagram (@hauntedorhoaxpod). We post all photos and videos talked about in the show there!
Haunted or Hoax Social Medias:
Sources for this Episode:
TELEVISION & MEDIA:
WEBSITES:
- http://hauntedhouses.com/wisconsin/shakers-cigar-bar/
- https://q985online.com/most-haunted-bar-wisconsin/
- https://onmilwaukee.com/articles/shakersovernight
- https://spectrumnews1.com/wi/milwaukee/news/2021/10/14/milwaukee-s-haunted-bar
- https://milwaukeerecord.com/city-life/spent-night-milwaukees-haunted-cigar-bar/
- https://www.hangmantours.com/single-post/shakers-a-haunted-history
- https://www.travelwisconsin.com/article/things-to-do/wisconsins-gangster-tour
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Schlitz_Brewing_Company
- http://www.davidrumsey.com/maps6523.html
- https://www.davidrumsey.com/luna/servlet/detail/RUMSEY~8~1~1954~190067:Map-Of-Milwaukee---Population-In-18
Similar Episodes
Apr 1, 2026 ·45m
Mar 27, 2026 ·27m
Mar 27, 2026 ·21m
Mar 14, 2026 ·57m
Mar 6, 2026 ·40m