Hello and welcome back to For The State, the show where journalists talk journalism. I'm Tina Quinn, joining you from Gallagher Land, Sydney. Thanks so much for your company. In the last few weeks, as the so-called ceasefire between Israel and Hamas collapsed, the Benjamin Netanyahu-led government has openly resumed its ferocious attack on the occupied Palestinian territories. The ceasefire, which had begun in January and lasted just eight weeks, barely lived up to its name to begin with.
During that time, Israel continued its attacks on Gaza, killing more than 150 Palestinians. The last remnants of the ceasefire were shattered when the Israeli Prime Minister launched one of the deadliest bombing campaigns on Gaza since this latest conflict kicked off 18 months ago, followed by an expansive ground invasion. The official death toll has risen above 50,000, although experts warn the number is likely to be much higher. Among the many accusations of war crimes that Israel stands accused of is targeting both aid workers and journalists. Recent numbers show that 232 journalists and media workers have been killed since the October 7th attacks, but after the last fortnight, that number will no doubt be much higher.
higher. Two weeks ago, a 23-year-old Al Jazeera journalist Hassam Shabbat was killed in northern Gaza when his car was targeted by the IDF. Mohammed Mansur, who worked for Palestine Today, was also killed on the same day in a separate Israeli attack. This week saw the death of 29-year-old Islam Migdad, who, along with her two-year-old son Adam, were killed in an air raid, both buried beneath the rubble of their home. A day later, a horrific IDF strike on a number of media tents saw three more journalists not only killed, but burned alive. Many more were injured and are still fighting for their lives. More journalists have perished in this conflict than in any other before it. It's remarkable that all this violence is taking place.
place in Gaza when just over the border in the Israeli-controlled Jerusalem, the situation is so vastly different. This is where you'll see foreign correspondents from Western media organisations like the BBC, CNN and Australia's ABC reporting from. Many of them would like to be on the ground in Gaza, but the Israeli government refuses to grant them access, so much of the information they receive from inside Palestine comes from the local journalists who are on the ground there. For this week's Fourth Estate, I spoke with two journalists from these two cities. Hani Mahmood, a Palestinian correspondent with Al Jazeera, who joined us from Gaza, and Matthew Doran, an Australian, who has spent the last six months as the ABC's Middle East correspondent based out of Jerusalem.
The contrast between their two situations was incredibly stark. Matthew spoke to me from a light-filled, quiet room in Jerusalem. His internet connection was clear and basically pitch perfect. Hani joined us from a darkened cafe in Gaza, busy and frenetic, a bit noisy, where the connection was at times dropping out, and he made it clear that he couldn't predict that his safety would be guaranteed throughout our conversation. It's a tale of two cities, both next-door neighbours living vastly different realities. They don't even share the same time zone right now. Here is my conversation with Hani Mahmood and Matthew Doran.
I want to thank both of you for taking the time to speak with us. I know connections are tricky and it's a very busy workload and schedule that you're both keeping to at the moment. Hani, I want to go to you first. Before we get to the events of the last 48 hours, which have been pretty horrific, I want to first speak about your colleague, Hassam Shabbat, who was devastatingly killed two weeks ago, a very young Al Jazeera journalist. Being a colleague that you worked so closely with, and I guess a friend, what was that day like for you and your colleagues? Well, it was very, very difficult to absorb what happened that day because we were just...
Before that day happened, before the killing happened, we were talking about how many of our colleagues, our friends, people that we got to know in the field while covering in the past 15 months. And many of them were deliberately killed by the airstrikes or along with their family. So we're just thinking it's been a very tough 18 months of our life. And we were devastated by yet another death of a close colleague, a journalist who worked tirelessly for the past months on the ground, documenting every single act on the ground, every single bombs that fell, every single rocket fired, every home destroyed. And it just happened in a way that...
lift us is speechless, because when that happened, we all realized that killing journalists is not a byproduct of the war. It's not just collateral damage. It happens in a deliberate way. It happens on purpose, because Israel, the one thing that bugs the Israeli military the most is a voice of criticism. By doing so, it's just a way to suppress any voice of criticism. These journalists, what they're doing on the ground, they are doing their job to the best of their ability, documenting all the acts carried out by the Israeli military. And just let's face it, when we think of a war, we think of two sides.
equal and they're fighting they have the same amount of weapons yeah one side might have the upper hand compared to the other side but here you're talking about that literally nothing there's nothing available here when western media talk about rockets fired from the gaza strip they amplify this um they make it sound like it's it's quite destructive it's going to burn a whole town or destroy the homes it it's nothing compared to the the one-ton gpu bomb drops nothing compared to the entire residential areas have been wiped out at all i mean most of the time we see these rockets landing in empty areas that did not cause any significant damage. Now, do I agree with when this is happening? Of course not. I mean, killing is wrong a thousand times. Fire and rocket is wrong another thousand times. But what we need to be maybe like morally correct and pull out that this is not a war. It's a genocide. And all the elements are available. It has been broadcasted live for the past 15 months. Now, back to our colleagues who were killed. It's devastating. It makes us think that death is imminent. I'm talking to you right now in a place. And there's a zero guarantee that this place is not going to get bought. There is a zero.
guarantee this place is not going to be attacked because most of the time, 100%, the attacks are carried out in an unpredictable way. We move it from one place to another with zero level of safety, zero level of security. You're married and you have children. What is it like? What is that like on a daily basis for you having to think about their safety as well while you're out in the field doing your work? It's a scary reality. It's not easy. And there's nothing really pretty about thinking about you in the field getting killed or being punished by having your family getting killed. I mean, that it's mostly horrible.
We have many of our colleagues who were punished by having their entire families, their grandparents, their parents, their siblings, their nephews and nieces, or killed just for doing their job. And this is the part you might not see or read about much on headlines in Western platforms, but it's a reality here. Just the other day, when we see the horrific images from John Eunice, I mean, these journalists have families, they have wives, they have children, and just think of the feelings of how they are now living their life, knowing that they're their father. was killed in the field for doing just a job that he was trusted to do, or those who are injured inside the hospital. And God knows if they will make it or not, because right now there's something that is not reported about much in the newspaper or in media. It's silent death. Many people die inside hospitals, not only because of the war one, but because of the enforced dehydration, the enforced starvation.
The lack of supplies that are coming in. Lack of supplies, yeah. The painkillers are not available. I worry about getting sick now. This is the level five I'm worried about and end up going to a hospital that does not have any basic care available for me. So I keep thinking about it. There's so many times that I wrote letters. I'm keeping a stack of letters now for my sons, for both of my sons, for my little daughters, for my wife. And every time I try to get a little bit creative just to think of how they need to continue on with their life if something happens. I'm keeping another stack of letters for my parents because both of my parents are sick.
They need to need a medical care. And I try as much just to stay protected. Because I know if something happens to me, my mom won't be able to make it. She is like at the edge of just losing her life if something happens. But that's a part of from the pressure of work. We have to deal with this.
many journalists who will keep this in the back of their heads all the time. Matthew Doran, you're over in Jerusalem, and obviously the conditions and the situation over there is vastly different to what your colleagues on the ground over in Gaza are experiencing. Since this conflict began, 232 journalists and media workers have been killed by Israeli forces since this latest uprising of violence from October 7th. That's an average of 13 journalists per week. So it's the deadliest ever conflict for journalists. Does it make, I guess, make you stop and pause? Oh, absolutely. And we...
only able to do our job because we have dedicated colleagues working in Gaza who are helping us tell the stories from within. the Gaza Strip. They are the ones that are collecting vision for us. They are the ones doing interviews for us after getting directions or having discussions with us about what we are getting to follow from day to day. And yeah, when you do see those reports about more journalists killed, I just think of the anxiety that I feel when I am sending one of our colleagues a message on WhatsApp and you look to see those, you know, the one tick, two ticks, has it gone through? Has it gone blue? Have they read the message? Or, you know, are we waiting hours before they've got...
connection, internet connection, to be able to see that message. What does that mean? Have they been targeted? Have they had to move? Or is it simply a case of the comms have gone down again, which is, I guess, the best case scenario there. This is something that I think weighs very heavily on the minds of those of us who are working with these incredibly brave journalists in Gaza who are trying to tell that story and trying to work with us to get that news, that devastating news out to a broader public. Absolutely.
And to Hani's point as well, do you feel that there are false equivalencies that are constantly drawn in this conflict by Western media? Well, I think there is certainly a need to highlight the power imbalance there. I think that's a point that Hani was pointing to when we're talking about a situation like, as you mentioned, the rockets being fired out of Gaza towards parts of Israel. That sets off warning sirens across the cities of Tel Aviv, of Jerusalem, of regional areas, areas closer to the Gaza border. Like it is something that Israel is much more equipped to be able to defend itself there. And again, we are talking about rockets as opposed to what Mani was saying, they're really large bombs that are being dropped on communities. Of course, we report on the fact that a rocket has been fired out of Gaza because there is a cause and effect there. That sort of behaviour then does prompt, in some cases, Israel to retaliate, to ratchet up and intensify its response in Gaza. This is a relevant fact, but I think there is a need for it.
And I hope that we do try to do that as well as possible. But there is a need for us to provide that context and explain the significance of what that actually means, because there is a very different situation at play there. And that's for certain. Israeli outlets have pushed a largely factory narrative that blames Hamas for this latest breakdown in the ceasefire negotiations. What do you think the journalistic antidote is to that? Well, that's part of the false narrative that we've...
We've been seeing over and over from October 7th. And just by the way, I just want to make it clear that if anyone outside Gaza thinks that journalists here are promoting for a narrative that October 7th was okay or was good, that's completely wrong. And I can make that clear and speak for a handful of journalists across the world who do not agree with that. That was not. And I'm one of the people who call for accountability for what happened because it's the devastation that we have to deal with. It's just massive beyond our capacity. It's just the smallest thing of going into this.
were not taken into consideration. Heck, for example, people were not asked if you want to go into a massive war like this. I mean, nobody checked with people. So that's part of it. That's why accountability has to be largely there. But did it happen in a vacuum? Of course not. I mean, the whole idea that the world picked up the story from October 7th, forget about it, October 6th, 1st, 4th, forget about July, May 1993, 1990, the 80s, the 70s, the 1940s, all of that did not seem to matter.
focus was put on one day, but housing went through and lived through many of these lives over seven. So I think it would be more like morally acceptable to say, hey, well, this is what was going on. But it's not to justify it. But I think, I mean, at the end of the day, you're human. You can be, you can tolerate things to a limit. You can't just continue to be beaten all the time and expect to be nice. I mean, nobody around the world is going to turn the other cheek. I'm sorry to say this, but if you are going to be continuing doing this at some point, when if people feel a little bit strong, they have a bit of power to retaliate, they will react at least just to get off the oppression of their life.
But we are back with the same exact narrative every time something happens, our citizens are blamed for the failure of anything. But let's just remind everyone, 42 days of ceasefire agreement, this really military and this really political system keep failing to fulfill the term of phase one. Well, the ceasefire, it didn't feel that the ceasefire ever properly... I mean, obviously there was a de-escalation of fighting, but there was still military advancements that were happening into Gaza, as you mentioned. Yeah, an ongoing failure to comply with the terms of the agreement. I mean, allow much needed aid, allow...
tents and mobile homes to get in, withdrew from areas that people were waiting to get to their homes. So there was an Israeli failure and insisting on pushing the agreement into an end. And by the way, the ceasefire was violated by the Israeli side when it started a blockade, imposed a suffocating blockade on March 1st that went on for two weeks until March 18th when massive air strike carried out across Augusta where 400 people were killed. There was no rockets fired from the Palestinian side and no retaliation on the blockade or any of that. But this is the normal. I mean, if you ask anyone, how much do you know Israelis?
I think people in Gaza and Taliban generally know them very well. They know how they act, they know how they take advantage of the situation. We know how much, when you have the bigger gun, how much you can manipulate everything around you. Matt, is there much support, do you feel, on the ground in Israel amongst the people? Are they starting to turn on the Netanyahu government?
I think certainly, I mean, we have been to multiple protests over the course of the last six months where there have been thousands and thousands of people taking to the streets, criticising the Netanyahu government's handling of this war. Now, they will have different views as to where the Netanyahu government has failed here. There is, of course, the families of the hostages who are still held in Gaza. There's still 59 held by Hamas, 35 of them believed to be dead. There are still families and loved ones of that group who say that Benjamin Netanyahu hasn't done enough to try to secure a deal with Hamas and get those people out of there.
Even within that cohort, there are differing views as to, OK, is a return to fighting, as we saw back on the 18th of March with the resumption of that bombardment, is that the answer? Does there need to be a ceasefire until all of those hostages are out? And then, you know, is it a free-for-all from then on? There is a multitude of views. It's quite a nuanced dynamic there. There are also many people outside of that immediate hostage community, hostage family community, who think that this has gone on too long and are also tying this return to fighting to and accusing Benjamin Netanyahu of doing this so that he can hold on to power. The Netanyahu government is a coalition government.
of not only his Likud party, but also members of far-right parties. And there have been two very, very noisy members of his government, of his ministry, the National Security Minister, Itamar Ben-Gavir, and the Finance Minister, Bezella Smotrich, who have been arguing and agitating for a return to fighting. Mr Ben-Gavir even quit the government when the ceasefire deal was agreed to back in late January. He has since returned, and he returned to the Cabinet after those strikes resumed on the 18th of March. There are many people who, remember, if we cast our minds back, and it seems an eternity ago, but if we cast our minds back to before the war...
beginning, back after the Hamas attacks on October 7, 2023, there were tens of thousands of people taking to the streets in Israel protesting against the Netanyahu's proposed, the Netanyahu government's proposed changes to the judiciary. There is a group there who still hold that concern about what he's trying to do in shaking up. one wing, one arm of the government in Israel, the checks and balances that the judiciary exercise, who are now also saying, well, look what he's doing with the hostages and look what he's doing with the ongoing war. This is a way to avoid scrutiny there. So I think something that's really struck me is that there is, since I've started covering this conflict and actually been here in Israel, there is a nuance in that community debate. There are far more people than maybe the broader world understand within Israel who are very unhappy with how the war is progressing and how the Netanyahu government is pushing forward here. There are also those who think that the Netanyahu government is not going far enough.
I'll use one example for you. On January 18, no, sorry, January 17, so two days before the ceasefire came into force, we were down in southern Israel in a town called Storot, which is southern Israel. It's up on a hill and it overlooks northern Gaza. And you can see into northern Gaza communities like Beit Lahia, Jabalia, areas that have been... basically raised to the ground and there was still bombing happening right up until that ceasefire coming into force. We were there on a Friday afternoon and we had heard that there were a group of Jewish Israeli settlers who were wanting to set up camp on the border of Israel and Gaza ahead of the ceasefire coming into force. They had it in their mind as part of their ideology that the moment this ceasefire was going to happen, they would be presented with an opportunity to move into Gaza and start settling parts of Gaza and build their communities there. Now the IDF didn't let them in, they moved them on and this community, this group, there was maybe two or three dozen of them.
started setting up camp in the car park of the Starock train station. They were rushing to set up their tents before sundown on a Friday when the Shabbat starts and they can't actually do any work. It was quite an odd scene for someone who hasn't grown up in this sort of community. But they were very much of the view that that land was this and that this is an area that they are entitled to by an act of God. And this is an element that plays into the community here in Israel and feeds into those very right-wing voices within the Netanyahu government, that they see this as going far beyond just what happened on October 7, that this is part of a divine...
a divine mission that they are part of. So that nuance is something that I think really strikes me, but I think it is worth pointing out that there are many, many thousands of Israelis who do not want this to continue and very much believe enough is enough as well. Matthew, you've been the ABC's Middle East correspondent for going on six months now. But prior to that, you were for many years a federal political reporter based out of Canberra with a public broadcaster. And so for the first year that this latest conflict was really sort of raging after October 7, you really watched it from afar. I'd be interested to know, I guess, your perspectives. Have they changed at all since you've been on the ground in the Middle East?
I think, like many people, I was quite shocked at the scale of the initial attack from Hamas on the Israeli population on October 7, the surprise factor there, the fact that, you know, the Israeli military presents itself as one of the most advanced and technologically powerful forces anywhere in the world, and yet it seemed to be caught asleep. And there will be many people in Israel who echo that sentiment, that they feel that they were let down not only by the defence force, but by the intelligence services, by the police and the like. We were speaking to one family about that very issue days ago. Watching that from afar, I think, you know, again, you don't have that knowledge there, but it is something that... that certainly struck me. Also, the scale and the pace of the response. I can't think who it first was, but, you know, Australia is a long way away geographically from the Middle East. Of course, we have very strong diaspora communities, among our Jewish communities, our Arab communities, who would be feeling this intently. But for the broader population, there is that geographical distance. And I can't remember who it first was, but someone likened the size of Gaza to similar to the size of Canberra, the nation's capital, albeit with two million, more than two million people in that.
pocket of land, as opposed to Canberra, which has a population of roughly 450,000. That was a way that we were trying to explain to people just how densely populated this area was and how that response from Israel initially in self-defense. And of course, there would be many, many debates and have been many, many debates, but that has gone far beyond self-defense now. That's something that has been discussed for quite a lot in the many months since. But that gave a sense of the scale and the pace of that response. And I think also, again, without...
Properly understanding the nuance of the community and the very diverse political views that are in this country, the inability to get a deal, I think, and to bring a ceasefire to pass was something that I found quite striking as well. Since being here, it seems to make a lot more sense because, as I mentioned, there are those very, very loud voices within the Israeli government, within the Israeli community. They may well be a vocal minority, but they are a very vocal group there that have the prime ministers here. And, you know, no one will ever condone what happened on October 7, but it is also something that there has been many, many decades of conflict between the Israeli state and the power. Palestinian people leading up to this point as well, and to look at it in isolation without acknowledging that in those many decades and many centuries really doesn't do it justice. And I think that's something that's struck me since I've been here. Well, I think that's a frustration that a lot of people talk about when they talk about coverage of this conflict is the sort of narrative that this all started on October 7, which is completely false, as we all know. Hani, we've heard comments recently from the defence minister, Israel's defence minister. He's declared that there'll be an expanded annexation of parts of Gaza.
What will that then mean for the people there? Because the situation, where you are at the moment, as you've described, I mean, the situation is pretty dire. I mean, what's left? Absolutely. It's beyond dire right now. We look at a multi-layered difficulty that keeps unfolding on each passing day. And now they already said with the buffer zone, there's already 32% of the total area of the Gaza Strip being controlled by the Israeli military. And nobody can get into these areas. And this is, I think, what should be addressed from now on. Occupation is the real reason.
of what's happening. And Israel is not only occupying the land, but it's doing what an occupying power is doing, crushing the occupied population. Really shrinking a small area of the Gaza Strip is going to lead to bigger explosions because you're talking about a generation or a population of young generation here. And they have dreams, they have ambitions, they have life that they want to live, they have things that they want to achieve in their life. And if you take all of this away from them, you know, there's something that I keep telling people here. I mean, you don't have to fight anything. Your existence here is resistance. And I'm already living hardship and difficult life because we are pushed into this refugee status.
It passed in 1948. The majority of Palestinians are refugees because they're made refugees. It's not like they woke up in the morning and chose to be refugees or not woke up and chose to be displaced. I mean, there is hardship linked into being a refugee. There's hardship linked to being a displaced person. And maybe a person in their comfort zone, somewhere in the way, do not feel that because they're not in their shoes. The byproduct of this genocide is a whole entire generation that is not sitting in classrooms, not learning, in the streets, ready to be brainwashed, ready to be manipulated.
God knows we might end up with the next generation of real terrorists now, if this continues to happen, because they are easily brainwashed. And you know, those who are going to take advantage are a lot. And that should scare everyone, because the future is dark now. Matthew, in terms of, I mean, you're in Jerusalem, as we've discussed, and Hanis in Gaza, and that's largely because the Israeli government hasn't permitted... It doesn't permit Western journalists into Gaza to report on this conflict. So it's created a real vacuum. Why do you think that is? What's the official reason, at least, given by the Israeli government to not let Western journalists into Gaza? I'll start by just explaining what the situation has been with regards to access to Gaza. While the war was happening, the only access that Western media could get to Gaza was in very limited circumstances while accompanied by...
The IDF, it's a phrase that's often used, it's called an embed. So the journalists would travel with the IDF, they would be escorted into a part of Gaza and they would be escorted out. There'd be no time for the journalists to get out of whatever vehicle they're travelling in and talk to people. It was very, very controlled, but it was still seen by many media outlets as a valuable way of actually getting into Gaza and at least seeing something and wrapping it in all of the necessary caveats that the IDF will be pushing a narrative there and the journalists should be questioning what that narrative is. So that is the situation.
ceasefire came into effect. There had, of course, been hopes that those restrictions would start to be lifted prior to the war. There was access for journalists to get into Gaza, but it was very difficult and it did require a lot of coordination. Permission was required from Israeli authorities because Israel doesn't control all of those entry and exit points around the Strip. Now, the official line has effectively been that general warrants too dangerous for the Western media to go in and not to not be in there in a supervised environment. That is why the Western media has had to rely on the brave Palestinian journalists in Gaza to help us tell those stories.
give you an example of just how odd that situation is. When the ceasefire began, the Jordanian government and the Royal Jordanian Air Force managed to begin some airdrops of aid into Gaza. Not necessarily drops, they were pushing big crates out of the back of planes, but they were choppering in very high-value supplies, so things like medical equipment, baby formula, things like that. The ABC managed to get into Gaza on one of those helicopter flights. We had to travel from Jerusalem to Amman, the Jordanian capital.
and then fly over Israel to get into Gaza. We were only on the ground for between six and ten minutes, and we were on a helipad within what was then the Israeli buffer zone, so right up against the border fence between Israel and Gaza. So technically inside, but again, we weren't allowed out of that helipad area to actually speak to anyone. We, of course, saw things as we flow in. We saw the devastation with our own eyes. Again, it echoed what we had been seeing coming out of the war for many, many months, but that is the only skerrick of access that we had, and we had to travel to a third country to get that access.
It is something that is being challenged in the courts. The Foreign Press Association here in Israel has launched a Supreme Court challenge to try to stop the Israeli forces from blocking access there. That is something that has somewhat stalled. It sits bogged down in sort of early arguments there, so it hasn't really progressed. But there are people fighting for that access. And I don't think there would be many Western media or international media, I think we should say. It's not just the Western media. It is any international press. I don't think there'd be anyone who'd be advocating for the ongoing restrictions that are there from the Israeli forces. This is part of telling the story of what is happening in Gaza. And, you know, sunlight is the...
the best form of transparency. Best disinfectant. Do you, I mean, do you believe the line that it's just because it's too dangerous for journalists? Because as it would seem, evidence does suggest that there has been targeting of journalists by the IDF. Do you really believe it's out of concern for safety? Well, I think going into any war zone always brings risk. Any conflict zone always brings risk. This is a very unique form of control that is enforced upon Gaza and upon reporting in Gaza. I think it goes to a broader argument about...
the targeting of the media and the protections that media deserve when they are in any sort of conflict zone, be it Gaza, be it Syria, be it what we're seeing, the horrors coming out of Africa at the moment, there is a certain amount of protection that should be afforded to the media there. Yes, but in those other conflict zones, journalists aren't barred from entering those hot zones. And that's what I mean when I say this is a very unique form of control and I don't think there will be any journalist who would be advocating for that. Very strict. uh form of control to to be continuing because it means that when the media have been there on those those embeds to use the jargon they have been restricted they've got access great they're inside the fence but they aren't able to spend a night in one of these communities to to speak to people they are under the supervision of the idf there now the idf will say that you know while they're there they can they can report on what they are seeing but if they're not being given access to every part of gaza or um feel that they've got soldiers looking at them and what they're doing then that is a an unnecessary and unacceptable
So it does allow the Israeli authorities to control the narrative. Do you ever feel concerned for your own safety through your reporting, even just from Jerusalem? Have you received pushback from Israeli authorities, from the Israeli government? Pushback, no. I think cooperation is not always the most forthcoming. And, you know, it's a journalist's job to ask questions and to scrutinise decisions and to scrutinise actions, whether or not, if that's uncomfortable. Of course, it's uncomfortable. I used to be a political journalist in Canberra.
I think I'm sure that when we were asking ministers or shadow ministers or whoever it was, tricky questions, they weren't comfortable. In terms of personal safety, no. I mean, I think that this is one of the stark contrasts between what those of us who are operating on this side of the border are experiencing compared to our colleagues operating in Gaza, that we are in a very different situation there. The battles that we fight are with access and with transparency as opposed to survival. What do you think needs to happen at some point? I'm not even just saying when this conflict ends, but what does need to happen in terms of, I mean, we know that journalists have been targeted. We know that there have been journalists that have been killed, intentionally killed in this conflict. As I've mentioned earlier, this has been the deadliest conflict ever for journalists. And in the last 48 hours, we've seen a Palestinian journalist burnt alive in a tent, targeted. What sort of reckoning needs to happen? Because this is a war crime, as we've mentioned, the targeting of journalists.
is a war crime. The safety of journalists is not being guaranteed in this conflict when it comes to being on that side of the border in Gaza. Yeah, the safety is clearly not there. These journalists are at risk and yet they are still doing their job each and every day. And that is admirable. It seems like you're underselling it, really. It is remarkable what our colleagues in Gaza are doing.
Of course, there have been calls for inquiries here in Israel as to how this war began. There are investigations underway within the International Criminal Court about the actions of the Israeli government, the actions of Hamas here. Remember, Benjamin Netanyahu is a subject of an arrest warrant by the International Criminal Court alongside his former defence minister, Yoad Gallant, for alleged war crimes in Gaza. So, too, were senior officials from Hamas for their role in planning and carrying out the attacks on October 7, albeit these individual subjects of arrest warrants are now dead as a result of the war. There are investigations that will...
clearly happen as to how this has happened. The problem is, I mean, if we look at the, aside from the issue of journalists in particular, if we look at how the Israeli government handles that debate in the country at the moment, it says that that is something that needs to happen down the track, that the war is still ongoing. This is something that happens down the track. There are many people here in Israel, many people in the community who say, no, those investigations need to happen now. And that would be something echoed by many around the world when it comes to those broader concerns and those broader allegations that are in Gaza there as well. So I think this is something that has been played out in a way that many
conflicts in the past have it. You know, this is the, for want of a better phrase, the social media war. We have all seen this vision coming out more so than in previous conflicts. And that doesn't mean that there is not only alleged evidence as to how this has played out, but also a greater awareness in the public as to the concerns here. And I think that's what needs to happen from here is, or what will happen from here as opposed to what needs to happen is that there will be that added pressure, that ongoing pressure for people to investigate and to pursue accountability. Honey, I can only imagine you must have many reflections over the events that have transpired in the last couple of days, seeing people that
Your colleagues, fellow journalists, people that you've known, like Hilmi, burning alive in that tent. His colleagues, not knowing whether they're going to make it, what their lives are going to be like afterwards. Hilmi was killed instantly in the attack. The other journalist, Ahmad Mansour, was pronounced that this morning he could not survive the serious injuries and wanted to be at Nautil Hospital just to be with other colleagues at the funeral. But I couldn't make it, honestly, because the coastal road movement on the coastal road was made difficult this morning. And I think that's part of the restricting movement or being there with...
with the rest of the people, because I was planning on working on a report right inside the hospital, just inside where the room Ahmed was staying in and starting from there into his burial site. But the coastal road was not helping just to move. And we're talking about an area that is 15 minutes of driving. It just made impossible to cross in. And that's, for those who do not know, that's how difficult it is to move across Gaza. With Nasserim now back under Israeli military control, that's part of the difficulty. These are the questions.
The Israeli public needs to ask itself on a daily basis, what have they done to the Palestinians for the past years? Because I think the Israeli public does not think about that, does not care much about what's going on. And this is a reality that I have to share with people. And it's just amazing to see Israeli journalists on local platforms Israelis promoting the IDF narrative, promoting for the genocides to continue, cheering at the sound of home demolition, the explosion and the home demolition of Gaza in the eastern part, and the cheer as they hear from where they're at in the settlements. So that's the sort of things that need to change, because without this, without the public...
The Israeli public is taking the streets because it's not happy with Netanyahu. It's not because it's not happy with the genocide. And that's a harsh thing to say, but it is the reality. Because if they were not happy with the genocide, they would have to stop it. They would have made the necessary pressure to stop it from the first opening weeks. But they let it happen because they don't care. They don't think Palestinians deserve to live. They don't think Palestinians are worth thinking about. They take the streets because Netanyahu is not doing his job domestically as he was entrusted to do. But they don't worry about it at all. And that's very clear from all the platforms, the journalists, the activists, the influential.
the figures that they host. Apart from our hearts, it's a different story, but everything else is really terrible. It's not a war. It's a genocide. I think that's the dichotomy between someone on the ground and someone reporting it from a distance. Even if they rely on people on the field here. And by the way, that is one thing that I refused doing in the past month of associating myself with any platform. And I'm sorry to say this, any Western platform, because all the time they want the story to fit their criteria. And most of the time, I mean, powerful stories, they end up on the shelf. They're not shown. They're not told.
and because most of the people that they work for these platforms are still young they want to make the money they want to feed their family so in order to keep that flow of cash coming in they're going to do the story based on whatever criteria is enforced on them and that's that's why it's not a clear picture that's why they still report it as a war not as a genocide i think it's worse than a genocide honestly it is worse and i i don't know if we're gonna make it honestly i i have no i i can't trust that the coming days are going to be easy or we're going to make it we're seeing our colleagues going one by one And every time one goes, we say the clock is decaying, it's coming. You feel like your own days are numbered. Yeah.
Unpredictable bonds are very indiscriminate. They destroy everything. I mean, the massive destruction they cause is shocking. It worries us a lot. Well, it's quite astounding, I think, that Israel prides itself on how advanced their military is and what they're able to do, yet it does seem that these attacks are very indiscriminate. They're either not as sophisticated as they're making out, or that, I mean, this is purposely causing the damage that it is. Yeah, sure, yeah. And just in order to maximize the level of destruction and pain, they are indiscriminate. I mean, anyone on their killed list.
they can take them one by one without causing any harm and we've seen this happen one time inside lots of hospital where a group of activists and journalists were sitting together and one of them happened to be a target and he was he was the only one who was killed and no one was injured this is this is how advanced technologically can get they get a single person from a group of people sitting together for the rest of the time they chose to cause maximum level of damage and destruction so it's not about hamas it's not about october since about pushing this population out of the area, make their life health, create the conditions that will eventually get them out, either by population thinning, by making them smaller, make their life difficult, so eventually they will pack them and leave. If it was about the hostages, I think it would have been resolved a long time ago, but it's not about it. The hidden objectives are much worse. I mean, if I had accepted these hostages, I would have put them on a vehicle and just let them just go, just get out of here, because while you're here, we're dying, so we don't want you anymore, just go. There's a much bigger picture to this.
That's one of the motives that I'm still on the ground, risking my life. If we're not telling our own stories, no one will. That's the thing, honestly. If we're not telling our own narrative, no one will. They will deform it. They will change it in a way to benefit those who are in power. I don't get to talk to media outlets other than because of my work with Al Jazeera. I'm dedicating all what I'm doing to Al Jazeera. Not because I work there, but I think it's a very fair platform and has been given opportunity for everyone.
I mean, I see Israelis getting run out of their English talking. I see officials. I see people, normal people, ordinary citizen. And I think that's the good part about it. Everyone is represented equally, given the amount of time, the amount of enough space just to express themselves. When I got offers from other platforms, I rejected that because I knew right away the moment we start talking about, OK, what are the conditions of the work? Then you are hammered by criteria and framework of how the story should get out. Yeah. Hani Mahmoud, are you able to see a future away from all of this?
I mean, I know it sounds fairly trite even asking you, but can you see a future? And if so, what are your hopes for it? It's hard. We get to the point where we are unable to think what is going to happen in the next hour. Honestly, I am so incapacitated that I can't think of what's going to happen in the next hour. I'm just living my life now minute by minute. And an hour goes by, I feel relieved that I made it this hour. Not I made it this day, I made it this hour. This is how bad it got. So I'm sorry, I'm unable to think or to tell you what are my hopes. I just want this to end. I want the killing to end because I am, for 545 days, I am tired and exhausted.
I'm losing my sanity, just reporting about the death and destruction. And seeing, I've seen decapitated children with my own eyes at the Sheikah Hospital, at Nasser Hospital, in Rafahat, the Kuwaiti Hospital, at the Aqsa in Deirbalah. I've seen decapitated children. I've seen the children coming out with their intestines out. Seeing elderly who lost all of their four limbs reported to the hospital. I've seen all of this. It's not a made-up lie. We've seen it. I have a whole archive of my phone with all of this. It's too graphic. We can't show it on. Even when it comes to Al-Jazeera, it's too graphic. We can't show it on this. But that's the thing that I've seen for 545 days.
And I just feel bad that if I want to think about my future, why this is happening. So it's either we're all in this boat. So whether we save or we will sink all, pretty much, this is how it got, unfortunately. Honey, Mahmoud, please stay safe. And thank you so much for speaking to us and joining us from Gaza. Thank you. Matthew Doran, thank you so much from Jerusalem for joining us on Forth Estate. Thanks.
And thank you for listening to the program. If you've been listening along via radio and would like to hear an extended version of this discussion, just head to the Fourth Estate Podcast. You'll be able to find all of our discussions there. And if you do so, please do leave us a review, a rating and subscribe. It'll help other people find us as well that way. I'm Tina Quinn. Please do stay well, stay safe and we'll catch you next time. Bye bye for now.