This is Acid Man. Hello, and welcome to this special festive microdose from ACFM, the home of the weird left. I'm Nadia Idle, and I'm joined as usual by Jeremy Gilbert. Hello. And Kia Milburn. Hello. And today, listeners, it is time to get cosy, make yourself a spiced hot chocolate, and light those cinnamon and sweet orange candles. Embrace all things winter, and join us for a reading of none other than The Communist Manifesto by Friedrich Engels and Karl Marx.
So guys, do we want to do an intro to this text before we start with the reading? by the Communist League, which is a pretty small group, I think, primarily had sort of emerged out of the League of the Just, which is a much more sort of conspiratorial sort of group led by Weitling. And they sort of took it over. They changed the philosophy a little bit. And then they got commissioned to write the Communist Manifesto, a manifesto not just of that organization, but of like a current, I think you put it that way. Obviously, Marx was late in writing it. And they started writing some committee of the Communist League, started writing to Marx, and you've got to get this out.
So if you look at the last section, which we'll come to in about four hours time, it's really brief and quick. I think he just writes it off. Shit, I better get this finished and writes it really quickly. So it's published in 1848. A few weeks later, the revolutions break out. There's a huge repression that follows that. And in fact, loads of the leaders of the Communist League, the ones in Germany anyway, are arrested. And the Communist League sort of dissolves. And then there's sort of like a period of repression, one of those ebbs in the flow of the workers' movement or the nascent workers' movement.
The old mole revolution, though, is tunneling away and bursts out again in Paris Commune in 1871. And so the manifesto finds a new audience in 1871. It's almost too late for the 1848 revolutions, but it's more than in time for the 1870 wave. I would like to say for listeners who have not read the Communist Manifesto, there will be many, is that actually, notwithstanding the preambles, which are not part of the Penguin Little Black Classics edition, which I got for ATP about 10 years ago or something, it is a short book. So this is only kind of, I've got a small A6 size, I think, version in my hand here. And it's 51 pages. So I read it all in a couple of hours. And it may not be the kind of book that you expect it to be. So I would really encourage you to get a copy and read along with us. Because I read it again for the first time in maybe 20 years now or something, at least 10 years I haven't read it. And I was quite surprised with various aspects of the writing. And it's very enjoyable to read. And it's a surprisingly easy text. So I would encourage people to read it as a story, if not as a manifesto.
No, no, they should read it as a manifesto and follow it to every word. But I would just say that you can just go and download it straight away. Now you'll find it straight away on the internet. Just go and find a version. It'll be close enough to the versions we're reading. We haven't agreed on which version, but it'll be close enough that you'd be able to follow along, I think. And you should do that. We recommend it highly. Okay, should we start then? Yes. Yes. Let's start with the famous first line. This is the most common translation into English, which is also close to the normal translation in French. A spectre is haunting Europe, the spectre of communism.
So the passage then goes on to explain that all of the old powers of Europe, the forces of reaction, the Tsar, the Pope, etc., have gathered to try to exorcise this spectre. It's quite an arresting and impactful opening line, isn't it? The impact that it had on me is that I felt like how refreshing to read an opening line of a book that exuded such confidence. Because in that kind of second sentence, by basically saying... all the powers of old Europe. It's already kind of casting a set of interests into the past from the get-go. And I think that's just, you know, really impactful for any, and really will have an effect on anyone who reads it, who's thinking of, you know, like joining this kind of like communist wave. So yeah, it's really great. It's also reminded me of the opening scene of Jean Genet's The Balcony. And I didn't make that connection before. And I wondered whether Jean Genet, I haven't read up on this actually, but whether Jean Genet's kind of scene of having the state and the army and the church on the balcony as a thing that kind of opposes revolution, because it comes directly from that.
it probably does. We should just reflect, I mean, to say that this is a manifesto. You know, it's full of like really bold statements and it's also full of like fairly careful analysis in other places, but like, you know, really huge statements such as the specter of haunting Europe, the specter of communism. It's a manifesto, so it's trying to bring about what it says. It's trying to bring about what the thing that it's analyzing or it's predicting, if you know what I mean. And people have written lots of books about this. Of course, the concept of hauntology comes from Jacques Derrida's Spectres of Marx.
written in the early 90s you know and then picked up by mark fisher etc and it's this idea in this spectrum of haunting europe of like what's haunting europe is it's not something that's it's something that's sort of like visible just about visible but it's like you know a potential future is haunting well it's the idea of an imminent possibility isn't it that what's being evoked is the idea of communism as an imminent possibility but of course well it's imminent and imminent like so both inherent to the overall set of social relations in europe and also maybe about to happen and that is a sort of tension of course that runs through the Communist Manifesto, because as Keir said, it's a performative text like any manifesto, and it's trying to make something happen. But in the process, it is making a set of claims, and it is basically claiming that Europe is more or less on the brink of communist revolution already, which is a very tendentious claim, and was clearly not true. Well, I don't know. I mean, a couple of weeks later, it did break out a revolution across Europe. The revolutions that broke out across Europe in 1848 were not communist. They were not workers' revolutions. They were mainly liberal bourgeois revolutions against the ancien regimes of Central Europe.
You can imagine what Marx and Engels felt like when they saw those revolutions break out. They thought what we think when somebody writes something in a newspaper about an ACFM topic, which we've just brought out, we think we're the trailblazers. But I think it's important to emphasize, regardless of what happened in the real world, as anyone that's picking up this text, there is a certain level of, as Jeremy said, saying that this is inherent and possibly inevitable, in a sense, in the way that the language is presented just in the first few sentences. And I think it has a certain energy to it that actually is quite unique. that kind of confidence because I believe it. I'm reading it and I think, wow, these guys are writing it in these words. It's got a kind of smugness to it as well, which I quite enjoy throughout the text. We must have mentioned that there's another translation of the Manifesto translated in 1850 by Helen McFarlane.
which doesn't say a spectre is haunting Europe. It says a frightful hobgobling is haunting Europe. And we should now spend two hours trying to work out what hobgoblingology would mean for the present context. Listeners, if you want to know a bit more about the thematics of the spectre and haunting and the genesis of the idea of ontology in spectres of Marx, then you could listen to our Christmas episode from a couple of years ago in which I talked about all that stuff. The Spectres Wanting Europe famously comes from the unnumbered kind of opening paragraph. And then we then move on to the first numbered section of the manifesto, which is titled Bourgeois and Proletarians. And it begins with, I think, an equally famous, perhaps even more famous opening line. The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles. This lays out the basic thesis, to some extent, of historical materialism, in a way which to this day is still its defining concept, I think. So a very sort of powerful idea.
They make the argument, polemically, in the sentences that follow, that you can go back to ancient times, you can look at the history of the Middle Ages, and in all of these contexts, you can see the driving dynamic of social change, arguably being the contestation between different social classes, who are defined basically in terms of their role in the overall economy, for resources, power, political status, etc. I wrote to myself in the notes, again, on that first sentence, I just wish more people wrote with such clarity. And I was going to make a similar point to you, Jeremy, about the polemic nature of... of what follows and i i just didn't expect to enjoy rereading this so much and i think there's something about the clarity of the presentation of the arguments that i yeah i just found really enjoyable like whether you end up agreeing with it or not but it's there you know and it has this this yeah this clarity and energy which i thought actually is quite unique compared to a lot of things i read these days it's banger after banger as they say in contemporary parlance but if somebody reads this and they've never had a communist manifesto before you will just come across loads of lines oh that's where this is that's where that line's from then this is where it's from it's just it's just littered with like incredibly um famous lines basically so the text sort of goes that the structure of the argument is that like you know
The motor of history is class struggle, basically. You know, it's the history of all hitherto existing societies and the history of class struggle. But it wants to get to our own epoch and what's different about our own epoch, basically. And so it goes, it says, our epoch, the epoch of the bourgeoisie, possesses, however, this distinct feature. It has simplified class antagonisms. Society as a whole is more and more split into two great hostile camps, into two great classes directly facing each other, the bourgeoisie and the proletariat. It's a great use of imagery there. It's really, really well written, that bit.
It's great imagery, but here we come immediately to one of the key problems, actually, with classical Marxism, because I would say this is the element of their theory as set out here, from which they don't really depart in their much more sophisticated work in later decades, which is just wrong. It's just not how things have actually played out. The idea that the tendency, the inherent tendency of capitalism was towards this simple bifurcation of society into two clearly unrecognisable social groups, the bourgeoisie and the proletariat, who would inevitably come into conflict with each other. If you're a sort of political economist who really wants to prove that this is still true, then you can by pointing out, for example, that distributions of wealth have just become increasingly unequal over the past 150 years or so. And that, in fact, there are lots of people doing lots of kinds of jobs, like teachers, for example, who would have been considered sort of bourgeois or petty bourgeois, as the phrase goes, in the 19th century, who are now clearly, in some sense, proletarians, like forced to live through selling their labour. But any sociologist with any degree of sophistication is going to acknowledge that, well, that might be true at some very, very abstract level.
But at the level at which anybody actually experiences the social world, including the level at which Marks and Engels are describing things in this book, what has actually happened over the past 150 years is that situation has accompanied a great deal of kind of cultural, social, political, institutional differentiation within the classes of people who live only by selling their labour. And if you look at a situation like Britain today, where you have this completely confused and complex situation where, as we've talked about on the show loads of times, for example, you have all these retired people who... clearly were proletarians for like most of their lives, meaning they lived through sending their labour time to an employer, but they have all been able to accumulate sufficient wealth that now they are living off pensions invested in the stock market and they're living in houses they don't have to pay for, which are ever increasing in value. And so they are, to all intents and purposes, they are sort of capitalists or at least petty bourgeois. But of course they carry with them the historical memory, their own personal biographical memory of having been working class and what that meant like 20 years ago or 40 years ago. And that's just one example of the extreme complexification of
the social structure and the experience of class in advanced capitalist societies. I think this is interesting because, for example, in the work of someone like Ernesto Leclerc and Chantal Mouffe, this is the point at which they think they have to define themselves not as Marxist but as post-Marxist. They say the point at which you have to depart from classical Marxism is the point at which you recognise, well, actually, that is the thing that just hasn't happened at all. So I do think, I would still say, like I think they would, and most people would, that you can hold on to most of the historical materialist method of analysis, and it's still one of the best frameworks available for understanding what's going on. I would say, in fact, The idea that all history is a history of class struggle gives you the conceptual tools with which to understand why the other thing they say, the thing they think is happening, isn't what's happened. Because it's because of the very, very complex way in which class struggle has unfolded over the past 150, 180 years. It's because of the outcomes of that that we arrive at this situation that I've been describing.
I sort of do follow, and I say to close, argument. On some level, you can't sort of have it both ways. You can't actually acknowledge the reality and complexity of class struggle and its outcomes and hold on to this idea of the simplification of the social space. And so I think that is important to acknowledge. Yeah, I mean, the other thing we ought to remember is when it's written, this is in 1847. You know, in 1847, there are probably just a few hundred factories in the world.
and capitalist social relations in a purer sort of sense, limited to a few countries in the world. So it's this incredibly prescient text, this, but it did get some things wrong. I mean, I always say this to students, the extent of what they got right, given how improbable it would have seemed to many people at the time, is extraordinary. So the entire proposition that what's going to happen is... the working class is going to organise itself politically into these mass parties and start making all these social and economic demands, that in itself would have seemed totally utopian to people. And that is what happened, for example, in countries like Britain, even where there never was anything we would recognise as a workers' revolution. And I would even say, even on this issue of the general division of society into two clearly competing camps...
I would say you could probably say that is more or less what seems to be going on up until the middle of the 20th century. But then once you get to the middle of the 20th century, it's precisely the unforeseen and unforeseeable consequences of the workers' movement internationally having so much success, but only partial success, that produces the context within which some of these anticipated outcomes are not what's happening. So the major reason why class becomes so complicated, especially from the 40s onwards, is because the workers have won all these concessions, which means that what it means to be a worker in a capitalist society just isn't what it meant in the 1840s. scale you know the cold war produces all these very completely different outcomes than anything that anybody could have predicted so i think that's how you have to look at it you'd also say that that um that the dynamics that they highlight are probably more active now than they were in the second half of the 20th century. A centralization of wealth in the hands of a very tiny, tiny handful of oligarchs, et cetera, and a process of like proletarianization much more generally. You can see that the dynamics that they think are going to lead to this clarification of class are still active. Do you know what I mean? They went into temporary abeyance partly because of the result of the workers' movement. But even then, I think there are lines in this, which we'll probably come to later, and I'll hold fire on that, which indicate that...
There are different logics going on in this and it's not quite worked out. Before we move on directly from that bit, I think for me it was interesting. how he brings in colonialism, how they bring in colonialism and how it's spoken about. And I was interested in the fact of the colonisation of America and talking about East Indian and Chinese markets so early on in the text was how that was fronted. So that's also something that jumped out for me at that section. Yeah, totally. I mean, it's important to acknowledge this, that they do acknowledge these relative historical contingencies. So the European discovery, quote unquote, and colonisation of these other parts of the world, and also the general development of industrial technology as well. So they do acknowledge all those as relative contingencies. Exactly what role...
play in shaping historical outcomes relative to the role played by class struggle, for example, is one of the great debates within Marxist historiography and social theory to this day and will never be resolved. But of course, a really key point, the idea that it's colonialism is the fundamental predicate for... the prerequisite for capitalism as we know it. That is not a new idea. I know I do encounter people who think this is a new idea that's been added to the Marxist tradition by decolonising theorists. And I mean, while there's a lot of value in a lot of that work, it's not true that Marx and Engels aren't aware of it. I mean, for them, it's more or less a banal given. If anything, they don't talk about it that much in some of their work because it's just a given. But here they make clear that it is a given.
In the next few paragraphs, they sort of go through this. So they're saying that there are these things such as the discovery of the Americas, as they say, and then the colonization of the Americas and other parts of the world that brings in this wealth which pushes the bourgeoisie or the bourgeois to the fore. uh amongst that primarily feudal society and it sort of traces that through a little bit and you know the development of manufacturing system and then the industrial system etc etc and of course bourgeois for people who don't know the term bourgeois initially just refer is a french word and it just refers to the suburbs of paris and so the bourgeoisie were the people who lived in the suburbs but what they mean by it here socioeconomically is they mean capitalists they mean people who make their living through investing in either building up manufacturing concerns or in trade many international trade and accumulate vast profits from it that's what they mean by the bourgeoisie Indeed. Part of the whole story is the story of the bourgeoisie going from being this relatively subordinate social group, saying the late Middle Ages, where there's a few cities, there's parts of Italy where they're very powerful. Mostly they are lorded over by the feudal aristocracy with their armour and their horses and their castles. But gradually, what happens is the wealth and power of the bourgeoisie becomes so great that they're able to really outmaneuver the aristocracy and displace them as the ruling classes of Europe. And the key factor there, of course, is that there's just so much more trade and industry that becomes possible once you've got access to all these colonial resources. Yeah. And what I like about, you know, I mean, on my edition, we're still on page five here, is that
on from kind of illustrating, you know, who are the bourgeoisie and like what role they have to play in society now, I think they come to the section which starts to illustrate the crudeness of capitalism. And, you know, there's this fantastic line, which sounds very 21st century, to be honest. It has resolved personal worth into exchange value and then goes on to other things and then does a takedown of free trade and starts talking about like what freedom is. And again, like rereading this after so many years, I was quite surprised about like... the strength of how that was illustrated, these ideas of freedom and what happens to personal worth under capitalism, again, so early in the text. The bit I want to read out is just after that. This is always one of my favourite bits. The bourgeoisie has stripped of its halo every occupation, hithitherto honoured and looked up to with reverent awe. It has converted the physician, the lawyer, the priest, the poet, the man of science into its paid wage labourers. The bourgeoisie has torn away from the family its sentimental veil and has reduced the family relations to a mere money relation. What do you think is the implication? What do you guys think is the implication there?
when he starts to bring in family, which I know comes in later. I keep saying he is, if it's not both of them. But when they bring in the family, so I'm not entirely sure what the implication there, because there's a takedown of the family later. And so is that a good thing? I think they don't really know what they want, because the main thing they want to say...
in all this is that bourgeois family life is totally hypocritical they know that it's sort of repressive that it's repressive towards women they know it's repressive towards children they know that basically bourgeois family life just involves people becoming obsessed with like inheritances and property which is that if you look at like the literature the novels of the period from the late 18th century to the early 20th century it is something that's really striking like it's there in Jane Austen it's there in Dickens it's there in the French writers like Balzac and Hugo you know it's the fact that really like for the bourgeois for your bourgeois who is often living this quite precarious life, actually, because they've got all this wealth, but one bad investment or one bankruptcy somewhere down the value chain can really fuck you. There's this massive obsession with who's going to inherit what, who's got how much income, how much money are you worth, how much can you get your daughter married off for.
And that is what they're talking about. I think this speaks to a larger point, though, which I was thinking we have to sort of bring out when reading this, which is the question, look, who are they polemicising against? Who are they having a go at? And for the most part, who they are having a go at is kind of liberals who really think they've got the world in their hands at this moment in history, because they sort of have, and who see themselves as like the forefront of historical progress, and who are basically allied to the advance of industrialisation. Who they are having a go at is a sort of progressive liberal who thinks that, well, basically what's happened over the past 300 years is the Enlightenment.
The thing that's been happening is that we've discovered science, we've discovered industry, and we've brought civilisation to the dark-skinned peoples, and we've made the deserts bloom. That's what we've been doing. And also, we've created this culture of family life, which is incredibly respectable and valuable, because women don't have to go to work. If they're bourgeois women, they don't really do anything apart from tell the servants what to do. And that's all fantastic. And so a big part of what they're trying to do in this book is to say, no, that's not all fantastic. It's a world of brutal exploitation, which has wrecked loads of stuff. And they're also addressing conservatives.
who themselves are conscious that all this bad stuff is happening, but they want to have a story about why all this bad stuff is happening, which doesn't end up with the proletariat being empowered and mass democracy happening. So that is what they're speaking to. But what's not necessary for all that polemic is for them to put forward a proper programme, like, OK, what is it we actually want to happen to women in the socialist society? What is it we actually want to happen to children? So I have that sense as well with reading, again, the issue of what exactly is it they want at the level of the family and gender relations that they're not really trying to work out here.
Yeah. I mean, I think that architecturally, it's only later. We'll come to it later. But in terms of the architecture and the aesthetic of the language that's used, we're still in the section of the book where they don't say you. And then suddenly it switches over and then there is a you that is being addressed. So we'll come to that when that happens. But that's a really interesting point. Just above that freedom section, that freedom being reduced to free trade.
The bourgeoisie historically has played a most revolutionary part, and that sets us up nicely for this huge wave of praise, actually, for the bourgeoisie. In the section just above the bit that everybody's waiting for us with bated breath about where we're going to profane a load of stuff, they say, bourgeoisie has accomplished wonders far surpassing the Egyptian pyramids, Roman aqueducts, or Gothic cathedrals. It's conducted expeditions that put in the shade all forms of exoduses of nations and crusades, set in a bourgeoisie as this revolutionary class, and that sort of sets up this section, which is a very famous section. The bourgeoisie... cannot exist without constantly revolutionizing the instruments of production and thereby the relations of production and with them the whole relations of society. Let's skip ahead a little bit. All fixed, fast frozen relations with their train of ancient and venerable prejudices and opinions are swept away. All new formed ones become antiquated before they can ossify. All that is solid melts into air. All that is holy is profaned. And man is at last compelled to face with sober senses his real conditions of life and his relations with his kind. Once again, this is really bigging up the bourgeoisie, I think. And in fact, there's quite a few passages in this in which the bourgeoisie...
really seen as something revolutionizing. And I think we should historicize some of this. I don't know. I don't read it necessarily as that. I mean, I read it as like, this is the introduction of the dynamism of a capitalist system. The one bit of text which you skipped over, I think illustrates like why it's more about the dynamism than like bigging them up because the bit that's in the middle of that.
passage that you read, Kier, is this constant revolutionising of production, uninterrupted disturbance of all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation distinguish the bourgeois epoch from all earlier ones. And I read that, and I think that to me translates directly to your point, Kier, from earlier about how these conditions in late capitalism in the 21st century actually speak directly to the conditions back then in a way that is really, really, really interesting. If I was going to historicise it, I'd say that this is written just before the revolutions of 1848. I think after that, There's a big repression and everywhere the bourgeoisie sides with reaction in the 1848 revolution. Those were bourgeois revolutions. And I think, you know, in some ways in this text, Marx and Engels are quite stages. I think later on in their development, they become much less stages, but they think that what needs to happen is the proletariat, you know, needs to develop itself, needs to grow in size, et cetera, and needs to become to a political awareness. And that has to take place for some sort of bourgeois revolution, you know, which sweeps away reaction and allows capitalism to develop its productive forces to develop the grave diggers of the bourgeoisie, the proletariat.
after 1848, I think they probably reflect a little bit and think, actually, no, the bourgeoisie seems to erect quite a lot of reactionary nostrums, you know, in order to shore up society, as well as its revolutionising size, as well as what Deleuze and Guattari would call its de-territorialising effect, undermining, you know, profaning everything that's holy and, you know, sweeping away social relations and beliefs and these sorts of things. You know, basically, what happens is that they put a new territorialisation there, new territorialisations come along, and in fact, capitalism sort of leans quite heavily onto things such as racism, sexism, you know, these sorts of... uh ossified um social relations there's a double movement i think i'd say to like de-territorializing and then re-territorializing that they underestimate in a communist manifesto and later on i think They changed their minds on that. I'm not sure they even changed their minds. I just think it's a polemical text. So you're not going to put in all the qualifications that you might well recognise as necessary if you're putting forward a systematic theory. But certainly it's the point that's often been made, you know, famously by the American scholar Marshall Berman in his book, All That Is Solid Melts Into Air, that, you know, there is this Promethean heroism about the way they imagine capitalism and the bourgeoisie. The way I always like to put it, to say they are very impressed by capitalism and the bourgeoisie, even though they also hate all their deleterious effects on people. So they're both impressed by them. You can be impressed and at the same time say, but it also does some really bad stuff.
I think there is something related to political strategy there, where they actually are looking for the progressive elements of the bourgeoisie to be influenced by their ideas to some degree, or that the workers' movement will form some sort of alliance with the more progressive element of the bourgeoisie. In order to fully bring about capitalist social relations in its pure reform, that might well change, basically, between something like 1848, all the repression, and in 1871, then you see, which is the Paris Commune, then you see the working class in the saddle for the first time, and you think, oh, I'll fuck the bourgeoisie then. In the next paragraph, actually it's the same paragraph, but it's a very long paragraph, they sort of talk about how, you know, in intellectual creation, the intellectual creations of individual nations become common property and sort of like national one-sidedness, narrow-mindedness becomes more and more impossible because what arises is a world literature, et cetera. I mean, that's another thing that you think, well, that's not proven true through the 20th century, et cetera, into the 21st. But then you look around and you think, actually, yeah, there is much more of a common culture, even though it hasn't resulted in the end of nationalism.
But there are, you know, there are common corporations around the world, et cetera, et cetera, you know. It's clearly true in a way it wasn't when they were writing, you know, even the things like the existence of a world literature. I mean, just the fact that there were loads, you know, you can get translations of books, you know, Chinese novels, which like most people in Britain in the 1840s wouldn't have even known there was such a thing as it could be such a thing as a Chinese novel. And then the next paragraph goes on. It's a bit more about that.
I'll add this section. The cheap prices of commodities, the heavy artillery with which it batters down all Chinese walls, which it forces the barbarians, intensely obstinate hatred of foreigners to capitulate. It compels all nations on pain of extinction to adopt the bourgeois mode of production. It compels them to introduce what it calls civilization into their myths. I imagine the Chinese walls there. Is that a reference to the opium wars? There's more than one opium war. And the second one, it was a bit later and the first one had already started. Yeah, the first one was better. That was a real opium war.
Let's just recognise the great swipe they have at the idiocy of rural life. Apologies once again for all our rural listeners as you tune into The Rest is Politics. We love you all the same. They do come later in the text and say that one of the aspects, I think this comes towards the end, that one of the things that they want is to kind of flatten the experience between what city life and rural life is. So they actually do come back on that. Yeah, I love that. They want to eliminate the difference between city and country. They want to turn everything into a suburb.
Which is problematic, of course. Even as the representative suburban on this recording. We start then to get into the sort of economic analysis to some degree. We've already had economic analysis, but it's had a political flavor, we'd put it that way. And we see after this effusiveness about the bourgeoisie, we sort of see, you know, they start to explain why we need to get rid of them. And they start to talk about how, you know, when the bourgeoisie came to, rose in prominence, you know, the feudal relations that surrounded the bourgeoisie.
they started to become fetters on production. They started to limit, fetters on society even, limit what was possible to do in society. And that point at which those fetters become limits is when they have to be burst asunder, and they were burst asunder. And he says, there's a similar movement that's going on before our very eyes. A modern bourgeois society with its relations of production of exchange and property, a society that has conjured up such gigantic means of production and of exchange, is like the sorcerer who is no longer able to control the powers of the netherworld, whom he had called up by his spells, which is fantastic.
It opens up this critique of capitalism, which is that the bourgeoisie are coming to power politically, but they're not in control of things. Part of the critique you would aim at capitalism is it's not under the control of the bourgeoisie, of the capitalists. They've conjured up something which is beyond their control, which has got out of control, which in fact is subordinating them. When I read that, I cannot but think about the current situation with climate change, et cetera, this huge existential crisis. We basically cannot seem to deal with it, basically. We cannot deal with it because capitalism is this fundamentally uncontrollable social system. It's something we've summoned up.
which we can't then gain control of without killing it, basically, which I think is Marx's point. You have to end capitalism in order to regain control over economic production coordination. I really like that section. I think it's really evocative of a kind of mythology, and it's their way of being able to present a series of ideas. While they're very clearly anti-religion, it's evoking these ideas that makes the argument actually understandable to people. This out-of-control sorcerer is such a good metaphor for exactly what you were saying, Kia. And it really evokes this kind of sense of, I think not just out-of-controlness, but what happens when a spell goes in directions that you could not possibly...
predict. And I think that comes later again, like this idea of loss of control, as you said. It's very, very interesting. Yeah, I agree with all that. I'd also highlight for listeners what's going on here conceptually in this section, which is, to a certain extent, yet another version of what it is that drives historical changes introduced. And this is the idea of the productive forces. It's a point that's been made by various readers and critics over the years that the idea that comes in here is this idea that, well, somehow or other, these things we call the productive forces, which mainly just means technological developments.
they develop according to seemingly some sort of endogenous logic, a kind of logic of their own, and sometimes existing social relations and political institutions facilitate that development, and then at some point they start to inhibit it, and then they have to be changed, there has to be some sort of revolutionary overthrow. And the argument again made by Ernest de Clau, for example, is that, well, this is not the same as saying that all history is the history of class struggle. This is a quite different version of a theory of history, which has a somewhat sort of teleological aspect, in that there seems to be this sort of direction of travel. which is determined by nobody really, which just happens, which is the development of the productive forces. And then it's the endless unfolding of the productive forces which sometimes smashes existing social relations. And that's a bit different from saying, well, actually, it's class struggle which does that. That's the argument. I think it's a slightly unsimplistic argument in itself. I think you can reconcile those views in quite a complex way. And I think that's partly what Marx does much later in more developed work. And I think also, I think one reason for that tension...
is the fact that it is just quite unclear. It remains unclear to everybody in the world, really, to what extent things like technological change is actually something you can subject to social and political control. And to what extent is something that just sort of happens and you have to deal with it from whatever point of view. So I don't claim to have an answer to it. I sort of think the reason it can't be properly resolved in Marx's own writing is because it can't actually be resolved on some level. But I think it is worth pointing out there. And also, of course, you could also make the point, and it's the point I made before on this show and others, that, well, there is also a version...
of Marxism which would say well that's all that stuff about class struggle like determining everything that's kind of naive and youthful and optimistic and actually what Marx and Engels discover through their historical studies is that the productive forces sort of unfold according to a certain logic and there's not much you can do about it and I think it is always a point worth keeping in mind that, well, if you survey the history of the entire 20th and early 21st century, then there's quite a lot of evidence to back that up. There's quite a lot of evidence to back up this idea that really no one is in control. Things are just developing according to this logic. It does have to do with where, at particular times in history, where the technological innovation is going on and where the political conditions make it possible for intensive innovation to go on. And that's why all the power is now a power and the sense of modernity and progress is all shifting to China now. And that is going to have all kinds of effects on us all, but there's nothing we can do about it. I'm not saying I believe that.
that or such a simplistic version of that but that is a version of marxism which you know has often been identified for the sake of critiquing it and attacking it as being overly deterministic by critics of marxism but which i also think with a certain degree of humility we have to look at the current world situation and say well actually it's not you can't you know it's got something going for it as a way of understanding what's going on I mean, the other reading of this, the way that it would be resolved, is to say that you have new innovations, and those innovations can take all sorts of forms, and they tend to take a form that suits the ruling class, basically, the bourgeoisie. But the only thing that drives the uptake or the uptake of investment in new technologies, such as automation, et cetera, is class struggle. And so Marx says in Capital somewhere that you can trace the history of new technology by tracing the history of strikes, basically. Innovation follows strikes, and so it's like Capital is fleeing the insubordination of labor.
into fixed machinery, into fixed investment, because fixed investment won't revolt, won't fight back. And of course, one of the big science fiction sort of notions of the last sort of like 40 years has been the revolt of the machines, which you just keep seeing over and over. What if the machines actually turn out to look a little bit like labor and revolt against their masters? I mean, that is the favored solution taken by most of our key, our key theoretical influences, including the Italian autonomous, including Raymond Williams, including indeed Leclerc Move. They all go in the direction of saying, okay, what we're going to do with this seeming contradiction.
we're going to say actually it's all history is history of class struggle and technological change is always subordinated to class struggle in a certain way and that i think that gets you further than any other way in terms of resolving it all i just i still have this lingering residual center there is something a certain like science and technology studies people want to say for example that sometimes there is something quasi-autonomous about all the unintended effects of new technologies, which can't be fully captured by the assumption that technologies only emerge in the outcome of class trouble. But I would say, I think that is sort of true, and it's partially true, and you need to acknowledge that to explain some things, but you can explain like 99% of things by saying that all the technologies that actually get researched and rolled out are the ones which make wage labor cheaper. But we should also think a little bit about China as well, and just go back to the opening sentence of this manifesto.
It doesn't have to be explicit class struggle as well. I think the Chinese Communist Party leadership, the Central Committee, they are haunted by the prospect of workers' revolts, basically. And that's driving their investment strategy as much as anything else. So I would like to pick up on three things from what in my version is page 11. So I think there's three interesting things that happen on this page. So the first thing is this question that's posited, the conditions of bourgeois society are too narrow to comprise the wealth created by them. And how does the bourgeoisie get over these crises? And then they go on to explain that. So here there's the introduction of crises, which I think is important because that's carried forward. Also on that page, I believe this to be true, there's the first mention of capital as such, just a little bit further on from then. But also I'd like to query this section where...
in the middle of both of those things, where they say the weapons with which the bourgeoisie felled feudalism to the ground are now turned against the bourgeoisie itself. And I wasn't entirely sure what they're talking about there. Do you guys have any idea? Well, what they mean is the industrialisation, the process of industrialisation and the process of creating these populations of proletarians, of people who can only live by selling their labour, that is now going to become the place from which the revolutionary proletariat emerges to overthrow them. I see. Yeah, that classic argument. Okay, understood.
So there's some discussion of the effects of capitalism on labor, which hark back to Marx's early writing around alienation, basically. And he says, only to the extensive use of machinery and to the division of labor, the work of the proletarians has lost all individual character and consequently all charm for the workman. He becomes an appendage of the machine. And it is only the most simple, most monotonous and most easily acquired knack that is required of him. Yeah, that's good. That's a good bit. That is. Yes. Yeah. And there's a bit later where he's sort of like, he's building up to this like pauperization thesis. This is the idea that wages will be driven down to the absolute minimum. I think it's here. Is it in this section? Yeah. Which is another thing which people say, well, that's not proven true. That hasn't been pauperization. That's a section or an argument that basically gets revised in capital.
So a little further on in the same section is the first mention of women as a group or as a class. In this section where they say, the less the skill and exertion of strength implied in manual labor, in other words, the more modern industry becomes developed, the more is the labor of men superseded by that of women. Differences of age and sex have no longer any distinctive social validity for the working class. All the instruments of labor are more or less expensive to use according to their age and sex. So obviously there are implications there, but this is the first mention of women as a...
as a sex class or as a group, which they then, I think it was you, Jeremy, that said that they don't actually provide a solution, but they're clearly trying to distinguish women as workers and people, in a sense, rather than just wives. And they do this juxtaposition later by talking about prostitution and also prostitution within the family, which I think is quite stark and jumps out and is quite interesting. But I think it's important to point out that it's on, again, not right at the beginning, but then this characterization of women, and then there's a similar characterization of children that happens later in the text, which is interesting. And I'm not entirely sure what the implications are there. I spent some time kind of thinking about it.
about it, but I think what's implied about their understanding of the role of women within that is not entirely clear to me, is what I'm trying to say. Yeah, I think you're right. In retrospect, it's pretty clear where this is going. It is heading towards the international socialist and communist movement, fully embracing the assumption that creating equality for women in society is an integral part of the socialist project. But you're right. This is a faltering gesture in that direction. Exactly. If they say women are people, that would have been very clear in that sense. But it seems to allude to that, but I'm not entirely sure to what degree their internalised sexism or misogyny is playing out in other spheres of that argument. But it seems to allude towards that. And we do see that, as you said, in how their politics play out later. On the same page, just after that, they go into this very interesting account of the social dynamics by which they think this...
polarization of society is going to take place they predict the disappearance of the sort of the middle strata of society there's the petty bourgeoisie the small business people the independent entrepreneurs and professionals and that goes along of course with their prediction that kia was talking about whereby gradually everyone in the proletariat is going to get poorer and poorer which of course as kia said later on they clarify that to say well they're only going to get poorer relative to the capitalist class which is true has definitely happened is still happening but um what then becomes problematic and which they really an issue they really don't resolve in even the very late work is well okay it might be true that people are all getting poor relative to the capitalist class and it might also be true that the petty bourgeoisie the small business people etc are losing some of their historic autonomy but if they are getting in return for all that and if even workers are getting in return for all that just unprecedentedly high standards of living by historic standards then are they really going to care that much about the fact that the capitalist class is getting richer and richer and richer and if they don't care about that
what is their politics going to be? And again, I mean, a lot of what happens, especially from mid-20th century onwards, is driven by the fact that actually it seems like for the most part, people don't really care that much if they're being relatively immiserated or if they're losing their status as independent business people or peasant farmers, if what they are getting in return for that is someone to boss around at work in a massive car. So I suppose the answer to that would be that basically capitalism is undermining the conditions upon which that's possible. That would be the sort of pauperisation arguments updated a little bit. And there are lines in this as well around, you know, how unions struggle, can raise wage levels, et cetera, which show that this pauperisation has counter-tendencies and that counter-tendency primarily is worker organisation and political action, et cetera. I suppose the argument would go, but like when workers do improve their lot, et cetera, et cetera, you know, basically what happens is that capitalist dynamics reassert itself and they undermine the conditions upon which that abundance, we might say, is created. We live in this world in which the dynamics of which capital undermining its own preconditions, et cetera, really have come to the fore, you know, not just for climate change, but also of like, you know.
economic stagnation, which global capital seems quite unable to escape from over the last sort of like 20 years, probably more like 20 years now, isn't it? Yeah. Or nearly 20, 15, 20 years, something like that. And so there is this thing of like, well, they basically didn't see capital's adaptability, perhaps, right? It's ability to adapt to the workers' movement. But like what they got wrong with that was not their ultimate analysis. It's just a timescale upon all which Ollis would operate on, if you know what I mean. I guess it's worth saying now that that issue, the issue of the timescale, is the big one that kind of hangs over all of their writing for me from this right through to the end of Capital. And this is what I thought about it when I first read this material as a teenager, and I still think it today, that you read all this and you think this is a very convincing theory of historical change. And it's talking about the shift from...
feudalism to capitalism having taken several centuries and is also showing that capitalism is the most dynamic socio-economic system ever and the bourgeoisie is the most successful ruling class ever so therefore why that why on earth do you think it's just like the end of capitalism is like just around the corner as they occasionally assert that i mean my reading of that is i would defend this reading very strongly is they at no point do they have any strong argument for that position and it is clearly wishful thinking on their part that they just do not present an analysis which would convincingly lead you to assume that all of this is going to get resolved really quickly with the proletarian revolution following on from the bourgeois revolution as they write at the end of the book they say is definitely what's going to happen in germany sometime soon. It's just nonsense. They don't have an argument for it. Future-making. Well, it's future-making, but they just don't have an argument for it, actually. They never make a good argument. They present an argument which would seem to imply, quite clearly, that capitalism is going to be around for a few centuries.
And he's going to have to basically industrialise every part of the planet and every part of the population before socialism becomes truly viable. But then they just stick in at the end, at the end of a paragraph or the end of a book, oh yeah, yeah, but capitalism's definitely going to end sooner because it is. Because no one's going to put up with this shit for much longer, obviously, surely. So I think that issue of timescale is exactly right. I just think if you just assume...
that the logical implication of their own analysis of historical change up to the point they're writing would be that actually the process which might lead to socialism are going to take hundreds of years, then it all makes sense. Of course, as various other critics have pointed out, including really right-wing critics I wouldn't want to endorse, there's an interesting analogy here, say, with Christian millennialism. Anyone who goes and reads the Gospels with an objective eye can see that Jesus is telling people that the world is going to end within their own lifetimes, and then it doesn't. And then to some extent, the whole development of Christianity subsequently partly is about having to deal with this fact that the world did not end. You might say that Christianity develops into a beautiful edifice on the basis of that, or you might say, well, it was all rubbish. And right-wing critics of Marxism would want to say, and some sort of anarchist critics of Marxism would want to say, look, Marxism has spent 150 years developing all these justifications and rationalizations for the fact that its millenarian promise was clearly not realized. I don't agree with that at all, but I'm just acknowledging it. I mean, I don't agree with it simply for the simple reason that I don't think you can look at what's happened in the world in the past 50 years and say there is an available explanatory framework which is remotely as robust as historical materialism for understanding it.
But I think it's important to acknowledge that this tension around the millenarian dimension of the project is a key theme in critical readings of this text and other texts of Marxism. A very short word in their defence, going back to the 1840s, is, you know, the 1840s is so close to like, you know, they're still living in the age of the sort of double revolutions of the American Revolution, the French Revolution, well, in fact, the Triple Revolution, because the Haitian Revolution as well, it's the period in which revolutions are in the air. And then you see 1848, and then they have 1871, etc. In 1917, you know, there have been quite a lot of revolutionary moments. But I do agree that there's a sort of voluntarism or millenarianism, perhaps even.
that goes against their more sober economic analysis. But let's move on because we haven't got much time and we have so many bangers to get through. Basically, the next part is all about, you know, they're trying to sort of like talk about why the proletariat is the sort of like revolutionary class, et cetera. They dismiss the lumpen proletariat, the dangerous class, the social scam. It's a funny either translation or use of words here. I couldn't figure it out, this sentence. This bit where it says, of all the classes that stand face to face with the bourgeoisie today, the proletariat alone is a really revolutionary class.
It's a very strange phraseology. Yeah, well, I think this is one of the sections that carries the traces of their Hegelianism. So they developed their theory of history initially from a reading of Hegel. And Hegel, the great early 19th century German philosopher, his whole thing is to have this entire theory of history, according to which there's this back and forth movement, things go in one direction, things go in another direction, then something emerges out of both of them, and then you get onto the next stage of history. And their initial move was, and the thing is, what he even means by history is really that human culture has registered in philosophy and maybe in art.
And that's kind of understandable, because at the time in Hegel's writing, most of what we actually knew about the past, especially the distant past, was the text that had survived, the poetry, the philosophy, what have you. And then one of the things that's going on in the first half of the 19th century is the development of... economic theory, the development of historiography, the development of archaeology, means that people have a much clearer sense of the changing ways in which societies have been organised, and the changing material economic conditions. And Marx and Engels' initial move, the formulation of historical materialism, was, as they put it, to stand Hegel on his head to say, right, actually, we are still interested in this unfolding process of historical change, but we think that historical change happens through class struggle, basically. But from that point of view, you've still got to be able to say at any one moment in history, well, who is really the agent of history at this moment? Who is really going to change everything? Who are the bits of society that just belong to the previous moment, really?
And so, yeah, so they're really compelled to say, well, it's the proletariat, the people who can only exist by sending their labour, because only they are the people who have a total interest in the complete abolition of all class relations, because every other social class, it just, it might have an interest in changing the present order of things, but it's only going to change it in such a way that someone else is going to be still on the bottom. But the proletariat, because they're on the bottom, because they have nothing to lose but their change and nothing to sell but their labour, they are the ones who are going to overthrow all of class society. And in the process, they're sort of going to resolve the entire historical process. They're sort of going to end history by doing that. It's all that. It's all that metaphysical baggage from Hegel, actually, where you want to have a total theory of history.
have, be able to point at any moment in history and say, who is the hero of the story? And you also want to say that your hero of the story is the one that's going to end the whole story. There's two, I think, really important points that are made at the end of this section. So this is the bourgeois and proletarians. And I think there's a really important point that's made in this section with a comparison of what happens to the modern labourer. And this bit at the end reads, it makes this comparison, the serf in the period of serfdom raised himself to membership in the commune. This is the petit bourgeois under the yoke of feudal absolutism, managed to develop into a bourgeois.
the modern labourer, on the contrary, instead of rising with the progress of industry, sink deeper and deeper below the conditions of existence of his own class. And I think that that's fundamental to the argument that they're trying to make, and they kind of illustrate it in that way, which I think is interesting. Yeah. Although the next line is about pulperisation, which is also something which we said they go back on later on, basically, is that this process of pulperisation is just one dynamic, which is countered by other counter tendencies. Sure. But I do enjoy the way they're making the argument, regardless of whether I'm agreeing with it or not. I think there's an illustrative sense there, which really kind of...
brings home what they're trying to say. And then there's a last paragraph of this section, which goes, the essential conditions for the existence for the sway of the bourgeois class is the formation and augmentation of capital. The condition for capital is wage labour. Wage labour rests exclusively on competition between labourers. The advance of industry whose involuntary promoter is the bourgeoisie, involuntary promoters, replaces the isolation of the labourers due to competition by the revolutionary combination due to association. The development of modern industry therefore cuts from under its feet the very foundations on which the bourgeoisie produces and appropriates products.
What the bourgeoisie therefore produces above all are its own grave diggers. Its fall and their victory of the proletariat are equally inevitable. We can have another two hours on that last word in that paragraph. I don't know if we want to. Okay, so now we are moving on to the second section, proletarians and communists. So again, this section, proletarians and communists, has this really good, clear start where there's this question that's posited. In what relation do the communists stand to the proletarians as a whole? And then they go on to explain that. I think what's interesting in this section is there's both a kind of statement of internationalism that comes quite early on and also about kind of like the holistic approach to their politics, which is presented just right in the beginning there. Do you guys have anything you want to say about that bit? No, I mean, I'd skip down to that.
to the seventh paragraph in this section where it says, the immediate aim of communism is the same as all the other proletarian parties. The formation of the proletariat into a class, overthrow of the bourgeois supremacy, conquest of political power by the proletariat. And it's the formation of the proletariat into a class, which is the interesting bit. It's not something that pre-exists. It's something that obviously can be brought about partly by political action from that paragraph. Yeah. And then after that, I think both in terms of the quality of the writing and the tone, they start to kind of ramp up.
what you know reads as a bit of like you know a confident bro aesthetic which i kind of like quite quite enjoy because you know slightly later we'll get to this they start slagging people off um in quite this kind of like playful way but i think what's interesting about this section is kind of the um the kind of strong argument that's brought forward about private property and you know that's not been brought in as like a section in itself in the earlier bit but like in this part it's all about you know in the sense the theory of the communists may be summed up in a single sentence abolition of private property like that statement is made and then they go on to to explain that. And then we get this section I find particularly interesting in the writing because you start to get the exclamation marks, which you don't have before, you know, hard won, self-acquired, self-earned property exclamation mark. And there's like a little bit of sarcasm after that. And then for the first time in the text, we start to say, here you, which harks back to what Jeremy was introducing earlier, this idea of like, who are the people that this text is addressing? And we start to see the...
you being used in this way, which is interesting because there's a different flavour. I think there's a kind of turn in the way the language is being used in this section, which I think says something about their age, but also about the confidence of what is being presented, which I find really enjoyable to read. Yes, and the polemic is very strong there. And the you they are talking to is clearly the bourgeois liberal. rather more than anyone else i think that's who they're addressing in this very hostile way it's interesting that they're really at pains in the first couple of pages of this section to first few pages of this section to clarify what they mean by the abolition of properties to clarify they they they don't mean that they're going to take away your personal property what they mean is they're not going to let but they're not going to let land and factories be owned privately Although I would say they don't really spell that out as clearly as they will do later on in their careers. That's really what they mean. But then this polemic where they start addressing with exclamation marks and the second person address the bourgeois who they're kind of attacking is very powerful.
And that's a really important section, I think. I mean, just before that, they say, in bourgeois society, the past dominates the present. In communist society, the present dominates the past. In bourgeois society, capital is independent and has individuality, while the living person is dependent and has no individuality. And the abolition of this state of things is called by the bourgeois abolition of individuality and freedom. And rightly so. The abolition of bourgeois individuality, bourgeois independence, and bourgeois freedom is undoubtedly aimed at. So they're introducing this very important set of claims that...
that the bourgeoisie and bourgeois liberals they use this language of freedom and individuality to justify their position but actually they're justifying a social system which gives all power to capital and maybe to those who own it or but maybe just a capital as an impersonal force which dominates the lives even of the bourgeois and And whereas they say, Marx and Engels say, what we are in favour of is a social change which would actually give more freedom, more individuality to most actual human beings. So it's very important. It's a great piece. And I'm really happy that you read that bit out because it's definitely one of my favourite bits. And after that, they go on to say, by freedom is meant under the present bourgeois conditions of production, free trade, free selling and buying. And this part of the text starts to read a bit more like a speech in some way compared to, I think, the earlier chapter. And it really has that quality to it. And then we get more used, like you said, the second person. Further on, you are horrified at our individuality.
tending to do away with private property, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. And yeah, you can see it starts to have this fervour built into it, which I think is, yeah, it's really great. And then it starts to get funny on the next few pages, I find. You must therefore confess that by individual, you mean no other person than the bourgeois, than the middle class owner of property. This person must indeed be swept out of the way and made impossible.
The personal life is dead. I read that as get in the sea. That's the 1800s version of like, yeah, get in the sea. I like it. A bit later on as well, they sort of like historicize that and they say, the selfish misconception that induces you to transform into eternal laws of nature and of reason, the social forms springing from your present mode of production and form of property, historical relations that rise and disappear in the progress of production. This misconception you share with every ruling class that has preceded you, which is, yeah, they all thought that and you're going to get in the bin just like the rest of them.
Also, let's be really clear what's going on here. I put a big star next to this bit in my book. The selfish misconception induces you to transform into eternal laws of nature and of reason, the social forms springing from your present mode of production forms of property. The whole point there is that the ruling class claim that the way they live and the way they think is the only way anybody ever could or should live and think, but actually it's historically specific. this is the critique of what Mark would call capitalist realism. And I'm sorry, I know it's tedious, but I always feel the need these days to point out to people that the idea that capitalist culture and ideology works to naturalise capitalist social relations was not an idea that Mark invented. It's right here. It's here in the Communist Manifesto. It's there in some kind of medieval peasant revolt type writings from the 15th century as well. It's not like there's one original point for that idea, but it's being set out here very clearly.
The next couple of pages, I have literally written lol next to so many parts of it. And that's where they kind of like, there's this bit about the abolition of the family, exclamation mark, and then education, exclamation mark, and then like women. And I think, yeah, this goes back to what we were saying earlier. I think the clearest of those three, that they say something that, you know, you can see where the policy outcome is or what the action is on education. I think what they're actually saying about what the proposal for the family and like what they really think about the position of women is not clear from this text, I would say.
But there's Desi sections where it says, but you communists would introduce a community of women, screams the bourgeoisie in chorus. And a bit later it says, the communists have no need to introduce a community of women. It has existed almost from time immemorial. That is a pretty clear statement that the sexism of bourgeois society is entirely historical and not trans-historical. Therefore, women are people, I think they're saying. I still think that's an extrapolation. I'm not entirely sure they're saying women are people. I quite like them to be saying women are people. We see that in, as we said, the actions of history following that. But as we know, there's always been incredible sexism within Europe.
So I'm not entirely sure to what extent they actually understand that. And on the next page, they have another classic banger of a line. Well, it's translated here, the working men have no country. It's often translated, the workers have no country. That's what I always say. The working men have no country. We cannot take from what they have not got. They're basically arguing that nationalism, it doesn't make any sense from the point of view of working class interests. And they are confidently predicting on this page that nationalism will disappear as an element of working class ideology.
I look forward to that. Also, on the bottom of that page, from my text, the thesis I was just talking about being stated again even more clearly, what else does the history of ideas prove than that intellectual production changes in character in proportion as material production is changed? The ruling ideas of each age have ever been the ideas of its ruling class. So basically, the generally circulated ideas and assumptions, even about things like aesthetics, perhaps, at a given moment in history, largely reflect the balance of class forces and the interest of the ruling class. Then the next bit I think was quite interesting is they start to move into...
Perhaps a little bit of strategy. It says, we have seen that the first step in the revolution by the working class is to raise the proletariat to the position of ruling class to win the battle of democracy. The first mention of democracy, isn't it? I'm not entirely sure, but I don't think, yeah, democracy is not like high on the list of terms that they use. No, well, at the time of their writing, of course, like nowhere apart from the United States doesn't have a property qualification for voting. And most people can't vote. And women can't vote anywhere. You know, you can see from the point of view of what they're writing now, the issue of political democracy is a bit of a sideshow.
And then the next paragraph reads in my version, the proletariat will use its political supremacy to wrest by degree all capital from the bourgeoisie, to centralize all instruments of production in the hands of the state, i.e. the proletariat organized as a ruling class, and to increase the total productive forces as rapidly as possible. We probably would want to qualify that a little bit now. In 1848, I'll let them off. And then, of course, this section ends with, I think it's interesting, like not a very strong introductory sentence going, nevertheless, in the most advanced countries, the following will be pretty generally applicable. Yeah, it'll be sort of generally applicable. It's not strong, is it? It's not. It's compared to, you know, the rest of the text, which has so many strong opening sentences to a section. This one is kind of like, we're about to introduce, you know, here is our policy programme. And it's kind of, it's a very, very wishy-washy way to introduce it, which I thought was interesting. And then there's this list of like the 10 things, which is like.
these are the things i think the wishy-washiness of that introduction to the policy program i think is one of the key points in the entire marxian corpus where you can defend them from what has been one of the strongest charges makes against them of like determinism or millenarianism or sort of proto-talitarian thinking because they marx and engels themselves were always resistant to laying out a really clear blueprint for what the communist society would supposedly look like because their whole argument was look a communist society is going to be one in which the working class the majority of the population are determining the direction of economic and social development in their own interests. And that is how you should judge whether it's good or not. You shouldn't be judging whether it's good or not according to whether it matches some policy agenda set out now or set out somewhere else or set out five years from now. I think that's really powerful and important thinking. But having made that important intervention in their defence, I think let's hear the policies. One, abolition of property and land and application of rents of land to public purposes. Two, heavy progressive income tax. Three, abolition of all rights of inheritance. Four, confiscation of the property of immigrants and rebels. Five, centralisation of credit in the hands of the state.
National Bank. Six, centralisation of the means of communication and transport in the hands of the state. Bring back British Rail. Seven, extension of factories and instruments of production owned by the state. Eight, equal liability of all to labour, establishment of industrial armies, especially for agriculture. Nine, combination of agriculture with manufacturing industries, gradual abolition of the distinction between town and country by more...
distribution of the population over the country 10 free education for all children in public schools abolition of children's factory labor that number four confiscation of the property of all immigrants and rebels i mean they are assuming that under revolutionary conditions the bourgeois will be trying to get their money and resources out of the country as fast as possible and you can have to stop them well they were right there they're doing it anyway yeah they were right yeah it's that ship that ship my communist friends has sailed nationalize the ports What do we think about this, about this arriving at this point in the text, like the top 10 policies? What do we think of this as a choice of presentation? Well, but it remains a classic programme of socialism or even just left social democracy. I think it's really interesting that so much of it seems still relevant. And it's also, it's not even put in the terms that people probably expect. And it's not put in the terms that would later be implemented by, for example, the Russian Revolution. It doesn't say all industry has to be taken into public ownership. It says publicly owned industry, nationalised industry should be extended.
So it looks more like, it's really, it's closer to a sort of Benite program, actually, than to the kind of program that we would come to associate with fully revolutionary communist regimes in the 20th century, which is kind of interesting. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I agree. I don't think it's that radical by communist standards, really, or by applied communist standards, but it's radical for the world that we live in. Well, also, this is really interesting to think, because literally most of this is stuff that are now popular policies, even with people who consider themselves relatively moderate. And not all of it, and maybe some of the ones that wouldn't be popular represent key kind of fault lines. But like most people in Britain think you should have a heavy progressive graduated income tax. They don't think you should abolish all right of inheritance. That is a key thing, actually. They don't think that. And that is a perpetual problem, actually, for the socialist project.
On one hand, these are very moderate things. These are not things that people would associate with being radical, but to be able to enact some of this is just, in lieu of what we were saying about runaway capitalism or whatever, would just be quite difficult. There's lots of writing about demands, et cetera, and the status of demands and what they're there to do and all that sort of stuff. Lots of it goes back to this 10-point program of demands. A demand would be something which makes sense in a current society, but points, if implemented, would fundamentally disrupt and disorganize a society. So transitional demands or whatever you might want to put them.
We would say, if we read this, we shouldn't say, oh, this is what they thought communism would look like. It's more, if we managed to implement some of these, they would fundamentally unwind capitalist society and strengthen working class, et cetera. And then we'd be in a situation in which we could work out how the world should work. We'd probably put them in that sort of sense. And in that sort of sense, it is quite remarkable how.
many of these are still sort of really, really applicable. So there's this one thing that I want to pick up on because I think this is, it's just interesting that at the end of number 10, there's two et cetera's. And I was like, who puts et cetera's in policy? It's just a weird choice to be like, oh yeah, education and industrial production combining those two means industrial policy, which is actually like a really heavy policy proposal actually. So to put et cetera, et cetera, on the end of it is just like quite a bizarre thing. So, because that could be interpreted in a hundred different ways. So I just wanted to point that out. Well, we've definitely got to do the bit after the policy programme though.
Because this is like the classic prediction of what is going to happen under conditions that they're describing. What will the transition from mere socialism to communism look like? And they write, when in the course of development, class distinctions have disappeared, and all production has been concentrated in the whole nation, the public power will lose its political character. So basically, what they think is going to happen is eventually, after you've started to implement this centralised socialist communist programme, eventually what will happen is all economic activity will come under the aegis of the state, eventually. And the state will be an expression, a kind of democratic expression of the will of the whole population. And sooner or later, you will arrive at a situation in which you don't even really need politics anymore, because the system will just produce everything for the good of everybody, and everyone will be happy.
And finally, what will happen is that in place of the old bourgeois society, with its class years and class antagonisms, we shall have an association in which the free development of each is the condition for the free development of all. there's a great deal written and thought about the question of whether, well, do they actually think that this is actually going to happen one day? Or is this this kind of utopian ideal towards which one might aspire, which should sort of regulate your activity, a regulative ideal, as the Kantians like to say, which will organise all your political activity, but which you know perfectly well you're never actually going to arrive at? Or is it actually a kind of proto-totalitarian, horrible idea, which is going to lead communist regimes in the 20th century to carry out all kinds of murderous crimes?
in the name either of the utopia they claim to be on the point of building, or in the name of defending the utopia they claim to have built. I'm just going to say, to put it crudely, Marx and Engels could not possibly have been intelligent enough to produce this and to have been so stupid that they actually thought you would actually one day arrive at this completely perfect society. But maybe they did. Maybe they really did think that. I don't think there's any elimination. It would be the elimination of politics and of tension. But they say it's the elimination of class politics, basically.
which is different so you'd have you know then you'd have this this other association based on other principles such as a free development of all being conditioned for the free development of each being a free development of all what they're saying is that like there'd be a politics would look incredibly different basically once you've got rid of this huge inequalities between people shall we move on to the to the next section on socialist and communist literature i think we should skip over a lot of this as it takes aim at lots of tendencies that have completely and utterly disappeared into the discipline of history yeah i mean really unless you're doing a phd on early 19th century socialism you don't need to read this bit and you i feel like it's important to say to people you might well get to this bit and suddenly you feel like you don't know what they're talking about the reason is they are talking about a bunch of stuff that nobody has cared about almost since the time they wrote it It is interesting, though, to again note the kind of change of tone, because this is the section where it just gets a bit of like, it becomes like the bro takedown section, as I've written in my notes. Yeah, shitposting. They're shitposting. They're shitposting, exactly. They're shitposting, and it loses a bit of its like...
its effervescent revolutionary chat quality. I mean, there is a bit of takedown that happens earlier with like the sarcasm, but this bit just gets a bit like dry and yeah, that shitposty, you're right. So yeah, other than to note that, you know, on what I've got at page 39, they talk about, you know, utopian, they use the word utopian as a pejorative, which I think is like, you know, important to note. But apart from that, there's not really much I want to say about this entire section, section three. We should just say that Marx would have been one hell of a poster and he would, if social media had been around, he wouldn't have finished the first volume of Capital. There's no doubt about it. No, it's often said like Lenin would have just stayed off Twitter altogether. He'd have been too busy getting on with things. Whereas Marx,
were just one of those people who lived on Twitter. There's just no question. So there are little bits about why they're rejecting a utopian socialist and what they have in mind are people like Fourier and Owen, et cetera, people who build these big plans of how society should work, et cetera. Fantastic pictures of future society. But they're not developing out of the working class movement or the class struggle, the dynamics of class struggle at the time. And they don't have an agent, basically. So we'd sort of say something like that, but let's skip really, really quickly.
I don't know if either of you to have seen the film, The Young Marx, which is basically about the period just before writing the Communist Manifesto and then ends with the writing of the Communist Manifesto. And one of the big scenes in that is that Marx and Engels take over the League of the Just and replace this idea of, the slogan would be like something like mankind unites or something like that. And they replace it with the workers of the world unites basically to sort of say, you know, there is class antagonism. You have to move through that. Well, I think this final section is divided into two subsections. And it's the first subsection that is sort of unreadable if you're not an expert on early 19th century socialist debates. The second section on conservative or bourgeois socialism is more interesting and has more contemporary relevance. And actually, the critique of what they call bourgeois socialism, I think, remains entirely applicable to a certain kind of centre-left politics, which is really sort of prevalent still to date, sort of the technocratic politics of the third way, because they are taking issue with forms of socialism, which, as they rightly say, they appeal to members of the bourgeoisie or people from privileged groups who don't really want to give up their privileges.
And they claim that what they can do is sort of administer a set of reforms to society, which won't cost anybody anything, which won't result in significant losses for anybody. And they can just do that in everybody's interests. And Marx and Engels' argument is no, you can't do that because sooner or later, you're going to come up against fierce resistance from capitalists defending their interests who won't want these reforms. And then you're either going to have to give them what they want, or you're going to have to really take the side of the working class against them. Absolutely.
100% applicable to the current British government. It was in name of a Labour government, but it's a Labour government made up of people who have deliberately expelled from the party anybody they thought might push them to engage in any form of confrontation with capital and its interests, because they don't want to do that, because they only want to administer reforms precisely to the extent that they are entirely palatable to capital and their interests. So still, it's totally relevant, actually. And in a way, actually, it's more relevant today than it's been for decades. Because Tony Blair, when people asked him, are you even a socialist? He would just say, no, not in any economic sense, I'm not.
And Starmer says, I am a socialist, but this is politics. So the critique of bourgeois socialism is actually more relevant right now than it ever has been in some ways. Can we just say that Rachel Reeves' plans for public-private partnerships with BlackRock are the most impoverished of all castles in the air, as Marx would put it, and put it full stop under that. Let's just get right to the end now, really try and move through this. So the last section, section four, is the position of communists in relation to various existing opposition parties. So the communists fight for the attainment of the immediate aims for the enforcement of the momentary interest of the working class. But in the movement of the present, they also represent and take care of the future of that movement. Then it's all about, you know, in France, the communist ally with the social democrats against the conservatives, blah, blah. And they go for quite a few countries to say which ones they should, who the communists should align with, the sort of progressive bourgeoisie, basically. And I think they'll revise that situation.
prescription a little bit later, well, about three months later, once the bourgeoisie betray the working class in terms of reaction. So in short, the communists everywhere support every revolutionary movement against the existing social and political order of things. They bring to the front as a leading question in each movement, the property question, no matter what its degree of development at the time. Finally, they labour everywhere for the union and agreement of the democratic parties of all countries. The communists disdain to conceal their views and aims. They openly declare that their ends can only be attained by the forcible overthrow of all existing social conditions. Let the ruling classes tremble at the communistic revolution. The proletariat have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a will to win. Workers of all countries, unite! Is that the translation that you have? Because that is not the ending that I have. The ending that I have is that working men of all countries unite, which is obviously what jars with me, because it's just such a shame. I hope it was really working people, but I don't think it is.
But it's definitely a banger of a section because it's only, you know, it's very short and it kind of has this kind of build up, which is kind of nice relief after the whole, you know, like communist literature section and then ends with, you know, these capital letters and an exclamation mark, which is everything you want. But there it is, yes. Some of the most famous lines in the history of politics, workers of all countries unite. famously, you know, in the 1870s, you get this revival of the socialist movement, the building up of the workers' movement, you know, the new unionism in the 1890s, late 1890s, 1890s, you get the building of this huge, the German Social Democratic Party, et cetera, the huge building of this international, et cetera, the second international, which all breaks down.
when the First World War is announced and all of the socialist parties vote for war credits for their party, et cetera, et cetera. And then at the end of the Second World War, you have a big revolutionary wave, a revolution in Russia, et cetera, et cetera. One of the things that all communist governments or actually existing socialist governments do is they pump out thousands, hundreds and thousands of copies of the Communist Manifesto and it becomes one of the most read books in the history of humankind. So that's it, listeners. Hope you enjoyed our reading of the Communist Manifesto. And all that's left for this year is to thank our incredible production team, Matt Huxley and Chal Ravens, without whom this podcast would not be possible. And to thank you, our listeners, for continuing to support ACFM. Wishing you a restful and joyful festive season full of love and connection. See you next year.