You're listening to the Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name's Tom Aonson, I'm sitting in the chair for Nana Koppel this week. Coming up on the show, Fairfax issues the biggest retraction we've probably seen this year over an ANZAC story. Plus the ABC is starting a new Buzzfeed style project after it acts 20 news positions, R-Russian Twitterbots influencing Australian politics and that Michelle Wolf comedy roast.
Was it more than just a storm and a teacup? All that and more coming up on the show. Joining me in the studio from Junkie is Sam Langford, Alex McKinnon from the Saturday paper and on the line is independent journalist Claire Connolly. Claire where are you calling us from?
In the Southern Highlands and New South Wales. Is it cold? It is, it's wonderful. Let's get into the topic.
So just yesterday the ABC revealed it's working on a new storytelling project. That's been described as an attempt to Buzzfeed eyes the national broadcast. Does that make sense? Well, Osman Faruque, the former editor at the pop culture and news website Junkie is reportedly joining the team.
I've been trying to come up with a funny analogy for a lifestyle vertical for the last 20 seconds and I have completely failed. I guess first congratulations to Osman or Oscar as he was named in press release by Senator Eric Bets. Apparently he's a purveyor of fake news and as a fellow purveyor of fake news who used to work in Oscar's role. I'm sure there's always room for this show.
I think Osman is an incredible journalist so it should not be seen as a reflection of his ability or talent and thoughts. I suppose in the back rooms of various newsrooms lifestyle has always been a little bit of a pejorative term for when you want to pivot from a breaking news or context journalism approach to creating more clickable shareable content. It's kind of like a polite way of saying we want hard hitting content that doesn't offend anyone. My concern with the ABC is that how to pretty great, if you can call it a lifestyle vertical although I would probably put it under a different column which is probably more contextual opinion but the drum was that for a long time and that was defunded a number of years ago.
I think it did a really excellent job of helping people to understand more broadly the context and issues of the things they were reading about and watching on the breaking news channel. Particularly after 20 journalists have been sacked and we've heard directives from Michelle Guthrie about creating more business friendly content and creating content that it seems to be more bipartisan although I don't really know what a news should be partisan in any particular way and claiming to sit down the middle is not what journalism role is meant to do. My concern with the creation of this vertical is it's a way to kind of water down the impact of the news that the ABC has for a very long time had a proud history of breaking and creating. Does anybody here see this as an attempt to reach out to those younger audiences that perhaps they lost when the drum is defunded?
Pushing they funded? I don't know whether the drum ever reached a young audience. They're definitely trying to reach younger people which is kind of evidence by the fact that they've hired Osman. It is a little bit kind of worrying like good luck to him I'm sure it'll be great.
The ABC is sort of trusted to break really hard hitting news and do long investigative reporting. It's by some way the most trusted media outlet in the country. It's one of the most trusted institutions in the country full stop and that's what sets it apart then in its regional reporting. Hopefully I can bring the ABC's ethos to this sort of reporting.
Hopefully they do it a little bit smarter and more substantive than everybody else. That would probably be the best outcome I guess. What do you think Sam? You work for Junkie.
Is this almost a crowding out with this producer crowding out in the media market? It's hard to know until we see the kind of content that they produce. I think if they're doing good original content and like some of the stuff that the best stuff that Junkie has published over the years then I think it's not so much crowding out is just introducing more voices and more trusted ABC voice on this kind of thing. I know that a lot of the content that we've had classed as lifestyle has involved really delving into the race politics of particular TV shows and stuff like that and doing stuff that I think you can consider to be hard-heating even if it's not news and I think if Osman brings that kind of work to this then I think it's something useful the ABC can contribute.
It's great to have a trusted voice backing that kind of narrative. The Australian first reported this story I think it was just yesterday but the Australians report back grounded Osman Farukis and his mother's politics and his defamation suit with Mark Latham. Is this genuinely relevant information to give us more of an idea about what this new vertical is or should we be judging the ABC's hiring practices based on this information? What do you think Alex?
I reckon we're going to have an entire Senate inquiry into it just based on the erica bets as of the world and their outrage about people with politics whom they disagree with working for the ABC. I can imagine Osman's name is going to come up at some Senate estimates hearings for the next maybe couple of years. No one is without political opinions. The real crux of it comes when an institution like the ABC hires them whether they can leave their politics at the door.
Osman's a pretty outspoken guy and now he's bound by the ABC charted to rein some of his opinions in. Chris Newman, the ABC political editor for a long time, he ran for ACT Parliament in 1998 on a pro-life anti-abortion ticket. That didn't really crop up anywhere when he became ABC's senior ABC political editor. I don't if it doesn't affect his career.
I don't see why it should affect Osman. Claire, what do you think? It's important right now that these instances of politicians telling the ABC who they should hire and fire demonstrate how important it is to entrain and law the ABC's independent. Yes, the ABC is government funded but that does not mean that it should be a government mouthpiece nor should that be the case for any public broadcaster.
And unlike the BBC, which either we might have its problems, it nonetheless has a legal case to make because its independence is enshrined. It worries me that any journalist, whether that's Chris Newman or Osmond Farraki, should be the subject of Senate hearings for years to come, that's not the role of the government to play. In a democratic country, it is not the role of the government to decide what is and is not newsworthy and it is not the role of the government to decide who should and should not be given the privilege of delivering that news. So I think it's really important that within these conversations we talk about what it means to what it means for the ABC to exist and what it means to work at the ABC.
And it even worries me that the ABC's charter requires people to reign in their political views because when you look at the parameters of the kinds of discussions that you see on the ABC on shows like Q&A, those parameters are very, very narrow. And often they don't provide audiences and readers of the various things that follow adequate context to make a proper decision about where they stand on any given issue. And I think it's important to have a range of voices with a range of different political opinions and any publication regardless of where that funding comes from. So I would like within this discussion and the discussions in the future, the issue with Emma Elboreche recently and a piece over company taxes and other examples of that, I think it's really important that these issues be included within these debates.
So what do you think? Emma Elboreche was actually incorrect and she was found to be factually incorrect in the articles that she was pulled up in front of Senate estimates for. Do you think it is possible that Osmo Faruki will be pulled up in front of Senate estimates in the near future? As far as independence, I think absolutely they should have it.
I think it's worrying that politicians, especially because they're some of the people the ABC, needs to report on and report on aggressively having a say in whose opinions they do and don't like and that's very, I think that's quite dangerous. As to whether Osmo be pulled up before the Senate, I don't really know. But I guess I would like to say, and obviously I come from a bit of a place of bias as someone who knows and gets on with Osmo. But I think that articles like the one in the Australian do him a bit of a disservice when they pull up every controversial thing he's ever done, whenever he makes the news and make a list of that.
It doesn't like accurately reflect what it's like to work with him. And given that he works in journalism and all that he's worked is publicly available under his byline on the website, all they would need to do is go and have a look at what he's done recently. I think they kind of side step and choose to ignore all the really good, thoughtful, considered work that he's done, the people who's worked with who have found that to be a positive experience. And instead they say once or twice he tweeted something angry or in some cases that they've interpreted as angry.
There was a line in the Australian piece saying that he retweeted and endorsed some tweet when actually he's retweeted was clearly criticizing it. Like in some cases I think they're cherry picking some of the more controversial things, which definitely exists, but it's not the whole experience of working with him. Yeah. I really agree.
In my experience I was a teddy bear. He can be a bit of a loose unit on Twitter, but Twitter is sort of designed for people to be a loose unit. If everyone was judged by what they did on Twitter, which is inevitably like the worst parts of their personality, myself and Cleo, none of us would ever work ever again. Can I just jump in to go back to the NREL breach thing real quick?
Sure. I'm sorry to sort of anchor on this, but what Emma Elberichie wrote was not actually factually incorrect. I think the issue was, at least from the ABC perspective, was that it too closely resembled opinion. I think that's a fair critique, but it's really important to mention that what the government claims to be correct or more factual was itself incorrect as well.
And I admire Emma Elberichie hugely, as I do many journalists in this industry, so I don't want to do her a disservice. But I think there is a broader problem here, which is that the way in which we talk about the economy is deeply flawed and often in some particular instances deliberately misleading. And it concerns me that when someone like Scott Morrison or Malcolm Turnbull pulled out the ABC and claims to know more about the economy than their own economics correspondence. That there aren't adequate resources within the ABC to be able to assess the merit of that claim.
And I think it was unfair that Emma came under so much criticism for her work, because actually there have been at least three or four studies, one from one of the most conservative complaints in the world, that actually argues for the case of abolishing company tax in the place of having all income or all profits made by corporations' tax as income. And the people who are the recipients of the dividends of those profits should also declare that money as income. And it should be a progressive taxation system. It's funny that something that Emma Alberichie wrote that companies that don't pay tax, it makes very little sense to cut company taxes when they're not paying anyway.
And that actually adheres to the claims of some of Australia and the world's most conservative and fiscally conservative think tanks and organizations. And so it is to this very reason that the ABC must enshrine independence legally within its charter, because I think Emma copped unfairly a huge amount of facts for something that wasn't actually factually inaccurate in the first place. Look, we may be straying a little bit. We'll probably have to return to this subject.
Again, when we know a little bit more about what the show will actually be or the vertical, the lifestyle vertical, you're listening to Fourth Estate. You're listening to Fourth Estate. I'm Tom Allenson, both Nina Coppole and Peter Frey are away this week. But tonight I'm speaking to Sam Langford from Junkie, Alex McKinnon of the Saturday Paper, and on the line is independent Geno Clare Connolly.
You can check our stuff out on Patreon and at Renegade Inc.com. Well, this week we saw possibly one of the biggest retractions and apologies this year. On Saturday Fairfax published a 300 word maya colpa over an era written historical account over the Battle of Phyllis Bretonore 100 years ago on Anzac Day. The main offense seemed to be where the story describes the John Monash giving a rousing speech to troops by referencing the painful memories of Gallipoli, but Monash couldn't have given it because he wasn't there.
Peace was written by the popular Anzac historian Dr. Jonathan King, and as far as I know Fairfax won't say whether it was fact checked. The ABC ran a radio piece including the same era unchecked and Malcolm Turnbull also made a similar mistake last week. Actually, in France at the site opening a museum named after John Monash, which was embarrassing for him.
And he was pulled up fairly quickly on that. I think he was, but it's possible that the bulk of the criticism came out today once people realised that the report was wrong. Right, yeah. Well, first of all, before we get to that, I just want to throw this out to everybody.
Has anybody here had to issue a retraction or an apology? How does that feel? I think I have. I can't remember anything specific.
Yeah, it's part of the job. Nothing like this. Nothing that kind of imagined, I think, an entire battle and the people who ran it and fought it. But yeah, everyone gets stuff wrong.
But that's why you need fact checkers. And if Fairfax is refusing to say that the story was fact checked, that probably means it wasn't fact checked. Yeah, right. Yeah.
I mean, is that the problem here? That such limited resources means that something as possibly sensitive as an exact history on the day, when the day's leading up to it comes out gobled. Claire, I know you work as an independent journalist. You don't have the resources to employ a fact checker or a copy editor.
Do you think this comes down to bad fact checking? I mean, on the one hand, yes, absolutely it does. And all new organizations should be employing fact checkers as well as sub editors because sometimes, you know, a comma or an apostrophe can change the meaning of an entire sentence. But if that entire sentence is wrong and there's no one there to pick it up, you know, that's even more of a problem.
As you said, I am independent. And I do fact check all of my work because I kind of personally feel as though the stakes are a little higher because I have all that much more to lose. So I mean, but also the kind of work that I do is quite research based. So, you know, I think it's really important to say there are some things that can't be fact checked and there are some things that you would have to make a judgment tool on, you know, sending a source, an entire story and then, you know, accepting a red pen edit is not for journalism.
But it also depends on the kind of journalism that you're doing. I work with a range of historians and political researchers and economists and at least with regards to how I'm quoting them and any work that they have been involved in, I will send them my work for fact check ahead of time because I live in constant fear of post publication and correction because I mean, we've all had them to some degree. I mean, I'm sure, you know, like Alex was saying, nothing on this level, but it still feels really terrible when that happens. And the goal is to have a watertight story ahead of time.
I'm also not dealing with the same kind of deadlines and I'm not kind of, I don't have to deal with the continual cycle of the 24 hour news cycle. So I understand that it might be a slightly different situation. But also with like within the need to fact check, I also think we need to recognize that there are some things that are still very much in contention and entire bodies of academic thought have been dedicated and who have argued for centuries or decades over particular issues. I'm not saying that this is that particular answer story is one of them.
But I think we need to recognize the limits that fact checking will have because there are some things that take 30, 40 years to come to light. So, you know, it's a complicated answer, but that doesn't mean that they should let newspapers offer books and not doing a very basic job of ensuring that what they're publishing is accurate. And on quite a sensitive occasion as well, I mean, look, Anne Zach, we can't lie. Is subject to a fair bit of mythology at times?
I think that's probably one of the core kind of pieces of tension in why it is kind of a contentious moment every year when it comes around. You think that, I mean, maybe it's an obvious question. Sam, should Fairfax and Alpiam have been a bit more careful in getting involved in what could be termed perhaps mythologizing? Yeah, well, I think they realized they were mythologizing given that they clearly thought it was true.
But I think maybe like in this case, it seems like perhaps because it was written by a historian, maybe they weren't as thorough with their fact checking as they would otherwise have been maybe they kind of assumed that he knew what he was talking about based on the books and stuff that he's put on. And I think it's important to make sure you're fact checking even reputable sources as well and even the kind of people who you think are the experts. Like some of the writing I've been doing recently has been about like open myth and legend. And all the experts in that give you different takes.
Like even the people with the PhDs, there's so much disagreement there and you only find that out when you've asked a few of them. I think unfortunately sometimes just deadline pressures mean that this is the first sort of stuff to fall by the wayside. Like we certainly don't have a dedicated fact checker. We make sure to try and fact check and sub edit our stories really well when we put them out, especially in the past.
But it's certainly not a newsroom. It's not a role that a person has. And I think in a lot of newsrooms that might be the case, but it could be. Well, I mean, I don't know in Australian history whether we have we don't have Martin Luther Kings.
We don't have many big heroes to look at throughout history. I hope I'm not offending anybody by saying that. We just don't feel we're doing perhaps attributing so many of the parts of ANZAC that people find heroism in. Attributing that to Monash is probably it just happened a little bit too easily, a little bit too lazily.
It's a weird phenomenon recently of people kind of going back and rewriting John Monash's life and his values. The liberal backbenchers who made the Sir John Monash for him, which is like a pro-col working group. And then his own descendants came out and said, you know, our grandfather or great-grandfather wouldn't have stood for this. I get your point about how we mythologize ANZAC Day.
Most people don't know pretty basic things about Australian history. A lot of people think we won on ANZAC Day. A lot of people don't know that when James Cook first landed, he wasn't Captain Cook, he was Lieutenant Cook. I didn't know that myself until an Aboriginal guy told me.
We have a pretty perfunctory understanding of our own history. Simpson and his donkey were in Australia, I don't know what nationality the donkey was. It was probably Turkish, but Simpson was British. Our own history is still kind of a mystery to us because often we are pretty indifferent to it.
Yeah, absolutely. And I think when you're talking about they're not really being one Luther Kings in Australia. I don't think that's true. I think there are so many hero figures or people who could be made into hero figures, who better or worse in Australian history, who just kind of get overlooked because I suppose media outlets and storytellers go to the easiest available person and they try to pile it all on someone like John Monash who they know about, who they've already got a bit of a legend around.
I've certainly heard like even the one that comes to mind is even in this actual story in the battle that the retracted story was about, the generals there arguably could have been defined as heroes. I don't know heaps about them, but the little bit that I read earlier today kind of showed that they had done some pretty impressive things pushing for particular strategies that hadn't been considered beforehand and pushing together credit for those afterwards and ultimately winning battles potentially saving lives there. But they get looked over and not even considered as an equivalent John Monash because we're also eager to leave onto that. Another example is when I've done reporting on public housing in Sydney, people like Jack Mundy and the union legends around Sydney have done stuff that you could compare to hero figures.
They've made profound speeches, they've been at important rallies, they've won really interesting battles on behalf of communities and we just don't hear about those. Can I talk in? Absolutely, please do. I completely agree with everything you just said.
The only thing I would add to that though is that within the range of what is considered acceptable opinions, there seems to be an attempt to one-dimensionalise the Anzac myth, which is that war is good and anyone who says otherwise it does. And like all wars, they are sometimes necessary, sometimes they're really messy. All the time they're incredibly complex and there are a number of things going on at any given time. All of them which sit on some level on a spectrum of atrocious, heartbreaking, unnecessary, heroic, brave, all of these things.
But anyone who tries to accurately address some of the more complex issues of war and in this particular example, Australia's involvement in the war, it's professionally threatened. We've had what three journalists over the last five years have their jobs threatened or have lost their jobs because they said something about the Anzac myth and the Anzac spirit that was deemed socially inaccessible. And then at least one of those instances that we have about now premised our. And again, this is coming down to who controls information.
And particularly when we're at a time when our own social networks like Facebook and Twitter are now saying that they're considering employing journalists out of the APNAP to put news alert on anything posted on Facebook that allows people to identify what is and is not Russian propaganda, just Russian propaganda, and just news which is considered to be conspiratorial or not within the range of acceptable opinions. And as we've all been discussing right now, things are really complex and no one is right 100% of the time and no one is wrong 100% of the time. And when we are being told what we should and should not believe and should not be allowed to read at any given time, I don't think any news organization or any single journalist will be able to individually accurately convey in the kind of words or less the entire body of context, history, truth and knowledge of any given story. And if journalists, if people who read journalism and who are interested in the news want to be informed, unfortunately that responsibility should fall to them.
And you have to read a lot of different things from a lot of different sources, some of which you will not agree with, in order to be informed as humanly possible. And no amount of fact checking and no amount of social media alerts will fix that problem for us. But it does worry me that for those of us who are trying to look into the myths and urban histories that have informed so much of our political understanding of the world threatened professionally simply for trying to do their jobs, that really worries me. Because as far as I know, this might have been an embarrassing retraction, but I don't think anyone has lost their job over it.
And I think that really should say something about what we will be prepared to tolerate within the media and the people who read it. I do think that perhaps Dr Jonathan King will not be writing for Fairfax anymore. I'd have to check that out, but I think I did read that today. But we'll have to leave that there.
You're on fourth estate. You're listening to fourth estate. You're with me, Tom Elenson, and I'm speaking to Alex McKinnon from the Saturday paper, Sam Langford from Junkie, and joining us on the line is Freelance reporter Claire Connolly. On the weekend, News Corp's The Times in the UK published findings from a study claiming that opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn's election campaign could have been influenced by 6,500 Russian Twitter bots.
But closer to home, the Telegraph reported this week that Labor Senator Kimba Kitchen, a factional ally of Bill Shorten, has more than 7,000 Russians following her on Twitter. That's more than a quarter of her followers. Most haven't tweeted anything in more than a year. Now, the Telegraph used a service called Export Tweet to analyze her followers' language and found 27% spoke Russian as their first language.
But Kitchen has since posted an official Twitter analysis that says 97% of a follower spoke English. Alex, it gets a bit technical here. Do you know, is this just a matter of what kind of analysis software is used to get such different results or is one of them made up? I don't know necessarily what the right kind is.
I don't pretend to be an expert. But I think that overall, these reports are pretty rubbish. And I think reporting on things like Twitter bots and things like Russia and elections has been in general really poorly done. So in these cases, the kind of claims that are being made about Jeremy Corbyn's supposed Russian bot helpers and the ones that are working in Australia, in both of these cases, there are still a lot of questions about the methodology they used.
I'm not quite sure what methodology they used in Australia, it may have been in the article, but I haven't seen that. In the UK, actual researchers are saying, hang on, there are lots of different things that could have gone wrong here. They get very technical and boring. But the option of it is no one at this point is totally sure that this data has been collected accurately.
It also needs to be put in context. At the end of the day, 6,000 Russian-speaking bots tweeting have probably not convinced the British public to vote for Jeremy Corbyn. And he didn't win anyway. I think that in that case, and certainly in Australia, even if 20% or something are for followers are Russian bots that have not tweeted, they're not persuading anyone and they've got a pretty low capacity to persuade anyone.
It's probably a situation I know that in some cases, people buy followers or in some cases bots are drawn to accounts and just follow them on mass. But it's probably not the situation for alarm that's being made out to be. Claire, what do you think of that? I completely agree.
I'm so relieved to hear such a crosion and eloquently put opinion on this because it's not one huge series often who's like to think. But why are we even talking about this? We still have no evidence that Russia was responsible for anything. There are 10,000 NATO troops sitting on its borders.
It was basically put under siege in Syria and to respond. This idea that Russia is responsible for all of the nation's ills is just like such a transparent attempt to try and divert attention from what the real problems were two and a half years ago, America voted for Donald Trump and half of Britain voted to leave the EU. And it was fairly aptly and confidently put at the time that it was because most of the general public are really sick of being left behind. And it seems as though for the last two years there has been a very deliberate attempt often by newspapers like The Times and The Daily Telegraph to put a dancer on those claims and put it all at the front door of Russia.
Now among the no illusion, Russia is not a democracy in Britain doesn't eat rainbows for breakfast. But you can't just put everything down to Russia. The West and Australia and America and Britain, we have a dying middle class. We have African Americans and Native Americans and indigenous people in Australia and women and LGBTQIA who have for generations been systemically excluded from the economy.
And now it's as though a greater portion of the population have now discovered that they're in the same situation that most of us have been familiar with for a really long time. And it seems as though every time we talk about Russian bots, it's an attempt to distract from the underlying issues that are affecting the massive political crisis we find ourselves in at this very moment. So like who cares how many people are following Jeremy Corbyn on Twitter and how many of them are Russian bots? Because there are probably American bots and Australian bots and German bots and Greek bots too.
And it's not the only country that has a counter-intelligence operation growing. Alex, we do know that we have a good idea that false accounts are being used to distribute political messages from foreign countries in the US and the UK. Here in Australia as well, do you think that the Australian media are ready for this? I don't think we have seen yet an instance where there has been a big social media impact on any of our elections.
We've seen politicians using social media. We haven't seen anything like a foreign power using industrial-grade espionage on social media to try to influence the outcome of the election. On the Jeremy Corbyn thing, the tablet newspapers in Britain come up with some new scandal every couple of months about Jeremy Corbyn and then it turns out they just kind of made it up. There was one a few months ago that basically accused him of being a traitor, of being like a traitor to the United Kingdom.
And then everyone had to come out and say, oh sorry, actually we got that one wrong. So this kind of seems to be that sort of thing. In regards to Russian Twitter bots, the whole analysis about whether if 20% of someone's Twitter followers tweet in Russian, then how are they going to influence politics in a country where everyone speaks English? I think they are the claims made where they are actually retweeting things in English, things are sympathetic to in the Times case, Corbyn's campaign.
In that case, Twitter, we vastly overestimate the impact of Twitter, Reddit, which is kind of popularly known for being a place where men's rights activists and men who live in their basements hang out, just the past Twitter in terms of number of active users. Domestically, I doubt 99 people out of 100 would even know who Kimbelly Kitchen is. Most people aren't on Twitter. Most people don't care about any of this sort of stuff.
The British thing and the Australian thing just seem like beat up to that. Unreally worth anyone's time. Yeah, I just think it's also about just using, you're not going to bit when stories like this come out. People say words like Russian and bots and I think maybe because they don't understand either of those areas, anything goes.
Like, if you've reasonably told someone that the equivalent of a bunch of Twitter followers sharing the content, like a bunch of people, you can't understand coming up to you on the street and giving you flyers, you disregard it. Like, we put more weight if we even used Twitter on the people that we follow who we respect, who we actually follow because we think they're putting out views that we're interested in who might link to actual articles about it. Like, there is scope for social media influence, absolutely. But I think we also need to bear in mind what a bot can actually make a person believe and it's not going to be this giant catastrophic event that these articles make it seem like it will be.
Of course, it seems as though it's an attempt to regain credibility, because in a fire, over the last two weeks you've had the time to publish two factually incorrect pieces, one which cited a Tory report about Russian bots and it identified as its main characters, four lead actors that it defined as Russian bots that were neither Russian nor bots. And then last weekend, it used the front page of its newspaper to attack a group of academics for launching a research group on Syria. So while they're publishing these articles claiming that Russian bots are having an outside influence, they themselves are trying to have an outside influence on their readers and they wouldn't be trying to do it if they weren't feeling as though their credibility was under threat. And it's disappointing when you see these arbiters of the fourth estate basically siding with the cowards that they're meant to be holding to a chow because they're concerned, I'm assuming because they're concerned for their bottom line because none of that kind of reporting actually helps readers understand better the world around them.
And that's essentially what journalism is well used to do, or at least part of journalism's role. And if they weren't so concerned about their legacy and their impact coming under threat, maybe they would be doing some more substantial reporting. But it seems like a waste of two pretty great front pages that could have been used for any number of issues like the homelessness rate in the UK if we're talking about the times or the fact that we have a dying middle class basically across Australia, the United States and Britain, you know, house prices, poverty, the closing of domestic violence shelters. You know, there are any indigenous issues, indigenous incarceration and abuses of power and incarceration.
Any number of issues that we could be reporting on and instead we're devoting time and energy to talking about Twitterbot. And I think perhaps then we're all agreed that maybe Twitter doesn't matter. My Twitter's pretty good. So you're on fourth estate.
I'm Tom Elinson, you're listening to fourth estate and in the studio we've got Alex McKinnon from the Saturday PayPass, Sam Langford from Junkie and on the line we've got independent Jerno, Claire Connolly. So every year we get some pretty searing comedy from the White House Correspondence Dinner roast in the US. You see the line between comedy and the offence seem to get a lot thinner though. Michelle Wolf was the comedian hired for the roast and her Royal Humour Centre be going down fine until she got to the White House Press Secretary, Sarah Huckabee Sanders.
Let's hear a little bit of it. I actually really like Sarah. I think she's very resourceful. Like she burns fats and then she uses that ash to create a perfect smoky eye.
Like maybe she's born with it. Maybe it's life. It's probably life. And so the backlash and arguments about that started and lasted all week.
Where do we start? I mean, was anybody offended by Michelle's roast? No. Like she was very funny.
I don't know why people also worked up about this when the point of inviting a comedian to this dinner is for them to roast everyone in the room and insult people gently. Weirdly people have tried to make this about her somehow insulting Sarah Huckabee Sanders body image in some way when all she said was a comment about smoky eye and people just latched on to that as if like any comment on appearances terrible these days. Ventioning someone burning the truth and making it into smoky eye is not body shaming someone, it's shaming someone for burning the truth. It's pretty clearly about her political activity.
Yeah. I think I have heard other commentary saying that it was actually quite clearly intended as a compliment on makeup school. Just from general observation over the years, the White House press call seemed like the most miserable, humulus bunch of pricks in existence. I guess like to Sam's point about inviting a comedian to roast you at an event and then getting mad when a comedian roast you, it takes me back to 2006 when the then Bush White House invited Stephen Colbert to MC the correspondent's dinner.
And George Bush was there. Donald Trump is the first president in a long time not to show up to the event. Coward. Exactly.
I just had to sit there kind of visibly seething as Stephen Colbert roasted him and the entire room of very kind of self-important journalists about the complete, the completely terrible job they did in reporting in the lead up to the Iraq war. And he was the only person speaking since in the entire room and he got booed and people walked out and it was a controversy and all the rest of that crap. But he wasn't delivering a message for them. He was delivering a message for people whose lives were impacted by those policies.
Claire, this seemed to you to be a little bit more of an extended and perhaps more I don't know a bigger outrage than press has seen before. I think it was fairly predictable. It helps that she was female and young. I think it probably helps keep that fire burning a little longer than it would ordinarily have.
But I think it's amazing that of all the insulting things that were said at night and accurately and rightly so, the only thing that both the White House and the United States Washington Press Corps had to cling to was you were mean about a woman. Because that's the only thing that they could come up with that they could reasonably put into a category of well this will make for a good social media shaming. Because she questioned the job that they've been doing rightly. She questioned Trump's heinous ability.
There was nothing that she said that was in any way incorrect or inaccurate and it was also hilarious. So body shaming Sarah Huckabee Sanders by a bunch of people who quite happily published headline after headline about various horrible things that they now president said about Hillary Clinton or it said about any journalist or any person who did insult him. So then to turn around now and say you're insulting Sarah Huckabee Sanders and that's where we draw the line. That in itself demonstrates the complicity between the United States Press Corps and the government and them in to be holding to a chart.
And I know I sound like the tired boring political junkie lefty here but it's like there's just a reoccurring thing here which is what happens when power and media colludes a little too closely. We're talking about collusion on a massive scale here at the moment about whether or not this election was a fact throwing influence watered down. But we're not really examining the role that the press corps have played in that. And Michelle will split up on stage and say I think you love Trump.
You act like you hate him but he's helping your bottom line. And I'm wondering if there's like an influencing factor because she kind of pulled out the elephant in the room but you can't then just address the elephant directly. So well they'll just take the identity politics and political correctness angle and all the rally behind Sarah Huckabee Sanders who regularly lies to the press and refuses to answer questions. You know it's just once again showing how we United States Press Corps has become and I thank Michelle Wolf for taking that bullet for all of us.
Yeah and I think also the only people I've really seen complaining of people who were in the room or who were targeted like politicians in the press corps like I haven't really seen a good deal of outrage from just average viewers on this one. Oh totally it's media generators. Well we might have to leave it there. That's it for us on Fourth Estate.
Thank you to my guests Sam Langford from Junkie, Alex McKinnon from the Saturday paper and independent Gurney O'Konely on the phone. Next week the amazing Peter Frey will be back in the host seat with the years of industry experience at his usual charm. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and weather to combine. We'll be back with Monnex Week but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Facebook or Twitter.
Our handle is Fourth Estate AU. My name's Tom Altson. Thanks for listening. A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen.
It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer. That's how we protect Ontario.
For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca. Pay for by the Government of Ontario.