Hi everyone, this is Jem, and you are about to hear our microdose episode all about this very important essay by Alexandra Kollontai, published in English under the title Make Way for Winged Eros. But before that, I want to tell you about an event that is going to be happening on Wednesday 7th of May 2025, and apologies to everyone listening in the future. But if you're not, then on Wednesday 7th of May 2025... At the Avalon Cafe in South Bermondsey, in South London, we will be holding a live ACFM event. This is being hosted by Circle Dance, which is a regular party featuring DJs and sometimes live music, which is organised by producer Matt. On this occasion, I think we're just going to have DJs, mostly playing sort of mood music. And the main substance of the event that evening will be a live evening length ACFM trip, a participatory evening for all of us. We'll be talking about the future.
what we mean by it, how we imagine it, how we get there, how we invent it. There's going to be a consciousness raising workshop style discussion for everybody attending who wants to take part. And that's going to be punctuated by things like conversations between the three of us who host the show, film clips, a slideshow, collective listening to some music, some theories and history. It's going to be like an interactive episode of the show that we create together. It's £7 to get in. There'll be a bar and hot vegan food on offer at the Avalon Cafe, which is a very nice little venue in, as I say, in South Bermondsey, all the way down in South London. So quite a schlep for me from Walthamstow, but absolutely worth it for anyone. You can find tickets at the website. There's no www in the address. The address is just circle-dance.eventcube.io. That's circle-dance.eventcube.io. And that is where you can get tickets. And we really hope to see many of you there. Now, back to the episode.
This is acid man. Hello and welcome to ACFM, the home of the weird left. My name's Keir Milburn and I'm joined as usual by my good friend Nadia Idle. Hello. And my other good friend, Jeremy Gilbert. Hello. And today we're doing one of our special reading group sessions and we're reading Madeway for Winged Eros by Alexandra Kollantai. We were doing this linked to our session, the main trip that we recorded called Fifty Shades of Acid. One of the things we looked at there was the whole Acid Communist, Acid Corbynist project, our project, ACFM project. And linked to that, we wanted to read.
what we thought of as a classic AC, acid communist text. We thought about something by Felix Guattari, but if you've ever read anything by Felix Guattari, you'll know the problems there. They're quite dense and not quite suited. So we thought we'd go back to a real classic, a text from 1923, a text from the moment of the Russian Revolution, or just after the moment of the Russian Revolution, the moment of effervescence, perhaps. Do we want to set the context about who Alexandra Kollontai is?
before we start the text. Yes, but before we even do that, let's just say that this is freely available on the internet. So if you look for, listeners, Make Way for Winged Eros, you will find this text. I've printed it out on recycled paper, of course, and it is around 19 pages, so 19 short pages with big margins. So if you would like to read along with us, you can go and pause this and go and get that reading now. So Alexandra Kollontai. Alexandra Kollontai was a Russian revolutionary. She came from a highly privileged background, but became a revolutionary at a young age. She's born in the 1870s.
So she's been heavily involved in the Russian Revolution. She's had a very interesting political career. She was a Menshevik for a long time. Part of the faction from the Russian Social Democrats didn't agree with Lenin's turn away from democracy. towards the organizational technique of the vanguard party but then she once the revolution was underway and the russian civil war was underway she joined the bolsheviks although she then joined the sort of anarcho-syndicalist fraction of the bolsheviks the workers opposition which is one of those figures that i often think yeah i think that's what i'd have done in that situation that's the fraction i'd have joined at that moment i always think it's completely absurd when people try to define their political identity in the 2020s on the basis of which fraction in the russian revolution they've aligned themselves with which loads of people still do on the other hand it's a sort of irresistible it's a sort of irresistible exercise Then Colin Tye would join the revolutionary government and she has the record of being the first woman in history to be counted as a member of a government. There were women legislators, there were women elected MPs in various countries before that, but no woman had been a member of a cabinet government, unless you are counting women who are like sovereigns. I don't think there isn't even an example, say if you go back to the Middle Ages, of a female minister in a government. There are queens.
But this, so she, that I know of, and I know that other people who've tried to assess this have also come to the conclusion, people who know more about this, come to the conclusion that Conanty is in fact the first woman ever to be a member of a government. Eventually, the sort of international factional conflict within the Communist Party in Russia leads to her, she doesn't end up being either exiled or murdered by Stalin, as happens to almost all of her compatriots, all of her cohort are Bolsheviks, but she does end up having to effectively be outside the USSR for most of her remaining life. She serves as an ambassador to Norway and to Sweden for a long time. And she plays an important role in negotiating peace between the Soviet Union and Finland at one stage. And eventually she lived until the early 50s. She's a really, really interesting figure. She's a key and she's absolutely, she was understood by her contemporaries in her own time and has been understood by many people subsequently as an absolutely crucial figure in the history of socialist feminism. You know, she was good friends with Rosa Luxemburg. They would sometimes hang out together. I believe they attended the first ever International Socialist Women's Conference together, for example. She's a very, very interesting figure. And she was obviously very concerned with the question of...
What is the place of women and what is the role of something like feminist thought in the building of a socialist society? And in the context of this particular article, this particular article was written for the Communist Youth magazine. in the early 20s and it is called letter to a young comrade and it is presented as a reply to a letter received either by the magazine or by colin tai personally from a young comrade somewhere out in the soviet union during this period of effervescent revolutionary construction and the young comrade is complaining that in in recent months their their fellows have been overly distracted by a growing interest in romantic love which wasn't something that was distracting people a couple of years previously And this is her response to that claim. Is it romantic love, necessarily? We'll get into that. Yeah, that is what the letter is responding. The claim that's being made is that they're spending their time on having relationships, having some romantic relationships. And then the implication being they shouldn't be. That's a sort of deviation and a waste of time. Yeah, one's always reminded of one of my absolute favourite lines from the history of world cinema is that line from the film of Dr Zhivago, where a commissar shouts at the titular hero, the petty bourgeois Dr Zhivago, the personal life is dead.
That is supposed to make the bourgeois liberal Western viewer shiver with terror at the thought that a dictatorial socialist regime might declare the personal life to be dead. I remember watching that even as a teenager thinking, well, that sounds quite good, actually. I wouldn't mind my personal life being dead, just being able to devote myself fully to the project of collective emancipation. That sounds all right. The reason I was questioning that specific thing about that terminology around romance, obviously we are going to get to this later, but whether it's romantic or not, I think is a question that is taken up by her analysis. I think probably it would be easier for us to say like personal relationships, that's what he's complaining about, like personal relationships and personal sexual relationships. And she doesn't use the word romance at all in the text, which is interesting.
Well, it's not used in this translation. I have to say, the translation is by... It's a translation by Alex Holt. Before we get on to the text, this is my first time reading this text. When I was sort of like a teenager, my father used to be in a libertarian socialist group, Solidarity, I've mentioned it a few times, and they republished Alexander Kolontai's pamphlet on the workers' opposition, basically, on making the case for the workers' opposition. So I read that, and there was some sort of context in that. I'd sort of known about this, but it was my first time reading it. And it might be useful just to mention a little bit about that, the analysis in that workers' opposition.
pamphlet and that and it was a current as well is that the party become bureaucratized basically And, you know, what they wanted was to de-bureaucratise the party. And sort of like an anarcho-syndicalist, they wanted more direct workers' control over individual factories, but also more direct workers' control over the direction of the economy. So sort of more democratic planning rather than the sort of technocratic planning. They were opposed to the new economic policy as well. Yeah, in particular, yeah. The policy of allowing some kind of restoration of petty bourgeois privileges in order to generate economic growth. You've got to say these days, like looking at world history for the past 120 years, given that basically that's what the Chinese Communist Party decided to do sometime in the 80s, instead of doing perestroika and glancenostal.
workers' control in a sort of Yugoslavian style on a global scale. And given that it does seem to have worked out quite well for them, I do find myself wondering if maybe the new economic policy was correct. But my historical sympathies have always been with that left critique. That's the argument for what happens in the Soviet Union is that they were immediately in a war with the Western powers as they all invaded, Britain invades, et cetera. And they're just coming out of that period when Colin Tye's writing this, whether they knew or not Hitler's tanks were going to be rolling up through Russia in order to murder and subjugate that population.
And you sort of need to industrialize to prepare for that. But anyway, that's a big counterfactual. But the other thing about, we should add a little bit more of a tragic tone to the story of Colin Tai. She basically says, I need to go abroad. And so they start sending her to various places in order for, you know, she wants to keep being participant in the revolution, but she can't do it in Russia. So she gets sent on various ambassadorial sort of missions. I think she's the first ever ambassador as well, isn't she? A female ambassador because she's ambassador to Norway. Yes, I think she probably is, yeah. But basically she sort of realizes that that is in effect sort of like an exile, that they're sending her there so they don't have to kill her basically. And she makes a decision to stop criticizing the Soviet Union.
Yeah, she doesn't get involved in any of the public criticism around the purges. And there's various speculations about why, but the most probable reason is she had a son and I think a grandson eventually who were living in the Soviet Union who probably would have been killed if she had done. Yeah, I mean, the other leaders of workers' opposition were all... killed in the purchase, basically. And most of the opponents were because I wasn't too. But there's a tragic tone to it. A lot of the revolutionaries, because she was a really, really committed revolutionary, and a lot of those, you know, there's a tragic tone to quite a lot of that because of the purchase, particularly in the 30s, etc. One more thing, sorry, one more aspect of Alexandra Kollontai that I just want to bring up before we start reading, which is that she has the look of an emancipated person, the way she looks at a camera. It is absolutely striking to me, looking at her portraits online. And I think it's quite rare to find women's pictures like that. And it reminds me of the kind of coffee table books that were made of like the late 60s, early 70s.
like feminists when like you know feminism was exploding in the west and like that gaze to have to have a series of pictures of women or in this case one woman who's just looking at the camera with such confidence i think has like i feel like she's got like the like her revolutionary ideals kind of behind her it really it really is striking to me like the images of her are online so do check them out the look of confidence yeah that's true well she wrote i mean also in the 20s she publishes a memoir called the autobiography of a sexually emancipated woman and she also published a novel called red love she definitely saw herself as somebody who was sexually emancipated And that's partly that's informing the whole of this piece of writing. You just don't tend to get women who are like staring down at the camera and they've got each arm on the arm of an armchair. It's a very kind of, it's associated with men, a lot of the poses that you find. It really stands out to me. And these are pictures from like a hundred years ago of her sitting, you know, on a chair wearing these, you know, Victorian clothes. But the way she's looking at us is, you know, I think is really striking. That sort of relates to the sort of period when this is written, 1923, you know, the full artistic avant-garde sort of effervescence is going on.
They'd just about won the civil war. They fought off the Western powers, et cetera. And it's that that gives this a sort of tragic poignancy, basically, because that is not the sort of mood. She probably wouldn't be looking that way later on in life when she's had to cut her cloth quite considerably. She's basically lived in exile.
for 30 years or something even in the later picture she is still staring down at the camera that's nice yeah that's nice to hear it's true staring down at the camera in all and almost all of her pictures which i think it just genuinely is quite rare and she's not smiling in any of them yeah totally i was trying to set that that period is like the period of effervescence with a later tragic period basically so that goes back to our earlier discussion about like the new economic policy where we definitely need an acfm line on that but like you know we do it's the question the question the wider question is you know was this effervescence always going to have some element of tragedy in it because it needed to defend itself when the German revolution fails, it then stands alone and it needs to defend itself against an incredibly hostile world, basically, a world which is going to become so hostile that it's going to include the Nazis and they're going to try to invade and subjugate the whole country, the whole population. That's one of the questions, isn't it, is whether in that period at that time, whether any socialist project was going to entail a deeply tragic element.
But anyway, let's get back to the effervescent moment. You're saying effervescent a lot, Kia. That's usually my term. You're usually Mr. Stats. I don't know what is going on with this conversation already. Everything's been subverted already.
Let's start. So the first section is called love as a socio-psychological factor. And in fact, you know, the historical sort of story we've been setting up there is quite relevant because the story she's sort of saying in this opening bit is that there's been this, and it's in reply to this supposed letter, that there's been this, you know, this intense civil war in which people haven't had the room to think about questions such as love. Now we've got a little bit of calm and we can start to address that to some degree. And she puts it sort of this way, there can be no doubt that Soviet Russia has entered a new phase of the civil war. The main theatre of struggle is now the front where the two ideologies, the two cultures,
The bourgeois and the proletarian do battle. Alongside the victory of communist principles and ideas in the sphere of politics and economics, a revolution in the outlook, emotions, and the inner world of working people is inevitably taking place. And your attitude to life, society, work, art, and to the rules of living, i.e. morality, can already be observed. The arrangement of sexual relations is one aspect of these rules of living. One of the things that comes up from there, and something that's going to structure the text, which might be worth talking about, is that opening line about how these two ideologies, the bourgeois and the proletarian, are doing battle. Because the text is really admirable in trying to position
concepts of love, like materially and historically. But you would say, reading it today, that this faith that there are two clear ideologies, two clear cultures linked to the material circumstances of the bourgeois and the proletarian seems harder to defend, I would say. I mean, I think it's really important that she starts this and she introduces this idea really early in the text, this idea that the revolution in outlook, emotions and inner world is, you know, up in front. as one of the main contexts that are going to be discussed, right? So she tells us right at the beginning, this is something that we need to be paying attention to. You need a kind of inner revolution for this thing to work. And then she comes back to that at the end. So I thought that was important. I think that's all true, yeah. I think Keir's raised an interesting point. I mean, you're basically querying the determinism of this model, according to which there's a clearly identifiable bourgeois ideology of love, and then there's a clearly identifiable alternative socialist ideology of love, where she says proletarian.
I mean, I'd say yes and no. I'd say, I mean, clearly, the actual lived experience of the past century has produced outcomes that are more complicated than a simple dichotomy would lead you to necessarily expect. But if you understand these as being sort of, they're sort of their tendencies, or they're kind of, they are sort of ideal types, but they're going to be, in reality, you're going to experience a sort of combined and uneven development in terms of how people actually live these, and they're going to be modified by circumstances, then I think it's still a, I think it's a pretty reasonable position. And I would say the regularity with which experiences of mass struggle, especially class struggle and all these complex forms have led to sort of questionings of abortion morality, for example, and a move in the direction of something that was trying to be more egalitarian, less individualistic. The regularity with which that has happened at different historical cultural moments, whether you're talking about Russia in the 20s, whether you're talking about the counterculture in the 60s and 70s, whether you're talking about revolutionary Cuba, whether you're talking about revolutions in Asia, the regularity of that seems to me to sort of bear it out to a certain extent as a model. It's like any model you're deriving from 19th century Marxism. You've got to assume it's going to only be applicable to the extent that you can complexify it. Basically, with the critique of the linking of a bourgeois conception of love to the material circumstances of a bourgeoisie.
given that those terms seem antiquated to us now. But that seems really convincing as we go through this text. I suppose the proletarian is more difficult because in which material circumstances is this new conception of love rooted? Because they're going through a process of transition, aren't they? They're going through a process of transformation. So that complicates it. And that complication seems to be overridden by a certain determinism in this text, I think. But I'm still on board with the project, Alexandra. Well, it's a polemical text. I think it's borne out. I'm standing up against your bourgeois revisionism.
The Lenin cap has appeared on the head of Tanky Gilbert once again. So after the bit you just read, Kia, again, I think it's really interesting, that one sentence of over the five years of the existence of our Labour Republic, the revolution on this military front has been accomplishing a great shift in the way that men and women think. So again, she's introducing, like, we have to be taking into consideration what is happening in our internal worlds and how that relates to the social reality. And I think that's really, again, she's basically saying, I'm going to be talking to things which are not just about the material, the external, the socio-political, the economic, but how we are as people and how that plays into how we actualize ourselves in everyday lives. I think that's why this is a really, really ACFM text, because she's trying to say, we have to be looking at both all the time. Yeah, I mean, it sort of relates a little bit to how we were trying to define the ACFM project as well in the last podcast, where we're trying to say that we need to widen the aspects of what is considered political. Two things such as love, et cetera, which of course is one of the projects of the feminist movement.
So yes, this is an ECFM text. That's what I'm saying. She's got this idea that we were having a war and fair enough, you know, we just wanted to fucking take our minds off things. But then we've got a bit of time and we can consider other forms of love. And there's something behind that. There's a model of like libidinal energy or scarce libidinal energy, basically. Something like that, I think. Not just attention. Not just, we're wound up on that. We basically have all our attention focused on the war, et cetera. We don't have time to think about love. It is a more energetic thing going on.
But I object to your use of the word fuck there, actually, because I think that what she's saying is it's unattached. So I would see it as casual sex. But she later goes on to say that having like, you know, I don't know. I don't know whether I would call it fucking or whatever, but like there's a certain kind of unattached sex which she's not getting behind. So I don't think actually from a female perspective that that's what she's saying. She's saying unattached sexual relations rather than the connotations that some people might have with what fucking is.
i think either we can agree she's talking about casual sex she's talking about the idea that in a moment of social crisis that's demanding huge expenditures of energy on it from everybody then there's a tendency towards casual sex partly just as a way of sort of relieving tension and there isn't really an opportunity for people to even think about forming relationships which again i mean this is completely consistent with the sort of social histories people have done of sex during world war ii for example like it's not it's interesting she's writing this in 23 and it's basically like her her general impressions of what's going on And there wouldn't have been, there was no such thing as social history at that time. So there wasn't loads of documentation of comparable historical moments which could verify whether this is true or not. And continue now, the social history of, as I say, of World War II, for example, suggests this is totally true. This is totally what happens during periods of massive social upheaval, which are generally understood to be more or less definitely temporary, even though people don't know exactly how long they're going to last. And also during periods when, I mean, to some extent, the violence means that people aren't really sure who's going to survive either.
And yeah, I think you're totally right. There is a sort of energetics here. And I was thinking it's interesting to think about this essay in a much broader context of people trying to think about the relationship between psychic life and social life and material life at this time. I mean, you could read this alongside Voloshinov's book about Freud and Freudianism. Voloshinov, another radical Bolshevik thinker of the period, which comes out six years after this.
and uh yeah he doesn't he isn't totally dismissive of freud and psychoanalysis as some more casual marxist would be but he says you've got you've really got to try to think about psychic life in relation to social and economic life in a way that psychoanalysis tends to avoid doing and and there's a long history of people trying to think in those terms and and of coming coming to the conclusion that in order to be able to do that you do have to sort of have to think in terms of sort of unenergetics whether it's imagined or real sort of uh energetics and um you know this is a this is a big big problem for me with michelle foucault's actually michelle foucault in the history of sexuality volume one famously is very very dismissive of this it's silly to think about sexuality of this as this rebellious little energy that is only ever subject to that is sometimes subject to repression and not subject to repression and instead we should just understand sexuality as always being sort of purely historically constructed in a given moment and the experiences of sexuality from one historical moment to the next being completely different from each other and i think from a materialist perspective that's not an entirely satisfactory viewpoint really that it's not entirely satisfactory and i think i'm partly thinking about this because it's again it reminds me of conversations i've had years ago with some conversations having with mark actually i'm always saying i'm going to stop referring i'm going to stop talking about chats i had with mark fisher but it's always coming up and because on the on the kind of blog scene that mark and anix were part of because they were precisely because there was this anti-hippie prejudice this deep anti-hippism this hippie phobia as i called it
They were always trying to promote the idea of a philosophy which, like, whatever it could or couldn't be, it could not be in any way vitalist. Like, it couldn't be in any way informed by some silly idea of sort of a life energy as informing people's existence. But on the other hand, they were always trying to sort of balance that with this intuition that something like what Jean-Francois Lyotard called the libidinal economy, like, it is a necessary component of, it's a thing you necessarily have to understand if you're going to understand human existence. That's definitely going on in Voloshinov, and I think it's going on here as well. You're trying to find a way to talk about the idea that we are always caught up in sort of economies of energy without either falling back into a sort of capitalist language, which just thinks of your relationships as investments you are making for the future, which you should calculate according to some utility, and without collapsing into a sort of mysticism, the sort of mysticism of somebody like Henri Bergson, as they would have seen it, who was a big famous bourgeois philosopher of the 20s, and I think really interesting, but they would have seen him as problematic because of his lack of class politics.
And I think that's partly why I do think this essay by Conanty, although it's basically a little, it's a speculative essay in a popular magazine. It's sort of the equivalent to a blog post today. I think it is making a really interesting contribution to this much bigger question. So yeah, she is implicitly working with this model according to which, well, everybody has sort of a finite amount of, you know, psychophysical energy that they can spend on tasks. And if you're having to devote too much of it to revolution at a given moment, then you're going to have to just, you're going to have to just meet your physical needs for a while. Yeah, I think that's really good.
What's also interesting about the text is it raises questions for us in the 21st century as well about energy. And then it's made me think a lot about, OK, well, she's in a very, very different context to how we are today. And I brought this up as well in my conversation with Amber Massey Blumfield in The Last Microdose. This idea we're trying to unpack, well, what's the relationship between art or creativity and war in contrast to creativity and capitalism? And this is partly making me think this. As I was reading the text, I was trying to think, well, how do these energetic principles relate to the world of today with the kind of what I call the slow sludge of capitalism?
opposed to, you know, the energy of war? Like, what does it do to like expending not just, you know, energy in the classic sense, but also like, I think, and this comes up for her, although obviously she doesn't use this terminology, like bandwidth. Like, do we have the bandwidth to even think about these things? Or do we have the bandwidth to act in this way or that way? So that's one area where energy is important. But also I have to say, I mean, we're still right at the beginning of the text. I mean, for me, I'm on page two, where, you know, there's this paragraph at the beginning where she starts to introduce this concept of the riddle of love. And what I take from that paragraph is actually, I can feel the spring in that. So what Kia is also pointing to, I think, in terms of like using this term effervescence is, you know, as far as she's concerned,
the revolution has won like they are in like the building of the infrastructure like after the war and i can feel the spring in her confidence of how she speaks about like what the program is next and i think that's also quite interesting should we just concretize it just read a couple of lines just so that people who haven't got the text in front of them So it's in the face of the revolutionary threat, tender winged eros. So she sets this thing off of winged eros and wingless eros. And what we were talking about as casual sex or sex without great commitment and parted without tears or regret is wingless eros. And now is the time of winged eros, she says. In the face of revolutionary threat, tender winged eros fled from the surface of life. There was neither time nor a surplus of inner strength for loves, joys and pains. Such is the law of the preservation of humanity's social and psychological energy. As a whole, this energy is always directed to the most urgent aims of the historical moment.
And in Russia for a time, the biological instinct of reproduction, the natural voice of nature dominated the scene. Men and women came together. Men and women parted much more easily and more simply than before. They came together without great commitment and parted without tears or regret. That's one of the ways she sort of talks about love is through this sort of energetics. But then just relating to like the war points, we probably get into this a bit more depth a bit later. She also talks about, she also uses warm and cold as like this way of like talking about emotion, basically. The coldness that you need in war perhaps is fading. Now we can have slightly more warm emotions, something like that.
I feel like we should explain this term as well, actually, for people who don't know. So Eros was obviously the Greek god or demigod, depending how you classify him, of erotic love. And then already, by the time she's writing this essay, actually, Sigmund Freud has proposed one of his various models of the psyche. the human psychic life according to which the fundamental drives which shape human consciousness and experience are on the one hand eros which is the drive partly towards sex but also just towards positive relationships with other people towards friendship towards reproduction all that stuff and thanatos the death drive which is this really is the is the tendency of the nervous system just to seek out the sort of the oblivion of inertia just to want to be done with it all And so this idea of eros as a sort of meaning generally sort of eroticism and love and affection and positive affect generally and connection with other people, it is around. I've never found any evidence that Kollontai read Freud or has any kind of relationship to Freud. And I think it's a more sort of generic use of the term. But when she talks about eros, it is in the context of this use of the term eros to mean eroticism, but it's eroticism understood as one very obvious manifestation of a more general tendency towards humans having affectionate relationships with each other.
The unadorned sexual drive is easily aroused but is soon spent, thus wingless Eros consumes less inner strength than winged Eros, whose love is woven of delicate strands of every kind of emotion. Wingless Eros does not make one suffer from sleepless nights, does not sap one's will, and does not entangle the rational workings of the mind. The fighting class could not have fallen under the power of winged Eros at a time when the clarion call of revolution was sounding. It would not have been expedient at such a time to waste the inner strength of the members of the collective on the experiences that did not directly serve the revolution. Individual sex love, which lies at the heart of a pair marriage, demands a great expenditure of inner energy.
The working class was interested not only in economizing in terms of material wealth, but also in preserving the intellectual and emotional energy of each person. For this reason, at a time of heightened revolutionary struggle, the undemanding instinct of reproduction spontaneously replaced the all-embracing winged Eros. I have so much to say about this paragraph, but maybe if any of you want to comment on the first bit, I've got a lot on the second bit. I think we've already said it, really. I think we've explained the first bit of that paragraph already. So, I mean, just to clarify again for anyone who's listening, that wingless eros, as Keir said, is basically casual sex. It's sex without romantic involvement, as we call it. And winged eros is being presented here as this obviously more intense and arguably...
preferable way of having sexual relationships, which are characterised by, you know, passion and love, etc. But without there being a kind of moral judgment, they are different. But she's also saying it's not that one is necessarily always better than the other. It's that in particular context, one might be preferable to the other. Just a little bit of context. So when Colin Tye's like critique, that she's also critiqued by Lenin as well, partly for this article.
she's sort of associated with the idea that she's promoting free love, basically, a sort of promoting wingless eros almost. And there's this idea that she's saying, you know, love is like having a cup of tea. We should treat it the same as having a cup of tea. Not love, sorry. Sex is like having a cup of tea. I thought that was a misquote. Yeah, it is. It is a misquote. Well, it's quite obvious she's not saying that, isn't it? She's not saying that we should just have love without, we should have sex without love, et cetera, or we should just have lots of casual sex. The line is like, under very specific circumstances, people might have to treat sex as just like having a drink of water, meeting a physical need. Yeah, the whole point of it, the essay is to say, is actually, we're no longer in that historical juncture when that's the way to treat it. And she got signed up.
millennium i think she got slagged off by clara zetkin for that it does seem to be a classic example of someone having skim read it and missed the point and just have this one line they remembered and that becoming a meme it's the twitter version it's a twitter twitter the twitter of the blog post I will press this point and I'm happy for us to disagree on this. I will still not define it as romantic versus non-romantic. I don't think romance for me is a helpful kind of addition on here because what I like about what she's doing and I guess what I was taking an alternative opinion to the use of the word fucking is that it's very clearly non-crude what she's doing. She's making strong arguments and allowing there to be like a variety, she's talking about a variety of different ways that people can relate. And obviously we're yet to come to like some of the really interesting conclusions she comes to this. But that's why I think using the term like casual sex.
is like what is most useful versus kind of more attached and involved. relationships but you're absolutely not right she's not putting a value judgment she's putting this in a social construct and uh and context which i think is important another thing that i find really interesting from as a 21st century reader of this text is what i found refreshing and this is almost relating to what i was just saying is it's refreshing that there's a lack of complex terminology put upon relationships so she's saying things like individual sex love and you know um and she used winged eros and wingless eros you know and between quotation marks as well whereas i think like these days you have so much like like liberal bollocks kind of terminology associated with every form of relationships as is perpetuated by the media. So there'd be like situationships and all of this sort of crap. So I think it's quite nice to be reading something that's quite descriptive, but in a kind of simple terms. And she keeps like her more complex terminology for like the politics around it. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, I think you're right. I think she's trying to find a language with which to talk about all these issues, which is not dependent upon the historically bourgeois language of romance, which is challenging, but it's also really important. And that doesn't constrain relationships because that's what she's saying.
She's not trying to constrain. When she goes on to critique marriage, which we'll get onto, she's saying, here is a little box. And she's saying part of the revolutionary project is it's not about that box. But at the same time, the complexity of human emotions and the way that humans relate in that complex ways has to be addressed now that we have more bandwidth effectively. Well, she sort of goes on and clarifies that. It's not just, oh, we've won the revolution, now we construct the new world. It says, only when the proletariat has appropriated the laws, not only of the creation of material wealth, but also of inner psychological life, is it able to advance fully armed to fight the decaying bourgeois world on the psychological and cultural.
front. So it's like, you know, this is also a moment of rearming so that we can then conduct the fight more effectively. I also asterisked that bit. I thought it was great because what's really central about that sentence is she's saying only when you look at the inner life, psychological life, are we even able to advance fully armed? So there's this kind of juxtaposition there, which I think she's basically saying is not a conflict between like the psychology and being able to like have the ability to do this, which I like the way that at least it's translated as like advance fully armed to fight the decaying bourgeois world.
It is decaying, unfortunately. There is no proletarian world emerging to replace it. In the next bit, she talks more specifically about the tender-winged Eros has emerged from the shadows and began to demand his rightful place. Wingless Eros has ceased to satisfy the psychological needs. And then further on in this paragraph, she introduces this phrase that I absolutely love, which is about for the inner life of the collective. So she's introducing this idea that there is such a concept that we need to be thinking about, a reality of the inner life of the collective. And I find that absolutely beautiful.
You know, that brings that effervescent energy to me because it then situates this text in this kind of project of how do we nourish and nurture this inner life of the collective? And that's how she situates discussions of kind of love and relationship and sex going on from there. So I love that. She basically then goes on to set up this next section where she's going to do a sort of like historical analysis of the changing functions of love, perhaps. I'm going to put it that way.
She says, it's time we separated ourselves from the hypocrisy of bourgeois thought. It's time to recognize that love is not only a powerful natural factor, a biological force, but also a social factor. Essentially, love is a profoundly social emotion. And of course, if it's more than just a natural force, then it can have history. And we can look back at history and realize, we can historicize the contemporary sort of dominant bourgeois mode of love, dominant in our world, deteriorating.
in Colin Tye's World of 1923. And then the bit after that, it seems like she's instrumentalising love for the collective in the next bit, where she says, the ideology of the working class must pay even greater attention to the significance of love as a factor, which can, like any other psychological or social phenomenon, be channelled to the advantage of the collective. So she basically sets in stone, following on from the bit that you read, Kia, that this is something that needs to be taken seriously. And I'm all for it, this project, and it makes me want to read on. And it's quite clear that she has a very complex understanding of the relationship between the individual and the collective, which is clear in a lot of this Soviet stuff from the 20s, that the historic, I mean, the historic of this late 20th century cliche about Marxism, especially the Marxism of this period, is that it's thoroughly deterministic, it has quite a simplistic model of historical change being determined by economic factors, etc. It's a ridiculously crude caricature that is quite clearly implicit in her approach.
She understands human subjectivity as trans individuals, I would want to call it, for example, as a very complex phenomenon which is characterised by all kinds of social forces acting on it, but also in which personal experience remains really important. Okay, so the next section is called Historical Notes. And Conanty offers this historical narrative, which really maps onto the classic Marxist, historical materialist narrative of history, according to which you have ancient tribal societies, then you have feudal societies, then you have bourgeois capitalist society, and you're hopefully moving towards socialist or communist society. And she talks about how within each of those different societies, there are very different attitudes to interpersonal relationships. And so the idea is basically in ancient societies, it's all about loyalty to your kin group, and basically friendship.
And fealty to your family and your immediate kin are both of much higher value than what we would think of today as romantic relationships. Can we just point out a couple of things that she says in the kind of ancient world, which is interesting because she uses a very, in a very little space, she makes quite strong feminist statements, which I think are important, especially because it's International Women's Month as we're recording. And I think one of the things she points out is that when she's talking about friendship in the ancient world, she's talking about friendship between men, because friendship between women is not even considered. And it's still a hugely under theorised topic. There's very little that's written about.
about women's friendships. And Elena Ferrente changed this a little bit, but it's still not something that people talk about. And then she gives this example, which I think is really useful, is that friendship was so important between men that you might offer your wife to a guest. Yeah, yeah. And that's where women as property. And that's quite important to highlight because it gives you an idea of what she's talking about in terms of kinship. That's also this line that says, the person who accomplished great deeds and risked his life for his friend was considered a hero and his action most virtuous. While a man risking himself for the sake of a woman he loved would have been reproached and even despised.
She started drawing on Greek myth to make these sorts of arguments. She's got its drawbacks, of course. Insofar as I know the sources she's drawing on, it's pretty accurate. I mean, she talks about women insofar as they appear in the sources, which isn't much. She talks about Antigone. Antigone's like a heroic figure in the story of the Trojan Wars because she risks her life to give the funeral rights to her brother. She has to go out onto the battlefield and risk being killed to get his body in Vering. I mean, it all seems pretty accurate as a sort of description. Obviously, if you're an ancient historian, you can have all sorts of queries. But then she goes on to the description.
Goes on to the description of the feudal world. She talks about the way in which, I mean, again, really what she's talking about is what you see in the chivalrous epics of the Middle Ages and this idea that, well, really, there's this complete split between the marriage relationship and the romantic relationship. The idealised romantic relationship in courtly love is this idea that the knight has this infatuation with a woman and that's a different relationship to the person he just happens to be married to and have children with. And then she offers a really, really interesting analysis of sort of, well, why is that useful to feudalism? Because she sort of argues that...
Well, the idea is that really the system overall can use this romantic attachment that men have to these women that they're almost in a parasocial relationship with a lot of the time in order to motivate them to really engage into a military action without there being any sort of other social costs and without them actually disrupting the kinship relationships which are being cemented on the basis of marriage ties. I mean, of course, if you want to rip this apart, you can, because apart from anything else, it sort of assumes that what you see in... the romantic chivalric writing of the Middle Ages bears any relation to the actual lived social reality of members of the European warrior aristocracy, which it probably doesn't really. There's a discourse that she's bringing forth and saying like, these were some of like, this is some of the imagery and this is some of the, you know, what's appearing in text, which I think is totally legit. This idea of like love as quest and the challenge. And I think what she's bringing forth here is saying like, actually, that's very male.
As she's making this argument, she's also uncovering the patriarchy within that because she qualifies that in no case any of these women have any choice. And this is not about a man actually having a relationship with a woman. It's about an unattainable woman. The two main points she's setting up, though, is one that she's already established is that we need to think about love. So she says feudal ideology saw love as a stimulus, as a quality assisting in social cohesion. Spiritual love and the knight's adoration of his lady served the interest of the noble class. And you're sort of setting that up because you also want to then think about...
you know, how winged Eros, in fact, wingless Eros fits into, you know, the building of a new society in Russia. You know, you're saying that love is always a social as well as a natural force, if you want. Later on in that same paragraph, actually, she says, love and marriage were kept separate by feudal ideology. They were only united by the bourgeois class that emerged in the 14th and 15th century. And that's the real ideology critique moment to point to courtly love to say, look, you know, not so long ago, the idea of love and marriage were completely separate. In fact, you know, marriages, perhaps they were arranged, particularly in this sort of arranged, you know, particularly in the sort of like nightly levels of society.
around building and maintaining estates and these sorts of things. And it's only in bourgeois society that these two aspects, love and marriage, are brought together and seen as natural. So it's that denaturalisation moment. Yeah, I think that's completely right. I think it's a really clever analysis. It's probably worth saying, what she's talking about here is elite ideology. So the question of how people who were not members of social elites in any of these historical periods lived and thought about their interpersonal relationships, we don't know that much about. She's not making any claims about that anyway.
either in fact i would say i would say based on what i know about the historiography on that subject subject you probably assume that amongst the poorer classes something a bit more a bit more like a kind of egalitarian attitude to interpersonal relationships and a bit more like a a bit more instrumental in a sort of positive sense in terms of people understanding that they had to sort of get through life as best they could and marriage was often understood in terms of a sort of um a relatively egalitarian relationship between partners who were just having to keep themselves and the kids alive. That's probably what you would expect to be the case. As far as we know, that sort of was the case. But she's not making any claims about what life was like for poor people. She's making claims about what is going on within the ideology of the ruling class at these different periods. And I think those claims are pretty robust, really. I think it's a really good analysis. I mean, honestly, in some ways, this is better than Foucault. I'm an enemy of Marxist anti-Foucaultism. There's a lot to learn from Foucault. Foucault's really useful. Foucault's really good. On the other hand, look...
you know, the massive claim in the history of sexuality, which is supposed to be this massive provocation, particularly to the Freudian establishment in France at the time when Foucault publishes it is, well, sexuality has a history. That itself is supposed to be like a massively shocking thing to say at the time when Foucault writes it. Well, that's what she's saying here. She's saying that, and she's saying it from a feminist point of view, and she's saying it from a point of view which has a more robust sense of historical causality than Foucault has. So, well done, Alexandra Collentine.
In the next paragraph, she introduces kind of this idea that there are institutions that pretend to wage war on one thing or another. And she really unpacks this in the next bourgeois section. But staying with the feudal for a minute, I mean, again, this is where she says, OK, the church pretended to wage war on depravity, but by encouraging, quote unquote, spiritual love, it encouraged crude animal relations between the sexes. The knight who would not be parted from the emblem of the lady of his heart, who composed poetry in her honour and risked his life to win her smile, would rape a girl of the urban classes without second thought or order. Yeah, good point. So she is making some claims about lived reality, and they're not wrong claims.
So there you go. And that same principle exists today under patriarchy. Yeah. So then the analysis of the bourgeois family, well, I think you've already said, Keir, a key point is that the bourgeois ideal of marriage, it does, it brings together the romantic relationship, the interpersonal relationship, the sexual relationship, the property relationship. It brings all these things together, doesn't it, into one relationship.
She specifically links this to the idea of the family union as being the little engine for the accumulation of capital. But again, the reason why I think it's important that it's not just romantic love when she comes to love of comrades later is that she's basically saying all kinds of love are piled into the one person which she will have this property relationship with in the household. So it's all love becomes piled into this relationship that benefits capital. And that's really important because she comes and unpacks that later, right? And then she also says that women become like not just a good housewife, but she says here as the helper and the friend of a husband. So I read that as she's also saying there's the emotional labor that's put onto women there. It's like all kinds of love.
and comradeship and everything gets piled into this one relationship. And that puts a lot of pressure on that one relationship and that one institution as well. This is really important, isn't it? Because her whole frame of analysis is to say that there are all kinds of different relationships people can have with each other. And different kinds of love. And different kinds of love. Different kinds of love. And she's using love in a very expansive sense. So I would say she's really talking about all kinds of affectionate relationship, including friendships, including family relationships, sibling relationships, sexual relationships of all different kinds.
Political relationships. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And she's presenting this picture of the ideal bourgeois family as one in which, in a certain sense, the only relationship is the relationship between the spouses. Every other relationship outside of that one is entirely kind of instrumentalised by commercial relations and by capitalism. And to some extent, almost all of the emotional needs of both partners are supposed to be met by this one relationship. And I think that is, you know, I think that's very powerful.
consistent on the one hand with Marx and Engels, these comments about the family and the reduction of all relationships and capitalism to the cash and excess. But again, it's also consistent with research into family life by radical sociologists in the 60s, 70s, 80s. It was a really important feature of radical critiques of the nuclear family from socialist and feminist and socialist feminist perspectives by sociologists who were actually studying family relationships from the 60s onwards. Really important critique was, well, the nuclear family just tends to force a couple to try to meet all of each other's emotional needs under almost impossible circumstances.
what I personally find really, really odd. I don't know how anybody could live like that, but a lot of people do till today in the 21st century. That's an ideal that's upheld, right? And she gives us a really interesting analysis around that. And then she's also saying later, and she's talking about when she talks about this bit of the bourgeoisie made love and marriage inseparable, which is what we've just been talking about, is that where deception sits within that. So this has become the model that's acceptable. So even when a marriage is made for convenience, the partners, as you say, should practice hypocrisy and pretend affection. I suppose she does go on to make some comments about what life was like in...
in feudal culture for peasants and for artisans in the towns and cities. She's largely dismissive of any idea that they had, that love relationships really played any part in marriage relationships. I'm not sure that's true. I haven't read up on this subject for years and years and years. But years ago, when I was looking into, I was reading social history, specifically of sex and romance and relationships, going back to the Middle Ages, it seemed to be that the emerging picture from the latest historiography then was that...
as far as we could tell i mean something quite like kind of modern attitude to relationships was actually was fairly typical amongst amongst peasants and the urban poor in other words marriage was considered a bit more casual less totally insoluble than it was amongst the bourgeoisie or the aristocracy but it was generally understood the person you were married to was going to be your primary sort of emotional partner and sexual partner and this was a fairly but this was this wasn't because there was some sort of advanced ideology necessarily it was it's that's a fairly rational response to you know making relationships under conditions of relative scarcity basically But none of this really undermines the broader thrust of her analysis. Yeah, I mean, towards the end of this section, she talks about the narrowness of bourgeois love. Love is permissible only when it's within marriage. Love outside legal marriage is considered immoral. The entire morality of the bourgeoisie is directed towards the concentration of capital.
And he says, love, of course, could not be contained within a limit set down by bourgeois ideology. Emotional conflict grew and multiplied and found expression in the new forms of literature, the novel which the bourgeois class develops. Love constantly escaped from the narrow framework of legal marriage relations set for it into free relationships and adultery, which were condemned, but which were practiced. Yeah, it seems pretty accurate to me. Yeah, it's really good. It's really good. And I think that whole little section on historical forms of love, I mean, it's a brilliant, brilliant example of historical materialist cultural history in a really condensed way.
to great potential teaching aid, actually. I mean, it really is, you know, it's often said he's an overly neglected figure, Colin Tye, and I think, yeah, I mean, that passage should be in sort of undergraduate readers of, on like cultural theory and cultural history. All right, so are we on to love comradeship? Well, let's just set the scene with the last little bit of the last couple of sentences, because, you know, she's going through this historical analysis of different ways that love has been employed for particular social purposes and the different way people have thought about love. The working youth of Soviet Russia is confronting this question at this very moment. This brief survey of the evolution of the ideal of love marriage relationships will help you. My young friend, to realize and understand that love is not the private matter it might seem to be at first glance. Love is an important psychological and social factor which society has always instinctively organized in its interests. Working men and women armed with the science of Marxism and using the experience of the past must seek to discover the place love ought to occupy in the new social order and determine the ideal of love.
that corresponds to their class interests. Yes. I mean, let's be real. If somebody said this from a podium because this was their speech at the end of a demo, I'd be going fucking nuts. It's so good. You know what there is? On marxist.org, on the page that introduces all the Colin Tai material, there's a clip, there's an MP3 clip of her speaking in Russian, of her giving a speech, which we should edit in, I think.
All right, so we're getting on to love comradeship. The new communist society is being built on the principle of comradeship and solidarity. Solidarity is not only an awareness of common interests. It depends also on the intellectual and emotional ties linking the members of the collective. For a social system to be built on solidarity and cooperation, it is essential that people should be capable of love and warm emotions. The proletarian ideology, therefore, attempts to educate and encourage every member of the working class to be capable of responding to the distress and needs of other members of the class, of a sensitive and understanding of others, and a penetrating consciousness of the individual's relationship to the collective.
All these warm emotions, sensitivity, compassion, sympathy and responsiveness, derive from one source. They are aspects of love, not in the narrow sexual sense, but in the broad meaning of the word. Love is an emotion that unites and is consequently of an organising character. The bourgeoisie was well aware of this, and in the attempt to create a stable family, bourgeois ideology erected married love as a moral virtue. To be a good family man was in the eyes of the bourgeoisie an important and valuable quality. The proletariat should also take into account the psychological and social role that love, both in the broad sense and in the sense of relationships between the sexes, can and must play.
not in strengthening family marriage ties, but in the development of collective solidarity. Absolutely amazing, isn't it? The concept that love has an organising character, it's like, wow. It's obviously true, but to put it as bluntly as that is absolutely amazing. Yeah, it is amazing. Yeah, it's really, it's so advanced. Like this line, solidarity is not only an awareness of common interests, it also depends on the intellectual and emotional side of the members of the collective. Well, that's fantastic. Of course, I'm starting to work on a book on solidarity at the moment, no contents of which will come as any surprise to listeners of this show. But this quote is like my starting point for the entire project.
Because on the one hand, of course, I'm totally preoccupied with the idea that solidarity is primarily an awareness of common interests. That's what it is. And that's important to say because there is some actual literature and there's a vast casual usage of the term solidarity in liberal and even in sort of left discourse, which completely ignores the idea of awareness of common interests, which instead thinks that solidarity is an ethical disposition based on self-sacrifice of some kind. And there are literal professors of political philosophy and political theory at Oxbridge going around giving public lectures saying what solidarity means is altruism. And as we discussed in our episode on solidarity, no, solidarity doesn't.
not mean altruism it means an awareness of common interests and so that is the first thing you have to deal with you have to get over this liberal assumption that solidarity is an ethical or purely psychological disposition but of course conantai is addressing a far more advanced readership than those people so she's saying of course it is an awareness but it's not only an awareness of common interests it also does depend on these emotional these affective ties as we would say today and that is in some sense that captures the whole complex problem of how we think about solidarity and what it is and then she goes on as you say to to talk about love to talk about positive affect as we might say as an organising force in this way, which is really just brilliant. It does make me think, actually, about that. There's that Che Guevara quote about... A revolution is moved by feelings of great love. Yeah, exactly, yeah. And just to come back to that warm and cold idea, like, you know, all these warm emotions that we need to nurture, basically, you can't have solidarity without them. Because, obviously, you know, Che is writing from a context in which they've just been conducting a guerrilla war, of course, and, you know, you need feelings of hardness and coldness in order to conduct those sorts of things. And, of course, the threat is always that those cold or hard emotions take over, and you find it impossible to find the warm emotions. Do you know what I mean?
Anyway, just an idle thought. But love is not as though that is not a concept which has come up again and again across socialist history. Don't use my surname in vain. We have to read the live in the second paragraph. It's just absolutely amazing. Okay. We've already seen that each epoch has its ideal. Each class strives to fill the conception of love with a moral content that suits its interest. Each stage of cultural development with its richer intellectual and emotional experience redefines the image of Eros. With the successive stages in the development of the economy and social love, ideas of love have changed. Shades of emotions have assumed greater significance or, on the other hand, have ceased to exist.
It's just an incredible critique of like a fantastic historical materialist critique of natural conceptions of morality, basically. I mean, it's a properly anti-essentialist perspective. It's an anti-essentialist perspective, which isn't allied to a mere individualistic kind of libertarianism. so yeah it's really it's really fantastic was it the next paragraph you wanted to talk about no idea was the one after that yeah so i'm i'm interested in how she's kind of like she she tries here i i read this as her trying to like be more specific about what she's talking about when she talks about casual sex and what she's also against which i which i really like because she has this concept of unhealthy cardinality so towards the end of that paragraph she says she says the sexual act has become an aim in itself just another way of obtaining pleasure through lust sharpened with excesses and through distorted harmful titillations of the flesh A man does not have sex in response to healthy instincts, which have drawn him to a particular woman. A man approaches a woman, though he feels no sexual need for her in particular, with the aim of gaining his sexual satisfaction and pleasure through her. Prostitution is the organized expression of this distortion of the sex drive. I mean, I think I agree. This is not a fashionable opinion on the libertarian left at the moment, but I'm interested in the way that she defines prostitution there. But she does this thing where she's juxtaposing the difference between like, it's okay to have healthy instincts and you're drawn to like a particular woman, you know, as a man. But she's writing this from a woman's perspective and she's saying,
that kind of, I think, sex, what I read into it is like sex as power or sex as domination or sex as, you know, just expending energy on another person as a object is what she has a problem with. Reading this, it really reminds me of reading people like Ellen Willis from the early 70s. She's an American journalist and critic who wrote very interesting essays about, really about the experience of being a straight woman who was kind of, who was a music journalist, who was active in the rock and roll scene, but she was also part of women's liberation. She was a leftist. She ended up being married to Stanley Aranowitz. She's a great American radical intellectual.
She writes very interesting little essays about all these experiences and about the problem that as a straight woman who doesn't want to conform to bourgeois norms, you want a certain kind of freedom, but you also don't want to just be objectified and you don't want to be experiencing new forms of subjugation. And Conantide does seem to have a really, really developed perspective on what that means. She has a really developed perspective on what that means. And she's trying to produce a vocabulary, actually, which is really, really, potentially really useful for answering what I think has been one of the perennial problems of... late 20th, early 20th century feminism and sexual politics, which is the problem, okay, what do we want from heterosexual men? What do we actually want from them? If we don't want them to be patriarchs and we don't want them to just stop existing, then what do we want from them? And I'm not saying she is giving the answer to this question, but she's giving a language within which that question can be thought about in ways which is quite sophisticated and quite useful. So I think it's really valuable in that. Yeah, I would agree. I think this text forms a kind of preface almost to some of those debates or some of those arguments or some of those...
that area of thinking. I would go one further and actually say that, you know, she doesn't make a comment here about homosexuality or like gay or lesbian relationships, but I would say what she's interested in here is like women having sex with men, not even the definition of like straight or gay, which I think is interesting in relation to like essentialism previously, because this is about women who have sex with men and men who have sex with women, regardless of what else they're doing. And I think that's important, actually quite liberatory in itself. She's not trying to define those relationships within certain borders because she is... she's uh she's critiquing that kind of definitional box in her when she discusses uh the bourgeois marriage and that's where she's saying the constraints are and she's saying i'm reading as her saying this is not about constraints it's about like the kind of relationships we want to have and how we act those out and the importance like you said earlier of including the warm relationships the ability to have those sorry sorry warm emotions the ability to be able to act out and live warm emotions is kind of like central to what we think is kind of revolutionary relationships in the next paragraph she goes on to sort of build on that i think
She says love is intricately woven from friendship, passion, maternal tenderness, infatuation, mutual compatibility, sympathy, admiration, familiarity, and many other shades of emotion. With such a range of emotions involved, it becomes increasingly difficult to distinguish direct connection between the natural drives of wingless eros and winged eros where physical attraction and emotional warmth are fused. The existence of love friendships where the element of physical attraction is absent of love for one's work or for a cause or of love for the collective testify to the extent to which lovers become spiritualized and separated from its biological base. She's complexifying her own argument here. So I like this bit. I mean, I think it's pointing out just before that she gets into this differentiation between different types of attraction and different types of relationship.
So for example, she says, a woman feels close to a man whose ideas, hopes and aspirations match her own. She's attracted physically to another. For one woman, a man might feel sympathy and a protective tenderness. And in another, he might find support and understanding for the strivings of his intellect. To which of the two must he give his love? And why must he tear himself apart and cripple his inner self? If only the possession of both types of inner bonds afford the fullness of living. So this is generally read as advocating, at least speculatively, for some kind of polyamory.
which I think is a fair reading. I think she sort of is. She's at least questioning whether that wouldn't be one of the implications of thinking about these things radically. Again, I'm seeing this through a woman's prism. And, you know, perhaps she's saying there is a possibility for men to love women and that not necessarily be a sexual relationship. I think she's saying there's various different ways that you can love another person. Yes, she is saying that. And that's also, I mean, that's usually, you know, that's one of the arguments that gets made for ethical polyamory, is the idea that there is these different kinds of love you have with different kinds of people. And it's better to kind of maximise the possibility of all of them being expressed.
You know, my relationship to those ideas is always, I think I do agree in theory. I'm not sure it's livable under contemporary historical circumstances for most people. Well, all the evidence is that it isn't really. But I think at least theoretically and as a sort of ideal of how people ought to be able to conduct their intimate relationships, I think it's very profound. So one of the next bits that I really love is this paragraph where she says, under the bourgeois system such a division of the inner emotional world involves inevitable suffering for thousands of years human culture which is based on the institution of property has been teaching people that love is linked with the principles of property bourgeois ideology has insisted that love mutual love gives the right to absolute and indivisible possession of the beloved person such exclusiveness was the natural consequence of the established form of pair marriage and of the ideal of quote-unquote all-embracing love between husband and wife. But can such an ideal correspond to the interest of the working class? Surely it is important and desirable from the proletariat's point of view that people's emotions should develop a wider and richer range.
I've written it next to this. Yes, yes, yes. So I absolutely love this bit because she's basically saying, like, come on, like, we can be more expansive in our thinking and our application of our emotions than this very constraining conception of what we discussed earlier, like piling all of your needs onto one person in a household and it being linked to the principles of property. Like, it's fucked. I don't like it. I don't do it. Also, I'd say this is entirely consistent with a certain kind of Spinozism, a sort of radical Spinozist idea that, you know, the point of almost everything is to cultivate joyous affect and cultivating joyous affect means cultivating the...
productive relationships that you have with others. And so I think that is, I think it is very profound. One of the other things to keep in mind when we're discussing this and then trying to relate it back to 21st century life is that she is talking in a post-revolutionary situation where she's anticipating that material relations are going to change quite fundamentally. And so, you know, one of the ways in which you might think that people are protective of the bourgeois family or, you know, the nuclear family is that like, you know, the way the nuclear family functions for some. in contemporary society as like you know it functions as like a haven from like the harsh harsh market relations that go on outside you know it may be gathered for other people it can also be a prison because you know you're trapped in these property relationships perhaps via a mortgage or something like that and so you know which structure and constrain your possibilities but you know it's a little bit like when when uh marx talks about religion as the opium of the masses you know he then he then talks about it in the next sentence as the side of the oppressed it actually you know it's a function it's a mode of protecting yourself against
the harshness of capitalist society. I mean, actually, when I still had the privilege of teaching an undergraduate degree in cultural studies as the main part of my job, I introduced quite early on in that story a lecture I would do every year just about romance, about romantic love in contemporary culture. And the reason I did it wasn't because it was a big research interest of mine, and there wasn't a big literature on it, actually. And most of the literature that there was, was fairly simplistic, like denunciations of heteronormative patriarchy from the 70s or 80s. And the whole substance of this lecture was the point that...
if you actually examined contemporary culture from an outsider's perspective, if you were an alien or anthropologist from some different culture, and you looked at what was the major preoccupation of the culture, especially for young people, especially people of the age of my students, you would immediately conclude that basically interpersonal relationships, sex, love, intimacy, romance was like the overriding preoccupation. It is the thing that people are most interested in. It's what pop music is about. It's about what soap opera is about. It's what the most popular fictions are about. And it was quite clear that in a certain sense, what was going on in the culture was we were being offered a certain kind of ideal.
of entirely self-directed intimate romantic relationships, which are quite different from what even our grandparents would really have expected, as being the major compensation for the loss of loads of other things in society, the loss of extended family, the loss of community, the loss of stable job prospects in the transition from forwardism to post-forwardism, etc. So, I mean, I would still stand by that. That's definitely what happened in the transition from forwardism to post-forwardism. I was first talking about this in the late 90s, and it was definitely true then. I think where we are now is probably kind of different, where we are now.
It's not even clear that that is available to younger people, even as an ideal, because the material conditions which made it possible are disappearing so fast. And the kind of the gamification of relationships through dating apps and things has produced really a different kind of situation. But I think that is totally consistent with what she's saying. It's totally consistent with what you're saying, Keir. And I think it was, I think, you know, whether it worked out for you or not, I think really, it really was part of the, I think it was very much the experience of sort of Gen X, actually.
I think it was a really central experience of Gen X that we were given. That was the thing we were offered, really. That was the thing we were offered as the thing which would make your life have some kind of meaning at the moment when post-modernity, the end of history, was stripping away the possibility of meaning from almost any other aspect of social existence. And I think Colin Tai is offering a really powerful set of analytical tools to think about that. So then she gets onto this whole idea of introducing joy and the relationship between joy and sex, which I think is really great. She's just got this one sentence where she says, outside marriage, there was room only for the wingless eros of momentary and joyless sexual relations. And basically what I take from that whole...
section is she's basically saying, you know, joyless sexual relations are a bad thing. This is not something we want. And then further down in this section, I'll just read this bit because I find it really beautiful. She goes on to say, in this sense, the proletarian ideology will persecute wingless eros in a much more strict and severe way than bourgeois morality. Wingless eros contradicts the interests of the working class. In the first place, it inevitably involves excesses and therefore physical exhaustion, which lower the resources of labor energy available to society. In the second place, it impoverishes the soul, hindering the development and strengthening of inner bodies.
positive emotions and in the third place it usually rests on an inequality of rights in relationships between the sexes on the dependence of women on the man and the male complacency and insensitivity which undoubtedly hinder the development of comradely feelings winged eros is quite different so this is her bit where she goes one two three these are the things that we need to um have in like why winged eros is is different which i think is great the way she lays it out if we're going to critique the bourgeois tendency to pile everything including sensitivity responsiveness and desire onto one person or to just to channel those inequalities on one person he says Bourgeois ideology demands that a person should only display sensitivity, responsiveness, and desire in the relationship with one partner. The aim of proletarian ideology is that men and women should develop these qualities not only in relation to the chosen one, but in relation to all members of the collective.
The stipulation is that these emotions facilitate the development and strengthening of comradeship. So this is this idea of love comradeship she's trying to introduce. No, you can have, obviously you'll have relationships with individual people, but hey, perhaps you might have a monogamous one and perhaps it might last all your life. Do you know what I mean? But you've got to be aware that those feelings that are being developed, they need to be applied to other people outside of that. It's also permission that she's giving. She's like, it's okay to have these strong, warm feelings to other people and to other things.
It's not a failure. It's a positive thing. We just need to navigate it within the ideology that we're trying to build together. And so then she starts to introduce this various different concepts and terminology again around this ideal of love comradeship. There's this brilliant sentence, which I think is so ACFM and gives that effervescent spirit, which you're talking about here, where she says, collectivism of spirit can then defeat individualist self-sufficiency and the cold of inner loneliness from which people in bourgeois culture have attempted to escape through love and marriage will disappear. Fantastic. That is great.
And then she goes on from that to, I think, stipulate the vision. So she's basically saying, right, in the new and collective society where interpersonal relations develop against the background of joyful unity and comradeship, Eros will occupy an honourable place as an emotional experience multiplying human happiness. And we come to the kind of area of abundance. I mean, these are my words, not hers, but I kind of, I thought that was really beautiful as well. In the paragraph after that, she sets out these three basic principles that must be conformed to. One, equality in relationships and intermasculine egoism and the slavish suppression of the female personality. Two, mutual recognition of the rights of the other, of the fact that one does not own the heart and soul of the other, the sense of property encouraged by bourgeois culture. Three, comradely sensitivity, the ability to listen and understand the inner workings of the loved person. Bourgeois culture demands this only from the woman.
But in Proclaim the Rights of Winged Eros, the ideal of the working class at the same time subordinates this love to the more powerful emotion of love duty to the collective. So beautiful. And also, such a good programme. So I take from that, going on from the vision which I read, I'm hearing this bit which you just read, Kia, as the programme. Here are very specific pieces of work which need to be done, which I think are a challenge to all of us. These things about needing to understand that other people have an inner working and not to be stuck in the machine of capitalist understanding of marriage or the family is really important. He's talking about a level of...
consciousness and awareness, which, you know, is like, it's just really great stuff. I have nothing to say except it's really great. Yeah, I agree. We should absolutely say if you're interested in learning more about Conanty or just hearing a reading of the entire text we've read today and loads of other readings from Conanty, then Kristen Godsey, who is an American historian, has an entire podcast, which is called AK47. because AK are the initials of Alexandra Kollontai, and supposedly she reads from a total of 47 texts from Kollontai, although she'll often spend several episodes on a text. So it's into like 100 plus episodes now, but the episodes are very short. They're usually 15 to 20 minutes. So that is a great project. So do check that out if you want lots more audio Kollontai content. I mean, it's worth thinking, I think, about the ways in which this kind of rhetoric is really, really terrifying.
to people to the liberals the thought that you might have the private sanctity of your personal intimate relationships might be intruded upon by the collective in any way at all it is that it's the nightmare that haunts the liberal imagination the nightmare of totalitarianism i think it's really important to understand that she is advocating for an attitude to love and relationships which would it would be experienced by some people as a reduction in their precious personal freedom because it's it's because it's asking that you do think at least have a think about how your treatment of people and how your even most intimate relationships fit into a wider pattern of collective behaviour. But she's saying that because ultimately, ultimately through doing that, everybody would achieve more freedom than they can have when they're ultimately constrained by a very narrow set of individualistic relations and a very narrow set of...
patriarchal roles. So I think it really is important to stress that. I think it is important to understand that partly for reasons I was going on about a few minutes ago, because bourgeois culture, and I think this is actually, this is a consistent feature of bourgeois culture that takes different forms under different historic conditions. It's a consistent feature of bourgeois culture that right up until the present, it presents the relationship, the relationship with your partner to whom you will get married, with whom you will have children as the compensation for all of the kind of degradation and alienation of the wider culture. So when you say to people, oh, well, this thing, this thing is the only thing you've got left to give your life a feeling of human dignity.
we're going to mess around with that as well we're going to politicize it we're going to say you've got to think about it in terms of the needs of the collective it seems like terrifying and awful to people in ways which are completely symptomatic of the functioning of bourgeois ideology, which I think are bad. But also based on, you know, building on what you just said, Jeremy, I think what she's also alluding to, she does not say this, what she's alluding to, is that, you know, men over history get away with all sorts of fucking shit in the domestic realm as well. And so she's saying that's why she's pointing out like things like, you know, the importance of taking into consideration, you know, she says at the bottom of that part, you know, respect for the right of the other's personality. This woman in your relationship is a person with their own aspirations and like feelings and issues. And so, yeah, I think that's what she's kind of pointing at. And in a way, she's like pointing like 50 years into the future.
with some of those. Shall we round this off with another great quote? The new class is capable of developing new facets of emotion which possess unprecedented beauty, strength and radiance. As the cultural and economic base of humanity changes, so will love be transformed. The blind, all-embracing, demanding passions will weaken. The sense of property, the egotistical desire to bind the partner to one forever. The complacency of the man and the self-renunciation of the woman will disappear. At the same time, the valuable aspects and elements of love will develop. Respect for the rights of the other's personality will increase and a mutual sensitivity will be learned.
men and women will strive to express their love not only in kisses and embraces, but in joint creativity and activity. the task of proletarian ideology is not to drive eros from social life but to rearm him according to the new social formation and to educate social relationship in relationships in the spirit of the great new psychological force of comradely solidarity stick that in your pipe jordan peterson yeah very good point yeah i think before we go we should just think a bit more about like content issues around the contemporary relevance of it we've talked a lot about the analytical use of the approach he's given and we've talked about kind of debates around polyamory and stuff because i think for me i mean for me i think on the one hand Yeah, I think it is really useful. As Nadi was saying much earlier, it is a really useful framework for thinking about things that are going on right now. And I think there is a sense in which her kind of energetics, you know, it does point to an analysis of what's happening to a lot of people today, which is, I mean, a lot of people are just too sort of exhausted even to really have relationships. And they're exhausted by the fact that the whole function of the regime of capitalist hegemony now works through the process of absorbing people's attention, demanding people's attention, demanding people's sort of emotional investment in these tiny little bursts that never really reaches a level of excitement or fulfillment, but is also just sort of exhausting and innovating.
And it's also connected with the ubiquity of anxiety. This is the process of what Mark calls consciousness deflation. It's the process by which people are kept in a state where they just don't really feel calm enough or relaxed enough or hopeful enough about the future or even just not tired enough for enough of a week to even really have relationships a lot of the time. And I think that is what's happening to a lot of people. And I think she does give us a useful framework through which we can understand that. And it's also just the incredible isolation of young people in particular, the level of people who are isolated for most of their...
most of their day or even week has just massively increased. And that's, you know, over the last couple of years, you know, the last four or five years or since COVID anyway, that seems to be the conditions in which you get some sort of like parasociality through relationships to influencers, et cetera. You just physically don't get the chance to... develop warm relations with people. Yeah, because that associational space has diminished. I mean, it's recent on the one hand. It's also very clearly a long-term trend of capitalism. And I've said this before on the show. This is something John Dunn is talking about in the 17th century when he's saying no man is an island. It's observable and has been observed by artists and cultural commentators and philosophers. It's absolutely observable as a persistent trend of capitalism. And it's only ever counteracted at historical moments when there's been significant pushback against the power of capitalism initially by reactionary forces which express themselves culturally.
through early forms of romanticism, sometimes forms of nationalism, forms of nostalgia for feudalism. But later, by the late 19th century, that kind of resistance to capitalist individualisation, the privatisation of all experience, the universal alienation, it can only be offered by various forms of working class organisation on various scales. And in this sense, she's absolutely right. And as we're often saying on the show, we'll probably never stop saying it. We're living through the consequences of...
both waves and cycles of collective resistance, which we've all been involved in, which everybody listening to this has been involved in to some extent at certain times, and also the consequences of their relative defeat at different times. And it's that complex set of waves of resistance and waves of repression that produces the outcomes at any given moment. It produces the ways in which people would experience love and relationships. She's absolutely right, really, that it is fundamentally... The question of to what extent you can even have meaningful and satisfactory relationships with people is partly dependent upon the level of the class struggle, frankly. I know that sounds really reductive. I'm saying that as somebody who was professionally trained to a world-class standard in all of the critiques of Marxist determinism which have ever been generated by anybody since the 19th century, frankly. All I can say is all those critiques of Marxist determinism you might want to make will serve as useful correctives.
to a simplistic understanding of what she's saying, but they do not in any way successfully refute the basic underlying hypothesis that the extent to which you are going to be able to have good relationships with people is at least partially dependent upon the sheer state of the class struggle at the moment in history you are happening to live. I mean, the last thing I'd want to say on this is, is, you know, we started off by saying, well, this is sort of like, you know, the blog post from a hundred years ago idea, but it's something else as well. You could sort of read it as like, you know, the self-help book of a hundred years ago, the self-help book, which is basically collective. So it wants to destroy the self. So perhaps, you know, you know, just after the Donald Trump's reelection, Trump 2.0, there was all of this. We need a Joe Rogan of the left says, no, we just need an Alexander, Alexandra Kollontai of the 21st century and the project she was involved in.
Well, then the question is, well, what would she be telling us to do right now? Because even me saying, well, it all depends on the state of the class struggle. What if right now you are someone who's struggling to make sense of their life and have a good life under these circumstances? I mean, one answer is just it's really valuable and useful to get involved in things, to join things, to engage in some sort of collective struggle on any scale that you can't substitute for that to some extent, whether it's joining a union or getting involved in community activism or joining a renter's union. Yeah, I have a simpler answer to that. And I would say, which also speaks to what you guys were saying, which is prioritise relationships.
Yeah. That's the project. Prioritize relationships. Yeah, you want to also try to develop in yourself the aspects that Colin Tai lays out in a more programmatic bit, you know, about comrade sensitivity, the ability to listen and these sorts of things. Of course. But I think there's a question there about, just to finish on that, there's a question about how that's done. And if you, you know, believe that people exist mostly in discourse, then that is through relationships, that you learn those things through practice with other people rather than like reading about this online. You know what I mean? It's in the practice of your relationships with people that your healing will occur.
I'd also say that consistent with her approach here would be the qualification. That doesn't mean you should join your revolutionary organisation and expect that to fulfil all of your emotional needs. Because I also think historically, and even in recent years, quite a lot of bad politics and a lot of bad comradeship comes from people over-investing in an organisation or a movement as being the thing now which is going to meet all their needs. And I think understanding the complexity and the necessary, the inevitable complexity and unevenness and the changeability of our emotional lives, I think is also really important to avoiding that. and being able to cultivate comradeship in a really substantial way I think is important. I also feel like, you know, I always feel conflicted when I'm reading about these issues and thinking about it and thinking about the fact that in my own life, you know, Keira and I are not totally different in this regard. I've been in a heterosexual monogamous relationship for decades. We've got two children. We've got a mortgage. We've got a house. And it's been really good. It still is really good. But I also feel like...
we were always really conscious that, I mean, not so much on an intimate level, but certainly at the level of organisation of the household, for example, that wasn't our first choice. We would have rather lived in a commune or in some kind of a co-op, some kind of a shared housing situation, because the problems which he raises with the nuclear family, I think, are real. And I think there's lots of good studies of child-wearing practices in different cultures, for example, to show that the nuclear family, which is the nuclear household, which is one of the things he's critiquing, isn't very functional. But one has to accept a lot of the time that... you don't get to choose the historical circumstances under which you're operating that under the historical circumstances we're operating given the material constraints on us in the end we pursue the best the best course available to us but i think even if that's what you're doing even if you are having a mortgage having a monogamous relationship raising kids that way i think i think if you understand that as a historically contingent response to historically contingent circumstances i think it can be really helpful it can be really helpful to kind of making that making that a fulfilling experience to understand that to some extent, it's not that you're just fulfilling the platonic ideal of what it means to be a human being, it's that you're making the best you can out of a historically circumscribed set of circumstances. And I think Kolintai, again, she gives a really useful set of intellectual tools for thinking about that. Yeah. I mean, perhaps like the other clue, the other part of the programme that Kolintai lays out is that bit which I read out at the end there, which is strive to express love, not only in kisses and embraces, but in joint creativity and activity. That's another way of saying you need to get involved in collective...
collective action collective projects in which you can express collectivity with other people it's not just a good way to meet people of the opposite sex it's a good way to develop the affects that you need for this more expansive sense of love comradeship basically it will basically improve your life it will it will give you more joyful um affects it'll allow you to you know that feel that collective to do the spinosa thing that increasing your capacities to be affected by the world and affect the world you know that's what joy is