You're listening to Fourth Estate, a show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from TSCR in Sydney on Gadigal lands at the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Tina Quinn, welcome to the program. A quick warning, this episode does deal with sexual assault and violence.
If you or someone you know is impacted, please call 1-800-Respect on 1-800-737-732 or visit 1-800-Respect.org.au. While this week in Australia we saw the pressure that has been continually building over the last month, reaching what felt like a crescendo. Since the thousands of people flocked to March for justice across 40 different cities and towns throughout the country, protesting sexual violence against women, and a government that has largely tried to sweep our endemic culture of misogyny under the rug. Many attendees carried placards and wore blackened protest.
In Melbourne, protesters carried a long banner, listing the names of women killed in acts of gendered violence in the past decade. On this edition of Fourth Estate, we further unpack this issue with the heart of politics and media, but also ask what art we missing. Joining us to discuss are two fabulous women, Margaret Symons, and award-winning freelance investigative journalist. She has written extensively about the media for numerous publications such as Guardian Australia, Inside Story and the Monthly.
She also spent nearly a decade as Crikey's media commentator. Margaret has taught journalism and media at several renowned institutions such as Windburn, Monash and the University of Melbourne and is also the author of several renowned political biographies. And the wonderful Isabella Higgins, Indigenous Affairs correspondent for the ABC. A proud Torres Strait Islander Isabella can be found covering Indigenous Affairs for ABC News, across online, radio and television.
And one, welcome to the both of you. Hi, it's great to be here. Thank you. Well, first I'd like to get both of your thoughts on Tuesday's extraordinary marches across the country.
Organizers have said that this could be the biggest uprising of women that Australia has seen. Are we in a moment of reckoning, do you think? First year, Isabella? Oh, I think absolutely.
I think when you see that many women out on the streets that angry, of course this isn't the first time we've seen women protesting for their rights out in the Australian streets. But it's the first time I'm still under 30. I don't really recall my living memory seeing that many women outside the front of Canberra. And so angry, I was incredibly touched by the strength of some of those women to talk about things that are so personal and that for so long have carried so much shame to be out there and to be supported by so many other women.
And so I think that's a great thing. I think you described it perfectly as a reckoning and intrigued to see how it will continue to play out politically because I think it's been pretty clumsy so far. But Margaret, I'd love to hear your thoughts on someone who's got far more experience in this than me. Yeah, I agree with you though.
I do think it's a reckoning. I was thinking about other demonstrations and 60 so I've got 30 years of momentum in the fight from you. But I was remembering the east marches of the 18s and early 90s and some of the other political movements that we've seen where I think women have often been dominant among demonstrators. But I think what's different in this case is that it's largely coming across political lines I think and is about gender.
That is the focus rather than women being key demonstrators in peace movements or environmental movements or demonstrating on other causes. This is explicitly about gender. It's probably fair to say that the marches were donated by left-wing voters, but it wasn't only left-wing voters. I think the anger and these sort of general sets of fed up must cross political lines.
And that makes it very significant. When you were talking Margaret, it struck me that maybe this wasn't one of those marches where it's people fighting for a change of legislation or a change of law so much, but a change of behavior and attitudes more than anything else. I mean, there were some very practical steps that I think women were calling for, implementing a report that the government's been sitting on for over 12 months. And also, I think probably most would support an independent inquiry into the allegations against the Attorney General.
But yes, I think most of all it's linked by a cultural change. I was struck in Melbourne by the number of elderly women who were there who were saying things like, you know, I don't want my daughter or my granddaughter to have to do this. And I think that that is really significant. So I suspect there's a turning point, but I would add the caution if it's a little bit too soon to say.
I think in terms of this government's response, it will depend very much on their perception as to whether it's down to turn votes, whether they're a female liberal voters, male liberal voters as well, predominantly female liberal voters who are prepared to change their vote on this issue. And I guess it was only six months ago that we saw those huge black lives matter rallies as well. And it's hard to see if that's that felt like a huge reckoning and it feels like maybe there's been a few changes around the sides, but it doesn't feel like we've had some huge leadership after the rallies of that side on that issue. And obviously they're different, but in some ways.
Do you think we should either of you think we should pat ourselves on the back for no bullets being fired? Is that something we should all be very proud of? It's not what I'd expect in a country like Australia. That's also a sign of a healthy robust democracy.
I always think it cuts through when I open up my TikTok and I see young people making skits about things that the politicians say and that line about the bullets made it into TikTok. There were a lot of really good hot takes mocking that line, so I'll leave it to them. But I think that captures a bit of the community sentiment when you've got, you know, Gen Z on TikTok making fun of it. Absolutely.
Margaret? Yeah, no, well I'm not on TikTok. Neither of mine. That's Margaret.
That's if that makes you feel any better. It was clearly a misstep and quite embarrassing one to talk to marches about violence against women and say, you know, just can't get shot. It's just so tinny. It's what it's not really funny that one has the love.
But I think, you know, I mean, one of the things I would say is that cultural change takes a long while. I mean, you know, sometimes in retrospect, you can identify key turning moments. Sometimes people want change to happen all of a sudden after an event like a march like that. In fact, you don't see the cultural change happening for years.
You know, I'm thinking again of the environmental movement here. You know, the Franklin Dam protesters, the protesters against logging the Daintery forest and so on. You know, they were key moments in Australia's history that the cultural change actually took a few years longer. And it involved political parties getting on board in that case, the Labour party.
It involved key court decisions. You know, so it often takes a whole load of sort of intersecting pieces. And only looking back and you say, oh, you know, those hit me on the Franklin, they were really under something. The problem, I think what's interesting is while you say it takes a long time for things to change culturally, but the problem isn't, surprisingly, I guess the problem isn't just about old, out of touch men in parliament and in our media.
Dr. Josh Ruse from Deakin University. On the ABC this week, he talked about research that showed that one in 17 men disagreed with the statement that women deserve equal rights to men. Now, that's 6% that didn't believe in equal rights.
So not great, but it's not a surprising figure by any means. However, the figure of one in three men under 35 was quite a surprise. So one in three men under 35 don't think that women deserve equal rights to men. So this, to me, points to a far deeper and much more disturbing schism in our society.
One, we can't just wait to disappear through generational change. What do you think we go from here? Can our political class seriously tackle this problem? Do you think our media can make sense of it, really?
It seems to run much deeper than any of us really give it credit for. And I think you're right. You can have all the political leadership in the world on some of these issues, but really you're talking about the men, boys, in our suburbs, in our cities, and acting, and rising to the expectations that many women have for them. And I don't know if that happens in parliament from changing, I mean, I think changing law is absolutely, sends a really strong message, but I suppose this is something where, yeah, when you say it like that, it's quite the question really.
It's quite struck me and, yeah, it's a big one. It really is Margaret. Yeah, and I think, you know, it's a mistake to think that those of us who are very engaged with this debate represent everyone, because we clearly don't. I mean, there was the National Attitude Survey into violence against women a few years ago, which likewise showed really quite concerning attitudes among young people, not only young men, but young people in particular about, you know, when a woman did or did not deserve to be the subject of violence, deserves to be the common thing, you can't do it in the common zone, right?
Yeah. I think there are still some very damaging ideas out there, but we shouldn't despair. It's only a very short while ago, and certainly in the span of my career, I think if these sorts of allegations have been raised in Parliament House 15 years ago, maybe even 10 years ago, it wouldn't have been regarded as a news story. It wouldn't have been headlines.
And the fact that it does now is not a complete and sufficient change on its own, but it is nevertheless a sign of real cultural change. And a big part of that, of course, is that the press gallery is now dominated by female journalists. If you were savvy hard-nosed women who have, like me, made their careers in a male-dominated industry, and certainly when I saw my career 34 years ago, sexual harassment in the newsroom was just the water in which we swam, you know, a daily endurance. I suppose as well today, it isn't just journalists or politicians who get to speak out and be heard.
You know, when we see the case of young women speaking out about consent and starting big campaigns online about the behaviour of their peers, we get to the digital world that we live in, women do have that big platform to speak out and to create their own sort of army to tackle these things and to let men know, or boys know, that what they're doing isn't okay. And I guess in this big conversation around consent, you know, I was only in high school 12 years ago or something, and that was not a conversation at all that was had amongst even my female friends. And I look back on things that have happened and I see them now in a totally different light. So, well, on the topic of consent, and I'm sure both of you know exactly where I'm about to go with this.
Today, New South Wales Police Commissioner Mick Fuller suggested a phone app would be an answer to the deep problems around consent, as if consent is like a tick box. Now, to be fair to me, Fuller, he now agrees with his high-destings, but it does, someone I guess tapped him on the shoulder, but it does point to a complete lack of understanding of what women face when it comes to consent and the low standard of behaviour. Why do so many men struggle with it? Why do they still struggle to get it?
First of you, Isabella? Well, I guess just kind of, as I mentioned, I don't think it was even really a word in people's vocabulary. I don't think it was something that, you know, men would sit around and at the pub and talk about, did you get consent from her? And I think on the flip side, I don't actually know if women talked about consent or had the language to understand that that was a thing.
I think you'd get generations of women who would describe feeling pressured into doing things, but perhaps at the time they just internalised that shame and didn't realise it was this thing called consent. So I think it's changing certainly for all those reasons I just mentioned before. But I just don't know if it was a part of the conversation around relationships, around sexual relationships, and I think it's about time it did. But it's also very hard to understand, I think sometimes it isn't a black and white issue.
It changes with time in an incident, you know, and someone using an app and saying, yeah, I'm ready now. It doesn't mean two minutes later, that it's the same thing. Very true, Margaret. Yeah, no, I agree.
I mean, it was just an extraordinary step and it's a great example of how men do struggle with this idea, because it seems to me, and at this point, has been well made by others. That idea is more about protecting the men from prosecution than it is about protecting women, which to his creative, and again, we take our hope where we can find it, it's practically recognised and acknowledged, I think, and once upon a time I don't think it would have been. And we've seen in the past police, for example, suggesting that women should walk in certain places at certain times, in other words, implying that when they're assaulted or even raped, as a result of their own actions, or putting the responsibility where it belongs. But I do think things are moving.
I think police are less likely to do that now, and they're quickly called out on it. And we've had a few examples over the last few years, I think we're policing others, so recognise their error quickly. Of course, it'd be much better if it might be areas in the first place. We have high hopes.
It's been over a month now since the Britney Higgins story broke, and close to a month since the allegations that have gone on to embroil the Attorney General, Christian Porter. The lifespan of these two stories has been quite extraordinary, especially given that we live in an age where we really hung really cycled through media in such a fast-paced fashion. Stories don't usually have the legs that these two have had. Why do you think that is?
Why are we still debating them so hot, like Margaret first of you? Well, I think it's that the allegations are absolutely shocking, and I think, uncrecedented. Again, I'm not saying that there never has been a Reagan-Povent House before. In fact, I'll be willing to lay money.
There probably has been, but women, young women, are more likely to come forward now. The media is more likely to recognise it as an issue, so too, the politicians, and a large part of this is because there are more women around. You know, still, among the politicians, still under 50%, well under 50% in the most powerful positions, but there's still a heap of women there who simply weren't there a generation ago. That makes a real difference, and I've already talked about the change in the gender mix in the press gallery.
And the coverage of young women, women in their 20s and 30s who are willing to expose themselves by coming forth and talking about this. So, I do think it's the culmination of some cultural changes which have been a long time cooking, but as well, of course, there's just a sheer seriousness of the allegations. We have a very serious, a very serious crime, it's an incredibly serious allegation against the Attorney General. I often think, well, how would it be different if, for example, he'd be accused of a serious fraud or an armed robbery or something?
Would it be regarded differently? But is that sort of scale as well as more serious than fraud? And I can't think of any time in our history where a serving politician has that seniority has been accused of such a serious crime, a bit long before he was in politics. So I don't think that's surprising that that one's headlines and of course his suit definition, that will take another couple of years, at least, to play out.
So we're going to be talking about it for a long while yet. Is it that? I just think this is kind of the issue of our time. You know, we've had the Me Too movement in recent years, women all around the world are talking about how they've been treated by men.
I don't think Australia is immune to that conversation. I think maybe we're even a tiny bit behind. And now we have also, you know, Grace Taim as Australian of the Year talking about these issues. It's never been, you know, more of a talking point amongst every Australians and then to have this sort of allegation made against such a senior politician.
I think Shek's people to the core makes them question who they can trust and makes people feel really disappointed. And I think there's just a desperate desire from the community to have some resolution to this. And of course, we know it's a really messy situation and we might, well, we're probably not going to get that. So people are just interested.
They're glued to their phones. I want to know what's happening in this case. And I think even more than that, they're desperately looking for a bit of leadership to say from our political leadership to say, is this okay or not? Because we're having this whole sort of cultural reckoning around this issue.
How do our politicians act to this? And I think the fact that so many women stepped out in March showed that many of them are very disappointed in that response. Margaret, you recently penned a really interesting piece for Inside Story. And you talked about how with the benefit of hindsight, we can now see the hole in four corners inside the Canberra bubble episode from back in November, which it seemed to allude to things more than it could actually reveal.
And it felt a bit thin at the time. Could you talk us through some of your analysis on this and also the more recent follow-up episode? Sure. Well, at the time that that first episode was screened, I had another piece of some for Inkland's case, which I defended it instead, but I did think it was digital journalism.
It was exposure of problems in relationships of power and so on. But I thought the stuff about Minister Tudge, for example, which was basically revealing that he had the fear outside marriage. I thought that was a bit marginal, whether that was legitimately in the public realm. But the Christian court of allegations basically of long-term socialistic behaviour, I thought met the test of legitimate journalism.
But nevertheless, it did feel a bit thin. And I think we now can see that at the heart of the plan for that programme was something which the ABC was not able to put to air due to legal advice. And it took the release of the letter into the public realm to change that equation. Well, in recent years on Fourth Estate, we've discussed defamation law and, at times, quite muzzling impact on journalism.
What are your concerns about the Attorney General taking legal action against the ABC and Louise Milligan? Well, defamation is a very blunt instrument, and it's not a good instrument for getting it to the truth. And I think the Attorney General knows this. He has previously called for and been working on reform as a defamation law saying that they don't strike a good balance between the public's right to know and people's right to protect their reputations.
Having said that, given that the Prime Minister has locked in this idea that there will be no other form of inquiry, I can understand that the reporter wants to attempt to clear his name. It doesn't leave him with very many options. I wonder whether if he had his time again, he would actually ask for an inquiry. I think politically that's now impossible.
It would involve such a huge climb down for the Prime Minister. But in some ways, if I was trying to clear my name, I would probably want an inquiry. And defamation is a very clunky, difficult, slow and unsatisfactory process for all sides, I have to say. And as I say, not necessarily very good at getting to the truth.
So he's entitled to sue, of course. The ABC is entitled to defend itself. But I don't know if it's going to shed much light in the long run. Does it make sense to either of you that Christian Porter is staying in his position as Attorney General while he's engaged in a major defamation case against the ABC?
Margaret? Look, I think it creates a whole load of management and exception problems. As I say, Attorney General is actually meant to be negotiating on reforms to defamation law right now. The conflict obviously has been pointed out any further.
Will he still be as enthusiastic about reforming the law, as he would have been, whether he's not a significant himself. He also, of course, presides over the federal court where the case will be heard. And that's before you get to his responsibility for a heap of legislation which is directly to do with violence against women and equal opportunity. Now, are they actual conflicts of interest or any perceived conflict of interest?
Either way, it's a bit of a problem. I note that the Prime Minister has said today that he's sought advice from the Solicitor General on what duties the Attorney General should not perform during this period. And I'm glad that the Prime Minister has remembered that there is an office that called the Solicitor General. I think it would have been helpful if he asked him for advice earlier on in the day.
But he's done that now. But it creates a perception problem and a management problem. And I think that's one of the other things which is going to make sure that this continues to be a bit of a festering soul for the government. And look, what I will say is whether these allegations are true or not, I think we kind of know that we're never going to go through a criminal trial and we're never going to be able to test it in that way.
Whether these allegations are true or not, I think there is a question for the Prime Minister of do you ever think your Attorney General can truly perform with these allegations hanging over his head? Can he really stand up and speak to the Australian public and then not question him because of these allegations and look politics is an affair game, but it is also a game of optics. And there's a really big question of optics here that I think Margaret's explained quite well. Looking at the papers that have been filed by Porter's legal team, they are pinning the ABC solely for identification of Porter.
But as we all know before he formally identified himself, social media was awash with his name. And also before he identified himself, all of the mainstream news sites were covering the story quite extensively as well. The Australian news.com in particular. Does it make sense to shirt all the blame onto the ABC for this, Margaret?
Well, I'm not a media lawyer, but I would have thought that was one of the issues that's like he'd come up before the court because while Louise Milliken broke the story, and was first in office or mentioned on Twitter account, but very quickly that story was published, all the other media were very quick to follow up. The senators who had received the letter and the company material were all roned by journalists. So too with the various friends of the complainant. I was actually an Adelaide at the Adelaide Writers Festival immediately after that.
We were just about all of those friends seemed to be hanging around and you know, that's all about the ABC and Milliken and what other media were doing at the time. And of course, a lot of people on Twitter went off and did their own research. And yes, it's any journals correct. They were able to identify him or at least come to a strong suspicion about his identity.
But you know, they were off doing their own research and if you like their own inverted comments, journalism to come to that conclusion. So yeah, I suspect that that's one of the issues that will come up before the extent to which it was the ABC's responsibility and the extent that it was more diffused than that. Also this week, we saw Nicole Flynn to announce that she wouldn't be recontending her seat at the next election as she was citing harassment and bullying. And the issue has quickly been put through the prism of partisan politics with a number of her contentions, a fairly heavily disputed.
We are time and time again that we should believe victims. Do you think politics can ever be removed when it's happening in our major parties? Isabella to you? I would say no.
And I think there's just this huge broader question when we are having this kind of reckoning with sexual assaults at the treatment of women. Is that the reality also is going through the criminal system and trying to stick justice through those means. I mean, for many, many years, we've heard people say that the system is stacked against survivors and it's incredibly hard to prove these things, which is why I think you have people who turn to the media who want to have their own justice, and that is the way they seek it. I think for a really long time, we've considered how our justice system can treat people better, can listen to the stories, but it's really imperfect.
And I think we are still very much stuck in this mindset of, you know, when there is a perfect victim and a perfect perpetrator, we can understand it. But when there's any sort of gray area, it just becomes far too much for any of us to really understand or comprehend. Very interesting analysis, Margaret. Yeah, and I agree.
I mean, the standard of proof in criminal matters is very high, and that's exactly as it should be, you know, to the state to find people or lock them up is an enormous use of state power, and it should only be used when we are confident that it's justified under the criminal law. But to pretend that that deals with all the issues in society, that if you can't prove something beyond reasonable doubt, then, you know, there's nothing to see here. Well, that's just clearly wrong. And a number of lawyers who have responded to the prime minister statements about the law of law have made that point that there are all sorts of issues that organizations workplaces individuals have to deal with all the time, which are not mainly or at all to do with the criminal law.
Now, Peter Van Anselen had a bit of an interesting time on Twitter over the weekend. He and Janet Albrecht in the Australian Road, quite heavily criticized peace, actually, about the deceased woman at the center of the Christian Porter allegations, and they published details from Hadocea. And I'm going to quote here, chilling and never before published details from Christian Porter's accuser can be revealed for the first time. Now, readers can judge for themselves.
I'd like to get the panel's thoughts about this. Was it in the public's interest? Well, and also should Peter Van Anselen declare he was a longtime friend of Christian Porter and should his name ever have been on the pace. Margaret, can you go first?
Yeah, look, my main reaction to that, leaving aside for the moment the privacy issues, I suppose, and the distress that was caused to the complainant's family. I just didn't think it had much. Now, admittedly, I've been following this very closely. They had to more closely than many ordinary leaders of the Australian would have been.
But I didn't learn anything from that I didn't already know from other media coverage. So, you know, this sort of slightly breathless way in which it was presented. I thought it was a bit overplayed, really. They knew have the ethical issues, but I'm actually less troubled by that given, as I say, I don't think it actually had much most of the stuff that was significant there had already been reported in the same to me.
In terms of Van Anselen, I had a declaration to make here, a long while ago, and I am one of the few people who remembers this, the Australian Hado people campaign against me about a perceived conflict of interest on my part, which I don't want to bore your listeners by going into ancient history. I didn't have a conflict of interest, but anyway, it was manufactured to look as though I might have. And Van Anselen was extremely critical of me doing that period in a way which I totally disagree with. However, you know, I have been noticing the irony, and I think, yes, it would be appropriate for him to at the very least declare his friendship.
And I think if it were me, I would not be reporting on this issue. Now, I realize that's difficult when he is a political reporter, and this is the main political item in the news. But nevertheless, I think that he and his aid is should be seriously considering whether it's appropriate for him to be reporting on this, but at the very least, a declaration, I think. Very full circle, really.
I want to make too much of it. It is really ancient history. And I've never had any other dealings with Van Anselen, really. So, you know, I don't think particularly personal against him, but I do find it ironic that he was very quick to judge me.
So it's now doing something which I regard anyway, much more the conflict than any other. Well, I mean, I think we all often say if only we could take our own advice. So it's a valid to you. I think what I'll say is if it were my friend who were involved in this sort of level of public debate for personal and professional reasons, I think I would make every step not to be covering that story.
I don't think I would want to be weighing in publicly, despite perhaps your personal inclinations to want to. I feel like in my role as the National Indigenous Affairs reporter covering Indigenous communities, you are forced to kind of reckon with that quite often how close is too close and check your own bias all the time. In fact, I would argue as an Indigenous journalist, you're asked to kind of prove your lack of bias more than others. But it's something I do with all the time.
And there's been many times where I have said I'm too close to this. I am too close to that person. It's a really delicate game balancing context and professional and personal relationships. So I would just say look at something I'm mindful of.
And I would like to think if it were me, I would be choosing not to weigh in. A number of people made the point that the piece ignored or actually trivialized the nature of trauma. So Guardian, Australia's Amy Rameek has wrote on Twitter that on a particularly low day, I'd scratched, I hate myself. I've run over in different sizes.
On another, I wrote fuck 128 times. Screaming inside your head can't always be set out loud. So you write it and hope for calm. Judging someone's story on a few pages is reprehensible.
There are some deep ethical elements to how the media has covered this event. But it shows that journalists are not also necessarily skilled to talk about matters of trauma and mental health. Not all journalists are. It's about I think you'd be the appropriate person to ask about this.
Do you think we need specialist reporters, more specialist reporters in this area? You're a specialist reporter yourself? Not particularly in this area, but you actually do deal with trauma on a daily basis really. I think as a country, we probably don't really understand trauma, how it affects people, the fact that it can affect everything right down to the way they choose to communicate in workplace, let alone how it might impact how a victim of a very serious crime chooses to live her life or interact forever.
I think if we have reporters who understand these things, it can only be for the public good. It can only lead to better, more robust reporting. And I also think from kind of an ethical standpoint of as a journalist, it probably means that we treat people who are in our stories better. That is this constant challenge I feel like I have where there is a news cycle and then there's often a family who are grieving or there is someone who is grieving something horrific that's happened to them.
And you feel like you need to rip them into the news agenda at the moment, perhaps where they're not quite ready. That is this conflict we have as journalists all the time is that I don't think the news agenda or the way the news works particularly serves victims very well, especially in the 24-hour news cycle where you feel like you could be beaten by a big news story. So specialist reporters I think, and obviously I am one, so I would say that they're worth their money. But I think it's better for everyone.
I think it's better for the public. I think it's better for those who are being interviewed for those who are choosing to share their stories and probably accountability as well. Peter Van Onselen's friendship with reporters, not exactly unique in the media, far from it. We've spoken about the chummy nature of the press gallery on the fourth state before.
We all know if political staff are coming to analysts and many journalists have become political staff or gone into politics. They'll go out drinking together and they even in some cases sleep together. Is this just the messy reality of human affairs or is there a need for clear lines? Do you think Margaret?
Oh, look, no, heading back, there were so many examples of that line if it is a line being crossed. But I think it is appropriate to ask what should we do going forward? I would have thought that if you're sleeping with somebody, your chances of actually being able to report on them objectively are pretty slim and you shouldn't be trying to do it. So, yeah, no, it's fun.
It's really. It's both a problematic part of the message. So, yeah. I mean, I have done nowhere near as much political reporting as you Margaret, but it struck me the very first time I went into the press gallery.
Just the fact that the Parliament House building is completely disconnected from the rest of Australia. You're up on this hill. You're in this building. There's not all that many places to eat or drink.
And it's almost like you lose sight of the purpose of the politics of the journalism when you're just kind of locked into the cage that is Parliament House. I don't know what your thoughts are. Yeah, and I actually wrote a whole book about the culture of the parliamentary press gallery back in the 90s. And yes, I mean everybody catches the same lips.
They speak the same language. They're watching each other really closely, maneuvering all the time for advantage. And it's quite unique. The Australian system is the only one in which the press gallery and the politicians are sort of so close to each other all in the same building.
And often with key departmental staff and public servants as well in the place. So it's a real hot house. And it's not writing that lines are crossed. Oh, and you can't even step out and get a coffee or a sandwich and not see normal people going about their day.
It's all people who are in that business who are living and breathing it just like you. I think that kind of brings the culture as well. And the hours are in long, the pressures are enormous. The only people who fully understand the pressures of the other people in that world.
So no, it's not at all a healthy environment and it never has been. Just on mental health, I might have to say a little bit about reporting of mental health issues. I think there is a change for the better there. You mentioned in your intro that I was involved in general education for quite a long period.
And we were certainly teaching reporting of mental health issues and there's a wonderful organisation called Mind Train that used to send the University classes to talk about it. So I think the generalists who graduated in the last few years, and I'm interested in what you think about this, but I think there is much more awareness than I would have had, for example, when I first started doing journalism. So I'm hoping that we'll see improvements in that. I don't want to be smug and say we're already seeing it.
But I think there is a great level of awareness, my young journalists, and I would have had it the same age. Yeah, and I guess probably in line with society expectations and cultural change as well. And you've got lots of organisations with a kind of adjacent to the media industry, putting out guidelines and things like that, which certainly helps. So Brittany Higgins was a month ago and Peter Van Anselen was on our end breakfast today saying, next week, more serious allegations will be coming.
So this matter is going to consume us for at least another week, but probably far longer, as we've already mentioned. It's a vitally important issue, but it's not the only one. The recent indigenous deaths in custody have struggled to be covered properly. Is this because we're now preoccupied, or is this how deaths in custody are treated by the media?
It's funny you say that because actually, as I was walking here, I bumped into a friend who said, oh yeah, I heard about those. Wow, they didn't get much air time, did they? So I think probably your observations are correct. And it's sometimes hard for me to know because it's all icy.
You know, it's my whole media, my whole social media, blows up when these sort of issues happen. But it's someone who's also been looking into covering the anniversary, the 30th anniversary of the Royal Commission, it's 30 years in April. And looking back at old's media reports, I think our history of reporting on these issues, it's not good the way we describe people. I mean, I was watching an old tape where a journalist stands over the grave of someone who took their own life in prison and describes them as a disturbed, petty criminal.
You know, so I think we have come quite a way, but it is just this constant issue you face in indigenous affairs where it is 3% of the population, that the issues sometimes don't feel fresh and new because they have been around for decades and decades. And it is the job of journalists like me to try and keep people engaged and in this new digital world where you've got the instant feedback mechanism of digital clicks, you can see what's rating and what's not. It's really difficult to carve up your piece of the media pie. And I think ultimately the result is a lack of accountability.
You have politicians, successive governments who choose not to act on these things. And it isn't just a matter of sad statistics and figures, it is mum's dad's brothers, sisters who grew up with loved ones. And I think sometimes we lose sight of that. Margaret, in the 30-class years that you've spent in journalism, I mean, have you seen much of a...
A shift in terms of the way we speak about this issue and the way we report on it? Well, certainly now we're near enough. I mean, again, I'm also a member of the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Blitz in custody back in 1997, in the early days of my career. And it was headline news then for weeks on end.
And I think there was, you know, real hope that that would be a turning point, that things would change as a result. And it's so clearly obvious, no one knew enough has changed. Most of the recommendations that Royal Commission would never implement it. It's just terrible really, that we know so much about this.
We even know many of the solutions and we haven't taken the markets. It's shameful. And it is one of those things where I think we often blame political leadership, say that they're not interested in not acting. But I do think there's a broader role that the public plays in this and having an interest in pushing for these things as well.
You know, we know politicians act when there is a desire from the electorate. And I think the Indigenous experience is quite different to some of the things that even you see in America where you have a much larger part of the population who are pushing and calling for these issues. And therefore also more people from those communities in places of power who push from the inside. Well, this week is obviously the week of Close the Gap.
Isabella, what would you like to see going forward in the next few weeks in terms of how we have this conversation? Oh, gosh, that's a big question. It's a bit broader. Look, what struck me is that I have been reading reports and it's very similar to what Margaret said.
So much work has been done. There has been, you know, sometimes people in the Indigenous community described death by consultancy where people die waiting for the next round of consultations, but no actions. So I think if we know the solutions are out there, perhaps it's time for journalists to report the solutions, to highlight the solutions, but also to push for accountability for those many, many reports that have been created that hours were poured into and that's seen on shelves collecting dust. And I think, you know, it is really important sometimes to capture the strength of the Indigenous community that so often it is incredible women who are leading the change who were doing incredible work at the grassroots who are changing who are really changing lives in the absence of big structural change.
So I think there's incredible stories to be told out there. And for me, they are Australian stories. They are not Indigenous stories. They are some of the best stories out there.
Did you see much diversity at any of the women's marches this week? Women of color represented fairly, do you think? I don't know if they were the ones leading it. I certainly know many people myself who attended.
You know, I know my mum was out there with a whole group of, you know, Aboriginal women who she hangs out with and they were there loud and proud. But I think there's definitely a chance to pass the microphone over to some of the really strong Aboriginal women on this because we know that the gender issues they face are interlaid with all these other issues around racism, stereotypes or lack of access to services. You know, it's compounded really by the experience of colonization and racism. So I think we definitely can pass the mic over to some of those really strong women during this close-up gap week.
Well, on that note, I think thank you to both my guests, Margaret Simons and Isabelle Higgins for joining us on Fourth Estate this week. Great to chat in. If you or someone you know is impacted by sexual assault or violence, call 1-800-Respect on 1-800-737-732 or visit 1-800-Respect.org.au. And thank you for listening to Fourth Estate.
This edition was recorded out the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back with more next week of course, but in the meantime, just stay in touch with us on Twitter and handle us on Fourth Estate.au.
As always, a big thanks to my executive producer Anthony Dockrill. My name's Nina Quinn. You can catch us next week on Fourth Estate. A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen.
It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer. That's how we protect Ontario.
For all of us. Learn how at ontario.ca.saferontario paid for by the Government of Ontario.