Skip to content
A Conversation with Judy Collins episode artwork

Sep 7, 2017 30 min

A Conversation with Judy Collins

from Hearts of the Dulcimer Hosted by Patricia Delich & Wayne Jiang

028 We spoke with legendary award-winning singer-songwriter Judy Collins about her good friend Richard Fariña. We also explored the importance of Judy Collins' Fifth Album in introducing the dulcimer in the mid-1960s. With additional commentary by Neal Hellman and readings from Richard Fariña's cousin Omar Lugones.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

A Conversation with Judy Collins

0:00 30:05
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

He was a dear friend and I always treasured the fact that I got to know him, as well as singing his songs. You may know Judy Collins from her big hits from the 60s and 70s. Both sides now, Suzanne and Senator Collins are naming just a few. You may also know her as the person who introduced Joni Mitchell, Randy Newman and Leonard Cohen to the world before they were known by recording songs they wrote.

But did you also know that she played a pivotal role in popularizing the Dulsomer in the mid-1960s? In 1965, already an established recording artist, Judy Collins released her fifth album. When many people dropped the needle to listen to this LP for the first time, they probably would have expected to hear Judy's voice accompanied by a guitar, like they had heard on her previous albums. But before Judy started singing, they instead heard an upbeat exotic instrumental solo with an unknown instrument accompanied by a bouncy bass.

And when they looked at the LP's liner notes, they learned the song was called Pack Up Your Sorrows and the exotic instrument was a Mountain Dulsomer. It was played by Richard Frina who also co-wrote the song. This was the first time a Dulsomer solo was featured on a contemporary popular song. Before that, Dulsomer recordings were mostly traditional Appalachian and sometimes British isle tunes.

This was a breakthrough recording for the Mountain Dulsomer. And for many, this was the first time they heard a Mountain Dulsomer. Many Dulsomer players have told us that they attribute Judy's recording of Pack Up Your Sorrows on her fifth album as their entry point to the Dulsomer. One of those Dulsomer players is Neil Hellman.

To give you context for our conversation with Judy Collins, we spoke briefly to Neil about the influence Judy's music had on his career in music. Besides being a fabulous Dulsomer performer, Neil is the founder, director, and one of the primary artists on the Gordon Music record label. Gordon Music recordings are known for less arrangements, often pairing the Dulsomer with folk and classical instruments. Over the past two decades, Gordon Music recordings have been frequently used in film and television soundtracks.

Programs like Ken Burns' National Parks, The History Channel's Pond Stars, and NBC's The Office are just a few of Gordon Music's impressive credits. I was really big, Judy Collins saying right from the beginning because I had a Native Constance Harrow, got it from my 14th birthday. But you heard the Dulsomer for the first time on Judy Collins's album? Yeah, you see what, sneak up to my brother's room because he was five years older than me.

And he had Dylan and Siloaks and Tom Rush and Judy Collins. And I would listen to his records, his vinyl. And I still remember hearing the Dulsomer come in and pack up his sorrows. And I said, oh, what's that?

It was so buoyant to me. It was so fun. I just loved it. I kept playing that track over and over again too.

The free music went on to influence you, right? And Judy's recordings played a huge impact on Gordon Music. Judy Collins herself even more than freeing you because when she got up to wildflowers and in my life, I was raised with classical music. And I liked folk music.

When I heard wildflowers and songs like Michael from Mountains that since she passed, I thought, well, this is like classical music, classical settings of folk music. And I thought, I'd love to do something like this where you have harps and ovals and just making it beautiful, very cold when it's like, if Aaron Colton wrote a vocal song, it would sound like this. Here's more of Pleasant Hill, a tune written and arranged by Neil Hellman. Neil played Dulsomer back up in this recording along with classical trained musicians on his Gordon Music label.

Neil told us that in this tune, he layered the Dulsomer with classical instruments. Using the elbow, harp and cello was very much inspired by the arrangements he heard from Judy Collins' albums in my life and wildflowers. Here's my interview with Judy Collins. Judy Collins, it's such a pleasure to talk with you today on the Heart for Dulsomer podcast.

Thank you. Since the early 60s, many people have known you through your iconic songs. Songs like Since You Asked, Both Sides Now and Suzanne are naming just a few of the greats. You're currently on tour and you're going to be in Portland on September 10th and like many of us in Portland, we're looking forward to seeing you at the Aladdin Theater.

The reason we're talking with you today is because you were friends with Richard Carina, and we'd like to talk with you about some of your memories of him. If you ran into somebody who didn't know about Richard Carina, how would you describe him? Well, he was brilliant. He was funny, deliciously funny.

He was a scam. He was a bad boy. He was very naughty and very funny, deliciously intelligent, hilarious at times, poignant, wonderful writer, and one of the best friends I ever had. I read your 2011 memoir, Sweetie Blue Eyes, and you mentioned you first met Richard in 1961 at the Internet Folk Festival.

What was your first impression of Richard when you met him? Romantic, dizzying, funny, hilarious, Office rocker. And did he play for you when you were there? Oh, what he did was to say to me, oh my God, it's you.

He said here, come into our room. And so we went into his room. He was married to Carol in Hester, who I knew a little bit in New York. Carol was a doll.

I always liked Carol in very much. So we went into his room and he said, okay, we're going to play you some songs now. And he had about 15 candles burning in his room. And so we had a lovely evening of listening to him play his songs and Carol and sing them.

Most of them were written together, I think. So I was very impressed. I think that was 1960 or 1961. And then shortly after that he called me up and said, you have to come to Martha's Vineyard.

And we'll have a nice weekend here. So we packed ourselves. My husband and my baby was about two and a half, maybe. And we all got into the Chevy carol and we drove to Martha's Vineyard and got on the ferry.

And we started driving into Martha's Vineyard and we saw these signs all over town that said concert. G. Collins and Richard Ferriero. A little bit of a surprise, huh?

Bruce Langmark was also there. So he was a scam. He had surprises. So you ended up playing that concert?

Oh, yes. After I got over being annoyed and pissed off at him. Of course I played the concert and we had a wonderful weekend. And then the next time we met he was married to Mimi.

And he called me up again and he said, I'm married to Mimi now. And we're going to be in Carmel for this. It was a Monterey Festival weekend. And he said, we're going to be there.

You're coming. So why don't you come down and stay the night with us in Carmel, which I did. And I'd say there, this time it was with Mimi, that he was sitting on the bed singing me all his songs. And I was drinking wine out of Silver's last.

And he really, he was a delightful player. He played wonderfully. It was a very special night and he was a wonderful player. So we had a great night and he signed me a lot of songs.

And I think that that night he sang me pack up your sorrows, which as you probably know was written by Richard with his, and now she's gone to Pauline Bayou. It was then she was married to the painter. Can't remember saying that. Anyway, that was spectacular.

And then I said, well, I'm just about to go into the studio to make another album. How about we record that? And he said, oh, how wonderful that would be. So we did that.

And we recorded pack up your sorrows that next time in the studio. It's 65, 1965. So he was on a radio broadcast in 1965 in Cambridge, Massachusetts. And he spoke about that recording session.

And he mentioned that there wasn't any rehearsal and that it was kind of loose and easy going. Do you have any memories about that recording session? The recording session was wonderful. Meany was sort of an infamous picture of us in the studio.

Meany and Dick and their dog, Lush and me singing. And I think Carol Levinddell said the studio, yeah, it was very lovely. But before that, and I don't even know where this is. I can't find it.

It disappeared into the woodwork somewhere. There's a recording of my six, I think my six interview shows on WBAI, Judy Collins Show. And I interviewed among other people, the Peak Family, Colonel Ray and Glover, Tom Paxton, and Richard and Meany Fareenia. And that was even more loosey-goosey.

I would go to the studio downtown. WBAI is our public radio station in New York City. And I go down there and I had a little table with a room with me, which could accommodate a few people. And I put a bottle of champagne on the table and a few glasses.

And then we'd just go to it. It was great fun. Do you remember what songs Richard and Meany played? I do not.

They played a lot of wonderful things. Yes, too bad that recording is getting around anymore. So send us a word and tell everybody that everybody is looking for it. There will be.

Okay. I will look for it. I'm pretty good at digging stuff up. So I will do that.

Probably 1964, by the way. Oh, okay. That's good to know. That's helpful.

Listening to your first four albums and then your fifth album, it looks like your fifth album with a real typical turning point for you where your first four albums were more traditional where your fifth one was more contemporary with just a couple of traditional songs. It seemed like not only for a pack of your starlets for Richard, that was probably an important point, at least for us in the D also you made a shift. I mean, that's how I see it. Is that true?

Well, I had made the shift on the third album and the third album instead of traditional, including songs by Masters of War, Billin, In the Hills of Shiloh, which was by Fred Hallerman of all things. The Bells of Remney, which of course is Pete Sager, The Fettled Down, which is Mike Settle. Again, a song by Freddie Hallerman called, um, Kama Wama-Wimba-Wimba. I mean, this is a big, big shift.

Okay, your shift happened on the third album. Oh, yes, it was earlier. Turn, turn, turn. Um, you know, he was so she'll, uh, she'll, uh, she'll have some songs for Christmas.

I mean, that was the big, the big shift. And then of course, 64 was the concert at the town hall, which we recorded. That was almost entirely songs, Billy Ed Wheeler, Tom Paxman, Freddie Neil. My God.

The only traditional one I see there is the Crow Mother, and then Bottle of Wine, which is Tom Paxman. Edgar Evers, lullaby, John Phillips, uh, Mia My Uncle, John Phillips, uh, Haynelling Ellie, which was again, Fred Hallerman. So then comes 1965. I mean, if we're being picky about that.

This 1965, which was of course the fifth album on which I turned to of course some wonderful writers. I must say really doing the song with the Farina was, let's see what happened, pack up your sorrows of course. And then the song by the wonderful she was from San Francisco. She was a gray-haired lady.

Oh, you know, Reynolds. And why isn't in my notes? I have no idea. So I have to remind people of that.

And Carrie-Don was of course a field-turner. Richard played Baltimore on Carrie-Don. And Richard was playing Deltzmer on that. Yes indeed.

That was the first time that he and I recorded together. So that was very exciting. And Eric Weisberg was on that album. And Bill Lee, the father of Spike Lee by the way.

He's wonderful. But we had a great time on that session. In a 1965 radio interview with Ed Freeman at WMBR in Cambridge, Massachusetts, Richard talked about Judy's pack up your sorrows recording session. That was a very groovy session by the way.

That was a lot of those songs in this album. One of the times, you know, one session for the song. And so we just all get together and get the evening. Nothing else to do.

And we just let us go and see. So it's a lot of fun. How long did it take to record a song to get a good cut of the song? Well, you know about as much as I did there.

I mean, with us sometimes it's... I would say the average is between two and six takes. Just that you said a whole evening. I thought you might...

Yeah, we just... In case of that particular pack up your sorrows, we tried a number of different things. Because they've been no rehearsal. So we just...

Eric Weisberg was on the session. And we just tried different combinations and instruments until we, you know, fooled around enough to get to the point where we wanted to be. And then did it. And it was very loose and easy going.

That was an archival recording of Richard Frina with W.M.B.R. host Ed Freeman in 1965 after the release of the Frina's first album, Celebrations for a Grade A. Ed was a friend of Mimi Frina and was part of the Cambridge Folk Music scene in the mid-1960s. In the previous Hearts the Dulsmer podcast episode, we spoke with Ed about his time in Cambridge during the 60s.

To hear our conversation with Ed, go to our website nolcemuse.com.com. And scroll down to episode number 23. It's called Richard Frina in the Cambridge Folk Music scene Part II, a conversation with Ed Freeman. Now back to my conversation with Judy Collins.

You know, those early guys were my friends. Still, it was a very good friend. Richard Frina was a very good friend. It was, we were all through the cluster together.

And it was a time of very strong friendships. I was very close to Mimi and Joan. I've always been very close to Joan. Bias.

And it was kind of a, you know, breathing ground of friendship and of songwriting. And of course Leonard, I just adored on the sixth album, on In My Life. Of course, they were both the two songs of Leonard's dress rehearsal, right? And Suzanne.

And you have a song of Richard's too on that. Oh, of course. How do I talk with him? He's wearing.

I'm going to learn again. But he was delicious fun. At that point, I think it was probably People magazine that came out and did a piece about us. Richard and Mimi would come and stay at my place.

And either when I was there or when I was not there, I would see them out in Carmel on the West Coast. And we spent time together. We were very, very close friends. I was just crazy about him.

And I didn't write songs at that point. But I was a would-be writer. I mean, I was somebody who wanted desperately to write songs and to write prose. And he had the same feeling of writing prose.

So we both talked a lot about the things that we still wanted to do. Well, what do you think he'd done musically in his writing if he would have continued living? I have no idea. What do they all know?

He was extraordinarily interested and interesting man. He had all kinds of deeply felt convictions. And he was extremely smart. Well, I got a letter.

When Ari and I were nominated for a Grammy, we did a lot of press. And the other thing he did was a piece on Extra. That funny show that comes on and makes you annoy that. It's an extra, the guy who was interviewing us turned out to have been a cousin of Marie.

Yeah, Omar. Omar. Omar. Omar.

Omar. Omar. Omar. Omar.

Omar. Omar. Omar. Omar.

Omar. Yes. It was so fun. And he was so delicious and such a good interview.

Then after the interview was finished, he said, you know, I have something for you. And he pulled out this beautiful letter, a copy of a letter from his father was the brother of Feringaurena's father. And he didn't know, he didn't know for anything about him until he was an adult. And then he found out, oh my God, I'm a cousin of Richard Feringa.

And he dug into Richard's life and all the things that were housed in Richard's uncle's home. His father was at the funeral. I met his father, actually. It was in Carmel.

And he brought his beautiful letter from Richard. And it was a letter from Richard which talked to his own father. He was at Cornell. And he was very, very unhappy.

And he said, you know, I hope you understand that I'm not going to come into the business. I'm not going to go to law school. I'm not going to do all the things that you had planned for me. I'm going to go Cuba, which is where he was headed.

His family was human. And he said, I'm going to go to Cuba. I'm going to play the Dalsamal. I'm going to write songs.

I'm going to be an artist. It was a breathtaking letter. And of course, he didn't know the time when he was probably not even, probably 19 or 20. And it showed that kind of dynamic forward moving spirit that he had.

Here's Richard's cousin Omar Lugone's reading parts of the letter Judy just mentioned. A number of months ago, you became aware that I was unhappy in engineering. And that I was going to major in English. Yet outside of this decision, you never bothered to question why.

If you had, then my future action would be easier to understand. The desire to write, or paint, or play music stems from kind of half conscious motivation. And for most people, it's very hard to explain. Once you have this desire, it can assess you more than anything or anyone has in the past.

You find that you are willing to spend each spare second at it, cultivating it, loving it, and seeking the best method of expressing it. It is not easy for everyone to be able to comprehend this. Deep within the person who seeks a mean of expression in the creative field, there must be a reason for his desire to do what he wants to do. If there is no such desire, then he can be called a hypocrite.

If, however, there is such a desire, you fail to follow it, and believe in it, then you are worse than hypocrite, for you are not man. Now as to why I want to write in the first place, and this is no easy thing to explain briefly, or to do it, I must write the books that I will write. In life itself, apart from the beliefs in what comes before or after it, there is something magnificent. There is something to be found in life that can give so much to a person that it feels that he can swell up and then just burst.

That something is simply the act of living life to the fullest. The recording you just heard is from Omar Lugone's 2011 presentation called Remembering Richard Farina that took place at the Carmel Valley Library in Carmel Valley, California, not too far from where Richard died in a motorcycle accident in 1966. You can hear Omar reading the entire letter on Hearts of the Dolesmer podcast episode number five, Richard Farina Trippute, part two. Now back to my conversation with Judy Collins.

Well, he was crazy. Also, he was crazy. I mean, that ended with a drunk, of course. He used so much booze that he used to say to me, you know, my kidneys really ache today, I just had too much booze.

He was drunk that night that he died. You know, he got on a motorcycle. He gave me his keys. She didn't drive.

He gave her right keys. And he got on the back of this motorcycle. I mean, that's insane. It was his big party.

And he was too hot and think straight. And he got on this motorcycle and died. And it just broke our hearts. I can tell you that.

Were you in Colorado when that happened? I was in Denver and I got a call from Nina Holzman from Jack Holzman's wife. And she said, oh, I have bad news. And I said, oh my God, I can't believe it.

And I got on the plane and went to Carmel. And Mimi and Pauline and our friend, both Jones friend, Mimi's friend and my friend and Dix. And Nancy Carlin. So the three of us and the four of us and their dog, lush, spent a couple of days before the funeral running the dog on the beach and crying and laughing and sobbing and getting, getting, getting too much wine and just terrible.

Yeah, I have to tell you a brief story. My husband to be our first date, this is my test. I asked him if he would be willing to go with me to find Richard Crenius grape sight for our first date. And we went, we found it and we put a dulcemer on his grave and we took a photo of it and we sat around and played music.

And so anyway, I wanted to tell you, we did that for Richard. So that's wonderful. That is wonderful. Just wonderful.

And you know, after his death, I used to dream about him a lot. We were riding around in the taxi in New York and I was saying, you know, finally, I wrote, it was after I wrote my first book and published my first book. My first book really was a seven chapters in my song book in 1969. And it was actually, it was even still to encourage me to write the chapters rather than just the songs with the lyrics and everything.

And he said, you know, you have such an interesting family. You want to write about it? So I did. And after that, after it was published, I had this dream about Richard.

We were driving around in a taxi in New York, a big yellow taxi. I was telling him, I finally got to do it. I'm finally writing, aren't you, proud of me? Oh, that's great.

And thank you to Stephen Stilter for asking me to do that because I thought that years ago and I had that book and I read it, it's great. And I love having all those stories between your songs. Well, it's been so thrilling to talk with you today. And, you know, his music was so great.

And, you know, he's kind of a mythical figure in the Dauce River world. So your intimate firsthand accounts with Richard are so valuable for his appreciation of who he was. We really thank you for talking with us today. I'm grateful for you calling me to ask me about him.

He was a dear friend and I always treasure the fact that I got to know him as well as singing his songs. Well, we're looking forward to seeing you in Portland on September 10th. Thank you so much. See you then.

Okay, take care. This is episode 28 of the Hearts of the Dulce River podcast. We're going out with Neil Hellman's original tune called Durango. This tune's arrangement was also inspired by Judy Collins' recordings.

Special thanks to Judy Collins for speaking with us on the Hearts of the Dulce River podcast. Judy's currently on a US tour until December 2017. She'll be touring in Ireland in January 2018. Find out more about Judy's touring dates and locations at JudyCollins.com slash concerts.

We'd also like to thank Omar LeGonez and Neil Hellman. For more about this episode, go to the resource page link for this episode on dulcemuse.com slash podcast. We appreciate you listening to the Hearts of the Dulce River podcast. Please consider supporting our podcast by shopping at our store at dulcemuse.com.

You can also go to our new support page to donate to the podcast. Hearts of the Dulce River podcast comes to you from Patricia Deleg and Wayne John. Thanks for listening. We'll be back with more Dulce River stories.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Hearts of the Dulcimer?

This episode is 30 minutes long.

When was this Hearts of the Dulcimer episode published?

This episode was published on September 7, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Hearts of the Dulcimer episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.