Hello and good evening. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from TSCI and Sydney on Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe by a podcast. My name is Peter Frey and my esteemed producer tonight is Anthony Dokkerel. Coming up, the government has just dropped its sixth written complaint on the ABC in five months, this time taking aim at journalist Laura Tingle, Barry Cassidy and Andrew Proven.
Guess that's a break from attacking Emma Alberichie, but what is going on there? A group of Australian journalists, including veteran political journalist Paul Bonjourno, have been denied travel visas to China, they were going with the former New South Wales Premier Bob Carr. Is this what the news media has to expect from the fallout of frosty relations between Canberra and Beijing? The much talked about foreign espionage bill looks like it's going to get up with bipartisan support.
Just how big a deal is this for journalism in this country? And finally, Bionaby Joyce, yes Bionaby Joyce has nominated this week's news cycle, but the same can't be said about the ratings for the Bionaby, Talal TV special. Was it all worth it? Joining me in the studio this evening are Geraldine Doo, the presenter of Saturday Extra on Radio National, whose glorious career spans print, TV and radio.
Hello Geraldine. Hello Peter. And on the line from Melbourne is Brett McLeod, star presenter and reporter for Channel 9, and one of the reasons to watch commercial TV in that fair city. Welcome Brett.
Hello, how are you? Oh, we're all very well. So, the ABC and the Coalition have been driving along a rocky road of late and last week relations between the government, funded broadcaster and the government hit another live pothole. Communications Minister Mitch Feilfield formally complaining to the ABC about its coverage on Friday, making it the sixth complaint in five months from the government.
In recent times, the government has complained about articles written by Emma Alvarichie, the change in the date of the Triple J's hottest 100 and a couple of comedy sketches for Good and Medio. This time, Feilfield is taking him at the ABC's 7pm news and the insider's program and a story on the website, all discussing the timing of the five violations on 28 July, initially the same date as the Labour Party National Conference. The guts of the complaint is that the ABC dared to report Labour's claims that the government had picked the date to coincide with that national conference. That, in other words, it was all political, heaven for, fend.
The government not only denied this, but took greater section to the ABC reporting and I quote, repeating, I quote, a Labour lie as fact. Court happened this complaint to the ABC, our Lord Tingleberry Cassidy and Andrew Probein and for Good measure, Fairfax Jones, Mark Kenney and Phil Curry. So, first up, what about the five-field complaint, Geraldine? Does he have a point about the ABC repeating quote unquote, Labour lies or is this just reporting to cut and stress or politics?
Well, look, if you really read the specifics of what Andrew Probein in particular said on 7pm, he could have perhaps added a couple of clever little riders that he could have, because he actually did say, because I was reading it, that the Prime Minister has decided when, in fact, it was the speaker and the AEC. I think you could very clearly imply, as Lord Tingle did, I thought more successfully, that it sort of beggared belief that this was done without some sense that they were messing up the Labour plans. And it was nine weeks, I mean, irony is, I think it could be an own goal for the coalition, because now Labour's repositioned its conference to December, and there was, as somebody pointed out, that chance for all sorts of embarrassing headlines to emerge in July, around about the time that we would have thought we'd maybe earlier July, we'd have these elections, these five violations. So, look, he could have chosen, he could have maybe put a couple of little riders in, but it just does seem to be this pattern emerging, particularly from Senator Fivefield, that quite surprised me, having dealt with Senator Fivefield, you know, up in Canberra when we've gone up as part of the ABCs, sort of charm offensive there twice, and he's always been extremely flattering about me and my voice in love about that.
That should be a good one. I think, yeah, it's quite so. I've, look, I just, I'm mystified by it. Yes, it is interesting.
I think, you know, Brett, bring you in here on this. I mean, look, the government complaining about the ABC is nothing new. No, it's not. But what it seems to be a new thing is that it's becoming very public.
So, you know, we seem to be finding out about it on a very regular basis that these complaints are being made. So, there's a change in tactic, if not a change in the substance. What do you make of that, Brett? The only thing that puzzles me in all this is why it's happening so frequently.
I mean, this is a court, the day to mid-wife field, is seeing that their coaches speak again. It's bringing in so many complaints. And this one, I grabbed your lead and perhaps the phrasing could have been slightly more couch in the way in the content of context. But ultimately, I think we got the idea in everyone's reports, but there's no way to speak with the House is going to make this decision without it.
So, of course, the Prime Minister's decision. Well, he said he did consult with leaders of his party. Actually, he said that. Yeah, I mean, yeah, OK.
And that's a fair bit of reporting and commentary around that because we are talking about commentary mixing in with reporting. I think everyone was pretty much on the same page. Well, that's the interesting thing about this, I think, is that, in a sense, one of the sort of conventions of journalism is, and maybe it's the wrong convention. Maybe it's one that needs to think about changing, but there's an issue, the government of the day says this, and then the opposition seeks to portray it as something else.
I mean, that's just the way reporting happens, isn't it? Yes, it is. Look, there is talk that there's a great deal of flagging. What you just said then about it being flagged publicly, six complaints from Firefield, that he's registered, let alone the two handwritten critiques by the Prime Minister, allegedly, of Emre Al-Rigi.
So maybe they are trying to send a message to others in their own party. This is part of the speculation that they are of a more conservative bent, that they are clamping down on the ABC. And look, what distresses me is that they think it's a casualty-free zone. Now, that is what bothers me.
So in other words, look, I don't think our managing director, Michelle Guthrie, I don't think she lands massive blows in a public space the way Mark Scott would. And I think that if you did hit out when Mark Scott was a leader, he would come back with, he was extremely deft on his feet in public. He was a politician. He was a politician.
And so they knew they'd get something back. I don't even think they're worried about that now, just because I don't actually think that's massively her skill set is public defence. The chairman, Tony Walker, your former esteemed colleague, wrote a devastating piece in the A to the other day, and two days later, saying where is the board? Where is the board in all of this discussion?
And the board finally came out saying everybody calm down. So I think it's the fact that they feel there'll be nothing that goes wrong for them. Yes, it's interesting, again, back to you, Brett. John Howard was said that the ABC was that our enemy is talking to our friends, which I thought was a very succinct way of perhaps putting his people at ease in a way.
You see the contrast of TV. Yeah, and I also think too that we've got to be sitting at a punching bag for all state of government ever since I've been a journalist. I've never worked with the ABC. I've never known all of the occasional guests, and that's about it.
But I always feel it's an easy target. And I think too, when you see, he's not the project artist, but when he wrote down that you're reporting the studio, reporting a label lie is fact that you technique politicians often you try to undergo journalists in press conferences when they say, oh, you just repeat your opposition, we're government talking points. So we're not capable of coming up questions on our own. And I just thought it might be a bit of an outro at the honest.
I'm interested, but I think it's a Geraldine's point. It is interesting that the CEO of the ABC and the editor-in-chief as she is seems quite silent on this. And I have invited her to come on the show and enjoy a whole half-hour of the fourth estate. Let's hope she takes up that office.
She might, I think she should, because I think you're right, Geraldine, that she's a very different person than the might. I think it's a very difficult set. I mean, not saying she has those skills. Perhaps as we enter into a full-on election cycle, it is also something going on there.
I decided to tame the ABC a little bit as we ready for another federal election. Well, I think it certainly shuts across bars. And I think that apparently in Victoria, in particular, there's quite a lot of movement at the station inside the Liberal ranks too. So whether this is playing a role, I mean, I really wish the board would say more.
I wish the board would give the staff good narratives for them to hold onto. The staff is really under a great deal of pressure because you can see the incredible changes inside the organisation as it tries to model itself to go across television, radio and online platforms and reach new audiences and so on who are using their devices totally differently. So there's an unbelievable amount of disruption internally. And I think it is the job of people who are in charge to give the staff narratives to hold onto.
Can I just finish on this point, Geraldine? You should be on the board. Should you not? Peter, what a thing to say.
You're listening to the Fourth Estate where journalists talk about journalism. I'm Peter Frey and joining me this week is Geraldine Duke in the studio, ABC Superstar. It's an honour to be in the same studio as her. And Brad McLean from Channel 9, pulled up on a near-doc lens apparently in a car in Melbourne.
In the shadow of a giant wheel. In the shadow of a giant wheel. Excellent. This week marked a clear damn journey in relations between Australian and China with the news that a delegation of Australian journalists have been refused visas for a planned visit to Beijing and beyond.
The trip was being organised by the Australian-China Relations Institute, which is based at UTS in Sydney and headed by the former New South Wales Premier in one-time journal, Bob Carr. Previous trips have included likes of ABC's Frank Kelly and other people. In fact, this one had veteran Canberra insider and Saturday paper economist Paul Giorno on the trip. The car blames the incident interestingly on the hardening of anti-Chinese rhetoric from the Australian side saying that, quote, we're the American ally with the most adversarial rhetorical position toward China.
So while the journal is getting in the neck because of Canberra's stance, what do you think, Brad? Well, interestingly, as you said, it's a state political report answered by 100% of the other, and it's just left China having visited the delegation from the Victorian government, including a premier. And he said the diaspora had this decision, and he said, we had no problems that we had a letter from the other of the particular problems that we were going to allow to get access. So at that level, the civil is still being allowed in.
I find it serious timing. Is it a direct result of the comments of that right of passage of the South's on the sea that we saw that issue come up again last week or is there? Is there some other line issue between the bigger institution and the Chinese government? I'm not aware of.
I don't know. The diaspora is continual teaching we are going to have with China. We're economically, we are absolutely tied to them. We're legally at a different end of the spectrum.
And we can't expect that we're going to have the exact sort of access all the time, but this makes me wonder what some of the gameplay we can expect in the future. Well, absolutely. I mean, look, let's look at what's happening in recent times in the world of journalism. In this country, we've had the very forthright reporting by the ABC4 Corners.
We've some very forthright reporting in Fairfax as well around the same time, and a few other things have been going on too. And there is a debate which Bob Carr is very much part of. In fact, Bob Carr is often portrayed as being too pro-China. And so there's a very interesting thing going on.
So you think that the safest person to go to China with these days would be Bob Carr, but so what's going on here? Do you think, Jolene, is this, is this a say, the fallback from this sort of robust reporting or is it just, you know, China sending a bit of a shot across the bears? I think it's very much a result of a series of tonal changes from about, well, I dated it to about August last year. I mean, I went to the Shangri-La dialogue, the one that is in the news this week last year, and heard Malcolm Turnbull give an excellent speech about the role of China, and very, I thought it was a very, I didn't actually think it was terribly well reported, a very inviting, you know, we see that you're coming, we have some queries about it, but we see that you're coming, and it wasn't exactly welcome, but it was a very good speech by Turnbull.
And then sort of two months later, and you know, talking about this, it is a trap, you know, that this is how we've got to, we must make sure we don't fall into the sort of inevitability of big power conflict when one power is dropping and one's rising. And then it turns on a dime. And that's almost evil. And it's, look, I've never been satisfied that we've heard what the reason is, and I'm not alone.
A lot of people say, you know, we had Duncan Lewis, the head of ASIO coming out, saying that these are serious issues and really going very close to questioning the loyalties of local Chinese, that they didn't know quite where their loyalties lay. And I think that car has been warning, ironically, I mean, I'm not, you know, I sit opposite the Cha-Chac wing building, so I see the famous man who donated money to the, you know, this is the Frank Erie building. But the car has been warning about this. I think it's, I think that we just, we don't matter enough if you know what I mean.
They want us, they like us, but we're just suddenly have turned. And I think they're sending very clear messages. I was invited on that trip, actually. Yes, I was.
And I decided I couldn't go for other reasons, because I'm going to a wedding in Hawaii, a friend of a young friend. You've got to much better deal with it. Yeah, so I think it's quite serious. It does go to the issue, the broader issue of the reporting of China in this country.
And, you know, another place to trace this back to would be Clive Hamilton's book, The Silent Invasion. And I think that the success of that book has taken a lot of people by surprise, not now, but when it first came out, it went off like a rocket really that book. And, well, it was a series of sort of, if you like unfortunate incidences, but interested in your take bread on the kind of reporting of China, because it is a very subtle story on one level, right? It's one that's gaining currency, my work for a commercial network.
And we probably haven't reported a great deal on China particularly political relations with China in recent years, but I know that so, because you're in XA, you know, it has been very strong on this, particularly in the past few weeks. And I think it's important that there is an awareness of the government we're dealing with. And the fact that we have a complex relationship with China, China, China's relationship with the world continues to change, particularly in America, and it's all from their power. So you're, it's from influencing our part of the world, trying to continue to place its muscles.
It's going to have a relationship with us that I guess we're going to have to be a weird journalist that we can't expect it actually from the way that we might have in the past. But also by the time I don't want us to change our type of reporting place on whatever the Chinese government does, journalists, like to think we can communicate it open as we can. Yeah, that was a very important journey. Well, in fact, I was just actually pulled out.
John Menager, who used to be head of Prime Minister and Cabinet for both Fraser and Whitlam, he's got this blog called Purls and Irritations. And he has, he's very annoyed that Andrew Hasty, you know, the man who came out and did the big vent under parliamentary privilege had actually it turns out it's been revealed that he told a, an hour and a half before he was going to do this. And Duncan Lewis knew about it, his head of ASIO. They both XSAS men.
But the Prime Minister didn't know until he was on his feet. And John Menager finds that absolutely outrageous. And he said in this, we've known for months about Duncan Lewis's public role, but now we learn at least in part how he's been acting behind the scenes. And we've also seen our mainstream media, including the ABC, in Thrall of the Spy Narrative.
They fall for the untested and gossipy tippets. They're prepared to accept stories and advice from ASIO, while dismissing experts of long standing on China as either China's lobbyists or stooges. Now, honestly, I think there's an element of real truth. And I think it's incredibly challenging for us as journalists to work out how we do alert our readers to the challenges of having our main friendship with the US, but our main commercial relationship with China.
And how we accept that there are differences there, but not to go back into unconscious bias. Almost, to be honest, I think some of it's bordering on yellow peril. Well, I think that HACI thing. I mean, there's an interesting challenge, isn't it?
HACI stands up in Parliament. Use this privilege to say all sorts of things about all sorts of people. Hard to ignore it, right? But at the same time, even harder to put it in context within that sort of breaking news space.
Very. Almost impossible. So that goes to a manager's point. And of course, seemingly the media is falling to some sort of spy narrative.
Well, because it's gorgeously exciting. And I think, look, what for me it's meant is that Huewit, the international analyst, said, what, four, five years ago, talking about precinct, we will have to become vastly more sophisticated in how we deal with this, because we haven't been here before. And I thought, oh, yes, that's smart. I realise that is coming true now.
And I think Four Corners had to deal with that, you know, and I try to deal with it regularly. And I'm interested, Brett, that you say that now your outlets are sort of realising there's a real story here in a way. But how we nuance it? I'm real challenged for commercial theatre.
Very big challenge to become that. Well, I need to know, and largely the story in China over the past few years has been commercial one, that they're then buying a line or an ad. So I get all that sort of thing. Not taking my place, but rather than recognizing it, but now we come with this other story of Chinese alleged interference and their politics and political donations and that sort of thing.
How do we not only report on that, but give it some sort of context. And we're trying to figure that out for ourselves. And the hastening was particularly interesting because the timing of it, certainly I give you the political backstory there, but also trying to report on that and give you some sort of context using the name of the business. I think my people will.
Thank you, Tri. Yeah, that's what it's certainly making. And it actually feeds beautifully into our next subject, which we're going to have a chat about the foreign espionage bill. So you're listening to Fourth Estate, and I'm Peter Fray.
And tonight we are talking to Geraldine Doove, the reason to listen to Radio National on a Saturday morning, and several other times I might say. And Brett McLeod, who I think is probably the sharpest tack in Channel 9's tool shed. Is that a fair description? Yes.
After months of negotiations, it looks like both the coalition and Labour have finally agreed to a series of amendments to the controversial foreign espionage bill. The devil, of course, will be in the detail, but there's much concern about the very limited protection the bill is likely to give journalists who handle information deemed against the public or against the national interest. It is expected that under the bill, there will be no blanket exceptions for journalists breaking stories only for those that fit into this very, into a very narrow definition of public interest. So, as I say, the devil isn't in detail, but it's pretty hard to keep the powerful to account if you are in jail.
So I'm interested in what you think, Geraldine. This is a tricky one, isn't it? But I think, as I say, we need to see the devil, the detail, but it does seem that this is going to restrict our capacity to our job. Look, I can't make up my mind.
The truth is, I've really listened. I heard a good discussion last night on Radio National Drive with the camera reporter talking about, see, there are two different, full different bills too. And so, honestly, I'm not sure. I find it hard to believe that, see, I thought it was more that you could, if you believed it was reasonably in the public interest, you could report it.
I thought that was going to be the test. So it's a definitional issue. And I suppose that goes right back to much more filmmaking complaints at the ABC. I suppose there's a nice sort of link there.
Absolutely. And it goes to the Senate inquiry into public interest journalism and all these things that we seem to be grappling with, which you kind of figured were kind of fixed, but apparently not. They seem to be much more fluid than we thought. It's quite true.
And so, look, maybe we've got to rely on the Senate. Can I say that? I know. God help us.
But Brett, those who support the Bill arguments needed to protect Australia's interests and national security, going to the China stuff we're just talking about. I think, I know, we're making too much of this. I mean, where do we pitch our tent as journalists? I think journalists have always got to push back against anything, which is going to work.
We're going to need to do journalism. And I think, yes, we're all aware of the need to be protecting Australia's interests in the case of possible foreign interference. But when the law of the laws they're considering, look at the material that he's quite harmful or likely to harm Australia's interests, who decides that? Let me say, if the Australian interests, if the Australian government is a prime minister, wants a definition.
For example, you had a story about a future prime minister caught in a compromising position in the hotel room in Moscow, and video I take to go with that. Could that be harmful to Australia's interests? Certainly. How about future prime ministers?
Exactly. That's the point. So that's what you were saying to you all about. The definition is to me, crucial in all this.
Maybe there's got to be, and maybe we'll find out, there is some sort of final appeal you can make, where somebody makes a judgement on that. I haven't heard this, but I'm just thinking of how you get out of this, because it is bipartisan, isn't it? It's the latest. So it's the end of the Labor's talking about it and having made 60 amendments.
So I think we'll leave it at that, because I think we need to come back to this one in another show. I think there's some big issues here, and I agree with you. So the definition of what is in the public interest and the national interest is probably worthy of a show of all of itself. Well, it is all tied up with this China thing.
The only thing I'd say is I've been scouring a place for some real sense, and Brett, you may know more than I, about what was it? There was something that made them all freak out. And there is something in, again in John Minajou's, but Stigman Fitzgerald, who was our first ambassador, Linda Jacobson, who runs that China matters, think tank thing. They did say that they clearly speculated that the security agencies had uncovered more than one effort to break into the internal communication systems of two of our government departments.
Now, if that one of those was defence, you can see that that is super serious, and especially if wearing with the Americans with the Five Eyes arrangement. So that was the first actual thing other than Dastyari that I heard that I thought, oh, this could have turned them all. But still no reason to cripple those journalists. Certainly not.
Certainly not. Okay, well you're listening to Fourth Estate, coming to you from 2SCR and sitting on Gadigou lands of the Aora Nation right across Australia on the community radio network, and directly to your device across the Globe via podcast. I'm Peter Frey, and before we go on, I would like to make a slight plea, which is you can make donations to 2SCR, and it's getting towards the end of the financial year, and they're tax deductible, because we're poor. We have DGI, we're poor, we're poor, we're poor radio station.
So while you're enjoying the show, please think about checking a few dollars our way. We couldn't let the week go by without talking about one of the Joys, I'm very sorry, but by the way Joy is a Vicky Campion, and that interview on Channel 7. So just 631,000 people tuned in across the five major cities to watch the interview that cost Channel 7 $150,000. That works out at about 24 cents per viewer.
Is that value for many? Well, not when Channel 7 executives were reportedly hoping for one and a half million viewers according to the Australian, but more to the point, was it good journalism? Brett, I know you worked for the other mob. It's very bad.
We're going to say that straight away, you worked for the other mob, but what do you think? Was it money well spent, and did the interview Alex Cowen do a good job? And I did read, I know, I didn't read it, but I didn't read it, so it was a good job. You would have done a great job yourself.
I didn't hear it. I don't know, journalism is in five roles, but it just gets in the way. It's only time. I think this is part of the problem with it, that when you pay for an interview, what are you paying for?
And are the rules absolutely clear before you start? I think it's always dangerous to be more than yourself involved in the negotiations. Maybe if you pay for the organization, pay for it, and I've never done that. But I think it's rather kind of at the end of the negotiations.
I think just on that point, I think you make a really good point, which is not only did the journalists get involved involved in the interview, but I think it's just on that point, I think you make a really good point, which is not only did the journalists get involved involved in the interview. I mean, I shouldn't have done that. The viewers didn't know the rules. I mean, there were clearly things that were not going to, you know, where I had the limits because they were clearly gaps in that interview, rather large gaps in that interview.
And they could have told perhaps it could have been more transparent, more kind of more objective, whatever, but they, by telling us the viewer what the rules were of engagement. I know, am I being a bit naive at that point? Yeah, I think there were contracts that you can't ask about, it's six, I'm not sure. I think about that.
To me, the problem with the walls, we got the law of the selection state house, exactly the sort of thing I really did not want to hear. But then get to the heart of the issue about how we spent or wrongly spent. And I will tell them later on to release some past eight of you and see we got not answered, so I did use it. I don't think it would have been better from service point of view to include some of the not answers.
So we did try and we got a this response, just to nullify something criticism. But ultimately, I think, several of us would have disappointed with those things. I think when you take it down the region, it did get close to a million. But it was a great result.
Give me a good, you know, almost no reason. Well, and also, I mean, the public really, you know, it started about six, mid six hundred's in it. They dropped about 200 more or less in the first few minutes. Do you think, Jodine, that we're all just kind of thoroughly sick of this story?
Is that what really was going on on Sunday night? Well, I didn't watch it. I made a conscious decision not to watch it. I'm afraid.
I look, it's very interesting. I, for instance, I've got an interview with a pre-recorded interview with Jermaine Greer. I think I'm the only coming up next week. She's re-reading out her- The rape son.
No, no, this is very beautifully unprogued. She doesn't want to talk about that. Oh, really? No, she's bringing out her book again called The Change, which is a very, very good book about the manneaport, et cetera.
And she's done a new forward or something, I haven't got the book yet. And they have said she doesn't, she really wants to talk about this book. She doesn't want to talk about everything else. So I thought, oh, hang on.
So what I think I've decided to do, your listeners can tune in, is say, because I think it'll be such an interesting interview, because any interview with Jermaine is interesting. And she's great. I think I will say, I have agreed to this interview. Now, she's going lots of extraneous discussions about rape, et cetera.
She doesn't want to talk about that. And I'm going to, I think I might even, I'm trying to form the question in my mind. I might say to an Adjamais, you're not a blushing pilot. You know, you know, what is it that so annoys you about all of this debate?
And if she sort of walks out, you know, because Jermaine is taking a Christmas letter to tell you what I'm interviewing. But I don't think she will. But I'm going to say, I'm coming, I just want to ask you one question before, so that the listeners know that I'm aware that she has been uttering all of this sort of bombshell stuff. So, I mean, it's quite a tricky issue.
I think that Brett's quite right. Seven should have been transparent with their viewers. Yeah. And said, we have agreed to this interview.
We have agreed to sideline certain things you can take us to, you know, take issue with us if you like. But we think that there are greater issues or blah, blah, you know, at stake. Well, and I think, I mean, to your both of your points are very well made. Because I think that in that interview, the bits that I found most interesting were when Barney was getting a bit defensive and say, I'm not going to go there.
I'm not going to go there and sort of getting red and, you know, all that sort of stuff. Because, you know, you're engaged in the narrative because there was an obstacle to overcome. I was much less interested in the shots of the baby and piggy and talking about love. Although, I wish them all the way up to all the abortion stuff.
Oh, yeah. Well, the abortion was a great political angle, right? Well, that was a problem with that one. It was a pretty extraordinary claim to make.
It didn't seem to be any for who made those who said that. And what was your response to them? I mean, just to try and draw it out of it. It kind of made me a bit of me.
I think. Yes, I agree. It's interesting that that part of that story was probably the most forceful part of that story. Well, it was the most forceful thing of the whole lot, I think.
I mean, you know, we had Tony Windsor there this morning sort of saying there's a lot more to come. I mean, I'll say the whole thing is so tortured. I mean, please take it away. Well, this is my pledge as opposed to the Fourth Estate.
I am not going to talk about Barney. Good. For at least another two weeks. Well, the real issue is to talk about love Ireland.
Yes, well, that's right. Oh, my God. Now, let's talk about love Ireland. I obviously don't know what to say about that show.
I really don't. The less good I think. Yeah, it's a very good answer. Yeah, great.
Well, look, that's it from us on the Fourth Estate. And I'd like to thank, I guess, tonight, Geraldine Duke from the ABC. Thank you, Geraldine. And Brad McLeod from Channel 9 in Melbourne.
Sitting next to a very large wheel. Thank you, Brad. Long time is the first time call. It's been a pleasure.
Pleasure's all pinhole, as I'm sure. Next week, my producer this evening, Anthony Dockera will be in the host seat. So if you don't like the sound of my voice, you can tune in and listen to him. And make sure you subscribe to the Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast episode that you can hear us talk media, politics and a few things in between.
Follow us on Facebook and Twitter. Our handle is Fourth Estate AU. My name is Peter Frey, and thank you very much for listening. Good night.