This is Neil or what's at the Center for New American Security I'm here today with Susanna Bloom, and our Defense Strategies and Assessments Program, who's here to tell us about base realignment and closure, better known as BRAC. It's just come up in new legislation, and it has the potential to be a very big deal. So Susanna, thanks for coming in. My pleasure, Neil.
So give us a sense of what BRAC is. BRAC is a process that the department has undertaken five times before, that allows for an apolitical approach to base realignment and closure. So when you're thinking about how to reduce defense department infrastructure, there are always losers in that game. Some congressional district is going to lose.
And the BRAC process was established as a way to do that, requiring a wholesale adoption of a complete package of recommendations, which takes some of the politics out of the process. And to be clear, this is shutting down a base when it no longer serves a compelling military reason, where it's only being used as a fraction of its potential capabilities. Correct. So what are the benefits of shutting down these bases?
Well, the Defense Department estimates right now that it's carrying approximately 20% excess infrastructure. That costs the taxpayer a lot of money. So the current round under consideration is principally about savings. Previous BRAC rounds, the 2005 round, for example, have had other goals.
It is sometimes an addition to sometimes instead of cost savings, you know, realigning military forces to better reflect the way that we're organized to fight today. And when we talk about cost savings, what magnitude are we talking about? The department estimates that a BRAC round now could save approximately $2 billion per year, once implemented. So not jump change.
Not jump change. Now, previous BRAC rounds have been about as popular in Congress as the movie Ishtar. What are the chances of this one? Well, it's important to first note that the McCain-Ried amendment currently under consideration isn't actually a BRAC round.
It's different from the BRAC legislation that's been used previously in a couple of key ways. First of all, it puts cost controls in the process. Up front costs for BRAC are not permitted to exceed $5 billion. And the BRAC recommendations must start paying back within seven to 10 years.
It's important distinction. Another important distinction is that the current proposal does not allow for the establishment of an independent commission, which had been a critical aspect of previous BRAC rounds. Instead, the department will build a recommendation, and GAO will review. Finally, whereas previous BRAC rounds, once the commission had made its final recommendation, it automatically became law within a certain period of time.
Under the current proposal, Congress will have to actually vote to pass the recommendations and make them become law. So given these differences, I think it's pretty unlikely that we'll see a successful BRAC or BRAC like round in 2019. I'm not sure that the proposal currently under consideration has enough votes to pass in the Senate. Even if it does, there are a lot of different ways that the process could fail between now and when it ends.
Now, one of the things that people talk about is that the military needs to spend smarter, not just more. Is it possible to make that argument credibly if the Pentagon isn't even allowed to do this kind of work? I think that's an excellent point. There are a lot of different ways in which Congress ties the hands of the department in terms of saving, obvious savings, not only with regard to base closure, but a number of other areas where the department is prohibited from achieving savings by the Congress.
Unfortunately, that hypocrisy is something we've been living with for many years and is not likely to end anytime soon. Well, on that happy note, thanks so much for teaching us about BRAC and here's hoping we get to talk about it a little bit more. Anytime, Neil.