Skip to content
A New Definition for Obesity - Part 1 episode artwork

Feb 5, 2025 13 min

A New Definition for Obesity - Part 1

from The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman

Welcome back to The Daily Dollop podcast, over the next few episodes, I'm going to look at a recent event in the world of nutrition and health and that is the Lancet's Commission on the definition and diagnostic criteria of clinical obesity. Download the Ayla Health App. Join the conversation over in the Ayla Health Community Group on Facebook. Follow Ayla Health on Instagram Follow Kate Freeman on Instagram Ayla Health Website Kate Freeman's Website The Lancet Editorial: Redefining obesity: advancing care for better lives

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

A New Definition for Obesity - Part 1

0:00 13:41
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, I'm Kate Freeman, and this is the Daily Dollip. Transform your eating habits and achieve long-term well-being with ALA Health. ALA Health is a mobile app that combines micro-learning with meal planning into a seamless user experience that teaches you how to eat well for the rest of your life, one habit at a time. Download it now from the app store, it's free!

On this episode of the Daily Dollip, I look at a very recent commission on the Landsat Journal on a new definition of obesity with the goal of improving individual patient care. We'll unpack what this new definition means and how it might impact the future of health care. It's Dollip Time! Hey, hey, my name's Kate.

I'm a registered nutritionist, and after 20 years in the field of nutrition, I'm tired of seeing people stressed about eating and confused about where to start. And so, I'm changing the conversation. You deserve to feel confident in your food choices and empower to maximize your health. Every weekday will dull up an episode into your feed, covering everything from busting nutrition myths, practical food ideas, my thoughts on trending topics, and habits for a healthy life.

My promise to you, it will always be sustainable, realistic, restriction-free, and strictly no-woo. Only good science translated into easy, everyday advice. Let's do this. Welcome back to the Daily Dollip podcast, everyone.

I hope you're having a fabulous day. Today's episode, as well as tomorrow's, we're going to do a little deep dive on some recent movement in the nutrition science world. And I'm going to cover some news that came out a couple of weeks ago in mid-January, and just really unpack some things more from the science research perspective. But I guess talk about some thoughts on that translating through to, yeah, your overall care as an individual within the healthcare system, what this means for individuals living in a larger body or who would be classified as having obesity based on their BMI.

And just chat through, I guess, some of the complexities and nuances around body size and health, and the kind of worms that that whole thing is. So essentially, what I'm going to look at is a recent event in the world of nutrition and health, and that is the Landsets Commission on the definition and diagnostic criteria of clinical obesity. Now, this commission is interesting to me as a nutritionist and professionally for a few reasons, and I've been working and studying in the field of nutrition for over 20 years now, so it's been a really interesting journey and career and seeing how things have changed over time, and this is something that is actually very cool to see some change in. So the reason this interests me so much is that firstly, I spent probably the first half of my career doing weight loss and specializing in weight loss.

Now, I always approach weight loss from a health perspective. I always advise weight loss to be as healthy as possible. For the diet to be wide and varied as possible, and for people to find other factors that, I guess, indicated their success in addition to weight loss, rather than slowly focusing on weight loss. So I have more energy, reduce insulin resistance, sleeping better, I'm able to consistently exercise, et cetera.

I never did weight loss for the sake of weight loss or where I could avoid it, and there was always this part of me that if we have to do really unhealthy, crazy things for you to lose weight, we'll be not doing them. But at the end of the day, I did help people with the goal of weight loss and help them achieve that to the best of my ability. And many of my clients were classified as obese by the BMI and essentially what is really a narrow definition of obesity. And, you know, I saw lots of different people from lots of walks of life with lots of different lived experiences in lots of different sized bodies, from small bodies to medium bodies to large bodies who wanted to lose weight.

And so I feel like just from my experience in working in this field, I have a few thoughts on this stuff. Secondly, this is interesting to me, this commission, because I did find that over many years of working with clients, that the process of losing weight is a stressful, frustrating and often unhealthy pursuit for many, many people. Now, it's not unhealthy for some people, but for a lot of people and even for clients who would come and see me, and I always had the goal of making sure we were maintaining health while we were doing this, it very quickly slipped into an unhealthy pursuit. They either went rogue and did some kind of like crazy diet or they just wanted to do shakes or they wanted to do like something really extreme, like the keto diet and right, they just think I'm just desperate to get this done.

And it became unhealthy from that perspective, or it became unhealthy mentally, like they were just constantly thinking about food, constantly thinking about their body, they sat on the sideline of life, like not engaging in their life because they weren't allowed to do that until they achieved their health goals. And I guess through my experiences with working with people one-on-one, I essentially saw a pretty high correlation of the goal of weight loss with that individual having an all-or-nothing thinking pattern, like I said, tempted to achieve weight loss at any cost. And then also this very slippery slope to what we call disordered eating, which is actually the number one risk factor for developing an eating disorder. So, you know, pursuing weight loss doesn't give you an eating disorder, no, it's not causal.

But pursuing weight loss, particularly over and over again and doing it for a large amount of time, puts you at risk of developing disordered eating, which is eating in a way that's actually, you know, thinking about your body and food in a really unhealthy, and helpful way, and disordered eating is the number one risk factor for developing an eating disorder. So it's just a slippery slope and I certainly, I've seen that in the research and I've also just observed that in my practice. And thirdly, I saw many people who had very awful experiences with healthcare practitioners, so general practitioners, DPs, doctors, specialists, who, you know, they probably had the patient's best interest at heart but maybe were ignorant to a few things, but who celebrated weight loss when that person was actually going about weight loss in a really unhealthy way, either starvation, excessive fasting, really extreme dieting, et cetera. An example of that is I had a client once who came to me and in their first session disclosed that they had an eating disorder and were starving themselves, but because they lived in a larger body, her suffering was unimportant to the GP, and in fact, after disclosing her suffering to the GP and the fact that she had been starving herself and had lost weight as a result of that, this weight loss was celebrated by the GP, and she was like patted on the back for it.

And as such, she didn't get the help that she needed and, you know, if we're losing weight from starvation or restrictive dieting, we're at risk of malnutrition, there are actually many weight loss diets who tick the criteria for a diet that would lead to malnutrition, and I guess these experiences along with reading research and just continuing to upskill in my field has actually led me to the point of where I now provide neutral nutrition advice. And so that essentially means that I help you be a healthy eater. I help you maximize your long-term health with food without the goal of weight loss. So the goal of your nutrition is long-term health.

That's the goal is how do we improve diet quality? How do we give your body energy to function? How do we meet your body's nutrient needs? How do we get your firing on all cylinders who feeling good and good long-term?

The goal is not to make your body smaller. And so essentially any weight change that we see in an individual working in this way is just seen as a neutral side effect. So it's a good and all bad. It's just part of us focusing on your health and mending your relationship with food, adequately nourishing you, building your diet quality.

And I am going to talk more about this approach in future podcasts because there's actually lots to unpack. And I've learned lots, you know, over the last couple of years that, yeah, there's a bunch of reasons why I've sort of come to this point on top of what I've already shared. But let's look at the Lancet Commission and I've popped links to this in the show notes so you can go and read more for yourself. Don't just take my word for it.

Before we get into it though quickly, for those of you who don't know, the Lancet is a scientific journal and it's actually one of the world's most prestigious and influential medical journals that was founded back in 1823. And it publishes peer-reviewed, so that just means people are reviewing each other's work before it's published, peer-reviewed research articles, reviews and commentary on a wide range of medical and global health topics. So this, the particular Lancet involved in this commission was the Diabetes and Endocrinology journal. So essentially back in 2022, a commission was formally announced by the Lancet with the goal of providing a new evidence-based definition and diagnostic criteria for obesity.

And this conversation was led by Professor Francesco Rubino. Essentially, it was recognized that there was no global consensus on the classification and definition of obesity, and that individuals actually have different health profiles and needs, and that simply dismissing the health complaints of an individual to a single cause, obesity, or only using one single parameter to define obesity, BMI, actually didn't allow for the best care of these individuals, fully agreed by me, absolutely. So on the 14th of January 2025, the Landsat Diabetes and Endocrinology Commission was published as a result of these couple of years' work, and it introduced a refined framework for defining obesity. And essentially, the new framework moves beyond the traditional reliance on body mass index, which is so good.

And then the new approach emphasizes a more comprehensive assessment of an individual's health by considering both the amount and distribution of body fat, as well as its impact on organ function. So essentially, looking at health as a whole. So in tomorrow's episode, I'm going to unpack this a little bit more. I'm going to look at Dietitians Australia, who is the peak industry body for dietetic and nutrition professionals in Australia.

I hire dietitians in my business. I'm going to look at their media release response to this commission, because it certainly aligns very closely with my sentiments on the topic. We're also going to look at in tomorrow's episode the limitations of BMI, where it came from, and why it's actually pretty limiting when it comes to somebody's health. And we'll look in more detail at this new diagnostic criteria, and I guess essentially wrap up the episode tomorrow on the implications of health care.

So keep tuning in, and yeah, let's get involved in this important topic and conversation. Catch you next time. The Daily Dog podcast is proudly brought to you by Ayla Health. Build food confidence and learn how to choose foods that are right for you and your body.

Download the app today and build habits that last. As always, you can find out more about our chat in the show notes. You can also join the conversation over in the Ayla Health Community group on Facebook. We'd love to see you there.

If you've got a topic you'd love to hear us chat about on the Daily Dog, please let us know. I'm Alice at hello at aylahealth.com.au, or you can send us a message on Instagram. Until next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman?

This episode is 13 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman episode published?

This episode was published on February 5, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Dollop with Kate Freeman episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.