Hey there, it's Liel. I'm dropping into your feed today to share something that just couldn't wait. Because earlier this week, we were very lucky to have Congressman Richie Torres stop by Tablet's offices. If you're a New Yorker, you know him as the United States representative from the Bronx. If you're a Jew, you might recognize him for being an ardent Zionist and a fierce defender of Israel, even or especially when it was not at all politically expedient to do so. The Congressman sat with me and Tablet Editor-in-Chief Alana Newhouse for what I believe is his most candid conversation to date.
So as you head into Shabbat and the weekend, I hope you'll enjoy this timely conversation about the Democratic Party and the Jews, about our urgent deficit of patriotism, about Israel haters and their scare tactics, and about how being a Zionist is, sadly, making the congressman's dating life more complicated than it needs to be. Have a listen. Welcome, congressman. It's an honor to be here. Although, before we begin, we just want to make sure we get this right, unlike some of our colleagues in the media. You are indeed Richie Torres. Just making sure. I am not the lieutenant governor, Antonio Delgado.
I am not Trevor Noah. I'm not George Santos. I'm the other Jewish gay Latino congressman from New York. So I'm Richard Torres. It is an absolute honor to have you here. These are not simple, easy days for you. Just the other day, a certain other New York politician who shall remain nameless accused you of trying to gain political power, insinuating that you were only kind of expressing pro-Israel views to get the support of, shall we say, people who control all the media and the banks. And I wonder, before we even dive into the issues, you've been such an amazing vocal supporter of the Jewish community, of Israel, getting a lot of flack for it.
What have the last seven, eight months been like for you? There's a sense in which it's been a nightmare. There's no issue on which I face more hate, harassment, and death threats than on the issue of Israel. Even my mother's been the target of harassment. There were activists who said to my mother, you're a genocide mother and you should have aborted your son. It's put strain on personal relationships. I have a sibling who has jumped on the free Palestine bandwagon. We have not spoken in months.
I don't know if I could share this, but it's actually had an effect on my dating life. There are people who will not go on dates with me because I'm pro-Israel. I'll tell one quick story if it's not too personal. I went on a date with someone who I'm openly gay brother, for the record. And this person said, you know, Richie, I support everything you stand for except one issue. And I said, what's the issue? He said, Israel. And when I said that I was a Zionist, he reacted as if I had uttered the word Nazi. So I proceeded to explain what the word Zionism meant.
And then at the end of the date, he asked for my number. So I put in the notes section, Richie Torres, your favorite Zionist. Richie, you're about to have about 18,000 Jewish women in your inbox with their son's numbers. So you'll have what to choose from. But you can tell all of those people that you're Zionist. Look, I was speaking at Temple Emanuel and there was a protester who interrupted and said, Richie Torres, are you a Zionist? She screams, are you a Zionist? And I said, look, I've never been in the closet of a Zionist. I'm proud as a Zionist. It's Pride Month and I'm proud of my Zionist.
So I think a lot of people listening to us, many of whom would define themselves as, you know, just kind of lifelong Democrats who are proud of the party, proud of what it believed, all of a sudden wake up, many of them after October 7th, some of them, you know, a little bit before, and realize that this is not their mother's Democrat party. All of a sudden there are people in this party and kind of like movements in this party that support and cheer on things that would have been completely unthinkable even, you know, 15 years ago. Pro-Hamas demonstrations in major university campuses, et cetera, et cetera. Explain to these people, how did we get here? So for me, the two disproportionate drivers of anti-Semitism, particularly on the left, the far left, are academia and social media. There are a web of ideas like intersectionality, critical theory, decolonization that have been percolating for a long time. But social media is what has enabled those ideas to permeate outward into the broader society. And what is unprecedented is not anti-Semitism itself. What's unprecedented is the algorithmic amplification of anti-Semitism on platforms like TikTok and Twitter.
You know, social media has enabled the virus of anti-Semitism to spread at a pace and to an extent we've never seen before. You know, viruses tend to have varying levels of lethality and transmissibility. There have been moments in history when anti-Semitism has been more lethal, but never in history has it been as transmissible as it is in this present moment. So I would attribute it to TikTok, Twitter, and academic institutions. It seems like there's one more factor to take into account, especially if we're going to talk about the relationship of Jews to the Democratic Party, which is a big area of concern for our readers, which is the Iran deal.
Because for many of our readers, especially looking back now, the last 10 years, there's a sense that the party embraced a realignment of American investment in the Middle East that feels like it has a host of downstream effects that generate anti-Jewish sentiment and anti-Zionism. And that is something that came out of the Democratic Party. And it feels... complicated and confusing for certain people inside of the Jewish community now to look back at that. And I wonder whether or not you could help us parse our way through understanding, the Middle East is obviously an incredibly complicated region, but understanding how we should understand that foreign policy move. I respectfully disagree. I feel like the trends that drive anti-Semitism.
long free date, the Iran deal. And look, if you are calling for the violent destruction of Israel as a Jewish state, then you're crossing a line that should never be crossed. I do feel, and I say this even as a critic of the Iran deal, I would have voted against the JCPOA, but it is an issue on which reasonable people of goodwill can disagree. The question of how best to prevent Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon is a complicated question that has no simple answer. And so I would not put it in the same category as supporting BDS. You can be pro-Israel, but be naive. And I feel like the trouble with the Iran deal was not that it was nefarious, is that it was naive. It was based on...
the wishful thought that if only we integrate Iran with the international community, then maybe it will magically moderate over time. Well, as China became more integrated with the West, it became more emboldened in its authoritarianism, not less. As Russia became more integrated with the West, it became more emboldened in its authoritarianism, not less. So why assume Iran is an exception to the rule? The lesson learned from recent history is that enriching your enemies does not make them your friends. It simply makes them more powerful enemies. And the logical question surrounding the JCPOA 2.0 is if we were to lift the sanctions and free up billions of dollars, tens of billions, maybe hundreds of billions of dollars,
where are those dollars going to go? How are those dollars going to be spent? If I thought those dollars would be spent on an Iranian Inflation Reduction Act, I would have no objections. But those dollars will likely be spent on proxy warfare and terrorism against Israel and our allies in the Sunni Arab world. And the United States should not be unwittingly subsidizing terrorism against our allies. But I see it as an issue of naivete, not nefariousness. Is that why, you know, one of the things that you and I sometimes disagree about is what you do when confronted with an institution that feels either broken or seriously hobbled.
I have impulses toward abandonment and making new things. And you have argued beautifully and very powerfully for the importance of preserving and not throwing out the gold that is still inside of an institution. Could you apply that idea to... Or do you apply that idea when you think about the Democratic Party and Jews, for example, American Jews now feeling anxious about their own political affiliation and wondering if they shouldn't abandon the party? I feel if you care deeply about the survival and security of the Jewish state, then you have a vested interest in ensuring that both political parties remain pro-Israel. There is no universe in which the U.S.-Israel relationship can succeed without bipartisan support. If you put all your eggs in one basket, in one political party, in a two-party system.
you will eventually fail because there are going to be moments when there's a Democratic Congress and a Republican Congress. There are going to be moments when there's a Democratic president and a Republican president. And we want to ensure that the U.S.-Israeli relationship is so strong that it transcends the vicissitudes of American politics. And so if you are a member of the Jewish diaspora and if you're a member of the Israeli government, you have an obligation to ensure that you have a strong presence in both political parties and a working relationship with both political parties. And if you're a progressive Jew or a liberal Jew in the Democratic Party and you're rethinking your allegiances, my view is if you purge yourself, you're simply doing the bidding of your enemies. You're simply playing into the hands of those.
who want the Democratic Party to become anti-Israel. So I feel like if you're a Democrat, you should fight for the soul of your party. The common criticism from those of us on the left is that the center-right fundamentally failed to stand up to the far-right, and as a result, the Republican Party has become little more than a cult of personality around Donald Trump. So we should do in the Democratic Party what the Republican Party catastrophically failed to do. We should stand up to the extremes on our own side.
I think about your job a lot, really, more than I should. It's depressing. I think how hard, just the job description that you sign up for, right? I want to be a congressman for the Bronx. There's a lot that needs doing, you know, a lot of jobs and crime and things that, you know, a congressman is in charge of doing. And then all of a sudden, it's also not just, you know, this crisis of Israel anti-Semitism, but really the recognition that these two parties are going through like tectonic, like plate shifts, that the whole system, social media, the whole way we perceive of reality and the truth is changing. Is this a job that's simply too big for government? The challenges are daunting.
But the challenges are often, it's often true that the magnitude of our challenges far exceeds the efforts of one person or the efforts of a party. But I feel like I'm optimistic, not by temperament, but by necessity. Like, if I thought I was too powerless to make a difference in the world, then what would be the point in serving in public office? Like, I'm a public servant precisely because I feel I could serve the public. I can represent my constituents effectively and bring us closer to a more perfect union.
And our present moment is far from the greatest challenge that our countries have to face. Like, I feel like we get too caught up in presentism. We ascribe far more importance to the present than it warrants. The greatest, and I would even say this to fellow Democrats, like the greatest challenge, I feel Donald Trump is a challenge to our democracy, but he's not the greatest challenge. The Civil War was the greatest challenge. Slavery was the greatest challenge. Jim Crow was the greatest challenge. And even though I'm concerned about the volcanic eruptions of anti-Semitism on college campuses and social media platforms, it still pales in comparison.
to the violence of the 1960s, the assassination of a president, the assassination of a presidential candidate, the assassination of MLK or one of our greatest civil rights leaders. And so we have to put everything in perspective. And I feel like there's no sense of history when assessing the moment in which we find ourselves. This is a topic that I'm super interested in and have been since before October 7th, but increasingly since then, which is the relationship between demoralization and propaganda or demoralization and campaigns designed to make you feel isolated or make you feel under attack. When I think about that and I think about some of the ways in which you are able to constantly excavate optimism and hope and context, I wonder about your experience being bombarded with some of the most vicious and I think actually bordering on inhuman social media campaigns. And could you just give us a little bit of a window into what it's like to be inside of that panopticon and how it relates to your ability to generate optimism? Look, it has never been more challenging to be an elected official than it is in the age of 24-7 social media.
and cable news and the sheer vitriol of our politics is hard to overstate, particularly on social media. But, you know, I refuse to live in fear. My view is the greatest threat to our democracy does not come from the far right or from the far left. They come from a center that lives in fear of the extremes. Like Franklin Roosevelt was exactly right when he said the only thing we have to fear is fear itself. And for me, the Achilles heel of most elected officials, including many in Congress, is what I call a pathological need to be loved by everyone.
And I thank God every day that I'm so socially ill-adjusted that I have no need to be loved by anyone. And I'm willing to stand up for what I think is right, even if it means standing alone. And I'm reminded of the words of George Orwell, who said, in a time of deceit, truth-telling is a revolutionary act. And so I prefer to engage in the revolutionary act of telling the truth and show that it's possible to tell the truth and not only survive, but even thrive politically. I'm going my second term without a primary challenge.
So when you project strength, you deter your enemies. Whereas if you capitulate and show weakness, it's not only bad morals, it's also bad politics. Are we victims of a propaganda campaign? I mean, there's no greater victim of a propaganda campaign than the Jewish people. I mean, BDS may be the most successful propaganda campaign. Before October 7th, the narrative was that Israel was an apartheid state. After October 7th, it's now a genocidal state. And we're living in an alternate reality. We're living in an Orwellian universe where...
Evil has become good, and wrong has become right, and aggression has become self-defense, and terrorism has become resistance. The world is upside down. So many of us, you know, have this instinct, which was fashioned in nice, good universities. You had a good sense of dropping out. Sadly, you know, some of us were far less intelligent, that you have to have a debate, that you have to present the facts, that if only you found some good and, you know, meaningful, convincing way of explaining to the other side that you're not really committing genocide, you're not really an apartheid state, et cetera, et cetera, then this debate would lead to some kind of reckoning, understanding and growth. It's kind of like the mid-90s American vision of civic, you know, fortitude. I think the thought...
That this is no longer the case and that we are living in this Orwellian universe is way too dispiriting for a lot of people to bear because if we don't have this, what do we have? We have no shared set of facts, no shared set of perceptions of reality, no shared language. It's as if we're speaking a foreign language. But there's one point that I've neglected to make. The problem with the Free Palestine movement, the problem with our institutions is not only anti-Semitism, it's also anti-Americanism. Like we have our own institutions are indoctrinating the next generation of Americans. Not only with a hatred for Israel, but with a hatred for their own country. And I'm aware of no civilization in human history that has ever succeeded.
on the strength of self-loathing. And so the lack of patriotism in America is a real crisis. I remember reading a poll from the Wall Street Journal showing that in 1998, 70% of Americans identified themselves as patriotic. And by 2023, it was down to 38%. There's a real hemorrhaging of patriotism in the American body politic. And I look to Israel for inspiration. You know, Israel has a shared language because everyone in Israel, almost everyone in Israel, most people in Israel.
have the shared experience of military service. Imagine if we in the United States had not necessarily military service, but national service, some common experience out of which we could form a common language, a common story of who we are as a people. And even during the divisive debates about judicial reform, I was struck by the patriotism of the Israeli left. The problem with the American left is that it has ceded patriotism to the right. But in Israel, I saw...
Israeli left-wing protesters singing Haqtikvah, the Israeli national anthem, and waving the Israeli flag and proudly proclaiming a love of country. And so I feel like we, the American left, has much to learn from the patriotism of the Israeli left. Because you go to any protest, any encampment movement on any college campus anywhere in America, you will see no one singing the American anthem, no one waving the American flag. In fact, you might see people desecrating the American flag and replacing it with a Palestinian flag. So it's not only a crisis of anti-Semitism, it's a crisis of anti-Americanism. And a country that no longer believes in itself will not long endure.
I actually think that the crisis of anti-Americanism is a much deeper problem. And that, in fact, the anti-Zionism and anti-Israelism is a costume for it. So my question for you is, how do we fix America? I have a simplistic answer. Great. Let's go with that one. I think patriotism. Patriotism. Yes, patriotism and excess can be dangerous, but the opposite can be equally dangerous. That every country, every civilization needs some degree of self-love. And we should have institutions that instill...
you know, patriotism in moderation. You know, what is the story of America? What is the story of ourselves? You know, I love America, and I'm a liberal Democrat. I'll just quickly tell my own story. You know, 15 years ago, I was at the lowest point in my life. I had dropped out of college. I found myself struggling with depression, abusing substances. I attempted suicide. I underwent hospitalization. I felt as if the world around me had collapsed. And I never thought seven years later I would become the youngest elected official in America's largest city.
and then seven years later become a member of the United States Congress. And I feel like only in America is a story like mine possible. I think of myself as a liberal patriot. And for me, the best definition of patriotic liberalism came from Bill Clinton, who said that there's nothing that's wrong with America, that cannot be cured by what's right with America. And so we have to recover the sense of America as a more perfect union.
as an experiment that can be perfected. And the great irony of modern progressivism is that it often denies not only the reality, but the very possibility of progress. Thank you so much. We are so grateful to have had you here today. Thank you. Absolutely. Pleasure. I hope you enjoyed this episode. But before we let you go, one more thing. Very soon, we will be inviting you to join us in celebrating Tablet's 15th birthday. Starting next week, we will be sharing our favorite pieces and offering a bunch of birthday perks for Tablet members, a party favor from us to you. So stay tuned for more Soonest.